No video :(

Would I Ever Renounce My US Citizenship?

Подписаться 795 тыс.

Просмотров 107 тыс.

50% 1

Have I thought about renouncing my American citizenship and other comments y'all had! Community videos are back!
Sign the petition! petition.parli...
►Become a member of the channel community and get cool perks! / @evan
►SUBSCRIBE for new videos every week! goo.gl/65evwQ
Thank you so much for watching! Hope you enjoyed it!
If you're new to my channel and videos, hi! I'm Evan Edinger, and I make weekly "comedy" videos every Sunday evening. As an American living in London I love noticing the funny differences between the cultures and one of my most popular video series is my British VS American one. I'm also known for making terrible puns so sorry in advance. Hope to see you around, and I'll see you next Sunday! :)
Discord: / discord
Merch: ► evanedinger.tum...
Patreon: / evanedinger
Second Channel: / evanedingertravel
Tumblr: / evanedinger
Twitter: / evanedinger
Instagram: / evanedinger
Snapchat: EvanEdinger
Facebook: / evanedinger
Twitch: / evanedinger
How I make my videos! {affiliate links that support my channel! :D )
Camera - Sony A7iii: amzn.to/2LaJL0A
Lens - Sony G Master F/1.4 24mm: amzn.to/31QRLuP
Microphone - Rode Videomic Pro+ : amzn.to/2RDXfmE
Lighting - Aputure 120D mk ii: amzn.to/2Zf5XQ3
Memory Card: amzn.to/1RGzGEh
Editing software - Final Cut Pro X

Опубликовано:

6 сен 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 969

@evan 3 года назад

The UK petition is live if you want to sign to prevent US-born UK citizens from being discriminated against by banking institutions. (The wording here is to ensure it is something the UK government can actually deal with) petition.parliament.uk/petitions/554690/sponsors/new?token=PHKjkK88WnivLe2WEOEP

@bluehairminerboy 3 года назад

Signed!

@justabitofamug6989 3 года назад

Illegalise?

@emilliem2992 3 года назад

In your vids you should keep us updated on how many people have signed the petition🙂 Love your vids🎃

@amywilson2292 3 года назад

The Petition says UK residents only etc. but when it asks you where you live you can select ANY country 😆

@lilyrc 3 года назад

the link says this atm "We’re checking this petition 5 people have already supported Evan Edinger’s petition. We need to check it meets the petition standards before we publish it. Please try again in a few days."

@ruarismith4107 3 года назад

Hello and welcome to a man in his bedroom not hiding from the IRS

@spottedtime 3 года назад

I accidentally read that as “not hiding from ISIS”. Whoops

@vocschip 3 года назад

Thought you might find this interesting In Finland, speeding fines are linked to salary. The Finns run a “day fine” system that is calculated on the basis of an offender’s daily disposable income - generally their daily salary divided by two. The more a driver is over the speed limit, the greater the number of day fines they will receive. This has led to headline-grabbing fines when wealthy drivers have been caught driving very fast. In 2002, Anssi Vanjoki, a former Nokia director, was ordered to pay a fine of 116,000 euros ($103,600) after being caught driving 75km/h in a 50km/h zone on his motorbike. And in 2015, Finnish businessman Reima Kuisla was fined 54,000 euro ($62,000) for driving 22km/h over the 50km/h speed limit.

@luce3619 3 года назад

I heard about from another girl before and that's actually a great law by the Finnish people

@Mojohjohjoh 3 года назад

To little people like me those numbers are insane! But to those people it's just pocket money

@enginerd80 3 года назад

@@Mojohjohjoh Thats the point of the system. Fines are supposed to hurt to incentivise to not redo whatever it was for. A fixed fine could be unreasonable burden for someone with low incomes, while someone with large income might not care at all. But when the fine is related to the incomes, it's supposed to hurt equally everyone who gets them, to give the lesson.

@annikaj6737 3 года назад

There is a Swedish equivalence of that system, that work the same way.

@Anna133199 3 года назад

Sounds great! I want that here in the Netherlands, not just for traffic tickets but for all fines. It just doesn't seem right that the same offence can cause one person to get into a spiral of debt and another person wouldn't even notice if the amount disappeared from their bank account.

@abigailgirma7881 3 года назад

As an Eritrean lady, I would be willing to participate in this experiment

@lookforward2life 3 года назад

How are you? I heard that part of the world is having a hard time. Solidarity and wishes you are well. That sounds insincere but I mean it.

@briocheoleary5043 3 года назад

I tried to sign it. But they said that they have to check that the petition meets petition standards, & didn't let me sign.. The US sounds like Hotel California: you can check out, but you can never leave.. lol

@Alexm0321 3 года назад

Same even though 5 people have signed it and everyone else can’t

@Tami_Kat 3 года назад

We have to wait abit

@castlestar454 3 года назад

Yep. Me too.

@wandirs 3 года назад

Anyone know if we can sign the petition if we do not live in the UK?

@Alexm0321 3 года назад

@@wandirs you can’t sign the petition yet anyway it’s still being reviewed

@Ixonyard 3 года назад

My brother-in-law actually renounced his US citizenship recently and used the Covid stimulus check he received to that effect. All in all a was bit cheaper than normal and he's very happy with it.

@cianelt9963 3 года назад

That's hilarious, make the government pay for it! !

@danielleramos2659 3 года назад

This is amazing 😂

@quanbrooklynkid7776 3 года назад

Bye

@iriscollins7583 3 года назад

@@cianelt9963 With taxpayers money. Which most citizens are very happy with.😊

@heyarnold1484 3 года назад

Im gonna use the stimulus to pay for the accountants doing my streamlined procedure for taxes i didnt know i had to file!!!

@koutashinji 3 года назад

Careful, Evan, it almost sounded like you wanted to renounce your citizenship to avoid paying taxes! You don't want to know what the US will do to you if they think _that!_

@jarodh-m6099 3 года назад

Exactly. This video is risky.

@kaitlinberanek4539 3 года назад

@Martina you get barred from returning to the country

@briocheoleary5043 3 года назад

@@jarodh-m6099 I think he's been pretty carefully legally. He's not been explicit and equivocal.. imho he's just been rhetorical

@MJsMind 3 года назад

@@kaitlinberanek4539 if I were an american that would be the only thing stoping me from renounceing the possibility that I coulden´t visit my family anymore

@nxtx 3 года назад

If he’s compliant (which seems he may be) with the IRS then it’s not a problem. He can talk as much as he likes. I too am a US citizen who lives abroad and has no desire, intention or reason to return to live in the US and I despise the IRS. We know the pitfalls of renunciation which aren’t pitfalls to many of us.

@BrownMousepad 3 года назад

“Hello everybody welcome back to a man with a snorlax pillow”.

@myrskykeiju 3 года назад

Evan: Tickets should be rearrenged so that they actually disincentivize all people Finland: Hold my beer

@ward.v2594 3 года назад

There are a couple of different countries doing it. I think Switzerland and Iceland are doing the same

@liamgbooth 3 года назад

The UK are also doing it.

@nxtx 3 года назад

@@ward.v2594 I live in Iceland. Not aware of this and haven’t been able to find a relevant law. If you have a link to the law please share! This would make sense but there is loads here that makes no [common] sense.

@cheshirecat5416 3 года назад

I thought speeding tickets are just incredibly expensive in Switzerland. Do they actually depend on your money?

@seneca983 3 года назад

@@cheshirecat5416 One Swedish person in Switzerland received about a million dollar fine for going 290 km/h.

@madabbafan 3 года назад

American citizenship - the gift that keeps on taking The NHS - the greatest gift any country ever gave to its self

@luce3619 3 года назад

That's the best thing about uk

@Muzzathemint 3 года назад

@@luce3619 yet its still terrible compared to other European health systems

@luce3619 3 года назад

@@Muzzathemint yeah

@pikachuisshook2795 3 года назад

@@Muzzathemint but it's better than the US and we should be grateful for that at least

@Siriastimeflies 3 года назад

@@pikachuisshook2795 you know I'm genuinely scared that the US being so terrible is making us all in other, somewhat better off countries, think "at least we're not doing as bad as the US" and thus give up on improving ourselves (on all aspects, not only healthcare)

@Marcos-wz6vz 3 года назад

It's weird how they always keep the american cult-ish stuff from the movies. This wasn't in high school musical

@IceMetalPunk 3 года назад

Well, yeah. Fiction is meant to be either (a) an escape from the sad reality or (b) propaganda. Neither of those include talking about the actual terrible things. Only documentaries dare to do that.

@paulasalazar2093 3 года назад

@@IceMetalPunk nah there's no way fiction falls into just those two categories unless my definition of propaganda is a much smaller scale than the actual meaning

@IceMetalPunk 3 года назад

@@paulasalazar2093 I mean... I can't think of any other reason for fiction. It's either for entertainment (an escape) or to promote one point of view (propaganda). If you can think of a third reason for fiction, let me know!

@ZebraJess92 3 года назад

@@IceMetalPunk i don't agree with that statement. You can "talk" about social/political/personal/societal/etc. problems in fiction. It doesn't need a documentary for that.

@IceMetalPunk 3 года назад

@@ZebraJess92 Well, sure! I didn't say you can't do that. But when it's written about in fiction, it's still part of escapism. For instance, one of my favorite books is Prey by Michael Crichton. In it, he makes some very good points about humanity, hubris, and technological caution, among others. But that doesn't negate the fact that it's still a story about something that has never happened to anyone, and thus by reading it I'm escaping into the story world and leaving my world behind for a bit.

@abarratt8869 3 года назад

On the theme that some fines effect the poor than the rich; Jeremy Clarkson once pointed out that it was cheaper to park a car on double yellow lines in Oxford city centre than it was to pay for all day parking in the car park...

@slideways8022 3 года назад

But parking in Oxford cost the same for everyone, too much

@lucie4185 3 года назад

Only a rich idiot would leave a car in Oxford centre to get bashed by the busses and scratched by cyclists and the rogue denizens of Blackbird Leys.

@ela_toile 3 года назад

i was born in poland, to an american dad. i have an american citizenship, we moved to the u.s. 7 years ago, now im trying to get back to the eu. if it means i must get rid of my u.s. citizenship, so be it. seriously, theres nothing here for me

@sisuguillam5109 3 года назад

Hope you will make it home safely... and soon!

@quanbrooklynkid7776 3 года назад

Bye

@RomilCPatel 2 года назад

You can get polish citizenship by decent

@wrenrix 3 года назад

I literally looked in the description for the petition

@evan 3 года назад

petition.parliament.uk/petitions/554690/sponsors/new?token=PHKjkK88WnivLe2WEOEP

@wrenrix 3 года назад

@@evan thank you

@cjhification 3 года назад

@@evan it's currently being checked as 5 people have already supported it. You will need to update when it goes live again (might take a few days).

@merrymermaid 3 года назад

it says please try again in a few days!

@Tami_Kat 3 года назад

Yeah, I’m up to signing it in a few days

@Mia-jw5hh 3 года назад

welcome back lava lamp, we missed you

@evan 3 года назад

Kevin says thank you

@liamgbooth 3 года назад

There is a new way the UK offers out driving related offences. It is based on the severity of the offence and a percentage of your monthly wage. 50%, 100% or 150%. It's been in force a couple of years.

@IceMetalPunk 3 года назад

TikTok is not banned in the US. It was going to be, but a judge ordered an injunction on that which gave TikTok's parent company enough time to sell their US rights to US-based Oracle, and with a US company in charge of the US portion of the app's dealings, the ban never went into effect.

@latortue09 3 года назад

I stumbled on your videos after making similar ones on TikTok! Someone told me to check your stuff out. I am a US citizen in the Netherlands. I'm so glad you brought up the "America centrism" of people saying "but what if you want to live in the US again some day?!" when you talk about renouncing. Sooo many American "expats" (I don't really use this word) seem to be temporary workers in their country, that I find this sentiment all the time. I always get a little exhausted having to explain why I would not want to move back to "the greatest country on earth". It's just tiring to explain that I do not see it that way and have not for a while. I'm thinking of buying a house in NL soon and really getting myself rooted here, but all this tax stuff makes me a little afraid to do that until I am no longer a US citizen. Great videos!

@christinebechhansen7475 3 года назад

In Denmark speeding tickets (and some other ticket types) are income dependent - so people with higher income are fined a higher amount.

@alexanderkono6369 3 года назад

I do think that it's worth noting that the person who made the comment about immigrating to the US does a point about how stupidly hard it is for non-Americans to move here. It feels like the US gov doesn't want people to leave, but also doesn't want people to come here either.

@laura1000 3 года назад

Kinda like a prison?

@nxtx 3 года назад

In addition to immigrating to the US being difficult it’s incredibly expensive.

@amygdala9679 3 года назад

In Switzerland the ticket prices for traffic violations are calculated according to the income of the person. Pretty good concept in my opinion!

@RebeccaElizabeth 3 года назад

After your video my boyfriend gave me an ultimatum: American Citizenship or Marriage. So now I have to renounce :D

@ganzsichertobi 3 года назад

I'm not really surprised after your video about your last experience in the US :)

@SofiaBerruxSubs 3 года назад

Why dont they renounce their citizenship? Or why does anyone have to renounce their citizenship?

@ganzsichertobi 3 года назад

@@SofiaBerruxSubs because they are living outside the US. both for many years. Also she probably already fulfills any requirements to acquire the German citizenship. acquiring us citizenship is a pita. (he mentions this in this video iirc) Also look at his most watched video where he explains taxation of us citizens and their significant others. That's enough reason in my opinion.

@quanbrooklynkid7776 3 года назад

Don't come back

@RebeccaElizabeth 3 года назад

@@quanbrooklynkid7776 You mean I shouldn't go "back" to a country that has basically become a meritocracy, has no universal health care, where education costs tens of thousands of dollars (mine is..*free*) and there is no safety net when you lose a job? Gladly. :)

@BenLlywelyn 2 года назад

I'm considering renouncing my American citizenship. No one told me America would be like an evil ex-boyfriend with my bank account details.

@heatherblowsbigones 3 года назад

My boyfriend is what’s considered an “Accidental American” as he was born in the US while his British parents were living working out there. He moved to the UK when he was 2 years old, so has spent some 30 years here. We only recently found out about the tax situation and are now worried about our options. Once the petition has been reviewed, we will be back to sign it!!!

@dehn6581 3 года назад

If he hasn't already, American Expatriates on Facebook has many in the same situation who have a lot of experience and happy to talk. The admin is a bit brutal at times, but it's in general a good place for info - and Evan's joined us there too which is fun.

@heatherblowsbigones 3 года назад

@@dehn6581 thank you so much, I will tell him to check it out!

@Bentleyspeed81 3 года назад

Has he filed a US tax return? If he hasn't and does not want to migrate to the US in the next 10-20 of so years he could renounce his US citizenship without filing a tax return. It would cost 2350USD but its minor compared to some of the accountancy costs which can cost up to 75000 to process.

@heatherblowsbigones 3 года назад

@@Bentleyspeed81 thank you for this information! He hasn’t filed a tax return - from the research we’ve done he pays a higher rate of tax over here so doesn’t have to pay anything, and the penalty for not doing so is a fine of 5% of his US assets (which we don’t have) - but I think we are going to need to save up the necessary funds to renounce his citizenship as his citizenship is a huge issue (e.g. we can’t travel to the US because he doesn’t have a US passport and all US citizens are required to use their US passport within the US) I also need to do some research as to how this would affect me once we marry, and any children we may have. Birth right citizenship makes no sense 😂

@davidcurry5239 3 года назад

@@heatherblowsbigones "Difficulty of travel to US" sounds like a good non-tax reason to renounce US citizenship.

@rentisme 3 года назад

BTW, his petition was REJECTED because, and I quote 'It’s not clear what the petition is asking the UK Government or Parliament to do.' On a petition called 'Illegalise financial institutions' discrimination against US Born UK Residents: Investigate the impact of the US acts of FATCA and FBAR on US-born UK residents'. That was DENIED, my god.

@jayzo 3 года назад

If you renounced your US citizenship (once you'd acquired UK citizenship) the UK _technically_ can't deport you because that'd render you stateless which is a breach of international law.

@MittensZora 3 года назад

Welcome back to a Yankee who isn't sure if he's British enough

@madabbafan 3 года назад

If he can make and serve a cup of tea correctly using loose leaf tea, knowing the CORRECT way round to add the milk and tea to the cup and pour from a china tea pot then he passes as British enough

@MittensZora 3 года назад

@@madabbafan agreed

@SwiftTelly20 3 года назад

LOL!!

@lucie4185 3 года назад

@@madabbafan hmm I am not convinced I need to know his stance on biscuits first. If he is a custard cream dunker, then he clearly has more to learn.

@madabbafan 3 года назад

@@lucie4185 if he is a dunker at all there will be an issue.

@franciswaters7043 3 года назад

Renounces US Citizenship *totally for political not tax reasons* 😂

@_stephanie 3 года назад

Signed the petition, I agree that I never want to go back. My dad got really annoyed when I told him the US is my "7th choice". I chose that number at random, but after I thought about it it turns out the US is #11. . .

@dizdozable 3 года назад

What were the top 10?

@littleinfinities 3 года назад

You say ‘even the Prime Minister couldn’t escape’ but tbf Boris Johnson couldn’t escape from a locked room if you gave him the key and pointed a sign saying ‘open here’ at the lock.

@1chish 3 года назад

Oh brilliant. We have a fuming Leftie with us.... He led us to escape the Remain Parliament that had been destroying our democracy for 3 years, he beat Corbyn by a landslide so we escaped Marxism and he got us to escape from the EU as we decided in 2016. Seems rather good at 'escaping' to me.

@littleinfinities 3 года назад

@@1chish Ah, we can agree to disagree I'm sure, but I must say thank you, I've never been called a 'fuming Leftie' before and it's just about made my night 😂

@1chish 3 года назад

@@littleinfinities Always happy to agree to disagree Sophie. And always happy to correct fuming Lefties .. 😉🤣

@michaelbowling1362 3 года назад

Helicopter is probably the US government checking up on you 😂

@danielstopps 3 года назад

To be honest when I was 5 I wanted to migrate to America, now it’s like nah I’ll stick with 🇬🇧

@julianshepherd2038 3 года назад

Are you 9?

@erikrobinson2547 3 года назад

Good choice.

@seanmcfarland5083 3 года назад

UK sucks

@chesh1rek1tten 3 года назад

Dude, your profile picture is literally illegal in Germany. Also wtf. Just.. wow

@thestorytellingmathematician 3 года назад

About the car ticket thing, a good thing I saw that sums it up it "punishable by fine means legal for the rich"

@katerinaluv2806 3 года назад

Yeah. I know someone who has gotten 4 speeding tickets this year. Each at least 30 over and each also reduced to a parking ticket with no points because they paid a lawyer to go to court for them.

@amiscellaneoushuman3516 3 года назад

I feel that fines should be a percentage of the offenders income not a set figure.

@AM-xt4jj 3 года назад

@@amiscellaneoushuman3516 I feel that wouldn't be fair either. The example Evan gives focuses on a very wealthy person. But in general there are wage differences between a construction worker, a teacher, and an engineer. Would you really be okay with giving a higher fine to the engineer, for breaking the same law?

@amiscellaneoushuman3516 3 года назад

@@AM-xt4jj Perhaps I wasn't clear enough, what I mean is that each offence should have a set percentage of income which is taken, rather than a set amount of money. For example, if the fine is 1% of annual income then someone earning £1,000,000 will pay £10,000 while someone earning £10,000 will pay £100 however they will both have paid the same amount of their income. Therefore, the fine will impact everyone who has to pay it equally rather than disproportionately affecting the poor. *numbers given are purely for illustrative purposes and are not intended to be realistic

@AM-xt4jj 3 года назад

@@amiscellaneoushuman3516 I understood what you meant. But I still disagree. Someone who makes 60000 a year would pay double compared to someone who earns 30000. But they commit the same act. I agree that as an incentive for the rich a fine does not work, but creating such a structure doesn't seem fair to me. Instead I would create a system where multiple fines stack up and then they might get their license taken or must do social hours. I think such measures would be a better incentive for rich people.

@alexemmadebor3698 3 года назад

A few years ago, the Canadian government took the drastic step of expelling the head of the Eritrean consulate in Toronto because he’d been involved in levying the 2% expat tax on Eritreans living in Canada. It seems Canada doesn’t like foreign governments shaking down Canadian residents. That is, unless the foreign government is the United States.

@natalieroy4849 2 года назад

A year late but I agree with you. There is also talk in Canada to make taxes citizenship based as well. I hope they don't do this as a Canadian living in the US.

@grantparman4705 3 года назад

The USA is currently a dystopian hellscape. Our major party choices for the upcoming presidential election are both abysmal, our government is rotten to the core, and we are the worst country on earth when it comes to the pandemic response. I'm an American living in the USA, so I am speaking from firsthand experience.

@ricochet4674 3 года назад

So am I. At this point we need foreign intervention to fix the scenario. I bet it will happen eventually. I just hope it happens before shit hits the fan.

@grantparman4705 3 года назад

@@ricochet4674 Hang in there. If things hit rock bottom, we can only go up from there.

@xaviercopeland2789 3 года назад

What government isn’t corrupt? Aren’t your opinions on presidents completely subjective? Aren’t the number of deaths we have in relation with our population pretty low even compared to other countries looking at the numbers? It’s honestly not worse than many other countries or as bad as you’re making it out to seem.

@dougall1687 3 года назад

I've a timeline of Eng->US->Canada->US and then married a Canadian in the US where we both got green cards. So taxes are fun. But just a note to keep an eye out for ongoing changes in pensions treaties and whether they ever change if you are/were a PR rather than a Citizen.

@janicew9 3 года назад

I'm in the process of leaving a high-demand christian religion in the US and it's striking how many similarities there are between this process and leaving the US. For example, you can't just leave. If you stop attending, they will track you down and harass you "kindly" with guilt trips and shame until you return, even if you move. Most folks who want to leave have to get a lawyer to sign send a letter telling the church to leave them alone. I used to dream of leaving the country (for other reasons, related to our country going up in flames) but this video makes it feel so daunting!

@sisuguillam5109 3 года назад

Look into it anyways. There are plenty of places that will welcome you as a Student (for example) in the EU. Quite often you pay very little or nothing for the actual tuition. Is it very different from College or Uni in the US? Yes... but that isn't nessecarily a bad thing. Sending you hugs and strength! Stay safe! Wishing you the best for your future plans.

@janicew9 3 года назад

@@sisuguillam5109 that is so kind, thank you for your reply! I'll keep this in mind when things get tough

@sisuguillam5109 3 года назад

@@janicew9 🥰 you are welcome!

@mahohmei Год назад

Which church?!?

@johnmunro4952 3 года назад

Boris was born in the USA. He used to love it and banged on about it all the time... until they chased him for tax. Then he dropped it like a bad habit.

@ArchitectAnna 3 года назад

Hey Evan, Loved the video, as a dual US citizen living in the UK I understand your frustration. Your petition was rejected on UK Gov and I would definitely support it moving forward if you submitted another one. We could potentially work together on this. Hope you are well!

@Ada-xr6bj 3 года назад

in Finland if u get a speeding ticket u get taxed depending on your income. if you are rich u pay more

@sotirismaragos 3 года назад

Evan please let everyone know that you have to be a UK citizen or resident to sign. Too many non-eligible signs and the petition goes to the trash bin... Also just so you know it's not working yet they're checking it.

@amys8082 3 года назад

In the uk if you get fined it’s now based on a percentage of your income rather than a set amount so that rich people can’t just get away with a small fine they’ll actually have to pay a decent amount and I think that’s so much better

@shalomjackie192 3 года назад

Imagine if Evan renounces his citizenship and then marries an American

@harisadu8998 3 года назад

That doesn't make you a citizen. But it would be funny, yes.

@shalomjackie192 3 года назад

@@harisadu8998 I was just saying cos then he’d have to start paying them tax again lol

@harisadu8998 3 года назад

@@shalomjackie192 Marrying, alone won't cause you to enter the tax net. However, the spouse, if American would still be under a global tax net of course.

@michellezevenaar 3 года назад

There are an estimated 6 million Americans living outside the US!

@meaganmw1205 3 года назад

Evan: *posts video My Brain: it’s Sunday, I guess!

@MittensZora 3 года назад

Same, I was looking at my home page and was confused why there was a new video because I forgot about community videos

@LadyMephistopheles 3 года назад

Big same

@ritadpt 3 года назад

About the driving fines: That's why in Finland the value of the fine depends on your income, I believe!

@neuroh8838 3 года назад

I live in Japan and deal with this double tax issue. It is totally ridiculous. I have French and American citizenship. My wife is Japanese, I totally wasn't thinking about the fact our kid would also have to deal with this double tax issue. I was only thinking of the upside of having multiple citizenships lol. I personally won't renounce because I do think about moving back one day. But the double tax situation is always nagging me.

@TravelingwithKristin 3 года назад

same

@doransoran 2 года назад

@@TravelingwithKristin the fact ur channel with 100k subscribers is just so casually replying like damn 🥲

@patienceisalpha 9 месяцев назад

Attends le maximum (18 ans) avant declarer la naissance de ton enfant à l'ambassade US. Si tu penses que ça vaut le coup pour l'enfant alors tu le déclare. (consular report of birth abroad)

@luke2393 3 года назад

After college I plan on moving to the London, but I wish someone would fix our tax laws/education system/healthcare/debt/wages. While I think America is a great country certain things we just missed the mark on.

@annikaz999 3 года назад

I distinctly remember the date and time I realized I could live outside of the US. And then I left.

@davidcurry5239 3 года назад

Getting final confirmation of UK citizenship is a good time to start the 'revoking US citizenship' shennanigans.

@laurabritton1613 3 года назад

Hi Evan! I’m a Canadian CPA and routinely deal with US citizens tax issues. Two things - 1. There is an awesome free webinar that is put on by an American lawyer (who practices in Canada exclusively on US tax and renunciation issues) that I’d highly recommend. Check out Moody’s Tax for the date of the next webinar. 2. I get that renunciation is expensive. However, doing it when you are younger and have fewer assets will be far cheaper than doing it when you have accumulated more wealth. Consider it an investment in future tax savings.

@joshtiley3460 3 года назад

“Hey Guys and welcome back to an American German speaking Londoner”

@robertdonnan2893 3 года назад

It says the petition will be up in a few days because they’re reviewing it before it’s posted but I’ll wait until it’s up and sign it. Good video dude.

@adamkorhan8465 3 года назад

Mentions the US tax system *Nomad Capitalist has entered the chat*

@jayc9345 3 года назад

Unfortunately, but understandably, it's not just the getting away from the US that's difficult, but also being allowed in other countries. I don't have a college education and will never be able to afford one, which means that it will be nearly impossible to meet ANY other country's requirements for nearly any visas. I get why it's made so difficult in terms of not wanting foreigners to flood in and take advantage of the system, but I feel so trapped in the US. Like I'm banging on a window asking for someone to let me out, and all the neighbors are just saying, "we don't care that it's your captor's fault, you aren't good enough to come live in a place where we treat people like people ". I just feel so hopeless and frustrated.

@sisuguillam5109 3 года назад

Welcome to the EU... where a lot of Unis are free - even for US citzens. Or really cheap. A lot of the courses are in english, too. Good luck!

@jayc9345 3 года назад

@@sisuguillam5109 tuition is cheap or free- cost of living is not, and student visas severely limit the amount of hours you can work. Believe me, I have looked into this.

@sisuguillam5109 3 года назад

@@jayc9345 Dang... maybe the eastern parts of the EU? I hope you will find a way to reach your goals!

@jayc9345 3 года назад

@memes memes oh, so in other words, you're a Canadian who aspires, for some unimaginable reason, to be American.

@sisuguillam5109 3 года назад

@memes memes do you understand how societies function? How insurances function? You person disregard for the wellbeing of others should not matter in a civilised society - and luckily in Canada (and in my own home country to a wide extent) it doesn't.

@vaudevillian7 3 года назад

and Britain wasn’t even a foreign country at the time

@laurencefraser 3 года назад

Hey, at least he acknowledged that it was about not paying taxes rather than the "representation" propaganda.

@vaudevillian7 3 года назад

@@laurencefraser ah it wasn’t a criticism, merely an addition

@lottie2525 2 года назад

I was so shocked about the taxation situation for Americans abroad that you raised in your previous video. Jaw to the floor! I already realised America is pretty shitty to its citizens about many things but this stealth tax is completely taking the piss! I talked to an American work colleague yesterday and he was pleased to have the chance to have a rant and see that someone actually knew about it.

@hannahphillips6293 3 года назад

Was the Chinese company Hauwei? They have been advertising no stop on Canadian RU-vid.

@evan 3 года назад

👀

@F100cTomas 3 года назад

Got a few ads here in the Czech Republic too

@sdewitte1629 3 года назад

Thank you so much for these videos - you have no idea the amount of stress, tears shed & pain on top of the money my family spent renouncing. For years we tried to get change but the time came when there was no choice but to do so. Good luck & thank you again!

@jmmonaco5680 3 года назад

Great vid. I found your recent one on taxation infprmative, funny and depressing at the same time. Yes, that's what being 'informed' about US taxation when living abroad means. Ugh. I've been living in tge UK since 1990, originally from Boston, and have no intention on going back to the US. I've considered renouncing my citizenship (I have an Irish passport) but now my son has rocked the boat by deciding to work in California and it looks like he's enjoying it. Also, I have a parent in Boston whose small estate I'll be responsible for at some point. The whole taxation thing and the expense for renouncing makes me angry. I feel like I'm a prisoner of the system. I feel even more sympathy for others born to US citizens who have never even lived in the US. How crazy is that, that they too have to file every year. Hope to see your petition up and running soon.

@ava8510 3 года назад

Omg I wanna sign that petition 😂✨

@evan 3 года назад

Thanks! It's here petition.parliament.uk/petitions/554690/sponsors/new?token=PHKjkK88WnivLe2WEOEP

@seneca983 3 года назад

Rejected.

@Trek001 3 года назад

Evan, if you ever became a citizen of the UK then I would be proud of you

@adamkorhan8465 3 года назад

He’s literally already applied

@Trek001 3 года назад

@@adamkorhan8465 I know but he hasn't become one yet which is to what I was referring

@aoibhinquinn7310 3 года назад

On the renouncing US citizenship thing, I have 2 reasons for keeping mine. 1) I can't afford to give it up 2) My current partner wants to be an academic and if he were to get an amazing research position in the US I would want him to have an alternate way of living there legally so he wouldn't necessarily get fucked over by needing a work visa

@benwhatford8825 3 года назад

When Evan was talking about speeding fines I just thought it would interest people to know that in the UK speeding fines are based off of a persons salary/income so that people can not just speed without caring because there rich, this is why you get the headlines about people like ant mcpartlin being fined 86k

@irenefernandez6656 3 года назад

I LOVE the colour, the light, the tone and clarity of this video, well done!!

@confusedSoulof2010 3 года назад

TikTok did not in fact end up banned in the US, it's still legal...

@IceMetalPunk 3 года назад

Yeah, because its American portion was sold to Oracle.

@mehtalks 3 года назад

The front-light hitting in the window and the reflection/shape of everything around it makes a very nice slight skull shape. Good job on the spooky vibes. 😆 (I'm /totally/ sure it was intentional, of course)

@laravio 3 года назад

Ah America, the land of the free. How amazingly ironic it is that you literally cannot escape the US.

@pixlmyst 3 года назад

The lighting and soft background in this video is really great! The hard work is paying off!

@OverlyCurly 3 года назад

"Hello everybody and welcome back to a man who counts helicopters passing by on a daily basis"

@shoelesshipster 2 года назад

I feel like I’ve passed a terminal genetic disease to my daughter. 😞 US citizenship is such a curse.

@TKelich 3 года назад

I have only been living in the UK for 4 months now, and don't see myself ever returning to the US to live if I can help it. I would gladly give up my US citizenship to become a Brit.

@mahohmei Год назад

I keep considering it. I recently visited London for 4 days and it was such a breath of fresh air compared to the hellhole of a country I live in now (USA).

@marcusmyge 3 года назад

Welcome back to a person who's seen more government forms than people this year.

@florkiler6242 3 года назад

"5 people have already supported Evan Edinger’s petition." mmm yes it is going rather splendid indeed

@Liggliluff 3 года назад

(5:40) Fines are made in 4 ways: - Fixed price in the law that must be updated ever so often, like in USA. Forgotten laws will then have meaningless fees, and large fees will hurts poor people a lot but won't affect rich people. - A point system per law, with a law that defines how much a point is worth, like in Australia. It's easier to update the fees since you only update one law. It still has the same issue about punishing poor people. - A system based on minimum wage, like Hungary. It's the same as Australia where the point is defined as the minimum wage, but updates according to the minimum wage. Still the same issue with punishing poor people. - A system based on your income, like Sweden and Finland. The fines are defined as a number of days worth of salary. Rich people are punished as hard as poor people, and poor people aren't ruined by breaking one law. You also get more money into the government when a rich person do break the law.

@librasgirl08 3 года назад

I talked with an American friend, who said, when she lived in Japan, she didn't had to pay her US taxes and now it's the same in Germany, both countries have a special deal with the US. She has to file taxes, but doesn't have to pay anything.

@blosphere1234 3 года назад

She'll have to for the portion that goes over the foreign income exclusion limit. That's somewhere around 110k USD in a year. So if you're an English teacher in Japan for a local language school, no worries ever getting anywhere near that figure.

@librasgirl08 3 года назад

@@blosphere1234 she's far from that in Germany as well

@blosphere1234 3 года назад

@Nicky L most of the people I know file themselves. If you have uncomplicated finances (just income from work), it's not that bad I hear.

@nxtx 3 года назад

True-ish. If a country has a no double taxation agreement with the US the person still has to file US taxes annually but possibly not pay. If their income is above a certain amount they may have to pay the US is their county of tax residency’s tax rate doesn’t nullify the amount. It can get wildly complicated and expensive just in tax preparation if a person’s tax situation is complex. Otherwise, self-file for free.

@dehn6581 3 года назад

The filing is the expense he's talking about - Americans abroad in the US tax system have to do a lot more complicated paperwork because we're essentially treated as potential criminals and corporations (the FBAR spoken about in the previous isn't actually a tax document, it's a Financial Crime Enforcement Network issue).

@emmadubuc3121 3 года назад

US citizen trying to move to the UK here... was looking forward to signing the petition but it’s been canceled. Thanks for your videos as always

@shogun2heroicvictories15 3 года назад

Never saw the attraction of the US. So glad I am not born with a noose known as US citizenship around my neck. Glad I was born else where and won't be hit with a surprise tax

@kilgoretrout3966 3 года назад

i would love to retire to several countries other than the US. My issue is, i cannot renounce, simply because my regular income is from S.S. disability...a nice amount, actually. That would go away with renouncing, i am reasonably sure. We have other revenue, insofar as land to be sold, Pension, etc. i really, REALLY want out of this madhouse, just am not certain about the feasibility, even without renouncing. now i'm depressed.

@MattNav 3 года назад

Great video Evan 👍👌 Btw having trouble finding the link to the Gov UK petition you mentioned in the video

@evan 3 года назад

SORRY! It's there now

@MattNav 3 года назад

@@evanbrilliant thanks Evan. Love your work as always

@JonTonyJim 3 года назад

I haven't watched a video in a month or so, your video quality is on another level now - great job!

@RichardGadsden 3 года назад

Travelling to the US - e.g. to visit your parents - still means going through immigration if you're not a US citizen. I wouldn't suggest giving up your citizenship unless you're prepared to commit to never going back even for a visit. As a Brit, I can say that US immigration is a nightmare, even just when I want to go there on holiday.

@chesh1rek1tten 3 года назад

I've been multiple times.. but he's white and living in a western country.. it's kinda annoying but not that horrible.

@merrping7777 3 года назад

Visually, this video was really lovely to watch, the colour, the clarity- everything! It looks fantastic!

@lewisfrisby5673 3 года назад

Hey ya'll welcome back to back to a man who says he posts on a sunday and then posts on a Thursday

@evan 3 года назад

Well Sunday AND Thursday :)

@lewisfrisby5673 3 года назад

Yeh I know I love your videos

@Nat-qj6cr 3 года назад

I missed it because I missed the update.

@chaole1000 3 года назад

I’m a Californian. We don’t associate ourselves with the rest of the country.

@chilldude30 2 года назад

America: where you're too free to leave

@simonchinnery1738 3 года назад

Yeeees a video on Thursday again! What a wonderful surprise!

@enbywithcats 3 года назад

when he said pennsylvania left i thought of a michigan left **shudders**

@alfieisherwood5568 3 года назад

Love your videos Evan your a great guy you supply great content that's factual and funny and interesting. You are a small insight to America however become more English by the day. You are an English citizen in our eyes and it's only a matter of time until you are officially.

@hedgehog_1086 3 года назад

I'm gonna scare my future children with bedtime stories about the greedy tax gremlin

@GeoffreyEngelbrecht Год назад

I had an American friend when I was living in Switzerland who once he obtained his Swiss citizenship renounced his American citizenship for exactly this reason. I am Canadian and I recall when the US was clamping down on this I was called into my bank and forced to sign a document that I wasn’t American. Just ludicrous, but I had the feeling at the time the US government was in serious financial trouble and desperate for the tiny amount of extra money they could scrounge from ex-pat Americans with the delusion that these people are ridiculously rich and only living outside of the US to avoid paying tax.

@beccaalee 3 года назад

After watching this, I feel less shite about currently being unemployed. Now when I'm asked, it's not "I'm unemployed because I can't find a job" it's "I'm unemployed cause I don't wanna pay the US Government"

@onewhoisanonymous 3 года назад

Currently living in China. I pay Chinese tax and US tax. Fun. I am an American citizen who can't decided where to go next. I don't really want to go back to the USA. Even if I tried to go back, I can't apply for jobs in the US! America companies make me fill out job forms online but most jobs have electronic applications that don't account for overseas addresses/job info.

@DJ-tr6nf 3 года назад

Ummm the government rejected the petition...

@mikaylaj4322 3 года назад

These videos give me so much joy! I’m glad they’re back

@FiveOClockTea 3 года назад

So on the way to having a culture the USA stopped at cult and forgot that there were 3 more letters to it?

@JustTheJames 3 года назад

Evan, I don't know how you do it, but you somehow make each video more and more visually stunning! Keep it up!

@ugrasergun 3 года назад

In civilized countries tickets and fines are not fixed but based on your income.

@jukka-pekkatuominen4540 2 года назад

About those speeding tickets: In Finland all fines are payed according to you income. They count a day rate for you income (there is a minimum so it still hurts the poorest the most) and they you pay as many day's salary as the fine. So for instant in case you get 13 day's fine you will pay lower amount when you have a low income and higher amount when you have higher. There are still some basic fines though. Parking violations are a set price. And I believe low speeding violations have a set amount. But in general it works like this. It also works like this is you get any other fines. Perhaps you are fined for a robbery or tax theft or something. You will have to pay the fine based on your income. This is made so that you wouldn't be able to break the law just being rich.