@@Agamingperson ya you're right coz they did that just after 1945 so taking over whole soviet union Africa and middle east then go for USA so it doesn't makes sense I would say if that happens like after 5 years or more than it's possible
I just realized that iran being overtrown by a nazi coup instead of a regular fascist coup, makes a lot of sense, since the word Iran means “for the aryans” so it makes sense that right wing extremist would not only be fascists but also nazis
Also it would be historically accurate, since Iran had an active and strong nazi party which was planning to overthrow the government and establish a new pro axis one
I like how you showed that taking Moscow wouldn’t have resulted in an instant Soviet capitulation, the ussr was simply too big and too determined for taking the capital to have had that big of an impact.
if Moscow would be taken, the soviets would basically lose because of the morale of your troops losing both Leningrad and Moscow, most of Siberia was also autonomous from the ussr, some even being “separated”
@@poffy02 I think you just completely ignored what I was saying, all I was saying is that soviets would keep fighting for a long time after Moscow was taken. With how much the Soviets hated facism, and how motivated they were to keep fighting, they would’ve kept fighting for a long time after Moscow had fallen. I did not say to what success they would fight, just that they would not surrender.
@@poffy02 taking moscow would have worked if the germans weren't nazis, surrendering meant not only death, but the complete extermination of the slavic peoples, the soviets would have fought to the last man, woman or child
@@eduardcardenas9736 "surrendering meant not only death, but the complete extermination of the slavic peoples" always amuses me that people that are absolutely clueless on the matter still write comments with full confidence like they actually know what they are talking about. No one planned to exterminate slavic people. NS germany was friendly to slavic people. Hundreds of sources and policies towards slavic nations confirm this. The "extermination" thing is just a soviet propaganda. You should take a deeper look into this. Fun fact more than 300 000 slavs fought for the wehrmacht and SS, not counting another several hundred thousands of soviet troops and citizens.
I do think that Saudi Arabia joining the axis (unless there was a secret coup d'etat or something) would be extremely unrealistic, and the Japanese surrender (also unless the Atomic Bombs were dropped early) would also be pretty hard to acheive as the Allies, along with how quickly the Germans advanced into China, the Soviet Union and other countries BUT, overall, I think it included a decent amount of realism. I really like how they didn't include a Spanish entry into the axis though. Edit: I can also say I love the detail of Germany invading the Soviet Union sooner in May so they have a small advantage because the winter would be farther away (which would likely make the Germans have more time preparing for it)
Great video but on my opinion, I don't think Germany would have continued the war in asia, (As Germany didn't declare war on US in 1941 in this scenario ). I think Germany would have signed peace with britain under strict conditions and Asia would have fell into something quite similar to what happened in real life between USA and USSR, more like a cold war between two states that aren't officially at war. China would have probably turned fascist, profiting from the help of Germany like the Communist got the help of the USSR in our timeline. In 1945 both sides would have been extremely tired from war, especially Germany would have to pacify all the newly occupied territories wich would be a great pressure for them as a lot of partisans would probably organise (Like in Yugoslavia in WW2), like the USA in Vietnam or France in Algeria. On the other side, the US would have less losses than in our timeline due to the fact that they didn't intervene in Europe.
You've set yourself great potential for a sequel, I'd pay to watch it. While the lore may be unrealistic, it makes for an interesting worldbuilding experience. keep up man!
Very detailed great job in all aspects I like the use of audio clips as well. Although obviously it would be impossible for this to have ever reasonably happened even if Germany made all the right decisions and other things went in their favor it’s still too much land for them to occupy and it also ignores geography a little bit. I don’t see the British people giving up after Churchill’s speech and due to the beliefs of Hitler the reich would still not have developed the nuclear bomb the USA would likely out of desperation sneak a few bombs onto the British Isles and send them towards Germany. A great sacrifice of millions of people but saving the world of a far larger number of deaths. But sometimes it’s better to throw realism out the window for a better story and video
This is the most unrealistic and under detailed video ever, how the hell did the German manage to invade asia since they be far from supply with sabotage ramped
@@Italian_Mapper Germany can't invade central asia. Japan would beat the Chinese. Germany can't invade China. Saudi arabia wouldn't want to mess around with the Italians. Germany can't invade middle east.
@Italian_Mapper Soviets did not rely on US Lend lease. It helped them be more specialized but if they didnt have it they still would have one. After America entered the war it was over. No way the germans could have one.
Very original work! I love the effort on realism! Next time make Central Powers victory in WW1, another original idea that not many people had ever thought about before
I don't think Turkey will remain neutral in this war. The Turkish government was following the Battle of Stalingrad very closely. If Stalingrad had been won, Turkish troops would have been deployed to attack the Caucasus. They would most likely raid the border with the Soviet Union. Since Stalingrad was lost, we continued to maintain neutrality
@@Italian_Mapper Ok, I've been voting in every post, I just hope that it doesn't take too much time, because I really love your content and I hope you never leave RU-vid, like some other Map Content Creators that I saw did, I was friends with one of them, but he leaved RU-vid and now he is making Football Content in TikTok, I hope that doesn't happens with you. Good work.
@@Italian_Mapper I think germany can win moscow and Stalingrad, But it will get pushed back by the allies. Soviet union will get Germany austria , Netherlands, Belgium ,Luxembourg, Northern Japan and other countries from Eastern block as communist countries And the west will have only france, Greece and Turkey.
So it would be a Soviet Victory scenario, the problem with this ideas is that the video would be like half just the soviets trying to push the Germans until they can. On top of that the allies would have to not make a move to liberate Europe which doesn't make sense
i don't know if this was intentional but it was super cool under standing how the germans beat the soviets with oil from Iran and the Arab peninsula witch gave their tanks oil in 1941-1943. so they were closer to their objectives by the end of the first year and could continue the fight in the second year in full capacity. also their air force most likely more help full in this timeline witch also had ripple effects.
Part 3 will come when I get the ideas because I still don't know how it will end For the maps I use standard templates or I just take it from google maps and then remake it with the borders I need from other maps
In this timeline Germany is able to mass produce a navy that could block the allied routes in the Atlantic Ocean, and with Germany focusing on the Middle East, the Italians in the Mediterrean and North Africa were far more supplied so they could gain superiority in Egypt and in the sea
belissimo il video, non molto realistico per la parte dove la germania avanza velocemente nella cina del nord (il giappone riusciva amalapena a supportare le proprie offensive dove la cina aveva delle ferrovie e strade, figuriamoci lassu), volevo solo chiederti che programmi usi per video come questo
I feel like germany advanced way too fast, russian war most likely would have ended in a stalemate along Moscow till d-day however german oil restictions being non existant here we would never know.
