My personal conclusion: Kartar uncle shouldn´t have been chosen at all as a wild card. He´s very sweet but he can´t even catch his breath, bless him. Manjeera´s voice is versatile and she can switch really well btw low notes and high pitched voice. Nirmitee proved that not only can they master western style but also severly difficult Hindustani notes. Also, the way they improvised a short children´s rhyme last time proves they´re true musicians ready to create everything fr. film to ad music!
You are right janta ko vote karna nahin ata hamare desh mein Manjira jaise kitne dhurandar kalakar bechare peeche reh jate hain unhein koi nahin poochta and jinhein Sangeet ka sa bhi nahin ata unke jay jaykare lagte hain
@@sapnathakur3096 Yes,you r right. Can anyone believe that geet won this show. He has such a terrible voice while manjeera,being such a melodious and trained singer got minimum votes. I am not able to digest it even now. Nirmitee and manjeera were best at their own places. I don't know why ppl voted very less for these two. In my views,last minute group or geet sagar should have got minimum votes because of their last performances.
WHAT THE HELL? Manjeera was the best female singer!!! She had a vocal range of 3 octaves!! What the hell are they voting on? Are we trying to find the next pop star or the next bhajan singer? This is ridiculous - Manjeera and Nirmtee were the best in their categories...if this was the US or UK they would have voted differently...stupid public.
kartarji sweet as though he is, is a far below par performer than the rest........but thats the vagaries of public voting for u...both nirmitti group and manjeera deserved to stay in the competition!!
Audience ko vote karne ka chance dena hi nhi chahiye. I personally believe that manjeera was the only talented singer in Shreya's group,rest three were not even close to her. In the same way,nirmitee was so very innovative and talented group that I still can't believe they both got minimum votes. Either the judges only should be given the chance to eliminate someone or there should be an independent guest judge panel who should decide this. Audience sometimes have no taste about music. How foolish is this they made geet sagar the winner and manjeera eliminated from the show. Pehli baat to,Shreya ko apni team me kartar ji ko nhi lena chahiye tha. It was a really bad decision. I don't want to disrespect him,but these type of shows provide a platform for young talents and when there were young contestants left with Shreya,why did she chose kartar ji. Ek baar khud unko sochna tha ki is show me kartar ji agar jeet bhi jayenge,to unko unki life me vo opportunities nhi mil payegi,jitni kisi young singer ko mil Pati. Just think kya karan Johar apni film me kartar ji ko gane ka mauka dete,and Sony music kya is age me unki music album record karta. And agar unhe yahan se cash price aur car mil bhi jati,to kya vo apni life ko phir se enjoy kar pate. Nhi. Kyunki,time kabhi wapas nhi aata. I know ki seekhne ki koi seema nhi hoti. Aap seekho,jitna chahe seekho,lekin aise competitions me agar aap aate ho,ro iska mtlb kisi doosre young talent ki seat chhenne vala kaam hai. And isme kartar ji ka fault nhi hai. Ye baat Shreya ko sochni chahiye thi,ki uske is decision se uski team se 1 contestant ka chance gya. And team bhi chodo,thode bade level pe dekha jaye,to itne bade show me aane ka chance ek young talented contestant ke liye gya. And see,ab jab kartar ji show me aa gye the,to Audience ne kabhi bhi unko bottom 2 me nhi aane diya,kyunki unki unar aur unki himmat ko dekhkar har koi unhe vote kar deta tha,lekin manjeera jaise talented young contestant ko vote nhi kiya. So I think that was Shreya's biggest mistake. Now,coming to Audience. Nowadays logo ka music ka taste itna kharab ho chuka hai ki Tony,badshah,honny singh ke gaano ko masterpiece bolte hai. Bchho ko raag alaap ka pata nhi,lekin rap aur catchy songs ke lyrics ka acche se pata hai. Kumar sanu,udit narayan,sonu nigam,Shaan,javed ali,Asha ji jaise acche singers ko kitne kam pucchte hai. They say ki inka time to chla gya. Sonu ji to chlo phir bhi bhagwan ki dua se accha khasa ga rhe hai,lekin aise na jaane kitne talented singers hai,jo bechare ghar par hi baithe hue hai aur dhvani,neha,jubin jaise singers ko remake pe remake ke baad bhi log sunte hai. Pata ngi,kya ho gya hai aaj india ko. Classical music ko koi kuchh samajh tahi nhi hai. Bas cringy lyrics aur bass boosted music se songs ban jata hai. Gulzaar saab,javed Akhtar ji ke lyrics ki koi value hi nhi hai. At last,main bas itna hi kehna chahunga,ki Jin logo ne yaha tak mera comment padha hai,please apne bchho ko Rafi saab,kishore kumar,mannadey saab,mukesh ji,sonu nigam ji,udit narayan ji,Shaan,Shankar mahadevan,hariharan ji ke gaane sunao jinke acche meaning ful lyrics hote hai. Please don't go behind the trend ki you tube me jo trending pe hoga,vo faltu songs vhi khud sunenge aur apne bccho ko sunaenge. Please don't do this. It's my humble request,please save indian music 🙏🙏
Audience should be more music literate before voting. They don't even know who is a fine singer. They should not be given the right to vote unless they really know the art. They fail terribly in their responsibility.
Tbh all the girls sound the same. There is no difference between the Sajda Sisters, and the other two younger females! Unbelievable! Shocked. I am shocked. Manjeera was the best!! She was the only one who tried something different. Stupid public.
This just goes to show what a bunch of fools we have as audience! Kartar Ji is a sweetheart but cmon, he cant compete in this show. what a waste of talent.
Probably they are looking for very different and fresh voice, not a copy of Lataji or Ashaji, just something new...may be this is why they rejected some of the singers.
Sonu jee apke leye ek newedan hy.agar sach me app lig reality so kaete hy to ek 9 sal ka ek bachee hy.jiska bao ka saya bachpan me chut gaya.aur vi bahut dukh vari kahani hy..kya use aplog ke manch pur moka mel sakta hy
Yes,absolutely. Thinking to Comment the same. In last performance,one good music listener can easily identify that manjeera was the only talented and perfect in Shreya's group. Audience voting sucks
Sonu Nigam ji , a kya kar dia apne . everybody knows last performance of Nermiti group was better . but only based on one performance you shouldn't take that decision . I hate Sonu Nigam for this foolish decision.
Baat to sahi hai aapki. Shreya ki team me bas ek manjeera hi best thi. But sonu ke paas koi option nhi tha. Last performance of nirmitee was very nice. He couldn't eliminate them. But that's public fault. Manjeera jaisi itni acchi singer ko Bahar kar diya show se. Pata nhi,kya bhaang khake vote kiya tha kya audience ne. Sonu ne sirf last performance ko dekhkar decision liya tha,jo ki us hisab se sahi tha. You can't blame him for that.
