Clear sky: I don’t want my son *1 year later* Clear sky: I WANT MY SON *2 days later* Clear sky: I don’t want him anymore Edit: woAH thank you for all the likes guys!
Clear Sky: he's not my son. Gray wing: he's my son, now, storms my dead wife. ---- Clear Sky: I want my son back. Gray Wing: ... --- Clear Sky: nevermind, he doesn't want to be a murderer like me, you can have him. Gray Wing: come here luke.
Nothing for Darkness yes he kinda is. He kill Rainswept flower and a bunch on other cats. He was also pretty angry most of the time we read in his POV. So.. (I have no recollection of writing this 😂😂)
Am I the only one confused that Honeyfern wasn’t expecting kits when she died because it would be “too sad” but they just had Bright Stream carried off by a hawk like it was nothing?
Dawn of The Clans has always (and always will be) my favorite series of Warriors. It really got back to the roots of the cats we know today and redefined what it meant to be a warrior. This PMV perfectly encapsulates that ideal and brought me back to when I first read DOTC! The illustrations and edits made it all flow so well and I could recall every single moment in this PMV happening in the books. Unfortunately, Vision of Shadows is starting to take over the community, so it's hard to find good PMVs from the better arcs these days. Overall, wonderful PMV and i'm happy to see that amazing artists are bringing back some of the best books!
I do agree, although you gotta give the Erins some credit for A Vision of Shadows- at least they're actually trying to make unique characters, and forbidden love is finally not the driving part of the story. Though DotD was definitely my 2nd favorite, bested only by TPB.
I’m sorry but the new series is awful lol and I agree DoTC is incredible but they really went wrong with Alderpaw’s whole story and from then on it just got worse
YES YES YES dawn of the clans has always been my favourite arc ever! The dynamic between grey wing and clear sky was amazing and all the characters (to me) were so interesting and very real. This is such a beautiful pmv keep up the great work!!!!
Dawn of the Clans was SO good. It really had the spirit, the emotional brutality, the *essence* of the first Warriors arc. It had the sense of epic ness and life that I feel like the rest of Warriors somewhat lacks now. Definitely my favorite Warriors arc, and criminally underrated by the fan base.
OMGGGGGG Roseshards this looks incredible! It's honestly amazing that you've made so many full length videos in such a short time on your channel, and this PMV really stands out among them! I love your painterly style so much that I can't believe I've never seen it before!!! The bright colors for the battle at the end really heightened the drama for me, and the emotions and storytelling was great as well! I could ramble on forever, lol, but just wanted to say that this is a wonderful project and you should feel very proud of it! :DDD
Me reading all the Dawn of The Clans books in one week and growing a emotional attachment to Gray Wing: Alrighty time to end off the series Me after finishing the last book in Dawn of The Clans: *you really had to do this to me.....why must you make my heart break so much?*
@@saltymarshmallo most of the warrior deaths aren't too sad. Ok gonna sound cliche but some of my favourite dead characters include Firestar and Tallstar. I think I liked Firestar more than Graywing in the first arc (not sure) but his death wasn't that sad. Maybe cuz he had a longer life, was cliche, was not so interesting anymore, whatever the reason, I wasn't too disappointed when he died. I was more sad when Tallstar died, and I definitely like Tallstar as much as I like Graywing. But his death. was so. Sad.
I'M DIGGING THE EXOTIC COLORS LIKE PINK/PURPLE/BLUE NEAR THE END. IT REALLY SETs a mood holy cruuud but serious this is simply the most amazing thing ever!!! you can tell there was so much work put into it and i remember watching your ain't it fun pmv with ivypool in it. you've improved since then! and i'm sure the pmv wasn't that long ago but still- i love the painty style in this one- it sets an old-ish look to it that really takes me back to dawn of the clans ohmy goodness good job ahah 👏👏👏
Oh man, this is so, so cool. I absolutely love the painted style you used for this and all the colours and your designs are lovely!! Plus, I'm a sucker for DOTC. Gotta agree that it's a really emotional ride and you depicted it really really well. I especially liked all of the expressions and colours you used
It's great to see another amazing PMV from you! ^^ I agree that Dawn Of The Clans is very underrated, so I adore the fact that you chose it! It's interesting to see that you (seemed to) portray Clear Sky as somewhat stoic and stubborn, but also very "torn apart" and unsure of his own feelings and actions Gray Wing somewhat confused, sad and desperate, trying to understand his brother whilst not being able to. I'm honestly not sure 'bout the style 'cause I don't see that much of a difference between this and your "Ain't It Fun"-PMV, bit that's probably just me, I gotta watch it again and compare it^^' Anyway, I love your style and your unique character designs and I especially like the way you painted the pictures in this paticular video, it makes it looks so... "ancient", idk lol, it kinda reminds me of an illustration from a children's book, very pleasing to look at and it gives a calm but deep nature to the paintings. (Gotta say that it makes me jealous :D ) Keep it up! I'm looking forward to more great projects! ♥
Gray Wing honestly died because he cared for others. Why so? He got asthma because he stayed in the fire for too long, BECAUSE he couldnt find his brother Clear Sky and in the end, he died because of THAT asthma, truly the only full grown, pure cat there is.
Whoa I loved this!!! Everything about it was so beautiful, I love how everything was always moving, even in “still” parts of it. Made the PMV feel alive.
famous quote from graywing to clearsky: "Kill me. Kill me and tell the stars you won." Graywing was the complete oppisite from clearsky and deserved a better brother then clearsky.
I just finished _Path_ _of_ _Stars_ today! I love the characters so much, the relationships with each other! _Dawn_ _of_ _the_ _Clans_ is my favorite series in Warriors!
Amazing! I just love your artstyle... especially yout shading! I also enjoy the lineless art you make. Just wishing to draw the fur as realistic and fluffy as you do xD
GrayWing: “ turtle tail!!!!!!!!! Don’t hang out with KITTYPETS “ Turtle tail : deal with it ;-; * becomes a kitty pet * DEAL WITH IT turtle tail * returns at the worst time ever *
Dawn of the Clans is the best arc in all of Warriors. Gray Wing, Thunder, Turtle Tail, Slate, River Ripple, Tall Shadow, and even Clear Sky....there are so many amazing and intriguing characters in this series. I’m so glad to see some of them done justice here. This is an amazing PMV! :)
Wwooooooooooooooaaaaaaaaaatyhhh Lineless looks so flippn cool!!! DAWN OF THE CLANS MY FAV! But Why does every pmv or map stops at The First Battle like the other books don't exist?
Am I the only one who loves Clear Sky as a villain? He is one of my favorite characters because we see him misunderstood and evil, then he regrets all he did and I just LOVE him. Even though he is mean to Gray Wing I don't like him because of that >:(
Your PMVs are so beautiful and well done! They are one of the best things on your channel. But this one, this one is unbelievable. YOU SHADED A 4:00 MINUTE VIDEO. Where did you get that patience?
Ok, I finished the 27th book yesterday night and really really needed to rewatch your amazing PMV. ✨💙 The relationships of Gray Wing, Clear Sky and Thunder are so complex, I needed just to watch something featuring it. Also, DotC is my fave arc now. 💜
This is amazing! Ain’t it fun was great, but you can tell how much you’ve improved even from then! This pmv is gorgeous, it has a very professional look to it. This must’ve taken forever, great job!
this is honestly one of the prettiest pmvs ive ever seen !!! the amount of detail put into this is astounding and i love the different colors and the whole style of it omgggg stan talent
Oh my god. WHO’S ARTWORK IS THAT! it’s the most amazing annimation skills and this person it SUPER good at drawing cats. Greywing still loves his brother, even after everything he did. Clear sky gets better. Dawn Of The Clans will always be my favorite series of Warriors.
No way it’s been three years since this was released. It’s incredible and always impresses me every time I watch it! My favorite part was how specific everything was and how you could keep up with the plot even if you hadn’t read the books. Great PMV. Favorite parts: 0:40 , 1:58 , 2:16 , 2:42 Favorite Animation parts: 0:20, 1:45, 0:45
Dawn of the Clans was so different than the other arcs because (in my opinion) it just seemed so real and beautiful and it really made me think about what it meant to be a warrior. This is extremely well made (just watched it a second time) and I look foreword to everything you post❤️
So- I've always loved the Dawn Of The Clans arc. It's frankly the best, and most well-written arc. The relationship between Gray Wing and Clear Sky is harsh. I've always felt that both of them had a fair point. River Ripple, Tall Shadow, and Wind Runner mostly kept to their own clans, but Thunder(the jerk in my opinion) always felt he had a fair opinion in something that was not his battle- Gray Wing and Clear Sky were brothers, and they had to sort out their differences by themselves.
This is 👌🏻👌🏻 scrumptious I love it. Dawn of the Clans is by far my favourite arc, I immediately fell in love with Grey Wing and Clear Sky ahah. I love the designs you used for all these characters hh
Me before reading the books: *Oh WhY Is GrEy WiNg NoT SpeLlEd GrAyWiNg and ClEaRsKy???* Me after reading the books: *oh StarClan, I'm such a Mouse-brain!*
I LOVE Gray Wing and DOTC in general, it’s honestly such an underrated arc. I really love how you portrayed each character, and the song choice is amazing!
Aw! I love this new style! Gray Wing really was a great character as well as Clear Sky. This PMV really captures the love and heartbreak the two had. So this gets a 100/10!
I dont really know whats happening here because im not into warriors but ohmygod??? your artstyle is aMAZING???? i absolutely adore this, just everythinf about it is incredible, the shading, the designs, the expreasions hust ,, ONGJSHEVDV
I love this! This is such a beautiful animation, much better than I could do, but I love the way you drew Thunder and Grey wing! They look almost exactly as I imagined them in the books! Great work!
Can we all collectively agree as a fandom that Clear Sky sucks? Amazing work! This has gotta be one of the most polished and beautiful PMVs that I’ve ever seen.
Damn I love this sooo much!! Love seeing DOTC stuff on youtube- I honestly think the plotlines in DOTC are way more interesting than most of the “modern day” conflicts in the series. Lots of unique characters too.. I loved Lightning Tail and Gray Wing and Turtle Tail
I love this! I know you may not have time to read this but just Incase, This is extraordinarily beautiful! This coloring, the expressions, and the feeling. I can’t get over all your videos, you have inspired me so much, I look up to you and I am in awe on how everything you make is perfect in its own way. The story that this shows is so amazing. One day I hope My animations and videos can be like yours, thanks for your time!
I love this so much! It’s so detailed and great and your art style is amazing! Even if parts of cats were awkward in places, it’s still great. And it’s good to see some more Dawn of the Clans stuff
Hey a little part of me is hoping you will see this RoseShard, I really appreciate you and this map because GrayWing is my favorite character in the whole series and the way you illustrated this is beautiful and I hope I could be like you someday.
Ok holy shit this is stunning. The painted style, the expressions,the colors, the scenes,, everything is so well done! Also DotC was the best Arc change my mind
