Zuckerberg's EU testimony: what he didn't answer 

that's precise.

PG eighteen he probably meant to say 100 since 9 and 0 are both next to each other in keyboards

Obviously because inevitably Facebook is a government tool in the USA

Chris McCaulley are you spamming this in every comment section

Chris McCaulley that case was settled for 65m$

I noticed that too. He looks very hurt.

He thought it was going to be easier

@@bridgettebianchi9315 SHADOW PROFILES! he had a himpscare when he heard that word

Then you should have seen the one with singapore politicians..:)

Yeap, it was obvious harder

LaFarrugia He is.

LaFarrugia Brexit yes. Ukip no.

I'm sorry but sometimes the US senate looks like a reality tv show to some europeans. many people don't like the hundreds of laws, sometimes useless ones, from the EU but I'm glad there are many people who care about something and know their stuff. exceptions are everywhere^^

Andy by now i think, that useless laws are created even by the most competent parliament. It seems inevitable. But hey, as long as the useful laws outnumber the useless ones...

LaFarrugia exceptions to every rule ;)

Well even though EU MPs were better prepared with better questions, the fact that they could only ask a question and not react to the answer made this whole hearing a waste of time. The format of the hearing makes US hearings much better

YES OR NO JUST SAY IT YES OR NO

"What's your name?" "Mark Zu-" "YES OR NO"

@@huguesjouffrai9618 not at all actually, thoes american hearings make things too personal and they aren't efficient

@@huguesjouffrai9618 not much better, much funnier xD I could not stop laughing after hearing those stupid questions xD

Lmaoooo😂

You just didnt.... 😂😂😂😂

lol

😂😂😂😂

You made my day bro!!

US government is a joke. They just can't keep up with technology.

Some of the US politicians did ask about shadow profiles. I did hear anything about the monopoly.

Ajay Tej well we do have better politicians

Europe is the best

@@klarnorbert On the contrary, the Article 13 fiasco could never happen in America because our Free Use laws can change over time. But those were made in 2001. In 2020, we still have a lot of the same congresspeople, and they don't understand how the Internet works now.

Jargalsaikhan Khurtsbayar that's because many of EU politicians are science people, not gun lobbyists and Texans

Patrick no then they would say man is man not man is women because of feelings

west hyppolite Great English mate!

That was also a joke. Questions to the wind. -- And leftwing is associated with destruction, not even science.

Patrick The left is equal all over the world. But they are specialized on lying. But they can be better exposed un Venezuela, Cuba ir North Korea (a puppet of China that play the "good" liberal capitalists to the world and crushes its citizens head).

"hOw dOe$ FaCeBoOk MaKe mOnEY? Senator, we run ads.

Alex Smith "dO YoU lOvE aMeRiCA? "

The difference is that Senators represent states and these guys represent entire countries.

Marcel Re that's because the members of the EU Parliament are not 100 year olds that have no idea how the internet works

Europeans are better educated in general, especially since the 60's and education standards dropping with school integration.

Lol.

😂😂😂😂

what can we do US is stupid like that

Szymon Harbuz There's no such thing as European lol

What the hell are you saying.

Szymon Harbuz you do know americian politicians are mostly European origins , mainly from Germany, England ,Italy,France etc . Most Americans are Europeans

Random guy most white Americans*

@@faith-ei9bv so we're Africans because that's where humans come from

you saw a heavily edited video from the goons at CNN trying to make Trump look bad

Josiuh what does Trump have to do with this?

Foreals

@@Josiuh dud, "orange man bad" had nothing to do with it.

In the US politicians are corrupt lobbyists who take money from these mega corps.

Jacco Stoete Well said. It's only together that we are strong enough to stand up to these multinational corporate machines.

Patrick even if they do business in eu ?

Patrick exactly it wud have costed him A LOT in the long run hence he was there cause uve gotta keep the investors happy

Patrick of course he had to show up to the EU Parliament: The EU has more Facebook users than the US. Being based in the US is not an excuse for not complying to EU regulations when you’re doing business there ( he was reminded in the meeting about that) The same goes the other way around: an EU company doing business in the US have to comply to US regulations (or what’s left of it) or face the consequences (look at VW)

To Release is To Resolve The EU is not a dictatorship

?

If you don't see it it don't exist!

Hum,Facebook is a company that wants to connect people,i believe in the power of ... 9999 words non-related to the question

@@meghanachauhan9380 Well can you see your brain? I guess it's does not defined as exist after all

I pretend not to hear 🙉

NA LuL

Ali youssef Well the congressional hearing did occur weeks prior, so the parliament had time to reflect on what the people thought about the congressional hearing and adapt.

ArnoldsK Also Senators represent individual states within our country and these guys represent entire countries so they’re going to be a bit smarter than your typical Senator.

countries that are smaller than an individual state. i think its way more about the 'Murica feels.

Corey Brandt states are like their own separate country under one goverment. And there's more than one person per EU country.

that is right, because if you want a filet mignon but you only have celery and lemons in the fridge, you're not getting your filet mignon

@@lucacanazza6263 what if I want human meat?

thats what you call brains hahahaha

@@lucacanazza6263 But it's HIS fridge and he should know it.

Politicians:” what do I want for dinner” *proceeds to open fridge* Mark is one step ahead of these politicians.

Sarcasynronic It’s because most people here (including me) only watched the compilation videos about US senators asking really stupid questions while in this EU hearing the investigators were way better prepared.

In the US I agree with Mark and in this one I agree with essentially everyone except the Verge

Asking informasi is you tranfer is many for asking you papulason wrong you now tranfer is many for asking you sorces you papulason wrong you now source is asking you papulason wrong polejay hoax Mark Zuckerberg is you women wrong polejay hoax corupsen palsu papulation mafia fakta asnking informasi is you adesten

Its probably because of lobbyiying

I know, interesting that. I don't actually have a Facebook account but I wonder if they do try collect information on non users? Having already said they still collect information on users who sign out. Interesting thought.

Yes they do, every Web site you go to has a Facebook sharing script, some of them contain tracking functionality for advertisers, abit like Google analytics.

@@320speed This is not a question, they do collect data from everyone who uses the internet (practically speaking). All the websites that have some form of Facebook link, collects marketing info, has a Facebook (or one of their third party related) extensions installed, will collect your data and sign it to your IP and the hardware you were using, and this data is stored in shadow profiles that talk with each other to create as fitting a match as possible on the people they monitor - and in most cases they will also get your name and residence information etc, could be from email subscriptions or web services that require you to create a user, etc. If you actively use the Facebook platform or not doesn't matter, the Facebook algorithms still survey you (and if they don't, then Google or some other company does, and in the end the information gets around to everyone). I constantly try to teach my family about this, but it's often hard for people to grasp that Facebook collects their data even when they don't have a Facebook profile. They don't understand that Facebook is not just a web platform, it's a marketing and analytics tool that has been imbedded in most websites that exist, and you practically can't avoid them. Sure you can deny cookies etc, but most sites denies you access if you decline their cookies so nobody does that - and in the end Facebook collects their data and stores it to the shadow profile linked to your IP and known hardware/devices such as mobile phone, computer, various third party user profiles on other apps and social media platforms etc.

Daniel Kemnitz well put

@@320speed What do you think how many people use WhatsApp who have your number saved in their Phone? If you use whatsapp you upload all numbers from your contact list to facebook servers. There they compare them and check if the other person too has WhatsApp. But even if not they now have this number. And know you are in contact with the other person. With this they easily manage to get a profile of most people you are in contact with. Because most of those people have whatsapp. Next they need your name. Easy, because most sites have a tracking pixel or a like/share button for facebook. And even if you dont give a facebook like, facebook knows you visited that website, because the button is from facebook and instantly establishes a connection to it. Now you just need to sign in on any website and chance is high they have your clear name and adress. Because ip adresses dont change every few minutes they can easily track you for longer times. And even if ip adresses change it is easy to link the new shadow profile to the old. You would be surprised how little information is necessary to determine wheter two profiles belong to the same person. And because facebook distributes targeted ads even outside of the facebook page as a service for other websites facebook makes profit with this. And chances are high they have from nearly everyone a profile or shadowprofile

You twist something there! *lol No soccer trainer in the EU parliament present!

Sue Sun it was a joke...

Hahahaha i swear right!!

Damn son! 😂

Aditya Aswal I was thinking exactly the same😅

To be fair, you didn't get much of a choice. If I were from the states, I would have voted Sanders... And accomplished nothing.

To be even more fair, the meeting only lasted 1h30, where the Senate testimony was about 6h

Jerry Peng Better Trump than Merkel

The senators dumbness aren't trumps fault.

@Nspnspker not only that...the coverage from the US congress was significantly edited by the goons at CNN to make them look stupid

Vlaams Belang won my dude. Belgium rocks.

Agreed.Proud of the EU questions. He was surprised he actually had to think here unlike the US.

@Főfasírozó You are not even a real person :P

He was talking nonsense. His analogy was stupid af.

@Főfasírozó lol, Belgium founded the EU

daycha turner not can‘t but won’t. A lot of it would be a PR disaster and have legal ramifications if answered truthfully.

I'm 2 years late, but.. The EU is a country by itself, it is a confederation

@@xano2921 it's a union

​@@xano2921 it is a union, if any countries think their benefits they got from being in the union is less than what they sacrificed, they will leave. But I get your point, it's the likely the closest countries ever were in an NGOs.

while on tv

Yay!

Ha

We’re not out of the woods yet. Just you wait....

its not their personal interests, some of these questions might sound stupid for superficial people, but you have to look at the bigger picture, right now social media is perhaps the most powerful communication tool, and in the facebooks case, it reaches so many people, every single day, so the way they influence and use information could change entire generations to come, of course it has to be regulated.

We all liked because of the “what is an Android”not the part you wanted us to know

man its not personal interest, can u imagine how can these companies manipulate people ? some people spend whole days on social media , few well chosen articles (and there is someone behind the posts that you see who chooses wheter you see it or not (wheter is a person or AI) )and they can absolutly twist peoples political views how they want.

@@borgresearcher bro of course thats personal they just dont want zuckerberg to become the almighty of social networks if i could say like Every person who is becoming too powerful because of the rockfeller's incident

Facebook is lying and fraud. I've talked to people about certain things in real life, like a hamburger or a tool, or a certain subject. NEXT THING I KNOW I GET A ADVERTISEMENT EXACTLY FOR IT. Anyone can access the internet. Facebook works with hackers and third parties.

That’s good old Farage. He’s a beast

yes he's a good Guy

He is a Belgian liberal.

Nice one Juan ;)

That's Guy Verhofstadt, member of the open VLD (Belgian Dutch-speaking liberal party, centre-right), three times Prime Minister of Belgium, current chairman of the ALDE (European liberal party, centre to centre-right), European Parliament's representative on matters related to Brexit. He's also one of the biggest supporter of a federal European Union.

Dakito Dasho he likes LGBTQ

“How does Facebook make money”

Raphael Bek They want to regulate Facebook to pursue their cucking plan.

The European parlaiment have enough questions to answer of their own like.......how do they justify their clique of unelected politicians that cannot be removed by the peoples voting power, making rules, regulations and laws that are imposed on other democracies. Can they answer the question of how we were all originally blatantly lied to in order to take the UK and other countries into the Common Market which was meant for trading between nations and then led into a European Union that has spent the last 40 + years stripping democratic nations of the right to govern themselves. No country has ever had a vote on this theivery and when they have the EU has made them vote again until they got the right answer. Answer these questions. The EU are control freaks and the only reason that they are giving Zuckerberg a hard time is they can't control, or regulate him as they have done to the rest of Europe. Glad the UK is out of the mess that is the EU..

@@racl1954 Ok Brexit guy. If you don't like the EU you can live (as shown by the Brexit), and I don't know what you mean by controlling democracies. It's like a club. If you want to be part of this club then you have to follow this rules: this, this and this. And when a country doesn't follow they control that infraction by convincing it that he will pay for this unruly behavior. We signed to be part of the EU. Countries are fighting just to be part of it. The things you've pointed out aren't actually that big of a deal in comparison with Germany "being able" not to follow this EU rules. But even that is understandable if you think of who has the money. I actually am pro EU and, honestly, I'm okay if people are against but I think that they're not what you've described. Pd:Anyway, pardon my lower English (I'm from Spain) and don't understand this comment as hate. I just wanted to engage in this debate but maintaining common respect while doing so. So yeah, sorry if I got to crazy hahah

@@santividal9387 Your english is more than fine, and you provided some great arguments. Love from a pro EU Swede

CharlieOliverBates "is getting"? He has been for a long time

Then people simply need to stop giving him this power.. no one is forced to used Facebook's services and people need to realize they are the product, not the other way around. It's only "free" product in exchange for access to all your data and information. They are a publicly traded company and as such will use any mean to exploit whatever information they have access to in order to generate revenue, increase market share, and dominate their sector people seem to forget that.

Well if we're honest people are stupid and won't stop using it no matter what.

Jonathan People are physically addicted. It’s not as easy for some people to stop using the service because Zuckerberg has them by the balls.

@@SecularDarwinism Thank you. Did it ever occur to anyone, that people LIKE being a "product". Social media helps us keep in contact with others but most importantly it helps feed our egos. Some people put up constant "snaps" about themselves, constant videos on "insta", or statuses on twitter, just because they love the attention. But I do feel bad for those people who don't have the ego problem. They should have more privacy.

it is clearly regulated, that is why he has to show up here and answer questions. It is only a matter of to what extent they are going to be regulated, supervised or even control more. This testimony is a big progress for regulators to keep up with the speed of the technology revolution. Even the people in the industry could not comprehensively understand how quick it is developing. That is why the regulators are so worrying about their policies.

Harsh Kumar that guy was damn genius. Better than US Senators

Guy Verhofstadt

Guy Verhofstad, president of ALDE, the liberal fraction in the EU Parliament. Also chief Brexit negotiator for the parliament.

Harsh Kumar hahahaha ... he is the guy who knows the best question by far among all them combine US congress

Jurgen Klopp

Her voice so smooth. Would be perfect for AI voice, with the voice like that she can take over the world and I won't mind.

Athan Condax well they could have shown the part where one of the politicians stated that zuckerberg chose those kind of proceedings, i.e. everyone asks his or her questions and then he tries to answer them. They were initially against it, it seems.

But don’t trust the source too much as they may only show the parts of the evidence that align with their political views. I do still think the Verge is a great source of news, but be aware they only show you what they want to show

Merrin Google isn't really better.

Gaunerchen still I trust them more then Facebook

I don't his demeanor was intentional. I'd say internally he felt nervous and under alot of pressure given the depths of this issue that no one really has much experience with handling. The previous monopolistic companies mentioned like microsoft had the skills and expertise to see a path toward a solution and execute. I don't think it will be easy to find a balance between protecting FB users from data mining and selling while allowing for users to continue enriching the site for the purposes of communicating and connecting people worldwide.

Merrin the real question is... how could he break the three laws of robotics?

zucks a legend

The real monster is Zuckerberg.

Humans* Humans are the monster

Facebook and Twitter are responsible for all the destructive movements and terrorist in this world.

@@grip2617 it's not their trouble. People Should have control over themselves.

😂

@ nah

branchyapple looked like a cat who just saw a mouse run by hahaha

😭😂😂😂

bruh like a robot

He scanned them

@branchyapple He was looking for help. simple psychology, a lot of us do it when we're put on the spot or taken aback - and unsure of how to respond. It seems he may have had one or two allies within the room also, you can see him look to them in the hopes of an out. The reaction itself is funny though!! xD

I swear that guy is an extraterrestrial

I know right... Jesus.

He already make Facebook..

@@prachirajniwal7752 whoosh/

@@prachirajniwal7752 not funny we are talking about this guy Mark Zuckerberg here

yeah US congress as a trial feeling while the EU just sits in a circle to have that conversation feeling.

I laughed so much 😂

Damn.... Skynet be doing today

ROFLL God, dude ahahahahahaha

He probably flies private too lol

Because he does.

Good move.

Same here

Jokes on you. Facebook collects info from non Facebook users as well.

F. Teixeira Every company collects your data and nothing is ever deleted from the internet, internet is free for a reason.It's not Facebook all of them do the same, but only facebook is getting a stick for it lol.

Aditya Aswal The internet is not free lol, unless you're leeching off open wifi then yeah it's free internet, but someone is always paying.

Nice commentary and clips :). Hopefully there WILL be alternatives. It's just they will NOT be funded by Silicon Valley, Bay Area, OR California. (I should know ;) ) - Worldie will be one, I hope (still working).

mesenger veediyo call face buk server store pleas answer

Kamaru Kannur, What do you mean?

mesenger calls data kalakted pleas answer

but only SOMETIMES (Article 13/17)

You papulason wrong polejay hoax palsu fakta

Definitely reptilian.

YES

L A M P

Well, Brexit didn't officialy happend

Lennart mustermann you do know that the uk is still a part of the eu as of now, right?

Dry German humor :D love it

Lennart mustermann I'm confused at how you managed to elect Merkel again.

My country has not yet left the eu we will very soon but Theresa May is a bit slow.

Byte Review as with most meetings if you don't get to the point

"okay then keep your secret"

This guy is really evolving to something else,the last time he was in Kenya and now this are completely different people

That's because US congress knows that Facebook is very advanced and usefull tool for mass surveillence and after that cirkus behind closed doors they pat him on the back.

The US is not parliamentarian it's congressional btw :P

clever lol

Funny because Syed Salah Kamall who's having great questions is a muslim

Yes we suck here in the US because for some reason we’re afraid of being smart or “european”

Hey hey were talking about the worlds super power.... please calm down

Are you European?

@@zytolen5356 Does it matter? no

Americans call the EUrolalas stupid every day in some circles. By and large a worthless continent.

ArnoldsK The format was insisted on by Zuckerberg. It makes it easier to ignore questions.

No they don't... Just imagine having those Legislators apart of the US Congressional meeting, not only was the US Congress a MUCH higher priority, its the US for petes sake who is still above all of the European Union, but they wouldn't have let Zuckerberg decide the format, they would have been like you know who we are? You have to come...

Shut up you have a Islam taking over your country

Erik Torres - What does it feel like to be mentally handicapped?

"Does anyone here know him personally" Uhh yeah no, not likely

Helmet one could think he knows him, but his AI is constantly evolving

I know him he’s actually my toaster

Just google it 😂😂very nervous robot or clone scared of the question are you a clone or robot ?😂😂

It seems you haven't been around programmers much, I know a few that are working on autonomous vehicle algorithms, they kind of behave in a similar fashion, their minds are always thinking on something

Lmao dude now i cant unsee it

He developed Facebook from scratch and turned it into one of the biggest corporate empire in just less than 2 decades. Pretty sure he knows what he is doing when it comes to running a company.

@@PurushNahiMahaPurush He did not develop it from scratch though lol

@@mastaw He did, he programmed it.

Lol😂😂😂😂

its called having no soul.

He has ASPD