That movie sucked

Doesn't she use a trombone with a trigger meaning she can hit that note without the arm length

The good ol’ “if you don’t see it, it ain’t broke” 😂

I play trombone i dint see it

Cutting away like it’s not an animated movie lmao

That's why trigger trombones exist

Not the dreaded 7th position 😭

Her bone wasn't a trombone

3D animators (especially for films in this style) are known to stretch a character's limbs as a camera trick. I doubt this was the actual reason.

Intentional for a reason... Those mean the same thing???

And that’s why we have trigger trombones it helps alot for fast paced songs

I wish there were a clean version to use as an educational resource

She probably could if she put her shoulder into it but it would look weird

*bones crack as arm extends*

Hello, I was wondering if you could give me any tips on starting a music RU-vid channel?

They could have had her grab it by the Lower part lmao

Technically if it has an F trigger, you can play B natural with trigger + 2nd position, but i think the trombone in the clip is a single trombone

So you mean to tell me she's playing a-minor because if she isn't this note would be in first slide position

Why did they pan away though they didn’t need to they could have animated them using the trigger which makes it possible to play B natural in second position

I had the same problem and kept dropping my slide so I switched to a lever trigger on my trombone, but I still sucked at it.

7

Ah yes. "Intentional for a reason"

Berlin did not approve

Just fix it with a trigger trombone. No need to go out to that position and makes for quicker playing.

I feel like thats a design flaw for the Trombone.

We got to meet the performer who recorded the trombone part and he told a story of how they had 4-5 cameras on him so that the animators could make this as accurate as possible. Of course, the animators probably didn’t realize that note would be impossible for younger students, but I love the detail that went into animating this.

Finally I can sleep! The mystery has been solved! *Throws away corkboard and red twine*

Why didn't they just, like, have her play a different song?

please, can we just cut this BS out. Really sad

False, for the C you can pull in to first position and use the trigger. I don’t even play trombone I play euphonium

Intentional MEANS For a Reason so that was redundant

I play trombone and my 7th position is sad my arms are not long enough

Tr-um-bone not tr-om-bone

I remember my arms not being long enough back in middle school to fully extend the slide, so I’d flick it out from my fingertips to the top of my foot with my leg extended out in front of me, and then tap the end of the slide back up to catch it back with my fingers 😂 that’s what happens when you were 5’1”-5’2” back in middle school

It’s too much to animate model an f attachment horn.

G

im sad u didn't mention fred wesley ;-;

To hide her octopus arms

Yep that's exactly the reason. Nothing else because we care about musical accuracy in a fucking cartoon

I literally just finished it! It was amazing

Back in sixth grade, I failed band class because they gave me a trombone and my arms were too short to play all of the notes.

you're right I didn't catch it

I noticed

What do you mean? She has an invisible F trigger!

A valveless bass trombone would be insane

Why didn't they made a smaller trombone?

But it would’ve been smart if that was a case of not reaching the position, they could’ve had her on a trombone with an F attachment but it be too much for basic music knowledge of her age range so it’s understandable

Isn’t it interesting that lowkey even tho trombone is in bass clef oddly enough that half note was a “G” on treble clef😅 don’t mind me it’s the bandhead (band geek) in me and yes I know that’s a B in (B)ass clef #stitchbait

Time. That's what you need to get good at anything... especially music. You are essentially an athlete that needs to forever train in order to be on top of the game. It really does get exhausting.

Interesting information. The trombone piece is played by Andy Martin. He is a pretty badass musician that also came up with the intro music for Monsters Inc!