The sound is too harsh and bold,starting at 1:27 at Trumpets melody,Trumpets were too sharp and not in tune even though they should sounded flat in the cold hall.This song's melody should sound beautiful and calming but it sounded harsh.The clarinet's longtone at 2:48 were flat and not in tune and before the longtone the toungeing of few instrument was too harsh.At 4:01 the horn's counter melody were too slow and can not be heard,that part was supposed to support the melody and to add some colour to the sound,but it sounded plain with only the melody taking control of everything,every part matters.Horn cannot be heard,only suspended cymbal that has the same part as horn can be heard.Not balanced.The trumpet's last note at 4:29-4:30 swelled and it sounded bad.At 5:03,when the horns came in the tuba's are still overshadowing they horns even though theyre playing longtone.Maybe even though the tuba's dynamic shouldnt change when the horns came in but the tuba's should be under the horns.Afterall,theyre basses.Horns is the tenor.
kim yeol thanks for the comment but I have to disagree with the hall condition. The hall was not designed specifically with good acoustic feature and it was very warm and dry. We agree that our horns were a bit slow and that’s what I kept pushing them really hard and yes they at least meet my expectation. For the trumpet, we try to adjust them to play differently because this hall was not acoustically the same as our school hall. So with very limited time on stage during soundcheck, We tried everything we can to readjust the balancing as we’re not used to the stage and environment. It’s hard to live up to everyone’s expectation and believe me my kids have done the best referring the original recording and yes we managed to play with at least 85% similarities and minimal mistakes. But, there’s always room for improvement. Thanks for the critique and we will work harder to achieve our ultimate dream; pouring our souls out to live in people’s heart.
penat la tengok video ni banyak kali, bulu2 badan tegak tinggal nk tercabut ja dri kulit... terjerit2 aku dibuatnya tengok video nih.... bestnya kalau dpt tengok live
Not gonna lie but you guys are truly amazing! Such young age to perform this masterpiece?! You guys have great potential in the future. Much love from University Malaya Symphony Orchestra 💓
They not just playing music notes but performing the art of music. Master piece performance by high schoolers. Thumbs up for all juniors. Goosebumps 😱😱
Sebagai Oldboy STAR, aku rasa korang patutnya menang WOC tahun ni. Or at least get best precussion and best woodwinds. Tapi xpe. Biar diorang takut, asalkan kita sampaikan mesej kita
Wm Hussaini but I was told that SAS was the one who the judges actually want to give the best conductor to but the judges said that they were afraid that u guys will call them biases. Anyway, congrats!
