As someone who dissects songs and music, this hurts.

Personally, I find some of the cadence fuckery fun (like in "coLORS"), BUT! When it's everywhere, it doesn't feel intentional, and it gets jarring. And in Wish, it's practically everywhere ://

Actually, I realize how teenager-y these lyrics are. Doesn't make it good but it does make a bit of sense

"im a star! Watch out world HERE I ARE" LIKE HELP

People really take this shit too seriously

what the HECK happened? What was Disney employees smoking? Just a few years ago, this studio made Encanto, a movie that was great and had infinitely more thought put into than Wish, a CELEBRATORY movie! So clearly it’s not that Disney is incapable of songwriting. Take any song from Encanto and it will have better lyrics, story, music, better everything than all of these shitty songs combined…

i died so many times listening to this song. i think if rather listen to baby by justin bieber

"Music theory is just a social construct."

I call the main melody "literally the Elf main melody but after the first four notes it changes" lol

10:49 idk why but with a little google search for synonyms for big i got, “The lengths he go, it’s far from stout”😂😂😂

I watched this Movie on a Airport waiting my Flight and while the Film was so lacking on its Mispotential, this Song is Worse than I’m a Star, this is when the Film Falls Apart with Asha villainizing Magnifico that she’s the main reason why they are in this Mess in the First Place, this turned Asha the Protagonist to a Manipulative Antagonist without knowing if those Wishes are Safe as some could have been Evil Thoughts.

"Here I are" coulda worked if it were made into a gag- in fact, I woulda kinda loved it. But alas, the song is kinda dumb

And yet Matthew still looks like an emo pirate

I know this Movie is Bad, but the Music literally drains the Disney Magic and I agree with Magnifico being the Fallen Hero that got Corrupted by Asha who ate the Forbidden Fruit, she doesn’t even know if the Wishes are Good, if anything some of the could be Straight Up Evil, this is a Mockery to Disney and all of the Years of making good Music, it got me Bored and Cringing Everytime I here then that I wish they would still with the Original Idea than this, At All Costs is my Favorite Song in the Movie that this should have been a Romantic Disney Movie.

I wonder if someone involved here watched Reefer Madness...because that's where I've heard that sharp 'ho!ha!' bit with the drums before...it's a hilariously not kid-friendly moment

Kinda reminds me of the Same Coin Theory from a couple years back, i love it!

So what your saying is that we should stop supporting Disney... knowing what you know now?

This is an example of how and why good poetry and music takes a TON of time and thought (and even plenty of mistakes in rough drafts) to be made into a successful final. I write poetry and I read some poetry and I know what good music is supposed to sound like.

Saying AI made these songs is actually an insult towards AI. 😂

The fact that you can't even sing or hum along on the first or even second listen is insane

Anyone else actually loved it.....?

Yet, he still couldn't break up with Knives at first in the show. I always found that as odd

How the Grinch stole Christmas 5:11

I think savaging Wish has become its own RU-vid genre.

"Krabby Patty Crap Show" is going in my vocabulary 😂

4:52 Ironically this in Castillian Spanish was adapted as: "And if you were harmed, I don't know if I could stand it, you can't even imagine how I would fight, I would give my all". Obviously in spanish. I'm finding that the dubbing in general did the lyrics a big favour, although it doesn't fix all the mistakes. There are more examples besides this one.

"The good in him I've watched it melt" - this was the most insulting to me of all so far. It's a transformative property. You put cheese on toast, you put the toast in the grill, you take the toast out, gee golly, its still CHEESE!

“I’m a Star” sucked badly, especially with the lyrics and the infamous line “Watch out world, here I *are*”. It still gives me pain.

I don't feel like that the soundtrack for wish is bad but like she said that I will repeat I am no music expert

Asha: It’s not right for one man to decide which wishes should and should not be granted!…but it’s right when I do it.

i know nothing of music but...isnt The thing you call cadence "Tempo?" Again Idk, I just always associated that with tempo

I will say, it’s a shame this movie was bad. Asha has a pretty design, and her voice actress was actually really good! I just wish she had better material

I have figured out a way to enjoy this song’s melody and instrumental without standing the criminal lyrics… Listen to it in Japanese!! (Or any other language you don’t understand)

Okay, I'm going to go actually hear the songs just to see how bad they really are.

You don't even have to go lyric by lyric. Its so bad you can notice everything wrong with it just by listening to it normally.

one of the biggest issues is that they didn't get musical theater writers for this. they got pop writers, and while they are talented, disney music is not their scene. they were trying to imitate writers like lin manuel miranda and shit, and it DID NOT go well.

Here I am even if I do hear this song exclusively in Castillian Spanish xD I love it.

I am seriously thinking that ai played a large part in this movie

I found the ONE SINGLE peice of media that uses the term "question marks like that" gimmie my money ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE--iwMFRPOkt8.html&pp=ygUqbGVhZ3VlIG9mIGluY3JlZGlibGUgdmVnZXRhYmxlcyB0aGVtZSBzb25n

I found the ONE SINGLE peice of media that uses the term "question marks like that" gimmie my money ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE--iwMFRPOkt8.html&pp=ygUqbGVhZ3VlIG9mIGluY3JlZGlibGUgdmVnZXRhYmxlcyB0aGVtZSBzb25n

Also tbh go off queen, you did sound angry but it’s not like you’re railing against an indie dev or something. This is the 100th anniversary of a multi billion dollar company famous for making these kinds of movies and they rushed and crunched it so hard that beginner’s mistakes are in every song. You’re not unfair, given the context. I personally think the ppl saying you’re overly critical just aren’t thinking about the standards we should absolutely hold Disney to. You’re not punching down

"Disney needs someone other than Lin-Manuel Miranda writing their songs!" and then a finger on the monkey's paw curled inward

At the very least, the songs at least sound better in the context of the original movie plot.

Wish juat becoming the same but worse failure than the SW sequils. Same nastagia baiting with no depth.