oh, my memorable moments are coming up in my brain....I was there acturally. I rememer that even now that Teayon broke a part like some settings in a song, and that was so cute...
Gilaa ini vocal mereka keren banget, nyanyi live dan stabil banget. Padahal ini peristiwa sejarah bagi sone. Tapi mereka bisa nyanyi mulus gitu pdhal lagi nahan nyesek paska berita Jess keluar.
38:10 This is supposed to be the climax of the song, the most energetic part, of one of SNSD's happiest and most rhythmic songs, but without Jessica, it feels plain :(
It was one decade since Jessica was no longer part of the group & I know that they're living both their lives as a individual & group member but TBH, I really wanted to know the REAL reason of Jessica's departure in the group because if it was still unanswered of why they performing as 8 since 9/30, the SONEs will be divided/separated as fuck...
So sad sones had raised a misinformative and smeary campaign against an important member of their favorite group with ZERO EVIDENCE against her. NEVER PROVED ANYTHING.
I didn't follow this drama as much as most, but I think a lot of the comments are missing a bigger-picture trauma playing out onstage. These 8 are in shock. People react differently to shock. I tend to zone out and just get on with the job until I can process it in my own time. You can see various members doing just that -- trying really hard to be professional. Others have the emotions come out at unexpected moments. But I think -- and you can see it near the end most of all -- there is fear behind the shock. In all of them. That fear is that this is the beginning of the end of the group. They had a great run for 7 years, and people more powerful than them just demonstrated they can dismiss a member real quick.
No they decided as a group that Jessica had to leave, the label supported Jessica staying but they conceded the members had to self determine. They voted five to three for her to leave, you can see the split between Yoona and Theydon at the end.
This video kinda makes it very obvious who Choo Mina is. She looked very very happy to sing Jessica’s lines, and she didn’t forget to sing a single one. Everyone else slipped up a couple times.
@@marcelofrias1631you’re not wrong. She was GRINNING during Mr Taxi. In the book Jessica did say it was two members but mostly “Mina”. The only one here who’s extremely wealthy is sooyoung though so we know she’s Mina. But yes Taeyeon was definitely happy for Jessica to get kicked
55:00 The fans (esp that girl) who kept shouting Jessica are so disrespectful. It just adds to the awkwardness. Thankfully some sones decided to shout SNSD to cover them up!
You know exactly what they're thinking back then Taeyeon: "Jessica's fans are no fans of mine" Sooyoung: " Losing Jessica's fans are acceptable losses" Yoona: "Drama is so much less stressful" Tiffany: "My new lines! My precious lines!" Yuri: "They said to trust the plan" Sunny: "They said everything will be good. This isn't good" Hyoyeon: "Pudding"
There literally no defending in this. And to people who said it’s SM fault, they supported Jessica’s business and even advertised it in their movie in the same year. People who say SNSD themselves doesn’t have power clearly don’t know they said previously multiple times they come up with decisions according to votes among themselves. Dispatch also released an article before it got released immediately stating the members themselves came to Sm saying they won’t share a stage with Jessica if she was there in the fan meeting. Moreover it said some members parents also got involved with it an demanded jessica to be removed. And mind you this was all because she started a business. People saying “Well why was she selfish to choose to do that” or “She missed group schedules” etc, the members started going into solo careers alr, many had released eps or started acting, so why couldn’t jessica do it too? And not to mention Jessica’s attendance as a member was one of the highest so clearly she could balance all of it. All members resigned the contract and jungsis season 2 was going to be recorded as well as their duet album, which was confirmed by the director on Instagram. Yes, I don’t think Jessica was right in everything because in an argument it’s impossible to be all right and she has her flaws too, but she definitely was not in the wrong and was kicked out the group by her members due to jealousy. Sm themselves would’ve rebuked her statement or even sued her for lying, but nothing happened because they knew she was right. All they could do was blacklist her. There’s so much evidence online which all match and are consistent people defending their actions should stop being delusions. Definitely some were against it, but at the end of the day, what’s done is done. I don’t want to point fingers and be certain, but clearly Yoona, Seohyun and maybe Sunny were very uncomfortable in this video. Yoona seemed to be angry at one point with Tiffany and Seohyun ignored many of them and even cried. I don’t want to point out others but some definitely seemed suspiciously guilty, it’s so obvious when people feel this way. Jessica spent as long or even longer and worked as hard as them to be in that group. It’s not really justified to ruin someone’s job, especially after you’ve worked AND known them for years, even if you’re not friends with them or have conflict. Yes they probably have a good side to them but this was something wrong for them to do, and they just can’t admit it. What’s worse is the fact they tried to erase jessica out of everything, even till today.
What are you talking about? Power? If they really had so much power, all of them would've renewed contract with SM after holiday night. At the end, they have SO MUCH POWER that they can arrange contracts that have just benefits for them, right? How do you explain the recent treatment Taeyeon is receiving from the agency? Oh, if she had that soooo much power you claim, she would've arranged things for herself. SM supported Jessica's business, until they saw she could make a lot of money out of it and the agency wouldn't be getting any of it. People like you forget that Jessica's boyfriend plays a huge role in this, he was a bad influence for her (the incident with his cousin at China) and still is. There's also a good amount of proof that he just gives Jessica bad advice. What makes you think he didn't intervene in her decisions at that time? And that part about the Dispatch article you say, may be caused by that. I may be angry with a person and I can say "I'm not going if they're going" and that doesn't mean I'm bullying them, that just means there's conflict and that's completely normal because we're humans and we argue. All 9 of them suffered because of what happened and of course, Jessica was the most affected one but everything you say are mere speculations and it's just what you may understand for what you see from above. None of us will know the real truth about this and it's very risky to spread accusations amongst SNSD when there's literally nothing that makes them "the bad ones", and Jessica isn't guilty too.
Time has shown how stupid Girls' Generation's decision was. They considered Jessica a threat to them and kicked her out. Without them, sica remains strong and successful. The members have not achieved much for many years, and the 8-year-old continues to be embarrassed
The disrespect from their own fans 😢 how awful they clearly where sad and their energy wasn’t there but they try their best and the fans pay them like that
So I've been back to binge watches some of SNSD's live performances from debut days until early 2014. There have been so many stages when they were incomplete. OT6, OT7, OT8 were the most formation. And mostly it was came from Actress/Maknae lines absent due to their filming schedule. And yet still.. some members during the introduction section (usually Tiffany), used to informed the audiences why some members wasn't on stage. ~But certainly not for this one! Clearly some deep things happened and it was all messed-up decision made in the VERY last minute. 😔
