Very interesting hearing all these perspectives. I find myself agreeing with all of them to some degree, but probably the most with MK Leo. The way we see the game and who we play/main may influence this. I agree with Marss bumping some of the characters like Pichu and Bowser up, but the Zero Suit downplaying was slightly nauseating, lmao. Falcon should go up a bit. I'm convinced people who separate Marth from Lucina more than a single tier letter from each other are inbred. I personally wouldn't have a tier lower than D, but it made things a little funny.
Bowser Jr in C+ Tier is perfect. I’ve always thought he had potential. Not as a top tier but he isn’t THAT bad either. Now heres one problem… WHY IS FALCON SUDDENLY THE 13TH WORST CHARACTER IN THE GAME?!
I'm of the opinion that there shouldn't really be an E tier for Ultimate. Most of the characters in C tier honestly belong in B tier, and everyone in D tier feels like they can be squeezed into either B tier or C tier. I don't agree with Lucina being S tier, and PT should really be there instead. Palu being in S tier is fine, but really only because she's about as good as the best A tier characters imo. Bayo could be a little bit higher in A high tier, ICs is finally being placed higher, MK and puff are still underrated, Falcon and Pichu belong a tier or two up from where they currently are, and Mewtwo, Robin, Duck Hunt and Marth will always be underrated. T Belmonts are a fair amount lower than they should be, Ness, Incineroar, Byleth, and Bowser should probably be a little higher, and both Kirby, Zelda and Isabelle could be a bit higher as well. Overall, a decent tier list. There's just some wacky placements here and there, and the difference in strength among most of the characters in tiers B to D is small enough for there to not really be a need for a 6th tier.
"Sonix is the only one to put fox and Joker in top 5... I'll have what he's having what the hell this dude's just basing his top 5 on characters that do well against Sonic" - Marss
