As a twelver, we do not claim Rafed, i think this video is Psyop to create diversion among twelvers and Nizaris I would further add that rafed himself isnt a twelver or even a muslim given his condescending tone and insulting attitude i would assume he is just a paid actor here to insult both nizaris and twelvers
No fast , no salat/islamic prayer, no Qur'an no hadees, no sunnah, no hajj....i don't know what type of muslims they are??. Can anyone tell me What was the life of our beloved Caliph hazrat Ali RA...is it??
the idea that the pen/light of muhammed have to be eternal is not a logical conclusion. It makes perfect sense that Allah could exist eternally then at a specific point create the first intellect through which he then created all things. Proposing that the first intellect is eternal is literally polytheism in an of itself.
Get your ducks in row you don’t have that much time for BS. you are on Allah’s time o’clock, what Allah SWT in holy Quran and Hadith of prophet Mohammed SAW, says clear and simple no mumbo-jumbo….
Yasir Qadhi, please be quiet! I've been a Hanbali for all but 2 weeks of the 18 years I've been a Muslim. This is _not_ an accurate representation of Hanbali theology regarding the Divine attributes and nor is Taqi ud-Din ibn Taymiyyah _representative_. Yasir Qadhi spent most of his adult life learning some type of "Hanbalism" in Salafi sect. That's like learning the Hanafi school from the Ahmadiyyah. He now claims to be a Sunni again and yet has clearly retained a residual Salafism in his thinking. He never studied with actual Hanbalis in Egypt, Sham or Iraq where they are centred. He made right royal screw up of the whole thing!
Jake doesn’t have the intellect to conversate with Khalil and it’s clear to see. He dodged every question and acted like a fool the whole way through, what a disgraceful person.
You keep saying there are creations of God, but there is no such thing in a divine simplicity model. If God has real attributes, He cannot have ownership of creation because ownership is also an attribute; therefore the advocate of divine simplicity would have to argue that God does not possess creation and that the Imams and Prophets are not creations of God, because if they are His creation that would imply ownership, and according to you God has no real attributes, including the attribute of ownership of posession. Saying God has no real creation and that we are not creations of His is kufr, and thus refutes divine simplciity.
Many butthurted loosers blind followers of 4th century cult of trinitarian pagan polytheism made up by gentile romans nothing to do with jesus and his deciples who were unitarians monothiests and also saul of tarsus paul the false prophet the self proclaimed self appointed apostle was not trinitarian unlike late church are anti jake because he left this pagan church for Islam
You have your theology, but I have my testimony. I almost die in emergency room then Jesus revealed himself as a Shepherd, through psalm 23. I fainted after that and woke up the next day I had been moved to a room. The doctor said I was going through a critical period but I had to have surgery. In the afternoon a woman came and prayed for me in Jesus' name. And he said you don't need surgery but invite Jesus as your Lord and a Savior. I feel light after being prayed for. Since that day I convert to Christian tho I was a moslem. Why ? Because Jesus is real, He is God, He was really crucified but from a very different meaning that you are trying to share. May you encounter Jesus in personal. May God bless you with the redemption.
I know this is a 7 month old video but I would like an answer for this. If there are no real attributes, what about actions of God. If you say God Created the first intermediary, that is a divine action of His. If that action is indentical to His being (cuz no distinction between attributes and essence of God) then the act of creating the Pen would in essence be Allah, naudhubillah. That is absurd, how can Allah be identical to His act of creating something. His act of creating the Pen would be indentical to Himself, so by that logic you cannot suggest the creation of the Pen is in any way dissimilar to Allah, which is kufr because now a created thing starting to exist is neccessary to the essence of Allah. There is no other way to define creation except as a created thing starting to exist, so the Pen starting to exist is naudhubillah the same as Allah, if divine simplicity is true. The only way you get around this is by claiming one of two things. Eithet you say that Allah did not create the Pen (or anything, because if you suggest Allah has created anything, you run into that problem) This would contradict your belief that Allah created the pen/first intermediary. Or you can say that creating the pen cannot be called an action, which also contradicts your cherished law of excluded middle because a thing is either created by God or it is not created by God, a middle ground between those is contradictory and impossible.
Your presentation is full of contradictions. One of the biggest ones is that if God is absolutely dissimilar to His creation, surely you will agree that the excluded middle, which is a law of logic that applies to created things, cannot apply to God, otherwise both creation and the Creator would be bound by the same logical categories. If you take this to be true you cannot say that the doctrine that the attributes of God are neither identical to Him nor seperate from Him contradicts the law of excluded middle, because that law applies to creation, and the Creator is not like the Creation. Furthemore if there are no real attributes, what about actions of God. If you say God Created the first intermediary, that is a divine action of His. If that action is indentical to His being (cuz no distinction between attributes and essence of God) then the act of creating the Pen would in essence be Allah, naudhubillah. That is absurd, how can Allah be identical to His act of creating something.
As an outsider exploring these ideas, I love Dr. Andani's explanations and breakdowns. With that being said, the music in the new videos are 👌. It adds some dramatic flair to what he's saying and is waaayyy better than the annoying ringing in his older videos. Thank you Dr.
يا مولانا شاه كريم الحسيني نتوسل إليك ان تشملنا برحمتك وترزقنا شفاعتك وان تجعلنا من المحن خارجين وفي حصون السلامة داخلين وان تمطر علينا بركاتك يا أرحم الراحمين. ياعلي مدد 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
God was created twice? God was not created, he's the creator. This is contradictory to Quran, Kalam cosmological and Ibn Sinas arguments for the existence of God, there is no Muslim sect that agrees to this. You have taken some people's words out of context. For example if Allah has multiple characters that doesn't mean he's made of parts, it just means that he shows those charcters from one character which is absolute wisdom or knowledge e.g sometimes you show mercy by killing an animal to ease its suffering or get angry at someone to save them from something. The same thing goes for his face or hands etc. Also if God literally has a face, but is so so different from our face, then it might as well be a metaphor, to elaborate on this let's say that we go to an alien planet and the transport machines their are so different that we can't recognise them, so the aliens tell us they are cars, in this case the car is really a metaphor because they are not the cars we use, but are transport machines, hence they are both a metaphor and literal, and since it is both then it must be literal and not a metaphor, as literal is real whereas a metaphor is not.
Here rafed was 100% right cuz neither ismailis believe in onenees of God not nor they belive in any of the usools of din .... They also refer to imam jaffer as kazzab ( a liar )... So rafed is still true in his stance 😂😂😂😂😂😂
The Quran Contradicts Itself Quran Sura 2:29 & Quran 41:9-11 says the earth was created first, then heaven. Quran 79:27-30 says heaven was created first, then allah went to finish earth. It cannot decide if earth was created first or heaven. To make matters worse, the consensus of Muslims is that the earth that was created first, which is materialism. It is like saying a virtual reality is created first. Proof it is untrue? The Bible says Jesus Christ is the ONLY way to get to Heaven and avoid Hell. (John 14:6)
