So how did you take the lore breaking Mundi moment he’s not even supposed to be alive yet and in phantom menace he even states the sith haven’t been seen for a Millenia
He wasn't on Khofar and didn't see the "Sith" - if that is what he is at all. Red lightsaber does not equal Sith remember. Ki-Adi-Mundi was not born at this point in the EU/Legends timeline - we are no longer in that timeline, so nothing in canon has been broken yet.
@@cubcos how can you say that with a strait face his name is in the credits so it’s the Mundi from phantom menace he’s not supposed to be even alive and your timeline argument is utterly ridiculous whose timeline?so now it’s not a long time ago in a galaxy far far away it’s now a new time long ago in a galaxy far far away stop making poor excuses for poor writing this is what happens when you hire people who have no idea about what they are working on headland even said it herself we hired writers who have never seen or read Star Wars
Cool, point out to me where in the prequel trilogy movies it says Kid-Adi-Mundi's birth date? Because it isn't in there, it was in ancillary material that eventually became non-canon after 2014.
another good episode. Should we have spent more time on the Khofar, hell yes we should have. I also think the "Sith" person is Mother Koril. she had some crazy yellow sith eyes in ep3 and you can kinda see yellow eyes under the helmet.
You do realise that a new canon was established in 2014, right? Most previous works became "legends" and "not canon". It's only been a thing for the last...ten years...
@@cubcos Correction my nubewan - the thread is strong in you, but misguided. Legends prior to 2014 >>>EXCEPT<<< the ORIGINAL SIX Star Wars films produced by George Lucas!
I love this episode and The witch coven I need to know more. They may have conceived mae and OSHA differently than aniken was. But I have a theory if it is the same it only enhances his story. OSHA is light and mae is dark aniken is conflicted between the light and dark. The force is creating balance since aniken was the only one made at that time is why he's conflicted and mae and OSHA have light and dark paths.
I think Mae and Osha were made by the witches using the Force, whereas Anakin was made by the Force itself. I think there is a clear difference and people are going a little too crazy. Excited to see how it plays out.
@@cubcos I totally agree with you people are being a bit dramatic. But I have to say I find it refreshing that you are be positive and not complaining about everything. New subscriber here
"The Crapolyte" didn't break Star Wars. It was broken as soon as DEIsney took over the IP. DEIsney Woke Wars is not considered cannon by any real Star Wars fan. The only Woke Wars fans at the moment are tourists and Hetrophobes!
You can't even bring your own talking points, you just regurgitate whatever you heard from somewhere else. Also it is spelled canon. Cannon is a large boom-tube thing.
@@cubcos I'd be willing to bet you live in Melbourn. The "Woke" capital of Australia! Just for you I used Woke again. And seeing how my other comment has been removed I'm guessing my words hurt your delicate feelings!
Nah I just remove comments because I can. I'm not obligated to leave them up. Sorry, bud. Also Google is free, there is no excuse for this many spelling errors in this day and age.
Lol, of course a smooth brain like you would gobble up this garbage writing. Massive contradictions with actual lore already written. Are you saying that the original trilogy isn't cannon? What about the prequels? Plot holes after plot holes. Worse than, "he came back some how."
The redefining of the force by Disney is nothing but a narcissistic power trip. Its obvious the person who wrote this "story" hasn't even watched episode one or the clone wars or read anything at all about the Jedi or know their objectives at all. Nothing about this "Star wars story" makes and sense at all. By the way, witches in SW dknt use the force. If you would have seen the clone wars you would know that. Also, Yoda already explained the force, so did Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan. It definitely isn't a thread that can be manipulated "at will". 😂😂
Learn to spell, mate. Cannon? A big boom-tube? You mean canon. Also the so-called contradictions (I assume you mean the birth of someone through the Force, because your comment is horribly structured) isn't a contradiction of current canon. No one is saying that Mae and Osha are now the Chosen Ones. They may get mistaken for them if the Jedi believe in the prophecy but you've got to remember that not all Jedi even believed in it. Even when provided with someone "born without a father" a lot of the Jedi didn't buy into it. The "Thread" that they talk about using could be the Force, it could be just Magick - which I say in the video but I guess you couldn't comprehend that. Anyway, thanks for clicking into a video about the third episode of a show you are hate watching - glad to see support for the show.
Did you not hear/see the explosion of the reactor thing? Mae obviously went and did a bit more damage OR we haven't seen everything that went down that night. More flashbacks are coming from a different point of view.
that's clearly not the entire story, we don't see what actually happened to the temple or the witches who weren't burnt, but dead. someone obviously killed them. star wars fans as well as getting angered and incredibly triggered by this lacklustre episode also seemed to loose basic thinking skills
At last a balanced reviewer. I’m loving it to be honest, and genuinely can’t see what all the fuss is about. Let’s just enjoy the fact that there is new content
Well which is it? Are you watching it and you know its shite or are you just saying it is without watching it? Either way, kind of weird to click into a video about a show you don't watch. You seem to want to know all about it. Funny that
@cubcos I appreciate what you're doing. It's a good thing having a crack at a youtube page etc, but let's be fair and honest.. this show is nothing but agenda laden crap. The viewership is dropping, the agenda is see through, the audience score is dropping, people don't want agenda driven, poorly written, excuses for tv shows any longer. This thing will join the trash with every other woke, anti male attempt at pushing a narrative, show that we've all had to suffer for the last 10 years. Disney star wars is dead.
My Reaction I Love This Episodes Now I Do Understand This Show Not For Everyone But It Not That Bad Of A Show But Over All And Happy You Kyle Star Wars Explained Star Wars Wave Squadron Gave Some Understand Of Pro And Cons
How to tell me you don't know the difference between a hull breach and atmosphere escaping, thus feeding a fire during an explosion and when there is a fire in space and you can CLEARLY see the fire no where near where the gas is escaping ... without telling me you don't know the difference.
It could be possible if it’s off gassing a flammable gas. It wouldn’t be a sustained burn.. but it’s possible for fire to be present in space.. what do you think a star is?
is there any chance, considering the second half of this video, that I am making fun of the people who are having a problem with the fire in space part...
Oh, well I missed that point. I took it as you saying that all those clips of the fire in space were silly too. I guess it just wasn’t very clear to me. But now that I know.. I agree with you!
yeah we know you folk will ignore 90% of these things with star wars and immediately laser target something else as too far or not acceptable. This goes way beyond fire or explosions but Star Wars content in general. There is zero consistency in your complaints, not unlike the arguments small children would make, and that is why no one takes you guys seriously.
They did it a few times but it was when a ship was being destroyed, and it was quick. The acolyte made this fire a charachter and gave it wayyyy to much screen time. That's what makes it awkward. Also it's acting like a God damn camp fire
@@JimmyTheGhost16 That's what I said in my comment. They've done fire in space plenty of times. If an atmospheric gasses such as o2 are being expelled from the hull of a ship flames will be visible in space until the fuel source is out. The problem with the acolyte scene is that it looks like a campfire in my fire pit, and it's the main character in the scene. Please compare the clone wars space fires to this lame ass scene. It's a lot quicker and not as much time spent on it, because Dave Filoni had a story line that was actually good.
No one on screen ever reacts to sounds in space. Only the audience has their ears everywhere. Also, there is an orchestra playing, but we are on a POV in space, how can we hear this? This never bothered onlookers. This is, where the difference is: characters on screen should behave to things that are there. Virtual camera and virtual hearing are for the audience's sake.
I think if people want to criticize a fire existing in space, it would make more sense if it was to criticize how scientifically illogical the whole franchise has been, not just this show. Nothing I’ve seen from this new show has been as ridiculous as the time the millennium falcon landed inside a giant worm, that not only had walkable surfaces and gravity on an asteroid, but was somehow able to walk outside the ship without spacesuits on. Also even as I type that, I realize having a lifeform on an astroid with no atmosphere in space is more ridiculous than a fire in space.
Didn’t Phantom Menace have a scene with a similar fire as the one in the show? It’s not like that scene was insignificant either, that was R2D2’s origin.
You will literally defend ANYTHING to maintain your SHILL credibility. This wasn't the primary complaint. People will tolerate breaking of physics in small doses and if it makes a moment or scene SPECTACULAR. But a slow lingering casual camp like fire in space looks stupid. At least make it look cool. The other scenes were in an ACTION sequence. There were several things on screen at that moment, and those breaks conveyed destruction. Of course you want to dumb the criticisms down. Enjoy your new Star Wars. It's all yours.
yeah we know you folk will ignore 90% of these things with star wars and immediately laser target something else as too far or not acceptable. This goes way beyond fire or explosions but Star Wars content in general. There is zero consistency in your complaints, not unlike the arguments small children would make, and that is why no one takes you guys seriously.
Oh... one other thing. Trek uses Light Speed. Star Wars doesn't use Light speed they use Hyperspace. Hyperspace travel in FTL because you're not traveling through Normal Space. You enter Subspace. Travel between planets becomes days or weeks or months... Instead of millions of years. When the Falcon's HyperDrive fails in Empire. Han uses his Back Drive to Hop to Bespin. That trip took weeks. They just didn't show it. Otherwise, the Trip would have taken 50,000 years at the speed of light. it's like 17 parsecs between Bespin and Hoth or 50,000 light years.
The examples you used are incorrect. You showed plasma, thinking it was fire. It's like confusing the flames on the sun for Fire. If a Ship bursts into flames in space it means the shielding is down and plasma is leaking which means the ship goes boom and everyone is dead. The reason no one bursts into flames and dies in the room when some nut lights a saber... it's because it is the shielding that refocuses the heat into the blade. No shielding on the blade and you don't need to swing the blade to hit someone. You're dead they're dead, anyone nearby is Dead when you turn the Fucking this on.{{ Why anyone not in a CULT would want to use a plasma sword is beyond me. The Jedi do it because the Cult fucks are crazy.}} That shit burning on the acolyte ship was clearly a fire in space. If it was plasma the ship would be engulfed killing the fools walking on the ship. This stuff is mentions in some of the books and games if you dig a little. Just google what a lightsaber is. They all say...Plasma. They just never go into details for the freaks like me that want to know this shit. Like TV SHOW RUNNERS. Every wonder why TREK was so much into the DETAILS... BECAUSE Fans want them to know the Details and Use them! This means the Laser weapons are also not Lasers... They are plasma weapons. You get hit by one and it's like a Star Trek weapons... Set on a Billion. It's the reason why a 40K Guardsman's plasma weapon overheats... He DIES! But he's not killed by Fuckin' Fire... It's a Plasma weapon... FIRE has nothing to do with it.
1. it’s does not make the fire in space any better thou 2. only 2 scenes where actual fire in space the others where expulsions, something totally possible 3. there can be oversights, this is a major plot point
Rocket exhaust is just fire in space. All the ships on fire can be explained by a liquid hydrogen coolant mixing with heat and an oxygen line. The acolyte fire has neither explanation
The fire in the space battles I imagine is the oxygen and fuel being burned up. People are silly when they say there's no fire in space. Explosions are the same. If fuel & oxygen is present then fire can burn, but violently and not very long. HOWEVER, the fire in Acolyte seems to be running steady and for a long time. It looks like a campfire, not oxygen being burned up quickly and aggressively like the others. Fires aboard ships are a death sentence because the whole ship is made of pressurized gas. The fire look or behave like that, it just looks stupid.
