Тёмный

$125 Lie Nielsen Vs. $15 Jorgensen (The Orange Plane - Lowes) Review and Comparison of the 101's 

Bat Cave Creations
Подписаться 6 тыс.
Просмотров 6 тыс.
50% 1

Опубликовано:

 

12 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 44   
@gautambarua8260
@gautambarua8260 Месяц назад
Loved the detailed comparative review.
@BatCaveCreations
@BatCaveCreations Месяц назад
Happy to hear it! Thank you!
@allen131313
@allen131313 Год назад
I bought one of the 102's based on this video and am very pleased with it. I got lucky and don't have to shim my blade like you so it works great. Thanks for the review. I would buy the block plane and smoother if I had the slightest need for them. I have a Veritas Pocket Plane and it's a great tool, but I like the 102 at least as well. Thanks
@BatCaveCreations
@BatCaveCreations Год назад
I am happy to hear that and I am glad you don't have to shim the blade!! Double win! Hahah
@ManuelGarcia-ww7gj
@ManuelGarcia-ww7gj Год назад
I just want to thank you for tipping me off to Jorgenson planes.
@timothymallon
@timothymallon Месяц назад
For the price, I bought one of these 102's (Stanley 101) planes. Mine, thankfully didn't need a wedge under the iron. Maybe the one you have was just a bad run.
@BatCaveCreations
@BatCaveCreations Месяц назад
It deff was from a bad run cus I bought another and it's perfectly fine! Foe the price I do expect some QC issues. Glad yours was good! It sounds like they are getting better
@jamesstenhouse7710
@jamesstenhouse7710 Год назад
Thanks for the reviews, i didn't know about the Jorgensens.
@BatCaveCreations
@BatCaveCreations Год назад
Happy to help! I am very happy with all 3 that they make lol
@dragomirdichev1196
@dragomirdichev1196 Год назад
If you are going to use this tool for the rest of your life, putting and fitting paper shims every time you sharpen it just to save $100 is not worth doing. Plus the quality of the steel matters a lot too.
@BatCaveCreations
@BatCaveCreations Год назад
Imma file the bed down or use tape and that will fix it. Others aren't having this issue, I just got a bad one haha The iron is O1 so it's pretty good depending on where you wall in the O1 vs A2 argument lol
@TomeOfKnowledge74
@TomeOfKnowledge74 Год назад
You've had to shim 2 of 3 planes, which does not bode well for the Jorgensens. It's a nice price point, but sometimes it might make sense to follow "buy once, cry once".
@BatCaveCreations
@BatCaveCreations Год назад
Some people can't afford to buy LN, Veritas, Bedrock, etc. This would be a good alternative for them.
@sandhill9313
@sandhill9313 10 месяцев назад
IF you were doing a LOT of work with a tiny plane, that might make some sense, and I'm a big fan of buy once cry once, but faced with an automotive task I need to do very rarely, I always go to Harbor Freight and let the Snap On truck roll on by, same thought here. The cost difference is jaw dropping. 🙂
@stevekelley1179
@stevekelley1179 Год назад
Here's my two cents. Leave the more expensive ones in the shop. Loan or use the cheaper ones outside of the shop. I have the cheaper ones for my grandson to learn on.
@jimrosson6702
@jimrosson6702 Год назад
Very cool thanks for sharing
@jessedealva5597
@jessedealva5597 Год назад
Great videos! They are super helpful and great comparison. For this plane and the block plane how do you know you needed to shim? What was wrong with the plane beforehand that made you recognize something was off? Thanks!
@BatCaveCreations
@BatCaveCreations Год назад
Great question! I could tell it needed shimmed because it kept cutting heavy on 1 side. For the 101, you can't adjust the lateral so shim was the only option. For the 60.5 you could adjust lateral slightly but even when I did it was still heavy on the same side. Basically if the iron is square and all other adjustments fail, shim it and see what happends.
@egglyph
@egglyph Год назад
​@@BatCaveCreations actually you can adjust laterally on 101, just need a small hammer, there's enough play in parts to allow it. Also, perhaps on that Jorgensen it's better to grind the iron out of square rather than shimming or trying to true up a frog.
@BatCaveCreations
@BatCaveCreations Год назад
@@egglyph 6:46 my Jorgensen did not have enought play for lateral adjustment. I do have a plane adjust hammer you can see it in the video.... lol I would prefer to shim than to try to find the perfect angle to grind it outta square. I will try filing the bed down so in the future I don't have to shim
@robertberger8642
@robertberger8642 10 месяцев назад
Why were paper shims needed for the Jorgensen! Was the cap too loose without them?
@BatCaveCreations
@BatCaveCreations 10 месяцев назад
The blade bed wasn't parallel to the sole of the plane :( it dipped to the one side making it always cut heavy on that side
@nickd5943
@nickd5943 Год назад
I’m still a little confused as to why you had to shim this plane and the block plane. Are they machined out of parallel with the sole? Meaning is the bed not parallel with the sole? If you would please elaborate on the problems you found. Thank you for making this series of videos.
@BatCaveCreations
@BatCaveCreations Год назад
No problem at all! Yes the blade bed isn't parallel and in-line as it should be. If I keep filing I am certain I can get them where they belong but... don't know that I care to since the paper worked lol For the 60.5 the very back bed (where the depth adjuster is) was higher/not in line with the bed closer to the mouth. With the 101, it was just not flat or parallel. I hope this helps! I am working on an overall review thay talks about the shimming a bit more too. Should be uploaded tonight!
@makenchips
@makenchips 9 месяцев назад
You should order a couple more picked out the best one! I want to get off of Amazon was spot on no issues what are the box and started using it shavings the same as I got with my lie Nielsen
@rhpsoregon
@rhpsoregon Год назад
I got my first 101 when I was 5 years old from my grandfather. I use it all the time. Up until now, I've never seen an adjustable 101. I'm not sure why Jorgensen calls this a 102. A 102, while it has the same lever cap as this one, the blade is still not adjustable (unless you use a hammer) and it's also about 2" longer. How far out of wack is the bed that you need to shim the blade? Would a diamond paddle or an Arkansas slip stone be enough to bring it back to true? I wouldn't mind getting an adjustable 101 if I didn't have to fettle it a bunch. Right now, I carry 2 in my apron, both set for a different depth of cut.
@BatCaveCreations
@BatCaveCreations Год назад
A diamond paddle or a file would be able to bring it back to true. That is a project I have set for a later time. Just have to keep filing till it's true. I posted a video reviewing the 60 1/2s in that video you see me file the bed of the 60 1/2
@rhpsoregon
@rhpsoregon Год назад
Thanx. You've got a new subscriber.
@BatCaveCreations
@BatCaveCreations Год назад
@@rhpsoregon happy to hear it!! Thank you!
@What_Other_Hobbies
@What_Other_Hobbies Год назад
I’m wondering if the parts are interchangeable with LN ones.
@BatCaveCreations
@BatCaveCreations Год назад
I'd imagine so they are basically identical. The only part I'm not sure about is the depth adjustment screw. Thread pitch may not match. I sent the LN back to its owner already so I can't check 😞
@What_Other_Hobbies
@What_Other_Hobbies Год назад
@@BatCaveCreations how about the other 2 planes?
@BatCaveCreations
@BatCaveCreations Год назад
@@What_Other_Hobbies for the 4 and 60.5, the iron, cb, and caps are interchangeable.
@xxxcarpfishing1657
@xxxcarpfishing1657 Год назад
Its bronze not brass
@sgtmcd
@sgtmcd Год назад
Orange though…😂
@BatCaveCreations
@BatCaveCreations Год назад
Haha right! Part of me wants to keep the orange because it just bugs ppl. But I plan on changing it to black and yellow and engraving the sides haha most ppl are painting them black
@sgtmcd
@sgtmcd Год назад
@@BatCaveCreations I was at Lowe’s a few weeks ago and bought one. I hadn’t yet seen this vid. I was pleased. You definitely get better materials and fit/finish on everything Lie Nielsen makes. A 101/102 doesn’t get much use so for the money, eh? This plane hangs out in my apron and pops out for a chamfer or two. Really no a bad little plane. Nice vid. Thanks much
@BatCaveCreations
@BatCaveCreations Год назад
@@sgtmcd exactly! I don't use it much but it's handy when you need it so $15 is perfect for me! Hahaha
@moneypenny174
@moneypenny174 4 месяца назад
Junkenson
@BatCaveCreations
@BatCaveCreations 3 месяца назад
Clever lol
@moneypenny174
@moneypenny174 3 месяца назад
@@BatCaveCreations as a violin maker, I have no time to waste shimming planes.
@BatCaveCreations
@BatCaveCreations 3 месяца назад
@moneypenny174 oh 100%! Profesional makers shouldn't use Jorgensen lol hobbiests tho diff story
@moneypenny174
@moneypenny174 3 месяца назад
@@BatCaveCreations friends don’t let friends buy Jorgenson..🤣
@BatCaveCreations
@BatCaveCreations 3 месяца назад
@@moneypenny174 hahahah
Далее
Новый уровень твоей сосиски
00:33
Is this the future of budget tools?
20:22
Просмотров 158 тыс.
Low Angle Vs Standard Plane - The Last Word
27:31
Просмотров 149 тыс.
Jorgensen 102 Low Angle Block Plane Review
22:09
Просмотров 10 тыс.
The Good the Best and the Ugly | Choosing a Hand Plane
14:19