You can watch this interview (very similar in content) in English on Fauji Days here: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-PKlIqzcRI5o.htmlsi=aEovI3yeuZIclIWs
Hello Mr Vaad your thumbnail is totally Unexpected unwanted they are our Brave soldiers not Any common man's dead bodies u Said MAARE GAYE Instead of saying them Shahid huye. Pls remove your Thumbnail otherwise I do a complaint against you and give u strike
I am sad that you repeatedly call our martyrs , marte nI marte , wo mare nai hai wo saheed hue hai . Please guys atleast show some respect to those who sacrificed everything for the motherland . They deserve all the respect. Kindly never say wo mar gaye for this blunder i may not wish you see your videos again. You are good but your maturity doesn't reflect in your conversation....🙏🙏
.....all said & done...!!! BUT... ----- GENTLEMEN.... wasn't it the great blunder of ATAL BIHARI's leniency in DIPLOMATIC SCENARIO of that time...??..??
I have served with him in Leh while I was posted there during the Kargil war. A Paratrooper and an Army Aviator. A very fine and smart officer. Did well during the Kargil war.
Brigadier Sir,a lot of wrong has been done by the Generals,your Seniors, you were worthy of a promotion, for their mistakes you, and many others like Bhatnagar Sir, were made scapegoat.Generally speaking How much one is trained,but ones character can't be changed. It can be seen in the military too,Good and bad,share your thoughts or opinions with your Seniors, be ready to be punished.
I had served in SSW, did two LRPs in this sector. Batalik sector including chorbatala are head up peaks. Very difficult fight. Well achieved. Especially, 12 JAKLI.
Salute to Brig Devinder Singh for his great role during Karggill operation. - I have served in Siachen Glacier as Head Clerk 71 Medium Regiment during 89-91
Brig Devinder, you were made out to be Brig Dalvi of '62 ops. I am grateful to you for bringing out the truth as it was with such candour but without any finger-pointing . You were sealed for your ldrshp. It's sad. You are a Hero. Jai Hind.
ब्रिगेडियर साहब, तगड़ा रहो, आप भारत के शूरवीर और राष्ट्रभक्त बेहद योग्य व श्रैठतम सैन्य अधिकारी हैं, आप नए भारतियों हेतु साक्षात सूर्य भगवान हैं, परमात्ना आप व आपके परिवारजनों पर सदा कृपालु रहैं हमें आपकी जाम्बाजी भरी सेवाओं पर नाज़ है व मृत्यु परन्त रहेगा । जय हिन्द श्रीमान ।❤
Each and every soldier irrespective of rank and hierarchy speaks volume of the Leadership of Brig Devendir Singh, A TRUE LEADER indeed who Deserved Recognition of the Highest Order not only as a Gallantry Award as Well as of the rank of Highest Leadership . Jai Hind and Salutations to Brig Devendir
I had the honour of being a staff officer under brig Devinder Sir during op Vijay A Great commander and a great human being He deserved a hero’s recognition and much more
mere man me ek sawal hamesha rahta hai jab hum 3 yudh me pakistan ko buri tarah harae ,kitne sainik ko atam samarpan karae ,bangladesh alag kara die to usi yudh me POK kyu nahi le lie ? aGAR HUM 1999 kargiil har jate to wo kasmir par kabja kr lete fir hum kyu nahi kr sakte ,international law bhi to dono ke lie same hi hai .fir
Bhai saare afsar colonial mindset ke nahi hote . Theek waise jaise Bohot saare jawan are not fit for duty let alone warfare ...wo bhi sachhai hai...toh please har afsar koi bekkar mat bolo jaise.... Bohot saare jawan makre bhi hote hai
Read about how we gave up all the area upto Khaybar pass, newspapers reported that our jawans cried when they learnt about the'order' from Delhi! V old story, sad..@@CLANFORD294
A big salute to Brig Devinder Singh Sir for bringing these details to the world. I endorse every word he has said. I was the company commander of the engr coy supporting 70 Bde. Regards
I salute Brigadier Sir the way he fought the battle without having proper resources & won the war with minimum casualties.This history must be re-write & rewarded by the current government. Hat's up to you Sir
Brigadier Sahib pressure hone ke baad bhi aapne ek bahtareen senanayak ki tarah apne officers aur jawano ke haq me sahi nirnay liya aur fatah hasil ki. Ye durbhagya to hai ki iska appreciation military leadership se milna chahiye tha wo aaj bhi nahi mila hai. Koi baat nahi aap pure bharat ke dilon mein bas gaye hai aur bahut samman hai aapki bahaduri ka sabke dil me
कारगिल मै सभी सैनिको को, जो जिन्दा और सहीद हुये, सभी जवानो को मेरा ह्रदय से धन्यवाद, इतनी विषम स्तितियो, काम सामान और थके होने के वाद भी विजय के लिए 🙏🏼🙏🏼
Straight trees are always the first ones to get chopped. Similarly, ground soldiers seldom rise beyond a level. It is rather interesting to note that despite such a courageous junior/mid level leadership in our army, one rarely finds senior ranks wearing gallantry medals. It may sound harsh but the conculsion is simple--gallantry gets you nowhere; good pen and command over language take you to higher echelons. But then ground soldiers don't really care. Long live our gallant officers and men! Jai Hind.
Differs from individual to individual. Ancient India had a concept of Rajrishi. Mudgala - born kshtriya, achieved to be Rishi. Bhardwaja - born rishi, became kshtriya. Vishwamitra & parshuram too.
These things eat away and hollow institutions. It's a problem in civil and military both but the repercussions can be more lethal if it happens in the military. After the 2020 galwan incident you saw armed forces especially the Indian Army making emergency purchases and civil/gov also got into action. This makes you question what the fck were they doing before it? Sit on your azz's till you get slapped from the enemy and then wake up while trying to pull up your pants. Even after kargil we got caught by surprise in galwan. Thank the stars weve got enemies like China and paxtan who keep waking up our civil/military elites with half azzed attempts! The sheer size of our nation is the biggest reason for such a lackadaisical attitude. If we were in a situation like Israel, I'm pretty sure we'd be living in refugees camps somewhere by now. I mean, you look at tv news shows and see armed forces officers there. You listen to them in podcasts on RU-vid and you can see kitne paani m hai apni fauj. The very fact that all our achievements are against paxtan. A nation with a similar population of uttar pradesh and that too with dwindling economy. I mean just look at the rot, country's prime minister gave the orders directly from the red fort on 15 aug and bring in CDS with a mandate of creating theatre commands but our armed forces haven't moved an inch as of now. Political interference in armed forces is never good but I think pmo should directly get involved and start a purge both in military and civil institutions. National security is nobody's personal fiefdom!
My salute to Brig Devender Singh & his troops for bringing the country glory in a tough fight with enemy in Batalik sector. While he & his Jawans did not get the true recognition (as heard in the story here) , I am sure in the heart of their hearts , they yet would have had all the satisfaction for bringing the country all the honour & reclaiming all the grounds earlier infiltrated by enemy. My special salute to all those who lost their lives in the war - Country owes hugely for their gallantry & courage. Our next generations will be richer to know about these soldier's stories of valor. Government can still take a lesson & cues from this Video & at least create a memorial (for batalik sector heros) so that these troops can be given extra pride which they richly deserve !
BRIG Devindersingh Sir Jai Hind. I had went to BSF Mountaineering Expedition 1990 to Momstang Kangri as Medical Officer (Assistant Commandant/RMO). Our one BN HQ was at Chenigund/Sainikund. After Zoji La the terrain is very difficult,dry.
🫡🙏 Hope Braves of Batalik get the due respect soon. Let us all take this story to larger audience and build up the awareness about the lesser known section of the victorious Kargil war.
Watching SKVerma is an important event in my life as I am an avid reader of his most authentic and genuine books on India 's various wars . May God grant him a very long life in future .
It’s a shame that even such a brave man have to go to courts to get himself cleared, he’s not given promotions just for some political gain 😭🫡 Still the man holds no regrets towards his nation or politics
@@rohitverma4147❤ शानदार प्रस्तुति, कमियों को दूर करने का प्रयास समय पर होना चाहिए।तथ्यों को ध्यान सुनना चाहिए।इस कोर के नेतृत्वकारी बहादुर ऑफिसरों को सलाम।
As a common man we think as if everything is simple. The difficulties that are faced by the soldiers are really immense, we are grateful to Indian Army for such a bravery and commitment. The controversies are unfortunate and must stop. I feel, media plays an important role and nurtures controversies.
That is a gross generalisation. Even Capt Vikram Batra,capt Manoj Kumar Pandey,Arun khetrapal, karam Singh etc amongst 100s of others have been recieved gallantry awards. We can't say the same for them. But it's indeed true that there are many brave armed forces personal who didn't got their due recognition,in form of gallantry medals & otherwise.
brigadier Singh you are true officer who has a lot of concern about jawans life that's the real purpose of officer, to win but not on count of soldiers life salute singh is king ❤❤ love for army and sikh brothers
Brigadier Devinder Singh Sir aur unke under yuddh ladne vale sabhi fighting force ko Salaam aur Pranaam. Many bravehears of mother India fought war valiently and made Supreme sacrifice of their lives. Dhanya hain ve maa baap jinhone is baduron ko janm diya. Jai Hind
Punjabi are always first line of defense for indian. havaldar ishar sing (saragari) ,major.kuldeep sing chandpuri (Longewala) and brigadier divinder singh ( kargil) salute 🫡 from gorkhi🇳🇵
This is the real kind of Military Podcast. Soo deep, small details, the host is also well read.(not kunal sir, baju wale bhaiya). Ranveer Allahbadia and every other RU-vidr who do military podcast should take lessons, that how a military podcast is done. Thank you for this podcast 🙏.
Try posting images/maps for the common audience who don’t have the geographical understanding. But, I must say, this is like reading a book on Kargil strategies and war games! Kudos to Vaad for this Samwaad! ❤
Taking lessons from Kargil, Indian Army & Modi government have learned a lot & made changes. Appointment of CDS, appointment of Deputy Army Chief, preparation to create theater command are prominent among them.
Sir, if you are reading this, I just want to say thank you for your service. We all know, within internal army circles, how brave you were. You were one of those few officers who were always at the front with the troops, not sitting in a bunker. At army gatherings, everyone knows what a good officer you were. These top generals, like V.S. Budhwar, were traitors. No one will say it on camera, but this is the sentiment in internal army circles and at parties.
The distance from dilbag to 5000 base to GSK to dah...in batalik was about 50km and there was no road...they reached Indus river and then everyone woke up
सर आपकी बात सची हेजब कारगील की जंग के वक्त में बीस साल का था फीर भी मुजे ऐ समज मे आता था के हमे लड़ाई लडने की जरूरत ही नहीं थी हम अपनी जमीन पर थे हम उनको चारो तरफ घेर के बेठे थे उनका रसद पानी हमने काट दिया था वो बिना लडे भुखे ही मर जाते बाजपाई की सरकार बहोत ढीली सरकार थी नीककमी ओर लबाड थी
So so so brilliant and knowledge emphasising podcast. Kudos to all intelligent and braveheart commanders (like brig. Davinder singh sir) and soldiers who fought for our nation. Nation will be indebted to you. Jai hind.
दुखद हैं !!! सेना में भी इस तरह की चीजें होना ।।देश में सबसे ज्यादा विश्वास सेना पर किया जाता है ।। कंपनी के नाम पर ,कमांडर के नाम पर , अवार्ड के नाम पर सेना को नहीं बटाना चाइए ।। आर्मी के अंदर इस तरह की बाते में पहली बार सुन रहा हु । जनरल्स अपने घमंड में रहे , वीर जवान देश के लिए शहीद होते रहे।।।
Awesome analysis of injustice by the corrupt system.. I was pushed back to General Shabeg Singh..... One should also ask that how many soldiers were the kids of the politicians.....
This type of group conversation is best for fullfill all gaps in talk which are uncompleted. I wish you do again and again. Thanku jai hind. Bharat mata ki jaa. 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
What's the point in being grateful and continuing the injustice of no recognition to 3rd Div & their sacrifices - we shed tears on stories of martyrdom of bravehearts like captain Manoj Pandeyji - but after knowing the real situation from ground Commanders like Brig. Singh - it's very evident that captain Pandey & the troops were thrown in the harms way for supreme sacrifices due to uninformed decisions
@@Robertpupo I totally agree. I just try to thank them on behalf of our thankless countrymen and generals. It’s heartbreaking to see their sacrifices and suffering going unnoticed.
Please continue to pursue this discussion so that the Commanders & Generals, whose decisions to protect their egos & incompetence led to 100sof bravehearts sacrifices is not relegated to singing patriotic songs & flowers being offered on their memorials but those responsible are also brought out - else these persons would continue to enjoy their martinis as post retiral benefits & would continue bragging about their bravery to the next generations
Brigadier devinder Singh ji aap ko naman hai.Aaap desh Kay hero hain aap ki desh seva kisi award ya promotion ki mohtaaj nahin desh sachai jaan chuka hai.Naman pranaam Sat Shri akaal ji.😢
Sir mein bhi us ops mein tha aur mein 5 para se hun . Maj Bhatnagar sahb ne ye nahi bola tha ki mere JCO / troups unfit hain. Unhone ye kaha tha ki 1. ham log abhi direct Siachin se down hokar aa rahe hain. Aur aaj hamko 4 din ho gaye hain continue chalte chalte . 2. Hamko din mein pahle tgt area dekhna padega uske bad ops plan TPS ko samjhayenge than attack karenge. 3. mujhe abhi Kam se kam 24 ghante chahiye taki Jo Troups niche se 4 din se continue chal kar aaye hain unko thoda rest mil jayega aur mein objective ko dekh lunga apni deployment aur dushman ki deployment samajh lunga uske bad attack success hoga. 4. Bhatnagar sahb ki is baat par wahan Jo bhi bare commander the wo naraj ho gaye aur Bhatnagar sahb ko jor jor se danth rahe the jabardasti unko usi samay attack karne ke liye bol rahe the . Jabki usi din ham log village Dhah se lagbhag 12 ghante chalne ke bad us jagah par raat ke andhere mein pahunche the. 5 . Agle din early morning jab CO sahb aaye to ham logon ko fall in kiya aur Briefing kiya aur ham sabhi PT 5203 ki taraf attack ke liye move kar gaye. Kisi ne bhi nahi bola ki unfit hain. Puri ki puri strength gayi thi. Aur Bhatnagar sahb ko back to 1/ 11 GR kar diya without buddy. Is mein Bhatnagar sahb ki bilkul bhi galti nahi thi. Unke sath galat hua.wo ek great offr the. Aur aaj bhi hain. Is episode mein mujhe kafi batein achhi lagi kyuki jitne name sahb ne liye hain un sab attacks par mein present tha aur purani yadein taja ho gayi. Ant mein yahi kahunga ki kargil ops mein jaldi baji nahi kiyi jati to itni casuality nahi hoti.
Namaskar sir,1st of all thanks for your service in army.I never thought I will come across a para commando here in comments.Can u tell us something about in how many missions in Kargil para commandos took part in & how much casualties they took in & gave it to the Pakistanis.I have heard about Late Sudhir Kumar walia & Yadav ji from 9 para-sf who won gallantry awards in this,but bakiyo ka mujhe kuch nahi pata hai.
Lodge Complaint against top brass for negligence, how top brass went to foreign country during war.Officers who speaks truth in national interest are facing punishments.Who caused loses to the lives of 100s of officials and injuries to 1000s are enjoying pensions etc.All responsible should be booked for criminal conspiracy to suppress the actual position fromnation.CBI investigation is required to fix responsibility and CBI FIR is required as this is not a normal case.Advocate
What a fantastic "Samvaad"! I've subscribed to this channel for its exceptional content. Kudos to the host for showcasing the true heroes of the Indian Armed Forces. It's eye-opening to see the politics behind the scenes, where such heroes are often made scapegoats to cover up the incompetence of certain high-ranking officers.
I am not a Army man but I am following the chain of Interviews and reading the related books. It is very clear that injustice has been done. This has to be resolved soon and immediately.
Brigd. Devinder Shab has done excellent work ....despite so much effort he has to face trail that is so shame ful .....he is tresure of nation ...hatts of to you sir .....
if you clearly see the geography of the batalik sector, the Indus rivers curls the sector towards kargil and thus dras, naturally the pakistan army had required to cross an extra valley and even indus to climb up to hills of batalik. therefore it can be said that it was indeed more likely for pak army to get short of supplies as compared to the hills of dras in the west of kargil. Therefore pak army frequently vacated the posts and ran away, because it was way long distance for them to evade as compared to the tiger hill / Dras.
मनीष भटनागर का कोर्ट मार्शल बिल्कुल गलत किया गया उसने बात एकदम सही कही थी थोरा सोच समझ कर बहुत अच्छी तरह की रेकी इन्फॉर्मेशन इकठ्ठी करने के बाद हमले की योजना बनाई जानी चाहिए थी कुल मिलाकर ये था कि उच्च स्तर के सेनाधिकारियों को वास्विकता पता ही नही थी कि ऊपर किस तरह के लोग ओर कितनी संख्या में बैठे है बस हमारे नए नए लड़को की युद्ब में झोंक दिया
Good aaj ye podcast arahe hai jiski wajah se reality samne arahi hai. I remember mere Ghar ke samne he 1/11 GR ki paltan thi Dehradun mai bahot dead bodies ati thi mere khud ke ward se kari young soliders ki death huyi. Ek baat bhool gaye sab us time ke defense minister George Fernandes jisne khud media mai kaha hum samne se ladenge unka bhi order tha jiske wajah se zayada casualty huyi
Any army person listening about different locations in this podcast and just remembering all his tenure he served that movie that is running in his mind and small memories is just awesome
@@sundersinghaithani7235 Same here. I was hooked in. It is so unfortunate what happenned & as a civilian, I didn't had the slightest of idea that there were so many mistakes from our side which we could have avoided starting from identifying the intrusion of Pak troops
Military science is based on "correct assessment of ground realities + best planning in those circumstances". For this the thumb rule should be: (1) Listen to the feed back given by the local military leaders; (2) send that info to the highest command without adultration; and (3) Let the highest command order and let the local commander obey. Now India is changing ... Command Theators, integrated use of army air power and navy, optimum use of all resources even in one theator, fighting decisions in military hands and war decision in political hands.
During initial war days, it is very difficult to ascertain the situation. If we wait longer, we do not know what would happen. Also, if we wait for long till next winter, the infiltration would have been increased in a second wave, and positions may have been bolstered. Thus, in hindsight, it would look easy to take the decision that we should have waited longer to get prepared.
Thank you so much respected sir Brigadier Devinder Singh ji sir aap k courageous decision ki wajah se bahut bada nuksaan bach paya jiska matlab bhi nikalt aur aage bhi force k manobal ko shayad effect krta🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
This is awesome video...2 hours...i did watch it twice to understand complete technicalities.....awesome job sir. Next time pls make it for 5 hours so that each and every respect will be covered..................amazing content and thanks a lot!!!
बहुत अच्छा diskasan एसे ही सभी युद्घ पर चर्चा करे जिस्से हमारे अनपड़ नेताओ को अक्ल आये युद्घ कमांडरो को लड़ने दे आप राजनीती वहा न करे 528 जवान अपने ही देश के अन्दर मारे गये 😢
