‘This isn’t freedom’: Douglas Murray on Scotland’s ‘really pitiful’ hate speech legislation 

Then do something about it. Organise and fight back.

@@oumunfeiholeto6885We already are, we have Alba and other parties. The Unionist Parties are no use to us, they just do as London says. Scotland has to break free of that arranged marriage termed the Union, it's our only way forward.

Don’t ignore the Scottish Family Party.

@@barbaralucas2375I can ignore them as they are religious extremists. People have a right to abortion and to deny that is ignorance of many factors. We have to have a Party that caters for all, not the few.

@@haraldtheyounger5504 being pro-life is catering for the life of the unborn.

He will bring in Sharia law next...

No thanks

Labour supported it too. I think only 3 Labour MSPs voted against it.

@@WillCamx lib Dems voted for it too

Exactly! Are people starting to realise now that we're under attack from within? Or are people still stuck with the childish notion that: 'It j-just d-doesn't make sense!"???

Agenda 30

100% agree

@@gw2780 I'd be interested to hear what your counter-argument is. I think it's always a shame when a reply is just an insult and nothing else. If you understand the politics and can form a counter-point, it's a waste of a reply just being rude. Could you explain your point of view?

not forgetting fascism. Its a weird mix.

Thank the Tony Blair government that introduced devolution.

I am born and bred in Scotland and did not vote for SNP. The writing was on the wall with Sturgeon when she ranted on about freedom but wanted the EU to dictate to us? She is under investigation for helping herself to public funds which we pay for via taxation. Now Humza Yousaf (who people did not vote for but was ellected by SNP to be their leader) is in charge and helping himself to public money paid via taxation and sending it to Gaza. It gets worse. I do not know how anyone here can vote for this disgusting party.

The snp are Irish Republicans that hate the uk now infiltrated by islamists that also hate Scotland and the UK

Yes then they gaslight by saying we have to fight against these countries (literally and metaphorically) all the time acting just like them for their own interests

It happens everywhere now. Western democracy is gone. Globalism.

So under Labour you won't be able to criticize Islam without going to the naughty step and 2 years for misgendering will be a thing. Those devouring mothers want to save you from the thoughts in your head and the words in your mouth.

Thank Goodness I and my Anglo Scots Pals travelled all over Scotland and The North of England in the seventies and eighties. FREEDOM !

@@philiprufus4427That is the point, us old farts will rail against the suppression of speech and remember back to the good times. The kids growing up in this pervasive atmosphere are either in favour of their thought and speech being controlled or don't realize any different as they have been self censoring anyway. I imagine the fringe will be a somewhat muted affair with its woke organizers and new blasphemy law.

Scotland Parliament has shown just how irrelevant it is and what a waste of money is us, for these idiots to offend the people they are supposed to listen to

@@pauldench1299I’m Scottish and the only thing that offends me is all you fascists telling US how OUR LAWS should be, get tae £!ck ya windae licking puddle drinking wallopers

Go to England then!

@@rhize797 I am considering it

@@rhize797 what? you in favour of this fuckin madness????

@@ksmax6310 They will bring in the exact same laws when Labour are elected next year. Lets not forget that the only party in Hollyrood to oppose this bill were the Conservatives.

Where my country gone?

We've never elected a First Minister based on them being a Christian either, thankfully.

@@allanscott4140 No, it was almost a natural process. As a nation that is who we are. You go ahead and be that Turkey voting for Xmas 365 days a year. It makes you a great person. Maybe recall that speech that he made about all the "White" people, he literally spat the word "white".

@@allanscott4140call me crazy but id want an actual Scot in charge. not a pakistani.

@@allanscott4140call me crazy but id rather a Scottish person was in charge and not a pakistani.

@@allanscott4140Ridiculous response.

Or ya know, just been dreadful humans .. reap what ya soe

Nailed it.

True that.

@@redkev81It is your right to say what you want...including the dreadful.

Guess who is no longer going to be invited for any dinners? Far left people

You can even decide you're a five yo girl and no one can tell you you're not, it's insane

Your comment has been reported to the relevant authority for processing. Expect a visit from an officer very soon. In the meantime you are advised to keep quiet. Failure to comply will have stonger consequences.

Good for you, just because they can’t accept what they are doesn’t mean you have to accept what they’re presenting as

@@nnagildan8455 Your comment has been flagged for hate speech.

@@williamsmiler184 I’m quaking

Bet you voted for them....

@@boabm6522 nope no chance . I’m a Scottish unionist with strong ties in Northern Ireland and the orange order my friend

and bring the old team back from england ,the unionist parasites to contiue plundering SCOTLAND !

@@gw2780 ooh dear you're one of them, ohwell. I was born and raised in south east scotland so come back when you have a better response than just leave.

@@gw2780 plenty will if morons like you keep voting in these incompetent tossers

​@@gw2780You should leave

move to gaza please we dont want you here

vote the SNP into oblivion ban all foreigners from voting,,,and holding any type of political office,,

You did it to yourselves, don't expect any sympathy from the rest of us.

I dont really want to be as blunt as madmax, but he has a point. Its in your hands at the ballot box.

I suggest casting your vote for a more sane party, or an independent.

​@@MadMaxx829Nearly two thirds of Scots did not vote for the SNP. They head up a minority administration propped up by greens that 2 blokes and a dog voted for - this bill is one of theirs, as are many of other ridiculous things that happen here now. This is what PR results in, and should be a warning to everyone who advocates it. If it was up to me I'd abolish the whole thing tomorrow. So, tell me again how we "did it to ourselves"?

Vote them out

Totally agree I’m from Inverness ,, and live in Colombia South America and we have none of this bs,,,deeply saddened to see what’s happening sorry don’t want to return

Wales Labour party is doing the same, giving a fixed choice of one or the other of their choosing.

Exactly agree mp should not be allowed to use religion in politics ridiculous

He’s not Scottish he’s a Muslim! Wtf he’s both ya 🤡

Born in Glasgow makes him Scottish or are ye daft or something?

He is Scottish, you do realise that you can be a Scottish Muslim don't you, much like being a Scottish Christian, Atheist et al?

And then some they have turned it into a pro terrorist anti white anti Christian anti semitic police state.

Labour failed to do anything for the Scots (like the Red wall) for decades and open the door for a mediocre bunch of chancers and grifters. It could be worse, just look at Canada

The Scottish voted for them. Scotland has destroyed its own third world nation.

Not quite, they aren't even a real government, just a puppet show... an "Administration"... and that's the real problem. Scotland needs Independence so that we can get the actual government we want and need.

I agree. But this is also a Tory , labour problem. As GG says just different cheeks of the same arse

You fell straight into the trap the WEF set-up for you to fall into. SMH.

Next thing you know they'll outlaw whisky.

Don't know about back door it's blatant takeover god help our grandkids l feel so sad for Britain

Sharia law begins.

@@ericdonvil7501 Minimum alcohol pricing and limited sale times...... its already began.

I’d jail them all for thinking…. full stop

Englaza and Canada too

Naw ye cannae dinnae talk pish.

careful now.

Oh be fair - it *might* only have been a bribe with public money to get his personal relatives out of Gaza. Which is not dodgy at all. . . . . . .

Exactly right.

100 % rightb

Do you mean HamASS useless as an unelected first minister

Join him.

Gays are leading the world on anti woke issues ATM. It's refreshing.

Who the hell is he!?

@@MrGreen1314 he's a fascist!!!

​@@MrGreen1314 and you? Where are you green?

Englaza never voted for Boris the buffoon either

@@davie8906Rishi or Liz 🤦

Vote for ALBA. SNP are british agents destroying the cause of Scottish independence

No true Scotman applies.

Unfortunately the Labour and Green MSPs also voted for it.

How did he get elected?

@@unanielson8837 ....he wasnt by public...an internal snp vote put him as 1st minister....otherwise snp would be called racist for not voting for a box ticker.....the public will vote him out soon.

Oh, understand now. That's how he got in. @@geoffdundee

He is still raging that Clan Chiefs are white. Unbelievable.

@@iainrae6159 it's actually scary how he's still in a job and shouting islamophobic or islamophobia every time the question's get to much. But facts are he sent £250,000 to UNRWA and suddenly his parents get access through Egypt. Come on how much more corruption does Scottish people need to see before they protest outside Hollyrood?

​@@AkitaBruno This is the land of David Hume, Burns, William Wallace and the historic 'Arbroath Declaration ' Wake up Scotland.

@@iainrae6159 every name will be turning in their resting place. It's the whole of Britain that's been sold or taken over without a sword been swung or a gun been fired.

😂😂😂yep

He did

thought i saw the state police arresting folk with placards against charlie in edinburgh and the expensive coronation£100 MILLION but cost much more !think your better off in lil england where folks were arrested for hissing at some politico!🤡🤡

Good. Stay in englaza then. it's working then

@@davie8906 ... I am not in England and I have been to Scotland I won't be back might say the wrong thing. It is bad enough with gender nonsense where I live now. Delia Morris

we didnt vote for this nonsesne!

@@nielszindelno don’t come back cause you might hurt yourself your not smart enough to ride this 😂 Free speech is protected hate speech is not. I live in Scotland you don’t so talk as much 💩 as you like it’s all lies anyway.

It’s absolutely rubbish. They don’t have a clue.

Poor Douglas is gonna go to jail soon 😢

This is why religion should not be near politics. Religion is just belief, make believe. Religion is not representative of the people, just of a minority. When we have minorities getting precedence, then there's trouble. Too much insanity these days passed off as normal, as progressive.

Yes it was his Bill from before he was leader

Sharia law next

@@ayeright320bill not law the law already exists 🤡

Familiar with the CCP 100 Year Marathon?

Welcome to the world of the SNP - the party of grievance and hatred. The party of division. The party of criminality. Outrageous Socialism empowered by dafties with half-baked ideas of Scottish free-dum. The very worst of people - with un-checked power, and making a fortune through the support of those unable to see beyond tartan, bagpipes, shortbread, haggis, Wallace, Bruce, Bonnie Prince Charlie... and utter hatred of England. Utterly embarrassing. ...and encouraged by 'ex-patriot' Scots in Australia, New Zealand, Canada and the USA. Fuds!

You cannot even speak the truth on here without someone's pretendy feelings being bruised.

I plan to keep speaking the truth, having an opinion and not being silenced by anyone. Not that I'm in Scotland, but I'm sure this foolishness will leak across the border at some point.

​@@paulncott4587I am in Scotland and will continue to say what I want, when and where I want. Everyone I know is doing the same. This law is unenforceable and they know it. Its a distraction from the real crimes Humza is committing.

Nope, I never heard of this until now. The SNP have put the last nail in their own coffin.

Unpopular legislation is seldom put to those it intents to suppress. They did the same with the gender recognition act, and its reform. They stole the freedoms of women, and we basically let them....... now that inch is won, they're grabbing the mile.

It's just like the Liz Truss situation but in Scotland

There was a consultation on this but as usual it was not very well publicised. The Church of Scotland and other groups tried to put a stop to it but unfortunately our msp’s from all parties dismissed all concerns and passed it. In essence a person can report a hate crime without evidence or proof as it’s their feeling is the only evidence is required for conviction. There is no defence as you are automatically guilty that’s the main problem.

@@thepuddlejumper500Which in essence is the absolute failure of this idiotic "law". It is itself discrimination, and encourages hate. The absurdity of this would be amusing if it was Police Chief Miekelson (Scot Squad) coming up with it, but that it is actual law is worrying indeed. The SNP have to go, and this law banished to history.

NO WAY !@@gw2780

"Now"?! Englaza occupation eradicating our language WASNT?

@@CaFe73100 Try the Neo-Marxist edition, funded by Zionism

"Two many"? I think you mean "too many". Get it right...

How many white people are in positions of authority in Hamza Youssef,s country of origin. Scotland is a white country.

ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-qUCFDzzZLKI.html

Yes he did.

Yes. He raged about elite jobs in Scotland going to ‘WHITE’S’ while he snarled about it - not having the intellect to understand that our population was well over 90% white and certainly some of these jobs were taken up when we were over 98% white INDIGENOUS people. And the eye popping thing is that he himself - a non white racist Muslim - has the most senior job in Scotland - also the top job in the uk is a non white Hindu And there are plenty of posts where the ridiculous ‘positive discrimination’ have allowed dumclucks of various nationalities to hold posts that they are in no way qualified for Just awful what is happening in Scotland. And considering the disgrace that snp have brought upon the country with all the financial irregularities, and massively brainless and ill thought out decisions that have cost the country countless financial losses while they go bleating about it being westminsters fault just because snp can’t do the job and are not up to it in any way. They will go down in history for their massive incompetence and so will the Scottish people for allowing it - This is a huge learning curve that there should be indigenous people of 3rd or more heritage who run the country - not all these people who have no respect whatsoever for the country. And let’s stop paying stupid amounts of money and fat pensions off the general publics tax payments. Sorry about the rambling but it’s so infuriating that yousef and his cronies are trying to kill our country. I hope to hell that he is found to have a conflict of interest through his sneaky behaviour with funds he siphoned over to Gaza so his in laws could walk free when the rest of the country was locked by Hamas. He needs to go double quick and snp need to crumble to dust. And yes I agree with Douglas - what is all the hoo hah with Kate ? It was just a photo of her family and seriously , why all the obsession - it was a nice photo and gesture, stop reading ridiculous stories into it.

That is what the parochials fail to understand - it is coming from the UN and its purpose is to stop any democratic discussion of the crap that they are imposing on us. Look it up - UN Hate Crime.

and Canada....we just introduced HATE CRIMES for online Speech.... Gay here and will NEVER shut my mouth when it comes to ISLAM and it's HATE for Jews or Gays!!!

More then likely

No further action to be taken.

@gw2780 And why would I want to. I'm not a Muslim. There are plenty of films made covertly of so-called preachers spouting their hatred and calling for the demise of non believers. So the evidence is there without me having to witness it first hand. So you're absolutely right, I've never been in a mosque, but you keep going, though.

​@@gw2780 go and watch the dispatchers docs , plank

Who does the "Radicalising" then if it's not in the mosques? The Hate Fairy?? There must be a regiment of them spread all over the world.

Clown he is 🤡

It would probably be the labour type socialist view from Billy he was suitably brainwashed in that in Glasgows shipyards.

He is a numpty too

That was Old Labour Though,Not Anti - Brit.@@BradleyUK58

@@philiprufus4427 Is there a difference Labour are still staunch socialists in the policies. They still support terrorist groups.

Cannot Believe I would end up living 1984 fifty years after I read it,in one of Scotlands Elysian Summers of The Early Seventies. The SNATS were regarded as loonies when they came round the pubs by most Scots then.

Becoming englaza

No one will ever be in court for this nonsense though. All we have to do is turn the table and raise a case against the SNP and the Greens for their discrimination against our right to reason, to live by intelligence and our right of non-conformity.

Now your nabour can say he heard gate speech thru the wall police come find your weed stash or your cheeky under the counter backi pouch it’s all to remove the walls of your castle and the need for a warrent

The cops don't have the man power. Just vote the SNP out. Vote for a Party that is actually Scottish and cares about us Scots and Scotland. I know who I'm voting for, and it's not the SNP nor the Unionists.

😢

​@haraldtheyounger5504 I've voted for the SNP for years but I'm genuinely questioning if it's even worth it anymore. I believe in independence, so I've tolerated the SNP's utterly moronic policies, but there's absolutely a limit, and I feel as though we're approaching it. The whole situation with Count Dankula was absolutely embarrassing and a hammer blow to freedom of speech.

Yeah but Monty python was hilarious

But there's no sign of the comfy chair

No, the real spanish inquisition has arrived unfortunately.

Nobody expected but it’s happened 😂

-" Our chief weapons are- No sense of humour ! And suprise ! 😮

Let's be honest here it's unlikely the majority of Scots agree with this draconian measure, however just like England or indeed the UK as a whole there is a deliberate and underlying agenda at work and it's not going stop until a bigger resistance makes its voice heard. Seems voting for any political party is a joke these days so that's a bust!

Been occupied for hundreds years

This is exactly why we don't outlaw speech. 'He said she said' doesn't hold up in a fair and ethical society

As Benjamin Franklin once said, " Whoever would overthrow the liberty of a nation must begin by subduing the freeness of speech." But another observation best suits those "sheeple" who continure to support the current idiocy prevalent in todays "woke" world: "The obedient always think of themselves as virtuous instead of cowardly."

A certain amount of obedience to the law is needed for a functioning society. The way to stop people obeying the law is to stop them respecting the law. The way to stop people respecting the law is to stop enforcing the law equally or to have laws that favour a blessed minority over the majority of ordinary people.@@wyattfamily8997

Poor Police Scotland, the will be vilified when they have to deal with idiots who report a member of their family or ex for saying something in a private setting

​@@richardliversidge8269and while the police are busy pursuing this nonsense drug dealers will be blatantly conducting business in plain sight, pedophiles will be ignored and you won't be visited after a burglary....the country will only become more lawless!!!

there are a great many under-educated, 'blind and stupid' individuals out there. yep.

@@gw2780 Be Quiet!!

⁠@@gw2780 You’re thinking you’re being funny?

The English have NEVER HARMED MODERN SCOTLAND the way this shower have. Not in my seventy years.

North Scotland acutely fella . Our flag will soon have a hint of green and the moon 🌙 and the star ⭐️.

North Korea have more rights than most on earth Don’t believe the Zionist Jew globalist propaganda

Hamas Yuseless 😂😂

Hamas Useless - has a nice ring to it, like Liz Truss and lettuce

Best avoid Glasgow at all costs anyway ( that's the home of Hamas Yuseless and his tribe).

@@gw2780wow. Why not ask this person to clarify what was said before shouting racist. Your all that’s wrong with the country. Something not suiting you shout racist. Someone sitting on a seat on a bus before you and not giving you the seat shout racist. Why can’t people just live and let live? If you want to move to another country then go through the appropriate channels and then integrate when you get there. Wake up.

Of course, Marxism and communism is virtuous in their eyes, but it's worse than that a subjective lie will be acceptable, and an objective truth will be hate speech.

They are introducing a tourist tax for camper vans, please don’t come up here and make my country Bankrupt!

No tourist money for islamic countries. That’s why. What a shame, I wanted to see some of your fascinating historical sites. Thinking it might be seen as against islam to visit memorials of blasphemers against the (now suddenly) state ideology sickens me but I cannot risk that.

Just stay in englaza. That's what it's about,we don't want englazans he re. You not welct,we politely tolerate you,but we really hate yo u,the million or so in Scotland to escape the cultural enrichment happening in englaza and vote against us and the free things you come for prescriptions, personal care etc

YES. DON'T come to Scotland. Please don't

@@davie8906 yes davie you can sit in yer wee clachan toasting yer bannocks by the light of the peat fire flame. Oh sorry ye can't due to carbon emissions.

You cant go out for dinner with your friends without commiting hate speech? 🤣🤣🤣

Some nosey gits will grass you up if they overhear nasty words. Then a bunch of cops will burst into the restaurant and arrest you and your friends for upsetting said nosey gits.

@@digitalzips I love the victim complex here

"For heavens sake"?! Englazan detected! 😆

No they can't arrest and imprison everybody, BUT they can be selective about it.

@@apiscator444 And they can cause a person to walk around with his/her head in the crook of his/her arm...

​@@TesseRact7228 you get it!

When the police arrive, create a MASSIVE crowd with your neighbourhood, muslims do this and the cops scarper.

They can close your bank account get you sacked and ruin your life though.

What political opponents and comedians?

@@scottkosmos Feminist campaigner Marion Millar was arrested over a picture of a suffragette ribon, and Count Dankula was convicted for his video about a dog.

@@scottkosmos Craig Murray.

No offence, but where in the world would you go where this nonsense wouldn't eventually catch up to you?

​@@billyballoonhead.6734wow!! Could you tell us what you said please? And what the result was?

Exactly. Well put.

No wonder! It’s an absolute s**t hole! More litter than wildlife these days. The people choose to live and rook in their own s**t!

Good. Just stay in englaza then

Define hate. Are memes and jokes or sarcasm hateful? Absolute madness.

Wasn't it the New Zealand ex Prime Minister.?

The Australian human rights commissioner has destroyed his grift by remaining silent over 'gas the jews' and all the other genocide talk. Anti-racist means anti-white. Everyone else can say what they want.

@@johnrogers5399 . NZ Hate bill gone for now. Delia Morris

Maybe it’s time to take things seriously and look at what’s happening to our country. The fun’s over and the gloves must come off.

Thank fk you're not in englza? Muslime majority towns and cities with child enrichment gangs operating freely for decades. Imma right?!

That's true,but he's a Scot. The one from englaza Labour boss,sounds like hes straight off the boat. Pakistani gibberish

Yep, he opened the door... just imagine how much worse it will get with Starmer in charge. Just vote the SNP out. Vote for a Party that is actually Scottish and cares about us Scots and Scotland. I know who I'm voting for, and it's not the SNP nor the Unionists.

You mean Sir Tony Blair. Didn't you know that the establishment that ignores us honoured him.

Vote for the Scottish Family Party!

@@graememorris7820 And Starmer is an Establishment man. Beware.

@@timmyboyproductions3947Nope, religious extremists. Every woman has a natural right to abortion, there are many factors as to why it is a necessary right too. Harassing women is not on. Vote for a Party which is actually for Scots and Scotland, that means no SNP nor Unionists.

England when labour get in.

It'll end up like englaza ,they've voted in a pro sharia no to wasteminster

@@christinehomer2185 It's already happening in England as well. Over a million 'legal' immigrants came in to the UK in general last year alone apart from all the illegal ones piling in on a daily basis and treated like royalty and that is under the Tories.

Lawrence Fox dosen't like chickens 🐔

As should Humza Useless for his hate speech

Their Engineers were sound

Because of that, there will be centres throughout the country, one of which will be an LGBT sex shop in Glasgow.

​@@dominochappinwhat would they sell that an ordinary sex shop wouldn't? Just curious lol 😆

Vote for a party that is actually Scottish and cares about us Scots and Scotland. I know who I'm voting for, and it's not the SNP nor the Unionists.

Me too. But I will not stop speaking my mind in my own home. Are they going to bug our homes. Really lost the plot What are rest of the SNP MSPs doing about this?

@@user-og8lk7wv7h I’d rather not think about that.