Тёмный

加入大灣區令香港前途蒙上陰影?! 香港前途將會...陶傑看經融(中文字幕) 20190429 

Sun Channel
Подписаться 540 тыс.
Просмотров 150 тыс.
50% 1

大灣區機遇討論得火紅火熱,但大灣區對香港的未來是好定是壞呢?點解會話加入大灣區令香港前途蒙上陰影?到底影響香港啲咩呢?

Опубликовано:

 

14 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 199   
@kinfan8523
@kinfan8523 5 лет назад
分析透徹,不愧為香港才子。
@hkmachi
@hkmachi 5 лет назад
多謝分享~真係拭目以待~
@sweetieip
@sweetieip 5 лет назад
陶傑只是发表他的观点。他不一定是对的。不过聪明的政治层会采纳别人批评而改出更好的策略。 10 年后我们再回顾吧。
@minkeiken1
@minkeiken1 5 лет назад
10年后證明是錯的。陶傑不一定是對的;大灣區也不一定是對的
@yiliu5606
@yiliu5606 5 лет назад
Swee Tie Ip 我霉油炸锅看过他发表的都是偏激和短见,如果香港以这种人为有见地,那就是悲哀
@sweetieip
@sweetieip 5 лет назад
@@yiliu5606 他算不偏激的了。
@yiliu5606
@yiliu5606 5 лет назад
Swee Tie Ip 胡说八道居多
@littleredbook2882
@littleredbook2882 5 лет назад
若果有得揀, 一個係美國矽谷, 送美國綠咭及US passport, 另一個是中国大湾区矽谷, 送中国護照及内地居民身份證, 会揀边個 ???
@WingKai
@WingKai 5 лет назад
梗係大灣區
@littleredbook2882
@littleredbook2882 5 лет назад
@Wing Kai 真係?我就“暗簡”本外國护照, 手揸另一本. 看看人行長, 易先生, 早年居美, 个仔born in USA;佢自己手揸住嘅, 应該係外交护照, 如果只係公務护照,就不成体統! 中國人, 你最懂的!😆👏👍
@何晔-g6y
@何晔-g6y 5 лет назад
可是美国没有市场啊。所以大家都要来中国创业,因为市场在这里。去美国只能做高级打工仔了。
@wongalan8062
@wongalan8062 5 лет назад
何晔 哇 咁你講 個個都係馬雲啦 你個強國人又唔見你e+入十大富豪榜 加上美國打公仔既福利都好過你班 中國鐵血工廠打工仔啦 幾多中國人農村人黎大城市咪一樣做苦力 最最最起碼啊 美國都有人權憲法 勞工法 你中國有咩啊 雜種憲法 小熊維尼唔高興 你就係叛國 叛黨 不愛毛xx啦 係中國做咩有錢啊 做五毛 村霸好過啦
@littleredbook2882
@littleredbook2882 5 лет назад
@@wongalan8062 做到馬雲又如何?刹那風光, 之後便要交出 “阿爸”, 叫你知所進退, 你就要急流引退喇, 唔好要爺爺講第二次 !港人要前車可鑑!
@asas-ni1mf
@asas-ni1mf 5 лет назад
Your channel is good, Pls keep up the good work :)
@風清揚-e9e
@風清揚-e9e 5 лет назад
香港的很多年輕人真是不學無術,很多人什麼都不懂,聽一些腦殘的政治人物幾句似是而非的說辭,就被洗腦,接下來就是毫無理據的謾罵,好像他們罵過癮了就對了一樣,就這樣的眼光和素質,怪不得會被淘汰。他們永遠不懂政治人物靠的就是陰謀獲取利益,明知道對手做的對,他也一定會反對來獲取自己想要的利益,那些聽信他的人,最終都會付出代價。
@jackyue8584
@jackyue8584 5 лет назад
所以不能相信民賤联工賊会等保皇走狗政棍,他们的主子是匪共头孑,香港人要保持头腦清醒.
@為什麼你辣摸可愛
@為什麼你辣摸可愛 5 лет назад
也不是這樣說的,自古媒體都是必爭之地,要得民心就要控制媒體,大陸在香港也控制不少媒體,若說僅憑幾個youtuber就能控制「無腦」香港年輕人,香港市場自由,媒體亦是,正反皆有,那麼就便是大陸反控制的媒體技不如人,說服不了廣大的香港年輕民眾 文人從來如此,如果不是這樣唐時不會有牛李相爭,宋時不會有朋黨等 況且無論是香港還是大陸,百姓的意見也不見得有多重要,這些朋黨相爭,最多的也不過是百姓茶後話題,真正掌權也不見得是這些媒體或者是百姓
@TungA-r5q
@TungA-r5q 5 лет назад
9:40部分我不大認同,有本書叫“Bad Blood”就是一個例子。 “2014年,伊丽莎白·霍姆斯所创立的企业希拉洛斯由于其革命性的血液检测技术--在一滴血上进行两百多项专业检测--在短短十年间成长为硅谷最具商业价值的独角兽公司。霍姆斯本人更是跻身全美四百大富豪榜,入选《时代》杂志影响全球的百大人物,一跃成为硅谷第一位亿万女性创业家。希拉洛斯的身后隐藏着豪华阵容的董事会成员--美国前国务卿乔治·舒尔茨、亨利·基辛格,媒体大亨鲁伯特·默多克,甲骨文创始人拉里·埃里森,传奇创投家唐纳德·卢卡斯等。就在人们期待着希拉洛斯成长为下一个苹果或者谷歌时,一个真相逐渐显现--希拉洛斯所声称的革命技术是假的,这个商业神话内核的只有一个,那就是谎言。” 當然上述只係一個例子,但係我只想話其實黎D野邊到都有,只係美國比較少。
@tcesourl3221
@tcesourl3221 5 лет назад
陶杰老咗,仲不留余力,可敬。
@rickychiu8032
@rickychiu8032 5 лет назад
你冇老咩
@yfung4140
@yfung4140 5 лет назад
林有冇訪問過 Redwood city 至 San Jose 一帶先?
@Alex-oy4oo
@Alex-oy4oo 5 лет назад
經常提鄧小平講了什麼,江澤民講了什麼, 習近平講了什麼。 廢話 !! 他們都是共產黨 ,共產黨講嘅說話 ,一個字都不能信,這是歷史教訓 !! 請問 中英協議如何? 世貿協議又如何 ?瞓醒覺未呀?
@tsechunming3800
@tsechunming3800 5 лет назад
Happy Life 正硧完全正確
@wuwaibun8893
@wuwaibun8893 5 лет назад
不如國民黨過黎?假設中華民國收香港會點?想試吓咯😂
@rogertam3425
@rogertam3425 5 лет назад
你的資訊很適合。
@pacoouyang8754
@pacoouyang8754 5 лет назад
陶生,如果不加入大湾区,拿香港出路又将会是什么?
@yiqingwu3053
@yiqingwu3053 5 лет назад
印度的人才留美了,怎么没看见多少人回国?我做为一个89年生的人,我见过的几乎所有留洋的,拿国外身份的。不是回国了就是和中国有关系的啦。而且这教授说的好像在中国不能创业一样的。。。马云是政府北京吗?我不是什么专业财政人士,我都知道中国的白手起家的人网易的老板原来养猪的!马云中国传奇啦~百度李红彦有政府背景?老干妈是搞不公平竞争来的吗?教授你敢留言回答我这些问题吗
@michaelchung9457
@michaelchung9457 5 лет назад
回歸的香港🇭🇰點會是97前的hk
@kamannmoore6168
@kamannmoore6168 5 лет назад
講得好好
@安仔-w5z
@安仔-w5z 5 лет назад
有錢佬嚇走晒啦! 有理想嘅人拉九晒啦! 頂尖人材趕走晒啦! 剩底只有陶生呢D就退休嘅人、我呢D無學識嘅人、同林鄭呢D咁能叻嘅人。咁究竟應該邊D人去大彎區呢?人材又無、錢又無、良好制度你又無、咁又話搞乜搞物、成班人係咪黐缐架?
@唔講得-u6h
@唔講得-u6h 5 лет назад
其實佢 真係識咩叫做經濟同政治? (我無言)
@zhangweidong1177
@zhangweidong1177 5 лет назад
硅谷的华人基本无论如何努力都没有升职的。华人很难融入他们
@Johnny.deeeeeep
@Johnny.deeeeeep 5 лет назад
分辨五毛好簡單,點入距地名稱去你會發現系冇任何資料 然後你就會發現,香港youtube被老共翻牆滲透
@Johnny.deeeeeep
@Johnny.deeeeeep 5 лет назад
@屈德肺 你沒有罵我們啊,我也很愛你們,一見到簡體字就想提醒你們,你們主子快要被老美滅了,你們這些走狗記得要陪葬哦
@冥侦探夜沐
@冥侦探夜沐 5 лет назад
@屈德肺 而我们也被共洗脑了 我比较中立 都各退一步。一国两制也是为了让他们慢慢适应
@dixianyang942
@dixianyang942 5 лет назад
Norris Li 无语的傻逼
@zoooinsingapore
@zoooinsingapore 5 лет назад
Yayaya, you are right, no change is the best for hk.
@jackyyao6006
@jackyyao6006 5 лет назад
不去试试,怎么知道不会成为下一个硅谷呢?
@何晔-g6y
@何晔-g6y 5 лет назад
粗粗看了下,就是人太老了,头脑还停留在20年前。现在是资本的竞争,市场的竞争,开放度的竞争。香港应该有年轻的头脑,敢于创新,敢于闯荡,如果听这样一位老年人的想法,那香港的未来很可怕。
@luisgui6832
@luisgui6832 5 лет назад
Not joining would make Hong Kong much more marginalised.
@alglin6237
@alglin6237 5 лет назад
陶傑說關於華爾街評估投資風險並不全對. Theranos 的 創辦人, 19 歲的Elizabeth Holmes, 大學沒有讀完就可以得到數以億美元的投資,就是因為她父親的關係.Christian Holmes 是Enron 前 Vice President. 後來又在美國政府高層任職. 根本全家都是騙子. Wikipedia 這樣說: "The early credibility of Theranos was in part interpreted as an effect of Holmes's personal connections and ability to recruit the support of influential people including Henry Kissinger, Bill Clinton, George Shultz,.." Bill Clinton 還特意上電視介紹 Elizabeth Holmes 為最年輕的科技天材及 entrepreneur. 其實為財無義,古今中外都是一樣態度. 不同者,在中國,有權有勢,可以逍遙法外. 在美國,還是有一點兒司法公正的.
@黄晓彬-v5o
@黄晓彬-v5o 5 лет назад
會不會杞人憂天?能理解陶先生擔心的是,到大陸投資的資金會被洗白后逃到美國。而美國硅谷受制華爾街沒地方逃..作為吃瓜群眾,我想當今社會最聰明的是錢而不會是人。當然我的水平不高,只是抱著言論自由的心態,望見諒
@dixianyang942
@dixianyang942 5 лет назад
其实啦,华为技术好不好啦,也不是我们吹的,是美国人吹的。我们也没有想到我们华为要引起美国这么大的关注,而且还把人家女儿抓啦!
@劉-s7o
@劉-s7o 5 лет назад
加入大灣區?香港無前途,依家香港又有前途咩?🤔🤔🐒🐒🐒💩💩💩💩
@grosu4750
@grosu4750 5 лет назад
劉美珠 死猪不怕开水烫的意思吗
@uuyu01
@uuyu01 5 лет назад
政治是经济的派生物,永远是服从与经济的,香港人如果葬送了自己的经济,还玩什么政治呢?而香港如果主动切断和母国的经济联系,还有什么经济优势呢?认真想想97之前香港经济是如何腾飞的,因为那时的香港是中国唯一对外开放的中转站。没有母国的市场作为动力,国外的公司为什么要选择香港上市,为什么要把香港作为货物集散地。
@siyinHo
@siyinHo 5 лет назад
@pangjoe3027
@pangjoe3027 5 лет назад
之前聽過香港的中藥港數碼港啦, 而家見到D咩呀!!又玩呢招騙港人,唔會再信你特區政府啦啦!!!
@toku7827
@toku7827 5 лет назад
數碼港 中藥港 是老懵董特首 明益商家的決定 從沒有相信過 跟大陸所說的大灣區完全不同
@ericwong8950
@ericwong8950 5 лет назад
數碼港被李嘉誠父子玩成了房產港,後來又來中藥港 大家都怕了,怕變成第二個數碼港
@maymi372
@maymi372 5 лет назад
陶先生的言論及分析每次都一針見血。香港政府如今還有什麼誠信可言?林鄭只顧擦習總的鞋,上任以來,那有真正為香港著想過?什麼大灣區,明日大嶼等等。。通通只為呃錢。香港就快比佢攪死!
@xsuper6086
@xsuper6086 5 лет назад
@@maymi372 祝香港赶快死
@edenz7879
@edenz7879 5 лет назад
很中肯。最怕大湾区和其他政府项目一样虎头蛇尾。
@alexzhang2898
@alexzhang2898 5 лет назад
上海发展快因为有长江三角洲做腹地,深圳发展快因为有珠江三角洲做腹地,新加坡发展快因为有东南亚做腹地。香港现在有什么?建大湾区还不是因为帮香港找增长点?香港拥抱大湾区,股市马上飘红,嘴上不要,脚还是诚实的。
@chanfranc
@chanfranc 5 лет назад
呀爺祇會利用你發展的科技用來控制人民不准作反,誰批評政府的,與外國有聯繫的,散播不啱聽言論的,或稍有不聽話的,就要你無處立足,佢個全國網絡一定找到你!
@区木嘴
@区木嘴 5 лет назад
内地批评政府是常事,唔了解无响度都吠
@hingkongkwan4693
@hingkongkwan4693 5 лет назад
解散現在政府架構,省回很多錢,不用香港警察,只用廣東省公安廳及政法糸统,簡單多了。
@Im.RealMAN
@Im.RealMAN 5 лет назад
香港被加入大灣區,令香港失去其特色,走向衰亡!
@yatpangko3823
@yatpangko3823 5 лет назад
RealMAN Zhu 如果香港唔入大灣區 就真正自己淘汰自己
@Im.RealMAN
@Im.RealMAN 5 лет назад
@@yatpangko3823 最近去過大陸的大灣區嗎?
@dbsse7503
@dbsse7503 5 лет назад
带着香港玩,是看得起你。没香港,大陆一样可以玩。香港敢不敢试试跟大陆切断一切经济往来?看看没有大陆,香港能发展成什么样子?
@Im.RealMAN
@Im.RealMAN 5 лет назад
@@dbsse7503 在大陸還是貧窮的時代,那時的香港已經是經濟起飛的四小龍了! 你好像都不知道吧?!
@Im.RealMAN
@Im.RealMAN 5 лет назад
@@dbsse7503 沒有香港這個後門,中國就得不到美帝的最高端科技。(你國借香港高校名義購買美帝最高端科技科研設備) 不過,你皇習帝自己想封死後門,美帝會成全他的。終止《香港關係法》,取消香港獨立關稅地位,以及即將通過的《香港民主及人權法》(制裁香港的專制官員),夠習帝享用多年了!
@rayraygor
@rayraygor 5 лет назад
等阿7畫隻咁大個餅出嚟,車公已經講左唔work. 不如打造亞洲矽膠中心仲快賺,全球d人都嚟隆胸呀,整鼻呀。仲好啦,反正個個都咁鐘意表面嘢,又要靚。隨時帶旺埋旅遊業添!
@lagunadeseca
@lagunadeseca 5 лет назад
We can look at other successful countries to set a model, however, we can also engineer our own miracle. Nazi Germany and Soviet Union did not have Western style of freedom or democracy yet they still pioneered some of the most advanced technologies at the time. Given China's great pool of talents and the Chinese society's eagerness towards new technology we should not doubt China's ability to create leading technologies. Who would have thought just 10 years back that Huawei would become a global company in the smart phone industry just behind Apple and Google? Who would have thought 10 years ago that Shenzhen would surpass Hong Kong in GDP, and that it would become China's Silicon Valley with great growth potential still untapped? Hong Kong may have cemented it's place as the financial hub of Asia under British rule, but in today's global economy, smarter living and utilisation of new technologies for everyday use are the focus of growth, wealth, and global competitive advantage. City state economies cannot compete with global powers! Hong Kong should consider itself lucky to be included in the Greater Bay Zone economy to enable it to use it's competitive advantage to drive further growth in the Zone and in turn benefit itself. If you grow the cake bigger then you get a bigger share too! If it doesn't accept this role and isolate itself it will just become irrelevant and fall from grace quicker than you think. Just look at how much Taiwan declined over the last 25 years as a result of this attitude, now they have democracy but are no longer rich, if it keeps this up for long it might get stuck in the middle income trap just like some South America countries are.
@g600f700
@g600f700 5 лет назад
What you said about some technology from one/two countries is similar to looking at a star vs looking at a galaxy. First, forget about the country level, if you want to design a game for people to make money, you need to have a fair game rules. Once these rules are set, more and more people will join. There will be some people don't like to play and they are free to leave. This is the building blocks of a money making game. When you want to start a new game, company or even a country, ask yourself " how do I design so that 1, most people have a chance to make money 2, most people like to stay 3, not only for one generation, it will work for other generations 4, it last a long time. 5, other empires like Roman empires, chinese dynasties, Egyptians...etc what are the reasons they failed? What can we learn from them? I am sure some people will disagree and if they have a better idea, feel free to explain how it's better. My 2 cents.
@lagunadeseca
@lagunadeseca 5 лет назад
@@g600f700 My comments mainly focus on the practicality of the state run economy such as China's using Nazi Germany and Soviet Union as reference, as they had a similar centralised power regime like China's, yet were similarly successful on the technological front. Their collapse were brought about not by their centralised way of ruling but by war and Facism (Germany), and failed economical reforms (Soviet Union). The point is that these examples show that centralised ways of ruling do not fail innovation or technological advances. Given China is a civilisation state with a modern system of rule at only 70 years young, so long as it remain stable with a focus on the core technologies and the right policy reforms it will surely thrive. It is true that China is not as open politically and does not have complete freedom of speech but given time and development it will surely improve. The west as we know it today such as the US had racial segregation policies up to the 1970's, it is only through constant improvements overtime that they achieved today's freedom. Likewise, China will improve overtime.
@ttssinmood9677
@ttssinmood9677 5 лет назад
@@lagunadeseca ...I am sorry...HK had been tripped and dream the fantastic as YOUR thinking since the HAHDOVER..Now,,what's happenings in H K in the last six years....the whole world seen it...!!
@lagunadeseca
@lagunadeseca 5 лет назад
@@ttssinmood9677 It is true that Hong Kong is counting on China to improve and in turn benefit HK. The disappointment lies in the fact that Chinese cities such as Shenzhen thrived more rapidly over the last couple of decades than Hong Kong, and that Hong Kong doesn't have democratic elections to enable it to do what they want. Yet again neither did Hong Kong have democratic freedom under British rule, but Hong Kong was still able to achieve it's miracle back then. The only exception is China has become stronger, being the 2nd largest economy and still booming. Though I too like Hong Kong and it's culture and influence in the hay days, I think it must wake to the new reality which is that you need to cooperate with China to gain your next wave of growth. Otherwise the resentment and declining attitude will bring HK down... It will be sad to one day see HK being surpassed by Singapore due to this resentment. HK has far too many reasons and advantages to thrive so much better than Singapore, Singapore couldn't even dream of swapping places with HK and be in the Greater Bay Zone, as they know that with the right implementation they will thrive, Singapore couldn't dream of Malaysia or it's closer neighbors to give it anything close to this advantage!
@mattc688
@mattc688 5 лет назад
美國成功因素是其本身自我糾正的能力, 而這種能力源於容許對抗力量存在, 鼓勵制衡力量check & balance.中國不容異議, 要為自己的錯誤不斷付巨大代價.
@tatchunglau5618
@tatchunglau5618 5 лет назад
中國開始發展行正路嘅時間有幾多年?美國又行咗幾多年?😍如果美國真係咁勁,點解呢幾年冇咩超重大突破?反而係中國長年出現風口位😍
@mattc688
@mattc688 5 лет назад
@@tatchunglau5618中國嘅發展都係利用他國的思維,技術,和經驗而成, 自己沒有建立發展能力, 他國是經過300年不斷投入, 積累失敗經驗一點點而成, 這種能力會不斷發展更新, 中國已經到了跟他國很接近的水平, 他國開始警覺不讓中國得到先進技術, 中國只會再被拋離. 中國的大進步是傾全國之力去做, 固然是有效率, 但亦會因沒有自我糾正的能力而必須付出極大仳代價去彌補, 中國壓抑思想, 把創造力也壓了下去
@tatchunglau5618
@tatchunglau5618 5 лет назад
@@mattc688 你覺得14億人嘅國家咁快就改變得曬?要循序漸進架。當年文化大革命冇留低教訓嘅?仲有創造力問題,如果講科技,背後係要講專利係屬於邊個,仲有就係得到呢個專嘅方式,如果日日話抄,你覺得係歐洲美國有業務嘅公司唔畀人告?如果你話影視遊戲呢類,我個人都要批評一番,特別係19廣電局,有啲太過一刀切
@samsanng7974
@samsanng7974 5 лет назад
加入大灣區,肯定更加衰!
@yimlee2533
@yimlee2533 5 лет назад
僕街有份呀!,想成為矽谷樣樣都輸打贏要樣樣都要叻呢個世界真是你個僕街玩曬咩?。
@robothugo8549
@robothugo8549 5 лет назад
哎,真的是对大陆的高科技互联网产业一点都不理解,香港在大湾区就是一个辅助角色,深圳才是核心,看看大疆吧。
@joelai1760
@joelai1760 5 лет назад
陶傑又在胡說八道,請不要評論一D自已完全不知道的事,又不肯花時間找资料。所說一切真是笑死IT人。
@tatlei1670
@tatlei1670 5 лет назад
反對政府就係有罪囉,由古代也是如此,到清代時更嚴重,對朝廷唔满者就係反清,是异己者就有罪,係黑社會,反賊,反清革命者被清廷鎭壓通揖殺頭,到了民國北洋政府對异己者一様是反賊,一樣打壓坐牢殺頭,蔣介石北伐到逹上海搞清黨運動,對异己者當赤黨查辦,進行拘捕打殺,中共推翻國民政府對异己者如同一轍,可憐的中華大地幾千年來從未有過言論自由,自主人權,民主的一天。
@alglin6237
@alglin6237 5 лет назад
About 20 years ago, when HuaWei started a new office in California, they contacted me in the East Coast and asked me to be their consultant in acquiring US intellectual properties. In particular, they were interested in terabit routers and network processors. I put together a small team from MIT and Harvard to do the research for them. To make a long story short, my impression of HuaWei was they did not seem to know much about the Internet and Telecom technologies. But that was 20 years ago. HuaWei is probably better now. Still, the Chinese ought to invest more efforts in fundamental research, instead of relying on Western technology. Their R&D infrastructure is pretty weak. Early in my career, I was with BB&N (Bolt, Beranek, and Newman) where my colleagues invented the Internet. For many years, I did technical consulting for a number of major telecom companies. I know the industry very well. I don't understand the hoopla surrounding this 5G technology. 5G is convenient for playing online games or downloading movies, not much else. It is laughable to think it will make an impact in military applications, which require completely different standards from civilian networking protocols. For that matter, check this out: "該波形稱為第5代先進訓練波形(5GATW)已由馬塞諸薩技術學院林肯實驗室研發,並在9月進行了最後的試飛,實驗中,該波形在地面站和2架飛機間傳遞了儘可能多的數據 ". Search online, and you will see the full story. 5GATW was designed and developed by my team (Tactical Airborne Networking Group) at the MIT Lincoln Lab over 3 years ago. The project was sponsored by the US Navy. We delivered the working prototype to Cubic, which turned it into a functional system for deployment. Our lab is a research institute; our job is to demonstrate a proof-of-concept, not to build products. Since then, we have moved onto more advanced research and technology. I, and my MIT colleagues' opinion is 5G is mostly hype. It might work in densely populated cities, but at a cost. In remote, wide-open areas with small populations, because of its short wavelength, it is not a viable solution. I think the future of wireless communications is in airborne infrastructures, such as small, low-flying satellites and space stations. Our lab started working on the airborne technology over 10 years ago. The reason Elon Musk's SpaceX exists is to help us launch these internet satellites. I truly don't understand why some people think the Chinese might have an edge over the US in communications technology. Perhaps I can paraphrase 鄭經翰: "你不認識華為就被它嚇死. 你認識華為就被它笑死."
@alexanderchen5538
@alexanderchen5538 5 лет назад
制度我不知道,大湾区人才一定要印度的?大陆培养的理工科人才不够?这点解释下?一个国家自己培养人才自己用才是正道!一个国家培养人才给别国用,一个国家老是靠别国的人才。我是不是说这两个国家都没前途?
@au4stevepau
@au4stevepau 5 лет назад
陶傑d分析無中過一次
@marcorubio3388
@marcorubio3388 5 лет назад
他就是死包着教条不放,废话连篇,深圳的发展把这傻逼的脸都打成屁股了,LOL
@wesleyqwe8345
@wesleyqwe8345 5 лет назад
一讲到大陆,陶先生噶理智逻辑全部唔见晒
@ronnyrong641
@ronnyrong641 5 лет назад
大湾区实则就系同化香港,慢慢融合香港。毕竟宜家香港人还系比较自傲,出国过关时候居然还排去外国人区,最后俾人赶翻去中国公民区,有时候觉得香港人有点幼稚得可爱,还未清楚宜家的形势,不过好快估计就会彻底变成真正的中国人了,有钱人还系趁早移民吧,迟早一日都会沦陷。
@chungqk
@chungqk 5 лет назад
見到咁多五毛我就放心相信了
@miuswn1160
@miuswn1160 5 лет назад
看到这么多脑残废青我也放心了
@eol5215
@eol5215 5 лет назад
五加入大湾区,香港被边缘化就对香港好好?香港有今日系靠前几辈人努力出来噶,如果靠你个口水佬,就惨咯
@八十万水军教头
@八十万水军教头 5 лет назад
香港号称自由港 仰赖的是周边尤其是大陆的不自由 随着大陆以及越南等东南亚的自由 随着中国大陆自身开放的需要 尤其是西方国家的要求同香港一样的所谓自由(金融等) 香港的没落不可避免 害死香港的 还包括来自西方国家要求中国大陆的和香港一样的自由 既然一样了 要你香港干嘛 香港的硬件是没有优势的也不在金融贸易运输的支点 有辐射的能力完全仰赖周边的缺失。
@wonghing5478
@wonghing5478 5 лет назад
97 前的香港是什么? 要正香港人才知道.这是書無得读.飯無得吃年代.我等有机流浪到外国做差俚半工读是万幸.今日的一班政治口水老是吹水.今曰中国強做华侨的才能领悟.
@yc2861
@yc2861 5 лет назад
林鄭根本未入班
@Msccube
@Msccube 5 лет назад
Tao said that silicon valley is so creative. Someone thinks about opening a web-site to let home owner to rent out their home to travelers. Wall Street has at once input ton of money and the web-site becomes Airbnb. China cannot do this. Does he know that years ago, a young guy called Ma played so many video games to a point that he developed a big tech giant called TenCent? Ma did not even get the money from Wall Street. So Ma is more powerful than those guys in silicon valley. Does Tao know that a young student from U of Hong Kong of Science and Technology built a drone in the U for his thesis and the drone was further developed to be the DJI company, a huge international company controlling the drone market. This student did not get the Wall Street money and so he is more powerful than silicon valley. Does Tao know that Facebook's Zuckerberg went to China to learn how to use an App, WeChat to send money or paying bill. Zuckerberg is trying to repeat the same in USA. Does Tao know that in the world, China has the second largest number of Unicorn in the world, next to USA? Does Tao know that Hong Kong does not have even one Unicorn? By the way, does Tao know what a Unicorn is? If not, please go to China to learn about it before you speak in this channel. Thanks.
@jerry-hh9dm
@jerry-hh9dm 5 лет назад
1.这个人对大陆的一切先入为主的不信任。华为5G目前确实是全世界领先,但他还是觉得西方厉害。 2.香港要破局,就要经济多元化,加入大湾区未来对香港来说肯定是有好处的。可他首先看到确实边界,法律这些问题。只要想进步,办法总比困难多。而不是像你这样,目空一切,抱足不前。 香港多几个像你这样空口白牙的文人,前途好让人担忧啊。思维局限,自带偏见。
@xiangli5582
@xiangli5582 5 лет назад
你是愿意被民主国家监视,还是独裁国家监视,就那么简单
@mmaaiissee1
@mmaaiissee1 5 лет назад
以前好崇拜陶生, 現在覺得佢好乞人憎.
@godfather7762
@godfather7762 5 лет назад
大灣區就是出賣香港呢
@chunlamszeto9640
@chunlamszeto9640 5 лет назад
够中行,分釋得透切,搞什么港,什么园,什么湾,套個好听的名字口號式宣傳,電视日日播引道一班年青小伙子入窿,共產党最劣是宣傳,因它政权也是这样夺回來。哈哈哈哈哈
@wing4725
@wing4725 5 лет назад
真係搞錯嗮,宜家唔係林鄭要打造大灣區,而係香港點樣融入大灣區。 最後佢講嘅幾個問題,有如人生一樣,係唔係宜家冇,將來就冇? 宜家冇,就唔需要開始? 人一出世乜都唔識就唔使做人? 陶生喺po嘢之前請先做吓功課,再唔係返學校再讀多幾年書補充一下自己嘅知識同分析力。 觀點同立場都錯嗮。
@hunglo341
@hunglo341 5 лет назад
大灣區咪就係開荒牛,剩係識得叫香港人去做開荒牛。
@leongoui5293
@leongoui5293 5 лет назад
广东成立特别行政区可解决
@leongoui5293
@leongoui5293 5 лет назад
@@pertayiiliu5832 完成之后你全家老衬?
@dixianyang942
@dixianyang942 5 лет назад
美国拍 泰坦尼克号时不是说,让妇女和儿童先走吗?结果先拿我们妇女儿童开刀!
@soulongwang9712
@soulongwang9712 5 лет назад
所谓的香港才子仍然对现时的大陆投资环境这么的无知!或者故意装傻!也难怪香港的年轻人这么容易煽动上街了!这真的是一种悲哀!
@oliverhuang9846
@oliverhuang9846 5 лет назад
???内地政府确实有制定政策指引国家发展的能力,但这位学者似乎忽略了市场在大湾区经济发展中的作用了。深圳、广州的崛起难道只是靠某些官员的一个电话???我觉得这位学者的观点有点以偏概全了。
@chunlamszeto9640
@chunlamszeto9640 5 лет назад
中國有知識産权嗎?研究一背子几十年给你偷了當是你架还要大声甲恶有透明法律基楚嗎?
@dragon123fantasy
@dragon123fantasy 5 лет назад
不加人大湾区香港就有前途了?
@willengel2458
@willengel2458 5 лет назад
host needs to decolonize his brain first. he must've missed the days when hong kong citizens as second class citizen on its own soil.
@bochurick9930
@bochurick9930 5 лет назад
Hongkongers, mainly descendants of Chinese refugees fleeing Communist persecution, didnt mind becoming the second class citizen as you described during the colonial era since they were able to enjoy freedom and human rights that you mainlanders feel envy. The host just tells the truth that stupid patriots find it hard to accept
@yiqingwu3053
@yiqingwu3053 5 лет назад
我就说吧香港人桥也不想要是大湾区也不想要。。。。。。这个教授也不看看90后的中国工程师储备是多少,而且大陆现在留学生回流。干嘛不移民啊这个教授。。。。。觉得中国人都是傻子二货,学历都是假的做不了学术研究,中国的四大发明也是因为古代人比我们智商高两百。搞什么民主运动我都ok啦。看不起我们年轻人和下一代这不是反共就是反中
@hegelg.b7408
@hegelg.b7408 5 лет назад
替其他名嘴們感到悲哀..專業是沒有的!艾~
@hegelg.b7408
@hegelg.b7408 5 лет назад
原來你叫井蛙啊.真悲哀
@xiaoleo275
@xiaoleo275 5 лет назад
唔做中国人就死出国
@siklau5443
@siklau5443 5 лет назад
一入大灣區,即係入左去一個没有法治的地方,如果有事件發生而知道你係香港人,死多2錢重,先屈你10萬8萬再講,如果你係儍仔或是白痴,去哪!哈哈哈哈哈!
@董鑫-s8f
@董鑫-s8f 5 лет назад
这个陶杰被美国那套价值观洗脑的已经傻了,瞎了,连基本事实都看不清
@wing4725
@wing4725 5 лет назад
對經濟,科技,對世界,美國,甚至大灣區一d認識都冇,簡直係語無倫次。
@jofpotier3873
@jofpotier3873 5 лет назад
美国人能行,中国人为什么不行
@张喆-t3w
@张喆-t3w 5 лет назад
陶杰疑似阿尔滋海默症!
@dbsse7503
@dbsse7503 5 лет назад
所谓印度人才算屁啊。中国人才在中国环境下,能力远超印度人。印度人在美国也就是占了语言的便宜。
@lovecat5386
@lovecat5386 5 лет назад
大陸喱!成日自己稱讚自己!面皮幾尺厚!!
@YY-mb8go
@YY-mb8go 5 лет назад
全世界邊個政府經濟唔係由一班富N代官N代操控? 今日先知原來美國冇官商勾結: ) 自由民主原本用來洗班弱智腦 洗洗下西方自己都落左搭
@yiliu5606
@yiliu5606 5 лет назад
你不加入就好了,没有人逼你把,卧槽
@chenjian290
@chenjian290 5 лет назад
怪不得加州有人要闹独立
@1636cltsang
@1636cltsang 5 лет назад
盲毛,德州、紐約州都叫獨立啦。 什麼叫言論自由,去共匪國叫下會點?
@chenjian290
@chenjian290 5 лет назад
不要怕大湾区的天门沔阳人多😜
@yiliu5606
@yiliu5606 5 лет назад
jian da 这里遇见老乡,幸会
@aki925100
@aki925100 5 лет назад
做你的香港梦
@chilo2513
@chilo2513 5 лет назад
眼光短見胡說八道
@WM-mc9ez
@WM-mc9ez 5 лет назад
嘥氣
@hingkongkwan4693
@hingkongkwan4693 5 лет назад
美國不擔心印度偷技術知識。
@kamcha5798
@kamcha5798 5 лет назад
it is simple, if your house has been broke into by burglars, what will you do?
@chrissymoy672
@chrissymoy672 5 лет назад
Kam Cha 好心寫中文啦,你啲英文好肉酸!
@kamcha5798
@kamcha5798 5 лет назад
@@chrissymoy672 you are urgly! Fxxk
@dbsse7503
@dbsse7503 5 лет назад
印度偷回去也做不出来啊。印度做条航母,全世界都给技术,根本不用偷。结果10年还没做出来一条。所以美国放心啊。
@lovecat5386
@lovecat5386 5 лет назад
看來中國人不認為做賊是恥辱!反覺得自己做賊!比印度出色!而很自豪!!
@zhnjqwe5769
@zhnjqwe5769 5 лет назад
蒙面超人,笑x死人!
@岩迩铭治
@岩迩铭治 5 лет назад
有种唔好加入大湾区
@kelwong116
@kelwong116 5 лет назад
有得唔加入就好
@ronaldau3518
@ronaldau3518 5 лет назад
陶傑講咁撚多嘢, 最終都係為搵錢,為揾食, 不敢得罪任何一邊, 日日想兩邊舔盡, 所以乜都係佢講哂 !
@吳知道-f1m
@吳知道-f1m 5 лет назад
吾識經濟,亂up
@wing4725
@wing4725 5 лет назад
突登入嚟聽吓佢有乜廢嘅觀點,不出我所料,真係冇料到。 對文盲嘅人嚟講佢確實係才子。
@云里看雾
@云里看雾 5 лет назад
大湾区其實想資源整合,共贏發展咋,你所憂慮噶,大陸班官員早就清楚
@陈辉-c6d
@陈辉-c6d 5 лет назад
加不加入大湾区,香港都是无前途!过多十年八年,香港最多算是广东的一个二线城市!广东加油!
@bochurick9930
@bochurick9930 5 лет назад
完全贊成睇法 橫掂都係而家即刻取消每日150個單程證限額 又唔使洗萬億填海 又唔使每年招呼六七千萬人嚟買奶粉打疫苗 全國最有錢嘅馬雲馬化騰又唔使麻煩攞香港身份證兼買咁貴山頂樓 廣東加油
@yyw7825
@yyw7825 5 лет назад
濕九才子.
@boscolin5790
@boscolin5790 5 лет назад
正吹水佬
@ivanpan1608
@ivanpan1608 5 лет назад
咪成日五毛五毛,我体你地讲野咁鬼极端,某咩思考能力?
@dr.jackylam1022
@dr.jackylam1022 5 лет назад
學台獨 就沒錢途
@射入你妈子宫
@射入你妈子宫 5 лет назад
點解覺得你好似許冠英呀
@Fuc888
@Fuc888 5 лет назад
乜香港仲有前途可言咩😂
Далее
PUBG Mobile СТАЛ ПЛАТНЫМ! 😳
00:31
Просмотров 95 тыс.
КТО БОИТСЯ КЛОУНОВ?? #shorts
00:20
Просмотров 488 тыс.
PUBG Mobile СТАЛ ПЛАТНЫМ! 😳
00:31
Просмотров 95 тыс.