As a former chinese independent school student, although it would be great to recognize UEC but it is not a must, most people went for UEC and should be prepared that UEC is not recognized by local government universities and most school will offer both SPM and UEC together, so we still have SPM that can be accepted, and we still can go to the private universities. I also agree that actually in chinese school, we hardly use BM and meet people from other ethnicity, and if we don't practise English on ourselves, there's also hardly any occasion that we use English, which makes quite a number of UEC graduate actually not good in English and BM, but still can slowly improve later when go into the university or the society. For me as well, I do recognize myself as a Malaysian, and I respect other ethnic, however I do not really have any friends from ethnicity for now, it's partly my problem as I already get used to playing with friends in the same ethnicity. One of the biggest reason to recognize UEC, I think is to allow chinese education to grow, as the law only allow a total of 60 chinese independent school in entire Malaysia, once UEC is recognized, we can slowly push to have more support in have chinese education to grow, maybe have more chinese independent schools in Malaysia. On the other hand, I actually would wish that one day we can actually talk about abolishing UEC, however that day won't be that soon. We need to understand what is the purpose of UEC, UEC is here because we need a better standard of education syllabus and mostly, we need to preserve chinese education. Alot of parents send their children to chinese independent school either for these 2 reason, and also there's better discipline in chinese independent school. If Malaysia standard education system can do all of these, why do we even need UEC. What I really want for Malaysia education system to improve is that they can improve syllabus, keep up with international standards, make local examination certification widely accepted instead of having STPM only accepted in Malaysia, then preserve all vernacular education within the system. improve the education system quality together with the teacher's quality, lastly abolish the quota system, giving the opportunity to all the talented students regardless of ethnic. At that time, we don't even need to talk about UEC anymore.
if u take a peek to our history, you would know that it's always impossible to give equal opportunity for all ethnic in Malaysia as privileges of Malay and native have been unchangeably written in constitution before independence of Malaysia. According to article 153 of the constitution, it states that Yang di-Pertuan Agong responsibility for "safeguard[ing] the special position of the 'Malays' and natives of any of the States of Sabah and Sarawak and the legitimate interests of other communities" (copy from wikipedia). This article aims to restrict Chinese and other ethnic (other than Malay and indigenous person) from possesing too much wealth to address the socio-economic imbalances between the different ethnic communities after independence at 1957. to sum up, I believe the equality of different ethnic is hardly to achieve as government given the right to only benefit Malay and bumiputera in term of public education, civil services, etc.
Excuse me, STPM is not ONLY being accepted in Malaysia, but also in other countries such as UK, Australia, US. Stop being condescending towards government school graduates. TQ
@@henrylys1350 Boleh, aku Boleh Maki Hamum sesiapa yg Rasis dan Perkauman di video atas Tu, Semua cakap Bahasa Cina, shock sendiri, Semua salah Kerajaan, salah Org Melayu, langsung Takde 1 melayu di forum ini
This is by far best discussion I ever watch on any social media. Why? It helps me understand where we heading towards. I’m a srjkc student, then entered private school(spm syllabus). Then study in Melbourne, now work in Malaysia. Do I support UEC, before I watch this video I am strongly against uec but now I do want to acknowledge brother/sister in uec all the best in their fight. :) Let’s go Malaysia and madani Malaysia.
I've been binge-watching many BBK episodes on your channel, and I am really grateful for the phenomenal content you have been creating, which shed light on many topics that are dear to Malaysians. Keep up the good work, and more Malaysians should be aware of your channel.
Good issues to be discussed and I hope we can see the good decisions made for the sake of Malaysians and not only for Hua community in Malaysia, cheers to all!
我明白bbk是以华文为主的媒体。要知道独中生根国中生的最大分别,Sila minta tetamu anda menjawab dalam bahasa kebangsaan. 我蛮confident他们一开口你们就可以直接分别出谁是国中出来,谁是独中出来的。如果独中没办法把他的学生做到和国中生的国语程度一样就别谈什么承认。身为一个马来西亚人如果自己的国语都说不好,真的不配拿马来西亚护照。 从马来人的看法他们就觉得身为马来西亚人就要以国语为傲。你可以问问几个独中生是觉得马来语重要的。甚至我觉得大部分的马来西亚华人都觉得马来语是个不重要的语言。如果不解决这个问题马来西亚永远达不到真正的团结。 所以sekolah wawasan是唯一的出路。很多马来西亚华人不是说新加坡什么什么好吗?可以建议去看看新加坡是怎样废掉所谓的华教。废弃华教大家在一个学校长大,只需要20-30年过了一代人,大家都会很骄傲的说自己是新加坡人。不管是华人,马来人还是印度人。枪口都一致对外。
一样。Those who go to international school or independent school should understand from early on they have to go college or overseas. Don't fight with us STPM
其實除了 A-level 以外,政府也承認IBDP,IBDP也有以華語為主的教育課綱(還可以選繁體和簡體),獨中轉讀中文的IBDP就解決問題了。當然董總不會那麼做,做了就少了一個政治議題來炒作,最後還是學生吃虧啊 Actually besides IGCSE's A-level, local public universities also recognize IBDP (International Baccalaureate Diploma Programme) from IBO. This syllabus is extremely versatile and it is up to individual schools to decide how they want to adapt the programme to the school's own directive, including doing the programme in Mandarin (Simplified or Transitional). DongZhong could've just built their syllabus on top of the IBDP framework and let the students take the IBDP exam in Mandarin, and the certificate would still be recognized and accepted by local universities.