Please note that I only comment based on my opinion of this video. I also have nothing against all of them. They all are great singers on their own. I just point out that Wheein's voice suits the most in this. I hope everyone understand🙏🏻 thank you😊
@@hasni4413 byul for one getting high note killing parts now. The other kids refining techniques too (e.g you dont see solar bending forward now for high notes unlike during old immortal songs performances; she just straight up does it now the bish got stronger ) theyre all doing something to get better theyre scary good. ❤
@@hasni4413 They certainly can as a group. For example, Moonbyul has been slowly singing more and more often with each comeback. Her trainee audition was actually her singing, not rapping.
I like how he handles the falches perfectly. Here in my country there was a duo called "Sin bandera". One of the two vocalists used that kind of style and they were legendary.
Compared to the old version of I Miss You, I feel this one have more texture, more spicy and very rich which is something incredible as the old version is already sooo good! I can't even imagine how they'll sound would be next year 😭😭😭😭💛💛💛
and byul's rap game has definitely "calmed down" so much. it now sounds so mature, soothing, easy to the ears, yet still badass even more than before. like, HOW?
Between Byul's raps and holding chorus down, Solar's power and sultry notes, Wheein's powerful yet soothing voice and Hwasa's raw emotional vocals and her beautiful falsetto notes this group is so complete. There is no missing link, no black hole and no inconsistencies. Literally the top vocal group of S.Korea. I'm so proud to be a MooMoo.
This song is in Melting album which mean they have been singing this song since MAMAMOO were less then 2 years old as a girl group. Indeed trust & listen to MAMAMOO. Leggo~
@@aceanthonylucero8018 What OP meant was that even as a "rookie" girl group** they were able to sing this song, which relies very heavily on their vocal skills. **Mamamoo debuted in 2014, the "Melting" album came out in 2016 and it included this song.
MAMAMOO = TALENT Also, Wheein blessing my eyes with her perfect visuals and curly blue hair, and blessing my ears with her ethereal vocals and flawless delivery... I can't
@@songoftheyear7046 yeah... When i saw that, i thought "no stage of i miss you is gonna top this." the vocals and rap were AMAZING... then they do this. 😭😍
WhatA Beaut gosh i hate mnet cut style, but i’ve received negative response from the avid viewers. but seriously it’s tiring to see so many reaction shot esp if it’s repetitive
보통 아이돌들의 앨범을 보면 항상 물음표로 자리잡고 있는 가창력을 입증하기 위해 발라드를 트랙으로 하나넣곤 한다. 그러나 오히려 이 발라드트랙이 아이돌들의 진면목으로 보이는게 아닌 그래 아이돌은 가수지만 가수같지않다고 하면서 선호 하지않는 경우가 많은데 마마무는 조금다르다 춤을 출떄도 일정하게 유지되는 음정과 그걸 대입하는 퍼포먼스가 압권이라고 많이들 이야기하지만 각잡고 노래만부를떄 마마무는 그리고 이 4명의 합은 무시무시 할정도로 강한 임팩트를 남긴다. 특히 스케치북은 어떠한 이펙트가 걸리지않은 쌩라이브 무대로 유명하다. 참고로 이노래도 밴드사운드로 편곡을 한거지 원래는 밴드사운드가 아닌데 결국에는 라이브도 휼륭하다는걸 입증한것이다. 그래서 마마무는 아이돌같지않다. 진짜 이렇게 안정적인 아이돌이 몇이나 되는건가. 그래서 마마무는 좀 귀하다고 생각한다.
Solar: powerful vocal Wheein: angelic voice Hwasa: versatile vocal Moonbyul: unique rapper with good balance Aaaaand when they harmonize... They bring heaven
Wheein’s voice is changing for the better everyday istg. She’s so talented. This is my fave song ever and i’m so glad they keep on adding some improvements to it everytime. I’m literally crying bc this is so beautiful
팬은 아닌데 퀸덤에서 이 노래를 우연히 알게 됐는데 너무 좋아요, 더 대박인건 처음 나왔을 때 음원이나 무대 라이브보다 최근 퀸덤이랑 이 무대 라이브가 훨씬 좋다는거 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 계속 성장했단 말이겠죠 음원이 오히려 심심해서 못듣겠는 정도ㅜㅜ 이 노래 주기적으로 방송에서 라이브해줬으면 하는 머글입니다...
예쁜 목소리로 팬들에게 노래,랩 불러주는 마마무 언니들한테 너무 고맙고 이런 노래를 서로의 목소리에 맞게 잘 불러줘서 고맙네요.. 가사랑 멜로디 둘 다 좋은 노래는 너무 오랜만인거 같아요.. 이래서 내가 무무가 됐다지..ㅎ 휘인언니의 초반 가성과 용언니의 가성에만 너무 처지지 않게 진성으로 질러주는 목소리 화사언니의 같은 노래지만 다른 느낌으로 감동주는 화사언니 거기에 별언니의 딕션좋은 랩까지 너무 완벽한 노래에요..
