1 SAMUEL 15 3! Why God Said Slay the Amalekites... "Slay Man & Woman, Infant & Suckling" 

Hi, thank you so much for this video. But I still don’t understand why God would have to “stoop to their level” if you will? Like why order the killing of children? That still just doesn’t seem like a loving God would do something like this. It’s passages like these that really make me question my faith at times. Any help you could give would be greatly appreciated. 🙏

Peace To All you tell me what a loving God would do, if he must execute justice and judgement?

In Thy Word thank you very much for your response! Spare the children? I don’t know? It just seems to be such a barbaric response? Like we wouldn’t want our leaders to do that today in another country? What if one of our leaders said he or she was going to go in and slaughter an entire group of people (including babies) in response to something. People would be outraged I think? And it seems that Jesus in the New Covenant teaches something totally difficult. It is hard for me to reconcile the two covenants. Why are the responses so different? I just can’t understand why Jesus said “love thy enemies” but God in the Old Testament said to slaughter them (in this case). Thank you again so much for any insight you can provide on this. And I mean no disrespect to God by these questions. I am just really grappling with this. Thank you!

@@JesusSaves77799 You said "I don’t know?" but you judge that it is wrong? You don not have a solution but you judged the solution as wrong? These two livestreams will help you: Is God different in the Old Testament and New Testament: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-qilcFOqeJ1o.html My Response to Killing of Babies, Infants & Children in the Bible: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-T9BdL3SVZH0.html

The Amalekites were chronic enemies of God and his chosen people, ancient Israel. The way God dealt with them provides a pattern for the way He will deal with his enemies today! Because of their hardened and unreasonable hostility towards God’s people and because they “did not fear God,” the Amalekites came under a permanent ban. Since they worked in opposition to the purposes of the Universal Sovereign, Jehovah God, he decreed their utter extermination. Nothing was to be spared, man or beast, no spoil was to be taken. Everything devoted to destruction!!

If it was just revenge, why did it take 400 years?

​@@InThyWord since when revenge have to be done instantly? no matter how many years, if the reason behind it was a payback for what Amalek did to them 400 years ago, its still an act of revenge. The Israelites didnt strike back instantly because they were weak back then. Just a bunch of refugees fled from egypt. Then they became stronger and they did what they did, claiming 'God tell them to do so'. The passage clearly tells you it was for revenge. Furthermore, it is wrong to kill babies in any context. If you can give 'context' to justify for killing babies, you need to check your moral. Even atheist wont do that.

You do realise 400 years prior Israel won right? Do you condemn abortion?

@@InThyWord its okay whatever the reason was behind the massacre or whatever history behind it. It is still an act of revenge. Though it is still wrong to kill a generation for what their forefathers did. Be proud of what's written in the scripture. It is still a good book to read. Thank you for the backstory of the verse. Keep on posting about contextualizing the bible verses. It is very helpful. tho it's out of the topic, i'll answer you. Yes I do condemn abortion. Unless for certain circumstances i.e disease, or any medical reasons that will cause harm to the mother or the child.

Aylin Secure so I hope you are consistent on abortion videos with comments like you did on mine. And secondly. If they were wiped out at the time and not given 400 years of grace, these descendants would never exist to be judged. If you listened to my video you would know they were doing the same things at the time of being wiped out.

arcguardian thank you for your honest feedback. 👍

@@InThyWord no problem brother.

You are right. Lots of those leaders were people who make up what our loving God was suppose to have said Using God's name to do evil things even today.

😂😂

True, no way in any way god says kill infants and kids.

Surah An-Nisa (4:56): "Indeed, those who disbelieve in Our verses - We will drive them into a Fire. Every time their skins are roasted through, We will replace them with other skins so they may taste the punishment. Indeed, Allah is ever Exalted in Might and Wise." Surah At-Tawbah (9:5) "And when the sacred months have passed, then kill the polytheists wherever you find them and capture them and besiege them and sit in wait for them at every place of ambush. But if they should repent, establish prayer, and give zakah, let them [go] on their way. Indeed, Allah is Forgiving and Merciful." Surah An-Nisa (4:34) "Men are the protectors and maintainers of women, because Allah has made one of them to excel the other, and because they spend (to support them) from their wealth. So righteous women are devoutly obedient, guarding in [the husband's] absence what Allah would have them guard. But those [wives] from whom you fear arrogance or disobedience, [first] advise them; [then if they persist], forsake them in bed; and [finally], strike them. But if they obey you [once more], seek no means against them. Indeed, Allah is ever Exalted and Grand."

God created life which means he has the ultimate authority to take it away as well. It can contradict how we feel, but in our contradictions also lies sin which we know and understand to be wrong. This event is simply something we struggle to understand.

God also said to Abraham to sacrifice his only son, and was about to do so until God said to stop as he has proven himself. God can be very brutal and have no mercy at times.

@@micahleuck1021 Why wouldn't god just not create it in the first place. He is all knowing and can predict the future. If I gave you 20 dollars knowing you would spend it on heroin, and then stole the 20 dollars back from you, leaving you with an endless heroin addiction, would you say that that is justifiable? All God did was incept suffering into a human, had that conciousness experience immense pain during their death and likely for the rest of eternity (assuming that they go to hell) for no reason. That sounds evil. Playing a sadistic game with the knowledge you would get rid of the persons existence for no reason once so ever.

@@charlie8344 Because he aint real.

@@micahleuck1021 'Your parents gave you life so they have the right to have you murdered'. K....

God bless Muslims now we see why Islam become the religion of peace and more people are trying to be muslim,

The bloody torah and bible say kill man and women and children and animals. The Quran doesn’t ❤️

So the first caliph went against the quran, even he knew how false that book is

And al bukhari 5134 the prophet married aisha at the age of 9

@@i7583 blah blah blah . Study learn stop being fool

Some of these Bibles are rewritten by demons. This has nothing to do with NOW TIMES! It despicable no matter who does it. Israel is brand new and colonized land. Same with Palestine. Europeans gave land to 3 groups. EUROPE IS MESSY AND VERY QUIET LATELY!!! Snakes!!!

The tribes of amelekites are sacrificing their babies in a pagan god while it's on fire while their parenta are celebrating....

​@@adameve2647blah blah blah

​@@adameve2647 yes so does this justify killing their innocent new born baby? And there amature children? Copium failed

​@@adameve2647 so what good did you do? You sacrificed their children for your god too. Bo difference between them and you except you genocided their children and infants and eliminated them not they who eliminated the jews.

@@youssefelsayed8025 you cant questioned Gods Wrath tho

@@youssefelsayed8025 So now you know more then God .. 🙄

@@Alamoboxing maybe because your limiting god what the point of god if god ain’t Godding god can be stupid or smart

What about abortion? People justify that all the time.

NO WAY God will say that and allow children to be killed .This is a fabricated verse,must be some evil person wrote it down

One day I had faith in "God". But for real, do you think that even with this context it is justify to kill children, women, etc. According to your morality, do you think it is good to take revenge by murdering men, women and children? Are they responsible for the orders of their king? Even the guy in the video looks embarassed.

@@hygienicdonut2344 if he was embarrassed he wouldn't have uploaded a video about it. It's not good to kill INNOCENT people regardless of their age. A terrorist is responsible for the crime they committed regardless if it's not or commanded by their terrorist's group leader.

@@lelouchvibritannia2327 I mean embarrased in the way he speakes. I was not saying that but anyway men can't be responsible for every bad actions committed by others as much as women or children. Finally the conclusion is the same. The context does not make this passage from the Bible more comprehensive especially with our modern morality. God contradicts himself afterwards. So he is not perfect. If he is not perfect it is because he is not God, he is therefore a creation of man. I only wish the happiness of my neighbor including yours and I don't need God for that.

@@hygienicdonut2344 I had to rewatch the video just to verify your assumption to the action of the man in the video. To me, he's not embarrassed speaking about it. He was very cautious not to say any less or more of what was said and to stay on topic which is the righteousness of God. If you think he's embarrassed because that's the way he speaks, then give your reasoning as to why you arrive at that conclusion. Do you have the same accent as him? Do you have the same body gestures when speaking? Do you also double-check things the way he did it? If you are telling things dismissively then that's not even a valid point of argument. I agree. The sin of the father is not the sin of the son. If you think there is a contradiction, it's perfectly understandable to know why. Have you heard about the saying "an eye for an eye, tooth for a tooth, etc?" God commanded to give the same treatment Amalekites did to the feeble jews - if you proceeded to watch the entire video, you'll know what I'm talking about. Basically, the Amalekites have fallen so low in sin to an extent where God had enough of it. Now the question I think you should be asking is why God did not execute the destruction of Amalekites himself as it shouldn't be any problem at all for a God who is Almighty, right? In Genesis, we have read the destruction of Sodom and Gomorah through hellfire directly sent by God from heaven so why couldn't He just do the same? Instead, HE COMMANDED the people to do the exact same thing to the Amalekites rather than sending another hellfire which would do the job better in my personal opinion. Did this line of questioning ever cross your mind? Probably not but keep reading... God as the epitome of righteousness had to serve the best justice He could to Amalekites which is getting the same exact treatment they did to others - making their women childless so God ENABLED a group of men to deliver justice in wiping out the Amalekites. I also only wish enlightenment for my neighbor so they wouldn't be foolish to assume things in their own bias, jump to conclusions, and approach someone in hopes of educating them into something they don't even understand. You need Jesus Christ. All praise and glory to him our Lord and Savior.

No he didn't, he said the evil in the conduct of October 7th by Hamas was the same kind of Jew hatred as the Amakelites

+A-A-Ron So you are against abortion?

​@@InThyWord I'm not a fan of abortion. I would rather it not be necessary in order to preserve a person's bodily autonomy. No one should ever be forced to have their body used against their will. If embryonic transfer can be perfected at all stages of growth then maybe it wouldn't even be necessary. To be clear, my opinion on abortion is a completely different topic of conversation than Yahweh's inconsistent character. Will my thoughts on abortion somehow make Yahweh's low moral standard more defensible? Are you attempting to show me that my moral justifications are as poor as his?

@@aaronjm94 let me borrow your words. “I am not a fan of babies dying in the Bible. I would rather it not be necessary in order to not have God’s name wrongly dragged through the mud. If God deemed another way sufficient, maybe it would not be necessary” Let me borrow some more: RE ABORTION “I have considered your points. However, there is NO JUSTIFICATION FOR KILLING THE INNOCENT HERE.” You want me to believe that mankind can decide when is right to take innocent life but God who in the Bible created life cannot?

@@InThyWord I can imagine scenarios in which killing an innocent person would be necessary even if regrettable, however I am not omnipotent. Your deity can be either omnipotent or omnibenevolent, but he can't be sufficiently both and still be backed into a corner were the best option was murdering children and animals. Convincing yourself he needed to do that to preserve his "good" name seems clearly delusional to me, but defending the indefensible is a tough place to be. I use to be there too.

@@aaronjm94 🤔 Re-read my comment. You can think of ways to justify it, But God cannot make this decision and justify it? Then you say you are not God. Stop contradicting yourself. I never said he did it to preserve his good name 😂. Start reading the Bible for yourself contextually.

Not to mention it was commanded in Islam not to hurt Woman babies /children elderly the sick or nature I think there’s one more but I forgot

@@DeathMorethanlife then why Eye for an eye and tooth for a tooth? this is just - because amelakites killed isralites women's infants, olders, animals, babies, so the justice demands eye for an eye, tooth for a tooth. they did bring upon themselves this judgement.

Kamal Alamin Ahmed ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-T9BdL3SVZH0.html

Is Abortion wrong Raymond?

@@InThyWord Only when your wife cheats on you and god tells you to give her some bitter water.

Sorry not trying to be disrespectful, in all honesty I don't believe in the bible but I idolize the teachings of jesus. I don't personally think people should get abortions, there are alot better options. And that was a rather snide response.

@@InThyWord also to be fair, the only reason I ended up on your video is because I asked someone "how many people would Jesus let go bankrupt from medical bills" and he sent the scripture "1Samuel 15-3" and I searched it real quick to find your video."

@@stormy5377 I want to see if you are hypocritical or not. If you are not against abortion, why are you acting as if killing babies is an issue for you? And the fact, you think people are equal to God is very interesting and not logical to be honest (even if you are an atheist, just observing a theists worldview). How can you idolize Jesus and not believe the Bible?

Sorry magic only goes to duplicate food and heal the cripples.

Huh? He did exactly that and you're still complaining.

You sholl know what to say.

Kat Maw thanks for your comment.

(Timothy 2:12) . Please shut your mouth Kat

Bro , don't use logic! This is not allowed

Someone told me they killed the children and babies because the “lord” knew they will grow to be evil keep in mind these children and infants for sins they didn’t even commit 😂 then i asked him then why the cattle and donkey he said “they are soulless”💀

Bloody qran. barbaric prophet. pseudoscientific misogynistic totalitarian halfeducated mulllah !

Bloody qran barbaric prophet pseudoscientific misogynistic totalitarian mullah !🍼

If a nation keeps killing people, in your opinion, what is justified Godly punishment?

@@InThyWord Killing man who fights with sword is one thing, at least where the fight is sin induced, but killing children and babies, no way :( God is love. Jesus teaches us to love but not through fear. I'd never want my family to love me through fear. In my tiny human mind my answer would be to heal. God can heal, Jesus did heal. Worst case, man should be subject to what our sinful human nature will bring which is death (unless born again), but surely not by order of destruction. For all those who are not Christians and read these scriptures, imagine what they'll make of this. Look how Stephen Fry reacted when asked about his feelings towards God and that wasn't even about destructive instructions. Hard times :(

Dave S do you think God was wrong to command it?

@@DaveSpicerUK cry about it

Galatians 6:7 Don’t be misled-you cannot mock the justice of God. You will always harvest what you plant.

Bro May Allah guide you nowhere in the Quran God says go kill children. I strongly recommend you to read Quran

@@hamzaarslan8044 yeah it doesn't mentioned because "the last prophet" used children for slave trade and for s3x.

*Pitty

@@Ivan23233 idgaf

Cry about it

@Justoo Islam.

​@Justoo Hi, with regards to Banu Qurayzah, there was treason committed. The Jewish tribes made a treaty with the prophet, however, they violated the treaty. In al-Bukhaari (4117), the Angel Gabriel comes to the prophet and says "have you laid down your arms? By Allah, we (angels) have not laid down ours; go out to them. He said: “Where to?” He said: Over there - and he pointed in the direction of Banu Qurayzah. So the Prophet (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) went out to them. So the Prophet (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) went out to them and besieged them with detachments of Muslims. The prophet makes clear in this hadith not to harm women and children as states not to harm children. "His verdict concerning them was in accordance with the ruling of Allah: their fighters were to be killed and their women and children were taken captive."

@Justoo Yes adult males.

@Justoo Sahih Al Bukhari (4117) "Their fighter were to be killed and their WOMEN and CHILDREN were taken as captive."

@Justoo Sahih al-Bukhari 2541 "Their fighting men were killed and their women and children were taken as captives."

😳

Like in Star wars Episode ll when Anakin was doing genocide on the tusken raiders for kidnapping and murdering his mother

@@bailujen8052 It was a camp of them

because netanyahu is a bible butcherer and is trying to rile up American Protestants (his biggest supporters/customers) to support him by quoting our holy book, without doing it any justice. Netanyahu forgets the fact that God, revealed to all the world through Christ Jesus , favors no nation over another and the old testament covenant has been fulfilled. This is from the same book he quoted. Israel’s war in palestine is unjust and genocidal

Simona Mankevčiūtė Thank you for your feedback. I really appreciate taking the time to let me know your experience.

Randy's Tropical Plants is your problem babies died or hearing babies died in the Bible in this instance, in this manner? Or both?

@@InThyWord my problem is why you looks so desperate and confuse? Your god wants you to kill women and babies of amalek, it's already context enough to understand.

Atheism for the win!

@@thomaslang7616 not really

Thou shalt not kill, unless I tell you to

It can’t be justified. I could never kill a baby. That’s evil and I am not evil. These are mens’ words.

'God bless'...well, unless you're an Amalekite or Canaanite woman, child or infant of course.

Luke 💪🏾

It depends if they are reasonable or not. I have had good conversations with Atheists, but also seemingly pointless ones too.

What happens?

Didnt answer the question lmao are u sure u are even qualified to tackle this issue?

@@USMCKong0311 no not plausible, if this were the case there wouldn't be such an aversion to harming civilians and such effort to move people to refugee camps

Christians say they understand so 🤷‍♂️. No need for your surprise. What do you believe?

@@InThyWord I Believe the Bible is been Corrupted&...Bible Writer like Methew,Like,John,Paul there all never saw Jesus,That's why Christians are leaving their Faith today...while Pope is Campaigning "Homosexual"

@@shenjamamzingi7950 Are you a muslim?

@@InThyWord Yes i am,I submit myself to the Will of God just like Juses(may peace be up on him)..&which Religion u are! Are u Christian?

​@@shenjamamzingi7950​Can you provide evidence the Bible is corrupted?

Do you condemn abortion?

@@InThyWord How is that related to whether or not the bible is moral, or whether genocide/infanticide is justified? Even if I don't condemn abortion, and even if you believed I was inconsistent for failing to do so, it wouldn't mean that genocide is justified or moral ever, let alone in a supposedly moral book.

The Atheist Appeal so you openly condemn the Bible as immoral for killing babies but cannot openly condemn abortions for killing 50,000,000 babies every year? And you really asked the relevance? Should God, or man be able to determine who lives or not?

Garth Andrews Hypocrisy

@Garth Andrews As I told In Thy Word, this is an irrelevant ad hominum attack. You may think my worldview is inconsistent, or that I myself have a ridiculous set of ethics, but that in no way lessens your intellectual burden to justify the atrocities within the bible. If you claim that the god of the bible is moral, but then suggest that that same god can command genocide and infanticide one day only to supposedly condemn it the next, invalidates your claim. And again, my original comment was intended to respond to In Thy Word's supposed justification of this genocide. Neither he nor you have provided any semblance of a defence for his justification, instead you have turned to irrelvant ad hominum attacks. This is not a genuine or productive method of discourse, and it certainly fails to address anything I've actually said.

@MacGuffin, Do you condemn abortion or rationalise?

@@InThyWord neither.

@@MacGuffinExMachina So you cannot rationalize and just deluded narrow minded?

@@InThyWord why the divergence? Killing children is wrong and God commanded it right?

@@MacGuffinExMachina you failed miserably

I'm Glad it was helpful Brittany Craveiro

So in your eyes, there are cases in which innocent beings deserve to be punished/killed for something they themselves didn't do?

Thanks for the question WHY Unify? do you have a reference specifically you are talking about. I want to know the context of what you are referring to before I answer.

@@InThyWord I'm referring to the fact that you make your God seem vengeful with justifying the killing of innocent in return for killing of innocent

Old testament Yahweh = the demiurge

Spooky Action At A Distance I know this will help if you are open and willing to watch ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-T9BdL3SVZH0.html

Interesting. If a man can look at the actions of God and say that they are wrong and that he should have known better, why too would someone think that God was created in man's image? If man's perception of what God should be like differs from the God of the bible, why do you think that the God of the bible was created by man? Not that I necessarily agree with this videos justification of this particular text, but I do think that is something that no one really explains. We always have these ideas about what God should be like, how he should act, and what he shouldn't do, but really that would only apply to a God that man actually created. If it's a God that man didn't create, he would be just as he was, and probably not confined by man's expectations of him. Whether man liked it or not.

Exactly, he has an emotional thing against it, but him claiming this disproves god is silly. You just don’t like it based off one verse

@@JA-jx1hk It's not solely based off this one verse -- there are lots of other reasons to believe that the God of the Bible is a product of man's imagination. Note that I'm specifically saying "God of the Bible" -- there may in fact be a god. What I was alluding to here is that Yahweh's "command" seems to be justification for something the Israelites probably wanted to do anyway, as it actually contradicts many attributes of Yahweh as described elsewhere in the Bible

@@mpersand This isn't the only reason I think that Yahweh is a product of the Israelites' imagination , just one of them. I do agree with your fundamental reasoning (if God is real, who are we to protest the way things are), but you first have to prove that Yahweh is in fact real and rules over us all. There must be some objective proof of this, otherwise it's all circular reasoning. And so far, the many contradictions in Yahweh's character , his tendancy towards war and vengeance in the Old Testament (which is completely consistant with other ancient Near East cultures btw), the evolution of the concepts of Hell and Satan as the Bible progresses (these concepts didn't even exist in early Judaism), among other things, suggests to me that it's far more likely that Yahweh was conjured up in the minds of men. But if there is evidence to the contrary, I'm open to it. Note that my argument is not that there is no God -- I think it's possible. My argument is that it's not Yahweh.

Thank you.

Also this screws the freakish hebrew israelites up as they are mistaken Europeans for already dead tribes

GLAD TO HELP we answer other "tough" Bible questions: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-ExUiV_c9VQQ.html

Can you explain it to me?

@Mahdi rahimi the truth is just in front of them I mean their whole fath is about Jesus is God and he never said he is . that would tell you Stone headed they are

@@aminhakim5087 Muslim brother☪️❤🤝🏻

@@aminhakim5087 yes it does I can tell you don’t know nothing lol

@@jasonrobert851 where

@@jasonrobert851 where

Are theists truly this stupid?

@GoyimAreNotSlaveshow is the Hadith like the OT?

But God said that there would be war with this family? That means that the babies would their footsteps, why is not good that the babies are getting killed so they wont grow up to kill more other babies and actually enter Heaven and not hell?

@@@Aden1234100 By that logic God should kill everyone about to enter hell because he knows they'll do bad and can therefore kill them as you stated in your comment. Absolutely shameful to justify the killing of innocents babies.

@@edmqnd8128 so u rsther wanted God to let these abies grow up and kill other babies?

@@Aden1234100 At that time they weren't guilty. They couldn't differ between right and wrong. If God just killed the ones that taught the babies to be evil they wouldn't become evil. And again by that logic shouldn't God kill everyone that are going to hell then? You know that logic is flawed. There is no justice in killing innocents. You're trying to justify the killing of innocent babies just because your belief. It's amazing what people are ready to justify just so they can say their belief is correct.

@@edmqnd8128 The reason is that God KNEW that they would follow their footsteps. He KNEW it. He said there will be war for generations. God is all knowing, he knew this would keep going for generations, so he STOPPED IT. THAT'S WHY. I added the hell part to tell u they spend eternel life in Heaven. But u rather want God to let these babies grow up and kill other babies and it would go on centuries?

Thou, implying mankind. Gods will is seperate from the will of man, and oftentimes men pervent the will of God for selfish gain

@@joshhill4903 God is allowed to murder his own children xD!!!

@@ponponpatapon9670 i wouldnt want to be the person to say "hey i know you just gave us all of this and we really fucked it up but youre wrong". Doesnt sit well on thr tongue

@@joshhill4903 Genesis 3:22 And the Lord God said, “The man has now become like one of us, knowing good and evil. He must not be allowed to reach out his hand and take also from the tree of life and eat, and live forever.” According to your own scriptures mankind has the SAME access to moral understanding as God does.

@@BlGGESTBROTHER just because mankind has access doesnt mean we will use it properly or understand completely. There are bigger pictures than what a little human brain can conceive and your capacity for "knowledge" wouldnt be the same as Gods. That doesn't mean we dont have a responsibility to strive to live as rightous as can be humanly attainable, at least in my personal view, ill never be able to "play ball" on the same court let alone with God. Because like discussed we are fallible

Greetings to India 🤝. Do you believe Jesus was/is God?

@@InThyWord Well, my faith is God the father who created this world gave his only begotten son Jesus to save me/us.Jesus died for my sin and rose again victoriously defeating the evil and he will come back soon. Corona time has given us the opportunity to explore Bible and we do the book of samuel now.

These two will help you: Why is God different in the Old and New Testament! ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-qilcFOqeJ1o.html Is Killing Babies in the Bible EVER Acceptable ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-T9BdL3SVZH0.html Feel free to ask more questions you have and I will do my best to help. Keep reading and always look at overall context. 🤝

Your god Yahweh is an evil murder

Glory to "God" for taking revenge. Glory to "God" who contradicts himself afterwards about it.

You are a scary cult member

Do you believe the same rules apply to everyone in every situation?

@@InThyWord Yes nobody is above the law. It jus doesn’t make sense to me that God can experience Jealousy, anger, wrath etc but if we experience those feelings (involuntary) it is a sin? Can God control those feelings in himself? and how can we be held responsible for those feelings that we have if we can’t even control them?

@@josephminder7366 Do the same rules apply when the Police break down a house door to get in, as if civilians did it? God creates the law, he is not necessarily bound by his law. For example the governments print money but it is illegal for everyone else to print money. Does this make sense? But to your follow ups, Paul (this is a New Testament disciple of Jesus, if you are not a Christian) talks about Godly jealousy he has, The Bible talks about righteous anger, and how we should be angry but not sin. We can control our emotions and behaviour, and this is why God holds us accountable. You have freewill to act voluntarily how you want. And judgement is a byproduct of our freewill.

@@InThyWord That is a good point about the money printer and police. But I know for a fact that people can’t control their emotions completely or their beliefs because I can’t control my emotions and I can’t choose What I believe. It is the same way people can’t control what music they like or what their favorite color is. I like diving deep into philosophical discussions but that isn’t really practical here but believe me I could talk for hours about so many things and I wish I could relay to you all the concepts I’ve pondered which I’m sure would influence your perspective. Like how the expansion of the universe parallels the growth of a tree (life in the universe is like the the fruit of the tree) and they both grow from a small point magically and mysteriously and that is just the tip of the ice berg. Anyway I think you’re really cool and nice and I love you!

Sorry for taking up your time I appreciate it tho

Thanks Tyler

No thats fulfilling the eye for an eye. Gods grace increased the more we sinned, and it’s not a contradiction but a fulfilment into turn your left cheek. Since the wages of sin are no longer death. Also the babies were not innocent, they were going to grow up evil, as they were in an evil environment and would try destroy the Israelites. God didn’t want this to happen; and it says in the Bible babies go to heaven since they haven’t understood the conscious of evil.

Congratulations, you've been fully brainwashed and binded by religious dogma.

Then why didn't he impose the punishment himself??? Why give the task of murder/killing to others....does not make sense...so l do believe in God as Creator, but, the Bible is tainted with biases and tribal hatreds.

Imagine thinking this lowly of yourself

+Kemal Batavian I would hope they would look into context more as well because God talks about in the Bible how many of the nations he punished were having relations with animals and that would cause all kinds of problems like diseases etc if consumed and other ways bacteria’s can be transmitted. Does this make sense +Kemal Batavian?

@@InThyWord does bibble even explain the diseases, etc? the problem by the animal is just your assumption. slay kids? even baby? what is god trying to teach us here?? compassion??

If you do research you will find that is true. Apart from being an inhuman act to have intercourse with an animal, the ramifications are severe on your body. If you read all my replies, in the comments, I believe I provide a valid explanation as to why this was justified and a gracious act on God’s part.

@@InThyWordi want words from bible. does the bibble tell that those amalekites have disease or even have intercourse with animal?

Not only Amalekites but all the nations that God drove out of the lands. It says in Leviticus, don’t do all these things the nations that are being driven out do (sleeping with animals was one of them.) The Amalekites were still killing babies 400 years after killing Israelites weakest and most in need people.

and that verse natanhau said it we will desteroy amalek look at gaza thats ur god sunny

So in your eyes, there are cases in which innocent beings deserve to be punished/killed for something they themselves didn't do?

If God were all-loving then he would find the idea of killing his children (humans) totally abhorrent. Fortunately, being all-powerful he would be able to achieve his aims without killing anyone. So have have a triangle of paradox - the 3 points of which are this alleged deity’s love, his omnipotence and his record of murdering those who displease him (we’ll overlook the fact that those he kills, are supposed to be his ‘children’ and the fact that he created them and their motivations). These 3 three attributes are in conflict and you can only have 2 of them. You can be all loving and all powerful and not have kill people; you can be all-loving and kill people/let them die because you lack the power to prevent this or you can be all powerful and murder people because you don’t love them. (In answer to the question, being all-loving is in conflict with murdering your child, all-powerful or not). Yes, you can argue that these three are human attributes and that your deity is not human so doesn’t have to abide by them, so why give it human characteristics? If you are going to describe your god as all-loving, you can’t then say it doesn’t have to behave as though it is.

@@Bugsy0333 well here's the thing. This was a group of people who rejected God but at one time were related to tribe of Ephraim. For a long time they rejected God. Therefore they are no longer classified as God's children because they never came to God and repented or sought how to be right with God. Furthermore God would want all people to stop sinning and turn to.him but they did not. What is worse is they attacked God's people unprovoked and the bible is clear in several scriptures that he will exercise judgement on those who come against his children. If you have a person or people who follow God vs someone who has not only rejected God but also caused harm to those who are following God then you wouldn't think there would be consequences? Your theory about triangle of paradox does not apply

@@Bugsy0333 did u even watch the video

So the all powerful God who could have just instantly had only the men drop dead instead asks humans to kill babies? Please use your rational brain. I know the brainwashing is tough but just think about how ridiculous this justification is.

God didn’t spare any babies or kids in the flood , wow how pro life of him

Nicholas Rourke glad it helped. Thank you for sharing. God bless.

Children are innocent. God ordered an evil act

@@guzavevic6736 I agree but idk God sees things different from us

@Mahdi rahimi Thats not true the bible is a very holy book which only speaks the truth it hurts me that you say those things about the bible Jesus loves you no matter what❤

@Mahdi rahimi yes very true he loves everybody thats why he sacrificed himself for us all glory to him

The donkeys started it. Kill the donkeys. While you are at it, please kill the camels and sheep. They were in on it

No, the key takeaway is "They wouldn't stop".

@@danieln.6097 They wouldn't stop doing what? Eating carrots? Donkeys are known to be stubborn, but did they deserve to die?

@@sbnwnc The intergenerational war, violence & murder of the Israelites & more particularly the most vulnerable among Israel such as the women, children & elderly. God made this command & judgement having this foreknowledge. Regarding the animals, likely God commanded the killing of them because of pagan practices & bestiality which occurred with them & was common among some nations in the ancient near east.

@@danieln.6097 Yeah that's absolutely insane and it is not something that an all-knowing and benevolent God would do. Killing babies is wrong. Killing women and children is wrong. Think about how bat-poop crazy what you are defending really is. Why should all the babies have been killed? Why couldn't they be adopted? If all the humans were killed why did the animals have to be killed? Who was going to practice beastiality on the donkeys if all the humans are dead?

justin neumeister all glory to God. 🤝

This is the peaceful book of the Quran.. ok😅

This world is filled with blood and violence maybe it's the reason why god called it curse soil

What was the sin of an infant who was killed because of what his ancestors did 400 years ago😂

What did the donkey and cattle do😂

@@af32218 Ask God what’s the sins with the kids in Palestine. Don’t Ask because that’s looks like a Wrath from here.

@@af32218 All the Unaliving going in there it’s because of God will, nothing it’s done out of he’s will. He’s the only One that Gives life and Unalive... Not like puppet Muhammad that unalive without God consent.

And he dosent even give an any sort of an answer and asks for "wHaT cOnTeXt?"

So your saying sence he’s god he can kill whenever he wants to yeah go f### yourself

What makes your opinion better than people who are for abortion, or anything you dislike in the Bible?

@@InThyWord Abortion is irrelevant. Are you saying killing children isn't wrong? That's my only point here. And I'm right

Ur book is evil.