Тёмный

16 JANUARY 1940 LETTER OF MAHATMA GANDHI TO QUAID-E-AZAM MOHAMMAD ALI JINNAH: Why was it written? 

Ishtiaq Ahmed
Подписаться 88 тыс.
Просмотров 7 тыс.
50% 1

#ishtiaqahmed
#indiahistory
#pakistanindiannews
#indiapakistanborder
#indianvlogger
#pakistani
#indianyoutuber
#Indianfilms
#indiafacts
#pakistannews
#indialegends
#indianmusic
#indiapakwars
#partition
#punjab
#Lahore
In this episode Prof. Dr. Ishtiaq Ahmed discusses the letter Mahatma Gandhi wrote to the Muslim League leader, Quaid-e-Azam Mohammad Ali Jinnah urging him to form an alternative national party consisting of Muslims, the Dravidian people of South India and the Dalits and thus both it and the Congress could form two national parties struggling for the freedom of India.
Dr. Ishtiaq Ahmed is a Swedish political scientist and author of Pakistani descent. He obtained a Ph.D. in Political Science from Stockholm University, where he is currently Professor Emeritus, having retired in 2010. During 2015-2019 he was Visiting Professor at the Government College University, Lahore, and in 2013-2015 he was Visiting Professor at the Lahore University of Management Sciences (LUMS). He is an Honorary Senior Fellow of the Institute of South Asian Studies (ISAS) at the National University of Singapore and was Visiting Research Professor at the Institute of South Asian Studies (ISAS). He was also the Visiting Professor at the South Asian Studies Programme, the National University of Singapore from June 2007 to June 2010. He is also an Editor-in-General of the "Liberal Arts & Social Sciences International Journal (LASSIJ)"; a member of the editorial advisory boards of "Asian Ethnicity"; "Journal of Punjab Studies"; "IPRI Journal, Islamabad"; and "PIPS Research Journal of Conflict and Peace Studies, Islamabad.
Connect with Dr. Ishtiaq Ahmed: 👨‍💻 en.m.wikipedia...) 🎥
RU-vid: / billumian47 🐦
Twitter: / ishtiaqlahori Website: www.ishtiaqahm...

Опубликовано:

 

23 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 108   
@Billumian47
@Billumian47 2 года назад
Dear friends, a character, probably with a fake identity called Simon Philips wrote in the comments section that I have denied Pakistan Army's atrocities in Bangladesh and called me a false historian. I have in several videos deplored the atrocities committed by the Pakistan Army and in my Garrison State book two full chapters are devoted to highlighting that. I checked who this fellow is and my feeling is that he is a paid troll with false name and just out to spread disinformation. I first gave him chance to check his allegations but realized that the best is to block him. This is becoming a great nuisance and I feel like again closing the comments section.
@ankushdas1995
@ankushdas1995 2 года назад
Uff. Seriously. Sir make your skin thick against these people (sarcasm). I understand you have to reply this person because you were charged with such a serious issue. But I see your comment as him getting to you. Comments should be use for suggestions, questions and references if we disagree with you. Sir I request you only use comment section for that and don't let these guys get under your skin.
@Billumian47
@Billumian47 2 года назад
@@ankushdas1995 thank you, I will try but you know we are human. One gets deeply offended by such provocations.
@dramjad1712
@dramjad1712 2 года назад
Please sir ignore such non sense.. you are doing a sacred job.. please continue your work
@reactorscale4fun31
@reactorscale4fun31 2 года назад
@@Billumian47 Sir, you are Great ❤️Sir love from 🇮🇳🙏👉🇮🇳🌹
@reactorscale4fun31
@reactorscale4fun31 2 года назад
@@dramjad1712 🌹🙏🌹👉🇮🇳🙏
@royanjan1966
@royanjan1966 2 года назад
Thankyou Dr Ahmed for a very enlightened discourse.
@anitoyeptho5095
@anitoyeptho5095 2 года назад
God is great all the time God bless my country India from Nagaland North East India
@Billumian47
@Billumian47 2 года назад
We resume the ongoing series on the Indian Freedom Struggle 1857 - 1947. This letter by Gandhiji shows one of the several attempts by him to persuade Jinnah Sahib to fight for the freedom of India by forming an alternative national party comprising Muslims, Dravidians and Dalits.
@Billumian47
@Billumian47 2 года назад
@@Gappasappa I do.
@Billumian47
@Billumian47 2 года назад
@Simon Phillips are you sure, it was I. If you are a gentleman then on your honour check if you are not confusing me with someone else because my book, Pakistan the Garrison State has two chapters just on the military action where I show the atrocities committed by Pakistan. If you are here with some disinformation mission then after 12 hours to correct yourself I will block you.
@manansharma6348
@manansharma6348 2 года назад
@@Billumian47 sir please ignore these dis-honest trolls they are not here to seek truth but only to abuse and troll take their words with a pinch of salt
@renukasahoo899
@renukasahoo899 2 года назад
Rightly explained Sir. Thank you. People must know the truth. Communal harmony must prevail all over the world. Jai Hind.
@usairam628
@usairam628 2 года назад
Great Sir 👍, Almighty Allah give you a long healthy life and protect you from all dangers.ameen.from Peshawar
@virah133
@virah133 2 года назад
Thank you professor. I am very grateful to you as an Indian.
@MB-xn2xq
@MB-xn2xq 2 года назад
Sir you’re doing a great service to the sub-continent by sharing these bite-sized videos about out history in a language that a lot of people can understand and also clarifying all the misconceptions that people hold. Aap iss mitti ka karz ada kar rahe ho❣️❣️❣️hopefully, i will also be able to do it one day. Take care & thank you so much 🙏🏽🙏🏽
@subhashsapra8265
@subhashsapra8265 2 года назад
Thanks Professor Sahib for telling us the facts of History. Sir, Aurobindo Ghosh had suggested Mr.Gandhi not to agree for Partition, but still Partition happened. May be it was destined that way. Let's see what Supreme Architect Of Universe has in store for us. Regards Dr.Sapra
@Billumian47
@Billumian47 2 года назад
He did not agree but had no choice.
@techakki81
@techakki81 2 года назад
sirji, a time will come, when subcontinent will overcome the legacy of partition and you will be a "ahm kadi" in overcoming it.. You have cleared the history of that time for me immensely
@बोलतीदिल्ली
Trolls are the people of terrorist mind. Ignore them. You have excellent knowledge of peri-indipendent period. You have removed all my confusions relating to the independence. Salute. Thanks sir.
@adityajoshi1586
@adityajoshi1586 2 года назад
Sir, if youtube allows, could you add a number to all the india-pak history episodes. It helps with the chronology.
@MOHDANAS-iz5lg
@MOHDANAS-iz5lg 2 года назад
Keep going Sir, big fan of your research since i read your book PUNJAB. That's such a masterpiece. Love from india.
@rajam6487
@rajam6487 2 года назад
Dear Dr.Ishtiaqahmed, Your one of few pakistani, who is very knowledgeable and honest and out spoke...if person like we're in pakistan politics... pakistan would have...been good country. Like your honesty and openness.. ❤️🙏
@subramaniam.r1270
@subramaniam.r1270 2 года назад
Ego of one person has changed the shape of the country after partition without any vision and principles see where Pakistan is.
@UmarFarooq-ty3tu
@UmarFarooq-ty3tu 2 года назад
That became necessary at that time... Now it's proven in both countries... Neither Muslims well behave with Hindu and minorites ,,,,,,,,,,,,, nor Hindu with Muslims and minorites ....
@rizwanalikhan2814
@rizwanalikhan2814 2 года назад
I'm proud to be a ind
@dr.pawankumararyan4892
@dr.pawankumararyan4892 2 года назад
Lucky to be sailing the carnal voyage with a commander like you.
@papunkansabanik2490
@papunkansabanik2490 2 года назад
Great analysis Sir, it seems if Mahatma Gandhi had the final say during the period before partition, things would be better integrated, harmony would have prevailed and possibly the communal violence that erupted during the period of partition could have been averted.
@polestar5517
@polestar5517 2 года назад
Thank you Sir for the insightful detail.
@reactorscale4fun31
@reactorscale4fun31 2 года назад
*Great knowledgeable Personality 🙏🇮🇳👉🇮🇳❤️🌹 Sir Please Live show kare or sir Please Questions bhi le Hamare*
@nicholasbourbaki7536
@nicholasbourbaki7536 2 года назад
Dr Sahab - I have read all your books and listened extensively to you. Your work is amazing - it’s objective and not insincere and theoretical like some other historians. Unlike the Punjab where you had the opportunity to interview many people who were adults during the Partition, you can’t do that with Sindh now. Those people are dead although some recordings may exist. All said, if a book is not possible, is there any way you can write at least some articles, or do some RU-vid feature on the partition of Sindh. This is the province whose partition story has been least written about. You will be filling a big gap…
@gopalkrishanbiswas4244
@gopalkrishanbiswas4244 2 года назад
Sir you are great. Thank you.
@nupursharma6869
@nupursharma6869 2 года назад
Great work ishtiaq sir
@karmyogi-2.1
@karmyogi-2.1 2 года назад
Thanks 🙏
@rafiqakbany7223
@rafiqakbany7223 2 года назад
Very informative data.Thanks
@numinex8009
@numinex8009 2 года назад
thank you sir
@khurrambhatti7492
@khurrambhatti7492 2 года назад
Thanks for the knowledge and the video’s.
@skg63c
@skg63c 2 года назад
Sir, am following your lessons on history to all of us which is directly referred to the present population of India or Pakistan. I have read all your books. I am glad that you have the moral courage to tell us all regarding the mistakes of our leaders, irrespective of cast religion color creed language etc etc. My father today is 100 years old and he enjoys listening to you on RU-vid. He totally supports your version. Sir, please continue to bring out the fact. One day we, INDIA & PAKISTAN, will unite and live in co-existance irrespective of religious differences, ideologies. If Germany could, yes they didn't have religion as a difference of open, then why can't we. Please continue the good work
@quamrulsiddiqui4225
@quamrulsiddiqui4225 2 года назад
Gandhiji the great. Thank you Ishtiyak sir.
@tanwerralammashallah7361
@tanwerralammashallah7361 3 месяца назад
Assalam alaikum sir. You are doing a great job. While the atrocities committed by Pak army against the Bengali Muslims could not be denied it is also a fact Mukti Bahini also carried out massacres rapes of civilian Beharis and non Bengalis who were residing in E. Pakistan. The genocide of the Beharis was of much larger scale. I request you to make a video of that. Another request which is personal that while starting your video please do say " Bismillah hir rehmanir raheem".
@UmarFarooq-ty3tu
@UmarFarooq-ty3tu 2 года назад
Keep going 🤗 professor SAHB....❣️👍😍
@tahirdanish6327
@tahirdanish6327 7 месяцев назад
Keep it up sir
@masroorkhalil9655
@masroorkhalil9655 2 года назад
sir please make a video on kashmir issue and about yasin malik and other kashmir leaders and tell wether kashmir is in reality a issue between india and pak i am waiting for your reply
@padmanabhas1458
@padmanabhas1458 2 года назад
In your new video, please let us know whether Hindumahasabha and RSS were invited by Congress for giving Nehru report in 1928 and what was there stand on making India a secular country.
@Billumian47
@Billumian47 2 года назад
Yes, get the book and read who all were invited and Hindu Mahasabha was and took part. RSS has become a major force after the partitione.
@somnathde8680
@somnathde8680 2 года назад
Thanks.Informative.
@arunachalasiva.
@arunachalasiva. 2 года назад
That is Gandhi 👏👏👏👏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏 Gandhi born for unification of India .
@surendrapatel5787
@surendrapatel5787 2 года назад
It was not terrorism sir, it was freedom struggle.
@soundar4270
@soundar4270 2 года назад
Sir, Liaqat Ali khan was responsible for partition. Jinnah almost agreed for Cabinet Mission Plan. Nehru wanted to Industrialize India at rapid speed. When interim Govt was formed in 1946, Nehru was PM of united India & Liaqat Ali khan was finance minister from Muslim League. Liaqat Ali Khan did not co-operate with Nehru and blocked all files. Nehru felt, out of frustration, his dream of Industrialized India would be at stake if India is not divided. Exactly, same happed in 75 years. India is being industrialized from day 1 but Pakistan is still an Agrarian country. Liaqat Ali khan would have been beaten to death if he were alive today.
@ashwanisharma7853
@ashwanisharma7853 2 года назад
Sir, I am really a big fan of your, katter pan har jagah par galat hai chahe wo hindu ho, Sikh community Ho,ya hamare Muslim bhai ho,is se sirf nuksaan hua hai, kabhi kashmiri pandits par bhi do line bole, Mai aapke badi kadar karta hu, God bless you sir.
@ramlakhansharma4674
@ramlakhansharma4674 2 года назад
Good evening sir, i read in history that the western boarder of india never remained in peace. Even in the era of Aurangjeb maharaj jaswant singh was appointed to keep peace in western side of india. After partition, India has been liberated by this problem. If suppose there was no partition in 1947,then TTP, TTA and other militant group would be a serious problem to india.
@Billumian47
@Billumian47 2 года назад
Borders are defended by strong states. So, you think TTP and TTA and all were written in destiny to be formed?
@pramodmahapatra7066
@pramodmahapatra7066 2 года назад
Sir,Is this letter of Mahatma Gandhi still relevant to-day.?
@Billumian47
@Billumian47 2 года назад
I think the spirit of the letter surely does. Let's hope one day it also influences the real world situation.
@kishorjain3920
@kishorjain3920 2 года назад
Sir, is it possible for these two communities to co-exist peacefully? If yes, why not try again to find such a formula so that we both can live and progress rather than fight a nuclear war which would eventually lead to destruction of both?
@prateekupadhya4875
@prateekupadhya4875 2 года назад
That can only happen when the Muslims of South asia become like the non-radicalized and peaceful Muslims of UAE and Oman. And the Hindus must learn someThing from Swamy Vivekanand and Chatrapati Shivaji Maharaj and not useFul idiots like Mohandas Gandhi. Unless that happens , forget peace
@Billumian47
@Billumian47 2 года назад
Let's hope so and we keep trying.
@porus5782
@porus5782 2 года назад
Sir, plz explain about the Mopla kand and Khilafat movement, people say Savarkar after seeing the mopla kand atrocities had drastically changed his opinion toward muslim having their loyalty toward 'Ummah' instead of Nation. And plz do explain about the origin of Hindu mahasbha RSS and Muslim league and reason behind?
@manikpatil5235
@manikpatil5235 2 года назад
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
@harshittiwari7424
@harshittiwari7424 2 года назад
Sir is it true that gandhiji hijacked the Indian freedom struggle and because of that a secular Jinnah got sidelined by Indian national congress and because of that he became messiah of muslims and he pitched the two nation theory.....I am not saying that he was right but I can understand why he did that.
@ankushdas1995
@ankushdas1995 2 года назад
Sir, I think you got the Hindu conservatives wrong. There is a major chuck of people who are actually saying that partition was the best thing that could have done to India. Without that India would have been in perpetual civil war. I can see some truth in why they say so. But I am realist and don't have the thinking to speculate what India would have been United. They are blaming Gandhi of misinterpreting Bhagwat Gita wrongly as non-violence everytime. The fact is violence is very much justified against adharma as British Empire was seen to be. But I will wait for your take on Vikram's book and life of Veer Savarkar. I know he does a very good scholarly work like you. I actually have his book as ebook but don't have much time to read it with all my exams. I am eagerly waiting for your future video and also your next book.
@manansharma6348
@manansharma6348 2 года назад
sir people like you ignite faith that peace between india and pakistan is a believe which can come to life
@jhanavkant3038
@jhanavkant3038 2 года назад
Long live Sir 👏
@onkarnathsharma6960
@onkarnathsharma6960 2 года назад
Jai hind
@aneeshkumar536
@aneeshkumar536 2 года назад
please reply that why non of the Congress leader not made any official statement on partion of the country
@Billumian47
@Billumian47 2 года назад
What a strange question!!!! Do you guys think I keep a record of everything? Already on 3 June when Nehru accepted the plan he regretted that it was not what the Congress had wanted but were accepting it. What more official statement is needed and why?
@shubhampathak4206
@shubhampathak4206 2 года назад
Sir, one request, and please do not take this in the wrong way. I am one of your earliest subscribers and really appreciate these videos, but I would insist that you state the references clearly whenever you mention each and every fact ( however small or big ). Maybe reference links in the description or mention them outright explicitly. The last time I requested you , you replied that one can easily google them and I agree; but if you present the facts with exact references, half of these notorious fools who question you would be driven away, and this will immensely strengthen the credibility and outreach of your content. Thank you sir 😊
@Billumian47
@Billumian47 2 года назад
I will try but you know it will make the discussion so boring with every fact and exact references being given in a talk. What I can do is suggest the sources but one needs to read the books and other articles. I have not seen anyone doing videos giving all references and so on.
@the_almighty_world
@the_almighty_world 2 года назад
Description me dal dijiye ga sir discussion me maat add kijiyega sach me boring ho jayega 😂
@सत्यान्वेषी-न1न
Where is Shakeel Chaudhary shahab thesey days ??
@shivram8426
@shivram8426 2 года назад
Lot of different opinions on freedom struggle the truth lies in between.
@viplovezoad5523
@viplovezoad5523 2 месяца назад
5:00 wow didn't knew this
@viplovezoad5523
@viplovezoad5523 2 месяца назад
Ambedkar is so revered in India but look here
@Lucky_Milestone
@Lucky_Milestone 2 года назад
Ok,Ok....Savarkar ne mafi mang hogi,but religion ke naam par country ko break to nahi kiya...Jinnah ne kounsa Mahan kam kiya wo to sari duniya dekh rahi hai.
@garhwalibhai2202
@garhwalibhai2202 2 года назад
This person is congress ka pidhoo and who the hell you are to comment on Veer Savarkar pl comment on leader of Pakistan.Because muslim will be always muslim
@dattarajnarad3872
@dattarajnarad3872 2 года назад
His contribution in marathi literature is notable
@rajesharora5228
@rajesharora5228 2 года назад
स्वामी श्रद्धानंद ने जब पाँच लाख मुस्लिम राजपूतों का शुद्धिकरण किया तब सबसे ज्यादा नाराज गांधी हुए थे जिन्नाह नही
@Billumian47
@Billumian47 2 года назад
Write in English so that we can understand what you say.
@MOHDANAS-iz5lg
@MOHDANAS-iz5lg 2 года назад
He is saying Swami shradanand converted 5 lakh muslim rajputs to Hindu because of this Gandhi ji was more angry then jinnah saab.
@ankushdas1995
@ankushdas1995 2 года назад
@@Billumian47 He is saying " when swami shardanand purified (converted) 500000 Muslim Rajput then Gandhi ji was very angry not Jinnah". I have no idea what it has to do with your video.
@BhartiyaDeepak
@BhartiyaDeepak 2 года назад
Sir please app ek baar sachwala ke youtube channel PR Jaye aur unse se debate kare
@shivram8426
@shivram8426 2 года назад
Sir, Only option for muslims why they are still here.
@viswanathbangalore9640
@viswanathbangalore9640 2 года назад
Mr Ishtiyaq Ahmed should know proper geography of India when he mentions South India (Dravida Deshsm in Sanskrit !). Eva Ramasswamy Naicker alias Periyar in Tamil, who started the DK movement was confined to some districts of present Tamilnadu (Madras presidency during British rule!) & his DK ( Dravida Khazagam ) movement did not find any takers in other parts of South India namely present Kerala, Karnataka, Goa, Andhra Pradesh & Telengana. Please correct your awareness professor.!
@Billumian47
@Billumian47 2 года назад
You should learn a hell lot about the Dravidian movement which embraced all four language groups and Periyar was at that time leader of it.
@sheikhejaz3174
@sheikhejaz3174 2 года назад
PARTITION. OF INDIA WAS. THE. WRONG IDEA.
@sureshkumar-vj9jp
@sureshkumar-vj9jp 2 года назад
Prof saab direct action day Ko 10 July 1946 jab bhi define karen toh british police word bhi jor den nahi toh sirf HS suharawardy akele nahi saath mein british police bhi thi tab ja kar sense clear hota hai CM law and order ka malk tha
@Billumian47
@Billumian47 2 года назад
Let me get there, please.
@pawansidhu3269
@pawansidhu3269 2 года назад
Sir,in Pakistani text books,students are intentionally taught false and fake history to prove 2 nation theory.they want to look different from india.what is solution that Pakistani people can discover their real past which is hindustani history for example,maurya dynasty,Gupta dynasty,harsvardna,in kashmir once 100% population was hindu or Buddha etc.how they can know thier roots?
@omkar6071
@omkar6071 Год назад
Savarkar was hero . Will be hero. Don't try to fool people
@Human_boy_91
@Human_boy_91 9 месяцев назад
Then why not Jinnah?? And Gandhi??
@shivram8426
@shivram8426 2 года назад
Where are Hindus in Pakistan. So all these are just to support one political party called congress. You are refereeing to one book. Lot of contradictory books are there, better you present along with them and see the difference of opinion.
@akuntes7584
@akuntes7584 2 года назад
From Dedy bladeer hand man end of Darling Asia fasipic unieropa antlantic perparticion.god Animisme adiamisme Hiddu Budda Kisnten Islamic Internasional tube one family World Citty Exfress family milion milion Darling awhe you trampront sosicial di publik of Dana awhe zona even single. You love Darling
@Shaily73
@Shaily73 2 года назад
AAP veer savarkar par pade…..sampath ji Se puche
@AbhaySingh-zq2jm
@AbhaySingh-zq2jm 2 года назад
Jaisa aapne kaha ki veer saavarkar ko jail jaane ka darr tha to kyu maanfi maangi ya unhone logo ko angrejo ke khilaaf kyu bhadkya to jinnah nehru gandhi ne kyu aisa nahi kya ki ajaadi 200 saal me mili nehru jinnah aur gandhi ji ke hissab se angrejo ko hindustan inki baaton par azaad kar dena chahiye tha
@Billumian47
@Billumian47 2 года назад
What sort of question is this? I wonder what level of education you have to pose such a weird question.
@vipinkumarsharma4025
@vipinkumarsharma4025 2 года назад
nai kitab kab aa rahi hai?
@mr_krunal_012
@mr_krunal_012 2 года назад
TOKYajinanemanigandikibat
Далее
The Jinnah - Gandhi Clash and the Khilafat Issue
39:05
Maulana Abul Kalam Azad (1888 - 1958)
19:52
Просмотров 7 тыс.
THE BRITISH POSITION ON PRINCELY STATES AND PARTITION
1:03:49