He was good and charismatic speaker but not a greater leader, the step nationalization of industries he took literally ruined booming industrial sector of pakistan and also the main reason for seperation of bangladesh.
@@Attitudezero884Yep. Bhutto’s refusal to step down as PM and concede to a Bengali PM directly led to the deaths of thousands and the separation of Bangladesh from Pakistan. He also mixed religion with politics which doomed us in the long run.
Very true. But once he agreed to having Socialism, angered the west to such an extent that all powerful lobbies started acting against him. He eventually was executed . His whole family died. Such a beautiful family ,which was disgraced to a point where the boys held guns in order to take revenge of the untimely death of their father.
Just 41 at the time, he was a giant of a man no doubt. A true nationalist and a peerless politician. Could've done great things for our country. But no one is infallible. His lust for power and total control collided with that of the Generals. They had guns and won in the end.
Absolutely. One of them however sounded like future Amir of Jamaat-e-Islami. I was a stunned at his remarks that Islam entails a whole socio-political system. It is not something that you may anticipate from a high school student today-nor such erudition!
Bhutto was right Islam is compatible with other systems if they do not contradict the main principles of Islam. What the student was saying was also right but he has misunderstood Bhutto, not everything in Islam is black and white its not my way or the highway, we need tolerance for other beliefs systems and allow them to practice their beliefs, if we take a look at Islamic history we find that Islam allows other beliefs systems to flourish. In Spain the Jews were allowed to flourish when muslims came to power, when the Christians did not allow another belief system to flourish other than Christianity. There cannot be such a Eutopia as a Islamic state, because their simply then will be no room for other beliefs systems in that particular Islamic state. We keep our Islam and also allow others who differ to flourish as long as they do not harm us.
@@ammaranwer867 you do anticipate today students like him. But the reality is they have not understood Islam properly, but have just read a fee books and we're brainwashed by political groups who actually have no interest in Islam but want to use it as a tool for their own selfish purposes. When you listen to them you would think what they are the saying is correct but when they act they do not act in accordance to Islam. We only find out the reality when we actually join these so called groups, seeing them contradicting what they actually say. I'm talking about groups like Isis who also call for a Islamic state. But look at the actions they do which are contradicting Islam.
the guy at 6:50 thought Islam is what the sects say. Little did he know that the founders of this country were non-sectarian muslims. Bhutto's view was same as Quaids. Quaid literally said, "Pakistan should be based on pure foundations of social justice and Islamic socialism.... not other isms". Bhutto's father knew Quaid, and Bhutto sent letters to him as student. Sir Syed, Quaid, Allama Iqbal and G.A Parvez (personal advisor of Quaid and student of Iqbal) were modernist Muslims, they had a Quran-centric non-sectarian understanding of Islam based on which they understood Quran's emphasis on social justice. Unfortunately this nation has no clue about its founders.
@@freeman4899 In my comment, I never referred to his intelligence. I said his English speech shows how standard English education he got in his early days. My comment was about his English education, NOT about his INTELLIGENCE at all.
Bhutto once shouted in a speech, "I am not a coward, I cannot be browbeaten. I am not scared of your guns. Come on, take up your guns; I have the power of the people with me".
We cannot fight with guns alone, or power of people , we need the mercy of Allah and His help. If we study the Seerah of our beloved Prophet ( s.a.w), and how Islam started with a few desert and illiterate Bedouins. It first began with Allah educating the Prophet on Islam through the Qur'aan and angel Gabriel who then in turn would preach and educate his followers. Once they had been strengthened with iman and taqwa. Which did not happen overnight, it was tough , their was persecution , from thier own people. After which the persecuted muslims were given permission to migrate to Medina from Mecca. Muslims then returned to Mecca and conquered it, from then onwards muslims conquered Rome, Persia, India was also entered by Muslims. Spain came under Muslim rule also,
@@3e372 You do realize it was his predecessors who committed crimes in East Pakistan? General Tikka Khan who is literally known as "The Butcher of Bangladesh" was the architect of the genocide in Bangladesh
“If Politics Fail. In Politics There Is No Vacuum” we are witnessing this today live within Pakistan… Army has complete control of the country due to the instability brought upon by the political system… a coup without a coup. Wow.
The population back then was so much less and stable. But because Pakistan has too much fertile land. It keeps producing much more food than it needs, so the population keeps on growing. Population always grows or declines in accordance to food availability; especially calories.
@@evolveelectricvehicles8551 polygamy isn’t encouraged it’s an option don’t twist it and the only reason why it’s an option is because of what happened in the past many women were widows
This very same person is one of the main character for the fall of East Pakistan and the rise of Bangladesh in other words he should be credited as Founding Father Of Bangladesh not Mujibur rahman because Mujib was there inspiration for freedom but this man Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto was there motivation for freedom from Pakistan.
@@ghazisoodhun6906 He played Central part in breakup of Pakistan his statement during Operation Searchlight was "Thankgod Pakistan is saved " The only politician of West Pakistan who praised the Army's brutal act during which more then 300000 innocent Bengalis lost there lives the blood of those innocent peoples were on his hand and he received divine Punishment from Allah for the role he played in breakup of Pakistan
@@ZeeshaanBukhari22 may more politician receieve these divine punishment for committing same crimes in Karachi, Hyderabad and Balochistan, or may be Bengali's prayers were more sorrowful or their prayers were more powerful
@@Shreaadedaa May be the crime of splitting Islamic country into two pieces for the lust of power were too much for Allah Pak to ignore so every single character involved in the crime were severly punished as an example.
6:50 only best piece and what he said is nothing but truth and absolute truth Bhutto pro soviet guy was assassinated by pro American guy Zia that's all there is to it,his time saw decline in GDP so yeah his socialism did fail in Pakistan and Zia's time saw rise but at end it bound to crash and fail since it was dependent on foreign money which brought guns and later they were turned on pakistan itself which Zia experienced firsthand with his own death, America did for sure destroy Pakistan as soon as it entered cause slow and steady growth of economy is better than boom which is suicidal and bound to bite you in tail and hurt you in long run and when you arm enemies of Islam and those who hate all Muslims except for khwarjis(who are not even majority in saudi)it was bound to haunt you back since you trained funded armed and nourished them and sent them to Africa,Iraq,Syria and all Muslims Nations where they wreck havok and killed thousands of Muslims believing it's permissible being khwarjis
As a politician you can differ with his idealogy but as a leader he was so loyal to his country n ppl of PKI but his journey of life abrivaited in sad way .
My father has seen Fatima Jinnah, Bhutto, benazir and many other brilliant leaders. He was lucky to have such politicians back then. But now we are surrounded by curropt politii😢
@@v-corps Zia Ul Haq is the only reason why we are in such position currently! Stop calling a dictator a leader we aren't a dictatorship we are a democracy based on socialism. Please idiolise someone after revsing the facts and figures. I hope you get my point!
@@hasanjamalkhan689He cannot interpret anything bro . If zulfikar ali bhutto could have changed pakistan for better but this zia ul haq destroyed your country pakistan .
@@hasanjamalkhan689Bhutto was the first civilian dictator ever born in the history of modern world.became PM when actually mujib ur rehman deserved the pm post.
Students were very brilliant at that time and they were talking with so confidence because they were addicted to reading the books and research. But today all things have been changed due to social medias where many students are wasting thier previous and valuable times.
A great leader is the one: Who knows the way (people), Shows the way and fallows that way. Results can be seen in that movements of students contradictory to what's happened hereafter since 50 decades. Who don't know and let the people in the darkness
Another sad chapter of Pakistan. A patriotic man gunned down in 1979 by those who freed them post 1971 tragedies and put the country together which was absolutely shattered as a result of martial law. It was complete failure of men with guns who want to rule the country with dummy parliaments as their mask. Constantly operating divide and rule principal, intentionally promoting illiterate and selfish people in politics to prevent a genuine leadership, strong in law-making and ensuring Rule of Law is executed throughout from top to bottom hence work purely in the interest of people & country. Full advantage is taken of illiteracy in society where people have so much time to look into others privacy and making judgements rather than personal improvement as an individual. 76 years gone, Might is right still in place. A lawless state, colony of foreign powers, personal objectives are on top of agenda, no respect of public's opinion and no value of human life. Only Might is Right, accept it or leave the country if not leave the planet.
Evil genius who chose to ignore the mandate of the Pakistani people to pave the way for the break up of Pakistan. He was great for Pakistan as long as it was on his terms
Great Leader of Muslims County, Pakistan loss a golden Pearl, Zulifqar Ali Bhutto will remain alive in hearts of good people. Allah bless upon his soul.
Bhutto's evil contribution in denying Sheikh Mujibur Rahman the right to form a national government after the latter unanimously won the December 1970 national elections will never be forgotten by the people of Bangladesh. This denial was followed by the swift launching of Operation Searhlight on the night of the 25th of March 1971 where the Pakistani military and their collaborators perpetrated one of the worst genocides of the 20th century against innocent, unarmed Bengali civilians. Bhutto saw Dhaka burn with his own eyes from his hotel room at the Dhaka Intercontinental. After Bangladesh became victorious on 16th December 1971, Bhutto did everything he could to discredit and undermine the creation of Bangladesh in the international community. It was not until 1974 where Sheikh Mujibur Rahman was practically compelled to accept the most unjust terms of the Tripartite Agreement in order for repatriation of Pakistani POWs to take place in exchange of Bengali civilians trapped in Pakistan. The result was that none of those brutal, evil, rapacious Pakistani POWs were tried for war crimes during the Bangladesh Liberation War.
Wow...What a man he was, ZA Bhutto.. nowadays Imran Khan is trying to emulate him so is his grandson Bilawal. But ZAB was a man out of this world with the greatest vision> Killers killed him alas!!
abi tak Pakistan ki tarikh me bhatto jessa leader nhi mli shaid bhatto ko janny wali maay mar gai hai Allah paak Pakistan ko dobara asi personality atta farmay
He is a great leader. Infact, he isnt the reason for seperation of Bengal it was YAhya and Ayoub. If he was the reason then sheikh mujeeb ur rehman would never attend Lahore's summit. Zulfikar Ali bhutto brought the propoganda done by the US and the Army to everyone, therefore it wasn't long until he was hanged to death after the Lahore summit. He took the blame and also recognised Bengaladesh as sovereighn. Please stop hating him just because they want you to hate him.
His Nationalization failed miserably,former Governor of the State Bank Ishrat Hussain said the same thing in his book called Governing The Ungovernable.
Perfect answer given by an intelligent student here at 6:49 and the same thing even applies to hindu way of living and systems. But its opposed in our country because of the diversity we have (including the muslims who oppose every culture of ours.) Pakistan was lucky to have jinnah but we had stupid communist Nehru and Gandhi.
@@ganeshnaik9463 It's quite funny and highly ironic that you say that on the eve of a borderline jingoistic political party winning the largest state in India quite handly and without even the slightest inkling of opposition. You can no longer stand on your soapbox and sneer at Pakistan's extremism, India is no longer an impartial and fair country for Muslims. Jinnah's point of view will become ever-clearer in the coming decades with the coming rise in state-sponsored aggression towards your domestic Muslim population.
@ahmedghumman9964 the question isn't how we treat our Indian Muslims or minorities. The question is, are they ready to put their beliefs aside and have an india first mentality like the Hindus in Sindh. They always say we are proud Pakistanis. That's the difference in ideologies 😊
@@akashbhasin788 Your grammar gave my brain a hard time. Islam is against nationalism, we are a single brotherhood, no one is above another except in their deeds. As a nation India should respect all beliefs, but unfortunately it is a barbaric and violent country, especially towards Muslims
3:07 "We are a civilization of 5000 yrs .." At least the old Pakistanis elites knew where they come from. Edit:- 6:50 A really intelligent dude right there pure gold!
Better than those moronic students who claimed we'd "re-join" India as if it was a part of the country India. Pakistan being the land of the Indus is the historical India.
We Muslim in Pakistan or in any other Muslim country don’t need anyone to tell us what system we should use. Because our beloved Prophet Muhammad has given us a perfect system to follow that’s called ISLAM ☪️ that’s the system we need to use. PAKISTAN ZINDABAD and leave the rest to Allah.
Bhutto's view was same as Quaids. Quaid literally said, "Pakistan should be based on pure foundations of social justice and Islamic socialism.... not other isms". Bhutto's father knew Quaid, and Bhutto sent letters to him as student. Sir Syed, Quaid, Allama Iqbal and G.A Parvez (personal advisor of Quaid and student of Iqbal) were modernist Muslims, they had a Quran-centric non-sectarian understanding of Islam based on which they understood Quran's emphasis on social justice. Unfortunately this nation has no clue about its founders.
@@tausif3k stop copying and pasting the same line again and again, we get it, u want dictatorship in Pakistan and dont welcome freedom of speech, we Pakistan dont want any military's regime anyday or anytime, . G pervez coward musharraf didnt know about Quran, sir syed was a puppet from Royal family, stop selling empy slugs
@@Shreaadedaa lol i am not talking about general musharraf. I am talking about Allama Ghulam Ahmad Pervez, student of Allama Iqbal and personal Quranic advisor of Quaid-e-Azam. You have got my comment totally wrong. Sir syed was not a puppet, if that is the case, then entire Muslim league and Pakistan movement members were puppets because they all came from Aligarh university. I don't want dictatorship in Pakistan, I am arguing the opposite. Read my comment again.
