2024 Alfa Romeo Tonale Review // Is this luxury? 

You got to give it to the Italians; when design is concerned, they know their business.

I got a green veloce three weeks ago, loving it

I bought an Alfa Romeo Tonale Sprint model PHEV ( the base model, not the dolled up, expensive Veloce model, which is more readily more available, as for every Sprint model Alfa imported, they imported 9 Veloces ) almost a year ago. I was the first one to buy one in Canada, and basically bought it off the truck. I paid less then MSRP, and got it less then what a Ford Escape PHEV ( which at the time had a dealer mark up of $3,500, and add ons like $3,500 for Ford's Blue Cruise ) was going for, and where a RAV4 Prime ( basically the same price without add ons ) was ( and still is ) unavailable, and a 2 year old used Prime was selling for $14,000 more then my out the door price. Other then 9 recalls ( 2 for decals that did not have metric or French on them, that I did myself, 3 for checking high voltage connections were tight, no parts needed, 1 to replace a switch, and 3 for software updates, because where I live the vehicle would not update itself ) I have had zero problems with it, everything is operating above my expectations, and I am getting better electrical range and gas mileage then stated on the Vehicle MSRP sheet. It handles great, looks much nicer then its competition ( I compared the Sprint model against the Escape and Prime, where most reviewers, etc., compare the Veloce model that they are given by the dealers against the BMW X1 or Mercedes GLA, etc. which to me is not a fair comparison, especially a PHEV to a non PVEV ). It is not perfect, just like every vehicle in certain aspects, but I love it, love driving it, glad I bought it rather then any of the half dozen or so other PHEVS I test drove, and I would buy it again. And, it fits nicely in my garage. All new vehicles have there problems, and mine did too, but the dealership I bought mine from, bent over backwards to accommodate me with the recalls, offered me a loaner while my vehicle was being serviced, and Alfa has resolved every issue with my vehicle, some well documented. I cannot say I would have gotten the same treatment from any other manufacturer. Maybe I am lucky with my vehicle, but my whole experience, from buying it through to service, driving, etc., could not have been simpler, easier, stress free, and satisfying.

I’ve already purchased a new vehicle yet watching ur content is always a pleasure. Love the chemistry between you two in ‘Questions, Coffee & Cars’.

In Canada the PHEV iZEV does make it one of the least expensive luxury branded PHEV you can buy. Not bad value preposition, but a brand new product and first year model would be a gamble

Test drove one a few months back, comes well equipped in the Veloce model but the steering was much too light to enjoy driving it, felt no connection to the vehicle. Really wanted to love it 🤷‍♀I went with an audi A5 sportback instead which I Iove. Thanks for your review Andrea and Zack!

I have a Stelvio, LOVE the paddle shifters and my dealer is five hours away! I guess I’m the fool/idiot/moron that everyone is referring to in the comments. But every time I walk up and get in my car, I’m smiling. Oh and haven’t had an issue yet (but I’m sure that’s coming, right everyone?!?)

Great review, but the X3, Q5 or NX are way better, even a Mazda outshines this model. Zach's comments are bang on...AR doesn't have the pull. After all, it really is a Stellantis product.

Why would stelantis use the jeep compass as a base for a luxury car. this compass structure is too small & it seems there are too many compromises in the tonale design.

I did do some research into Alfa Romeo prior to buying a Kia a few years ago. Purely because it they didn't match up spec wise, unless you pay property like prices, however they are a stylish make none the less!

Andrea ..the paddle shifters are used to remove the tire from the rim… they disconnect from the steering wheel

360 miles of range on a full tank and battery? I get that on my 22 Civic.

Okay...so what does the d n a stand for? I'm not familiar with Alfa Romeo... Good to see wireless included. Hyundai/Kia/Genesis, I heard you cleared up the issue with wireless AA/CarPlay...so where is it? Thanks for the honesty, Andrea...I thought you were going to like this one more! Thanks for the review!

I paid the same price for my Mazda CX5 signature I would certainly prefer my CX5. I can by a bunch of gas for $20,000.

I'd rather take a Mazda CX-30 over this to be honest

Ouch! Tough review for the venerable Alfa Romeo. Curious to see how it compares to it's Dodge cousin.

You have nothing to worry about when it comes to reliability anymore , the sister company who designs the motor-train is FERRARI . The Parent Company Stellantis which owns the Brands Ferrari Maserati Alfa Romeo Fiat Chrysler calls for a Premium , CEO John Elkann has set the Bench Mark, Cheeers Fantastic Review

Alfa has truth in advertising: the snake in the logo is devouring the owner. Love the leather pants!

❤ Andrea!!

So many ignorant comments by people who have never driven the Tonale! Perhaps these enlighten individuals are not aware of the JD Power rating of the current Alfa lineup as 3rd best of all marques for reliability Also, the Tonale came first, the Hornet came afterwards. Most people who buy an Alfa rate driving dynamics most important, not a rolling lazy Boy. I do agree that a Stelvio is a better deal for the money but if you want a sporty plug in hybrid in this category then you should at least drive it to better understand its qualities.

Would be great to see a review on the Volvo V60 Recharge (PHEV)

It is a nice looking vehicle ..very Italian …hopefully they have addressed the reliability of previous models..

I really like it, some of those options that make it so expensive just aren't necessary. Also like the other similar brands you'll be able to find these depreciated heavily in a year or so but still under warranty if you're gunshy.

That’s too bad this vehicle is such good looking but overall I give a 5 out of 10. Cheers! ☕️☕️

alfa twin dodge horn eh in canada

Very nice watch Zack...Last week, I saw that watch at Time & Gold in Vancouver and got very tempted to purchase it. It is in my bucket list now. Don't get to see lot of Zenith's around. Enjoy!

I absolutely love Alfa’s history. I revere many of their past models. But beyond those iconic wheels and that infamous V-shaped grill, two words come to mind… self-aggrandizement and pomposity. Both words typically reserved for describing someone/thing ‘clearly punching above it’s weight’. It seems to be trying too hard to be different… but it isn’t. Too bad. Thanks for the video.

Im comparing this to a Mitsubishi outlander phev 2024. Same price range

I like this show, I’m a subscriber but in the interest of accuracy the car’s name should be phonetically pronounced.. “Toe-NAH-lay”, not “Toe-NAH-lee”. Of course it’s better than pronouncing it (as I’ve heard most recently) “Toe-nail” 😂!

I’m not even joking but I saw one of these being pulled out of a flood here in the uk(we have had awful storms) by a absolutely prehistoric Land Rover defender. I genuinely think it must’ve been one from the 50s or 60s

Does the phone charge in a protective case ?

For years I've been looking for a car company that'd take this approach to Phev as this is the first ever mainstream car with such a powertrain configuration being the IC powertrain completely separated from the electric motor but Alpha just messed it up with that questionable 1.3l engine and those razor sharp shifters that looks like they'd cut some fingers off if the driver didn't hold the steering wheel properly while maneuvering 🤦‍♂️

It's not. My wife leased an Alfa Romeo Stelvio, and it was a mechanical nightmare; odd electrical issues, major brake failure, and it also completely shutdown in the middle of the highway during morning rush hour. Gave it up with only 19,000 miles and the local dealership shutdown with no notification.

Zack will have to dress for the show Andrea a 10 Zack those pants! Good show I would never consider that car!

Great review as always

that Michelin tire on the car looks... nice 🤣

I love the new Alpha high performance sedans, however I would not own one because I drive down to Virginia from Montreal, to take the Amtrak Auto Train to Orlando in the fall and back in the spring which is a 9 - 10 hour drive each way and would be afraid to drive it in the US because if it breaks down, then good luck finding a dealer and even if you do you the parts may not be in stock. This vehicle's turning radius is bad and the interior is dated. The interior is stark and uninspiring while the paddles are ugly and the infotainment system is sub par. We recently drove our recent model fully loaded BMW X1 to Hendersonville, NC for a wedding which according to both the navigation in our X1 and Google Maps indicated that this was a 16 hour drive (at speed limits) along the i81 from Thousand Islands, Canada and both were completely wrong. It took us 2 days and over 20 hours of driving each way. We drove over 4,000 kms in 1 week and a total of about 45 total hours, the Bimmer was quiet, comfortable and got great gas mileage. Plus each fill up was substantially less than it is in Canada. Foot note: The i81 going south to North Carolina is the worst highway I have ever driven on in my life south of NY state in to Pennsylvania; It was full of huge semis and pick up trucks and in a lot of cases 2 /40 footers or 2 /53 footers hooked up together. The truckers follow each other very closely almost tail gating each other. The trucks change lanes at the same time as they signal which forces a driver to go from 75 MPH to 55 MPH; this is very nerve racking and I can only say, "Thank God" we had nice weather. White knuckle driving for over 12 hours on the second day! I was surprises that there weren't more accidents because of the way these truckers drive and surprisingly there was not a lot of construction and what little there was didn't cause much delays. You need a comfortable vehicle if you're planning on driving long distances and X1s are just that. So is the Porsche Macan which is one of my favorites vehicles.

The gas version price at $47k with a dealer discount isn't crazy.

We will keep our CX-5 signature!

Love the looks. Hate the price for just over 500k range. Nope. Is it ok if we mention how horrible their quality is? It's a 3 dressed up as a 9.

You know i saw a silver one of these all the time on my daily commute. I was wondering how does he keep up his maintenance on that?? And soon realized he worked at a parts store 😂😂

What an unfortunate model name choice - the Alpha Romeo Toenail. 🤨 Speaking of the Lexus NX450h, they seem to be about as common as unicorns - at least here in the central U.S. My wife has been on a wait list for an NX450h since April 2022. The salesman occasionally calls to offer her other NX models at ridiculous markups over MSRP but no NX450h.

Too expensive. Not even a consideration.

Funny you mention Dodge, just like Maserati a lot of Alfa dealerships are owned and are next door to Dodge dealerships and do not have any upscale waiting facilities for the price! Great review as always, I like the way you do not cave into Brands you just tell the truth!

Save yourself about $10,000 and just get a Hornet R/T and it'll actually have more power with the same mileage. It's the same vehicle.

Nice design though reliability concern makes me think more Japanese.

Mazda CX-50...

It is called " TONALE" not "Tonali"

❤

Nice Toenail

Never saw 0 to 60 time

Looks like they forced the Alfa design onto a dodge hornet… the front looks like they added .. not sure it works… looks like they don’t match.. reason it’s a Hornet dodge design 1st

The hornet exterior looks nicer.

Alfa Romeo Unghia Del Piede

The NX will be serving its original owner long after the Tonale is sitting at a pay by the week used car lot.

Like my Stelvio better. ❤

It feels like a mere rebadged Dodge Hornet, which is something we have seen from Detroit in the past. It doesn't scream luxury to me. Especially with the driving experience so similar to the Hornet. Give me a Q3 and X1 anytime.

Another POS vehicle from Stillantis. Alpha Romeo also makes the new Dodge Hornet

So beautifull

Why is it that you never show the Mitsubishi Outlander PHEV as an option? My Outlander gets at the least 63 km (38 miles) of electric range, and it costs only $58000 in Canada. I've owned it since May '23 and I've only filled the gas tank four times, including a 2000 km driving holiday in July. It's a slow charger, yes, but it's worth the wait in my opinion. Very pleased!

ja Andrea alpha romeo got that female vibe but which sane person would take it over a Macan...

Nightmare to fix Imagine a mechanic trying to figure this car out. $$$$$

I'll settle for Outlander PHEV 😅

I have driven both the Tonale and Hornet, very little difference. I thought your review was a little too positive on the vehicle for its price point and the comparisons at the end were the next class up. The Tonale while claiming to be a small luxury SUV it is not, perhaps a premium suv as it is a little better than mainstream. The handling falls well short, its speed is just average, and the interior quality is below all the Comparisions you mentioned. The interior road noise is extensively louder than almost every car I have driven. The PHEV system is nice to have, but the truly terrible gas mileage is well below expectations; many ICE SUV's will provide better mileage. If a buyer has a commute, they are better off buying something else. Personally, I would compare the Tonale/Hornet to Volvo xc40 it is an ICE vehicle but gets better gas mileage, if you must have a PHEV then a Volvo S60 which is better significantly in every category over the Tonale for the same price. A Ford Escape PHEV, much better EV range and gas milage, but with less handling and interior quality for a much cheaper price. Last a Rav4 prime, it is faster, more electric range, significantly better gas mileage, cheaper and comparable interior quality. Personally, I would buy the Volvo S60 T8 for the same price, it is a significantly better vehicle.

Alfa Toenail

🍋

I can't understand why anyone would spend this much money on an Alfa Romeo when you could buy a Bmw or Audi product.

It’s not TAN-ALLY. It’s pronounced TONE-ALLE.

So this is a dodge product, kind of?

Definitely better to lease this vehicle and walk away at the end of the lease.

💙⚡💙 Alfa Romeo 💙⚡💙 . 👁️🗿👁️ 💋 🖤 . 🕶️ 🌹 💙 .

The Giulia is a masterpiece. This, not so much.

In the U.S. we get the Hornet. Another piece of junk.

Alfa Romeo will never gain a real foothold in the U.S. BTW - the Dodge hornet won't sell well either...😮

😄😁 Only old Italian men BUYing Alfa Romeo! 🤣🤣. Be prepare to spend your Pension, IRA, 401ks, and get a equity loan to repair the Alfa! But, your mechanic will retire well before you do.

Tonally 🙄

honestly i had no idea that the americans even knew about such a small car maker such as alfa... so strange he he

For the price, get a Stelvio. Better in every way.

No one will every buy hornet ugly thing...My bet is - they will recycle them in some back junk yard very soon. So dont worry, Italian brands lovers - hornet - no more. Tonale only! ))