Seeing Wonwoo cried sooo much and then hug Woozi after. It really made me cry. I an hands down to the 95 hyungs. With Jeonghan and Joshua just being there even without talking. Just being by your side. Checking every members. While Scoups is taking control as to make the show wait and be sure to talk out to people and enlighten the mood.
I can feel Wonwoo's pain on personal level, I have lost my mum too, the intense pain doesn't ever get easier, as time passes you just learn to live with it, I can only hope and pray that the pain gets lesser with time for Wonwoo, be strong Wonu💜
I feel really bad for Mingyu too, his best buddy's mom passed away same day as his birthday. It's hard to celebrate your birthday with you friends again 💔
This literally broke me into a million pieces. Wonwoo has gone through so much the last few years and he barely had a break. He held himself so strongly throughout it all. The members did as well. Woozi must’ve been in so much pain when writing this song for Wonwoo, the members and carats. I always felt like Circles was really special but after Dingo Live and Woozi shared about this song, I cry every time I hear it. But in Caratland, in front of carats, they just let go of it all and allowed themselves to be vulnerable and show exactly how they feel. The love and trust they have for each other and carats is really beautiful.
Although Jeonghan such a caring sweetheart, as soon as wonwoo started crying it's first Mingyu who noticed him and stood by him i saw in another version of this video, anyway all the members are so caring❤
95z - being there silently, like a pillar 96z - being there beside you, like a friend 97z - being there to hug you, like comfort maknaes - being there to brighten up the day, like sunshine
caring for someone, grieving with someone as a band member without having to share words just through looking at each other and to each other, is I think one of the truest forms of love. their bond is so strong and it warms my heart seeing them sharing this bond on stage but also hurts me
everytime i see wonwoo cry because of his mom.. i cry a lot too.. my cousin died at 16 the same date wonwoo's mom died.. it's really hard to accept.. it's untimely.. he was just 16.. he's just starting to enjoy life..
I think it's a bit unfair on Wonwoo part, knowing that it will hurt him again and cry again seeing something like this, he's still longing for his mother seeing other members mother's message and photos really triggers his sadness..."for me" staff should a little bit sensitive and considerate before making that... well this is just my opinion... I just felt so heartbroken seeing him crying and sobbing like that... coz for someone who lost his mother there's no healing from that he just keeps moving on that's why it's always a fresh sadness to him... as I'm typing this today is mother's day... I just wanna say to Wonwoo's mother thank you for giving birth and raising a very wonderful child,,, Thank you and happy mothers day to all of mothers out there...
I STAN THE BEST GROUP,I STAN THE BEST GROUP!!!i feel wonwoo pain because the hardest thing in our life is losing a parent, you don't know when the wound will heal because every day time passes, you can't avoid that you will always remember and miss the days when you were happy with your parents, tears will suddenly fall you and cry on one side that's what i've been experiencing until now since my father lost it hurts because your parents also hurt because you weren't by his side when he lost you didn't say how thankful you are that you became my father how much i love him,until now i missed him and i want to see him,hug my father but iknow ican't😔 Virtual hug to wonwoo iknow the pain still there like mine,😭🤧🤧🤍🤍i missyouu Dad
처음엔 너무 많이 울어서 마음이 아프기도 했지만 전체 과정을 보면서 마냥 슬픈 것보단 오히려 더 마음이 따뜻해졌어요 세븐틴은 누구 한 명 힘든 일이 있더라도 언제 어디서나 옆에서 위로해줄 멤버들이 함께 있다는 점! 앞으로는 웃을 일만 가득하면 좋겠지만 사람 사는 게 어떤 일이 생길지 모르니까 서로 지금처럼 잘 지냈으면 좋겠어요 세븐틴 최고야 ㅎㅎ 이 노래 끝나고 인터뷰에서는 또 서로 때문에 웃고 있어서 저도 울다 웃다 했어요 그래도 행복한 일만 가득하자 얘들아 캐럿들도 행복만 가득하길! ㅎㅎ
I really admire SEVENTEEN and I'm so happy to be Carat💎...let's support them with lots of love and let's be happy forever, Carat is always with SEVENTEEN no matter what💎❤
omg the carat crying represents all of us she cries with all he heart ahhhhh stop i am crying noooo the sobs when both woozi and wonwoo were hugging broke my heart in every way it hurts to hear their sobs
I've lost both my mom and dad just one year apart, 20 and 21 years ago. Seeing Wonwoo in such pain, I wish I could comfort him and all who are going through such heartache right now. All my love for Wonwoo and everyone who needs it. And please know that they're never truly gone because we are part of them - and they are part of us, forever. And one day you will wake up with a loving smile on your face and you start realising that the sadness is softened by so many fun and loving memories you thought you had forgotten. Share those precious memories with your loved ones and friends, and let the love and laughter reach Heaven as they all watch over us. I still miss my parents and I will till the day we meet again, but I am also relieved and grateful that they are no longer suffering with pain. And more than everything, I am a mother myself, and my two sons and I often talk about our memories of my parents. All my love to anyone who may need it. 💗💗💗💗💗
I lost my mum at 11. Although I can't exactly relate to the pain that Wonwoo faced, I know how heartbroken and empty he felt. It's like losing one of the most important parts of your life forever. No one will answer you anymore when you call “mum”. I was not a fan of Seventeen when I saw this video last year on Instagram. But the scene where Wonwoo cried made my heart, which also reminded me of the time I lost my mum. However, I am glad that he has 12 brothers beside him and will always be beside him. It’s 2024 now and Wonwoo becomes happier day by day. I'm so grateful to see him recover from the pain❤️ Wonwoo ah! Please be happier than anyone else!
「Carat Land」 should be an island of happiness, not a place where the company's behind-the-scenes planners manipulate and gain profits... 0312 I use a worse analogy: the hybe or Pledis staff dug the dead from the cemetery less than a year old, put it in front of the relatives, reminded and hurt him (and his relatives) again🔪. and the dead can be used in exchange for more benefits . From 95's chilly expressions and speeches, it can be seen that they didn't know beforehand and were angry.
S.Coups said that the staff were laughing... I was not at the scene so I don't know if it is true or not, but the fact is that many people watching have normal morals and feel very sad and poor perception 。 I can only bless the family members of the decision-making staff (or company) with good health and immortality, or they have been born orphans and never had family members. Otherwise, I will smile all over my face 。 In case some employees see this comment, they are not qualified to be angry and refute, because this is what you have done to others
I thought that too that this wasn't right, Wonu has been through hell what was the point of reminding him again of his wounds, he was smiling before this Vcr and suddenly he was broken again, the fans and members vcr was enough like day 1 and 2, this was so wrong🙁
I couldn't understand well what Scoups was saying but i could see from Jeonghanie face that we was not happy and they were not aware of this. I do think that it was unsensitive for wonwoo they should think more carefully circle is already a meaningful and tough song to hear.
I might have a different opinion here, I have read some comments here talking about how inconsiderate the staff but I guess it is inevitable and I think its a best way to sum up the concert. I guess the main message of the staff is aside with each other, their family is their first fan, support and pillar from the very beginning. Their family is the one that they can turn back to when the world is against them. That aside with the svt members they always have their family. It’s heartbreaking that Wonwoo lost his mother but this video shows that not only he gains an angel but he also gains a battalion of people empathizing with him. I really have a soft spot with the 96-liner. They always have this calm energy around them that pulls you with them.
I think if it hadn’t been a surprise, even just to Wonwoo, it would have been better received. I want to believe it came from love that the staff arranged this, but with the timing, it was guaranteed to get an emotional response. I wasn’t even a Carat and I immediately saw this everywhere. As someone who just lost a parent, I wanted to fight the staff. It just felt a bit inconsiderate of Wonwoo as a human.
I think the surprise was one thing, but zooming in on the crying faces of the members was a bit... exploitative. Especially if they know (they should) what this song means to Wonwoo and seventeen as a whole
I don't mean to offense at all I'm very New to this group but do we see Wonwoo's mom on the screen when their parents appear??? It must be very hard for him.. 8:10
I can't imagine why some fangirls cried too much more than Wonwoo when their mothers are still alive!!! They should feel lucky when they still have their mothers... Please don't try to act and become outstanding over other people's pain!!!
Maybe they went through the same pain of losing someone, empathy can cause tears too. You dont know the carats that can be heard crying in the video. But surely they can relate and understand it that's why they cried.
It call empathy, you don't feel like that, doesn't mean the others can’t, you don’t know them, you don’t know what they have been through, you don’t have the right to say that. They are not act and become outstanding over, it just you are a heartless person.
I can understand what you mean, but you're not acknowledging such a primary emotion which is empathy. Of course, fans who haven't lost their mother won't understand the kind of devastating sadness Wonwoo must be feeling. So no, they're not crying because they're pretending to feel the same way, they're crying because they're witnessing such a sad moment, they're seeing a person they care about and look up to break down because of his pain, crying... it's not easy! Have you never wanted to cry seeing a loved one break down in tears before you? Have you never cried or at least felt sad seeing a tragic scene in a movie even though you didn't experience the same thing ? One more thing, it's not like the fans were crying in front of Wonwoo, or filming themselves to get attention... they were crying all by themselves in the background.
This is called empathy, imagine the pain and depression someone has been through after losing a family member who has been supporting them and giving their life to them when they enter this world. I’m pretty sure Wonwoo does have a hard time letting go but he will gradually get over it 💔💔💔
