In my opinion, Wangxian (audio drama): beautiful Wuji (drama): powerful Xian Yun (donghua): sad (also it's the closest to how wangxian was described in the novel) All the 3 are amazing adaptations nonetheless ❤️
Also to y'all who are a bit thrown off by the fact that the donghua theme is sang by Hita: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-6TliXs5zr2o.html Here's the official WWX and LWJ version, sang by their official voice actors.
Same...I read in the novel that the song is named wangxian, heard the song from the RU-vid, then saw the donghua and kept on wondering how they were so different but are mentioned as the same song and then finally saw the live action which is completely different from the other two until someone finally told me that the wangxian I heard first was from the audio drama and everything made sense
Audio version feels like how Lan Zhan fought for Wei Ying against all odds. Live version feels like the yearning and unsaid emotions of Lan Zhan towards Wei Ying. Donghua version feels like a memory, how Lan Zhan would always remember their past and his faithful love since the day he laid his eyes on Wei Ying. Any versions of this story is always a masterpiece, but the CQL has stolen my heart forever. I keep saying this but The Untamed is like a memory I didn't have but felt belonged.
I love all 3 adaptions of MDZS. In my opinion, I really liked live-action. Although it's censored but Yibo and Xiao Zhan did a really good job of showing their emotions to each other. Their eyes spoke it all, their emotions are too real. It just proves that you don't need to roll on the bed naked to be a BL. Sometimes love isn't all about sex...but yes...I would like them to hold hands, hugged and kiss each other like a boyxgirl XianXia novel but censorship won't allow that.
I think the director didn’t try to be subtle at all, just avoid explicit dialog/context. Pushing as far as he could with Chinese censorship. My 60 yrs old mom can sense that it’s BL and I told her nothing 😂
@@fearnes.5272 My mom said the same LMAO She saw me watching it and there was scene in the special where LWJ got drunk and confessed and WWX held his hand assuring him, it's not his fault... My Mom: Are they a couple....awww
Xiao Zhan Gege ♡ moms always know while my dad, watching alongside my mom since we’re all quarantine and got bored...after 50 ep he still can’t remember WWX name 😂😂
@@fearnes.5272 You know how the drama starts with the death of WWX, and LWJ is holding him with that desperate expression on his face? My fiance asked me if or simply affirmed they're in love or something XDD I don't think i knew because i first discovered the donghua and then the drama, though we watched first the drama. I forgot which episode I/we got the confirmation though lol
The donghua version might be my favorite lyric-wise because of how beautiful this part is: “Unfortunately, time waits for no one Nothing can stay If I can use my entire life to wait for you Will you be willing to exchange a glance with me? So when I wake from my dream I'm not left with nothing”
This part of the lyric really hits well with their romance 😭Idk why but everytime I hear the Wangxian (donghua song)I would tear up🥹...Its so beautiful I love it
The donghua wangxian really grabs my heart and refuses to let go T_T I have listened to the LWJ version (male version) and you know, the translated english lyrics just makes me cry. "If I gave you my life, would you please just notice me?" Lan Zhannnnn T_T
This is only my impression. But just imagine. These songs written by Wangji are representing the three stages of Wei Wuxian's life; Youth, Death, and Resurrection/Reincarnation. Just....Wow.....my heart......😭
@@cristinaewican2285 oh yes I am. Nice to know you. I literally live in Untamed world. I watch them, bts, a member of many untamed communities on fb, made a few friends.l, share daily with them ... going to buy something related to TU 😅
@@nurfatehahnasir2630 suibian subs has the audio drama translated, but you have to create a discord account, the instructions are on their page as well.
Audio drama song - cute Live drama song - very lively and meaningful Donghua - so fucking painful...have u people seen the lyrics???? 😭😭 Pls I am obsessed with this story😢 Edit- ok that's alot of likes thank u soo much!!
All these version are wonderful ✨ my personal opinion is that: the audio drama's one is the most beautiful the drama's one the most famous but the donghua's the more similar to the one described in the original novel anyway ❤
i think the drama one followed the novel perfectly but just more it's just much more detailed to connect all the pieces together at the climax of the show
the audio drama one will always be the most special to me... the line where lan zhan says "they say you were a disobidient and free spirit but you were filled with chaos inside" (may not be direct so apologies, its just what i've gotten from eng translations) breaks my heart over and over everytime i hear it
Does anyone else love the fact that all 3 adaptions of the song Lan Zhan composed for Wei Ying (wangxian) spell out the abbreviation for Wei Ying’s courtesy name (Wei WuXian). WWX! WangXian (audio drama)=W Wu ji (live action drama)=W Xian yun (donghua)=X
This is crazy that all versions are super hit because most of the time when a movie or drama or whatever it is got hit their second versions are usually not go up like first one but THE UNTAMED made history by breaking the bridges in all kinds & their fans growing day by day.
@@happytia god now that u mentioned it, i still cant imagine how hard it must've been for the main actors, especially xiao zhan. They suffered a lot with the sudden rising of fame.
三首都很棒。广播剧的两句词尤其令我感动。”千帆过还天真“ 说的是魏婴。”十年梦未觉冷“说的是蓝湛。 All the songs are amzing. Just two lyrics from the Audio Drama touched me the most. "I have expericed all the things but still keep an innocent heart" - this is a summary of WeiYing, "I have dreamed of you for ten years and still feel warm when think about you" - this is a summary for LanZhan.
wuji is always gonna be that nostalgic song which reminds me of wangxian more than the other songs since i was introduced to mdzs and danmei in general through the live action
Audio drama killed it, it's the first yet still wearing it's crown. You can just feel the love and effort that went into the adaptation. If not for the novel, it would be my favourite. As for donghua, I liked the cave version a lot and I have a theory (I really hope it comes true!) that we'll get Xianyun male version as our opening for s3.
everyone in the comments picking their favourite versions meanwhile im here just glad that there's a video with all three versions since i can't pick XD
Am I the only one that thinks the last version sounds like someone else is retelling their love story? And there is a mans voice in the background. Prolly Lan Zhan in the past.
Hehhh!?!dont you guys like the donghua???but its nice espicially if its music /video backround shows Young master Wei wuxian and Lan wangjis romantic and affectionate moments together
Same, that song was composed by Lan Zhan, so it being sung by a female doesn't feel the same. Don't get me wrong, Hita is a wonderful singer, but that song feels best when sung by a male.
Audio drama: Powerful and soulful. Wei Wuxian's return and the start of their romance. It's their song to the end. Live action: Adventurous and heartfelt. It's their bromance song. Donghua: Melancholic and wishful. It's Lan Wangji's feelings for Wei Wuxian during his absence.
I cry that I have been back for years... yeah since 3 years. The songs, the story, the characters... MDZS is my favorite and I thank the author MXTX who thanked me enormously and I am always in my heart Wangxian. I do not forget how it was the most beautiful and emotions of the best BL despite the censorship. I listen to my 80+ years old.
If I were a random listener without knowing the story, Audio Drama would be my favorite because it’s indeed a beautiful song. But if I were to consider it’s a song made by Lan Zhan, the Donghua version looks to be the most fitting whether be it lyrics, melody, or energy of the song. The energy of the first two songs are just a tad too overpowering for someone like Lan Zhan imo.
my personal favourite is the drama version (i probably have a bias since it was the first ver i watched) but like all three versions are amazing and they really hit you with the feels.
All 3 versions are so different and yet so amazing. Personally, the harmonies and perfect synchronicity of Xiao Zhan and Yibo’s vocals of the live action version always gives me chills. Even watching them perform it live it sounds almost identical to the recording and the timing is exact. They must have worked really hard to get it perfect.
the order of the songs is also how I personally would rank them, I like Wangxian from the audio drama the most, and the song from the donghua i would rank last, cause sadly it is not sung by LWJ & WWX
Does the audio drama one make anyone else cry? like ACTUAL tears, not like tears in your heart but like the ones on ur face? GFJDHGKJSDF sorry but I remember listening to it after finishing the book while I was just getting into danmei novels, so listening to it not only prods on my wangxian heartstrings but also recalls those memories,,, it just sounds nostalgic and makes me want to turn back time and experience it once more T.T
All version is really good. You just have to feel it. When I watched TU my favorite was wuji..I thought other two odd. But after reading manhua WangXian(audio drama) hit me differently. Then I made this two my favorite. But last month I finished the anime...and at last I can feel the song(donghua). It's really really sweet... So I came to a conclusion that all version of WangXian is really really good...all version. The flute tone in wuji, the music in WangXian (audio drama), and the meaning in donghua version....God idk why all this song is so addictive
I am here for the live Action Wei Ying. - #XiaoZhan So many Toxic people in the world might rub their negativity on him. Truly multitalents young man. I hope we have a Legend in The making.
I dunno how to explain it but imo the donghua hit it actually. The lyrics and the song describe how desperate Wangji's love for Wei Ying and make it so sad. This is the first time he's fallin love, it's sweet but suffocating sometimes coz at first it was more like unrequited love for him, so at least he wants to watch Wei Ying from the side even tho Wei Ying doesn't love him back. I think the song more likely describe his love after Wei Ying's death that's why he's recalling all of those memories and don't want to wake up from those sweet dream. For the AD version, it's love song from Wangji's and Wei Ying's POV and some lyrics using a poem, that's make it beautiful and have a deep meaning for me that's why i like this one the most. Also 'avoiding the dust of everyday life’ has same meaning as Wangji's sword. Its describe their old days and Wangji's strong love for Wei Ying. "It turns out that all along, these feelings have actually been about you" describe their love to e/o. So i think this song more likely after Wei Ying is back and Wei Ying began to realize his feeling. For the LA more likely when they are together (?) But there's also some hint of reminiscent of the old days. Excuse my bad english 🙏
Encima cambian de fotos, para que llores más a gusto (y más fuerte) no, no, no señores, esta calidad no la encontramos en cualquier lado 😭😭😭😭😭👌 Amo, amo, amo, amo
I love all the ost. They all so good. They all made me cry. But if i hv to choose audio drama wangxian is my fav. After tht is from donghua. The lyrics for donghua is really hearthbreaking. Tht was LanZhan pure feelings. His pain yearning fo his love to weiying. Not only the story but the song is great as well. One of the best story and drama i hv ever seen.
The audio drama is very beautiful and has such a heartbreaking feel to it imo. The live drama ver. has the feeling of longing the one u love, especially the piano parts that were played throughout the drama were very romantic and beautiful. The donghua is very beautiful, yet very reminiscing. You can just vision the love and memories between the two. They are all beautiful in their own ways❤️
Definitely xian yun is the best in my heart, the best best one. I read manga and listen to the song and just cry myself out :> bcs of LWJ and the kindhearted WWX. Next one definitely Wuji ver of WYB 💙 the manga is worthy reading i means the stroke the drawing everything is on point
Ok hear me out, I am completely in love with all the versions of WangXian but, I have to say my top favourite version is Xianyun (the donghua one) but sung by ZJN! He does it so well and also something hurts even more with a male voice singing it…💗
Yo siento que la version del audio drama es la segunda reencarnación, la del live action cuando eran estudiantes...y la del donghua en el medio, la espera de LanZhan
I love all of them but wangxian from the audio drama has always been my most favourite since a long time...the lyrics just make me so happy PS- Inquiry is another song that pulls my heartstrings from all direction
to me WuJi represents their youth full of adventure and triumphs before the angst kicks in with Xianyun (which i feel is the closest to the novel one) with LWJ yearning and mourning WWX and then finally WangXianTM plays as they reunite and have their happy ending (which still has a lot of melancholy feelings obviously cuz come on their past is just
All three are my favs. One day I'm gonna old. And this realisation hurts me I don't wanna grow old wanna feel this magical fantasy for the rest of my life😭
They are all beautiful, but I feel that 2 wuji has a main melody which could have been hummed in the cave of slaughter and later played on flute. Simple and memorable. I think this is what was really hummed that day, and remembered after 16 years.
Obsessed..That’s how I’m with this 🙈 To the extend that when It comes to my dreams,It means I had a very sound sleep When it comes in my life,I smile forgetting whatever is troubling me And Im a perfectly normal person
2023 here. I was indeed amused by The Untamed Drama although it has been released for past year. I really like the song in every versions. At first I watched the Donghua but couldn't remember much of it after I watch the Live action. Afterall, before I watch the live action it was 1 year ago when I watch the donghua and I really have bad memory to remember such before I got fund on it. I was thinking to re-watch it again, since as I was reading some comments in here that the live action due to its censorship has got some cut outs and it's very different in the donghua, manhua and novel if I am right. Still wouldn't change the fact that every versions is showing a very good meaning on it. That's why I chose them all.
Wangxian es como la parte del amor y la lucha. Wuji de The Untamed (Cql) es como los obstáculos, la vida misma y el amor de ellos entre la desesperanza por buscar la justicia, Inquiry del dongua son los recuerdos de Lan Zhan cuando Wei Ying murió. Algo que une a las tres es que duran unos minutos, pero duelen toda una vida. AMO CADA VERSIÓN DE ELLOS ✨🏮
Wangxian (audio drama): gives me soft lovey dovey feels and rlly highlights their lives afterwards makes me so happy. You could feel the love and tenderness between them that makes u wanna melt Wuji (drama): gives a sense of longing and a salute to their futures and their love for each other. Xian Yun (donghua): makes be bawl my eyes out so much cuz u can fricking FEEL WangJi's yearning and sadness during Wei WuXian's death omg i cant stop crying but its still beautiful😭😭😭😭
Every time a new version starts up, my lips start wobbling and my eyes start tearing up all over again- this is unscientific!! F*ck! How is it 2022 and I’m STILL crying over these two?!
