3 Unsettling TRUE Prom Night Horror Stories 

Ah bro... don't be ashamed.... imma scardy cat as well

I'm desensitized to these videos now, but I still watch them cause I like stories and Mr nightmare's voice is so calming.

Im 33 and I still get night frights were I'm momentarily paralyzed 4:23 .

I'm 39 and use Mr Nightmare as my lullaby alot of nights 😊

I started back in 2015. He’s the best

Slenderman vibes

Sounds like an evil James Bond or something.

Jack Torrance vibes

@@aishlelleto true😭😭

Bro really thought he was patrick bateman,chasing people around with an axe😅😅

💯

Exactly

No no, I wouldn’t even have agreed to go to anyone’s house to begin with. My parents have always done Craigslist transactions in PUBLIC areas, like crowded parking lots or parks.

@@person8834 Damn never thought of it like that. I've been told that you should always buy cars in public parking lots and even some police stations let you do that near their parking lots but i never applied it to craigslist aswell. Thanks for the tip

@@person8834 My police station has locations designated for online transaction meetup spots. I would assume you could do that at any police station and what safer place to meet someone.

@Lavender Trebuchet Me too! Can relate so much

@Lavender Trebuchet tbh that’s sounds a lot better than prom

Sounds like cope for not having a date

@@mrlucid9270 Dont need a date to go to prom.

@@mrlucid9270 you can go to prom with friends or alone

Sadly that outcome only will happen 1% of the time. Beyond satisfying to hear though.

I agree. A lot of the time, these creeps get away, so I’m really glad that stalking idiot Darryl got caught and hauled off to prison. People like that who ruin others lives really disgust me

I’m glad he got 30 years and I’m sure he’s gonna have a rough time in joint but I was really hoping her bfs dad shot him dead

Yeah, Darryl sounds like a particularly nasty stalker, considering he was willing to stalk her to multiple locations. 0_0

honestly some people are just scum

@Unknown being turned down shouldn't be humiliating, he was clearly socially awkward ( among other issues he clearly has ).

@@CaseyRedgrave It shouldn’t be humiliating, but it often is. Especially in high school, as kids can be quite cruel.

@@CaseyRedgrave the point is she could have said no and left it at that it's the fact that they laughed at him to rub salt in wound yes she has a right to say NO but they didn't have to be aholes about it

@@Mimi-kf8ey Also, that one guy who "cheered sarcastically"....

@@AngelxBunnihe’s talking about before he went psycho. No one knew he was like that until after he was humiliated, from what we were told.

Yeah I'm an awkward guy too although I've never really had interest in dating during my School years but he's got a lot more problems beyond that like seriously I don't consider myself a totally mentally stable person but I'd never do anything like that.

Kid clearly has problems. No sane person would come at someone like that.

@@pyramidhead138 cope

You are all weak prey

I don’t care. Also stop talking cringe little girl

I used to jump off with them random sounds n jumpscares he used to do 😂😂 now idk y but he tamed vids a lil bit

@@aultic The only thing that freak me out was the picture of a bike with a boom lol. But that's all. I mean he does not use loud noise like in horror movie. The sound effects are perfect.

​@@roastedlion1 bike with a boom?

No trying to be creepy? That's literally what the point in the channel is...

imagine shooting a man with your last bullet, and he stands there - unfazed!

FAX.

My prom was 10 years ago. Im glad I don't remember much of it.

Never went

How's that?

@Don't Read My Profile Picture Ok I won't.

He's got some nerve, getting all haughty and asking them to leave! Personally, I'd piss him off by refusing and informing him he'll have to call the Cops. And if he tries to physically eject me, I hope he likes singing soprano for the rest of his life...

Was she fat or something? I kind of imagined her being so when they said something about checking the size of the dress

@@evanevanf4033 idky you'd think that when there's nothing to suggest her weight, she just mentioned sizing but that doesn't mean she's fat.

@@evanevanf4033 you realize that skinny girls have to check the size too right? it could’ve been too big or too small for her.

@@spiltmilk0204 well I’m skinny (in case you thought I wasn’t but I guess you wouldn’t be wrong for thinking so: frightening statistics show that my generation, Gen Z, is morbidly obese and suffering a decline in IQ and lifespan. I’m not like that so I guess I have good genetics 😂)

It’s hard to make an actual case with no tangible evidence

Yeah report him for acting suspicious and trying to lure you in, he probably tried do same to other girls and nobody knows how it ended which is sad.

@@teehee1431 It's not to make a case, but make the police aware of him.

Then he‘ll just move places and keep going. You‘re causing more harm this way, contrary to belief. It‘s happened before.

@@SorrowAvenue nah, they're not causing more harm. running away to a new house doesn't erase your identity from whatever list you can get on for that behaviour

When I was delivering pizza's I used to listen to pizza delivery stories lol

​@@terriaki1273 😮😂

@@terriaki1273 that’s lowkey cool lol

Senior year?

Same

And hopefully woman will stop expecting him to make the first move on them and they should make the first move on him. Equality right?!

Yea it sounds like, even though what he did was completely unjustified, they understood that their response to him getting turned down didn’t exactly help anything. I mean, even after being threatened the op still took a step back and looked at it through Joshua’s perspective.

It's stupid imo. Cos Joshua was harassing them. Sure it was embarrassing but the moment a weapon (ie an axe) is used. There is attempt to assault. And they did not want to press charges?!

"Everyone laughed at him" "Tried to peacefully talk it out because he had a weapon" They're human beings for sure but decent is kinda a stretch

They were laughing at him did we watch the same story? Only the op was a decent human being

@@Gawlakman mb it was probably the wrong word to use in this scenario, it means original poster

Why would ALEX even try to think to rape this girl? Why couldn't he just hired an escort?

@@desensitizedanalyser5624 It’s about power and having that control. People like “Alex” don’t want to pay for services, they want control over the situation.

@@mclovinbrown2743 but can't you pay to have control over the situation? And while we're at it, so what! Who haven't wanted any kind of control in their life?!

@@desensitizedanalyser5624 idk if you’re trolling or not but cut it out you’re not funny

Here’s the thing. A pedophile like him chooses to take of advantage of minors because they consider they weak and easily manipulated. They’re kids and they feel they can easily have power over them.

Did you go as Ashley J Williams

Same, never went. But because my school decided to expell and sue me for 70k coz they were tight on money. It went to court and the entire case was dropped because the judge could see it was bs. Entire senior year gone because of that dumbass school. Well, what can you do

​​@@wockboi1999 how tf do you know their middle name?

@@that_little_mf ?

​@@bobograndmanAmigo what did you do to actually get into a case with the school (If this actually is real)

My prom wasn’t canceled, but was a bust. My prom was outside in a cold weather at night. I never had a good prom experience.

Well I’m sure he found some bitch dumb enough to come alone.

I still think that the should have called the Police. I dread to think of him doing the same thing with another young girl. The girl in the story was so lucky that her mother was waiting outside.

@@alisonn43 I know right, I agree. But it was even better that her mother came inside. That’s what actually saved her… if she had stayed in the car, that wouldn’t have made a difference. And yes they should’ve called the police too, not just reported the add

Agreed, that only happened because her mom came in

Moreover I honestly think that Story # 2 would rather fit with Craigslist Horror stories that Mr. Nightmare has shared a number of times. All that scary part didn't happen DURING a Prom Night

Congra"d"ulations!!! Remember not to let others pressure you into what to do next. Do what YOU want to do. And it's ok if you don't know what path you want to pursue - I graduated 10 years ago and I'm still trying to figure it out. We're all trying to figure ourselves out while pretending we have it together. Don't let appearances fool you. And one last piece of unsolicited advice that comes from my own experience: don't go to beauty school. That's all I'm gonna say. 🤪

Good luck on adulthood and stuffs

@@comeflynextome94 thanks man. That’s great advice

Congratulations my little brother is graduating next week ☺️

omg congrats fellow grad!!! i graduate next week!!

Agreed.

I'd agree

agreed

yaas

I think 6,21 million subscribers says enough.

Maybe that’s what horror shows and dramas should do: make stories about male problems and mental issues like depression and isolation and loneliness (women are generally more social then men that’s why autism is considered to be the “extreme male brain”: because it’s the exact opposite.)

To be honest, there are worse things than being laughed at and made fun of (yes, I’ve been laughed at). If you don’t want a public rejection, don’t give a public proposal. Not saying laughing at someone is okay and that those kids weren’t assholes, just that it’s not THAT bad.

Tkl

​@@person8834 other guys theorize that they're sweetening the reaction, because the story is really worded to make him look weird despite the otherwise normal events, So assuming it's real it's likely possible that Josh has experienced way worse by these guys, but those are baseless accusations. I just can't sympathize with someone who goes "We laughed at him, but what did he expect proposing infront of everyone like that" as if that justifies it

@@ghetoknight7801it doesn’t justify it, but they were high school kids and high school kids are dicks. he asked someone who didn’t really show interest in him in a public setting, so the possibility of being made fun of was always there.

🏆 great reward

Amen 🙏🏻😈

I never hear of that story

You DID NOT just referenced Carrie, did you?

​@@kyrohowe3156 he sure did.

My favorite scene is when she gets revenge so satisfying

“Stay out of my shed!”

They are a variety of stories from anywhere unless specifically stated in the description

There was one story that took place in the UK. I don’t know whether most Mr. Nightmare stories take place in the US or at least from the perspective of Americans but it was still pretty interesting to hear a British guy’s horror story

@@murraytc4641 I wish there were more British stories. Being from britain, there’s a range of potential horror stories

Last one is a great idea

​@@nelsondiarrheaexplosiva9481 Those would be great to see. How about Train Ones that haven't been used yet

@@katelynthewhitewerewolf6376 I got one. The Amtrak bathrooms were so disgusting that it looked like poo on the walls. That's a horror story in itself.

Definitely would love to hear update stories from the past!

@@coleworld681 Me too especially with extended adaptions

Chilling Scares is another good channel 👌

Normally when I split up with someone I’m happy , good riddance

It's mostly about control. The fact that they lost the person they felt they had power over drives them crazy and they do unthinkable things to regain it.

Facts. And I miss his voice when I don't hear him for awhile .

Amen to that

May sound counterintuitive, but I actually thank God for Mr Nightmare because I love his videos 😂😂😂

Heck ya

I concur

i hope you’re doing better

You kids are weird

​@@happiness_isabutterfly thank you 🩷

Are you ok?

​@@SkyNinja357 I'm trying, thank you 🥲

Call it Karma, what goes around comes around

I'm glad she got justice too though

​@@josephbletsas6314 I could say the same. Feel bad for the women who didn't get justice

That was a total fabrication… lie of a story it happens but it’s a wash when you hear the lie of a conclusion..

@@josephbletsas6314 Karma is a pagan concept even some Christians say it.

How?

Police usually won't do much unless there's clear evidence, sadly

@@elizabethgirl123i was just about to say :(

Ikr

I had my car stolen by an acquaintance who it turns out had priorly been arrested and at the time was released on parole for car theft of someone else's car. The police in my city not only didn't even attempt to do anything to get my car back, but when he came by to demand I pay him money to get my car back, he attacked me because he thought I called the police and I didn't pay him ENOUGH despite being exactly what he wanted me to pay him... and *I* was the one arrested because I defended myself from being violently attacked by a drug-addicted dealer-cum-car-thief in front of my own apartment complex. EVEN BETTER... While I was in jail and then out on bail dealing with court date after court date, I got called from the jail because only a handful of months after my "stabbing him for stealing my car" he STOLE SOMEONE ELSE'S CAR AND USED IT TO STEAL DRUG-MAKING INGREDIENTS FROM WALMART. But, hey, according to the police I'm the unrelenting perpetual felon and he who is currently in jail for several felony charges across multiple types of criminal actions right this very minute, is completely innocent. I am literally never going to call the police again, because the police have proven that they are utterly useless to do anything to stop actual criminals or prevent actual crimes. Or, perhaps, it's that the police just don't care. Either way, they aren't reliable enough to trust to stop such things.

Monday was exhausting today for me, especially since today was the last day of testing for freshman year of High-School, and here comes Mr. Nightmare for the save. He's the real MVP. 💯

​@@darkclaw1462 I don't have school anymore so I can listen to Mr Nightmare anytime I want.

I mean I was at his shoes at times myself (I'm bad at talking) but I didn't even once consider murdering others and I'm sure many others didn't. Thankfully I did have relationships and friends throughout high school so I didn't feel as lonely

What did Joshua expect though? He literally asked out some random girl he’s never met before in his life infront of a group of people, anyone would laugh during a situation like that

⁠@@Bransaucesauce mean, that’s kinda how dating works sometimes. It’s not like everyone only dates people that they were friends with before hand. Sometimes pre-existing relationships make it hard to start dating. It’s also common for people to promote the idea that you should just put yourself out there and ask and that the worse someone can say is no. Clearly that’s not actually the case. At least not with young and immature people, which is when a lot of dating happens. Even if it was weird, it’s pretty fucked to just start laughing at the kid. That’s definitely bullying and while Joshua was in the wrong, those kids are definitely still complete assholes.

@@tavatavatavi9446 fair point, luckily my crush is one of my friends

@@Bransaucesauce Just because it’s something you should expect, that doesn’t make it right. Whoever wrote the story just gave the typical “boys will be boys” excuse. I don’t care what gender you are or what age you are, laughing at unfortunate people is wrong. Not saying that attacking someone is justified either lol.

I know right.

So true

Well the cops are usually bias against the guys and a lot more lenient towards the girls. I've seen guys get arrested for things but the girls do the same exact crap and all they get is a warning.

This is why the justice system in america is so messed up.

I'd bet you anything he only got that cause it was a cop's house. Had the dad not been a cop I bet he wouldn't have even gotten a fraction of that time.

And going strong! Let's wish him a full health bar and endless boss stories 🤣🤣

He’ll be going strong for as long as humanity stands

@@moonlighthunter5421I'll hold you to that, mister! 🧐🤣

Hope you feel better soon Frank 🙏

Ehhhh Frank? He never said his name… and it’s not even in his profile… kinda sus

It’s not pain but hes like mentally fucked in the head and needs help that isn’t normal what he did😂😂

I felt really bad for him.

At least the author wanted to try to talk to Joshua and make amends with him, but I think Joshua was too embarrassed and humiliated to even wanting to have a conversation with the author and their friends.

Yes

Si'.

You thank him by subscribing to his channel.

Thanks to him

​@@paige172 Yeah he's one of the best.

I never went to prom, and I don't regret it

I never had a prom, my graduating year was 2020

@@Maelstrom9945 Sorry to hear you didn't have prom night

Introverts/socially anxious people can relate :')

​@@paige172 I seen the horror movie Prom Night the 2008 Remake version.

He did have an old (now deleted) video and one of the stories was about a scary event that happened to him.

@@EthanPriccowhat was it about?

@@EthanPricco Really, that pretty cool. If it’s deleted, then maybe he can basically revamp the video of something like that

@@xWingzTV IIRC, it was about a time when he was staying in a trailer in upstate New York and one night when he was home alone a man tried to break into the trailer.

i guess they trust people too much

nothing about that is ironic, unless your prom night was a nightmare

Did you get any? Is that what made it so great u dog you... proud of you

Was it pure Blue Bliss?

@@davidl570 It was bliss, but not blue. The theme was enchanted forest

@@MustacheCashStash125 Cool!

If I may ask, where did the incident occur in?

I second this!

Yes, I'm praying he makes an hour long video someday 🙏

I agree

He never does

Same I never went

@@melissagrant4178 same and I’m happy I didn’t. That night I went out to dinner with my sister instead

@@jasonbaptiste2257 I beat you have a wonderful time with your sister, I just stay home

during the work shift even better if possible lol