5 Surprisingly Expensive Cards You Might Have Lying Around 

Have these cards? Follow this link to go directly to each of their listings on the website: bit.ly/3yR2CIu

11:00 The weird interaction with counters and Undying makes for a pretty powerful Pauper combo deck. Putrid Goblin is a 2/2 with Persist, which is Undying but -1/-1 counters. Skirk Prospector lets you sacrifice a Goblin to gain R mana. First Day of Class puts a +1/+1 counter on every creature that ETB's under your control. Since adding a +1/+1 counter to a card with a -1/-1 counter on it removes the counter, Putrid Goblin is able to Persist indefinitely so it can be sac'd over and over for infinite mana. And with an infinitely recurring minion and infinite mana there's gonna be some way to win the game with a Fireball type effect or even Makeshift Munitions. Makeshift Munitions is funnier because I imagine a zombie goblin being fired out of a cannon over and over and over again...

Stuff I found in my old box of cards, back in 2017, when I looked after not having checked since 2002, Lions Eye Diamond, 4x Grim Monolith, Wheel of Fortune (Rev), Demonic Tutor (U), Berserk (B) (HP), 5x Force of Will (mint AL), etc ... Lots of stuff like that.

The back-stories of the cards and gameplay usage were really interesting! Thank you, guys.

Suprisingly Expensive - Deadly Dispute. Trend is 4+ Euro And it is a COMMON. And still relatively new. Not some "old-goodies".

Given that the Dominaria United saga is slated to have New Phyrexia centered set, i think Triumph of the Horde price would get skyrocketed. IMO chance are high infect will come back in the newest New Phyrexia set

Recently discovered Pitiless Plunderer when I decided to see what my most expensive uncommon and common cards were. I was surprised it was so much higher than my other uncommons until I read the card. For common, it was Priest of Titania.

Another fun and interesting video, when will the podcast happen? Would love to hear you guys talk about limited too! Much love!

i played back in the 90s, im pretty sure my most expensive card is a revised time walk. Its kinda funny YT recommended this video as i have been thinking about pulling out the collection from storage and seeing what its worth.

Very helpful, guess I have to look through my bulk box this weekend.

Cool video, nice to see you talking magic Toffel!

Was building a tiny bones deck and found a liliana's caress in my box of chuff. Apparently it's quite expensive aswell.

Great video! If i remember correctly i should have plenty of these left in my bulk :D

Number 1 on this list for anyone who played pre-2000, but post-1994 is Rhystic Study. Between 3 collections of older players I picked out 40 of these. It's the sort of card that is sitting in a lot of collections gaining dust as the players don't know how much it's worth, and the players that do have them sitting in their collections will tend to have 4+ too. It's exacerbated too by a lot of the players who have a lot of these sitting as effectively bulk are players that have never played commander, so don't really see its use. Most other expensive commons are cards that are good in 60-card formats so they aren't sitting around in bulk.

I played Pemmin's Aura in my elf deck and equipped to my wirewood channeler and timberwatch elf

I would mention since the guest assumed infect is busted in commander... it's really not. The problem with infect in the format is that unlike other combat based decks, if you're playing infect, your opponents are even less likely to be helping push your ultimate win goal than they would normally be. This is because creatures with infect don't actually reduce your opponent's life total. So if I'm attacking with just generic goblins and the person to my fight is attacking with infect, he's not helping me drop a player's life total, and I'm not helping him add poison counters. I'll add to that the number of creatures that naturally have infect aren't at a real critical mass, and most are relatively small bodies. So most of the time you'll see a win in commander with infect is with Triumph of the Hordes. There are other cards that might take out specific players one by one like Tainted Strike, or other combos of cards like a Blightsteel Colossus + Chandra's Ignition, but in general Triumph of the Hordes is used in a similar way to other overrun style effects that is used as one fell swoop in an attempt to kill everyone at the table at once.

i started lookin for that last black card in my collection, cause it will help my combo Ghave edh

Plunderer is so great, because it works with creature tokens also. WB decks are very happy about that ;-)

Another thing that makes Mikaeus unlikely to be reprinted is intimidate, since they use menace nowadays instead.

Wait? You are in berlin? Deshalb ist Thoralf mit diesem wunderbaren Akzent gesegnet :D

Nice stuff, guys!

Hahaha I’ve bought most of these within the last 5 years so I’m already painfully aware, the plunderer especially.

meint ihr dass die remasurikönigin irgendwann einen reprint bekommt? / do you think the sliver queen will get a reprint?

Just checked one of my Scars' boxes, I have at least 6 Exsanguinates.

Man i went through the cards i had as a kid and though most of it was chaff i found a shock land lol

I know you have done a video on foils, but why is the foil Arboreal Grazer from War of the Spark so expensive. I found one in my bulk and was staggered by the cost.

Seem to recall Mikaeus getting a reprint soon unless i imagined it.

Loved the superman story! Funny enough, Pemmin's Aura and Aether Vial are exactly some of the cards I found in some bulk of mine and friends. Plus a casual Rhystic Study. Mikeaus is also the only good card I ever got from "The List". :P

pls more of them

Interesting that Mikaeus has come down so much over the last year. Even since this videos he's come down from 35 to 20

@8:55 if only they knew......

too bad by the time I decide to dig these out, they will have been reprinted in Double Masters or a Commander set, thus making them worth way less.

Thoralf- Undertaker.

Exsanguinate realy strong and dont say black mana tron black realy good lol

"Yeah I know who Superman is"

Solemnity + mikeaus opens so many doors

I saw this and the Fortnite sld in there same day...

Why you said big money when the card value is low 5 euro is not big money.

My whole collection is expensive…

I'm sorry but the two of you saying that wizards 'cant' reprint something is uterally stupid. There are half a dozen reprint sets now a year but including camander sets for every set that include new and reprinted card, commander sets and commander reprint sets that don't hold to a theme. And the holding to a theme is both completely arbitrary and a lie as every set has random cards that have nothing to due with that set theme wise. For the last three to four years the cards could easily been printed in the plethora of side products, you spouting wotc bullshit shows your a consumer not a customer who will buy every lie as they could come out tomorrow with a reprint set with every card that needs a reprint. Nothing but the value in the secondary market is stoping them, drop the bs