Тёмный

7 Ways To Pull Carbon From The Atmosphere | Random Thursday 

Joe Scott
Подписаться 1,9 млн
Просмотров 693 тыс.
50% 1

Get 20% of a premium subscription to Brilliant when you're one of the first 200 people to sign up at www.brilliant.org/answerswithjoe
If we are ever going to return the atmosphere to pre-industrial levels, we have to take out some of the carbon we've already put into the sky. Still, carbon capture is a controversial topic and one that many people know very little about. So let's look at 7 carbon capture methods and how they work.
Learn more about the Carbon Removal XPrize here:
www.xprize.org/prizes/elonmusk
Watch this video ad-free on Nebula: nebula.tv/videos/joe-scott-7-...
Want to support the channel? Here's how:
Patreon: / answerswithjoe
Channel Memberships: / @joescott
T-Shirts & Merch: www.answerswithjoe.com/store
Join me on the Our Ludicrous Future Podcast:
/ @ourludicrousfuture
Interested in getting a Tesla? Use my referral link and get discounts and perks:
ts.la/joe74700
Follow me at all my places!
Instagram: / answerswithjoe
Snapchat: / answerswithjoe
Facebook: / answerswithjoe
Twitter: / answerswithjoe
LINKS LINKS LINKS:
techcrunch.com/2021/01/21/elo...
www.npr.org/2021/02/08/965372...
www.nature.com/articles/s4155...)
www.anthropocenemagazine.org/...
climate.nasa.gov/news/2927/ex...
science.sciencemag.org/conten...
cropwatch.unl.edu/2019/cover-...
www.sare.org/resources/cover-...
www.nature.com/articles/s4159...
www.nature.com/articles/d4158...
qz.com/1718988/algae-might-be...
www.wri.org/blog/2020/06/6-wa...
www.wri.org/blog/2020/10/ocea...
www.intechopen.com/books/co2-...
www.carbonbrief.org/direct-co...
news.mit.edu/2019/mit-enginee...
physicsworld.com/a/biomass-en...
www.carboncure.com/

Наука

Опубликовано:

 

15 июн 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 3,2 тыс.   
@SirMatthew
@SirMatthew 3 года назад
"Seement" Yeah you're not slipping that one past me Joe
@ethanurmson9342
@ethanurmson9342 3 года назад
So that’s what the carbon industry is spewing all over our faces
@Ingcivilcarlos
@Ingcivilcarlos 3 года назад
I came to the comments just to say that. Sneaky Joe
@myscreen2urs
@myscreen2urs 3 года назад
Semen...t. He must've been still thinking of the tangent cam bit.😁
@zomb_bree7950
@zomb_bree7950 3 года назад
SAME
@ArealMrsSmith
@ArealMrsSmith 3 года назад
That’s honestly how most Texans pronounce “cement”.
@Lethgar_Smith
@Lethgar_Smith 3 года назад
If you walk around the forests of New England you will constantly come across stone fences running randomly through the forests. These are the remains of old farms. During the colonial period they would clear these forests for firewood and building material and then plow the cleared land for farming. However, the soil of New England is very rocky and the fields had to be cleared of the rocks before it could be plowed. Therefore the rocks were dug up out of the soil and piled into fences along the borders of the farmers land. This was back breaking work. I remember trying to repair an old stone fence on my property and I found the majority of the stones were too heavy to lift by myself. As Americans moved further west the vast majority of these farms were abandoned for land easier to work. However the fences remain to remind us of a time when New England was largely deforested for farming.
@Jack-tm4er
@Jack-tm4er 3 года назад
I see them everywhere around southern new york! Every now and again you'll see a giant tree probably a couple hundred years old, around the newer trees, the ones planted after they deforested for farmland.
@minecrafttutorialsandhaxfo1735
@minecrafttutorialsandhaxfo1735 3 года назад
wow
@goofygoob0373
@goofygoob0373 3 года назад
They are so beautiful when they're taken care of
@Snugggg
@Snugggg 3 года назад
We have the same thing in old england too! farm fences made with back breaking labour :D except not many are reforrested unfortunatly. we just have lots of empty fields.
@venturefanatic9262
@venturefanatic9262 3 года назад
You forgot about the part of Killing off the Indigenous Humans first.
@JD3Gamer
@JD3Gamer 2 года назад
I saw a study recently that looked at trees ability to fight climate change and it showed that forests help to release more moisture into the atmosphere creating more cloud cover which helps to reflect more light from the sun. It basically was showing that there’s more benefits to planting trees than just carbon capture.
@skiptheroad
@skiptheroad 2 года назад
Shade
@destructorzz7197
@destructorzz7197 Год назад
Water vapour is a greenhouse gas so the benefits of this are probably negligible. Might be helping to block light but also traps more infrared so comes out pretty neutral
@TheWhiteDragon3
@TheWhiteDragon3 3 года назад
In Iowa where I live, our farmers plant a LOT of soybeans, and while they're not _technically_ being planted as cover crops since the soybeans are being sold for profit, in all effective regards they're an incredible cover crop. They're a legume, so they enrich the soil not just through carbon capture but also through nitrogen fixation, and if the soybeans can either be used for making people food or for feeding livestock.
@andyiswonderful
@andyiswonderful 3 года назад
But that carbon capture is only fleetingly temporary. Eventually, the CO2 of that biomass gets returned to the atmosphere through microbial metabolism.
@dividedconquered3784
@dividedconquered3784 3 года назад
Soy beans are expensive! We need less meat and fish! To make 70% of the wild back to full diversity! It is at 40% right now! 😏
@Aconitum_napellus
@Aconitum_napellus 3 года назад
@@dividedconquered3784 Cannibalism is carbon neutral.
@fortwoodmisery
@fortwoodmisery 3 года назад
@@Aconitum_napellus only self cannibalism.
@rolandsalomonsson3854
@rolandsalomonsson3854 3 года назад
@@dividedconquered3784 No! Humanity needs MORE meat. That kind of fat is needed to make our brains grow in intelligense. At least 40% of our food have always been meat. It´s not about any kind of protein, it must be MEAT! All steps of human civilisations have started with new kinds of using meat. First step was to grill meat. Men made hunting-parties and got the 40%. Women gatherred the other 60% of food.
@localsymbiosis
@localsymbiosis 3 года назад
I almost spit out my coffee at the “carbon spewing all over our faces” part. I love this channell
@adrianruiz4144
@adrianruiz4144 3 года назад
same
@Twinkcentral
@Twinkcentral 3 года назад
Well, you do have carbon-spewing all over your face, every time you breathe out.
@kayfrenly5460
@kayfrenly5460 3 года назад
Climate change activism is a racist plot to try to keep many PoC countries from changing to better climates.
@jimmjimms
@jimmjimms 3 года назад
Love it
@rolandsalomonsson3854
@rolandsalomonsson3854 3 года назад
More CO2 on Earth. Look above!
@adamlytle2615
@adamlytle2615 3 года назад
Me: You know, Joe doesn't really sound like he's from Texas Joe: See-ment Me: There it is.
@joescott
@joescott 3 года назад
Hehe, yep. It comes out sometimes.
@OG-vb1pl
@OG-vb1pl 3 года назад
Classic old joe
@shoam2103
@shoam2103 3 года назад
Paused at 22:00 just to see if someone posted a comment about this. Not disappointed!
@shoam2103
@shoam2103 3 года назад
For a moment, I thought he was making a pun tho.. To match the earlier one about Sex-ed. You know about the CC. Carbon c-
@phantomwalker8251
@phantomwalker8251 3 года назад
@@shoam2103 if you get this,read my comment to joe,,its shocking..
@samanthabeamish8631
@samanthabeamish8631 2 года назад
Really enjoyed this video. I am a farmer in Canada but also went to school for environmental engineering. We do our best to protect our water and soil but I had never thought much about ways to decrease carbon in the air. This is very interesting and I will think and do more research on it. Thanks! Also, thank you for your respect. It seems farmers always get blamed for all environmental problems without people realizing they are the ones who need the food or that most farmers also care and have made many improvements over the years.
@jamesspry3294
@jamesspry3294 Год назад
Good on you Samantha! Look up Gabe Brown, and also Joel Salatin. They are legendary regenerative farmers in North America. (I'm a regen farmer in Aus, so what I do is not really applicable...) Cheers!
@Sniperboy5551
@Sniperboy5551 Год назад
Of course you never thought about it, nobody really cared until a decade or two ago!
@retrocentral
@retrocentral 3 года назад
Ecosia: Search engne that plants trees. OceanHero: Search engine that pulls plastic out of the ocean.
@sirmongrel511
@sirmongrel511 3 года назад
I'm up to 275 trees since making Ecosia my default a two months ago.
@johndododoe1411
@johndododoe1411 3 года назад
Those are just economic pseudosolutions, using good cause donations as an excuse to profit from people believing the marketing. Doesn't mean the good cause they donate to isn't good and worthy, merely that other ways to send money to the cause are probably smarter.
@timothysummers3807
@timothysummers3807 3 года назад
So satisfying seeing Joe get the following he deserves.
@shxtgigs4662
@shxtgigs4662 3 года назад
I’m only upset that I didn’t find joe earlier
@dakotajones2487
@dakotajones2487 3 года назад
It's a long time coming I've been watching for a good bit
@happyundertaker6255
@happyundertaker6255 3 года назад
I represent this insinuation..
@AwesomeBlackDude
@AwesomeBlackDude 3 года назад
00:10 Here's the benchmark of this above post commentary and your welcome 😷
@_JamesBrown
@_JamesBrown Год назад
Found him last week and I'm on a hard binge!
@JacobJames8
@JacobJames8 3 года назад
I literally just taught a two hour lesson on CCS, then I login to RU-vid and find the video! Guess what the students homework is!
@Kavriel
@Kavriel 3 года назад
Damn, if my homework had been watching educational youtube content, my scholarity would have been great/better.
@benjaminriches9736
@benjaminriches9736 3 года назад
If I could just sit and watch Joe Scott for homework, I’d love life.
@knowa24
@knowa24 3 года назад
Start with Joe Scott and then learn the maths with the organic chemistry tutor.
@simonmorgan225
@simonmorgan225 3 года назад
Washing your car?
@paulhaynes8045
@paulhaynes8045 3 года назад
I hope it's going to be a critical analysis of why Joe is dodging the real problem with CO2 by pretending magic tech is going to help?
@TrustyPumpkin
@TrustyPumpkin 3 года назад
“Of course, that would make the carbon...,,Eww.” Lol
@MrGreenutedave
@MrGreenutedave 3 года назад
As a Farmer who has been using cover cropping and spreading basalt recently I found this pretty interesting. No incentives to do it from government or anywhere else, it just makes sense.
@Sciencerely
@Sciencerely 3 года назад
As a stem cell biologist, I think it's fascinating that we might be able to combat CO2 emissions through synthetic biology. Plants contain a set of unique genes which enable them to convert CO2 into sugars. Recently, scientists have introduced the same genes into bacteria thereby also giving them the ability to consume CO2 (I made a video about this). Although this technology is still quite ineffective and in its early stages, we could use it in larger scales to reduce CO2 emissions one day!
@fredbloggs5902
@fredbloggs5902 3 года назад
1) You still have to put it in sunlight somewhere 2) Efficiency is low
@rhaven090
@rhaven090 3 года назад
Just exploit the gene editing market and make profit And with it gene that enables us to use carbon dioxide for energy will be developed along the way Just imagine gullible consumers tryna edit themselves to oblivion in the next decade.
@crackedemerald4930
@crackedemerald4930 3 года назад
What *haven't* you made a video on?
@phillip6083
@phillip6083 3 года назад
But then what?biofuel?plastic?so it's more a carbon neutral tech then?
@GhostScout42
@GhostScout42 3 года назад
Forests move the water from oceans to inland areas. Planting forests may be necessary just to fight droughts in the coming millennia
@nokaton
@nokaton 3 года назад
Planting forest causes more problems that solving it, because oftentimes they either plant wrong alien species or plant only one species (monoculture) which do more harm to the ecology in the area. The correct way to solve it is just leaving nature to be restored by itself. Literally, just leave them alone. Everything we human touches, it's screwed up.
@Aconitum_napellus
@Aconitum_napellus 3 года назад
@@nokaton So you plant a mixture of indigenous trees.
@nokaton
@nokaton 3 года назад
​@@Aconitum_napellus Good in theory but not practical. By making some kind of artificial plantation, the plants need to be taken care of. You need an irrigation system, because you 'force' the plants to grow there. The aim is to restore the original ecosystem, not turning it into another kind of agriculture (monoculture or either mixed plant). The point is that the original ecosystem is more much much more diverse than what we can imitate. Letting the area to regrow plant by it self is better. The ecosystem can restore itself; plants can regrow without human intervention. I do not argue that, if it has been done enough correctly, it won't be good. But the strategy like mass planting would rather give worse outcomes, as more people involve, or either politics, it would lead to poor bureaucracy and poor management. (It already did happen in my country). You will end up in monoculture of alien plants. (don't underestimate bureaucracy).
@rolandsalomonsson3854
@rolandsalomonsson3854 3 года назад
NO! Forrests do not "move" any water from oceans onto inland areas. It´s another process. When it rains in extream dry areas, the rainwater will evapourate in just some days. Only a minimum of that rain will go into the ground, if any, and build up subsoil water. NOTE! In most dessert areas there are enough rain to keep up forrests. That´s where humans have to help nature get those areas re-forrested. You have to plant trees! There are some "rules" to follow in order to get a happy result! Among others: * Forrests build up it´s own water suply * Choose trees species who can resist ground fires as most as possible. Mostly because it´s rootsystems sticks right down under the tree, and not grows wide near it´s stem. * The army have to protect the growing forrest from grassing cattles, especially goats. * The trick is to let tree species grow which protect from sun burning the ground. * Another trick is to build a lot of ponds up in the hills, where you can see old creeks etc have once flowed. They will catch a lot of water when it rains and not let it flow down too quickly. Then a lot of water will build subsoil water. Also start plant the right kind of trees round every pond. * To re-forrest a dessertarea needs time. That is possible to reduce. Build a coalplant and supply a system of pipelines from the oceans into the dessert areas. Then desalt that water and fill a lot of ponds/inlandsea´s. Better with coalplant, which can produce a lot of CO2 to spread around the dessert areas. Trees grow a lot faster then. Every professional vegetable grower knows that. * It´s also possible to make a cold area "warmer" if you plant the right species of tree. For ex northern half of Siberia was a normal forrested area where it today is tajga during the ice-age. But it´s only possible if there lives the right kind of animals, like mamuths, wolly rhino´s and especially the american bison. In fact russia have started a large project in Siberia about 50 years ago, where imported bisons now are re-moddeling large areas into steps and forrested areas. Bisons eat "bad" species and leave the good species.
@rolandsalomonsson3854
@rolandsalomonsson3854 3 года назад
@@nokaton Read my post above!
@ALT-fp9vc
@ALT-fp9vc 3 года назад
I am an agrologist and the part about cover crops was well summarize. Good video and thanks for your good work :)
@susantait1987
@susantait1987 3 года назад
I’m the furthest thing from educated in all of this but, tell me Joe, how do you manage to scare the shit out of me and give me hope at the same time?? Keep up the good work and let all of us “ commoners” know what we can do to turn this beautiful ship we call home around. Thank you for just being an “average, concerned joe”. You represent so many of us!
@altortugas5979
@altortugas5979 3 года назад
“Spewing carbon all over our faces” is the best laugh I’ve had this year 😂
@getsmartr
@getsmartr 3 года назад
I love how moderate your videos are. I know that doesn't sound like a compliment but I don't feel like you have any hidden motives. It's all out in the open. In a word, honest. It's refreshing and I appreciate it.
@mtiedemann11
@mtiedemann11 3 года назад
And evidence based - far too little of that these days
@richardlangley90
@richardlangley90 3 года назад
I agree. Dave Borlace of Just Have a Think is the same that way.
@darksu6947
@darksu6947 3 года назад
He's a paid shill!
@GimmieUtoob
@GimmieUtoob 3 года назад
I never would have thought I’d hear a joke about facials in one of these videos.
@vaunniethayer1484
@vaunniethayer1484 Год назад
Joe, you give me hope for the future, you are an amazing teacher/ communicator. Thanks for educating us all.
@Ulmaramlu
@Ulmaramlu 3 года назад
"ever heard of trees?" is the carbon capture version of the retail customer joking "does that mean its free?" when the scanner doesn't work.
@phantomwalker8251
@phantomwalker8251 3 года назад
cant have scanners without a forge,metals.ect..
@TMS9918A
@TMS9918A 3 года назад
By customer, you mean boomer, right? That's totally boomer humor (not funny or clever in the slightest)
@Ulmaramlu
@Ulmaramlu 3 года назад
@@TMS9918A Nope I mean customer. never called anyone boomer, never plan to. same with calling someone "a Karen". Derogatory terms rub me the wrong way
@c.s1393
@c.s1393 3 года назад
@@Ulmaramlu waah waah
@jamesrempel8522
@jamesrempel8522 3 года назад
@@TMS9918A Maybe, but I've heard plenty of gen-Xers and millennials use that sort of humour too.
@MyPoposo
@MyPoposo 3 года назад
I feel like carbon capture is less of a condom and more of a morning after pill...
@Reth_Hard
@Reth_Hard 3 года назад
Yeah, what about planting trees? Hehehehehhhh...
@robbirose7032
@robbirose7032 3 года назад
Either way we are fucked.
@iamtheleuz
@iamtheleuz 3 года назад
Did you actually pay attention to the video?
@MyPoposo
@MyPoposo 3 года назад
@@iamtheleuz yea! and I really liked it! learned some about new technologies for carbon capture and had some good laughs!
@Leopold5100
@Leopold5100 3 года назад
@Genie Le Bottle after its been left in there for far too long ................
@viknumbers701
@viknumbers701 3 года назад
The answer is to use a variety of cost effective carbon capture techniques appropriate to the climate, bio and geo environments and available technologies.
@jimmage7430
@jimmage7430 2 года назад
EverGreenCoin will reward you for DIY carbon reduction and sequestering.
@1drumshark
@1drumshark 2 года назад
Partially yes, but reversing climate change will not be cheap. Acting as if it could be will just be used to wait until it's too late
@jimmage7430
@jimmage7430 2 года назад
@@slevinchannel7589 no but am always happy to learn new stuff. I have just paid people for composting, using char and, mulch in no till zones.
@troyward8349
@troyward8349 Год назад
Someone out here really appreciates what you’re doing, and how you’re doing it. Good job. Keep after it.
@FackFaceMcAcehole
@FackFaceMcAcehole 3 года назад
I use Joe to help as background sound to fall asleep. And then I rewatch when I wake back up. I don't know what that means about me, but at least he has a soothing voice.
@raghavgupta5808
@raghavgupta5808 3 года назад
It's strange but so very true.
@3ri10
@3ri10 3 года назад
Haha same.
@joescott
@joescott 3 года назад
Maybe I should play my own videos to help me sleep.
@na195097
@na195097 3 года назад
Doing this right now.
@Nunyabeeswax777
@Nunyabeeswax777 3 года назад
I can’t stop thinking of the fact that the best carbon scrubbing machines also create carbon.... and often a lot of it
@cmath4871
@cmath4871 3 года назад
Needs to be combined with nuclear. We now have portable non meltdown producing reactors. Just needs the will and care...
@MiceOnVenus_
@MiceOnVenus_ 3 года назад
@@cmath4871 “the decisions made by the powers-that-be will get to us in the end."
@aronseptianto8142
@aronseptianto8142 3 года назад
i mean ofc, the law of conserved mass, unless you literally nuclear it, carbon is still carbon, however way to move it around the trick is to make the carbon useful in a less messy way
@isaach1447
@isaach1447 3 года назад
@@aronseptianto8142 damnit...I was gonna say that!🤔
@rhoell2050
@rhoell2050 3 года назад
Carbon scrubbing centipede
@natchongsanguan
@natchongsanguan Год назад
Fantastic job, Joe! You are doing all of us a great favor.
@babyruuth
@babyruuth 3 года назад
Congrats on 1 Mil Joe and team!
@alentrav
@alentrav 3 года назад
I missed most of the video because I'm dealing with work stress, but hearing Joe's soothing drone as I stressed out was very nice. Thanks Joe
@swapshots4427
@swapshots4427 2 года назад
Funny, it just occurred to me the other day how I rarely nod off....unless...I'm listening to Joe.
@nameless2259
@nameless2259 3 года назад
This gets a like from me just cause of adult humor
@miroslavhoudek7085
@miroslavhoudek7085 3 года назад
"Instead of bitcoin mining, you can mine sky" *Midnight Oil wants to know your location.*
@ATM648
@ATM648 3 года назад
I just like the sound of mining the sky! I look up and see dollar signs all around!
@bernhardkrickl3567
@bernhardkrickl3567 3 года назад
I'm embarrassed that I didn't think of this. Long time fan here and Blue Sky Mine is one of my favourite songs of theirs.
@stooge_mobile
@stooge_mobile 3 года назад
Joe Scott's audience and Midnight Oil listeners. Surprisingly, there's an overlapping area in that Venn Diagram.
@rapaerawaitai7483
@rapaerawaitai7483 Год назад
Very entertaining and the best talk on the Carbon emissions that i've watched so far
@SabethDrake
@SabethDrake 3 года назад
Hey Joe, long time viewer here. I love and appreciate what you do and one of these days I plan on joining your patreon. Thanks bro
@joescott
@joescott 3 года назад
I appreciate that, thanks!
@S.R.Crnt.
@S.R.Crnt. 3 года назад
Congratulations Joe on your beautiful channel's well-deserved success. It's amazing to see how far you've come since the first time I stumbled upon your 'how to make an old fashioned' video. Which BTW, I did make and turned out so good, I am constantly asked to make one for my friends.
@adamtettamanti2080
@adamtettamanti2080 2 года назад
Joe you rock! I love to laugh&learn and you make it happen.
@Philipp_K
@Philipp_K 3 года назад
Excellent video, thank you! May I suggest a few more ideas? 1. Agroforestry. The planted trees (or bamboo) are fast growing and capture a lot of CO2 in max 2 decades. You can burn them to coal (or use the biomass in a BCCS-Powerplant) and use it as a fertilizer. 2. Basically every engine, that sucks in air, can use a CO2-filter (like the really genius MIT-battery!). That may be a good opportunity for fuel cell vehicles! You'd need a lot of them though... 3. You can plant trees not only on land, but also in the sea. Mangroves grow in seawater, so it would be possible to grow them on artificial floating platforms. The platforms would be a few feet under water held in place by cables. That could work great on continental shelfs and be used even during rising sea levels.
@AdeptXR
@AdeptXR 3 года назад
I stopped mowing the back half of my lawn. I've counted 20+ little trees that are now naturally growing. Plus I use less gas mowing the lawn. It's a start.
@adamwest8711
@adamwest8711 3 года назад
I’m sure your neighbours salute your efforts.
@AdeptXR
@AdeptXR 3 года назад
@@adamwest8711 my only neighbor will soon be out of sight.... when the trees are fully grown lol
@rth0mas
@rth0mas 3 года назад
Some characters do that towards the end of the Overstory (great book). Everyone tries to get them to mow their lawn again. But it’s not what the planet wants or needs
@alwayslearning3671
@alwayslearning3671 3 года назад
I saw one last week about growing kelp on buoys in mid-ocean. The dead leaves would sink into the deep ocean. Once in place, it would just keep running as long as the buoys were there to provide an anchor point for the kelp.
@ricknoyb1613
@ricknoyb1613 2 года назад
I could see turning our Pacific plastic mass into a floating platform for kelp forests. Fight two problems while increasing biodiversity by increasing biospheres in deep ocean areas that do not effectively produce sealife.
@InservioLetum
@InservioLetum 2 года назад
I hadn't heard of seamint before, I learn so much every time I watch your videos!
@malemusa7900
@malemusa7900 2 года назад
Good report Joe!
@AndysRamblings
@AndysRamblings 3 года назад
People often forget that trees can feed us, too. Nuts are some of the most calorie-dense foods. Carbon-sequestration farming = reforestation
@GhostScout42
@GhostScout42 3 года назад
And that they move water from the ocean inland through rain and evaporation
@kensmith5694
@kensmith5694 3 года назад
Don't forget things that are technically bushes and not trees. Some of them produce a very large food harvest.
@DrJohnnyJ
@DrJohnnyJ 3 года назад
Tree farms aren't forests and only capture 2% of the CO2 that a forest would.
@AndysRamblings
@AndysRamblings 3 года назад
@@DrJohnnyJ True, modern industrial monocrop tree farms are definitely NOT forests, and are pretty lame about sequestering carbon (some are actually net emitters by depleting soil carbon) but we can do much better than that. Modern experiments in agro/ecology/agroforestry and permaculture have shown that we can in fact steward systems that simultaneously feed us and sequester substantial amounts of carbon, while also rebuilding biodiversity and becoming more resilient to the already-changing climate. Edit: I will try to dig up some reference papers on this after work; I know I have them somewhere but finding them again is the challenge :P
@AndysRamblings
@AndysRamblings 3 года назад
A lit review I was able to dig up quickly: Nair, PK Ramachandran, et al. "Carbon sequestration in agroforestry systems." Advances in agronomy 108 (2010): 237-307. Will dig more if I have time later
@hoarder66
@hoarder66 3 года назад
"Spewing their carbon all over our faces" haha. Guess thats the money shot. Dang that casting couch is looking gross. Lmao
@joelpassanha8996
@joelpassanha8996 3 года назад
Well.... we do have to stop spewing Carbon into Mother Earth...
@wallabra
@wallabra 3 года назад
@@joelpassanha8996 Onto*, it's on the air, and it's pretty darn visible
@robertthompson7059
@robertthompson7059 3 года назад
@@joelpassanha8996 Earth: What are you doing step species?!
@mikeharrington5593
@mikeharrington5593 3 года назад
Yes the timing of that comment following the preceding theme conjured up messy thoughts.
@Jocobalo
@Jocobalo 3 года назад
I shouldn't have watched this while at work. This comment made me laugh so hard.
@ironassbrown
@ironassbrown 2 года назад
Great content from Joe, good one.
@vaszgul736
@vaszgul736 3 года назад
All I know is I hope for a future where teachers tell students "people back in the 21st century believed that the climate was going to collapse and that the world would become a lifeless desert" ---as a means of explaining the strange, foreign concept to kids, kids who can't fathom anything of the sort because it is so far beyond their reality. A man can dream.
@BigDaddyWes
@BigDaddyWes 3 года назад
This isn't a problem that any future generation won't have to deal with.
@Sorcerers_Apprentice
@Sorcerers_Apprentice 3 года назад
At one time, everyone was concerned about overpopulation, but due to birth control, governments are now worried about population decline (in reality, it is stabilizing). We can't hope for a single technology to come along and fix the climate for us, but hopefully we can find a way to at least pull back from the brink within our lifetimes.
@terranovarubacha5473
@terranovarubacha5473 3 года назад
I'm surprised you didn't mention that well intentioned tree planting programs have often destroyed peat bogs (cheap land) but those peat bogs had been sequestering way more carbon than the trees planted there ever could. I feel like I learned this from you
@griffithsOZ
@griffithsOZ 3 года назад
Natural Sequence Farming and Regenerative Farming are also ways to increase the carbon holding capacity of the soil on farms.
@terapode
@terapode 3 года назад
This channel deserves way more subscribers.
@titchglover2601
@titchglover2601 2 года назад
Team everything on board. Cement homes that absorb carbon sounds good however does it absorb continuously or after a year it's full?
@ltmq6641
@ltmq6641 3 года назад
lmao, the condom reference killed me
@fatdad64able
@fatdad64able 3 года назад
So as a German, let me ask you this: a condominium is a small condom?
@GAMakin
@GAMakin 3 года назад
@@fatdad64able maybe in Joe's case IDK (and I don't want to know, although he'd probably tell me if the price was right) BUT elsewhere in Texas (Land of the Swinging Dicks) we make use of (or at least claim to do so) the CONDOMAXIMUM. Extra room, in case you wind up in the "family way". On the BRIGHTSIDE™: you get to tear through walls.
@punditgi
@punditgi 3 года назад
Joe, great video! Also talk soon about regenerative farming and land restoration and wilding plus natural cycle livestock farming methods.
@MrFishChamp
@MrFishChamp 2 года назад
The background snare drums are killing me! Can't unhear it!!!
@josephelijah1211
@josephelijah1211 3 года назад
:20 - :23 the reason why this is now my favorite Joe Scott video. 🤣
@brianbeswick
@brianbeswick 3 года назад
Joe: “Big Oil is going to unload all over our faces!” RU-vid: “We call that the No Money Shot. #Demonetized”
@caroljo420
@caroljo420 3 года назад
I've read that planting bamboo cleans the air much faster than trees, because they grow so quickly.
@Myth8Anthropology
@Myth8Anthropology 3 года назад
Bamboo is a type of tree! And yes, bamboo is a carbon sequestering champion but is only appropriate in certain climates and certain micro-climates within the macro climates.
@matheussanthiago9685
@matheussanthiago9685 3 года назад
@@Myth8Anthropology isn't it an type of grass?
@jakobklee2800
@jakobklee2800 3 года назад
@@Myth8Anthropology Bamboo is anything but a tree species.
@randomguy-ys1mu
@randomguy-ys1mu 3 года назад
@@Myth8Anthropology it's grass
@Myth8Anthropology
@Myth8Anthropology 3 года назад
@@jakobklee2800 You are correct, I stand corrected. Bamboo is taxinomically in the same family as grasses. However, Caroljo is correct in saying that they grow faster than trees. Growth = biomass = carbon sequestration.
@niklas_Slam_O
@niklas_Slam_O 11 месяцев назад
Love that you are so interested in this topic❤❤
@stephentroake7155
@stephentroake7155 3 года назад
Thanks for another informative video 👍🏻 You mentioned that alternative cement was a different material, but I seem to remember hearing on a podcast recently that there is a low-carbon way of making exactly the same material. The beauty of this is that it's less of a worry for the construction industry, who are often (understandably) conservative.
@stephentroake7155
@stephentroake7155 2 года назад
@Slevin Channel yes, I find it sad that connecting people into new communities based on beliefs and ideologies ironically makes society more polarised. To be rational is to fight against human nature and I think that critical thinking skills should be embedded in school curricula around the world.
@garethbaus5471
@garethbaus5471 2 года назад
The production of normal cement as it is used in concrete is inherently going to realease a significant amount of CO2, the best we can do is replacing the heat source with something carbon neutral.
@stephentroake7155
@stephentroake7155 2 года назад
This chap's had a look at the options as they stand at the moment: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-MkE-2npiqFc.html
@RahulJoshi
@RahulJoshi 3 года назад
I remember reading that tweet as it happened "Hey Elon, ever hear of a tree... yap yap!" and that's the exact same Karen face I made. LOL!! 🤣🤣
@JonathanAdami
@JonathanAdami 3 года назад
The issue with biomass is the economics behind it. The romantic "it takes waste products and make energy" quickly turns into "how do we make more waste products to maximise profit" and you're back in destructive behaviours :/
@paulhaynes8045
@paulhaynes8045 3 года назад
Excellent point. Like growing soya - to feed cows!
@JJs_playground
@JJs_playground 3 года назад
That's exactly what I was thinking when he mentioned BCCS. Sure, at first it'll be waste biomass, but knowing humans and our propensity for needing / wanting more energy, we're going to end up cutting down more trees / forests to burn. Not a good idea.
@bryanforbes5962
@bryanforbes5962 3 года назад
Its truly bizarre to think that a generation of humans reared in post apocalyptic, hindsight being 20/20, less effort is for metaphoric effect, carbonless causational irony? Click = C02 coal plant woosh. That a bottomless sticky bag of clicky sugar clicky pellet info entertainment clicky news is best neutralizing or disuading the power in voting, or better still silencing the potential collective voice in our economic power to choose our future. Truth is positive. Its gotta stay positive not to balance failure or hedge funds. Silouette Absoltuism, candy coated fatalism and comfy defeatism worry me more. We have already cautioned, thorough scientific study, and reasonably open doors and minds. Should we consistently lose the future for humanity arguing money= bad humans? Should empowered humans only be Monkey's Paw twilight zone cliches? RU-vid click = Coal powered Co2 Wo0sH = Automated machine that cleans up carbon while rubbing a silicone wafer and lithium battery together into a AI sparking neuron that says "shut up dumb poor people..kaboom" Sigh. Do it anyway. More cowbell though= more human. The waters are deep here, we should set an agreed depth, build the ladder down with public demand, the will to build bridges, dams, Aquaducts! Canals! concentrated public effort and employment interest, to gauge the real difficulties and daily stress to climb out, each day, back to our safe warm more bells easier whistles homes? So we dont automate out of human. Underneath highway overpasses. We should jump feet first. Into the water, embolden by the cold, the will and love to swim. Heck, push and pull all the older generation businesses in by their nethers. We gotta do this before a tv celebrity, anti leads, our anti-government, into throwing all our skilled labor out of college, and solvent work, and instead into detainment camps, with our families on the wrong side of graffiti and train tracks. We need a Gamal Abdel Nasser, a friendly old jewish guy in mittens, we need to dream huge here. Thanks Joe. Great video!
@Monstah7
@Monstah7 3 года назад
Had to pause @ 5:29 during the Tangent Cam to give the thumbs up..lol sooo good, well done Joe.. =)
@aaronwelther3536
@aaronwelther3536 3 года назад
4:45 I'm totally on your side, we really need to do EVERYTHING to reduce the level of greenhous gases in the athmosphere! #TeamAllTheThings
@finnorir5709
@finnorir5709 3 года назад
omg I was just thinking about this, can't wait to watch this!
@hearmerant
@hearmerant 3 года назад
8:40 Rotating crops is so new a practice it's mentioned in the bible...
@joescott
@joescott 3 года назад
Everything old is new again.
@matheussanthiago9685
@matheussanthiago9685 3 года назад
''I see the future repeating the past, I see a museum of big novelties'' - Cazuza, time doesn't stop
@Cspacecat
@Cspacecat 2 года назад
@Timothy Mckee Before the industrial revolution, CO2 was at 280ppm. During the last glacial period, CO2 was at 180ppm. Plants still grew. The only difference is the amount of breathing holes at the underside of the leaves. We are now at 417ppm. That means there will be fewer breathing holes under the leaves. Like sunlight, plants absorb only so much per day. It's a stupid idea to think CO2 will be beneficial in additional quantities. If you haven't noticed, the western US is on fire. How much CO2 are those burnt trees and houses going to absorb?
@Cspacecat
@Cspacecat 2 года назад
@Timothy Mckee Quite the contrary, if the temperature continues to rise, the majority of the planet's land area will turn into a desert.
@Cspacecat
@Cspacecat 2 года назад
@Timothy Mckee I have listened to Harper on numerous occasions. He's a denialist. If we continue in our direction, we will encounter another Permian extinction-type event. No matter what, the fossil fuel industry is coming to an end. Civil lawsuits will probably kill them off before anything else. Right now there are only about a dozen lawsuits. It won't be long and that number will go into the hundreds.
@jameseglavin4
@jameseglavin4 2 года назад
Deserves a follow-up video, this would be a great one to elaborate on. I’d like to see some focus on the marine CO2 cycle, how the ocean is a massive carbon sink not just chemically but ecologically/biologically and why removing carbon from ocean water would be more efficient and effective than trying to pull it out of the air itself. There’s even a pilot program creating fuels from seawater courtesy of the Navy, *that* has massive potential for both carbon sequestration and for zero-carbon liquid fuels (given that the process energy would come from renewables and/or nuclear). Anyway great work as always Joe and team, keep it up!
@jamessellards7157
@jamessellards7157 2 года назад
Great video, all the things is what it's gonna take
@99nejko
@99nejko 3 года назад
I was sad that you didn't mention regenerative grazing
@kensmith5694
@kensmith5694 3 года назад
Yes, he missed that and some others where it isn't trees.
@colinwalke2443
@colinwalke2443 3 года назад
Huge opportunity not just for carbon, but water and work. Labour intensive and not very vulnerable to Automation.
@apexpredator2118
@apexpredator2118 3 года назад
They should try to find a way to incorporate all that carbon into batteries we all are going to need so many of in the future.
@kensmith5694
@kensmith5694 3 года назад
It is already happening with Lithium batteries. New types use carbon.
@scottiejohnson2639
@scottiejohnson2639 3 года назад
Great idea!!! 💯
@silviafox78
@silviafox78 3 года назад
we can easily turned captured carbon into fuel for vehicles. Carbon neutral fuel!
@kensmith5694
@kensmith5694 3 года назад
@@silviafox78 Yes, microbes that use sunlight and CO2 to make oil are already a thing. We just now have to make the process more efficient. I would keep this sort of thing mostly for aircraft. The car I use on a daily basis can easily electric. Long haul trucking needs an energy source that brings a lot of energy for not too much weight.
@silviafox78
@silviafox78 3 года назад
@@kensmith5694 - Yeah, Fossil Fuels are still one of the easiest and highest energy-dense tools to use for transportation along with being extremely cheap and already having world-wide supply/demand... It's only going to be replaced in select ways and I believe only once it the price rises due to scarcity will we ever stop using it and switch to the eventually 'cheaper' options which may be better for the environment but that could still choke our lower income workers and families. That reminds me how the american president Biden cancelled the keystone pipeline. That pipeline would have helped save on emissions since the oil would otherwise be transported by train and truck. People say pipelines are bad for the environment but in reality they are overall better than our older ways of transporting the oil. That particular pipeline was targeted strongly even though america already had many thousands of giant pipelines already in operation.
@howardjohnson2138
@howardjohnson2138 2 года назад
Thank you
@toddkorson8207
@toddkorson8207 3 года назад
Good show.
@quantumfoam539
@quantumfoam539 3 года назад
Last time I was this early our oil was still walking.. Edit: thank you all to point that out scientifically it is indeed true that most of fossil fuel comes from plants especially from the great rainforest collapse from the end of the carboniferous period. Still oil is frequently called dinosaur-juice as a joke.
@findlvrg4276
@findlvrg4276 3 года назад
That's early...
@jb76489
@jb76489 3 года назад
Oil comes mostly from plants
@DanielPereira-ey9nt
@DanielPereira-ey9nt 3 года назад
I belive most of it was swiming
@heliosphaeresonnen_wind_ki5720
@heliosphaeresonnen_wind_ki5720 3 года назад
never was. 🌱
@crackedemerald4930
@crackedemerald4930 3 года назад
@@DanielPereira-ey9nt probably not, plankton comes from greek and it means "drifters". Plankton are lazy bastards.
@nicholaskelly7275
@nicholaskelly7275 3 года назад
I would love for you to do a show about the use of intensive herd grazing to sequester carbon. Getting rid of the massive feed lots a getting animals out on pasture. Helping build soil and sequester more carbon than any of the other ways you talked about. Watch Kiss the ground. It does a great job of showing how this works. Also there are lots of ranchers out there that are following these practices like Joel Salatin, Gregg Judy, and three sisters cattle company.
@kbye5323
@kbye5323 3 года назад
I fricking love this channel. Team All The Things!
@windmoor
@windmoor 3 года назад
LMAO Love the tangent comparison. Good Job!
@BLClark-wf2yk
@BLClark-wf2yk 3 года назад
Dude, I had to replay that face you made at the beginning 🤣
@JonathanOrosco
@JonathanOrosco 3 года назад
I love that you promoting options gets "context" from RU-vid. They really are kind of acting like a publisher right now...
@maximummarklee
@maximummarklee 2 года назад
Hello Joe, A handy way to put CO2 back into concrete can be done at home when building a home out of “AirCrete“, which is basically whipped, foamy concrete. Instructions are available from multiple sources on RU-vid that show how to make a simple rig comprised of an air compressor, a 55-gallon drum, PVC pipe, water and concrete mix along with a dose of dish detergent. Normal “FoamCrete” or “AirCrete” is made by injecting the detergent-generated bubbles into the concrete mix, producing a very lightweight but very strong concrete with excellent insulating properties. Now substitute CO2 to replace the air (and a sealing agent to retain it) you have a 200-year vault of Carbon-longer if the structure is cared for.
@glenbeckett
@glenbeckett 2 года назад
Thanks!
@gurbym5513
@gurbym5513 3 года назад
Hey Joe, firstly THANK YOU for this amazing channel, love your videos, insights, and dedication to spreading well researched knowledge. Could you do a video on the new (unscientific) theory that older, advanced civilizations built the pyramids and Gobleki Teppi (mostly made famous by Hancock). The theory sounds sketchy to me and although it would take only 10,000 years for no trace of a civilization to remain, isn't that incorrect? Wouldn't there still be some signatures that would remain (fossil bones, waste that was fossilized, etc)? I thought that whole pyramid thing was put to rest but this new theory seems thought provoking. Thank you.
@ricknoyb1613
@ricknoyb1613 2 года назад
Not exactly. Should we perish and an alien science team arrive 100,000 years after our demise. Our activities in changing the earth's surface would still remain. Effects to the terrain from road building, mining and construction would be evidence of an intelligent species once dominating the planet as would leftover nuclear stockpiles and waste. A few of our probes sent into space or to other orbiting bodies would also show the emergence of a space-faring species long into the future. I like the idea of a massive glass pyramid or cone built on earth's south pole as a repository of everything humanity has ever encountered. As long as Antactica doesn't move around too much, the poles would seem a logical point to explore for an alien species. And should temperatures remain low enough, a lot of earth's dna could remain viable for study
@PaxxMontana
@PaxxMontana 3 года назад
See-ment. Love the Texas access joe ❤️
@PaxxMontana
@PaxxMontana 3 года назад
Joe liked my comment!!!!! AHHHH I LOVE YOU JOE. KEEEP MAKIN AMAZING VIDEOS JOE. I LOVE YOU WITH MY WHOLE HEART
@UnattendedNarrative
@UnattendedNarrative 2 года назад
🤣🤣😂 I like this guy's sense of humour. Love this channel.
@scb123465
@scb123465 3 года назад
hey joe, I was wondering if you knew or have heard about a program like Brilliant but for kids? if so id appreciate any info you may have. Loved this video. Keep it up!
@HilaLeftMe
@HilaLeftMe 3 года назад
Good job on the video, joe (haven’t watched it but I somehow know this to be true).
@BazaarGamer
@BazaarGamer 3 года назад
The albedo of forests are higher than that of bare ground, what are you comparing it too? Around 7:20 .
@kuromibff417
@kuromibff417 2 года назад
I adore your style. Subbed right away. I feel the same way! I fuss at my students every time they waste a sheet of paper. Like really fuss. Cried twice. Just a little. Save the freaking TREES!!
@mcfehn25
@mcfehn25 3 года назад
5:30: The absolute funniest thing you have ever said. Well done.
@klunkmedia
@klunkmedia 3 года назад
The EAS could be integrated into the aircon systems of office buildings or homes is suppose.
@MarkLLawrence
@MarkLLawrence 3 года назад
My brain registered the thumbnail as Minecraft for a few seconds. I don't play but my kids do, maybe too much?
@MrRustyB2
@MrRustyB2 3 года назад
The best is regenerative agriculture and the equivalent in forest management to sequester carbon back into the soil, in part using cover crops as mentioned. But also growing and farming kelp seaweed forests like what’s happening off the coast of Tasmania
@litebkt
@litebkt 2 года назад
Outstanding. I’m in all the things camp.
@adamderrick5336
@adamderrick5336 3 года назад
“Spewing their carbon all over our faces” I laughed so hard
@petrapewpew
@petrapewpew 3 года назад
We need to make soil, grow more than just trees, we need to grow EVERYTHING. Better yet, grow a food forest that provides food for people and animals. You grow more than tree crops with guild planting than increases the biomass per square foot
@steel8231
@steel8231 3 года назад
I saw someone saying it might work to turn yard clippings and farm waste into charcoal briquettes with the waste heat from power plants and bury them in old coal mines, based on the idea that in mid to late summer the US corn belt rivals the Amazon Rainforest for o2 production but most of it leaks back out of the farm waste.
@Sniperboy5551
@Sniperboy5551 Год назад
I love the fact that Joe approaches these issues from a practical, non-ideological point of view. Some people are so wrapped up in their climate change ideology that they’re unable to negotiate a realistic compromise regarding the issue. Joe is able to proper articulate the different stances all in one nice monologue, I love it.
@FabiWann
@FabiWann 3 года назад
I'm on team all the things PLUS Molten Salt Thorium Nuclear Reactors!
@scottslotterbeck3796
@scottslotterbeck3796 3 года назад
He said zero about clean, safe, carbon-free nuclear power.
@Sciolist
@Sciolist 3 года назад
Thorium isn't exactly a nuclear fuel, more of a nuclear filler that can be used with fuel.
@agsystems8220
@agsystems8220 3 года назад
Nuclear weapons for everyone! Unfortunately molten salt reactors are a proliferation hazard, and it is nigh on impossible to make thorium work otherwise. Any reactor capable of burning thorium is also capable of producing plutonium 239 while burning uranium, and we don't want those type of reactors being common.
@jackielinde7568
@jackielinde7568 3 года назад
So, what you're saying is that we could see SodaStream (TM) devices with this "Electroswing" carbon capture in it? But wouldn't that cut into SodaStream(tm)'s business model of selling us bottles of CO2?
@tuxuhds6955
@tuxuhds6955 2 года назад
23:39 "This is really exciting stuff!" I'm totally onboard with that statement. It will be exciting to live in a matchsticks house. 😝 Seriously now, I wish you'd cover the fire safety angle on these solutions.
@simplecreativity6809
@simplecreativity6809 2 года назад
I really enjoyed the video. It is very structured and informative. Also, I like how you point out each idea from all angles and specially economical perspective. I have never thought of using the ocean to capture carbon. It seems to me the best method for carbon capture. We also need to stop hunting whales because they also capture a lot of CO2.
@amicloud_yt
@amicloud_yt 3 года назад
wait what the frig joe ur telling me my water tastes 'stale' because of the carbonic acid from the air? holy shit i never woulda thought
@bbernotus2354
@bbernotus2354 3 года назад
“Then that makes carbon the.....” and Joe a fluffer
@barth9580
@barth9580 2 года назад
16:56 We just found Carmen San Diego! Good job gum shoes!
@Lorentari
@Lorentari Год назад
There is also making biochar. Biochar releases syngas when produced and that syngas can be used to power the furnace making the energy input zero once the furnace is running. The biochar can afterwards be burried
Далее
A Crazy Solution To Global Warming
33:23
Просмотров 513 тыс.
How Thermodynamics Holds Back Negative Carbon Tech
25:13
ОБЗОР ТРЕЙЛЕРА STANDOFF 2 0.29.0 FUN&SUN
13:13
Is CO2 Removal Ready for Its Big Moment?
16:21
Просмотров 411 тыс.
Concrete Carbon Capture. A pathway to net zero?
16:54
Просмотров 160 тыс.
Why Go To Space - An Editorial | Random Thursday
24:50
Просмотров 408 тыс.
What Happened To Airships? | Answers With Joe
23:46
Просмотров 1,2 млн
What Is The Loudest Sound Ever Made? | Answers With Joe
21:27
The Reality of Carbon Capture
16:08
Просмотров 453 тыс.
Is Mycelium Fungus the Plastic of the Future?
12:43
The 7 Smartest Animals In The World | Answers With Joe
25:56
ВЫ ЧЕ СДЕЛАЛИ С iOS 18?
22:40
Просмотров 107 тыс.
НАШ ЛЮБИМЫЙ КЛИЕНТ
1:00
Просмотров 509 тыс.