A Discussion with Clint Hill, Lisa McCubbin Hill and Gerald Posner 

Excellent discussion. Time well spent.

I do not know why his wife Lisa has to be there. She adds very little, other than occasionally smiling and looking at her elderly husband.

None of that means LHO shot Kennedy all by himself, however.

@@bwm3013 Yes' that is correct. And we will never know the whole truth in this murder.

The gig is up… very few still buy the Posner/Bugliosi fake narrative of the lone gunman… Oswald didnt even pull a trigger as shown by overwhelming evidence. He was a CIA patsy as is now almost common knowledge.

Liars. Clint hill let the president down. He is no hero. He stayed out drinking the night before sadly. Hero? No way. Clint and Lisa are money grabbing opportunists

Read Sylvia Meagher's "Accessories After the Fact". Meagher indexed the WC evidence volumes (that the WC intentionally did not want done.)

Posner is an acknowledged plagiarists and cheat. Horrible reputation He was fired by New Yorker magazine

I believe what the drs said was they thought it was an entrance wound. Dr Jones has basically admitted he was wrong by explaning the outward push of the threads on the tie as the bullet exited. Perry didn't talk much about it after that day he seemed to disappear after that at some point but that was because the press was hounding him. Funny you would mention Posner on a show he was on a friend introduced Posner who said he was allowed to interview Perry because he was from the town he lived in. Perry told the man the best book he ever read on the Kennedy assassanation was Case Closed that schould tell you what Perry's real opinion on the bullet was. As far as Mccleland goes I read his WC testimony he never said they knew it was positively a entrance wound. Mccleland a proponent of the bullet coming from the front on the head shot didn't say that in 1964 in front of the WC when asked did he have an opinion which direction the head shot came from his answer was it would be impossible to say.

You should read his book. He explains it in a lot of detail

It's a case of do you trust our government? I don't​@@Heroball299

Mr hill why omit the fact that the agents hàd been out drinking the night before

@@user-cp6ht1pr4c Hill is a criminal,not a hero.The truth will never come out .If the official story was true,I would never research this case.The criminals can fool the Public,they cannot fool God.

She is definitely in the Trophy Wife category...and I suspect she pursued Clint, not the other way around. Likely enjoys the semi-famous aspect of being married to Clint Hill. But she is not really that young (50-ish), it is just that Clint is so old!

​@curbozerboomer1773 Actually, she'll be 60 this coming January 12th. She had her own life before Clint. I think they really fell in love. Clint had the ability to know how to give Mrs Kennedy freedom and how to protect her at the same time. I think Lisa and Clint fell in love. Plus he can trust her with his legacy. Two wonderful people fell in love slowly. I saw them answer the question in another interview. He made the first move after he saw how compatible they were and as he said she didn't put up resistance. She helped him to have a healing and joy.

Clint wasn’t drinking and left at 2:00 am. The others stayed until 5:00am according to Clint Hill.

Always check the validity of your statements before making them rumors are no good.

Don’t be vulgar please.

I’m not trying to be vulgar. The doctors at Parkland Hospital have claimed in their opinion, but he was shot from the front because of a large hole in his skull in the back. Actually, I think Clint Hill had said Mrs. Kennedy did what I mentioned. This is an assassination! Don’t be vulgar …really? They can discuss sensitive topics but I can’t?

@@Paul5520 Nothing vulgar here!. I wish that Mr. Hill had been even more graphic and precise, when describing the head wound he saw!...In earlier interviews, he suggested there was nothing left, regarding brain material at the massive head wound...The official photos of the brain removed from JFK show some trauma, some brain material missing towards the front, but most of the brain seems intact. The brain was removed, and put in formaldehyde, before being closely examined. It was not damaged at all on the left side, but some damage was done to the right side of the brain.

Agreed. He starts filming and stops when he realizes it’s not the president’s limo. He then resumes filming when the limo is in view. He isn’t filming an assassination about to occur , he’s filming one already in progress.

The first shot might not be captured on the film at all. At least that's the theory of Max Holland. I'm not quite convinced though.

Please learn how to spell & use punctuation. G’lad.

Why were you such a dunderhead, when it comes to using the English language?.."too" is an adjective!

​@@curbozerboomer1773a good question though.

Yeah, but... Weren't there fibers from Kennedy's shirt blown into the wound at the back of his neck? This would all but prove the bullet hit him from behind. As for the head wound, I still suspect Agent Hickey lost his footing and fired a AR-15 into Kennedy's head. Just my thoughts.

Dear boy when you grow you’ll get wiser. You’ll realise the nonsense you’re talking now was so ridiculous but you believed you were right at the time. JFK was shot from the rear by a madman with notions. It’s sad. Extremely sad.

In the official autopsy photos, there is a photo of JFK lying on the table, and the tracheotomy only partially messed up the exit wound--you can see the bottom semi-circle that the bullet made when exiting below the Adam's Apple!

@@mikehiggins946 That is not my "claim" - it is what Perry stated at that press conference. He called it an entrance wound three times - maybe he was wrong but he still claimed it and saw it that way when he performed the tracheotomy and when he spoke at the press conference. As for the autopsy there are many questions about tampering with the evidence.

No magic bullet????!!!!! that would be tantemont to burning every copy of Posner's book Cased Closed in the universe! Gerald is watching his whole house of cards collapse.

Just like the WC telling actual witnesses what they didnt see.

Posner didn’t argue with Hill, at all. Posner, in a very respectful manner, shared where he disagreed with first and second shot. Disagreeing with someone very respectfully is a lot different than arguing with someone. You’re injecting drama here where there is no drama.

It’s therapeutic for Hill to tell his story, and Posner is only helping him along. There isn’t anything untoward about it.

There is no argument here, only questions asked for clarification and answered.

There was no 30cal bullet found. The bullet found on Connally's gurney was from Oswald's Carcano, lands and grooves prove that. And why would a bullet be found on Ronnie Fuller's gurney? His gurney was placed by the elevator before Connally's.

There were many

There is no credible evidence that supports a conspiracy. Name one......

How do you deal with the mountain of evidence Posner presents in Case Closed that refutes the various theories.

There is much more evidence that LHO acted alone.

Then, you better stop discussing this with yourself!

If you believe something, it's worthy of discussion, isn't it? Present your case if you really believe something and let's see how it holds up.

They had never seen a head wound like that and did not know the physics of balistics.

The doctors dealt with bullit wounds all the time. They recognized entry and exit wounds from experience.

In an press conference after the assassination, Dr. Perry was asked several questions about JFK's wounds. Asked about the wound in the throat, he said, "Questioner : What was the entrance wound? Dr Perry : There was an entrance wound in the neck. As regards the one in the head, I cannot say. Questioner : Which way was the bullet coming on the neck wound? At him? Dr Perry : It appeared to be coming at him." First, he said it was an entry wound, then immediately qualified his answer and he continued the qualified response about the nature of the wound throughout the questioning. Dr. Perry based his initial answer on a smooth, round wound in JFK's throat and to him, it was characteristic of an entry wound, not an exit. The reason Dr. Perry said the throat wound was an entry was because of its physical appearance. In his experiences, entry wounds made a small entry, large exit wound from standard bullets. The copper jacketed bullet does not behave like standard bullets when hitting only soft tissue. Instead of expanding/mushrooming, a jacketed bullet will remain intact when it hits only soft tissue. That style of bullet only deforms when it initially hits hard material such as bone at full velocity impact when the jacket fractures and the lead alloy core fragments throughout the target. Anything else?

They did not turn Kennedy over. They observed him only with him lying on his back. They did not observe the rear of his head and see the entrance wound there, or the complete damage to Kennedy’s head. Nor did they see the wound to his upper back. With conspiracy people, every account of his wounds and their placement begins and ends with the Parkland doctors. They ignore every observation before (including the obvious images of the Zapruder film, which show zero damage to the rear), as well as the more careful examinations after. They just refuse to acknowledge.

@@bshunter550 Excellent summation.

Sorry, but you are a total rockhead.

Oh you poor sad person

Janet Janet Janet..

Mr. Posner is correct. Oswald was the lone assassin. Jack Ruby had no association woth Oswald. Posner's blockbuster book of 25 years ago, " Case Closed ", methodically tears apart every conspiracy theory. I am from Dallas and I recall that day well. My dad, Anthony Marotta, filmed the motorcade. I became interested as a child, reading all the conspiracy books. Mr. Posner is an American hero for proving them all wrong.

Do you have an alternate scenario that differs from all the investigations done in the years since the assassination?

It is very devinivately the only theory

Oooooo,,,we akk see what you did there!