A LETTER OF CHALLENGE - You Become a Magical Girl & Nothing Bad Happens To Mahou Shoujos in the game 

Giving someone with social anxiety the power to rewind time doesn't seem like the best idea tbh

The villain gave her bad social advice on purpose, as a joke.

Huh, I expected a much darker twist. Thats kind of wholesome

Manly doing a Voiceover on a highschool girl he wont even change his voice a little... I like it.

honestly the image of a girl with poor social skills and little experience making friends going to her Reformed Villain Friend, who likely also has poor social skills and little experience making friends, is adorable. Of course they gave her bad advice! No one in this equation has any clue what they’re doing!

A funny thing to imagine is that all of the Mahou Shoujos remember the time loop, and in a completely different town, there's thisone girl that doesn't even know her powers yet and is just confused and unknowing of why deja vu is happening over and over again.

"well you're already in second season in your town aren't you" She's about to fight ultimate life form now

Like how the start mentions how the guardian being snarky and the magical girl not being sporty as if that's not a common trope already.

The real lesson learned is that magically enhanced awkwardness makes you memorable, shy-chan.

Me: sees a magical girl in the title me: oh that sounds cut- *sees manlybadasshero channel pfp* me: oh shit it's magical girl Madoka but videogames this time

Everyone: noo we cant trust cute thumbnails Me, who realized who the studio is by the artstyle: ooooh boy its gonna get real gay

Game: “Don’t be stupid, nobody even writes love letters these days.” Manly: *Has flash backs* Also Manly: “hmm...”

The last time I got a letter of challenge I ended up at the principal's office for "Unwarranted Instigator of Cafeteria Food Fight"

"I like these clothes... they make me feel safe." Geeze that line hurts me in my soul. She probably never had anyone to depend on and dug herself into the mahou shojo life as a coping mechanism.

I love this creators style of games. It’s incredibly unique while also appealing and kinda strange.

For once, there's really nothing bad that happened.

25:50 Umm, yeah... "Ask Vegeta for advice"... I can even hear his answer: "beat her into submission and force her to be your friend"

Title: “Nothing Bad Happens” X for dOuBT

Who knew the same person who made a game about a soul trapped forever in solitude and banned from society would end up making a wholesome game about Magical Girls.

A cute game that actually did turn out to be cute and innocent in the end! Really liked both characters, the blue girl had a Homura rewind thing going on but kind of looked like Sayaka to me

Everybody gangsta til the witch starts speaking Gaster language.

Madoka meets Sayaka: the lesbian energy Homura wish she had.

That was a really cute story. I like this dev's way of using groundhog day loops to tell their stories, and I hope they do more neat stuff with the concept. Also, that mysterious girl reminds me of myself in some ways like being shy, being bad with tech stuff, not knowing how to approach people IRL, stuff like that.

Title: Nothing bad happens to mahou shoujos in the game. Me: Kyubey flashbacks.

I've really been conditioned by Madoka to expect horrible things to happen to magical girls, it's nice to see a wholesome subversion of expectations.

In a pet shop after dark, Manly got a file as secret. He was told it could be used in the future and I wonder if it has an impact on this game?

I love npckc's games, they're always really well written and fun to play

“Yes I did, my name’s Homura” l m a o idk why that killed me XD

Already sus of the game from the cute thumbnail and title 😂

*reads the title* Me: *listening to madoka magica soundtrack* hmmmmm.... "There may or may not be time shenanigans" Me: HMMMMMMMM Edit: I like this story, it was simple but cute and compelling. If this isn't Madoka Magica-inspired then I'm losing my mind

The rare time when Manly plays a game that looks cute and it's actually cute. That ending is just... D'awwwww.

I wonder.... would slipping in that one file from "A Pet Shop After Dark" into this game do anything? Well, if this game was made after that one, that is.

the blue girl over there looks like Claire from witchs heart HKISDFGRYJ

Oh this is gonna be good based off the title- also it's by the same creator as pet shop after dark so that's a good sign Edit: That was really cute- it was good

So a person with a pink hair stuck on another dimension where they just die endlessly?

*madoka magica flashbacks*

So basically... Groundhog Day: Mahou Shoujo Version

This really is just Madoka Magica except with less existential dread

"nothing bad happens to mahou shoujos" Me: did you forget that *being meguca is s u f f e r i n g*

Oh god, this was so cute, I adore this creator so much. Also I find it interesting how in these games "we" aren't the protagonist.

It's weird seeing manly play a game that isn't about gruesome murders.

The little happy ending just made me realize they kinda look like marceline and princess bubblegum but magical girl version-

Manly once again proving to have great taste by talking about Madoka and favoring Vegeta over Goku.

Man, keep doing games like this, I will start calling you "ManlyWholesomeHero"!

i know you won't see this, but your gameplays have always been a huge comfort to me when i'm sad or having an adhd episode, they're the only things i can really focus on and ground myself in. despite the horror nature of the games, they're always fun and casual, your videos are really awesome, and i'm really happy they're on here!

I honestly love everything about this game Cute and simple artstyle The pretty pastel color choices Amazing story line Also the element of mystery and suspence And a very very satisfying ending Even though I never played this game myself it just looks awesome all around

Stuck in a time loop where a girl's trying to cast a spell on you? _LET ME IN! LET ME IIIIINN!!!_

Letter: **have a challenge** The protagonist: I like your funny words magic -man- letter!

Titles: "...Nothing Bad Happens To Mahou Shoujos..." Me: Hahaha.... yep-- *insane flashback to Madoka*

Not even finished watching the video and already like it.

_From mahou shoujo to just shoujo_ This was cute, very anime repetitive - but the repetition was neceesary & part of the whole gimmick. Nice little story.

Manly I'm not so sure talking to Vegeta would be any better than talking to Goku. Goku: Make friends with everyone by fighting them! Vegeta: Friends make you weak! Fight everyone you come across!

Whan a cute game on Manly's channel is actually cute. I thing I just went to a different wordline.

3:27 nice sneaky Madoka Magica reference you did

Watching this game just kind of makes me mad after a while of thinking about it, imagine someone who just does shit to you, over and over, never says anything or explains themselves, and then years later you learn they were just too stupid to human normally and just wanted you as a friend, and are just lucky you were too nice to get proper vengeance. If our main character had decided instead to train herself and become more powerful in the loops, and just one-shot the time girl like she was friggin' Final Fantasy 1 Chaos/Jack Garland, Time Girl would have had a tragic ending!

Manly: Sees Blue mahou shoujo Manly: "My name is Homura" Me: __

I can't stop thinking of Madoka Magica and I'm glad the bee wasn't evil🤣

Title: nothing bad happens Everyone: _...hol up_

Thank god. Was so bored I thought I might have to go to bed. And then you came along...❤️

Magical girls with a manly voice. This needs an anime

Looks like Claire from Witch's Heart became a shy mahou shoujo

This low key sounds like a nice beginning to an anime.

Now I wonder if her former-villain friend will get involved next.

Damn, watching this with manly's voice reminds me of Magical Girl Ore.

That was incredibly adorable but I don't know what's safe anymore if this was "cute" too

Is the fact that the mysterious girl is Sayaka Miki in WITCH'S CLOTHES is trying to tell me about the most obvious reference?

Would You rather become a Magical Girl or Be friends with a Magical Girl.

glad to see this creator getting more attention, they make a lot of underrated games tbh

I like to imagine the cute witch took lessons from Nanoha in making friends.

Awe such a sweet, heartwarming ending ❤

I wanna hear how Vegata would give advice for making friends.

this was so cute and it made my day

It's been so long since I got here early. Lately I've been asleep or at work when Manly uploads a video.

Wow it really was just a cute game about magical girls where nothing bad happend and the girls just become friends.

Finally a genuinely wholesome magical girl thing

The blue haired girl radiates Tsubasa vibes from Comic Girls... I loved this game, simple but fun.

You’re awesome Manly! Thanks for making my depressing days so much better with your videos :)

Dude I had subscribed a while a go just to listen to you say, "Ooh secret."

Ah the art style is so cute and simple!

This was surprisingly wholesome. Glad to see another game by npckc.

OH! this is so adorable! I love this~

I wonder if there is a direct connection to A Pet Shop After Dark (APSAD). In that game the girl you save has some sort of power that she can't stop using which causes her to go to the shop owner. If the girl you save is the magical girl that was rewinding time then that would also explain how APSAD had that time loop mechanic that never got clearly explained. I'm not sure if the owner is the "friend" the blue magical girl mentioned, but everything seems to fit too well for it to just be a coincidence. It does make the ending of this game a bit sadder though since it would mean that the friendship didn't work out. Maybe APSAD started because blue-hair used the time rewind and pink-hair got mad at her. It might not have been a big fight (and even if it was pink-hair would probably be willing to make up), but blue-hair probably took it very seriously and looked for a way to seal her ability. I do kinda wonder if something would happen if you dragged the calling card file into this game however. Even if this one came first, there may have been something added later.

magical girl game? is manly a magical guy?!

For once, Magical Girls get a happy wholesome ending. Usually they end up stabbed or turning into laser-spewing snake monsters.

Considering how many cutesy horror games Manly's played this was a pleasantly unexpected outcome lol

oh cool new video, was just binge watching your videos

While I do prefer A Pet Shop After Dark, I'm down for a simple cute game. In defense of the incredibly awkward magical girl, if I had time rewind powers then I would use those for anything and everything. If anything, I'm kind of disappointed we didn't get to see her reformed villain pal.

Manlys giggles are the best. Reminds me of Rumpelstiltskin from once upon a time lol

Wow this is ... surprisingly wholesome compared to the other content on this channel or maybe I spoke to soon

still haven't recovered from the recent Magia Record EN closure T_T and that battle at the pier they were talking about reminded me of how ACT1 ended against Walpurgisnacht

Madoka Magika wants a word with ya~

npckc has such a cute artstyle omg, I'm in love with it 🥺🥺

Is it only me who is tired of comments like "(manly: nothing bad happens) (me: doubt)". I mean seriously, don't you have anything better to comment on, aren't you bored?

she wasn't attacking at all, just winding back time. Wholesome dork.

23:18 oh no this is gonna be super gay isn’t it 29:01 ALL ABOARD THE GAY TRAIN

insane, the title did not mislead me at all

Hey, have you tried using the girl from the Pet Shop After Dark's help? Or it does nothing?

so it WAS a love letter

The beginning reminds me of magical girl raising project (probably inspired by Madoka)

Who here’s gonna translate the wingdings because I’m too lazy to do it