A Perfect Circle Judith Reaction Video (Audio Fixes  

I think so too

He was mad at the injustice of it and the “mysterious ways” copout that dismisses that injustice. His mother devoted so much time to good works and prayer and just gets crippled by a tiny blood vessel in the brain at 33.

@Khorne Berzerker How does that make sense to you when you say it? Why do apolegetics always blame the bad shit on fundamentalists like it doesn't rip the foundation from under you? There wouldn't be any problems like this if the fundamentals of Christianity weren't themselves flawed. "Fundamentalist" wouldn't have such a negative connotation if the fundamentals of whatever the subject may be weren't negative also.

In this link you can find Maynard's reasons to write the song and the meaning that all this have for him. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-YU0BrwlWNTk.html

Pay close attention to his lyrics and you will see that he’s not mad at God, he’s sad that the faith in Christ actually caused a rift between him and his mom during her years of suffering. He couldn’t identify with her. Maybe even a little jealousy that she was closer to God and Jesus than she was with him....

Talk to jesus christ as if he knows the reasons why, he did it all for you.... Another line that needs more love.

Agreed. On Mount Calvery the two men jabbed the spear into Jesus' side and water came out. Now Maynard is angry cause "These guys jabbed a spear into your sons side while on the crucifix, yet my mom is the one suffering for loving you."

In the Roman way of thinking he was doing him a favor.

Agreed

Tru story !

Art is the miracle of transforming loss, struggle and suffering into something others (and yourself) can expierence as healing, as katharsis. It's a manifestation of beauty out of misery. Isn't it a saying that the worst artist is one who is totally satisfied with life? I mean it's definitely true for Blues! If I would believe in god I would mean that art is the one thing we have to rise above all that mundanity and ordineriness and be a little more like god or take his perspective. But of course I am making the mistake here to think of intellectuality as something superiour to mundanity. Well I wish it would be. Music and art comforts me in that way. In the end I think everything is the same. Duality. Endless dialectic - thesis antithesis synthesis. Yin Yang. Our desire to compare things to value anything at any time without exception if we want to or not is our nemesis. Our inability to deal with coincidence and randmoness in combination with fate which drives us into a believe in a (not random) afterlife which will give everything meaning in retrospective, our struggle to find meaning in sense in things is deeply human. Which is why we would rather be like god because we don't like being human at all. Fragile, mortal, with little control, knowing the right way but to weak to stick to it and all that. There is no deeper meaning. Only now.

I don't think he will totally healed

He actually said this in an interview a few years back, people asked him why as the years went on why he did a lot less angry screaming, he said because he uses the music to heal.. he's basically exercising his demons.

Not completely.

Good info. Ya sometimes people can be so aligned with their faith that anger at them v God can sometimes be indistinguishable. Good call

I think the real progression should have been Intermission/Jimmy (he talks about when she was paralyzed), Judith (still alive, but fading), Wings1/2 (she had died). You are missing which is about when everything happened.

Jimmy is such an amazing song. Sober is what was always played on the radio but Jimmy is the song that hooked me and made me a fan of the band.

We’re adding that as the “prequel” to the “Maynard’s mom” trilogy

just to add a little context to this, Judith had been faithful, that did good work; volunteering in soup kitchens, missionary type work earlier in her life. She was hit by a drunk driving pedophile which caused her paralysis and she remained faithful after. This song is basically about 1 person questioning anothers faith, How in the face of such hypocritical tragedy can you remain faithful?

Much love man !

@@VinAndSori you should do type o negative September Sun.

Open minded, this trio have listened to Lord Abortion. They should be in the Government somewhere. :)

I’m certain we’re going to get APC requests after tonite, so it’ll happen I’m sure !

Weak and Powerless is about heroin addiction

Same with Orestes, one of the most beautiful APC songs imo.

So who is the demon behind the bastard gas giant star Saturn?

Damn man. Nostalgia. I forgot about media play. Loved that place.

Thank you !

Exactly ! The trilogy is complete! Let us know your thoughts !

That’s high honor! Thank you !

michael porter it is pure uncut Maynard.

Great perspective to have my friend. You’re surely not one of those to cut us all right in two.

What does atheism mean to you? Just wondering. Does it mean you don't subscribe to organized religion or does it mean you are 100% positive and hold proof that there is no higher power?

Dude, very similar to how I grew up. Very traditional church of Christ/Baptist. I eventually walked away from my faith. Most of my family turned their back on me because I had a different belief, I'm a hippy, believe in the universe and oneness shit. My dad couldn't bear the thought of many things of my life and when I hit rock bottom he attacked instead of helped. He couldn't handle a poem I wrote that I posted, or The Doomed. He was disappointed that I wasn't sharing his same faith and held it against me. So this much of Maynard songs hit some for me.

@@chrisclevenger1582 were you on drugs at Rock bottom?

Thx! How did u stumble? Ya vin and I do this even when we are not recording. After we watch movies it turns into a deep discussion. Love It! -Sori 🤘🏻

Came across your channel from the Cradle of Filth reaction actually. I have a background in theological studies and a love for metal, so I find the perspective of people who approach rock and metal from a scriptural framework fascinating. Tool and APC are two of my favourite bands of all time, so as soon as I saw the rest of your output I was hooked! Gojira too! And Devy! If I could humbly request a reaction to Steven Wilson's Routine, that would be amazing. I think you'd genuinely find a lot in the lyrics to muse over.

thats a hard story man i hope you are ok right now

You’ve commented a few times! Thanks for that. It means a lot !

Yes I think we’ll probably add that at some point. “Wings” and “10000” were so highly recommended we shot two vids in one sitting and we’ll release those succesviley ... jimmy has been mentioned so many times though we have to get to it

Appreciate this so much my man!

Ya I felt that too except the song was doing that more to my soul then my head!-Sori

Cool! Welcome!!! -Sori✌🏻

I was waiting for a comment like this. The one who did the angry growl was Billy, not Maynard

Your English is great! Do me a favor and suscribe so that we can put war flower on the list !

I’ve already did that.

It’s on the list !!

Thanks !!

Nobody can do pain like Rock and roll. Great stuff thanks for your honesty Justin

For Wings 1&2 use the video from youtube user "Lyric Music Videos" it is really well done. Simple but hard hitting cinematic effects. DIg your channel by the way.

Thanks for the reccomend we’ll do that!

Agreed. Even if you cut the video into part 1 and part 2 I hope you guys can sit down to record it all the way through in one sitting. It's long but better that way

Glad ur enjoying! -Sori🤟🏻

that song isnt insane... only the truth...

truth. No matter how smart, and grown you are, losing your mother, especially if you absolutely adore her, seeing her suffer would break you down in every possible way. Anger is part of that process of grief.

Who’s that ?

VinAnd Sori Director of Seven and Fight Club

Director of Seven, Fight Club, Gone Girl, the Social Network, the Girl with the Dragon Tattoo and many more

Lol orrrrrrr we had terrible tech issues before we upgraded!

You definitely upgraded to be more caring to our ears *thumbs up

Thanks Marco, we’re publishing “wings” first today and then 10000 Friday

Exactly ! It was a great thing to be able to do

Hahahaha!! Thanks lol I appreciate that!

That’s the second request in 2 days !

Please do. It's a great song. Not really rock at all.

It’s sacred man. Gotta give it respect! I appreciate you seeing that!!

Yesss I love the way they analyze the lyrics.

We’re recording wings soon tonite

Awesome Brother !

Jamey Alford indeed lean more towards being a heathen metaphorical acolyte of trickster deities myself.

Same

So I’ve heard, we’re going to get to it soon !

Thanks!! I’ll add it to the list!

Seconded!

Took me so long to determine who sang what they sound amazing together they should do it again

Warren Leggatt uneffing believable. epic.

That songs so goddamn great, it's about car sex which is hilarious to me but it's such a good song it doesn't even matter Kinda like tool does with prison sex and stinkfist

Ya it was unclear ... she died in 03 and the song was written in 2000 I believe

In the last few months I have got into watching music reaction videos and I have to say I enjoy and appreciate the way you both react to music more then the rest. Very analytical and deep. I can't say your perceptions are wrong about this song but I perceive that Maynard is not mad at his mom but baffled or confused at her faith. I believe he is saying why are you not as enraged as me about your unearned short comings. Just my opinion. And in case you didn't know the band always writes all the music first and gives it to Maynard then he comes up with the melodies. Then begins to write the lyrics so the emotion of the music always dictates the emotion of his lyrics. Keep up the great work. I hope nothing but the best for the two of you.

Yes I agree with you, probably should have articulated it better but yes I don’t think he was mad at his mom in the pure sense of being angry at a person. We’ve heard constantly folks saying we’re a deeper reaction channel, that’s such an honor. We started this out of our passion for music and outright love for human beings. So to hear that means people get us. Thank you for that !!

Same! -Vin

Thanks

3 libras is such a beautiful song. the entire album is so pure. I love the song Brena

Wow I appreciate that. We’re reviewing “wings” and 10000 days. As s trilogy after Judith. If you’re suscribed you can get priority in song suggestions. Do you have any titles you suggest ?

VinAnd Sori The Patient or Parabol/Parabola are some hot suggestions. Any song from Tool's Lateralus would do it actually, such a masterpiece!

Word!

Hey thanks. ;) I know you must get a ton of requests, But I have something a bit different. There are a lot of reactions videos out there right now dealing with the the size of suns and the universe and so forth. I see mostly musical reactions in your que may I suggest Albedo 0.39 from Vangelis from the album of the same name. If you have watched the Cosmos series you have heard the song Alpha. A potent song in it's own right. Albedo 0.39 is a scientific description of the earth set to some really cool sounds. Even if it is not something you think would work on your channel it is still a cool song to listen to. Again thanks and I look forward to your posts.

Email us VinAndSori@gmail.com

Sent and thanks. ;) oh yeah I almost forgot. This might help. Albedo definition The proportion of the incident light or radiation that is reflected by a surface, typically that of a planet or moon.

Recorded both of those last night. Being released tonite and tommrrow

VinAnd Sori awesome! Can’t wait!

Friend request us on fb!!

😉

Thank you!!! You should check out our update videos... major Maynard project in the works !

Thanks ! I think once the music comes in it corrects ... lemme know as you continue

VinAnd Sori I meant in the beginning! Forgot that part!!

We’re working on our editing. Sori is progressing so far. She’s gone from not knowing a thing about iMovie to editing like mad. Thanks for letting us know it sounds better as it progresses!!!

Jeff Nerdcore Peralta magdelena, the hollow. the rose.

ill go ahead and pass that motion,,,,,,on you now vin and sori

Lucky!!

On the list !

Diorama and Neon ballroom both worth listening to.

🍻 if we’re ever in chi town we’ll toss s few back for sure

Invite me too :-)

No doubt!

ChicagoTRS you got it bro !! 🤘☘🤘🍺🍻

Right on, this is what we’re trying to build!!

Finally someone agrees with me!!!

Wait?!? What?!? What the heck did I get a zero for?!?! 🧐😡😝 -Sori🤟🏻

That's my "won the interpretation contest" score (which admittedly is equally as skewed on my end as it is either of yours lol). Great stuff! Keep em' coming!

How rude! We are all friends here buddy no need to be so serious, Sori and I were just having some playful banter.

Thanks for listening to us!

You actually in Ireland friend ?

True story !