A slow motion topple | Steeple Collapse New London, CT

Подписаться 65 тыс.

Просмотров 282 тыс.

50% 1

The steeple was slowly tiliting towords collapse but nobody noticed. The church steeple of of the First Congregational Church in New London, CT, collapsed at 1:30pm on Thursday Jan 25, 2024. Through frame by frame measurements of the security footage the lean has been measured and described in the video
The currents building owner is Engaging Heaven Ministries. This church was completed in 1851 after the previous church burnt down. The architect rejected the construction of the spire and said the only solution was for it to be rebuilt. This did not happen and it turned out to be a 170 ticking time bomb.
The following is a transcript of letter by Architect Leopold Eidtlitz addressed to the church building committee as recorded in the church register:
New London Oct 21, 1851
Gentlemen,
The walls of the main tower of your church have parted in several places, in consequence of defective masonry and unequal settling, produced by a want of sufficient bond in the walls and by the hurried erection of the steeple.
Mr Blescch and myself thought proper to secure the tower with iron anchors, by which means we succeeded in staying the progress of the parting of the walls.
In order to arrive at the most efficient mode of remedying the defect of the structure in a permanent manner, I have (without your consent) consulted Mr Upjohn, (architect from city f New York) on the subject, and after mature deliberation we have come to the conclusion that in order to secure a sound and substantial tower to your church, its would be advisable as the only sure remedy, to take down the whole of the steeple and tower, and have it rebuilt by a more competent and reliable person than your present contractor. Submitting this, our opinion to your deliberation.
I am, Gentlemen, Most Respectfully Yours.
Leopold Eidlitz of the firm Blesch & Eidlitz
To
Andrew Frink Esq.
Sydney Henn Esq.
VS Perkins Esq.
Building Committee of the first Congregational church, New London.
Voted that the Society take no actionat present on the subject of the communication made by L. Eidlitz to the building committee regarding the main tower & spire of the meeting house.
The meeting was then adjourned without day
Attest Ephehenbrough Clerk
*certain words are indistinct and this is by best assumption.

Наука

Опубликовано:

13 апр 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 492

@Helladamnleet Месяц назад

Nah, judging from those stairs it was SCREAMING out in distress the same way the condo collapse in Surfside was incredibly preventable.

@chrismoyler Месяц назад

EXACTLY SO!! The structure was indeed screaming its distress to all. But nobody listened!

@matthewzeller5026 Месяц назад

Out of curiosity how do you go about fixing something like this? I imagine you can't just pluck out a brick and put in new ones especially if it was already that unstable.

@boggisthecat Месяц назад

@@matthewzeller5026 They built an internal steel brace within the Christ Church tower here (in Christchurch, New Zealand). A mistake was made in starting it further up the inside of the tower, relying on the base to hold up against the expected forces from earthquake, rather than anchoring it in the ground. When it was toppled by the earthquake here in 2011 it sheered off where the brace stopped. These sort of processes are difficult and extremely expensive, so it’s really only very significant buildings where this is viable - and the work done was not adequate in this case. Very few old buildings here survived that earthquake, and most of the much newer high rise buildings (most built from the late 1980s on) were severely compromised and had to be demolished. Not many complete failures and collapses, due to mandatory earthquake strengthening work. Rebuild must now be to much higher structural strength, so most buildings have very obvious heavy structural steel frames. (Insurers took a huge hit when most of the city was written off.)

@matthewzeller5026 Месяц назад

@@boggisthecat thanks for the info. It's crazy how everything can look so stable and then collapse in an instant because of the tiniest things over time.

@boggisthecat Месяц назад

@@matthewzeller5026 Usually there are warning signs of building failure. In the case of the buildings that totally failed here, two were built by the same company in the late 1980s and were found to have been not constructed to the plans. Occupants of the building where the worst casualties occurred had complained consistently over years about structural issues, but no proper inspection was done and remedial work not enforced. The person responsible for constructing those buildings decided he needed to urgently travel to South America immediately after the earthquake. A replacement building near the city centre here that was nearly complete had to have major additional strengthening done. An architectural engineering student happened to be passing by and noticed what seemed to be major problems. They managed to get the ear of city officials and an inspection found that this was another building where the plan was apparently considered optional. People are highly resistant to learning when money is involved.

@RinoaL Месяц назад

I help maintain old buildings, and people are far too trusting that they will last forever and ever when abused. Buildings are machines, they move and wear down. Especially when they get wet.

@ligametis Месяц назад

I think over 500 years old Rotbav church tower also seemingly randomly collapsed in Romania, Transylvania in 2016. But of course there was the same reason, building got old, not enough maintenance, a bit lower quality materials finally gave way.

@TheStygian Месяц назад

True. Water is a huge eroder.

@dizzykwalla1198 Месяц назад

I never thought of a building as a machine but you're absolutely right! They move and sway and take on damage over time which needs repair and maintenance like a car. Well said.

@HobbyOrganist Месяц назад

@@ligametis "On the evening of February 19, 2016, the church tower clock struck twice in Rotbav, then came the end of it. The clock, bells, tower and part of the church’s nave dropped down to the ground in the blink of an eye." That nicely proves the swinging bells in the tower in the end brought it down

@christopher9727 Месяц назад

... Jesus Christ is the only hope in this world no other gods will lead you to heaven There is no security or hope with out Jesus Christ in this world come and repent of all sins today Today is the day of salvation come to the loving savior Today repent and do not go to hell Come to Jesus Christ today Jesus Christ is only way to heaven Repent and follow him today seek his heart Jesus Christ can fill the emptiness he can fill the void Heaven and hell is real cone to the loving savior today Today is the day of salvation tomorrow might be to late come to the loving savior today Holy Spirit Can give you peace guidance and purpose and the Lord will John 3:16-21 16 For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life. 17 For God sent not his Son into the world to condemn the world; but that the world through him might be saved. 18 He that believeth on him is not condemned: but he that believeth not is condemned already, because he hath not believed in the name of the only begotten Son of God. 19 And this is the condemnation, that light is come into the world, and men loved darkness rather than light, because their deeds were evil. 20 For every one that doeth evil hateth the light, neither cometh to the light, lest his deeds should be reproved. 21 But he that doeth truth cometh to the light, that his deeds may be made manifest, that they are wrought in God. Mark 1.15 15 And saying, The time is fulfilled, and the kingdom of God is at hand: repent ye, and believe the gospel. 2 Peter 3:9 The Lord is not slack concerning his promise, as some men count slackness; but is longsuffering to us-ward, not willing that any should perish, but that all should come to repentance. Hebrews 11:6 6 But without faith it is impossible to please him: for he that cometh to God must believe that he is, and that he is a rewarder of them that diligently seek him. Jesus

@henryptung Месяц назад

> Eidlitz added anchor ties in 1851 and in his words they were there "to stay the progress of the parting of the walls". He noted the ties were a temporary solution. _shows modern photograph with ties still in place_ Really demonstrates a key point - in construction, there aren't really "temporary solutions". There's what you built, and then there is (or isn't) the funding and will to maintain/improve it.

@AlexofZippo Месяц назад

“Nothing more permanent than a temporary solution.”

@spex357 Месяц назад

No funding because the Church had a lot of power once and governments really hated it, so tempted the public away from them. Nothing is temporary as far as the weather is concerned, and wet weather is the most destructive.

@baneofbanes Месяц назад

⁠@@spex357genuinely one of the dumbest thing I’ve ever read. Church and state have always been separate in the United States.

@spex357 Месяц назад

@@baneofbanes Not so in the UK.

@baneofbanes Месяц назад

@@spex357 cool, this video takes place in Connecticut, aka the USA, not the UK.

@garywatson3778 Месяц назад

I live not far from there, and I know one of the firefighters who responded. He said it looked like a scene from a war movie. It's a miracle no one was killed, much less injured. He told me: "There was a lady inside in the back office when it happened. She said that she heard the noise, and went to go see what happened. When she opened the door to the sanctuary, she was met with sunlight and wind."

@ominous-omnipresent-they Месяц назад

Noice.

@Paul_Wetor 14 дней назад

That is one lucky person, to be so close to disaster and yet only hear noise. You'd think the collapse would have done more shaking.

@garywatson3778 14 дней назад

@@Paul_Wetor I mean, it is/was made of stone, which is pretty sturdy and sound proof-ish. In either case, I'm sure she felt protected that day.

@DeereX748 Месяц назад

Outstanding 3D computer modeling and overall engineering analysis. I was never aware of this collapse in the news.

@pedecadonstudios714 Месяц назад

Uh... modeling was pretty poor actually especially with the amount of detail clearly visible yet ignored.

@nhutran86 Месяц назад

A few questions@@pedecadonstudios714 What do you know about modeling Second what do you know about 3d animation Third did you see the Google earth mesh

@germansteamlocomotive Месяц назад

i think it went under the radar bc it was ENTIRELY overshadowed by the notre dame fire that happened like what? 4.5 years prior?

@ginog5037 Месяц назад

What news? The joke msm is useless today...

@sirzebra Месяц назад

@@pedecadonstudios714 stick to roblox kid, dont embarass yourself voicing your worthless opinion. Why dont you spend the hours and produce your own version if that's not to your liking ? Because you wouldnt even know where to start, and would have never put in the work, that's why you're blabbering in the comment section. now move along.

@goofytycooner5519 Месяц назад

It's pretty surreal seeing a youtuber from halfway across the world analyze the church I used to go to. I had no idea the steeple had such glaring flaws from when it was first built or that the 2011 inspection was never signed off by a structural engineer

@chrismoyler Месяц назад

THE DISTORTED STAIRCASE tells us all we need to know. That degree of movement was ignored but proved to be fatal! Finally, speaking as a surveyor who monitored the movement of structures for 20 years of my career, it would have been an extraordinarily easy and cheap thing to survey the tilting movement of the tower externally, using modern survey equipment. A log of that movement would have demonstrated clearly any acceleration of the tilt. Why wasnt this very simple surveying procedure enacted?? Madness!

@john1703 Месяц назад

Equally, the report cited at 10:30 is going to be used against the author(s).

@Drobium77 Месяц назад

Anyone with a plumb line from the top of the tower to the ground, could have measured the tilt. Looks like a lot of people simply looked the other way, probably due to cost

@spacethingreckoning5114 Месяц назад

It seems suspiciously convenient that structural engineers were excluded from that study. From the church electing to do nothing after initial warnings, to ignoring very obvious warning signs and omitting the people who would've sounded the alarm, it sounds like the owners of the church didn't want to hear confirmation of what they feared.

@Blackadder75 Месяц назад

@@Drobium77 "in god we trust" it is written on their money..... Every time they look at money they think, should we spend this to repair this? nah.....

@JJRClassic88 Месяц назад

As a New London CT resident and a former member of the Second Congregational Church, I just want to say thank you for making this excellent presentation! You've visually answered so many questions that I've had for months. There hasn't been any coverage of the sudden collapse from the local news since February. I'm looking forward to hearing what the investigation report has to say. Hopefully it comes out soon.

@Mike-Bell Месяц назад

Always happy to hear my efforts are appreciated.

@crazychicken7125 Месяц назад

I know the church itself was demolished, but was the annex/offices demolished as well? I haven't been able to find a good answer.

@JJRClassic88 Месяц назад

@@crazychicken7125 last I saw, the annex building is still intact.

@kacperwoch4368 Месяц назад

Why was the remaining structure demolished? Isn't this like a landmark? Where is the community, the city council?

@AlexofZippo Месяц назад

@@kacperwoch4368it’s likely that with the tower gone, the rest of the building was structurally unsound. I’d wager that it was demolished to ensure safety while a permanent solution is decided upon. The sad part is that a restoration became almost impossible the moment the tower collapsed; the building’s fallen, it’s not coming back. They can rebuild it, but using the old materials and getting age-appropriate materials to match will be an enormous expense.

@timsullivan4566 Месяц назад

Fascinating and perfectly explained. So refreshing to be spared the insulting hyperbole typical of most content in this genre - thank you.👋👍🙏

@donaldhoot7741 Месяц назад

LOL!

@borntoclimb7116 Месяц назад

Agree

@rotunnoe Месяц назад

Agreed! Very well done!

@QPRTokyo Месяц назад

Yes.

@awesomeferret Месяц назад

What "insulting hyperbole"? It's easy to find examples of channels on this kind of topic that are not insulting or hyperbolic, and it's really difficult to find one's that are. Is my RU-vid algorithm just better than yours or something? He's just another great channel, because there aren't really any channels that I've ever come across that fit your accusation. To be clear, I'm assuming that the reason my reality is different than yours is because I've clicked on "the right" videos and probably have watched way more of them (basically, I'm assuming you know something that I don't). Or maybe we are simply thinking of dramatically different genres that happen to both apply to this channel? TLDR: what the heck do you mean by "insulting hyperbole", considering how insultingly hyperbolic that accusation appears to be to this specific RU-vid community? The irony. 😂

@therealzilch Месяц назад

Brilliant analysis. As an instrument maker, I'd just add that it's not impossible that the organ contributed another straw that broke the camel's back: if the masonry was already water damaged and loose, then the constant vibration could slowly shake more mortar loose. Subscribed. Cheers from sunny Vienna, Scott

@alextirrellRI Месяц назад

I've heard stories of churches warning organists not to use certain bass stops because they might damage the building.

@therealzilch Месяц назад

@@alextirrellRI Thanks, that's good to know. But I don't think this was one of those churches. And you're right, of course: the bass pipes put out the most energy by far, and if one of them hit a resonant frequency of a room in the church, it could transfer quite a bit of that energy to the masonry.

@HobbyOrganist Месяц назад

As a pipe organ builder I don't buy a word of that. If vibrations like that was enough to "shake mortar loose" the mortar was already cracked and failing because it was crappy sand or lime mortar that has little more strength than sand, the mortar doesnt actually hold blocks of stone together in any case.

@HobbyOrganist Месяц назад

@@alextirrellRI "Stories" is just that, and has nothing to do with the building, it would apply to already weakened water damaged plaster covered walls and ceilings under or around the organ, but then slamming a nearby door would be all it would take to cause the plaster to fall in that condition.

@HobbyOrganist Месяц назад

@@therealzilch Oh come on now!!! LOL!! a church like this doesnt have pipes that big in the first place, this was not a massive cathedral that had 32 foot open wood or 32 foot stopped wood (that generates very low frequency tones) organ pipes in it! The organ was built in 1870 and had 16' facade pipes as the largest. The church had CLOCKS and at least one big heavy bronze bell if not more for the clock to ring out the time, they were all placed up at the top. Plenty of churches have had to stop using swinging bells because they are so heavy and the back and forth motion they have- literally SHAKE the tower when being used. From an engineering forum; I've been asked to take a look at a church bell tower. I was told that every time the bell rings, plaster falls off the ceiling. They want me to come down and take a look to make sure its not a structural problem. Doesnt sound like a structural problem to me, but I certainly will take a look. It sounds inevitable that vibrations from the bell after years of use would eventually shake some finishes loose. A response included; 2. I did work on a bell tower years ago that had a similar problem. It turned out that there was so much pigeon manure in the bell tower that the added load from the wet manure pile caused deflection in the wood joist and cracked the plaster. Really! There were areas 4' thick of manure! 3. If the church is new, then I would look more toward a structural vibration problem. Perhaps, the bell support structure needs to be stiffened? --- There's also this youtube video titled; Bell ringing at St Mary's Church exposes serious damage to building West Bridgford Wire News The video literally shows the stone wall MOVING back and forth as the bells are ringing!

@crazyguy_1233 Месяц назад

This is incredibly sad. Had the church taken the advice given when it was built this may have been prevented. Had people monitored the tilt this could have been prevented. Had the structural damage been noticed and repaired properly this could have been prevented. Fortunately nobody was harmed but the many times it could have been prevented led up to the loss of this historic structure. We lose these historic buildings everyday often from lack of proper maintenance and monitoring. If we want these places to survive we need to be paying attention to structural changes and shifts. This building's lean doubled in such a short time. It shifted enough in such a short time that had there been monitoring it would have been caught by somebody before it was too late. You have done an incredible job with this video and you have brought up something very important that more should be aware about especially in places with historic buildings.

@Spartan322 Месяц назад

It seems almost miraculous in how avoided and disregarded the problems were, as a Christian it would potentially even suggest that it also was a case of God warning the church. Sometimes He uses very ordinary means to do that. As for why He'd do such, I can't say, I don't know the church, its people, or its history.

@crazyguy_1233 Месяц назад

@@Spartan322 I wish the warnings had been noticed. Too many beautiful old churches have been lost this year due to ignorance and accidents.

@hia5235 Месяц назад

Maybe the govt should stop giving BILLIONS to random countries.

@crazyguy_1233 Месяц назад

@@hia5235 I agree. We should be funding ourselves and stop putting the nation in even more debt. We could be doing more for our people on the streets or our vets who have PTSD and we could be maintaining some of our historic sites.

@hunterbear2421 12 дней назад

@@hia5235 Then again its not like the govt is giving much money, If you look at how much tehy are giving its less then 0,5% of the total amount the country makes. I don't think 0.5% would really make a difference even if we kept it

@kamikitazawa Месяц назад

I used to live in New London and this is the first I am hearing that the church tower collapsed. Just stumbled on this video. That steeple was one of the few attractive elements of the town’s skyline.

@FiscalWoofer 24 дня назад

Wonderful video presentation! Thank you. I bought an old church c1450 we have repaired much of the tower now, but the main reasons for the damage from structural reports are primarily: water damage over decades washing out the lime mortar, then addition of a bell frame that was imposed into already weaker areas high up . The movement of the frame in part acted like a slow battering ram as the two main oak lintels rocked on the west wall corners. There were inadequate ties pinning the four wall at the corners together. Very interesting!

@Mike-Bell 24 дня назад

Thats is very interesting. Good luck on your project

@chosen1one930 14 дней назад

@@Mike-BellI would say it was rain from granite or slate roof where it met at the tower. Water slight leaking down against the roof affecting the already inadequate mortar. That would be my guess by the video. It looks like the tower sinks slightly down than toppling and breaking half way up during the fall. It's just a guess but rain water on roofs that arent checked adequately are a problem. The added prolonged wetness if hidden. From elements with prolonged dry periods is something can be a cause. These are guesses and ideas from everything I've seen other the years on the job.

@nhojnhoj6767 Месяц назад

Another masterful presentation.

@Mike-Bell Месяц назад

Glad you think so!

@Bobrogers99 Месяц назад

Sadly, there are many churches with grand historical buildings and a dwindling congregation that lacks the resources to keep them in good repair. One by one, we lose these architectural gems.

@alexhajnal107 Месяц назад

In many cases they are being repurposed. For example, there's a wonderful coffeehouse in Brunswick, MD that's in a former church.

@buckodonnghaile4309 Месяц назад

@@alexhajnal107perhaps not the grandest example but my neighbour lives in the country church my grandparents were married in in Eastern Canada. It make a beautiful home.

@Nash1a Месяц назад

And they are not building new ones like that anymore.

@thunderbird1921 15 дней назад

@@alexhajnal107 In the small Virginia town I live in, the largest Baptist church moved out of their traditional sanctuary to a a more modern building on the town's outskirts in like the 2000s. The old building is now a performing arts center and business location (a coffee shop is in the annex, the old sanctuary is the auditorium and the church offices are used for various small businesses). A farmer's market is hosted in the parking lot as well, I believe. It was a historic landmark, so thankfully the townspeople found good use for it.

@alexhajnal107 15 дней назад

@@thunderbird1921 That sounds lovely. (Not to mention being a much better use of the space IMO.)

@madmanmapper Месяц назад

If your model is accurate, the side that gave out had quite a few weak points. It appears to be thinner than the front wall, and there are two archways on either side, but offcenter towards the wall that gave out. Add to that two flat roofs on either side where water would pool and leak into the masonry. As so many disasters are, it's sort of a perfect storm. The mangled granite stairs should probably have been a dead giveaway...

@dbaider9467 Месяц назад

Very impressive. Your Plain-speak is much appreciated.

@TheMrMikeo Месяц назад

Great video! I like that you found an old building appraisal

@Yora21 27 дней назад

My mother works in the administration of the Lutheran churches in Lübeck, which includes five very large medieval brick churches. All of them have enormous maintenance costs, and two of them in particular have pretty much permanently been undergoing repairs and reconstruction for decades. They are very much not static objects. (Though one has to question the medieval architects' decision to build a giant church tower on the corner of "Sand Street".)

@philipmcniel4908 13 дней назад

haha especially since the danger of doing that was literally used as a parable in the Bible.

@rickyquinteros7100 Месяц назад

This video is extremely well researched and high quality, great content!

@Mike-Bell Месяц назад

Glad you enjoyed it

@maudessen573 Месяц назад

Mike, this video is is so richly detailed. I really appreciated the examples of other tilting structures, the historic references, etc. It is a testament to your reputation for quality that you were able to get the HD video that helped your analysis. Your voiceover script is very clear and readily understood. I think this is your best video yet! Congratulations!

@Mike-Bell Месяц назад

Thanks Maud. Always appreciate and look forward to your comments.

@patrickradcliffe3837 Месяц назад

A cautionary tale always check the structure behind your organ.

@TheLadderman 26 дней назад

Wow, this analysis is super high quality. I'm really impressed with all the effort you put into tracking the progress of the lean by modeling everything and syncing it up with the camera.

@Mike-Bell 26 дней назад

Glad you enjoyed it!

@BoogsMcNoogs Месяц назад

Mike, I have no idea how I got here but I'm glad I did. Fascinating stuff to learn here.

@MerrimanDevonshire Месяц назад

Thank you sir - very professional report ❤

@GrumpyYank26 Месяц назад

Excellent presentation! Good work.

@Bellicosy 9 дней назад

Tremendous video, Mike. It's wonderful that you are thorough and willing enough to use primary resources to ensure the accuracy of your work.

@Mike-Bell 9 дней назад

Thank you kindly!

@More-Space-In-Ear Месяц назад

What a brilliant video & very easy to understand. Thanks for sharing

@Mike-Bell Месяц назад

Glad you enjoyed it!

@RaspberryWhy Месяц назад

A very thorough video

@BobQKazoo Месяц назад

Absolutely PHENOMINAL video. The great lengths you went to-to ensure your video was high production value and extremely informative is quite impressive.

@Mike-Bell Месяц назад

Wow, thank you!

@Rhinozherous 20 дней назад

Awesome animations and explanation! Thank you very much!

@Mike-Bell 20 дней назад

You're very welcome!

@supermonkeywtf09 Месяц назад

incredible work, this was a fantastic breakdown and intellectual exercise!

@Renville80 11 дней назад

We had a well known pharmacy building that changed hands and was to be remodeled by a regional pharmacy chain to return to their roots, the ‘new’ store being less than a block away from their founding store. They also acquired the building next door which had been a bar for decades. The contractor removed the load bearing wall between the two, even though the city stated they had only given permission for a couple openings between the two. The contractor thought it would work, but without warning, the pharmacy building slid down into the street. Almost everyone got out in time except for one employee (RIP) and a resident in one of the upstairs apartments in the pharmacy building (thankfully rescued with minor injuries). There was some worry about cascading failures in the next buildings, but some timely repairs were completed. The contractor was put under a microscope, some sketchy work was uncovered at other locations (including the next building over), and they are no longer in business. The new owner had the site cleared, proceeded with construction, and has since opened.

@luiztosk Месяц назад

great content, no fillers, and the trick of building the model from Google mesh is pretty cool!

@seldoon_nemar Месяц назад

Wow, this was crazy detailed and concise. amazing video, you have my subscription instantly

@Mike-Bell Месяц назад

Awesome, thank you!

@Apfelvater Месяц назад

this is so good. so much information gathered and combined from that little material. you are a detective, dude.

@Mike-Bell Месяц назад

Glad you think so!

@batarasiagian9635 Месяц назад

Excellent analysis. Many thanks.

@BackToTheBlues Месяц назад

Chesterfield was granted a coat of arms in 1955, featuring a shield topped by a Derby ram, with a cockerel on one side and a magpie on the other. The motto below is just one word, but a very clever choice: 'Aspire.'

@stanley_427 Месяц назад

Incredible video! Everything was perfectly explained, and the recreation was wonderfully done!

@Mike-Bell Месяц назад

Glad you enjoyed it!

@oliverclothesoff5397 Месяц назад

Great video! Thanks for sharing! Subscribed!

@Mike-Bell Месяц назад

Thanks for the sub!

@quantumleap359 Месяц назад

One way to ensure the stability and longevity of any structure is to keep it under a good roof. Once there is water ingress, the damage begins and ultimate failure of the structure is almost inevitable. Good video.

@vladimus9749 Месяц назад

Impressive modeling and investigative skills! This channel will grow by leaps and bounds.

@user-ellievator Месяц назад

Very nicely edited video with great attention to detail! This is professionalism.

@Mike-Bell Месяц назад

Thank you very much!

@richardmattocks Месяц назад

Stunning work, well researched and fascinating video.

@Mike-Bell Месяц назад

Glad you enjoyed it!

@markymark-r Месяц назад

Just discovered your channel. Very interesting and informative. Subscribed!

@Mike-Bell Месяц назад

Welcome aboard!

@alannakennedy5273 17 дней назад

Learned alot...Thank You.

@captainchaos3667 Месяц назад

Fascinating and very well produced.

@Yezpahr Месяц назад

That was a very professional model you perfected there, good job.

@Mike-Bell Месяц назад

Thank you very much!

@user-er1ld4bq2u 13 дней назад

Just stumbled across this, great video, simulation and narrative.

@cinobro6393 Месяц назад

Amazing how the church administrator kept working after the collapse.

@nian60 Месяц назад

Very interesting. Now I want to know more about that shorter tower at 16:19. How is that still upright? I will check it out.

@ptonpc Месяц назад

Fascinating video. Subscribed.

@Lawman212 Месяц назад

Quite a thorough account and a very interesting story. I'm surprised I had not heard about it.

@killaronjones3933 Месяц назад

This is incredibly enlightening and entertaining

@xander1052 Месяц назад

This might happen to the local to me All Saints Church in Isleworth. The 14th century bell tower is unsafe these days. Hopefully they solve it before we lose an icon.

@School-kid123 Месяц назад

Wow this is so well done! I am not an expert, but I think this situation could have been preventable by proper observations. This type of videos always fascinate me.

@-Hari-03 Месяц назад

collapsed "out of the blue"... its literally been building up to this moment for almost 200 years

@WhiteWolf-lm7gj 9 дней назад

Unfortunately, it seems like that's frequently the case.

@EternamDoov Месяц назад

Hey, great video. Thought you'd like to know that on the diagram of the lean angle (such as at 8:01) there is an error. The decade 1930s has no apostrophe in. You may be thinking of the apostrophe in '30s.

@Mike-Bell Месяц назад

Thanks. Useful to know. When I put that in, it didn't quite look right 🤔😅

@awesomeferret Месяц назад

Well done. I thought Building Integrity was the only one who went this in depth, but you arguably outdo him due to your CGI. New subscriber.

@Mike-Bell Месяц назад

Welcome aboard. More like this to follow. Josh seems to have faded away.

@explorer47422 Месяц назад

Imagine if the church congregation was full, there'd have been very few if any survivors based on the aftermath images

@jonnawyatt 12 дней назад

They all would have been with God. That's the main point of being religious.

@weekendwarrior3420 Месяц назад

When you see something leaning, RUN AWAY! If they are stupid enough to let it standing like that, how can they know when it'll collapse? Apparently they didn't even have monitoring equipment installed that would show the dramatically accelerating tilt in prior days. Their level of "understanding" was likely "other buildings tilt even more, so we have nothing to worry about".

@christophergagnon54 Месяц назад

Yup, but leaning towers are monitored daily and inspected probably yearly by engineers.

@chrismoyler Месяц назад

Yes they should be examined annually for their tilt. This is a simple and cheap exercise using ordinary EDM equipment.

@scottbogfoot Месяц назад

Think that high advantage point cameras could, in the future, monitor skylines for minute movements of structures as a early warning system?

@markmalasics3413 Месяц назад

I had no idea this happened! On Sunday, June 7, 2020 I stopped there to take photos of the church for my upcoming photo book Classic Churches Of Connecticut. In the final print I couldn't understand why the church steeple seemed to have a slight curve, and I used PhotoShop to straighten it the best I could. But something didn't look right when I examined and edited the photos that night, but I couldn't figure it out as most architectural photos need a little angle correction. I just wonder if the homeless guy who accosted me was still sitting on those steps in the front when the collapse happened. Thank you for posting.

@samuellourenco1050 Месяц назад

The stone had to gave way due to the increase of the lateral force. My guess is that the steeple was not made out of massive stones, but of small rocks and mortar.

@SysOpQueen Месяц назад

twisted church steeples remind me of «Мор. Утопия» maybe it's the masonry and stoneworks, maybe it's the twist itself, i dunno. good job hunting down the actual security footage and not a re-recording! PS: Fantastic job with your 3D modelling and maths! Very interesting stuff!

@antonsmith1497 Месяц назад

High quality content.

@LTKK Месяц назад

This is the good type of old school youtube content I miss. The algorithm just recommended this for some reason. Maybe because I was in a 9/11 wormhole, and the collapsing steeple is similar in a way. Nonetheless, good video... salute!

@willewiking98 Месяц назад

Excellent video

@dalar2 Месяц назад

utterly fantastic!

@Mike-Bell Месяц назад

Glad you think so!

@j3tts0n65 Месяц назад

Wow this is very interesting The 3d models are great for understanding the collapse

@Mike-Bell Месяц назад

I’m glad you appreciated the 3d’s 😊

@rossritchie7611 Месяц назад

What a story! Good video!

@Mike-Bell Месяц назад

Glad you enjoyed it!

@onlyoneamong300 14 дней назад

Great engineering analysis! On the lighter side, a pleasure to listen to this gentleman talking! He kind of sounds like old, British character Mr Srooge! I can even imagine his old, musty house, with a steep roof, and dormers shedding a constant, misty rain! Brrr! I need a cup of very hot tea already! And warm biscuits! 🥶 ☕ 🍪

@charliem5254 Месяц назад

I can't believe I'm just hearing about this now...

@motohddk Месяц назад

Amazing research on this one!

@Mike-Bell Месяц назад

Glad you think so!

@Bellringercameron Месяц назад

How many many bells in the tower? We’re there any in the small side towers

@bradye21playsIndieHorror Месяц назад

This is really well done. I might have seen this traveling several years ago and not even known. That is ridiculous it was allowed to continue operating with the stairs buckled like that.

@wapartist Месяц назад

Im a commercial building inspector and honestly im surprised this doesn’t happen more often with load bearing masonry construction

@RayBecker 21 день назад

Oh wow, I remember that Church. I was at Submarine School late Fall, 1982.

@rufushowell 5 дней назад

High quality video

@mfree80286 Месяц назад

Interesting that the degraded area is directly behind the organ pipes. I wonder how much vibration would be induced in the structure from the proximity...

@user-lx3th5on8l Месяц назад

Probably where the pedal pipes are located

@theOlLineRebel Месяц назад

OMG! This was a town I frequented when I worked up there a few years, and not far from the train station I used to frequent when going home! If this was so catastrophic, I can’t believe it didn’t make some national news!

@Gabriel87100 Месяц назад

This is so sad, the architecture of that tower was so pretty

@DarkElfDiva Месяц назад

Please do a video on the Purity Distilling Company of Boston's Molasses tank that collapsed in January of 1919.

@kuzter1737 Месяц назад

What great work sir!

@Mike-Bell Месяц назад

Glad you liked it!

@christopher9727 Месяц назад

.. Do you know Jesus Christ can set you free from sins and save you from hell today Jesus Christ is the only hope in this world no other gods will lead you to heaven There is no security or hope with out Jesus Christ in this world come and repent of all sins today Today is the day of salvation come to the loving savior Today repent and do not go to hell Come to Jesus Christ today Jesus Christ is only way to heaven Repent and follow him today seek his heart Jesus Christ can fill the emptiness he can fill the void Heaven and hell is real cone to the loving savior today Today is the day of salvation tomorrow might be to late come to the loving savior today Romans 6.23 For the wages of sin is death; but the gift of God is eternal life through Jesus Christ our Lord. John 3:16-21 16 For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life. 17 For God sent not his Son into the world to condemn the world; but that the world through him might be saved. 18 He that believeth on him is not condemned: but he that believeth not is condemned already, because he hath not believed in the name of the only begotten Son of God. 19 And this is the condemnation, that light is come into the world, and men loved darkness rather than light, because their deeds were evil. 20 For every one that doeth evil hateth the light, neither cometh to the light, lest his deeds should be reproved. 21 But he that doeth truth cometh to the light, that his deeds may be made manifest, that they are wrought in God. Mark 1.15 15 And saying, The time is fulfilled, and the kingdom of God is at hand: repent ye, and believe the gospel. 2 Peter 3:9 The Lord is not slack concerning his promise, as some men count slackness; but is longsuffering to us-ward, not willing that any should perish, but that all should come to repentance. Hebrews 11:6 6 But without faith it is impossible to please him: for he that cometh to God must believe that he is, and that he is a rewarder of them that diligently seek him. Jesus

@timothylegg Месяц назад

173 years is ancient for construction in North America. Practically nothing lasts that long. The fact that it lasted this long makes it a kind of an outlier in durability.

@SamCyanide Месяц назад

I live pretty close to this, surprised I didn't hear about this

@williamlloyd3769 Месяц назад

Appreciate your scientific modeling. PS - Would recently developed laser scanning technology been a better way to evaluate the building? Seems on documentary programs, this method of scanning allows for a better means of detecting subtle clues

@Mike-Bell Месяц назад

Yes Lidar radar is extremely accurate.

@patrickbuildsit Месяц назад

Can anything be said about the placement of the pipe organ? Can that level of repeated reverberation add to the deterioration of a stone wall?

@chris-hayes Месяц назад

the 3d cut-outs are really cool

@paulvalentine1483 Месяц назад

A beautiful think to see!

@fuckoff5893 Месяц назад

It’s a shame it was condemned and demolished completely. Sure it would have been exorbitantly expensive to rebuild from what remained, but whatever they replace it will surely be another modern brutal corporate eyesore

@Biface 12 дней назад

your intro logo is really nice

@peterhagen7258 14 дней назад

You can see on the photos from prior days, that there was snow on the ground at least part of the time. NL had gone through several freeze-thaw cycles in the preceding days. I don't think that the possibility of water infiltration (and resulting freezing) in some of the compromised masonry can be ruled out as a contributing factor.

@vali5411 28 дней назад

This must be a contender for the longest awaited "I told you so!"

@Khumry 26 дней назад

Is Caerphilly Castle the second biggest castle in Europe? Dominates the Caerphilly basin Set in a Lake with Drawbridge over the moat Partly Ruined by Oliver Cromwell who ran out of Gunpowder trying to breach the walls. The Tower leans 131/2 * More than the leaning tower of Pisa. The lake was used as the Thames/Walls of London in a film

@williamv0242 Месяц назад

great video

@Mike-Bell Месяц назад

Thanks!

@TheDeletingnow Месяц назад

do you get commissioned for these videos? the quality is insanely high

@viktorakhmedov3442 Месяц назад

I read in the condition assessment that they filled the tower wall cavities with grout in the 1990s. Surely that would have added weight. Any thoughts on that?

@Mike-Bell Месяц назад

By cavities I presume they are referring to the continuous gap between the outer and inner skins of masonry which were separated for good reason. Filling the cavities would have benefits but also downsides. Without knowing the size, extent and detail it’s difficult to draw any conclusions about the result. But I find it hard that those who were part of the decision to do so would not have seen and known the precarious state of the structure.