Тёмный

A Theory You've Never Heard Of | Michael Robinson | TEDxUniversityofHartford 

TEDx Talks
Подписаться 41 млн
Просмотров 9 млн
50% 1

The Hamitic Hypothesis was a 19th century anthropological theory that claimed that humans originated in Asia and then migrated to other regions of the world. The theory was used to explain the discovery of so-called “white races” in Africa in the late 1800s. The Hamitic Hypothesis was not simply a curiosity of anthropological science. It was an idea that changed lives: from those European colonists who relied upon it to justify their presence in Africa, to the scientists who used it to explain away the accomplishments of African civilizations as a result of “white” influence. Ultimately, the Hamitic Hypothesis anchored a global theory of human origins and migration that, when combined with the Aryan race theory, shaped anthropology, colonial policy, and even the attitudes of Africans themselves for a hundred years.
Michael Robinson is a historian of science and exploration at the University of Hartford. He is the author of "The Coldest Crucible: Arctic Exploration and American Culture." His new book The Lost White Tribe: Explorers, Scientists, and the Theory that Changed a Continent" comes out with Oxford University Press in December.
This talk was given at a TEDx event using the TED conference format but independently organized by a local community. Learn more at ted.com/tedx

Опубликовано:

 

3 май 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 10 тыс.   
@MrJeffcoley1
@MrJeffcoley1 2 года назад
This lecture underscores the importance of understanding the past on its own terms instead of projecting modern ideas and attitudes back into the past.
@AkakaDomenjer
@AkakaDomenjer 2 года назад
This lecture is lies and agenda.
@alexanderrober9587
@alexanderrober9587 2 года назад
@@AkakaDomenjer you must not understand scientific theory. Imagine actually using your brain.
@vibratoryuniverse308
@vibratoryuniverse308 2 года назад
@@alexanderrober9587 do you think that’s an intellectual argument lmao, sad
@thomaslangkvist5830
@thomaslangkvist5830 2 года назад
Realyminportant to know what exactly are we fitghtingfor
@graceclague747
@graceclague747 2 года назад
@@AkakaDomenjer totally agree. Neverending whiteman ego
@joshbarr6390
@joshbarr6390 6 лет назад
Guys. This man is explaining history and a theory that existed; not his personal views/opinions. He ends the video explaining why it's wrong and the damage it has caused and why it's important to remember. He is trying to understand the point of view of the theory's author. There is no racism in this video. If you see racism, it seems like the mr Magoo effect.
@rosyenrica
@rosyenrica 5 лет назад
yes, he is honing in on a lot scientific racism that was prevalent during the 18th and 19th centuries within the social sciences and medicine which suited the colonialist agenda and the dangers thereof, and which are still relevant today (i.e that the observer is separate and therefore objective on what he or she is observing which many within the social sciences in particular have been trying to challenge by highlighting the need for transparency on the lens/perspective, and reasons for the research), but also how those theories from that time, have lingered on in the present and this is exemplary of this, so yes i agree with you.
@TheCaptnHammer
@TheCaptnHammer 5 лет назад
If you don’t watch a video in full, to its conclusion then you should not comment. I see a lot of comments that are addressed by the video. Negative commenters seems to watch the first minute of a video before posting nonsense.
@jcb3393
@jcb3393 5 лет назад
It shows the danger of latching on to the "scientific theory du jour" without allowing for peer review, testing, refinement or even dismantling and replacement with better theories.
@KeithCooper-Albuquerque
@KeithCooper-Albuquerque 5 лет назад
Josh Barr: You are absolutely correct! Well-stated! Thanks for a dose of reality!
@wildranger992
@wildranger992 5 лет назад
No he is saying his personal vews because egyptians built the pyramids and they have more middle eastern dna than african
@alelgnmass9712
@alelgnmass9712 11 месяцев назад
I'm Ethiopian. In Ethiopian you can find from the blackest to nearly white person. I think Ethiopians are the most diverse people in the world. And those people on the illusion are actually my ancestors. They live on the northern part of Ethiopia. That is how they use to live and dress back those days.
@GhostRiley-zs8zb
@GhostRiley-zs8zb День назад
I think Indians are the most diverse, I mean you can find really dark skinned people in India in the south or in Islands to a person who is as white as europeans in the far north mountanious regions
@aluxbalum
@aluxbalum 2 месяца назад
As a Native American (Purepecha, Kickapoo, Comanche) it was always so interesting to me and questionable the history of humanity being so lineal. I always thought there was much more to it, talking solely of the Americas there is evidence and indications of world wide populations being present in the hemisphere. Australian aboriginie DNA is found in some Native American nations, so is African and European vestiges pre dating Columbus are wide spread. The folklore of the world has so much in common
@user-wy2fu4un8r
@user-wy2fu4un8r 17 часов назад
This is false, African and European DNA, artifacts, skeletons, etc are not present in any pre Colombian American societies, as for the Australasians it’s theorized that they could have crossed and populated or mixed with the Indigenous people already there. It sounds like you have a belief that you’re trying to make fit when it just doesn’t
@robinwilkin
@robinwilkin 9 часов назад
I think that Native American and Canadians look like a cross between Mongolian, Philippines, Thai and Chinese!! Nobody else not see this?
@dolmanationable
@dolmanationable 6 лет назад
It's REALLY obvious that people commenting are not actually watching the video. He very clearly does not support this theory, he's outlining how it shaped European colonization of Africa. Watch the damn video before commenting.
@kgthebest11
@kgthebest11 5 лет назад
Thank you
@CastleDragon78
@CastleDragon78 5 лет назад
Right!
@matthewguzda4075
@matthewguzda4075 5 лет назад
Yeah but that's nothing to get angry about! Gr=rrr=r
@dudeinoakland
@dudeinoakland 5 лет назад
If it's a 'Theory you've never heard of', as the title states then why does he have to debunk it?
@danielbaronne753
@danielbaronne753 5 лет назад
@@silentgee9784 well the African continent is at its most peaceful ever and is the fastest growing economic block in the world. You are mistaken to say that the people of Africa are totally in control of their country as multinationals from the western world still have major say there. Remember this is a continent traumatized for hundred of years by slavery and collonization and is slowly recovering from such a trauma. It will take a while for the utopia but we are heading there.
@madoxxxx06
@madoxxxx06 3 года назад
I'm Rwandan and this theory is very right, the Hamatic theory literally caused the genocide, Tutsi and Hutu used to be social classes, but when this theory was weaponized and used as part of the divide and rule policy of the Belgium what was a social class became a different race. That's why so many Tutsi were thrown into rivers, it was to literally send them back to the Mediterranean Sea through the Nile River, where they supposedly came from.
@ph222000
@ph222000 3 года назад
The world is crazy .. (Most)Americans don't realize how lucky we are!
@jamesfranxx6151
@jamesfranxx6151 3 года назад
@John Wright links?
@Lancetronium
@Lancetronium 3 года назад
Damn! It's amazing how much power a misunderstanding or assumption can have, when we're looking for an excuse to rid ourselves of negative emotion.
@trulurecords
@trulurecords 3 года назад
The "Hamatic" curse has been debunked...admitted by the one who added it to the scriptures himself. Now let's look at the history of Yakov,(Yakub,Jacob). Also the encyclopedia hermitica by Walter Scott speaks of the Tamahu.
@davidhollenshead4892
@davidhollenshead4892 3 года назад
Mr. Gilbert Habarugaba, We have had similar Ethnic Cleansing here in the US & Canada. The Métis People were of mixed European & Native Ancestry, mostly from the Great Lakes Region. In the US Métis are very rare, as only those who could almost pass for White remained, with the rest being forced West as White Colonists wanted their land so they became part of Nations like the Lakota, Dakota, etc. But in Canada, Métis still exist but until recently were treated as second class citizens who were pushed into the Frontier by White People, who also wanted their land... So here in the states, we are an almost extinct ethnic group...
@KiberaKid
@KiberaKid Год назад
As an African, I can't help but feel bemused by the attitudes of these early European travelers. I refuse to concede that they "discovered" anything really, because all these people and places had their own identity and heritage long before their vessels littered our horizons. Further, I am deeply saddened to learn that early Africans accepted and adopted these ideas regarding themselves. However, I am glad that there are scholars out there seeking the truth, for its own sake. Thank you for your work, Mr. Robinson. Love from Kenya.
@dawnsalois
@dawnsalois Год назад
and the tribal people of North America feel the same.
@ashantesanaa4310
@ashantesanaa4310 Год назад
The minute he said discovered he lost me
@buttholesniffers
@buttholesniffers Год назад
@@ashantesanaa4310 he did discover it for Europeans. That isn't to say it didn't exist prior to this but that this was when Europeans became aware of it.
@crqf2010ruler
@crqf2010ruler Год назад
What "our horizons"? 15:31 Says "Africa is the most diverse place on Earth". Do you understand what this implies? If not, let me elucidate to you: There is no "our" as there is no such thing as a solid "African" person if not for a continent. Do not bring others to your own personal feud, which is unexistent regardless. Otherwise, this would validate the concept of the existence of races, and therefore of unity, and thus, if you are "African" and you think there is such a thing as "our horizons", then the horizons were littered with "their vessels", and their means another group, a cohesive formation, one that is solid, therefore there is a reason for anyone "European" to protest the refugee crisis that's going on and justify expelling them for the sake of countering colonization, which we have seen to cause slavery and to spread misery, and no one would like that again.
@buttholesniffers
@buttholesniffers Год назад
@@crqf2010ruler I'm pretty sure race exists. How else can they test the DNA of a skeleton and determine what racial group it belonged to? In some cases not even needing to go this far, they can tell just by looking at it's proportions, that is how distinct the skeletons are from one race to the next.
@charlesboyd8325
@charlesboyd8325 Год назад
We are all brothers and sisters floating in space on a rock💯
@Social_Infidel
@Social_Infidel Год назад
That God placed there.
@ClinicalpsychFTW
@ClinicalpsychFTW Год назад
@@Social_Infidel praise Buddha
@Social_Infidel
@Social_Infidel Год назад
@@ClinicalpsychFTW Whatever floats your boat.
@ooooowwussthaataseloik2866
@ooooowwussthaataseloik2866 Год назад
@@Social_Infidel God kills babies. Everyday.
@alimerhi5531
@alimerhi5531 Год назад
Sounds like a TV show
@21stcenturion68
@21stcenturion68 5 лет назад
Those explorers very well may have misinterpreted what they saw, but "blonde" is a very specific descriptor that you can't mistake for anything else.
@ulalaFrugilega
@ulalaFrugilega 4 года назад
21st Centurion yeah! Ge let that drop completely in the latter part of his speech! Why weren't there drawings or some such things?
@bmanwells4200
@bmanwells4200 4 года назад
Blonde does not mean white...
@chipwalter4490
@chipwalter4490 4 года назад
Many children (and some adults keep) blond/ reddish hair in tribes of New Guinea and even some Australian aborigines. Also the whitish hair color of albino people can be taken for blond, which happens in every ethnicity. I think the Global examples given were too cursory, and were left without an confirmation or refutation for the subsequent jump-off into his Mr. Magoo diagnosis specifically directed at African colonialism. ...very weak TEDtalk here...
@DfsOutlier
@DfsOutlier 3 года назад
@@chipwalter4490 - That's what I thought, Feels like he is trying to disprove all white tribes discovered in the world by attacking one instance in one place. Very poor argument.
@consuelochavez3610
@consuelochavez3610 3 года назад
Children in the Andes grow reddish dark hair a sign of malnutrition
@seanmcneill8899
@seanmcneill8899 2 года назад
Amazing talk...Never forget history is written by a person, or even worse by governments.
@loveandlight3486
@loveandlight3486 2 года назад
"his story"
@marcorodrigues8303
@marcorodrigues8303 Год назад
de onde já ser viu que há função de um Governante e Escrever Story . agora como e que se explica a situação das Redes sociais e da mídia se uma vez que a Story foi escrita . só um social mídia.e o Governo fez foi sonda e dar GOP e Depois foi compla e estrupar a mídia Adulterar as Redes e clonar Rask isso ele fez com as redes sociais da mídia em Diretamente com Direct Elected.😮#🤡🚬
@gerryvandepol7630
@gerryvandepol7630 Год назад
History is created by victors…
@jeanmitton4287
@jeanmitton4287 Год назад
History is written by side that wins
@johnadkins5918
@johnadkins5918 Год назад
My history teacher taught me a very important lesson that has stayed with me my entire life and that is “There are three sides to all history the victors the losers and those that were caught up in any given event”
@jonburton4897
@jonburton4897 Год назад
The Mr Magoo hypothesis is spot on , on how humans filter out what they accept as the truth
@Hj61S827
@Hj61S827 Год назад
Really? You think after this entire talk, and Stanley’s life work, that he just “made it all up?” Because he was white? That’s a cop out and dna testing should easily be able to confirm or deny his findings.
@bassplayinggoalie
@bassplayinggoalie Год назад
It's also widely known as confirmation bias
@brucekliewer2623
@brucekliewer2623 Год назад
Yes. This include people who hold evolution to be true. They filter information through that filter. So when soft tissue was found in dinosaur bones, that couldn’t not accept that the age of the dinosaur could be much less than their beliefs would allow so they had to come up with a counter explanation to explain how soft tissue could be there.
@velikovskysghost
@velikovskysghost Год назад
@Jon Burton This is especially true when one has visited the thunderbolts site!, they have a theory based on the early works of Velikovsky that makes so much sense!
@sandyclaflin2844
@sandyclaflin2844 Год назад
I just told him to dump the Mr. Mcgough hypothesis. The reason is it's because it's a very prejudicial against the blind. I know I experienced it.
@waltdill927
@waltdill927 Год назад
As a good rule: Explanatory theory does not describe; descriptive theory does not explain. But, really, theories work not because they are irrefutable -- they work because they are a best "fit" for reality confirmation, and what is real here is just about anything that is fairly predictable.
@Dingbobber
@Dingbobber Год назад
Every scientific discovery and theorem is refutable. That’s the nature of science as a system of belief. There was a point in time where even scientists believed that the earth was flat and women couldn’t board trains due to how their ovaries were theorized to fly out of their bodies at “great speeds” (over 40 MPH). Those were irrefutable facts, the “best fit” for people who were uncomfortable thinking that what they knew could be wrong.
@horustrismegistus1017
@horustrismegistus1017 Год назад
You're a brainrot slime using hueristics and pompously trumpeting it, to feel smart.. and it's because you think you're using logic, need validation, and can't tell logic from hueristics. Go save someone's life for cnn and act selfless. Turn it up.
@waltdill927
@waltdill927 Год назад
@@horustrismegistus1017 Don't comment if you do not understand the subject, Horus.
@watcher805
@watcher805 7 месяцев назад
We need explanatory descriptions of descriptive explanations. Also, don't tell other people what to do unless you're willing to force them. You don't know what he understands
@waltdill927
@waltdill927 7 месяцев назад
Theory explains the phenomenal. Laws describe the cause (force). Descriptions explain nothing. (related: Cartesian Dualism.) Specifically: Phenomena are "moments", describable, but not "caused" by anything: think of an adequate and complete "description" of why, how gravity "works " the way it does. The Newtonian explanation (a modeling of theory) works; it works so well that it has become a mathematical (deductive) "law". But "laws" on this order have nothing to do with inductive reasoning or predictive value. Such "laws" do not contribute to an explanation of what can be reasonably described. They are laws since, while a matter of "best fit" for reality testing (consensus), they are outside the scope of "refutation" -- for the time being, of course. ----Circular argument adds nothing. ...besides, it's only a generalization. (I should have said "law" and not "theory" respecting description, however. My apologies. Laws are just "massively confirmed" theory, after all.) @@watcher805
@mullimulli6259
@mullimulli6259 4 года назад
And there's the Dafaqarwi tribe. They are the ones in the long grass that jump up and down and shout "where Dafaqarwi?"
@magsmcgarrigle981
@magsmcgarrigle981 4 года назад
mulli mulli That’s a Dad joke I can’t wait to tell my Dad!! 🤣‼️🇮🇪
@keirfarnum6811
@keirfarnum6811 4 года назад
mulli mulli 😂😂😂
@MrDomiko
@MrDomiko 4 года назад
Dude!!! LOL.
@royshippen
@royshippen 4 года назад
@@MrDomiko It's "We're the dafarqawi"
@VoodooEagle
@VoodooEagle 4 года назад
This is literally my dad’s favorite joke 😂
@johnmcnulty4425
@johnmcnulty4425 3 года назад
Isn't it possible that some of the Inuit picked up some 'blond genes' from the Vikings that settled briefly in Greenland?
@balderii7340
@balderii7340 3 года назад
Vikings got kicked out Greenland, don't think the Inuit chicks got that frisky with guys twice the size of their men. (get it?)
@DieFlabbergast
@DieFlabbergast 3 года назад
Much more likely that it was just a genetic accident that led to a single tribe having numerous (exaggeration?) or some blond/blue-eyed individuals. Such things happen in parts of Asia. By this time, they would all have blended back into the larger genetic background.
@balderii7340
@balderii7340 3 года назад
@@DieFlabbergast But Asians accidentally born with those characteristics are still Asian, aren't they? During the ice-ages Europe wasn't frozen all the time. There were intervals of a 1000 to 10000 years where the glaciers retreated and grew back again. Where people went (back) into Europe when it was a tundra filled with herds of animals and retreated to different parts of land when the glaciers grew back. During those periods it is of course more than likely they had relations with Asians and Africans, therefor passing on their genetics. Because of these relations Europeans and Asians and also Africans share DNA, but they are all at the base separate races. Ice-age mummies were found in the desert of China that were genetically Caucasian. Not Asians with blue eyes, or a branch. bleached in
@balderii7340
@balderii7340 3 года назад
@@DieFlabbergast Goddammit, half my text is gone! Wait for it,...
@willyreeves319
@willyreeves319 3 года назад
by that measure America has been briefly settled by white people
@JasenChase00
@JasenChase00 10 месяцев назад
I'm baffled as an anthropologist, why he finds it fascinating to find caucasoid DNA in Africa because the Northern African regions have caucasoids called Berbers.. you also have carthaginian DNA, and Greek DNA, Roman etc... I always feel it's better called Southern Mediterranean than North Africa!
@shawnahall7246
@shawnahall7246 9 месяцев назад
It’s considered both
@atilathesonofdanubius4277
@atilathesonofdanubius4277 Год назад
Very insightful information. I'd like to add that there are ancient tribes in Africa that were light skin resembling more Asiatic people, and it didn't have anything to do with white people, but perhaps positioning of how far from the equator they were. Also, you have to take into consideration the military movement from the west of Europe into those places. There are deserters or others that for some reason decide to switch or stay with the opposition, it happens more frequently than not. Americans staying in Vietnam after the conflict, buffalo soldiers switching sides in the conflict in the Philippines and on and on.
@kamion53
@kamion53 Год назад
it is remarkeble that the Khoisan of Southern Africa, actually genetic the oldest people in Africa, were never connected to the Hamitics in spite of being lighter skinned than the Bantu people.
@monnieeeeyt7037
@monnieeeeyt7037 Год назад
Those light skinned people are Khoisan people. Asians look like them. The Khoisan was here first and they are genetically linked to the Khoisan
@penelopehunt2371
@penelopehunt2371 Год назад
Yes . Transkei coast where Mandela came from . Clearly Chinese genetics . Lots of Chinese pottery etc found there
@Sam-df9rs
@Sam-df9rs Год назад
Deserters & those who switch sides do not happen more times than not. It happens more than we would assume, but there is not more soldiers deserting & switching sides during conflict than sticking to their side.
@shells500tutubo
@shells500tutubo 11 месяцев назад
@@penelopehunt2371 Excpt the people are not even remotely connected to Chinese people through DNA.
@elsea8901
@elsea8901 3 года назад
...and in 5 more years it’ll be presented to me for the third time as “a theory youve never heard of”....testing my memory or some algorithmic dingus...
@Peter_Wang
@Peter_Wang 2 года назад
Not sure 2021 is going to be kind to this theory.
@sbritton1313
@sbritton1313 2 года назад
10 years...
@vif3182
@vif3182 2 года назад
it really is irritating the red bar isn't permanent after you've already seen a thingy
@jhonny3053
@jhonny3053 2 года назад
@@vif3182 As long as you watch a video while you're logged in it does.
@deniseclark9051
@deniseclark9051 2 года назад
El Sea - will you be my friend? The above comment is excellent in spite of the current ubiquitous osmoregulatory derping... I now know what hope is- Thank You. Do you wear a faraday hat? I was certain we were the equivalent of paramecium and bam - someone else notices. I am going to go meditate in the Bermuda Triangle for the rest of my existence.
@Adam-bq2vw
@Adam-bq2vw 7 лет назад
Let me save you all some time. He's saying not to be racist. You're welcome.
@airliadazen9495
@airliadazen9495 7 лет назад
Adam 1,
@Adam-bq2vw
@Adam-bq2vw 7 лет назад
Might Is Right Why do you say that?
@Adam-bq2vw
@Adam-bq2vw 7 лет назад
Might Is Right Why do we need different colors?
@Adam-bq2vw
@Adam-bq2vw 7 лет назад
Might Is Right Did you ever think that if your philosophy was more solid, you wouldn't need to get ugly to defend it? I was more than willing to give you that opportunity, and was hoping we'd have an intelligent conversation. Generally, the only people who respond your way are those who feel threatened.
@jamesjones4396
@jamesjones4396 7 лет назад
he's a troll account
@johnsutherland168
@johnsutherland168 Год назад
Interesting. As a genealogist I recognize that many times there may be inaccuracies in paper recorded history, some errors made through simple recording mistakes, some through record translation problems, some through background and experience mistakes, and some through malicious intent, but what genetic genealogy is now showing us is that DNA testing and analysis doesn't lie. Perhaps the way to resolve some of these paper historical questions is to focus a bit more on DNA testing and analysis. However, I've tested with five current fairly large DNA testing companies and found that none of them agree with each other 100%, and that is largely because they all test different parts of the DNA string. But, one of the side benefits of most DNA testing lab results are the migration maps that are often provided, and they could perhaps help resolve some of the white tribe questions. But this effort, because of the numbers of potential records involved, might (would) take a lot of human effort and involvement. Perhaps a problem better resolved by computer, eh? But, would the human written computer algorithms be true, open, and honest, or would they be biased? Humans are such complex animals...
@rustyshakleford1445
@rustyshakleford1445 4 месяца назад
All that understanding, you are high in empathy. I bet you are your loved one’s therapist aren’t you?
@johnsutherland168
@johnsutherland168 4 месяца назад
@@rustyshakleford1445 -- Some love me, and some want to stay away from me. I suspect we are what we are, and since we are all different, we appeal to some, and not to others, eh?
@janforney
@janforney 4 месяца назад
But especially it points to how humans WILL interpret any genetic or color differences tribally or at least thru different lenses. This man provides good empathetic framing which is sorely needed
@johnsutherland168
@johnsutherland168 4 месяца назад
@@janforney -- I suspect that part of the human communications problems is that we-all have different backgrounds and goals in life and we-all often use different word and phrase definitions. Of course the communists always want to put humans into the same box, but that never works out very well for anyone but those who support such a bizarre view of life. If we view others as being different and ask more questions, rather than take the 'I know everything' attitude, I suspect there would be less conflict on Earth. But, I could be wrong.
@7x779
@7x779 2 месяца назад
It seems I recall sing some videos on here that exposed what a hoax and fraud DNA testing is and that it is not able to so accurately find one's ancestry as they claim. That was a few years ago so not sure if it's changed and become more accurate
@yu-haowang6710
@yu-haowang6710 8 месяцев назад
Amazing talk. this talk makes me feel that, anthropology nowadays has been developed by hundreds of years, and near half of them are misrecorded, in African history, especially. I'm a stem student, but this video makes me give more attentions on the history and the development of different races.
@mariacuevas8778
@mariacuevas8778 5 лет назад
What I understood with this talk is the when history was being created there might’ve been more than one theory but the side that prevailed was the strongest theory which suppressed all other theories and thus we might not have the whole story of our history. Being able to go back in history to study all theories of the times and thus maybe understand why according to our knowledge of history sometimes it doesn’t even make sense.
@alexandriarennie5992
@alexandriarennie5992 2 года назад
Person As side of what happened Person Bs side of what happened What really happened all three of these are true unless one person intentionally lied but basically the one who wins the battle is the hero who tells their story
@satoshinakamoto840
@satoshinakamoto840 2 года назад
@@alexandriarennie5992 thus history is his Story, only once story
@danh7739
@danh7739 2 года назад
I think someone "Someone doth protest to much" After all, I can logically prove to you Dragon Flies can't fly as we watch we watch them fly about. Best of luck tu you???.
@jamberry8026
@jamberry8026 2 года назад
History is not theory, but rather the recall of facts which have been recorded. If you lie in present tense and record that lie your history will also be a lie.
@satoshinakamoto840
@satoshinakamoto840 2 года назад
@@danh7739 oh u smart
@kentcoble4578
@kentcoble4578 2 года назад
"They had European hair, noses, and eyes and regarded themselves as foreign people who came from elsewhere." "So they were European?" "No it's just coincidence"
@codyplatona6886
@codyplatona6886 2 года назад
Uhhh have you heard of genetic mutation d umbass
@glenncater1
@glenncater1 2 года назад
they were the original africans !!
@mr.z9829
@mr.z9829 2 года назад
@@glenncater1 😂
@glenncater1
@glenncater1 2 года назад
@@mr.z9829 WE KNOW THAT AFRICANS GOT DARKER OVER TIME WHEN THEY LEFT EUROPE AND STARTED LIVING IN AFRICA! NOW LOOK AT THE AFRICANS! THEY ARE ALMOST ALL DARK-SKINNED NOW !!
@moorishsociety7339
@moorishsociety7339 2 года назад
for exploiters anything needs me some extra explanation.
@jesselore6374
@jesselore6374 Год назад
Brilliantly presented. Thank you
@jenniferwebb5954
@jenniferwebb5954 Год назад
Not really
@dudorotomy
@dudorotomy Год назад
@@jenniferwebb5954 I agree. Shoddy. Why are so many taken in by a bad idea presented slickly…?
@davido3028
@davido3028 Год назад
I bought a ranch in Northern NM and the village near the ranch was supposedly occupied by 'white haired folks' when the Spanish arrived there in the early days. The locals still talk about them... but supposedly they 'left' shortly after the Spanish arrived. This would all be easy to dismiss except that the village's name means 'white hair'.
@a.i.gorerithmit456
@a.i.gorerithmit456 Год назад
Maybe it was a retirement community?
@bruceh4833
@bruceh4833 Год назад
@@a.i.gorerithmit456 Just like the nursing home folks "left" after getting boosted.
@hazzajonesmusic27
@hazzajonesmusic27 5 лет назад
Was interesting to see that first map with the stars on it, there is a star in New Zealands North Island. There were pale-skinned tribes (as well as very dark-skinned tribes, ie: Mori Ori) in New Zealand Aotearoa before the Melanesian and Polynesian people immigrated here 1200 years ago. Pale with ginger hair, many are still around, and many Maori have surprising red hair. 3 tribes with these features were Ngati Hotu, Ngati Ruakopiri and Ngati Kurapoto, all living near Lake Taupo, the largest lake in the Pacific.
@theroidragedtrex7908
@theroidragedtrex7908 3 года назад
Youre kidding? Thank you for the info
@ottodidakt3069
@ottodidakt3069 3 года назад
3 pre Polynesian tribes ? I thought there where only 1. Thanx for the info !
@Bliind
@Bliind 2 года назад
Facts, go back farther tho. That’s still too early in history. Both tribes have sort of voyages in there history
@yoza359
@yoza359 2 года назад
New zealander here, im pretty sure we found chinese relics dated back to 457 ad in nz
@kamion53
@kamion53 2 года назад
could there be a difference in traditional dieet between the dark and the light skinned Maori? When the dark skinned have a dieet that contains enough vitamine D, becoming light skinned has no benefit. When a dieet creates a vit D deficite, becoming light skinned increased the amount of vitamin D obtained through sunlight.
@tvelasquez718
@tvelasquez718 2 года назад
When De Soto ventured in the Southeastern US, he noticed that the Cherokee people had many members with Red & Blonde streaks of hair. And also lighter skin. Historically approximately 500 years prior to DeSotos campaign there was a Welsh campaign by a man named Maddox at the time of William the Conqueror who debarked Wales with 10 ships and were never heard from again. I’d love to see more extensive DNA testing of known Welsh Ancestry.
@lr7221
@lr7221 2 года назад
Yes, indeed. So, Stanley may have encountered Albino people. Some tribes in East Africa, Tanzania, Southern Bantu tribes are known for Albinism. These people were either killed or sent far North Africa. As a matter of fact, the Zunni Tribe in the USA were known for albinism. We are all so connected!
@YungPrince2k16
@YungPrince2k16 2 года назад
@@lr7221 What he claims about Africa is wrong tho at least by calling them White, we have evidence of this but they were Semetic Middle eastern/Caucasian people, not Europeans which we consider White today. Ham is a Middle eastern Lineage .. not European. East Africans have confirmed Semetic ancient dna.
@SCHMALLZZZ
@SCHMALLZZZ 2 года назад
@@YungPrince2k16 Arabs and Jews and all other Semetic Speaking peoples are considered white by the USA census.
@YungPrince2k16
@YungPrince2k16 2 года назад
@@SCHMALLZZZ Brother even if we go off lightskin genes, lightskin evolved firstly in the Middle East 22-28,000 years ago compared to the genes that evolved in Europe 8,500 years ago which by the way both are two different genes. All the ancient migrations into North/East Africa were from the Middle East, not Europe. They were lightskin yes but not what we in America label "White". Stop trying to steal Middle Eastern history.
@Musick79
@Musick79 2 года назад
@@YungPrince2k16 caucasians came from Asia. Ever heard of the Caucasus mountains? I’m sure many escaped and migrated over the years to all 4 directions, but the ones captured by Assyria, were placed north of Assyria to buffer the border. All those areas caucasians were known to come from. They went North, East, and west from there everyone assumes.
@juliawoodman7916
@juliawoodman7916 Год назад
Very interesting looking at this map and thinking in terms of continental drift.
@mikemalo6336
@mikemalo6336 Год назад
There are totally obvious differences between the peoples of Africa along the eastern coast from yemen to ethiopia, each country has a characteristic look. Also the tribes of central africa around the congo have very different body shapes along with the facial differences of the east coast.
@oranebrown2169
@oranebrown2169 Год назад
Yes this known Kenyan look different from Ethiopian, Ethiopian breed with neanderthals, Kenyan genes is pure it will serve them well.
@mikemalo6336
@mikemalo6336 Год назад
@@oranebrown2169 aren't you cheerful.
@oranebrown2169
@oranebrown2169 Год назад
@@mikemalo6336 I tell no lies, east African and inhabitants of the Swahili, are mix breed
@skp8748
@skp8748 Год назад
@@oranebrown2169 were the original people. The j haplogroup that Niger Congo people have is new. Science doesn't care about your silly theories
@IDontBuyIt50
@IDontBuyIt50 Год назад
@@skp8748 and Aboriginal Australians say they were never in Africa, they also look very different, in fact, if it was just about looks, I'd say they were right, and were likely first. I have always assumed the out of Africa theory was wrong, because the dates are proven to be wrong. Yes, much like the big bang they just push the date back and act as though the theory is still fine.
@dipaolo3955
@dipaolo3955 6 лет назад
It seems to me that people are making negative comments before watching his conclusion where he claims the Hamitic Hypothesis is BS. Either that or his Mr. Magoo hypothesis applies to the comments as well.
@dieselbourbon3728
@dieselbourbon3728 6 лет назад
He does this with zero evidence or proof. Speculation is not very scientific.
@i-v-l9335
@i-v-l9335 6 лет назад
The Mr Magoo Hypothesis is very very good!
@r13hd22
@r13hd22 6 лет назад
Racial determination is based on cranial measurements, not skin color. Did Mr Robinson, at ANY point, use SCIENCE to form his hypothesis? No. He SHOULD have found out the cranial measurements of these "white tribes" to determine if they WERE white tribes or not, then make a hypothesis. So, it is actually Mr Robinson that is suffering from his own Mr Magoo hypothesis.
@theculturewatch2414
@theculturewatch2414 6 лет назад
Its sad you actually believe this.. sadder still is you believe makes you smarter than the rest of us.. waiting for your arbitrary and impotent 'stats'
@Drutzie
@Drutzie 6 лет назад
Richard Depaola jr - Where did you read that race is based on cranial measurements, Mien Kamph?
@byamugishabrian8062
@byamugishabrian8062 Год назад
I am Ugandan. 🇺🇬 The entire story surrounds my place of origin (Western Region of Uganda) so I feel particularly touched by such a discovery. I have for long sought to find the cause of difference in color among the natives, which is usually attributed to intermarriages with foreign nations. This theory opens up a new field of discovery. Fascinating
@amirhassanel6124
@amirhassanel6124 Год назад
The differences in skin tone do not mean there was intermarriage with foreigners outside of Africa.
@binder946
@binder946 Год назад
Blacks are blacks with variation is skin tones.
@VeritasEtAequitas
@VeritasEtAequitas Год назад
Yes, the old "out of Africa" hypothesis has been thoroughly disproven. It's a narcissistic trap.
@mikeaskme3530
@mikeaskme3530 Год назад
@@VeritasEtAequitas actually it has not and you just saying it has does not make it correct. Ignorance is abundant on this video.
@sharaudramey9336
@sharaudramey9336 Год назад
@@VeritasEtAequitas 🤣🤣🤣
@superwildside4585
@superwildside4585 Год назад
"History is a set of lies agreed upon." - Napolean Bonaparte
@southwestchannel6715
@southwestchannel6715 Год назад
From what i've seen, just about every great "explorer" had an indigenous guide of some sort that had already been there, took care of the the explorer and his team when they fell ill or got lost.
@tubester4567
@tubester4567 Год назад
The speaker ignores the possibility of white people being taken as slaves. The whole world has a history of slavery, we know white people were enslaved in Africa, Europe and Asia. Even if only 2 or 3 white women were taken, they could produce a small tribe of lighter skinned Africans in just a few years. Europeans could have even bartered a few poor white women, in exchange for other goods.
@Omega0850
@Omega0850 Год назад
Isn´t it great to be the very first to discover something?
@anupamachannan602
@anupamachannan602 4 года назад
Excellent command over the topic. Very profound and interesting talk. I wonder why some people have given thumbs down. They must be the ones with no interest in the topic and neither listened nor followed anything. Why did you have to comment if this was too over your head? Go look for something you'd follow.
@mtlicq
@mtlicq 2 года назад
"Victoria is the ultimate source of de Nile" - Victoria's Secret
@sippndipp
@sippndipp 2 года назад
Lol
@kellyhall7373
@kellyhall7373 Год назад
Us guys know that secret.
@pickettywitchoriginal
@pickettywitchoriginal Год назад
Cleopatra‘s favourite store
@Nino_Row
@Nino_Row Месяц назад
3:37
@Nino_Row
@Nino_Row Месяц назад
3:37
@raimundomuthemba766
@raimundomuthemba766 7 месяцев назад
Great talk. Sadly the effects of this are still present in Africa today but we are waking up to that fact and working towards change.
@ThePearsch
@ThePearsch Год назад
The last few minutes were the most informative.
@pronoob1983
@pronoob1983 7 лет назад
Yup, most of the thumbs down are due to people not really listening to what he is saying. What is being explained here is an idea that had a significant number of followers in its day, influenced the thoughts and actions of people far and wide, and shows how preconceived notions can blind a person, or group, from reality. Good talk, this should not be forgotten! :)
@major600
@major600 7 лет назад
He expended an awful lot of words to explain how this stupid, stupid Bible-centered theory influenced a bunch of bigots in the 19th Century, and to a lesser degree, the 20th century. The Mr. Magoo Theory was more interesting, but even that was simply an explanation of confirmation bias.
@Lakelighter
@Lakelighter 7 лет назад
Comedy
@VJBlues
@VJBlues 7 лет назад
I am far, very far from been a political correct oriented individual, and I listen to this and to any other theory because when an scholar do a true UNBIASED research it have to be expose to each and every theory in order to formulate an opinion.
@haraldv2383
@haraldv2383 7 лет назад
Nope, my thumb down is for not mentioning John Hanning Speke even ONCE in this speech. And for not doing his research properly
@KenJackson_US
@KenJackson_US 7 лет назад
Well come on, Peter Lee, speak up. Say something. What do you think?
@jolly7728
@jolly7728 2 года назад
It's fascinating to hear someone pontificate on evolutionary theories that can never be confirmed but can only be hypothesized upon, demonstrating that there is still so much we don't understand and probably never will.
@speciesofgark4169
@speciesofgark4169 2 года назад
How could you know what can never be confirmed?
@shawnmontgomery3569
@shawnmontgomery3569 2 года назад
@@speciesofgark4169 That is called faith.
@speciesofgark4169
@speciesofgark4169 2 года назад
@@shawnmontgomery3569 but that's not knowing. Faith has nothing to do with knowing anything.
@shawnmontgomery3569
@shawnmontgomery3569 2 года назад
@@speciesofgark4169 It is by faith that people were getting a COVID vaccine to prevent infection and transmission of COVID.
@tlahe2
@tlahe2 2 года назад
@@shawnmontgomery3569 - Even though we Montgomerys have to stick together, Covid is science not faith; of course one could have faith in science as I do.
@RobbyTripp
@RobbyTripp Год назад
Great video and presentation. Very intriguing.
@bluerose3385
@bluerose3385 Год назад
The book, the 7 Daughters of Eve, always fascinated me as well. It starts to make sense.
@villagenz
@villagenz 3 года назад
If you are interested there is a documentary called Skeletons in The Closet from Aotearoa, New Zealand which is in a similar discovery shape.
@munchyghecho1329
@munchyghecho1329 3 года назад
thanks emma!
@SiliconBong
@SiliconBong 2 года назад
It was here on Tubes in the early two thousands, but seems to have been taken down/disappeared.
@pappagallagher2227
@pappagallagher2227 2 года назад
That was complete fraud
@pappagallagher2227
@pappagallagher2227 2 года назад
@@SiliconBong yeah because it was completely made up
@SiliconBong
@SiliconBong 2 года назад
@@pappagallagher2227 That's what they want you to believe :o
@BrianStone0
@BrianStone0 7 лет назад
Close your eyes and imaging Owen Wilson is giving this talk
@papadopp3870
@papadopp3870 7 лет назад
That is almost the funniest thing I have experienced. Hard to believe it isn't OW!
@erins.5420
@erins.5420 7 лет назад
Brian Stone I can't stop hearing Owen Wilson now!
@norml.hugh-mann
@norml.hugh-mann 7 лет назад
Erin S. hahaha so true!!!
@noph785
@noph785 7 лет назад
now im imagining owen giving a speech to ben stiller
@ebkdeviousd3392
@ebkdeviousd3392 7 лет назад
lol
@rebeccashifflet8843
@rebeccashifflet8843 Год назад
Loved this!! So interesting!
@keithkersten5586
@keithkersten5586 Год назад
Love this and How important our Historians are for todays generation's to discover. Love exploration histories!
@cryptolover827
@cryptolover827 Год назад
Love it too, shame I could not have a teacher like this who could actually make me thinking about history a lot more than remember a dates of events! Current educational system is so behind of technology that I find it difficult to actually learn more from it than search engines, staking it up with gptchat, current system is doomed to fail.
@userman44
@userman44 2 года назад
11:26 Robinson: "Literally all of Africa had been carved up by Europeans." Ethiopia: "Excuse me?!?"
@ashantesanaa4310
@ashantesanaa4310 Год назад
Complete nonsense
@TGIM
@TGIM 6 лет назад
Wow, I learned something today. Thank you. I am of Rwandan descent and during the genocide, Hutus referred to Tutsis as Ethiopians or Nilotics. Even though genetically it has never been proven, the history that was tought to us and passed from previous generation is the Hemetic theory due to colonialism and people believe it to this day.
@suppernova1184
@suppernova1184 6 лет назад
Hametic is a myth but Tutsi are mixed Ethiopian ,nilotic and Bantu (just like many hutus due to intermarriage) ...im Somalian and i believe Tutsi arrived to Rwanda from east Africa (no idea where exactly ) Rwandan people look very similar to Masai tribe in Kenya (they are half Ethiopian) and i notice many of you look like our people i even saw your president family and they look from horn of Africa but they are taller off course
@r13hd22
@r13hd22 6 лет назад
Umm, it has been proven genetically...both via DNA and via cranial measurements, the thing the speaker conveniently left out so his opinion makes sense.
@user-ti4dl8tw7h
@user-ti4dl8tw7h 6 лет назад
Miseducation is so sad...
@MandeepSingh-bv2zw
@MandeepSingh-bv2zw 6 лет назад
84JLane thats exactly why one must never forget his roots. If d next generation is not taught the history of their forefathers, they will be susceptible to believe anything and everything that is taught to them as history, including propoganda.
@ghettoyouthkatakyni7843
@ghettoyouthkatakyni7843 5 лет назад
84JLane you need to wake up they are just trying to graft albino to them
@thesetruths1404
@thesetruths1404 Месяц назад
Hollow Earth. The mighty governments prevent the north and south poles from being explored. I find that interesting. Furthermore, many discoveries and accounts of strange experiences around both.
@davidmedley6232
@davidmedley6232 Год назад
What do we do as online instructors who have no control over our curriculum? We know that they've constructed to the middle but don't have the time to rewrite an entire set of resources! Shouldn't they be the ones watching this video?
@daaadoooo
@daaadoooo 3 года назад
*finally: the based land*
@SirMonty_
@SirMonty_ 3 года назад
I dont get it
@jehriko7525
@jehriko7525 3 года назад
@@SirMonty_ consider yourself lucky
@qwejxkwbdk
@qwejxkwbdk 3 года назад
I don’t get it
@johnymackd7933
@johnymackd7933 3 года назад
Hyperborea, we must return
@qwejxkwbdk
@qwejxkwbdk 3 года назад
@@johnymackd7933 isn’t Hyperboria a far-right conspiracy theory?
@danh7739
@danh7739 2 года назад
No picture can capture how spectacular these monuments are up-close and in person They're stunning relics from a bygone era, but they're also mesmerising works of art. I saw them 40 years ago and I can still remember them as if I saw minutes ago.
@Snow-bq6ny
@Snow-bq6ny 2 года назад
wtf are you referencing human beings as relics you saw 40 years ago?
@jonathanslayton3112
@jonathanslayton3112 2 года назад
I agree in terms of the monuments. I presume you are talking about the pyramids picture he used as a reference point. Totally not what the lecture was about, but way to focus on 1 tiny thing mentioned in the video. But I agree. Much more spectacular in person I would imagine.
@danh7739
@danh7739 2 года назад
@@jonathanslayton3112 Happy New Year; I'm glad you presumed and didn't assume. Best of luck to ya'.
@charlytaylor1748
@charlytaylor1748 2 года назад
Dan, you seem to have broken some unwritten yt comments rule. I'm not entirely sure what you did wrong, but don't do it again or you'll get commented at.!
@danh7739
@danh7739 2 года назад
You show signs of being a genus; beware no good can come from it. Good luck and good riddance to all.
@jeanmorin3247
@jeanmorin3247 Год назад
We are progressing! We are progressing, my good man! When you suddenly understand that your eyesight is not as good as you believed it to be, you then realize that things are not what you see them to be. This creates a wide opening in the acceptation to be wrong. Accepting to be wrong is the most basic tenet of intellectual honesty, integrity and science. You have to actively seek ways in which you could possibly be wrong in what you see if you want to be honest. Mr Magoo becomes a telling allegory of what people naturally become without the help of a self-testing methods: erratic yet self-assured.
@apollomars1678
@apollomars1678 Год назад
funny part of these old theories is often, that they put the core of civilisation in the near east asian area or in india and they define these groups of the west of India as white, including all today called muslim arabs or turks etc.
@WhiteFyre
@WhiteFyre 3 года назад
1. - There some natives of New Zealand who are red-headed. They tell of a story where their ancestors come from far away to escape a brutal war and came to New Zealand, and married with the Natives already there. Apparently some of them didn't stay there, but move to PNG. When DNA tests were done on these people, it was found that they are closely related to people from the Middle East! 2. - We are not taking into account that we do *not* know what happened in our *previous civilisations!* There are TONS of evidence saying that the world was previously civilised (and possibly an advanced civiisation). But a great cataclysm/natural disaster/flood occurred that wiped out humans save for a few survivors. And we lost all our technology and scientific knowledge. We reverted back to living as cave dwellers. 2.i. - WHO'S TO SAY that this previous civilisation wasn't international, and that the people travelled all the time? Maybe that is why there are PYRAMIDS around the world, including Japan, China, Indonesia, South America, Egypt and so on. 2.ii. - This might also explain why the DNA of SOUTH Native Americans were found to be genetically connected to Native *Australian* DNA, whereas the DNA of NORTH American Natives are connected to Eastern Europe genetically! 2.iii. We don't remember all our human history!! ✨🐬✨
@georgedunn320
@georgedunn320 2 года назад
Red hair is the result of a mutation in which melanin is imperfectly assembled. It can occur anywhere.
@pinkdoll3578
@pinkdoll3578 2 года назад
This doesn’t have enough likes for my taste
@WhiteFyre
@WhiteFyre 2 года назад
@@pinkdoll3578 oh I get likes and comments disappearing all the time.
@susanaldridge2000
@susanaldridge2000 2 года назад
By undermining Sasquatch searchers, he loses my respect
@mirba6933
@mirba6933 2 года назад
You are completely right. Never mind what i think about certain topic!
@bcguitarteacher7328
@bcguitarteacher7328 Год назад
Yet we still haven't found it or proven it. Imagine of these people were actually being tricked for decades. Ouch, that's got to hurt.
@lilas8217
@lilas8217 Год назад
by underminding the mentally ill?
@mirba6933
@mirba6933 Год назад
@@lilas8217 Exactly
@Gstv76
@Gstv76 8 месяцев назад
While trying to rewrite history and saying at the same time, "This isn't like some wacky idea like scientists who go looking for Sashquatch" made me belly laugh! That, sir, is who your audience is! AKA, opened minded people.
@whitekaren7742
@whitekaren7742 8 месяцев назад
do you think bigfoot doesnt exist? lol
@Gstv76
@Gstv76 7 месяцев назад
@@whitekaren7742 I'm neutral.
@whitekaren7742
@whitekaren7742 7 месяцев назад
WELL THEY DO EXIST !! I LIVE NEAR A FEW FAMILIES@@Gstv76
@danjf1
@danjf1 Год назад
The Ainu people are fascinating. A whole Ted talk could be devoted to just their people.
@trashpanda7859
@trashpanda7859 7 лет назад
Fyi this is a informational video. He's offering context. Not something to take offense over. To which, based on the comments and dislikes... Over half seem to be entirely missing the context and unable to listen outside their own.
@ingeleonora-denouden6222
@ingeleonora-denouden6222 4 года назад
Exactly.... they react like Mr. Magoo !
@trashpanda7859
@trashpanda7859 3 года назад
@HEREWARD THE WAKE *context not content.
@Blalack77
@Blalack77 7 лет назад
damn...that was an eloquent breakdown of mr. magoo... this guy has a way with words.
@bigpanda307
@bigpanda307 6 лет назад
LOL
@Barutokun
@Barutokun 6 лет назад
The mr. Magoo hypothesis, otherwise known as confirmation bias
@uppitywhiteman6797
@uppitywhiteman6797 6 лет назад
But Mr. Magoo is a great analogy
@dhutch71
@dhutch71 Год назад
Thanks for a well-presented talk of this nearly unknown theory. As DNA sampling of populations continues around the globe, the various tribes, civilizations and migrations of humans will continue to be refined and reveal our diversity and our origins.
@ironknives5395
@ironknives5395 Год назад
You can't get history or origns from dna only close relatives.
@Yarblocosifilitico
@Yarblocosifilitico 8 месяцев назад
Indeed. But the results seem to be contradicting the official narrative, so their not talked about, just kept as side news.
@natashagattis5694
@natashagattis5694 4 месяца назад
WOW I learned so much in this video. I have heard about this more and more the last 6 months!! I'm so glad that the truth is starting to come out and I'm here for it!!
@LJSims-ob3dv
@LJSims-ob3dv 2 месяца назад
There could’ve been albinos on that mountain 😂 all speculation
@lionsgorrilla8822
@lionsgorrilla8822 4 года назад
After reading the comments first. I enjoyed his presentation non- bias(ed)(ly).
@Javajoinjun
@Javajoinjun 4 года назад
"For those of you who aren't old enough to remember Mr. Magoo, here's an even older and less popular example you won't get either."
@HeavyJEdgar
@HeavyJEdgar 3 года назад
true
@righteousred723
@righteousred723 2 года назад
Kek
@Tubulous123
@Tubulous123 2 года назад
"Who is Don Quixote" lol - nice:)
@balaam_7087
@balaam_7087 Год назад
“Noah parks the ark on top of Mt Ararat” 🤣 “Shem! Japheth! If you two kids don’t knock it off back there I swear to God I’ll turn this ark around!”
@francesmendenhall189
@francesmendenhall189 Год назад
According to Luis L'Amour, who had been there, the people of the Rif mountains in N Africa appear to be completely white, including numerous redheads. Possibly descendants of the "People of the Sea" who invaded the Middle East about 1500 BC. Supposedly they included the Hittites and "philistines" (Pyoset) of the Bible.
@cynthiajohnson9412
@cynthiajohnson9412 3 года назад
Doesn't sound very scientific to pass everything off as observational prejudice. The dismissal is about as scientific as observational prejudice itself. It's like saying I'm not capable of any level of objectivity, so you're not capable of any level of objectivity either. Maybe, or maybe not.
@bindaredundat-uv6wz
@bindaredundat-uv6wz 3 года назад
stop with you nonsense !!
@abutorab2914
@abutorab2914 3 года назад
Stan was a lier.. where are these white tribes now!! In those days in was easier to get funding by lieing 👍
@paulcampbell840
@paulcampbell840 3 года назад
Quite possible that there would be no trace of ancient white africans. We know what has happened to many albino africans in their recent history.
@yardfowl3149
@yardfowl3149 3 года назад
@@abutorab2914 as you say that consider the rest of the lies you have been taught that were spread under the same principal. Offer proof of your claim or remain seated.
@orlamcmanus9019
@orlamcmanus9019 2 года назад
He probably never heard of the thousands of years of back migrations, Stan didn't either but he was slightly more on thr money noting admixture, but wrong to pass it off as "white" should have said Eurasian lol
@jonnipon3491
@jonnipon3491 7 лет назад
apparently hardly any commentator heard the whole speech. the lecturer is actually NOT advocating the hamite hypothesis, but describing it as dead buried colonial bullshit. which is correct.
@jonnipon3491
@jonnipon3491 7 лет назад
Benjamin _ R8ght. Egypt. Which is not sub Sahara Africa.
@jonnipon3491
@jonnipon3491 7 лет назад
Benjamin _ This is what Google gas to say: Hair color is a fascinating study in itself, and the wide range of shades portrayed in Egyptian art does, to a large extent, reflect the diverse range found in reality. The most common hair color then, as now, was a very dark brown, almost black color, although natural auburn and even (rather surprisingly) blonde hair are also to be found. With their great fondness for elaboration, the Egyptians’ skillful use of dyes has produced yet further shades for us to study, analysis showing many to be various forms of henna, which even an aged Rameses II had used regularly to rejuvenate his white hair.
@jonnipon3491
@jonnipon3491 7 лет назад
Conclusion: nobody knows the exact origin of the ancient egyptians. They clearly had both light and dark hair. This has nothing to do with the claims made in the video. It's about dated theories about there being white people living in sub saharan Africa in pre historic times. There are no proof for this theory and it's considered bogus since many years.
@jonnipon3491
@jonnipon3491 7 лет назад
Benjamin _ No, watch it again. there are plenty of youtube videos that might touch on your personal human race theory, but this is not it.
@joeschultz2
@joeschultz2 7 лет назад
+Benjamin: So how come the Nubians and Egyptians, whose roots are subSaharan, built a great culture long before Northern Europeans ever did?
@joanndirks8024
@joanndirks8024 Год назад
So very interesting. I'm a history nut . His subject is so interesting. But then there are some of us who want to find out more, but are afraid of "ruffling the feathers" so to speak, if we ask too many questions.
@wolcottwu756
@wolcottwu756 Год назад
Would be interesting to understand the extent to which Hamitic attitudes have fostered the legacy of slavery among Africans that continues to be pervasive today. Furthermore, were those that captured individuals and sold them as slaves to Arabs and Europeans of lighter skin than their victims?
@halweilbrenner9926
@halweilbrenner9926 2 года назад
I theorize in my head, frequently, about humanoid racial origins & migration. Really fascinating subject.
@balderii7340
@balderii7340 2 года назад
What have you come up with so far?
@ranevc
@ranevc 2 года назад
Nothing
@mightymouse1111
@mightymouse1111 2 года назад
I dont think I really have extraterrestrial origins but the rh-negative theory is a fun rabbit hole
@dexterabend8945
@dexterabend8945 2 года назад
@@mightymouse1111 We came from a nordic alien race
@mightymouse1111
@mightymouse1111 2 года назад
@@dexterabend8945 aaaaaaah, last I heard it was a basque alien race...
@johnmcnulty4425
@johnmcnulty4425 3 года назад
Don't forget how the Vikings travelled very far.
@jacobhall7718
@jacobhall7718 3 года назад
Northern Eurasian People’s, who were partial ancestors of the Indo Europeans had the same genes for blonde hair. People always say “Vikings Vikings Vikings”, the Vikings were active 1000 years ago, the Ancestors of those Inuits that gave them blonde hair would’ve happened 10,000-20,000 years ago maybe more.
@VikingMuayThai
@VikingMuayThai 3 года назад
Yamnyan Chariot Chads
@nathan-jh2ku
@nathan-jh2ku 3 года назад
"Sail our ships to new lands, fight the horde" led Zeppelin
@salingstuff8085
@salingstuff8085 3 года назад
Yes but not biblical or ancient it was within the past 6k years of the birth of the white race
@dustingilger8258
@dustingilger8258 3 года назад
But Leif Eriksson was the first recorded to discover Canada, and norsemen were known to leave behind small settlements. Wouldn't that also be a viable source of blond hair?
@sirmanni4534
@sirmanni4534 Год назад
Very informative thank you. I wonder if this theory and others account for giant people who are 8 - 9 feet tall or higher. Such as Magellan’s account of very tall people on the Patagonian coast.
@meggtokyodelicious
@meggtokyodelicious Год назад
I was thinking the same thing. I doubt this guy knows the existence of tartarian giants civilization worldwide pre 1776, amazonian giants, Manchurian giants, Japanese giant sumo wrestlers, Persian Giants etc..... pre last deluge aka global great reset.....
@thealchemist7871
@thealchemist7871 Год назад
I heard giants were indians N Chinese...all Asian countries 🤷I dnt no how true that is....
@HeartOfTheSource
@HeartOfTheSource 10 месяцев назад
Hmmm. I discovered Patagonia as part of my recent genome deep analysis. Almost every continent actually. The Andes, North America Plains, Central Asian, Africa ( all over including small percentage Egypt) Meso American included which I traced back linage to the Toltecs. Europe: Scandinavia, Ireland, England & France...I've been everywhere and the ancestors are running through my veins daily.m to remind me that I'm a nomad.
@watcher805
@watcher805 7 месяцев назад
​@@thealchemist7871no there were giant white redheads too, their skulls are a foot tall and in museums
@brer_rabbit2090
@brer_rabbit2090 Год назад
The Ainu were the original inhabitants of what we today call Japan. The Ainu were displaced by the "Japanese" who likely migrated from China. The only remnants of the Ainu are found in Hokkaido today.
@am6322
@am6322 3 года назад
Hyperborea more like Hyperbased and redpilled
@fkssjs
@fkssjs 10 месяцев назад
Fellow telegram user?
@conscious3714
@conscious3714 6 лет назад
Interesting talk, specially for people who are not aware of Hamitic Hypothesis.
@ShowSheezy26
@ShowSheezy26 3 месяца назад
5:20 Greeks in white shirts is a very interesting statement
@laughingvampire7555
@laughingvampire7555 Год назад
today we know of this very interesting concept, cognitive biases, one is called ingroup bias, and this thing makes us believe that the members of our group are superior to the members of another group, but the method to determine our group and the method to determine the other groups can change a lot. the method we choose can be based on political alliance, on nationality, on economic system, on religion, on the color of the skin (not necessarily race), on race or like in infamous Jane Elliot's the color of our eyes. This is a key factor that is forgotten in any conversation about race. Another fact that is forgotten is that Europe was like that, they saw the differences in what we would called ethnicity today but the latin word for that in those times would be race.
@mayainverse9429
@mayainverse9429 Год назад
there is also a thing called victory bias. if you win at something you are superior
@angelab4652
@angelab4652 3 года назад
I guess humans have been explorers for far longer than they taught me in school
@ricardouribe4173
@ricardouribe4173 3 года назад
How long was that?
@brianbishop9905
@brianbishop9905 3 года назад
Sweet cross. So right about 6K, I reckon?
@beckyboop3517
@beckyboop3517 3 года назад
Indeed they were. There are many videos on here about ancient civilisations and out of place artifacts. all mind blowing stuff. School and the rest of it have got it all wrong, science is proving that. Try looking at Gregg Braden and Graham Hancock.
@Smason432
@Smason432 3 года назад
@@beckyboop3517 graham handcock is a little bit too cringe 😬
@beckyboop3517
@beckyboop3517 3 года назад
@@Smason432 oh i do like him.
@nazgulkardar1235
@nazgulkardar1235 2 года назад
Michael Robinson explains the mindset of European explorers in the 18th and 19th centuries who saw the world from the perspective of Bible and racism.
@mellowrage4892
@mellowrage4892 2 года назад
Does the Bible promote racism?
@jojo18eighteen69
@jojo18eighteen69 2 года назад
@@mellowrage4892 i wondered the same thing
@atrichardable
@atrichardable 2 года назад
@@mellowrage4892 it does it put Jews over other people , it says that certain people of a certain linage are cursed , the Bible is a book written during different time period with certain views
@timouellette4693
@timouellette4693 3 месяца назад
Bottom line the mainstream history most of us have been taught has many voids throughout. Very interesting Ted Talk many thanks. Also,Mt Ararat in Turkey has a wooden boat very high up on it’s flank. There’s even an exit on the HWY mentioning ‘the Ark’. National Geographic went up to explore the remains of the boat in the late 80’s I believe in was 1987. Now Turkey has closed off any further exploration on the mountain.
@paulmurphy8549
@paulmurphy8549 Год назад
Vikings scandavians travelled alot.
@thecentralscrutinizerr
@thecentralscrutinizerr 3 года назад
As a little boy I walked into a shop in Wyoming with my dad. There inside was a wooden Indian holding cigars in one hand and his other placed above his eyebrows acting as a sunshade. I asked my dad about the Indian and he said, "That a Fugawi Indian". I said, "Fugawi"? I've never heard of that tribe. He said, "Well just look at him. He got his hand above stretched out above his eyes like a sun shade and is saying Where the Fugawi"?
@user-jh8cx4jf7u
@user-jh8cx4jf7u 3 года назад
😂
@JNith
@JNith 3 года назад
Haha awesome story!
@wooddoc5956
@wooddoc5956 3 года назад
Remember F-Troop?
@Diniecita
@Diniecita 2 года назад
This is why when I travel I dont have expectations. I find that I enjoy it so much more that way. I do always try to learn some of their language though. I fond it helps people connect with me more. (Although in Iceland they laughed at me. But, they appreciated that I tried.)
@pamelasosin8228
@pamelasosin8228 Год назад
I think the subject fasinating. Thank you for telling us about your research.
@magburner
@magburner Год назад
3:55 My family are from Denbigh, where Henry Morton Stanley was born. His house is still there, up by the Castle. For generations too, most of the people in the Clwyd/Denbighshire counties were born in St Asaph, in the HM Stanley hospital.
@thewhopper411
@thewhopper411 2 года назад
I'm not white...I study ancient writings and various cultures do indeed talk about these whites tribes. In North and South America, these white tribes have red hair. Elongated skulls are found all around the world near megalithic stone sites, if they still have hair it's usually blond to reddish hair. In very ancient Indian texts they talk about white tribes.
@mikuspalmis
@mikuspalmis 2 года назад
A non-biased rarity you are. Thank you.
@stoppernz229
@stoppernz229 Год назад
We definatrly existed.
@stoppernz229
@stoppernz229 Год назад
Nice condescending white man comment Mikus , you sure put him in his place didnt ya.
@spjr99
@spjr99 Год назад
@@stoppernz229 LOL. non whites were in the americas 130000 years ago
@ODaughterofZionMinistries
@ODaughterofZionMinistries Год назад
They’re nephalim
@trent5807
@trent5807 4 года назад
A Fun Minigame: Find TED videos with a high amount of dislikes, and only using the top 10 comments, try to figure out which group of people is responsible.
@ottley32
@ottley32 4 года назад
So true
@thekingofmoab1181
@thekingofmoab1181 4 года назад
Interesting idea
@rattrap8819
@rattrap8819 4 года назад
sMALL hATS?
@slimtimes.l.l.c4081
@slimtimes.l.l.c4081 4 года назад
Let that sink in
@FilliD1
@FilliD1 4 года назад
It really seems as a disease
@zuikoglass4091
@zuikoglass4091 Год назад
Thank you. Well done.
@markberman6708
@markberman6708 9 месяцев назад
Been all through the area of East Africa he is discussing, how fascinating. Heh, I was there in 2012/3. Uganda, Kenya, Tanzania, etc.... fascinating that he was there in 2013.
@dragmaplays-new9811
@dragmaplays-new9811 5 лет назад
70% of the comments: "Guys, this man is explaining history and a theory that existed, not his personal views or opinions." 20% of the comments: The guys that the above people were talking to. ~10% of the comments: Everything else. ~0.024% of the comments: This comment.
@jamesblunt006
@jamesblunt006 4 года назад
@Joe Me Yes they do. ~10% could be 9.976%.
@jamesblunt006
@jamesblunt006 4 года назад
@Joe Me Yes they do. ~10% could be 9.976%.
@jamesblunt006
@jamesblunt006 4 года назад
@Joe Me Yes they do. ~10% could be 9.976%.
@SodiumInteresting
@SodiumInteresting 4 года назад
@@jamesblunt006 but why?
@lathentrigg9066
@lathentrigg9066 4 года назад
Well I simply thought mountainous is in the clouds and cold .No need for melonin.And Glacier on top.And some I won't mantion about Noa.
@brontologos
@brontologos 7 лет назад
In a remote part of Paraguay there are people who are blue eyed and blonde. This is because, back in the Thirties, a bunch of idealistic Australians decided to go to South America and create a utopian society. They set up a self-governing commune in the jungle, anticipating the hippie communes of the Seventies, which, like the communes of the Seventies, eventually crumbled from in-fighting and power struggles. The utopian dream failed but the descendants of those idealists have passed their genes on to several generations via intermarriage with Paraguayans. The Out of Africa model of racial dispersion is not a one-way street. For thousands of years different peoples have travelled and set up colonies in distant lands which is why I would have no trouble believing that might be light skinned Arctic peoples that were descended, perhaps, from Vikings. The fallacy lies in assuming that certain characteristics such as light skin, blue eyes and blonde hair will eventually be overcome by the "dominant" genes of dark hair and skin and brown eyes. Genetic traits can persist for hundreds of generations particularly if people continue to marry within their own ethnic group.
@gratiaxantos9309
@gratiaxantos9309 5 лет назад
Please tell this to that crazy lady on Red Ice TV who seems to think all non-white people are plotting to bully white people from planet earth.
@MASTERARTGOD
@MASTERARTGOD 5 лет назад
gratia xantos you mean the people who have said they will hold whites as slaves for 500 years then genocide whites. There are reasons she believes that
@chriscollins3840
@chriscollins3840 Год назад
Glad I found this. I didn't realize there were so many white tribes scattered around the globe. The I'm familiar with was not on the map. It was located in western Mexico. I read about them in a friends book Can't remember the name of it but I've got in my mind that it may be found in Salt Lake City.
@indigenousrugbyleaguei.r.l8764
@indigenousrugbyleaguei.r.l8764 2 года назад
I think people are confused because this looks like a lecture but it's only an ad for his book.
@reddwing4368
@reddwing4368 2 года назад
That's what half of RU-vid vids are someone promoting Themselves and their art
@gregbellinger5765
@gregbellinger5765 2 года назад
A really wonderful presentation of the influences of how diverse we are and the influence of the Hamitic Hypothesis. Thanks for the bit of appropriate humor in a very sad part of how we have and do treat each other.
@blandeauxfillaskii7344
@blandeauxfillaskii7344 2 года назад
You can also thank TEDX for censoring Mikhaila Peterson's Carnivore Ted Talk. So diverse and brave.
@wildfire9280
@wildfire9280 2 года назад
@@blandeauxfillaskii7344 profile pic checks out
@historysmysteriesunveiled8043
@@blandeauxfillaskii7344 what? That Satan engineered meat eaters. Word
@whodat8902
@whodat8902 Год назад
Races don't share all the same ancestors. Different races have different admixtures from different extinct cousins of "humans". The single ancestor model doesn't hold up. It's far more complex than that.
@coweatsman
@coweatsman 7 месяцев назад
@@whodat8902 Certainly all humans are descended from mitochondrial Eve and Y chromosomal Adam in Africa about 200,000 years ago. The out of Africa story is just amazing. Everyone outside of Africa are descended from a few groups which left Africa about 100,000 years ago. We are all Africans, everyone in the world. That is why more genetic DNA diversity is found in Africa than in the rest of the world put together.
@robertjohns9543
@robertjohns9543 Год назад
There was a remnant of the giants that had made it through the flood. Its not unreasonable to think that others made it through the flood as well.
@certifiedalienist492
@certifiedalienist492 9 месяцев назад
I’ve watched this so many times because I love the Mr Magoo reference!!
@sbadaro
@sbadaro 3 года назад
On the off chance that the speaker is interested in reading commentary, I note that you cannot approach history and anthropology as "pure sciences" leading to conclusive and clean cut theories about human geneology and evolution. You need to either personally master both the shared "popular" knowledge (folklore) and the language of locale (or community) or to employ the sevice of those of the locale who may voluntarily or inadvertently present that knowledge to you. For example, as a young european-looking but Palestinian / arabic speaking student in Ohio , I recall being teased about being one of the ناس الحلبة "MILK PEOPLE" due to my fair complexion by a Sudanese friend from Madani in central Sudan. Turns out, that is a derogatory term among the tribes of central Sudan (Jaaliyyin الجعليين in this case) used not to describe an individual with fair complexion but to describe a specifically "white" community of circassian (Caucasian) origins settled in the region in Memluk times... You only need to look at current history and the population movements from the Middle East and Central America northwards to figure out that the history of human population is a fluid mass pretty much independent of geography and, over time, race and genetics.
@claudiafahey1353
@claudiafahey1353 3 года назад
It seems there is alot of judging by skin color and its not limited to "white" people, however you want to define white....the more we concern ourselves with skin color, the less we can relate as HUMAN, kwim?
@TheElitesRdividingUs
@TheElitesRdividingUs 4 года назад
The mr magoo hypothesis is brilliant! Well done with that one
@ghostrider369
@ghostrider369 Год назад
Humanity has been here for 450,000+ years.
@lolaislounging
@lolaislounging Год назад
A.D.D is like the explanation of Mr.Magoo he gives...a room that mr.magoo is in being the task...every object bumped into being the distractions and rabbit holes we go down when distracted.
@TheDoors777
@TheDoors777 Год назад
Whoa
@somas09
@somas09 6 лет назад
When we all have perfect knowledge, then we'll know why people look the way they look and how they got to where they are. Until then, we are all Mr. Magoo, at some level, on just about everything. We all believe that OUR perspective is THE right perspective on "X" topic. (And, yes, I believe MY perspective on perspectives is THE right perspective. Ironic, isn't it?) Still, Michael has put together a working hypothesis - good for him. Now, it's a matter of investigating and gathering data. It's interesting to travel the paths which intellectual curiosity leads us to. As long as the hypothesis continues to develop to account for the data, we'll continue to be interested.
@waynemyers2469
@waynemyers2469 2 года назад
Bravo, you are logical AND clever...
Далее
ЧТО ВНУТРИ ЧЕРНОЙ ДЫРЫ!
18:29
Просмотров 225 тыс.
TEDxAddis - Daniel Gad - Mining Gold from Dirt
39:02
Просмотров 413 тыс.
ЧТО ВНУТРИ ЧЕРНОЙ ДЫРЫ!
18:29
Просмотров 225 тыс.