Тёмный
No video :(

A7SIII LENS COMPARISON // SONY 20mm 1.8 vs TAMRON 17-28mm 2.8 

Connor McCaskill
Подписаться 97 тыс.
Просмотров 48 тыс.
50% 1

Опубликовано:

 

25 авг 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 122   
@bananapie2198
@bananapie2198 3 года назад
Dude I love your style...actually fun to watch and not just informative.
@jauzon22
@jauzon22 3 года назад
Hi, in Zack. I'm no "Peener" McKinnon, but..
@bomatravels
@bomatravels 3 года назад
The Sony 20mm has heavy breathing that's why I returned it within a week of using. I got the tamron 17-28mm instead, much better!
@JaneivyHilario
@JaneivyHilario 3 года назад
Just made my decision then 👍
@aleencaeli
@aleencaeli 2 года назад
what does heavy breathing mean? XD
@DolphinsEatFish
@DolphinsEatFish 2 года назад
@@aleencaeli zooms in or out when you turn focus. It’s more an issue for video rather than photography
@the180degreerule3
@the180degreerule3 2 года назад
lens breathing compensation would fix that, but not with the A7sIII for the moment, maybe after a firmware update
@anhtran9111
@anhtran9111 3 года назад
dude this is super creative and hilarious, thanks for this.
@sonicneutronic
@sonicneutronic 3 года назад
I am loving the 85mm 1.8 on my A7S III.. Favorite lens for sure, with the 35mm and 20mm in second place, and the Tamron 28-75 as an all rounder for filming events etc. My next purchase would be the Sony 55mm 1.8 or the Tamron 75-180 2.8 but I don't really like zoom lenses...
@TuckerPearce
@TuckerPearce 3 года назад
Oddly I didn’t notice a huge difference. I have the Tamron 17-28 sitting in a box in my office. Just waiting to buy a camera. I could only afford one lens so I decided to go with the one I could zoom with. Hopefully I made the right choice. Great video by the way.
@BryceKuhn
@BryceKuhn 2 года назад
you made the right choice, it's a great lens!
@chrismonsen
@chrismonsen 3 года назад
Oh my god! Does anyone else feel like we found a raw awesome kick ass RU-vidr? Oh I love this guy and his awesome roommate. Keep doing what you are doing, seriously one of the most fulfilling video I’ve seen in a SUCH a long time on RU-vid.
@sandorcayon992
@sandorcayon992 2 года назад
That 17 mm makes a high difference specially for real state gigs. So Tammy is a winner for me
@AJGalecki
@AJGalecki 3 года назад
dude, you're funny af, and thats hard to translate on RU-vid haha
@9adriano21
@9adriano21 3 года назад
My golden rule is (for Vlogs) : Zoom = A-Roll Prime = B- Roll So for run and gun the Tamron would be my pick
@snowboardtraveler
@snowboardtraveler 3 года назад
I’m trying to make the same decision. I feel like the 17mm will give more room to crop in if I need to stabilize footage.
@wvansluisveld3011
@wvansluisveld3011 3 года назад
Probably a good decision. I purchases the 17-28 as I wasn't sure which focal length I'd like best and seem to be using 20mm most of the time. Then again I dont have any regrets, l really like it and the versatility is worth something as well.
@TheThaiLife
@TheThaiLife 3 года назад
Haha beat opening for a Camera Video ever!
@NinhNguyen2
@NinhNguyen2 3 года назад
"recommend any lenses from Sony a7Siii e-mount..." "...all of them."
@MollyFitzBrown
@MollyFitzBrown 3 года назад
This was hilarious and informative! I just tried the Samyang 18mm and the quality just isn’t cutting it, I think I want the 20mm instead!
@joshuaaruiz
@joshuaaruiz 3 года назад
This did not feel like 10min at all ! GREAT video! You’ve convinced me, I’m getting the 20mm 1.8 ..oh and i subscribed because you’re awesome
@alongeleonard770
@alongeleonard770 3 года назад
it was at this moment 1:43 when you channeled Jim Carrey and I subbed!! great humor and comparison.
@TheThinFrame
@TheThinFrame 3 года назад
I have the tamron 17-28 already, now i want the sony haha i am not sure if i will see a big improvement
@unmeshmondal
@unmeshmondal 3 года назад
7:18 that was so sweet!!
@Pharesm
@Pharesm 3 года назад
Samyang AF 18mm F2.8 - because its super light, 64mm tall, its perfect for walking-talking-vlogging at arm's length. (sadly not weather sealed, as with the 35mm) Samyang AF 35mm F2.8 - because its the smallest FE lens made at only 33mm tall allowing you to fit the camera in your coat pocket. never need to put the cap on your camera anymore. I'll ignore obvious Sony and Tamron choices in between... Samyang AF 85mm F1.4 - because its big and good glass for ~$500 to shoot the night sky and anything else in the dark. Super well weather sealed.
@thenewyorkgamer
@thenewyorkgamer 3 года назад
1080p why ....
@DanieleMuratoriCaputo
@DanieleMuratoriCaputo 2 года назад
Great video! 🐇🎩😎
@garybecker7047
@garybecker7047 3 года назад
Love the look of that 20mil (aperture ring is kind of sick). My work finally received our a7s3 last week, and the first lens I threw on was my Sigma 24 1.4... its a cream-beast. You should rent that new Sigma 35mm f/1.2 !
@YaleWall
@YaleWall 2 года назад
The opening sequence earned a like even without the rest of the video. Lol!!
@rickt.8866
@rickt.8866 3 месяца назад
The active stabilization on the first party Sony lenses are much better than on 3rd party glass. I own both.
@marcin_piechocki
@marcin_piechocki 3 года назад
You gotta do a Bokeh Balls T-Shirt 😂 great vid!
@karlevlogs
@karlevlogs 3 года назад
i agree
@derrickmickle5491
@derrickmickle5491 3 года назад
Great video. One of the most helpful Tamron vs. Sony vids out there. Bonus to see footage of downtown Nashville, my home town.
@MeowHikes
@MeowHikes 3 года назад
I’ve never subbed so quick. Great video man
@davidaltizer
@davidaltizer 3 года назад
Bro this video was so good!! Stoked for ya 😎
@got2beable
@got2beable 3 года назад
the editing is so funny and totally my humor. subbed and im struggling still which one to take but im closer to buy the sony 20mm 1.8
@vaskoobscura_
@vaskoobscura_ 3 года назад
Both lenses look really blurry to me. But that's probably because this video is 1080p and i'm watching on a 4k monitor. I liked the Matrix opener.
@Pharesm
@Pharesm 3 года назад
They are blurry. Well, after tilt-shift got old, there had to be a new fad to pick up the slack, no?
@HDBnB1
@HDBnB1 3 года назад
I needed this video a few months ago when I was facing this same conundrum. I'm glad I didn't skip to the end and watched it all to see you pick the Sony. I love my 20miller and have no regrets
@Aryyanuarf
@Aryyanuarf 2 года назад
Still confuse to choose this two lens
@ronborkowski1721
@ronborkowski1721 3 года назад
This is old for RU-vid but just wanted to say I can never get over the yellow color cast of the Tamrons especially in the blues of the sky.
@RafalGendarz
@RafalGendarz 2 года назад
Hello, I just bought the lens today, wanna ask one question: does it make the sound like 3 clicks when turning on - its like 3 times it sets the aperture and makes weird sound - or it's something off?
@mullinsmediaLLC
@mullinsmediaLLC 3 года назад
This Video Is What I Needed!
@_juanchamorro
@_juanchamorro 3 года назад
this is EXACTLY the video I was looking for thank you!
@marcusbonham
@marcusbonham 2 года назад
The only thing that I see is an advantage for 20mm is the aperture. I miss that sometimes on my 17-28mm. But using it on 28mm gives me a little bit of macro, because of its 19cm minimum focus distance. I can say that those extra 3mm is a bunch, love the 17mm angle. You should try 55mm 1.8 for sure, the optics is Zeiss, nuff said. One of the sharpest Sony lenses, very fast AF, and its super light.
@paulbeckmann
@paulbeckmann 2 года назад
A fun review as always! Thanks!
@brianpalmer6385
@brianpalmer6385 2 года назад
Entertaining video. Nice job making it. I'm using the 24GM for photo only I hear the 20 is just as good. Also have the Voigt 21 3.5 which has very rich colors.
@JustinEspejo
@JustinEspejo 3 года назад
hey dude! this was such an enjoyable video to watch! thanks so much for not helping at all tho. 😂😂😂😂
@aaazfarrr93
@aaazfarrr93 3 года назад
I was literally indecisive just like you in this video, I have now decided! Thanks! Entertaining to watch 😂
@scampifingers
@scampifingers 3 года назад
WHAT YOU DECIDE ON? I went Tamron
@aaazfarrr93
@aaazfarrr93 3 года назад
@@scampifingers going with the sony. I currently have the 28-75 so I wouldn’t bother much abt the 28mm focal length, and do I reaaaally need the extra 3mm from the 20mm? Am more inclined towards the wider aperture f/1.8.
@JaneivyHilario
@JaneivyHilario 3 года назад
Dude watched this video twice just for the humor.. 👏👏👏
@Edgeofdavid
@Edgeofdavid 2 года назад
Weird comparison but I would love to see the A7S III with a wide angle vs the 90D with the Sigma 18-35.
@dpjohnjones432
@dpjohnjones432 3 года назад
Dam I wish I was this cool ( looks down at the ground).
@50shadesofNV
@50shadesofNV 2 года назад
Ha, mad skills by you, I too a former Fuji faithful defected to Sony this week, seeking consistent autofocus tracking, looking at these two lenses. The 20 it is
@DavidStella
@DavidStella 3 года назад
Sooooo many good lenses for the E mount. I recently bought the Sigma 85mm F1.4 DG DN, and earlier this year also purchased the Sigma 24-70mm DG DN. But, I'm seriously considering adding the Sony 20mm f1.8 to my bag (that's how I ended up here), but I also need a telephoto lens that can go longer than 85... I just don't have enough money to buy them all! Ugh.
@stefankoen
@stefankoen 3 года назад
Brooooo I have the 24-70 sigma Looking to get the sigma 85 And the sony 20
@DavidStella
@DavidStella 3 года назад
@@stefankoen nice! The 85 is such a good lens. I have to call Sigma, though. I just noticed the 24-70 has some specks of dust inside of it. No biggie to me, I’ve been using it all weekend, but still.
@stefankoen
@stefankoen 3 года назад
@@DavidStella would you recommend the Sony F1.8 rather? Or the Zeiss
@DavidStella
@DavidStella 3 года назад
@@stefankoen I corrected my post. It’s the 24-70 that has the dust specks. Sorry for any confusion. The 85mm has been flawless so far. Great for video too.
@Donbros
@Donbros 2 года назад
My a7siii is also first full frame :) though i used university media studio full frame camera for years befote It is so hard to decide. I feel i will save for 16-35 so 20 sounds like better addition to upcoming collection, but 17-28 is pretty good too, but it may feel obsolete when I finnaly save up for sony 16-35, but that may happen not too soon. Everything would be perfect on 20mm but that focus breathing ah
@adolphemusanga3319
@adolphemusanga3319 2 года назад
This dude is hilarious 😂😂😂!!! Came here for the lens, and left very entertained 😂😂😂😂
@Consilliere89
@Consilliere89 2 года назад
Is there a big difference for astro?
@themondoshow
@themondoshow 3 года назад
Solid setup
@mtnnomads
@mtnnomads 3 года назад
Awesome video! I have been deciding between these two lenses for the Sony A7c. I was leaning towards the Sony and that 1.8 aperture just looks fantastic!
@LucSzczepanski
@LucSzczepanski 3 года назад
good video, super entertaining BUT PLEASE... to satiate us pixel peepers, 4k on a lens comparison video next time would be awesome
@PaulFeinberg
@PaulFeinberg 3 года назад
I thought Sony was expensive till I looked at the Canon glass and the L-Mount Alliance.....Alliance....Alliance....🤣 welcome to team Sony! I am waiting for the a7siii to come back in stock for EDU pricing, probably will be a while. Great all around lens is sigma 24-70, and my favorite is 24mm 1.4 (but you got the 20mm so your covered)......I also really enjoy 55mm & 85mm 1.8. I have also been eyeing a 100-400
@GuilDormeus
@GuilDormeus 3 года назад
00:33 heard a pun then subbed! lol
@KenAppledorn
@KenAppledorn 11 месяцев назад
I like this guy, what’s his name? Can’t find more of him here.
@cameraramblings4107
@cameraramblings4107 3 года назад
I’m 3 mins in I’m guessing Tamron before i get to the end.... lets see...Doh! I got it wrong. The Tammy is awesome to me i think the extra wide distortion gives you the “character” i love the lens for music videos. Anyway i enjoyed the vid as i sit here layed up with a bad back surfing the tube.
@EricLouisYoung
@EricLouisYoung 3 года назад
lens...lens - I almost died
@dennischapin
@dennischapin 3 года назад
When in doubt get both...
@JesusImageWorshipMoments
@JesusImageWorshipMoments 3 года назад
I love the humour in this video 😂😂😂😂😂
@jasonrae3049
@jasonrae3049 3 года назад
I bought both of those because i couldnt decide. Lol.
@sjmedia_official
@sjmedia_official 2 года назад
Very enjoyable comparison! I am new to Sony and want to get first glass for it, I cannot decide if I should get this Tamron + Sigma 105mm Macro DG Art for macros and portraits, Sigma 24-70 or Sony 24-105. HEEEELP!!!
@aaronpeipert
@aaronpeipert 3 года назад
Lol at the Matrix edit.
@scampifingers
@scampifingers 3 года назад
I STILL CANT MAKE UP MY MIND!
@scampifingers
@scampifingers 3 года назад
I made up my mind... the 20 millermeter
@noe-tobin
@noe-tobin 3 года назад
@@scampifingers Why did you go with the 20mm? I gotta decide too!
@scampifingers
@scampifingers 3 года назад
@@noe-tobin I watched loads more of Zachs videos they're all with the 20mm and there was something I liked about it (for video mainly) although he is using the sony a7s iii plus I would like to match it with the 35mm GM and maybe the brand new sigma 28-70 that was released yday.. down the line this year... I noticed when taking pictures of people its not very flattering at all tho so if that's something that's important id take that into account. I use my 35mm for that kinda stuff tho
@dennisD..
@dennisD.. 3 года назад
Get a Zeis Batis. I've heard a lot of good things about it.
@ry8y
@ry8y 3 года назад
😂😂😂🔥
@MikeMena
@MikeMena 3 года назад
I know there's a million vids on the Sony 35 1.8, BUT, being that 20 and 35 are similar in price, maybe a little lens battle is in order?? I also have NOT seen a 'practicality battle', or like which has more uses creatively, professionally and practically, Specifically, which is more useful to a content creator... for real, I just like the way the 35 makes faces look, but ya can't vlog with it, but dang it... that 35 tho! Anywaaaaaay, just a suggestion for a video idea! PS: FujiJuice is in your heart, not is your camera.
@electrichimp
@electrichimp 3 года назад
As a 35mm 1.8 owner, I myself am debating about getting this 20mm. Unpopular opinion, but I love wide angle portaits. I’ve seen awesome enviromental portraits done with the 20mm
@veereels
@veereels 3 года назад
Awesome video I laughed alot! ahahah
@zakiradi450
@zakiradi450 3 года назад
Would be better if you didn't mix 28mm pics in between 17 and 20 so we could see the comparison between wideness 🤣 😅
@JpBoudreaux
@JpBoudreaux 3 года назад
Check out some of the rokinon cine lenses. 👀
@b3naqua
@b3naqua 3 года назад
If the bokeh balls aren’t big what’s the point in those bbs
@liljaeger2k
@liljaeger2k 2 года назад
Bro just upscale the video to 4k please i hurt my eyes 👀
@phucmapvlog
@phucmapvlog 2 года назад
Great video, but I still can’t decide…
@ffffffelipe
@ffffffelipe 2 года назад
I wanna die because I'm in the same dilemma and I don't wanna buy one of them and then regret it, have you decided yet?
@phucmapvlog
@phucmapvlog 2 года назад
@@ffffffelipe I ended up with the Sigma 14-24 😅
@willcrespo24
@willcrespo24 3 года назад
I would keep the Tamron.
@PaulFeinberg
@PaulFeinberg 3 года назад
17-28 lives on my sony
@scampifingers
@scampifingers 3 года назад
why?
@scampifingers
@scampifingers 3 года назад
@@PaulFeinberg why?
@PaulFeinberg
@PaulFeinberg 3 года назад
@@scampifingers great image quality, sharp, lite lens and compact. I like wider. 24mm is my favorite focal length. For RU-vid videos in my house at my desk it sits arm length away no issues with focusing. I am happy with just the 17-28mm & 28-75mm. Solid combo.
@scampifingers
@scampifingers 3 года назад
@@PaulFeinberg Great portable combo!... im debating between sigma 24-70 & Tammy 28-75.. if the Tammy was 24-70 id grab it in a heart beat
@romainhebre
@romainhebre 3 года назад
AAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH 4K 120 but video in 1080P so sad
@waverunneradventuregfx
@waverunneradventuregfx 3 года назад
20mm g vs 24.14 gm review please?
@cow77cow
@cow77cow 3 года назад
For vlogging 20mm. General use 24mm.
@ARSFilms2023
@ARSFilms2023 3 года назад
Sony 12 - 24mm GM 85mm f1.8 Zeiss
@kifley19
@kifley19 3 года назад
That Zeiss 85mm 1.8 is my favorite lens for portraits
@stefankoen
@stefankoen 3 года назад
What about the Sigma 1.4
@eduardonery3260
@eduardonery3260 3 года назад
genius lol you are so funny, man (in your sarcastic way) great vid
@ALLvideogamesFANBOY1
@ALLvideogamesFANBOY1 2 года назад
hmm nah ima stay a zoom boy. I like my BBs
@antisocialclimber
@antisocialclimber 3 года назад
Is it just me, or does the Sony seem to have better contrast?
@jasonlindquistmedia
@jasonlindquistmedia 3 года назад
get the 135mm Sigma!
@stefankoen
@stefankoen 3 года назад
‘Zoom boy’
@stefankoen
@stefankoen 3 года назад
Sigma 85!
@hsienpanghsieh3879
@hsienpanghsieh3879 3 года назад
24-70 f2.8GM
@petrieme
@petrieme 3 года назад
Sigma 14-24 art, 55z.
@jbello9398
@jbello9398 3 года назад
My suggestion is that I should buy the Sony😂😂
@paprhat
@paprhat 3 года назад
Dude. I legit left Fuji after many a failed videos trying to get my damn xt4 and xt3 to stay locked to any and all faces. I love you Fuji, but you’re not it anymore.
@defasio
@defasio 3 года назад
Still don’t get how you don’t have so many followers...
@chiradeepg
@chiradeepg 2 года назад
If you are more into photography go for Sony, the video guys may choose Tamron...
@sijilo
@sijilo 3 года назад
Sony cash
@barlswrld
@barlswrld 3 года назад
you got a mask on outside lol
@reeldaras
@reeldaras 4 месяца назад
Rocket launchers loooooolllll
Далее
Ajdarlar...😅 QVZ 2024
00:39
Просмотров 232 тыс.
Wife habit 😂 #shorts
00:16
Просмотров 53 млн
10 Best Lenses of All Time
24:52
Просмотров 188 тыс.
Canon R5 vs Sony A7S III | Why I’m Switching
25:12
Просмотров 936 тыс.
What PROs knows about Camera Metering You May NOT
10:04