Acoustic Paradiso - Gibson J45 Standard & J45 Custom Comparison 

It was a very surprising day when I finally realized that I hated rosewood guitars... all the Internet loves to exclaim their huge tone and I spent thousands and thousands wondering why none of them sounded good...then I played a j45 standard and turned it over to find that sweet, lightweight, punchy, clean beauty that is mahogany. The sound I had been searching for all along was cheaper, lighter and the one few people talked about.

Always my favourite show on Andertons, great guitars, great playing and great content.

I've noticed that Pete plays more over the sound hole or towards the bottom, while Mick plays from the bottom of the sound hole and more towards the bridge. This in its' self will make a difference in the sound of the two guitars. They could play the exact same guitar, and it would sound different just because of this. I'm sure it's not intentional, but it is what it is.Otherwise, great job guys. Love it!

Please can you make these videos 4 hours long! Such wonderful playing from both, I could listen to this all day long.

My ears like mahogany, my eyes like Rosewood..

I have j45 standard and its perfect, so inspiring instrument

Just got a custom Gibson J45. Have a Martin OM 28. Same woods, different companies, and different sizes. Both excellent. Will keep playing and comparing. Will keep the preferred one.

You guys are awesome! Y'all do a great job jamming, naturally, and especially showcasing the instruments. Love the series!

Best sounding acoustic guitar demo I've heard in ages. Those mics sound killer. Great job

You guys are fantastic. Keep on doing these acoustic demos.

Love the playing. I wish I knew more about the guitarists. Amazing sounding guitars, and amazing players. Thanks guys!

Just bought a 2017 J45 (Standard) It’s amazing. Such an inspiring guitar. Quality

Really good personalities for a guitar channel. Keep up the good work!

I could listen to that ending jam all day long! what a show! Well done Mick and Pete! Paradiso indeed....

another flawless video,well done chaps!!!

Love it - great video and playing. It’s nice to hear them both at once

Love these videos and love these J-45s. So glad you just kept to the mics this time. Can you guys do J-15 vs J-45 sometime??

Thanks for uploading, I was falling asleep but the notification for a new video woke me up xD

Just back from my trip to Memphis...... while inside the Gibson factory on Beale St, I had to purchase a J-45 Standard......... Best Guitar I have ever owned by a country mile!!!!!!

excellent episode and show!

Oh boys! Another fantastic episode. I really really wand a Gibson acoustic more than ever. Between this video and the last Gibson video my mouth is watering for one. I wish the pair of you would do an acoustic album together. As ever beautiful playing guys. :-) :-) Mal

Mick is a great acoustic player

Ok Picked the guitar up in my music room totally in love with the sound, interestingly i have been playing along as best i can and the sound of the guitar is identical to the recorded sound put out by Mick and Pete so sound guy well done this is a very true representation of the sound of the guitar ( the Standard that is ) Thanks guys great show.

What a fantastic demo by you guys...I enjoy so much.Thank you . Wow~ after hearing this video I can't wait to get one from a near by stall~

I have a J45 custom 2017! Stunning guitar!

Awesome video guys!!! I love this channel!

Wonderful playing! Wonderful guitars! I have the custom in rosewood and I love it! This is one of my favourite channels. You guys are great!

Good video as always, love the background information as well as the playing. J45's great shape and sound especially for recording, finger picking you hear the difference between the 2 for sure. More guitar I have to save up for ....

I bought a 2016 J45 recently,The shop i bought it from has assured me it has the 2016 spec even though it hasn't got 2016 written on the truss rod cover?Great review lad's.

Wow there's a noticeable difference between the two; the standard has that brash, in your face sound, whilst the custom is a bit more subdued. I love the J45 Gibsons.

Mahogany is miles better to me. Absolutely love the standard and I can really see myself owning one of these. Stunning tone. They sound great fingerpicked too.

I've got a 2015 J-45 Modern Classic in black. BEAUTIFUL instrument. I use it on ALL of my acoustic recordings. Mic it with a neumann TLM 103 and a pen mic, with a direct in to my DAW. Fantastic. Gold hardware, made at the custom shop. They increased the price after I bought it. I definitely lucked out. I highly recommend them if you can find one. Love the video's!

Absolutely beautiful...

You guys really complement each other very well, some real talent.

This is such a joy to watch

Hard to beat a good workhorse j45. I bought a standard brand new at GC in 2017 and it has inspired so many great ideas, riffs, and songs! Not to mention the J45 is considered to be the most recorded acoustic of all time. A real bond! Love it.

my 2016 j45 Custom is a great guitar....you guys are brilliant and did a great job of showing off the best of both of these guitars. the more i listen to the standard the more i like it ...my custom has brighter bass and treble but its not always what you want in subdued subtle playing.

woody Guthrie, buddy holly, donovan, Bob Dylan, james taylor, Jackson Brown, Chris Stapleton, John Hiatt, Lightnin Hopkins, David Gilmour, John Renbourne . Dave Van Ronk and so many others. My favorite too

The Standard wins this shootout

great video. high quality in every meaning.

Nice review and performance!! I own rosewood back/sides and love it. I still love rosewood of high and low end beautiful tone, but I wanna mahogany one next time.

There was a flawless J-45 custom in a shop near me last year at a steal of a price but I couldn't afford it at the time. Amazing guitars.

Great video guys! IMHO I think the J-45 std sounds deeper, darker. Nice warm vibe to it that I like better personally. I love a dark/warm acoustic guitar sounds

Thanks for a great review I just purchased a J45 Standard

Nothing records better. Live a Martin D-28 is a monster but recording it can be a real challenge. The J-45 is just easier to record, thus the most recorded guitar. Russ Barenberg (bluegrass player), plays a war era one with a laminated maple back and sides.

Wonderful job, guys! I'd love to see some Yamaha action on the show, acoustics or electrics.. Something like an "L series shootout" would be great.

I have discovered the reason the guitars always sound different when the two of you wonderful men play guitars together. Go to 14:30 Pete picks closer to the sound hole. Mick picks closer to the bridge. Finally!

J45 is my favorite acoustic ever... I have a J15 now, and it does the job admirably well, but this is my dream acoustic.

Absolutely fantastic! Love the history bits, playing, and humor too.Please keep making these acoustic vids!

The J-45 standard just has a cool edgy sound about it. All the strings have an equal presence and separation. The only way to create a scoop midrange is in your hands. Thats why so many players use them Id suspect. Everyone can get their own personality out of the even eq platform it provides. Making the player uniquely interesting to the listener and themselves.

I think these are my favorite type of dreadnought. Although I didn't like every J-45 I have played, I know how good a good one sounds. :)

Thanks Mick and Pete lucky me is going to the big boys sweet shop to buy a Standard that I tried yesterday 😬😬😬👍🏻🎸

J45 Standard and I do love the jam at the end

Mike Rosenberg from Passanger plays a j45. on the video "Let her go" sounds great and looks cool. The j45 belongs in all guitar quivers.

Lovely playing and some nice gags too.

great again! MICK, HELLO!

The standard just has the magic 🪄

Really Missing these two guys demos on Andertons Paradiso would be special to see them back for a show..PLEASE

At 20.10 sounds like Cat Stevens "Farther & son" i wish you would play that ! Great video guys, you 2 are great !!

You guys are awesome.

I am surprised, I found the standard to have a better overall sound. The only J-45 standard I've played was at my local music shop had worn out strings, so I couldn't give a good comparison.

I couldn't get my Hummingbird on EBay fast enough so I could buy a J45. The bird just didn't do it for me.

I love my j45 vintage burst such a beautiful warm tone.

Hi there is a few words from my side. I have been watching here in youtube for the sound of acoustic guitars. 2 years ago first time as a beginner, I liked Martin as I went on watching almost a year and I got to play Martin D28, HD28, OM28, OOO28 etc but my experience of playing with these guitars, was not appealing to me at all, rather frustrated. Then I picked up Taylor 814CE Deluxe and suddenly I started liking its sound and feel of playing on it, specially the feel of the comfortable neck and also, the typical mellowed sound. Anyway, it's almost 1 year ago but these days, I had the feeling that I should own one J45 nice sunburst from Gibson as its sound is very exceptionally pleasing to my own ears as I listened to each play on J45 standard with Mahogany as there is no Chime as many other high end acoustic guitars used to have. That's the bottomeline and I look forward to play on it myself and hopefully buy it on the pandemic settles down.

My dream acoustic guitar. Custom J45

i f**kn love these guys!

I own one of each and both are great. Just depends on if you want the Mahogony or the Rosewood sound.

The Hog is definitely more string separated and compressed, forward and focused. The Custom warmer, blended chords with more harmonics. Horses for courses, great guitars.

Two great guitars! I would prefer the rosewood I think (it's a hard choice).

I want a J45 but also like the Martin D18. Hard choice. Great video, I prefer the Standard.

Fantastic playing, especially the jam out track. Is it possible to do a video about a J-185? Maybe compared to a J-200 and J-45? Thanks a lot guys! Please keep it up!

Nice video, thank you. Great A/B check. Like most, I prefer the mahogany J45 standard. For me, Gibson have never really succeeded with Rosewood the way that Martin have - they seem to just add it for "bling" and the deeper part of the sound that r/wood adds is a bit late and somewhat vague on such of their guitars that I've tried. That said, I love the mahogany Js and I have a Gibson J35 - it's like a 45 or 50 but has the bracing of the Advanced Jumbo, a more "open" sound, a "player's" guitar rather than accompaniment - it's also substantially cheaper than a J45 or the Advanced Jumbo. Nice, nice video.

Standard for the win. Made me finally commit to one.

What are the names of the James Taylor pieces quoted from in the video, please? They sounded lovely on this week's instruments!

As someone who has never owned an acoustic and is pretty unlikely to get one anytime soon, I still make a point of watching these shows, just excellent entertainment.Get home from work and grab a large mug of coffee feet up and relax to Acoustic paradise...chillout time.Keep up the great work guys.

also duff mckagan izzy stradlin and slash are playing j45s and obviously many more

What strings do you recommend for the standard Phosphor bronze or 80/20 elixir ?

You don't typically hear that acoustics with scalloped bracing having clear note separation. Scalloped bracing typically produces overtones which is like a chorus effect. But scalloped bracing over mahogany does this....circa the Martin D18GE and the 000-18GE. And someone who is a Martin snob - these J45's have their own tone that is really good - when you find a good one.

Nice for both ones

I cant believe im watching this for the third time ,,,I so aspire to a j45

Tim O'Brien frequently uses a J50 to play bluegrass. I get the association with power bluegrass (as volume can be extremely important), but some very well-respected bluegrass players use J45s, especially in context where there are multiple instruments involved - it's just another sound at their disposal.

I have a J 45 Custom. I think both sound very very similar. Hard to know if you don't play them personally..

You should compare and review the new g series

I LOVE WHEN THEY PLAY...THEY'RE GREAT

I laughed harder at the Adams family "hand" joke than I probably should have...I was not expecting that visual. haha

Mick plays closer to the bridge Pete closer to the sound hole , this makes a big difference in sound , both guitars sound beautiful

Rosewood always has a more classical guitar sound to my ear , I found the same to be true with the D28 , def, more of a mahogany fan. Analyzing what it is , perhaps the woody boom 💥

The Gibson J-160E (Beatles) this guitar is quite different from the j45, although the shape, the body and the scale was the same tone woods, the bracing was different. on top the top was laminated, by the tablet and other mounted controls. the pick up was practically a p90, without the soap cover.

Please do a comparison of Martin 00 and Gibson L-00 12 fret guitars.

Damn Pete, that was some spot on Robbie McIntosh right there!

@17:00 love the Robbie Macintosh

j15 gibson acoustic vs a Gibson Hummingbird acoustic can you do video so see i can spot any difference

I bought the standard new in 2020 and thought I may be disappointed when I saw this video. I'm not. I do love the deluxe but I have two rosewood martins the hd-28 and d-35. They don't get played as much lately. I play mostly at church and rotate but I cheat sometimes and the j-45 may get two Sundays in a row.

8:18 sounds amazing.

j45 standard is my #1 , n' i do prefer it over the custom rosewood.

Ralph McTell's favourite guitar is a 1952 Gibson J-50 that he records and tours with..........His is the best acoustic I've ever heard for fingerstyle

Custom is stronger in the bass and treble, Standard is stronger in the mids, at least to my ears. I have one of the customs, and it's a great guitar.

I like your style danish leonardo di caprio!

Can't resist. The guitar model today is the J($)2749.

The Standard Sounds much better, thanks for this comparison