AIVA Walkthrough and Review 

And that's fine. I think as long as we are judging other people's intentions or abilities on the tools they use, whatever we chose for ourselves is fair game. I will add an exception to creating a full track with AI and claiming creative ownership of it. That's just false and whoever does it and identifies as a composer or producer is just fooling themselves. Other than that, let's just do our thing, support each other and be happy. :)

@@synapticschism If you're not writing the melody and/or the lyric, you're not the songwriter. It really boils down to that. If you're "collaborating" with a machine to compose the melody, then you did not write the melody. Likewise with the lyrics. See how that works?

That was the idea, yes. AIVA didn't do lyrics (and maybe still doesn't) when I tested it and my music is instrumental, so I never got around lyrics. But to be clear, yes that was my objective when I got the pro license. I wanted to use AIVA to generate base melodies that I could orchestrate. I generated dozens of MIDIs that sound really nice but never got them to work with my workflow. I don't know why, I simply didn't like what I was coming up with it. That's not on AIVA, it's on me. In the meantime I changed genres and those MIDIs are... well... taking disk space. The exception was a video I did after this one, comparing what AI could do with what a human could do. The track I used in that video was generated with AIVA and I think the result is very acceptable. That video comparing AI with a human is outdated unfortunately. Since then Suno and Udio gained traction and all I said and analysed a year ago is basically trash and my excitement with AI disappeared.

@@synapticschism Thank you for your reply. Since I do compose melodies and lyrics, but I am not an "arranger", I'm looking for a software with which I can import MY melody and have that software enhance it with various arrangements, in different genres. Can I import my melody(s) into AIVA and have AIVA produce the arrangement?