Thank you for using my audio to further inspire alternate history creators! Although, please credit me in the description :)) All the best to your channel, comrade!
Philippines isn't connected to Indonesia. Philippines🇵🇭 is connected to Malaysia🇲🇾 Indonesians are connected and relatives to Melanesians, Papuans🇲🇨🇵🇬, Australia Natives, etc
One question are indonesians not proud with their own face, skin, height, genes, culture, language?? Why do they always say they're similar to Filipinos, Malaysians, Dutch, Indian, Arab, etc even though they're not
@@Edgar_Ramirez471So many miss right there. We have so many ethnicities, we have various forms of physique. It's not like we weren't proud of ourselves, cause that's the reality. Indonesia is a big country, our culture is rich. You can watch "Wonderland Indonesia by Alffy Rev" and also "Indonesia Geography". That will explain you a lot. And for "not proud of our culture"?? Hoho buddy you don't know us, don't get me started😂 Edit: Also Malaysia, Philippines, and Indonesia do have similar faces. Not only those 3 countries, generally Southeast Asian mostly quite similar to each other cause we're Austronesian duh
@@reecka916 wrong I'm Mexican American🇲🇽🇺🇲and have many Southeast Asians co workers here in LA and I can differentiate between a Filipino or Malaysian against Indonesian. Filipinos and Malaysians have similar stature, skin, height, face, language while Indonesians are small and darker and is closer to Melanesians, Papuans🇮🇩🇵🇬, Australia Natives, etc Are you gonna deny this too and claims you're similar to Fino's, Malays, Dutch, Indians, Arabs, etc??? Edit: No one is laughing neither😶
@@Edgar_Ramirez471 Lol what, you know us more than the local itself. You just saw a little group of us and you claimed that you knew better? Like I said, Indonesia has so many differences wherever culture, religion, physique and so on. We have all the colors here lol. Light and dark skin, narrow or large / black or brown eyes, thin or thick, round or slim faces, black to brunette, etc. We have many ethnicities such as Balinese, Javanese, Sumatran Malay, Papuan and many more. We also have ethnic immigrants such as : 1. Chinese 2. Arabian 3. Indian 4. Portuguese 5. Dutch 6. Afro-Asian These 6 are mostly from of the colonialism, empires, and immigrant trade in the past in Indonesia. So that's why we have various ethnicities until this day. You get that? Not only that, we have 715 languages here, that makes us good at being multilingual even with just our local languages, you can search it on google or even YT. Now Malaysia and Philippines are mostly Malay people, just like one of our original ethnic. Because we _are_ Austronesian. You understand? I'm not denying anything, please point it out where I denied being rich in culture? It's not our fault for being different and yet we still became one in this country. :) I just don't like it that you _are_ a stranger but you seemed to know _everything_ better about us. Fly to Indonesia, then go to Malaysia and Philippines. You will see what I meant. You shouldn't assume somebody's identity by just meeting _some_ of them in _your_ country. Come to their homeland or just watch more YT about Southeast Asian or Austronesian lol.
"One Brotherhood,one people and Nation By The Will of God" should be the motto, ❤️🇮🇩🇸🇬🇧🇳🇹🇱🇲🇾🇵🇭❤️ i also love the fact this mix anthem have God name on it
Islam doesn't recognize Jesus as part of the Holy Trinity so no it is not the same thing. For them Jesus is a prophet named Isa but not God so no they don't believe that God can have a physical form nor do they understand the concept of Holy Trinity so yeah it's very different.@@just_dmitri3192
The fact Brunei is in it even though it’s “Maphilindo” (Malaysia, Philippines and Indonesia) kinda gave me a chuckle If you can’t see it then look closely on Borneo
While a union like this would be amazing, this would be extremely difficult to manage and create without angering one of the three countries. The Philippines is a majority catholic nation, while Indonesia and Malaysia are both majority muslim. While the 3 languages share a common ancestor, each have different variations, most especially Filipino which uses words derived from English and Spanish. Malaysia is still a monarchy while Indonesia and The Philippines have presidential systems. There are a lot more differences between the 3 that I haven’t mentioned, but the point is; this country would sadly be impractical and won’t survive without some form of unrest
Indonesia itself is a United States of Kingdoms, united because of the same purpose, Freedom and Independent from Colonialisation. To unite we need to have the same purpose it's the key we share the same ancestor.
Jayalah wilayah Sabah Serawak ko semua mesti bisa lepas dari malingsian haram give way semenanjung Go Go Go Sabah Serawak tetap lc dalam senyap tunggu masanya👍👍👍
Lyrics: Bayang magiliw, Perlas ng silanganan, Alab ng puso Sa dibdib mo'y buhay. Lupang hinirang, Duyan ka ng magiting, Sa manlulupig Di ka pasisiil. Bayang magiliw, Perlas ng silanganan, Alab ng puso Sa dibdib mo'y buhay. Hiduplah tanahku, hiduplah negeriku Bangsaku, rakyatku, semuanya Bangunlah jiwanya, bangunlah badannya Untuk Indonesia Raya Rahmat bahagia Tuhan kurniakan Raja kita Selamat bertakhta Rahmat bahagia Tuhan kurniakan Raja kita Selamat bertakhta Links: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negaraku#2003_rearrangement_and_proposed_renaming; Negaraku en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indonesia_Raya#Lyrics; Indonesia Raya en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lupang_Hinirang#Official_lyrics; Lupang Hinirang
Whenever I play 4X games like eu4 and hoi4, this is my no 1 goal. And then spent the rest of the game turtling. Don't really care about the rest of the world
This country would probably have the most languages in the world. Indonesia itself is already so diverse that it has been the 2nd country with the most language, after it's neighbour, Papua New Guinea But managing this country would be kinda hard. Every country has a little conflict going on, such as Sabah being wanted by Malaysia and Philippines, the similarity of the Malaysian and Indonesian culture making both sides thinks that the other copied them, such as the Batik, and Halo-Halo Bandung getting copied by a channel in RU-vid, calling the song "Hello Kuala Lumpur". The Halo-Halo Bandung copying issue was a serious insult to the indonesians because the song was based on a real event where the Bandung citizens burned their own house for it to not let the colonizer (dutch) take advantage of their houses for a base, this is really serious because the difficulty of declaring independence of this colony (Indonesia) was basically at the same level as the Indians, being colonized for nearly 400 years, so much peoples got killed during the independence war which takes place in 1945-1949 which killed like 4,5 Million peoples, the peoples want the future of this country to success so they decided to take risk of dying.
No Malaysian copied Halo Bandung. We don't know the song, we don't even like it. It was an Indonesian channel trying to create arguments between Malaysia and Indonesia. Indonesia have a lot of hoax channels and Indonesians stupidly believed them
It makes me think, if Malphilindo become a real nation (including Brunei and Singapore). Would Malphilindo have more than 10 monarchs or more? Malaysia + Brunei total monarchs is 10. But possibly places like Sulu could reinstate their monarch again under this nation.
@@iseeyou-qw4zx 1 - Religion (Philippines are christian, Malaysia is muslim, Indonesia is muslim and arguably buddhist) 2 Unnecessariness (literally why, there is ASEAN) 3 Sabah Dispute between Malaysia and Philippines. 4 Existance of Singapore, Brunei, Palau and Timor Leste, all of whom would just be surrounded by this country.
Saya Malaysia. Saya tak setuju kalau perkara ini menjadi kenyataan. Hidup bersatu padu memang digalakkan. Tetapi percayalah, dengan gabungan tiga buah negara ini (Malaysia, Filipina dan Indonesia) akan membawa kepada konflik dan kehancuran sejagat. Sedangkan di media sosial pun kita berbalah, inikan bertentang mata? Saya tahu ini semua gurauan dan rata-rata komen mengharapkan perkara ini menjadi nyata. Tetapi percayalah lagi, anda akan menyesal.
Tidak, kita semua bertarung dikarenakan kita terpisah, padahal budaya kita sama, ras kita sama, orang orang kita hidup di pulau pulau yang sama. Orang Indonesia dan malaysia sendiri sering bertarung di Internet, bukan karena perbedaan budaya, namun karena persamaan budaya, yang mana saling memperebutkan budaya kepada negara sendiri. Jikalau kita menjadi satu negara, tentu akan lebih akur, lebih besar, lebih jaya dan subur. Mabuhay Maphilindo! Jaya Maphilindo!
Kalau ini terwujud maka akan jadi majapahit reborn. Dan masalah konflik yg anda sebutkan kemungkinan besar akan terjadi, pertama karena banyak budaya yg berbeda, kedua karena banyak pihak luar, terutama barat dan cina yg tidak suka, jadi mereka akan berusaha agar bisa dipecah belah sehinga terjadi perang sipil.
@@dorayap7734apakah jika negara negara kita terpecah akan lebih sulit untuk dipecah belah dan dibuat untuk melawan satu sama lain? Enggak juga, malahan lebih mudah kita dipecah belah kalau begitu. Harusnya kita bersatu secara perlahan untuk melindungi tempat lahir kita bersama
Alternative universe SG: 1. Singapore invaded by Malaysian, Indonesian offensive 2. Malay becomes sole official language 4. All Indonesian and Filipino overseas workers and the native Malay Singaporeans listed as Maphilindo citizens 5. Bumiputera laws put into full effect, Chinese and Tamil Singaporeans lose their citizenship, alienating them, who then repatriate to their ancestral nations after some time and loads of civil unrest 5. Singapura becomes capital of Maphilindo 😮
Maphilindo should exist already before. if Rodrigo Duterte, Joko Widodo and Datuk Mutang Tagal had a agreement, it would be better even Maphilindo did not happen in 1963 🇵🇭🇮🇩🇲🇾
i assume maphilindo would be a federation whose head of state is a ceremonial monarch since malay part said, "raja kita selamat bertakhta". question is, what monarchy that would symbolises maphilindo? obviously we cannot unilaterally choose a malay (ethnically, not racially) to be the monarchy. why? eastern indonesia is inhabited by melanesian peoples (like east nusa tenggarans, moluccans and papuans). melanesian peoples of indonesia are more related with pacific islander melanesians. .
Council of Kings of Malaysia, Council of Kings of Indonesia and Presidential Council of the Phillipines, and they elect some random dude with 3 deputies from each division. Then war happens cause no one liked one another
Make a new kedatuan/kedaton.. sri vijaya and madjapahit were mandalas. Keep everything as is but have a merged foreign office, and military like more of an eu style. Historically, filipino rajah and datu acted as temenghong and laksamana in command of the bruneian fleet as well as expeditionary forces in defense of aceh and melaka
@@markv1974 i believe if it ever the case, filipinos should abandon the name, "philippine" / "filipino/filipina" and goes with something more native to the country
@@simplethewaterbender6264 Indonesia should've as well abandoned the name "indonesia" since it wasn't native it's from Hindi What makes "Philippines🇵🇭" or "Malaysia🇲🇾" great is because not just the names isn't native but also the population. In Philippines there are Islanders, Spanish, Americans, Europeans, Chinese, etc In Malaysia there are Islanders, Indians, Arabs, Chinese, etc Unlike Indonesia that are native people and is closer to Melanesia, Papuans🇮🇩🇵🇬, Australia Natives, etc that's why they're darker and shorter than their Southeast Asian neighbors
Filipino Translated: Bayang Magiliw Perlas ng silanganan Alab ng puso Sa dibdib moy buhay! Lupang Hinirang Duyan ka ng magiting Sa manlulupig Di ka pasisiil Mabuhay ang aking lupain, mabuhay ang aking bayan Aking Bayan, Aking Bayan, Lahat Gisingin ang Kaluluwa Buuin ang iyong katawan Para sa Greater Indonesia! Maligayang Grace Biyayaan ka Ang aming Hari Maligayang Enthronement Maligayang Grace Biyayaan ka Ang aming Hari Maligayang Enthronement Indonesian Translated: Tanah yang Pagi Anak dari Matahari Turun Dengan Semangat Terbakar Engkau yang Mencintai Jiwa Kami Tanah yang Suci/Dipilih Tempat lahir bagi Para pahlawan yang Mulia Jangankan ada Penjajahan Menginjaki Pantai Tanah Pilihan Hiduplah Tanahku Hiduplah Negeriku Bangsaku Rakyatku Semuanya Bangunlah Jiwanya Bangunlah Badannya Untuk Indonesia Raya! Rahmat Bahagia Tuhan Kurniakan Raja Kita Selamat Bertakhta Rahmat Bahagia Tuhan Kurniakan Raja Kita Selamat Bertakhta! English Improved: Land of the Morning Child of the sun returning With Help Burning Thee Adoring our Souls Land of the Chosen The Birth Place of Warriors (National Hero) Must Never have Colonizers (On our Land) Touching our Shores (of our Chosen Land) Long live my Land, Long live my Nation My Nation, My People, All of them Revive our Souls Revive our Bodies For the Greater Indonesia! The Happiness That our god blessed Our King Shall be safely enthroned! The Happiness That our god blessed Our King Shall be safely enthroned!
I hope this happen, but i hope this happen on "the allies name" because its gonna cause very much conflict about tribes and other if its united in "united country"
Sometimes I wonder what if this nation really does exist? -Would it rivals that of China and US? -How will its existence affect the balance of power in the world?
Combine of the three anthem is good but malaysia anthem not conected well with indonesian, unlike Philippines and indonesia that really have similiar melody that make it like conected
It is probably chaotic and unstable if it happened in the past and will only be reaulting into more countries than the three mentioned. However, ASEAN is enough for us now.
If this country exist. Its logistic distribution and infrastructure development will be hell. Also poor Singapore for become a country inside of a country.
Jayalah wilayah Sabah Serawak ko semua mesti bisa lepas dari malingsian haram give way semenanjung Go Go Go Sabah Serawak tetap lc dalam senyap tunggu masanya stelah tiba baru kita koyak ❤❤❤SABAH SERAWAK❤❤❤ merdeka merdeka merdeka👍👍👍
I think this concept is better to be a union than it is a country, like the european Union. I know we have asean but its not even close to the concept of EU. Or like the United Kingdom. Idk im just throwing out ideas here, but I love people from all 3 countries, but i can see where there will be disputes, in a world where people can only see things through small lense instead of the bigger picture. I dream of maphilindo, but unfortunately its just that, a dream.
If you were stupid you would.. This whole alliance is just a way to make a great imbalance of power in southeast asia + each of them have different relations. Also ethnically speaking, these countries are fucking different, so unless you want an austro-hungarian empire in asia, don't hope for a MaPhilIndo.
We can become a good neighbour to each other but we cannot become in one country. we have different policy of country. In Malaysia we have Malay Sultanate and we have King of Malaysia that become our Head of Malaysia State while we have Prime Minister as a Head of Government.. our Official Federal Religion is Islam. Bahasa Melayu is our National Language.. and one more thing, i don't agree when it talked about being together, once u become a bigger country, you cannot cater equally for every nation. we see singapore as example, small country but have a strong economy.. I'm as Malaysian, proud what Malaysia have just now. our country also are far away from the disaster like earthquake, tornadoes, volcano and so on. thats why i proud and grateful live in Malaysia
It wont last long, the facist Melayu is a thing. And they hate Javanese so much because of Soekarno dan Soeharto act, the reason why Javanese mostly killed the Sultan of Melayu also because of their affair with Dutch. They take javanese people to Deli to become slave/koeli to work in their land. This complicated history will be the biggest disadvantage to united
I think it should be the same, and should work like Czechoslovak Anthem "Zeme Ceska Domo muv" instead of "Zeme ceskoslovensko domo muv" "Slovaci oziju" instead of "československý oziju"
@@Raymund38TVM I know, all I'm saying is, "based on the parts taken from Malaysia's national anthem, is this frankenstein of a national anthem implying that the merged nation would be ruled under a monarchy rather than a democracy?" :v
Ini yang dukung jadi malphindo kenapa sih? Negara tetaplah negara karena mau bagaimanapun gak bisa di persatukan seperti itu, karena bedanya semboyan, kultural, dan dasar negara
dia juga hanya mendukung gak berharap, Kalo gw bilangin lu "ini yang dukung palestina kenapa sih? Kan palestina udah di bombardir gak bisa di apa apain" mau gak?
For I don't want to agree because it must be English for everyone to understand or one language that understand people in my country pH and indo and Malay so if there is no language that three country understand each other it would be english
Saya indonesia sedikit resah, gak sedikit orang yang mengharapkan ini bersatu dari 3 negara berbeda Justru kalau ini dipersatukan akan kacau dan muncul konflik yang sangat amat besar, padahal sejarah indonesia kelam juga udah diperjuangkan mati2an eh malah begini generasi muda Pliss pikirkan kembali dengan akal sehat bersama demi kebaikan kita semua, jadilah orang yang waras kawan INDONESIA TETAP INDONESIA NKRI HARGA MATI
Kayanya banyak yg salah paham. Mapilindo itu niatan koalisi/aliansi kerjasama antara Malaysia Filipina dan Indonesia. Semacam NATO jika pertahanan atau EU jika ekonomi. Bukan negara malayaia filipina indonesia jadi satu
