Тёмный

AMD 7900X3D vs i9-13900K in X-Plane 12 

Michael Brown, XForcePC
Подписаться 30 тыс.
Просмотров 14 тыс.
50% 1

Both systems have 32GB of DDR5-6000 and an RTX 4090.

Опубликовано:

 

7 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 70   
@xforcepc
@xforcepc Год назад
Yes, I do know there is a 13900KS, but that chip is dumb and is barely any faster for a lot more money.
@light3267
@light3267 Год назад
you should have used higher ram for the 13900k cause its not a fair fight now 😅
@xforcepc
@xforcepc Год назад
@@light3267 Higher ram? They are both using DDR5-6000. That is fair.
@light3267
@light3267 Год назад
@@xforcepc well, the amd system is maxed out at 6000 mhz with 3d cache but the intel system can do 7200 or even more and its bottlenecked by slower ram. How is it fair?
@DC3Refom
@DC3Refom Год назад
Hi could you do a comparison between the 5900x and 7900X3D , I want to see what the actual increase in xplane' 12 to see if it's worth upgrading my 5900x I have running co , and custom pp tlimits , also why did not put world density at max settings
@maxbirdsey7808
@maxbirdsey7808 Год назад
@@light3267 You can get 2x16GB of DDR5-6000 CL30 for about $130. The 13900K is about $40 cheaper than the 7900X3D. At best for that price difference you're getting DDR5-6400 CL32. The cheapest 2x16GB DDR-7200 CL34 I've seen is $220. Also, from what I've seen the scaling on memory for the 13900K, while present, isn't especially significant. Compare to DDR-6000 CL36, DDR5-7200 CL34 typically offers up to a 2% performance benefit. It's easy to google and see that it really doesn't make much difference at all running at that faster frequency memory.
@willembont4790
@willembont4790 Год назад
Near identical performance. AMD 7900X3D a few FPS more on avarage. Thanks for sharing, Michael, very informative.
@sailorf585
@sailorf585 2 месяца назад
7900X3D does 5-7 fps more with significally less power consumption (37-40 W vs 52-56 W) and lower cost.
@flightsimdeskuk
@flightsimdeskuk Год назад
So the Ryzen is 300Mhz slower here, and consuming much less power, yet beats the Intel chip fairly convincingly. That said, I will be sticking with my Ryzen 5800X3D and RTX 3080 Ti for the foreseeable future.
@Cdawg-vb7no
@Cdawg-vb7no Год назад
I think the 5800X3D is AMD's own worst enemy. After looking at the gains for the 7900X3D/7950X3D in MSFS over the 5800X3D isn't not worth the upgrade. I have it myself it was a game changer in MSFS but didn't really do much for me in xplane. I also went from a 6900xt to a 4080 and running frame generation is game changer there as well in MSFS. If you went from a 3080ti to the 4000 series you would see a difference in MSFS. But if you're just using the 3080ti just in Xplane 11/12 then yea not worth upgrading.
@flightsimdeskuk
@flightsimdeskuk Год назад
@@Cdawg-vb7no I only game at 1440p, so the 3080ti is fine for me to be honest. I do have MSFS, but I prefer x-plane. I run that with triple 1440p screens on two PCs.
@romainedmond9947
@romainedmond9947 3 месяца назад
Hi, from what did you upgrade to a 5800x3d please ? I’m considering this cpu for fixing some cpu bottleneck on several games including xplane. I currently have a 5800x
@RetroPcCupboard
@RetroPcCupboard 3 месяца назад
​@@romainedmond9947I had the 5950X before the 5800X3D. The 5800X3D was around 20% faster at gaming.
@dr_nerdrage
@dr_nerdrage Год назад
Hi Michael, thanks for this video. Would love to see an additional video on the new 7800X3D if you do get ahold of one as it does differ in chip architecture.
@xforcepc
@xforcepc Год назад
I have one coming tomorrow, but performance will be the same in gaming as the 7900X3D and 7950X3D.
@conanmavericks4044
@conanmavericks4044 Год назад
@@xforcepc are you sure ? clock of the non x3d is higher. and x-plane 12 is not gaining from the x3d cache.
@willswings
@willswings 6 месяцев назад
One thing to mentionned for the future buyers of the 7900x3D CPU is that this magic cache is not apply to all of his core instead of the 7800x3D wich does. When MSFS 2024 will be out and Laminar's team will (at last I hope ! Ben , pleaaaaase !) use all the core of the CPU for their sim (it's sure now for MSFS2024), the 7800 X3Dwill be a better match for flight simming (even with less freq ).
@F1monster1
@F1monster1 Год назад
Thanks for the comparison. These new X3Ds are impressive with really top performance per watt
@SimHangerFS
@SimHangerFS Год назад
Thanks for making this, very informative.
@VRFlightSimGuy
@VRFlightSimGuy Год назад
Fancy seeing you here ;)
@flysimpilot5530
@flysimpilot5530 Год назад
Great information as always. Any comparison with mac m1 m2 maybe more mini
@Seansmit23
@Seansmit23 Год назад
A bit more FPS.. but the thing I notice is that the AMD chip is at a lower clock speed and lower power.
@dawnrommel7548
@dawnrommel7548 Год назад
Hi Mike, Why wouldn't you use higher settings that put more demand on both CPUs, looks like you have the ability to raise the sliders a bit more. Also, what would be the bottleneck if you maxed out XP12? Thanks
@DC3Refom
@DC3Refom Год назад
It would still be the CPU being the biggest bottleneck
@Penallica
@Penallica Год назад
Thank you for the information.
@mstar5831
@mstar5831 Год назад
Yes, its a great side by side. But I really really wish he would do something like this for MSFS. I have $3000 cash ready to go for him, but I really need help to determine the best system/upgrades to buy from his company - alas I dont have xplane.
@williamroberts5943
@williamroberts5943 Год назад
@@mstar5831 Buy the best one you can afford.
@actionjackson8439
@actionjackson8439 Год назад
@@mstar5831 Can't go wrong with the setup that Michael is using in the demo. If anything it will run better on MSFS because they have a lot more developers and receive more support.
@JoshKoch
@JoshKoch Год назад
What about with VR? Similar performance gains?
@volaticusfilms6185
@volaticusfilms6185 9 месяцев назад
I couldn't see much between them. The AMD running a few % faster on frames, and less energy. Other than that pretty close I'd say. I'm wondering how a 7900X would compare with the 3D variant on AMD chip. Thanks for the video
@emvill4520
@emvill4520 Год назад
Thanks for doing this. I wish you showed the minimum frame rates though.
@VRFlightSimGuy
@VRFlightSimGuy Год назад
Great comparison thanks!
@Searider76
@Searider76 Год назад
Do you have any conclusions of your own on the differences? Would like your insight on what you showed us.
@AquaStevae
@AquaStevae 9 месяцев назад
I like the AMD systems MUCH better as a more versatile computer. And Intel's history is enough for me to avoid giving them a single penny...
@n1vca
@n1vca Год назад
Happy to see the AMD ahead, always good if the underdog catches up, creates a healthy balance on the market. I also see why I don`t ever start my X-Plane installation, when I look at its graphics, that seem to have been stuck in time at least a decade ago. Though I also have to say that graphics isn't everything, regarding an overall simulator performance, but the rest isn't that much realistic either.
@caribbaviator7058
@caribbaviator7058 Год назад
If only they did a better job with their GPUS. My RX6800 is a solid card but when it comes to XP12 its not that great.
@cheesyriceo4
@cheesyriceo4 Год назад
If you know of a more realistic civilian flight sim id love to try it out
@Cdawg-vb7no
@Cdawg-vb7no Год назад
Are you running PBO with the 7900X3D? Or did you leave PBO off?
@tomc1380
@tomc1380 Год назад
My wild guess is no. I believe PBO 2 mainly benefits multi-core optimized apps.
@blacksand9805
@blacksand9805 Год назад
I wonder how long we'll have to wait for the ultimate CPU for Xplane12 to run it smoothly with every setting to the max
@romainedmond9947
@romainedmond9947 3 месяца назад
Spoiler : Never unless they upgrade the cpu thread logic
@blacksand9805
@blacksand9805 3 месяца назад
@@romainedmond9947 Multithreading would improve a lot. Because we all have 4,6, 8 cores or more and Xplane only uses 1
@tomc1380
@tomc1380 Год назад
Thanks for you always honest and informative vids Michael. Good to see AMD stepping up to the plate. Nothing to make me want to upgrade my current i9 13900k/rtx4090/z790, but probably something to think with my next major PC upgrade in 2-3 years time. One quick question mate; I currently have 32Gb 5200MHz ram and now that ddr5 prices are slowly coming down, do you think it's worth upgrading to faster ram (I see you have 32Gb 6000MHz)? In Australia I have 2x ~ same price point options; 32Gb 7600MHz or 64Gb 6000Mhz. Which do you think would be better with my current flight sims (xp11/12 and msfs)? Many thanks again mate and cheers.
@xforcepc
@xforcepc Год назад
Intel is not overly sensitive to RAM speeds. I would not worry about it. The most you would gain is 5-10%.
@obetemojkardi6473
@obetemojkardi6473 Год назад
Hi, i have a laptop, 5900HX and Radeon 6700M, i installed latest drivers and the performance has tanked a lot When i install drivers 22.5.1 to 22.8.2 it works flawlessly From 22.10.1 and later the performance drop is huge Any tips?
@ATCATL
@ATCATL 11 месяцев назад
Dear Michael, For a new build I’m debating between the 7800x3d and the 13600k for XPlane. Any recommendations or tips please? I’ll be using a RTX 3080. Thank you
@jeanyonsei2318
@jeanyonsei2318 9 месяцев назад
I'm currently with an i7 8700K and a RTX 2080 XCII should I upgrade for a 7900X3D and 4090? I'm thinking about getting into VR in the near future. I mostly play DCS and Flight Simulator.
@advancedaviationreno9212
@advancedaviationreno9212 Год назад
Very interesting! Pretty much the same spec machine (with intel) I was looking at building except maybe doing 64gb of that spec ram. I thought the fps was going to be significantly higher with that GPU/processor combo. Is it even possible to run a 4k display at 60fps consistently down low with surrounding objects??
@actionjackson8439
@actionjackson8439 Год назад
Judging by this test, 4K with the most expensive CPU/GPU combo will achieve about 35-40 FPS in 4K. Something doesn't seem right.
@GunniesLetsFlyVFR
@GunniesLetsFlyVFR Год назад
Hey Michael, Thanks for all your insights. Any tips for stuttering in vr xp12. System ryzen 5600x 3070 32 gb 3200 RAM. Runs well with smooth 50fps in 2D but locks at 20 on vr. Looks excellent and smooth on screen but stutters when looking sideways or turning. Some days it smooth and others it's rubbish. Ocukus Rift 2. Works beautifully on DCS. Note DCS is going multi threaded soon. Apparently quite the performance boost from those doing beta testing. FYI. Speak to Austin please. Haha we want it :) Thanks in advance 😀
@br4713
@br4713 11 месяцев назад
Your first bottleneck is the graphic card. Remember that in VR the GPU has to calculate two 3d images instead of one. I have a 5700x with a 4070 Ti which is just powerful enough for the Quest 2 (fluid i and playable in game). Next time I change my cpu for a 7800x3D. I'm waiting for AMD's next cpu generation in few months (the price of the 7800X3D will drop). You can still get more FPS in your actual setup but you'll have to lower your graphical settings.
@GunniesLetsFlyVFR
@GunniesLetsFlyVFR 10 месяцев назад
@br4713 Yes reduced some graphics settings now getting 40 fps with steady 25 ms frame time. No stuttering. Happy :) 😀
@svenwd
@svenwd Год назад
Any chance to do a test with a more mainstream card, may I suggest a 3070?
@SimsSmith
@SimsSmith Год назад
Hello Mike, if you get a chance please let us know how is the new AMD - Ryzen 7 7800X3D that is around $100 cheaper.
@xforcepc
@xforcepc Год назад
I did a video on that. It is good. Faster than 13900k.
@xforcepc
@xforcepc Год назад
ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-RXNm7Hgo3ZE.html
@HurricaneJahya
@HurricaneJahya Год назад
Was SAM or resizable bar enabled on both?
@Falcon900EX
@Falcon900EX Год назад
How are the 1% lows between the two CPUs?
@paradoxicalcat7173
@paradoxicalcat7173 16 часов назад
Intel is worse.
@BogdanSerban
@BogdanSerban Год назад
Throw a SASL plane and an AMD GPU and watch those FPS number tank. X-plane is a mess in terms of performance and anti-aliasing.
@paradoxicalcat7173
@paradoxicalcat7173 16 часов назад
You mean SASL is mess and is tanking FPS. If developers learned to write software properly instead of using a 3rd party shim between the SDK and a scripting language, performance would be higher. All scripting languages suck.
@JacobTJ1
@JacobTJ1 Год назад
Please test 7900x without x3d
@paradoxicalcat7173
@paradoxicalcat7173 16 часов назад
There is no point buying a non-X3D chip.
Далее
Why I use Xplane vs MSFS 2020
15:17
Просмотров 15 тыс.
I Upgraded To The 7950X3D And Regret It
13:10
Просмотров 152 тыс.
Нарвался на сотрудника ФСБ⚡️
01:00
Fake watermelon by Secret Vlog
00:16
Просмотров 9 млн
▼ЮТУБ ВСЁ, Я НА ЗАВОД 🚧⛔
30:49
Просмотров 291 тыс.
Smart Fly Yoke Review - Part 1 of 3
9:59
Просмотров 1,8 тыс.
Userbenchmark - the April Fools that never ends
14:05
Is the HATE Justified? - No! - AMD Ryzen 9 7900X3D
18:20
Why I switched back to Intel...
17:16
Просмотров 1 млн
5600X vs 5800X3D in MSFS - Was Upgrading Worth It?
19:34
WTF happened to X-Plane 12?
5:41
Просмотров 34 тыс.