Тёмный

American reacts to British vs. American Humor: What's the Difference? 

Ryan Wuzer
Подписаться 94 тыс.
Просмотров 45 тыс.
50% 1

Thank you for watching me, a humble American, react to British vs. American Comedy: What's the Difference?
Original video: • British vs. American C...
Got a video request? Fill out this form!
forms.gle/NeQp...
Thanks for subscribing for more European reactions!

Опубликовано:

 

4 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 481   
@Dqtube
@Dqtube Год назад
For me, the main difference is that the British humour has more complexity and twists than the American one. The jokes in British sitcoms and comedies don't need to have fake laughs in the background.
@sharonmartin4036
@sharonmartin4036 Год назад
Oh, you got that so right! The canned laughter is not obligatory because the audience is in heaps anyway! I didn't think about it that way, but yes!!
@surfaceten510n
@surfaceten510n Год назад
The irony is they think irony is like silvery or metallic.
@KissMyFatAxe
@KissMyFatAxe Год назад
Tbf there are still British comedies with canned laughter. We weren't immune to it. But it wasn't present in EVERY TV show like in the US
@maryamniord2214
@maryamniord2214 Год назад
Yes same about brittish crininal movies. More natural and tvisted in an other way. You need think more when enjoy it in some way.
@gabecollins5585
@gabecollins5585 Год назад
Once fake laughs are added in the background it instantly makes it not funny.
@MsCheesemonster13
@MsCheesemonster13 Год назад
British humour is not just entertainment; it’s part of our everyday life. It’s how we cope with anything we find uncomfortable (which is most things for some of us). It can be a play on words, sarcasm or just plain silliness; but a joke shared and understood breaks the ice.
@herrbonk3635
@herrbonk3635 11 месяцев назад
And you self centered brits also think you are unique that way... so smug...
@bronwyn6415
@bronwyn6415 11 месяцев назад
I think Aussies are bit the same, that's why I get British humour more than American.
@Kari.F.
@Kari.F. Год назад
The Brits use sarcasm, satire and wordplay in extremely clever ways, and that goes for every Brit I've ever known - not just comedians. It can be dark, and it's often not in your face obvious. Americans are funny, too, but a lot of Americans don't understand sarcasm, and satire even less. That (like everything else) seems to depend on which side of the political aisle you're on in the US.
@Anson_AKB
@Anson_AKB Год назад
the famous words _"the queen is not amused"_ do NOT simply mean that she didn't find something to be funny, or that she didn't have to laugh.
@Eldenaro
@Eldenaro Год назад
I love Mr. Bean(Rowan Atkinson) um, he doesn't seem to do much talking though.
@herrbonk3635
@herrbonk3635 Год назад
Kind of true, but I have met many UK citizens that don't get sarcasm either (and not just mine).
@stewedfishproductions7959
@stewedfishproductions7959 Год назад
British humour is often very 'stoic' - it's what got us through two world wars. We can take the suffering, complain a 'little', but soldier on... Until WE survive and WIN !!! 👍
@SotGravarg
@SotGravarg Год назад
Most americans don't even understand the concept of your and you're, how can you expect them to understand such complex structures as sarcasm, irony or satire?
@whitecompany18
@whitecompany18 Год назад
Our humour (uk) is low-key and dry... Like where you missed Ricky call us "the big two" and you thought that was a term rather than Ricky being intentionally obnoxious ...and that was kind of the joke too ,where it would go over an Americans head and they would probably agree.... Like Sasha Baron Cohen getting a room full of Americans to sing antisemitic songs..when he's a jew 😆👌
@paulleach3612
@paulleach3612 Год назад
It's so dry we take it with gin.
@herrbonk3635
@herrbonk3635 Год назад
Sasha Baron Cohen feels *very* american to me. That kind of "to much" and to obvious style of humour.
@sharonmartin4036
@sharonmartin4036 Год назад
British humour is usually quite subtle, and can be sarcastic, but not in a malicious way. Just go to a UK pub, sit in a corner and listen. Everyday average people having normal conversations, but liberally peppered with some of the best ad hoc quips, one-liners and stark wit you will ever experience. American comedy is one thing, natural inbred humour is different. American comedy is written down and lines are learned, and can be very good indeed. "Cheers" and "Frasier" were two of my favourite USA comedy shows. However, impromptu wit is missing in Americans in general. They tend to take things very literally and miss the intended but subtle sarcasm that almost every Brit has from birth.
@I_Don_t_want_a_handle
@I_Don_t_want_a_handle 11 месяцев назад
You have obviously never been in an American bar. Their beer, for example, is hilarious.
@sharonmartin4036
@sharonmartin4036 11 месяцев назад
@@I_Don_t_want_a_handle BUD-dy, I've been there, and I can't argue with you on that. LOL
@Lily-Bravo
@Lily-Bravo 11 месяцев назад
What about Curb your Enthusiasm? Squirmingly funny. I never liked the Office. I find Ricky a bit smug. I am English and I love humour.
@lawrenceglaister4364
@lawrenceglaister4364 10 месяцев назад
" they tend to take things very literally " there you go they must have a German background !!
@Songfugel
@Songfugel Год назад
In US comedies the punchline is underlined, explained and pushed down your throat. In British (and most European comedy) comedy there is either no punchline at all (Monty Python) or it is mostly ignored and you have to cypher it from the context and the atmosphere of the situation Also another common difference is that in British comedy, they are almost always acted seriously, even if the situation is absolutely ridiculous, and the characters don't act like they are in a comedy, but play it straight instead Not to say this doesn't happen in US comedies as well, especially the classic US comedies that stand out from the trash, seem to be the ones where the actors are playing their characters very dead pan seriously like in Airplane!, Naked Gun and Loaded Weapon to name a few
@greenman4946
@greenman4946 Год назад
Michael Caine in ”The Muppet Christmas Carol” springs to mind. He agreed to take the part as Scrooge only if was allowed to play him completely straight.
@Wishbone1977
@Wishbone1977 Год назад
@@greenman4946 As someone wisely pointed out at some point, the reason Michael Caine and Tim Curry are so fantastic in their respective Muppet movies is that Michael Caine treated the Muppets as fellow actors, while Tim Curry treated himself as a fellow Muppet.
@etherealbolweevil6268
@etherealbolweevil6268 Год назад
Kipling (definitely a Brit) wrote this - "If you can meet with Triumph and Disaster And treat those two impostors just the same." Which has a great deal of bearing on modern British comedy. The fact that they are both 'impostors' not to be trusted, not to be lauded, not to be criticised or loathed.
@georgebennett3197
@georgebennett3197 11 месяцев назад
Yes! You're right. Well said.
@christianchetwood2581
@christianchetwood2581 Год назад
I think the main difference between British and American comedy is that American comedy relies on one liners and seem to try really hard. Alot of the time, the gags in American comedy are either corny, stupid or not funny at all. The canned laugh in sitcoms don't help this. British comedy usually contains a joke that comes full circle, the two Ronnies for example are a prime example of that. British comedy is clever and whitty. We laugh at ourselves, everyday situations or sterotypes that we all think about, but never really discuss. Personal misery is one area of comedy, but its a lot more than that!
@barrysteven5964
@barrysteven5964 11 месяцев назад
I agree. So many characters in US comedies come out with incredibly witty, clever remarks (even children). Everyone is a comedian. In British comedies the circumstances are what makes the comedy. People can say quite ordinary things but the context makes it funny.
@bronwyn6415
@bronwyn6415 Год назад
From an Aussie, I love English humour try watching Dad's Army, I know it's old but very cleverly done, I can watch that show over and over again and still laugh all the way through along with Mr Bean. There are so many other excellent comedy shows that have come out of England, I'd watch English comedy over American any time. Sorry if that offends anyone.
@sunisbest1234
@sunisbest1234 Год назад
I'm from Aus. as well. I find the British humour funnier as it's often a lot more subtle than American. The American humour is more often so obvious it takes the fun out of the joke. Our use of sarcasm etc is more aligned with the Brits, in general, so a commonality is there.
@robertfarrow5853
@robertfarrow5853 Год назад
Never apologise for an honest opinion. You are not responsible for other people's perceptions. You stated a reasoned viewpoint, without malice or insult to it. Best wishes UK
@Trebor74
@Trebor74 Год назад
Allo Allo,is good too
@MrBulky992
@MrBulky992 Год назад
I don't think "Dad's Army" would appeal in the USA as they would have no handle on the subject matter. The USA were never under any real threat of invasion during WWII and they most likely had no equivalent of the Home Guard. Also the series leans heavily on British stereotypes of provincial life and behaviour which would be wholly unfamiliar to Americans. They wouldn't get it and, to my knowledge, the programmes aren't shown there or, if they are, no one from the USA seems to mention them. That's a great pity because they are all hilarious, the casting, writing and performances were perfect and the show ran for many episodes with a consistently high standard of humour.
@chrisholland7367
@chrisholland7367 Год назад
The unique thing about UK humour is that there's not one size fits all . I grew up in 70s I would suggest, as the golden age of British comedy.You've already ready mentioned an absolute jem (dad's army) . I all so like alot of 80's UK comedies. I'm guessing that alot British humour works in Australia because we've got a similar sense of humour.
@NikolaBulj
@NikolaBulj Год назад
Many people think of Monty Python or MR Bean when mentioning British humor, but for me the best series will always be Black Adder and Only Fools and Horses...
@chacka4292
@chacka4292 Год назад
From my personal view, I guess most people from Europe are more prone to do some banter and darker jokes. American and Canadian people sometimes get offended cause of obvious offensive joke and don't understand banter. Every brit I met is pretty close to my eastern europe vibe of humour, jokes about themselves, sarcasm is our main weapon. In general being more open how funny it may sound when you compare EU and NA. 😃
@JeroenJA
@JeroenJA Год назад
yeah, certainly a good point, when seeing examples from the office, i renember, as Belgian, hearing warning from friends to make sure you don't accidently pick up the stupified american version :-D . but in general, if something gets a specific american version, it seems best to stay clear of it, love the simpsons, but actually, certainly in the early sessions, they could get pretty dark, pretty unusual for american shows ;). the biggest problem with american comedies is they tend to extremely keep pushing the one down even further down.. do a laugh band on it, to pretend it's still funny.. while it only feels.. so unnessary, and a bit.. bully glorifiying even, cause it normallises bully beheavior.. .. it's not funny to KEEP on pushing down, once the moment has pasted, lighten the mood a bit, :-) the strangest thing of usa comedy, is how high school seems to have to contain someones head being pushed in a toilet.. that bloody extremely disgusting! why do usa high school shows tend to show it as , just a normal part of high school? i would be disgusted hearing it happened in any school i knew! and perhaps the one who did it would need to see some guidance to dig in why he did something so disgusting
@fedodosto3162
@fedodosto3162 Год назад
Canadian here, I much much prefer the Brittish humour' It's more clever and unexpected. American comedy and sit coms are so predictable.
@fedodosto3162
@fedodosto3162 Год назад
@@JeroenJA by thw way for a good Canadian show check out Corner gas, very sarcastic
@moondaughter1004
@moondaughter1004 Год назад
Yeah even us swedes prefer British humor and according to people we're very easily offended. I guess it's the obvious sarcasm that makes it funny because you know that the person is making fun of the joke itself
@uinsel
@uinsel Год назад
in Europe, I think we are used to failure much more making us less proud and acknowledging our own fault in it. and humor is to process this which is why ww1 and ww2 jokes for us Austrians is totally OK if they are witty. if they are not witty, it feels like an insult and maybe this is why we are bored with US comedy sometimes - just feels lazy and offensive. like someone is not really understanding a situation and makes jokes in a bully way showing off.
@olienajh
@olienajh Год назад
British comedy is clever & makes you think. It’s also about real life, whereas American humour seems to be fake. I can’t think of a time when I’ve had a laughing fit at an American show but give me a British show & my face aches where I’ve laughed so much.
@damirhlobik6488
@damirhlobik6488 Год назад
"Only fools and horses" and "Monty Python" is another universe for "American humor"
@davidwebley6186
@davidwebley6186 11 месяцев назад
@@damirhlobik6488 true, they can understand the visual elements well but not so much our usage of sarcasm and insults and the reflection of British society in general. American humour to us does seem a lot more staged where as humour generally in the UK is very much a part of our everyday life between those we interact with on a regular basis. Along with a lot of US TV shows there seems to have to be some moral preaching included in everything they do which is not something we British like to be force fed at all.
@rree9550
@rree9550 11 месяцев назад
british comedy is often clever. the brits however mainly smug and self congratulatory....................
@rree9550
@rree9550 11 месяцев назад
wow. that's witty...... @Jamie_Pritchard
@Henoik
@Henoik Год назад
European humour tends to be more self-ironic and self-conscious.
@SotGravarg
@SotGravarg Год назад
British humor hits harder, it's dirty and dark, it's for people with a humor that would offend 99% of Twitter. I love it.
@beldin2987
@beldin2987 Год назад
Its especially not "political correct" and most of todays american snowflakes would be soo "offended" by it that they just melt 😄 No seriously, this damned political correctness and trying not to offend anyone just kills all good comedy since it mostly lives from exact these things.
@kathryndunn9142
@kathryndunn9142 Год назад
😂😂 same we see it as being witty
@AlexGys9
@AlexGys9 Год назад
Indeed. It is way easier to offend an American than a Brit. We choose not to get offended but to take it as a good sport, shrug it off and dish back when we can.
@kathryndunn9142
@kathryndunn9142 Год назад
@@beldin2987 ooh yeah 😂😂👍
@SotGravarg
@SotGravarg Год назад
@@beldin2987 Ik that kills all humor, can't even tell someone who tried to shoot themself but missed, that they have bad aim. Like that's my kind of humor but people explode over it.
@phoenix-xu9xj
@phoenix-xu9xj Год назад
Well, tell me this, if we haven’t been brought up with optimism, how have we been such great creators, innovators and explorers. And exported, so much talent across the pond. Yes, we’ll have our great actors back please.
@Trebor74
@Trebor74 Год назад
We're incredibly optimistic,but we understand that optimism is overrated.
@feldegast
@feldegast Год назад
monty python is NOT dry, US humor leans more to slapstick and less smart jokes
@thefridge6558
@thefridge6558 Год назад
I remember hearing a story that I shall have to paraphrase. Back when the TV series the Young Ones was airing there was an attempt to create a version to play in the USA. However, when the original was shown to American test audiences the main question that kept being asked was "Who's the good guy/hero?". They failed to understand that every single character in that show ESPECIALLY the main cast were total and unbelievable bastards and losers. That to me is the difference in humour styles, the Americans need a hero, someone to root for, or at least some optimism in the work. The Brits don't, in fact we love to see people fail or just be awkward. Or alternatively just have totally off the wall humour like Monty Python, Mighty Boosh and League of Gentleman.
@Thurgosh_OG
@Thurgosh_OG Год назад
Monty Python is an almost unique style of UK comedy, a bit like Mel Brooks films for the US. Both are funny in very different ways and both styles are different from the majority of other comedy styles in their home countries and abroad.
@ForaNakit
@ForaNakit Год назад
Actually, when you mentioned those two, Mell Brooks's comedy is the closest thing that comes to my mind to Monty Python. The difference is: Brooks had better production, and Monty Python made a little bit less sense. But just a little bit. That was the point of their comedy.
@fedodosto3162
@fedodosto3162 Год назад
@@ForaNakit I think that's the whole point of Monty Python, to be senseless. That's what makes them so weird (in a good way) and funny.
@simonpayne5475
@simonpayne5475 11 месяцев назад
You're so right about Curb Your Enthusiasm, it's so "British" and appeals to my Brit sense of humour. A prime example of a subtle, clever British comedy where the protagonist is always the loser is Ever Decreasing Circles, I recommend it, especially thr first two series.
@amyb1078
@amyb1078 3 месяца назад
I think of Curb as Jewish humor.
@kimvenning2801
@kimvenning2801 Год назад
Of course the "No-one expects the Spanish Inquision" is even funnier when you learn that they gave people 30 days written warning of their visit. ❤
@stewedfishproductions7959
@stewedfishproductions7959 Год назад
Now that HAS made me smile... That IS British humour. 😄
@denewst01
@denewst01 Год назад
So many historical jokes in Monty Python - pretty well known that the latin lesson in holy grail is actually accurate (Cleese used to teach latin) but other more subtle ones too, like "blessed are the cheesemakers" - not just a joke about people at the back of the crowd mishearing but the historical name for that region actually translated as "valley of the cheese makers" so it's a double gag about playing to your audience, the "hello [town!] thing.
@chemistmanuk
@chemistmanuk Год назад
@@denewst01Life of Brian - not Holy Grail.
@denewst01
@denewst01 Год назад
@@chemistmanuk doh!
@claregale9011
@claregale9011 Год назад
Our comedies tend to be a mixture of tradegy and comedy , lots of characters that we can all identify with , American humour is more geared to the one liner or the guy that always wins , we always root for the underdog in comedy . 😊
@russetmantle1
@russetmantle1 Год назад
When I read this about the mixture of tragedy and comedy, the thing that jumped to mind immediately was Ted and Ralph from The Fast Show. And very specifically, the scene where Ralph comes to the pub where Ted is playing a drinking game with his friends and has some news to tell him. For anyone who hasn't seen it, this is how it goes: Ted and his friends won't let Ralph say the news unless he does it by joining in the game, which is to put the name of a vegetable before every word, using the vegetables that have already been mentioned in order and then adding another one. Ralph tries to resist at first because he doesn't feel it would be appropriate to deliver the serious news he has this way. But, being gentle-mannered, eventually feels he has to do it, so delivers the piece of news like this: "Tomato - Ted - aubergine - your - potato - wife's - turnip - dead". It's a stunner, because Ted very rarely looks particularly happy in the Ted and Ralph sketches. He's usually at work rather than in a social environment. But in this scene, he's smiling and evidently in his element with his friends in the pub. The news obviously hits him like a thunderbolt. It's heartbreaking. There's so much going on in that scene, because we've seen the unique relationship that Ralph and Ted have over many previous sketches. Essentially, there's a class divide between the two men, but Ralph adores Ted and the joke for some time has been that he's secretly in love with Ted but far too respectful to share that openly, since Ted is a married straight man - and one who works for him, no less. Much of the comedy up until this scene is about how Ralph struggles to contain his feelings. Ted respects Ralph but there's always a distance between them. At the same time, you always get the feeling they do care about each other, even if it's in very different ways. When Ralph comes to deliver that news, he's embraced by all of Ted's best friends who invite him to join in the game, so the scene starts off as one of the least awkward scenes we've seen in the Ted and Ralph series. Nothing but jovial cross-class bonhomie all round. And then - the darkness. I remember watching that when it first aired and it was absolutely mindblowing, utterly superb. The FEELS, I tell you. For us Brits, I think this kind of melding of tragedy and comedy makes both the tragedy and the comedy even more powerful, which is probably one reason we embrace this approach so much.
@annicecooper8105
@annicecooper8105 11 месяцев назад
Only Fools & Horses springs to mind. When Rodney marries is so touching and full of pathos and then the following scene the laughs are restored. Wonderful
@BoBnotThat1
@BoBnotThat1 Год назад
I think it's more we Laugh at everything, no matter what it is. So the dark stuff isn't off-limits. Yes, I'm from the UK 🇬🇧
@mrd4785
@mrd4785 Год назад
I started playing mens soccer in Australia from the age of 14. The teams I played in were largely composed of guys from all over Britain. The guys were just constantly joking around from the minute you arrived at the ground for games or training and most of the guys would hang around in the bar for an hour or two afterwards. Constantly being funny and telling jokes just seemed to be in their nature but I think it is a bit of a by-product of spending more time indoors with the weather, more cramped living conditions and pub culture. I think British people are just more realistic about their status and prospects and life and are more about making the most of living in the here and now. Historically the boundaries and expectations of social class has played some part as well. People in the UK tended to be less mobile and stuck to the areas they were from, so that is why you have so many regional accents and almost a tribal culture when it comes to football etc. I guess the narative in the US has been more about opportunity than other places, where there are less barriers to success. Hollywood movies promoted this and also there are few places in the Western world where the son of a family of underworld gansters like the Kenedys or an actor like Ronald Regan could make it all the way to the top and become president. People in the UK have a better understanding of their limitations (i.e. I am not qualified to do this and there are plenty of people ahead of me who are). Honestly you could spend days comparing. The format for sitcoms in the US is determined by a number of factors. They try to cram in a lot of jokes in 22 minutes (due to advertising) and appeal to the widest audience possible, right down to those with a low IQ or general knowledge. Much of the TV in Britain is government funded, so they can afford to make shows that will appeal greatly to some people, but perhaps not all, and there is no problem if the show has to run for an hour to enable better character development, plot etc. A lot of American tv shows try to make situations larger than life. They nearly always incorporate very good looking people, the odd 'zany' character, canned laughter, and a lot of product placement. You can't put all British humour into one category though - it varies a lot. People tend to focus on the shows and concepts that wouldn't work in the US. In this vein, I reckon the show Red Dwarf is another good example. It is based on the lives of 3-4 guys (admittedly including a hologram, a robot and a lifeform evolved from a cat) stranded on a space ship in deep space, a billion years into the future. There is occasionally hope, but basically nothing goes right for them, and the show ran for 20-30 years, yet every episode is funny and strangely uplifting. It is about making the most of the situation, no matter how dire. I just don't think the concept would appeal to advertisers or that the show could support the inclusion of adverts for that matter. I cannot understate how the inclusion of advertising would ruin most UK commedy shows. American TV shows also employ a lot of writers and for me it is a case of the old addage "too many cooks spoil the broth". In Britain, you usually have only one or two guys with a clear vision of what they want to bring to life. I've recently been enjoying shows like Peep Show and The Inbetweeners at the moment - very British!
@phoenix-xu9xj
@phoenix-xu9xj Год назад
More real life. Won’t concentrate on so many clothes changing in sitcoms. And the actors don’t always have to be super good looking
@phoenix-xu9xj
@phoenix-xu9xj Год назад
And look what did happen when somebody to told Donald Trump he could became president. We’re still suffering. And terrified that he’s coming back.
@mehallica666
@mehallica666 Год назад
Funnily enough, they did try a US version of Red Dwarf. I don't think it lasted long, but I have seen the pilot episode out of curiosity. It was awful! Doubt the Yanks knew what to make of it. I'll cut 'The Office' some slack, but an American 'Red Dwarf'? Nah!
@carmenl163
@carmenl163 Год назад
I think this is not very accurate. It's not like all British Prime Ministers were from nobility. And how good-looking were Archie and Edith Bunker, the Roseanne Barr family and the cast of The Big Bang Theory? Personally, I find there are some great British comedies (like Fawlty Towers) and some great American comedies (like Modern Family). It's just too diverse to make comparisons.
@I_Don_t_want_a_handle
@I_Don_t_want_a_handle 11 месяцев назад
You may well be right about the adverts, that may be why ITV rarely manages a good comedy, although C4 often does. Adverts break up the flow of comedy, so if you have more than one in a 30mins show, you have to rely on quick humour. Setting up the gag in the first scene and paying it off in the last is never going to work if the audience have just been treated to 3 minutes of tampon adverts. In the UK, until the 1980s, comedy was mostly Working Class. Until the 'student humour' started to take hold it was often written and starred in by people whose parents were Working Class. The Goons, Carry On, the writers of Dad's Army, Porridge, Morecambe and Wise, The Two Ronnies etc. They were then pretty much excised by the children of the Establishment. The Oxbridge set first and then the rest. These people neither understand nor like the Working Class, and their humour shows it. Many BBC comedies, like 2.4 Children, are meant to be Working Class, but the attitudes of the characters are wholly Middle Class, if Left Wing. There are stand-outs from this like The Office, Red Dwarf, Allo Allo etc, but the path was downhill from there. There has not been a decent sitcom on UK TV for years, unless it came from the US. Panel shows are a different thing entirely. A good example of the difference is Friends and its UK variant Coupling. Six friends and their relationships. Friends is very funny if unavoidable saccharine at times, like most US comedy, whilst Coupling was mean-spirited and very variable in quality. In Friends all six of them are good people struggling with life and they love each other. In coupling the same struggling occurs, but the characters don't seem to even like each other and only the BBC would think these were 'good' people. It was hard not to think they deserved their fates each episode, which was part of the comedy, of course. All hardly surprising, though. The UK is not the US, so why would we share exactly the same comedy? Oh, and paragraphs, dear heart. Paragraphs.
@baku2461
@baku2461 Год назад
I think British humour is also more understated. American humour seems overwritten amd often wants to spell out the joke for you. Where as the Brits just let the scenario speak for itself and they don't try as hard. Which ends up being funnier in a lot of ways Plus...the accent lends itself to humour more. Not sure why, it just does. I also like that British shows use ordinary looking people whereas American shows have everyone looking glamorous which is more fake and less relatable.
@MrBulky992
@MrBulky992 Год назад
There's nothing funnier than when a pompous character gets deflated e g Captain Mainwaring. Perhaps we have more pompous characters in the UK (or characters who seem to be). I wonder whether class differences also play a part. One of the funniest episodes of "Dad's Army" was when one of Sergeant Wilson's relatives died and he inherited the right to put "The Honourable..." in front of his name and how everyone in the town began fawning over him, to Captain Mainwaring's detriment: how Wilson was asked to open the local fete instead of Mainwaring and offered immediate membership of the Golf Club which Mainwaring had been waiting for years to be invited to join! Wilson had been to public school (i.e. for US readers, private school); Mainwaring was a grammar school boy (i.e. for US readers, a less prestigious school, possibly public) with pretensions but a chip on his shoulder.
@DDanV
@DDanV Год назад
"Europe is just basically a gene pool of people whose ancestors said: Oh, I don't think I can risk - there, I can't risk it". Wtf?! Who does he think were the ones who did the Age of Discovery, who found the maritime route to India, who sailed around the world to prove it was possible? Martians?! Took two World Wars for us to finally say "well.... maybe we should take a breather".
@carmenl163
@carmenl163 Год назад
You can also say our ancestors didn't run away from their problems. They stayed and tried to solve it or make the best of it.
@klarasee806
@klarasee806 11 месяцев назад
Of course, Europeans don't completely shy away from taking risks either. Our ancestors are also a colorful mix of migrants who had to risk a lot to survive. But the USA was settled by particularly risk-taking Europeans. It took a lot of courage and a lot of optimism to leave everything behind in order to build a new life in an unknown and far away country. This has remained noticeable in the attitude to life of US citizens to this day. While we in Europe try to protect each other from falling too far, for example by making some insurance compulsory, in the USA there is more of an attitude that it's good to take risks - even if you can fall very far . Everyone has the chance to reach the top. On the other hand, no one is protected from ending up at the bottom. To a certain extent, the freedom to fall deeply is also a valuable asset in the USA, and this is often not understood by us Europeans. In fact, we often find it more sensible to avoid or mitigate risks, even if this means that social classes are less permeable not only downwards but also upwards.
@Jeni10
@Jeni10 Год назад
American comedy is very slapstick, but British humour is very clever! When I tell a British joke to an American, they never seem to get it, even after I have tried to explain it!
@steveallen3434
@steveallen3434 Год назад
If you have to explain a joke then it is not funny
@Jeni10
@Jeni10 Год назад
@@steveallen3434 Oh it’s very funny! But the dynamics are very different with American humour! British humour is very clever!
@christinestromberg4057
@christinestromberg4057 Год назад
Monty Python was something different. It's not typical of British Humour. We do enjoy stuff that's "out there" but that's just one kind of British humour. Word play often plays a big part. But we do laugh at the hard times. It's a way of getting through. :)
@lavalamp6410
@lavalamp6410 Год назад
I grew up with British humour and really enjoy it, when Friends started I had friends tell me I should watch it but after about half of the first show I just changed channels, I found it just boring, the laugh reel really grated and it just wasn't funny. That was all I saw of the entire series, half of one show. Some American comedy is good, Married with Children springs to mind but generally I prefer British humour.
@etienne8110
@etienne8110 Год назад
I don t know if it is american humor but i found south park to be great. Underneath the harsh langage, there is real satire.
@phoenix-xu9xj
@phoenix-xu9xj Год назад
Me too. It’s so contrived.
@lavalamp6410
@lavalamp6410 Год назад
@@bonnie7898 Frasier was great, I really liked that show, but at the time I thought Friends and Seinfeld relied too much on the laughter machine trying to make it funny and not enough on the humour. Its like differences in their comedians, I grew up watching comedians like Dave Allen who I think is a comedy genius, but when I see American comedians they come across as rude and crude and trying to derive their impact by constantly swearing which I don't find funny at all. Yes comedians like Billy Connelly swear a lot, but he is funny too.
@carmenl163
@carmenl163 Год назад
That's what I did with Absolutely Fabulous. What a complete bore.
@RickTheClipper
@RickTheClipper Год назад
It's called the American dream, because You have to sleep to believe it
@johnclements6614
@johnclements6614 Год назад
The US has lower social mobility than most of Europe as any pub landlord knows. In 2020 the UK ranked 21st in the Global Social Mobility Index whilst the US was down at 27th. The top 5 are all Scandinavian countries.
@AlexGys9
@AlexGys9 Год назад
Indeed, the famous line of George Carlin, the all time best American comedian.
@mollycasey5070
@mollycasey5070 11 месяцев назад
I really enjoyed watching you absorb and articulate what you were seeing and hearing. We need both tones in comedy and film.
@cenedra2143
@cenedra2143 Год назад
Our humour is being hurtful in a way where no one gets hurt 😂
@denewst01
@denewst01 Год назад
Apart from the one telling the joke. But hey, yourself is always an acceptable target.
@cenedra2143
@cenedra2143 Год назад
@@denewst01 makes no odds to me, I have no sense of humour at all 🤷‍♀️
@HeatherMyfanwyTylerGreey
@HeatherMyfanwyTylerGreey Год назад
That's a bit narrow!
@mosthaunted2
@mosthaunted2 Год назад
There is optimism in British comedy, everyone has a plan that's going to work, but in the end they are brought down to reality, either by realising themselves that it's not going to work out, or by someone else who spoils their plans, You hardly ever get a successful main character, Unlike the US.
@robertfarrow5853
@robertfarrow5853 Год назад
Only Fools and Horses. That was very trying for the dream which we all knew to be an impossibility for them. The final payoff was the joke was on us. Cos they made it. The after sequel just wasn't as good . Watching a dream turn sour
@mosthaunted2
@mosthaunted2 Год назад
@@robertfarrow5853 They should have kept them Millionaires and carried on, Yeah it ruined it a bit when they went back to being normal broke people, The best Sitcom of all time though.
@MrBulky992
@MrBulky992 Год назад
​@@robertfarrow5853That's true: the joke was on the audience. The other point is that they made their fortune purely by chance: their own efforts hampered by their stupidity counted for nothing: it was only when someone else recognised the valuable John Harrison timepiece which Del Boy had dismissed as worthless that they achieved wealth. Mr Bean is rather like that too: things go badly for him through his character faults but he will often end up getting out of bad situations by pure luck.
@grimreaper-qh2zn
@grimreaper-qh2zn Год назад
I think one of the things that gets US humour in the eyes of many UK people is that it seems dozens of writers are needed to write a US comedy. In the UK only one or two writers are generally involved. UK humour quite often pokes fun more that US comedy and clever use of words (watch some of Ronnie Barker's monologues for example). Doesn't mean both aren't funny. I think sometimes (in both humours) "local" references often confuse the watcher.
@mehallica666
@mehallica666 Год назад
Also, UK sitcoms are mostly shortlived, leaving audiences with fond memories and wanting more, (one of the most loved, Fawlty Towers, was only 16? episodes in total). US sitcoms get done to death, dragged on and on, dozens and dozens of episodes a season, becoming stale with people sick of the sight of it. Even then, they just hire another 30 writers and continue, audiences only watching out of habit, sense of loyalty, or nostalgia for the earlier days. US networks don't understand "quit while your ahead", and will bleed the life out of once enjoyable comedies.
@julianne_warren
@julianne_warren Год назад
Brits are one of the nations of Europe that really lean into sarcasm and Americans have more light-hearted shows. Even though there have been some very good US shows, the UK shows have a humour that is more natural and realistic.
@sprint955st
@sprint955st Год назад
What I’ve never understood about Americans audiences is that they need every joke or situation to have an explanation, to have it handed to them. If they don’t, they’ll say “I don’t get it”. If they do get it, then they tell you that they got it. British humour leaves it hanging for the audience to work it out for themselves.
@Lily-Bravo
@Lily-Bravo 11 месяцев назад
I remember reading "Punch" at school and there was a cartoon I didn't understand. I carried that lack of understanding for about 10 years until suddenly one day I got it! The same thing happened with a very rude joke I heard when I was too young. I had laughed dutifully when I heard it but I didn't understand it until years later.
@amygone2pot
@amygone2pot Год назад
Sponge Bob is on a comedic level with the best of British humour. But most American humour is too obvious. You see the joke coming before it is born. Sometimes before it was conceived. Good British humour sneaks up and bites your behind.
@francespetrak4600
@francespetrak4600 Год назад
My favourite comedy in the UK is Blackadder.......... all the series. I think it just about sums us up.
@paulbriggs5238
@paulbriggs5238 Год назад
I like American humour but it's mild and tends to insist on having a moral message.
@phoenix-xu9xj
@phoenix-xu9xj Год назад
It’s so lame.
@paulbriggs5238
@paulbriggs5238 Год назад
@@phoenix-xu9xj I used to enjoy sienfeld
@damirhlobik6488
@damirhlobik6488 Год назад
Then read Bible
@andrewlaw
@andrewlaw Год назад
We excel in self depricating humour, we're not afraid to take the piss out of ourselves. Americans don't do that as they think it shows them in a bad light. We're also kings of sarcasm, Americans just end up cringy when they try to do sarcasm.
@glastonbury4304
@glastonbury4304 Год назад
British humour is self depricating, whilst American humour has to be optimistic and never sarcastic...i think British humour is so much funnier ss its usually always about real life and you can relate to it, whilst American comedy is something always wished for or hasnt really happened yet!
@daveofyorkshire301
@daveofyorkshire301 Год назад
American humour is unsophisticated, it works on fewer levels but it still works... It's like a classic car and a brand new base model car, they both provide the same functionality, but the classic car provides either depth and fun or if you don't see it fails to give you the comfort you expect... American humour hits you around the face with tag line and punchlines, British humour will often have layers from the obvious to the almost subliminal. Different people can watch it and get a totally different aspect of the joke... It's not as if Americans can't do deep dark humour, watch MASH that was exceptional. It's almost as if they prefer Seinfeld over MASH...
@amyb1078
@amyb1078 3 месяца назад
I enjoy the Simpsons, Seinfeld, Frasier, Barry, Curb Your Enthusiam. If that makes me unsophisticated, so be it.
@daveofyorkshire301
@daveofyorkshire301 3 месяца назад
@@amyb1078 I'm saying the humour is unsophisticated not the audience. It's how you experience it, not your intellectual capacity. Everybody laughs at slapstick, a slip or fall is a universal form of humour, it's not based upon intelligence it's based upon cultural and shared understanding.
@amyb1078
@amyb1078 3 месяца назад
@@daveofyorkshire301 You're right. It's a cultural difference. I have a family member from Denmark, and she doesn't seem to get ANY humor. This will sound sickeningly American to you, but I'm glad to have different forms of humor. To me, whatever makes you laugh is good, and it takes all kinds.
@bobbyboko6317
@bobbyboko6317 Год назад
You got it with Curb Your Enthusiasm , full of embarrassing failures, my favourite US comedy ever 😂😂
@cpmahon
@cpmahon Год назад
The biggest difference between British humour and American humor is u!
@evelynwilson1566
@evelynwilson1566 11 месяцев назад
The title sequence to The Office makes me laugh - just something about those cars on the roundabout, whilst 'Handbags and Gladrags' plays
@The_Original_Geoff_B
@The_Original_Geoff_B Год назад
A lot of British humour is of the "I've done that, but just not quite so badly". US humour seems to be "Oh, that worked out well in the end".
@graceygrumble
@graceygrumble Год назад
Laughing AT people and at yourself, riffing on ridicule and delighting in other's embarrassment are key to British humour. Many Americans see this as 'cruel' or 'rude'. Having a disastrous day is 'comedy content' for your friends and family. Making people laugh at your expense is cathartic to a British person. Americans would sympathise. Comedy comes in all different shapes and sizes, both here and in the USA.
@beech1013
@beech1013 Год назад
I think you nailed it, a lot of American comedy I find "corny" Although my favourite comedian is Dave Chappelle, and I enjoy some American comedy, "The last man on earth" was one of my favourite comedy series, and Will Forte was brilliant.
@Eastlomond
@Eastlomond Год назад
As someone from the UK, I love watching Curb Your Enthusiasm. It is so unlike any other form of US comedy, but it is hilarious. One thing I don’t like about some comedies is the over use of canned laughter.
@norbertrottenari4516
@norbertrottenari4516 Год назад
it is a basically different mind set in many things. like for example starting your own buisness`? in the us everybody supports you, in germany they will tell you why it wont work
@debbielough7754
@debbielough7754 Год назад
Monty Python has it too... "So always look on the bright side of death, Just before you draw your terminal breath". And the Spanish Inquisition one - making funny something that killed and brutalised hundreds of thousands of people for four centuries... (and enough of them studied history to know exactly what they were doing). But I think The Office is a good example. The British one is funny to British people because anybody who's worked in an office has known somebody like David Brent. It's funny because it's real. Same goes for most of the most successful comedy shows in Britain. They're funny because you can go 'yeah, that's what it's really like', and laugh at ourselves. Also, there's a lot more sarcasm and punning (see Ronnie Barker for both).
@missharry5727
@missharry5727 Год назад
Nobody expects the Spanish Inquisition.
@whiteknight-m4q
@whiteknight-m4q 5 месяцев назад
'Frazier' is very funny because it's a synthesis of American and British humour, which makes it a great sit-com. There are other great American sit-coms, mostly, from the 60s: 'The Beverly Hillbillies', 'Get Smart', 'The Munsters', etc. Back to England, there's no mention of the bawdy and hilarious Carry-On films; they're a British institution, and very funny.
@Burglar-King
@Burglar-King Год назад
I think the best comedy is off the cuff. I love our Brit quiz panel shows Would I lie to you (Wilty) and 8 out of 10 cats. The insults fly back and forth but is taken with a pinch of salt and a belly laugh.
@mollycasey5070
@mollycasey5070 11 месяцев назад
just subscribed. Like your vibe. Us brits need the American escapism as much as you need our gritty relatable stuff x
@iain860
@iain860 Год назад
America are/is the adverts... The UK are the documentaries...🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿
@rowietappy187
@rowietappy187 Год назад
Best way I can explain it..... Americans....it rained today and we survived a Hurricane, tomorrow its gonna be sunny and warm, let’s do this thing...... YAAAAA British..........it rained today, F**Ks sake it gonna rain tomorrow, and the day after, bollocks to this crap I’m off to the pub YAAAAA Australians...it rained last month, it’s always sunny, let’s go surfing and eat shrimp on the beach then lets go to the pub . YAAAAA Irish ............it rained but I don’t care because I’m already in the pub and tomorrow and the next day, let’s stay in the pub YAAAAA
@kaiatherton
@kaiatherton Год назад
I think a big difference is hat UK sitcoms tend to be written by, produced by and staring comedians.. where as USA sitcoms are written by comedy writers, produced by networks and star actors. The office is a prime example... certainly a generalization but It's the vast majority for sure. UK v in general focus on the average working class person. American shows on wealth and status.. and even the one UK show that I can think off that did feature weakly people was Ab Fab and hey where incompetent as hell.
@cireenasimcox1081
@cireenasimcox1081 Год назад
Ahhh. Finally: "American is more, like, corny." Yess! Only people don't want to say that directly to an American's face - because it isn't very complimentary. But the humour, in US shows, is just as rigidly constrained as are all the other constraints on USA film & tv shows, like: there's ALWAYS a happy ending. Good always triumphs over bad. The main characters always end up getting married. And if you look at old USA sitcoms...they're all pretty standard in that Mum stays home and spends all her time being a), wise b)ditzy. She & Dad slept in twin beds which had the whole of the rest of the world scratching their heads & muttering "Wotha?" All Dads have REAL wisdom: from learning. While Mum's wisdom is all about relationships and fashion & stuff. Dad works 9 to 5.most days. Dads worked at a place called "the office". Women possessed the magic key to waking in the middle of the night beautifully made-up, and with every hair in place. And no-one, ever, was gay. There was never a mixed race family portrayed. Everybody always believed in a Christian god. They inhabited a different world to the Brits or Europeans: theirs was make-believe. Unreal. In this mythical 'Merica humour was more visual...even to this day I've seen clips where people smash 'pies' into people's faces - and the crowd - still - goes wild.Someone standing on a garden-rake is hilarious. But our humour has developed through words: minstrels that went from place to place singing rude ditties about the Upper echelons. Nursery Rhymes, Traditional (& bawdy) songs sung in pubs, Clever little 4-line verses that could be taken as being pretty disgusting, or as an innocent little poem. People falling over or having accidents with garden equipment are pretty everyday occurrences. I don't think many of us would laugh at someone who's just had an accident?. It gets old after a while.But there are many, many ways we can play with words and sentences & phrases. That never gets old to us. In the clip where Gervais is doing that eye-wateringly-cringe dance sequence the humour, for us, isn't the moves he's making...it's in looking at all the people watching him with no expression whatsoever. We know how much they're in agony. Every nerve in their bodies overwhelmingly wants to run away. But they can't. That'd be rude & insensitive - even though he's a total arse.But if they stay there with all this pent up emotion iit's gonna explode in one way or the other....they're gonna wet their drawers or they're going to laugh themselves silly. And you know from the uncanny silence and carefully held expressions on their faces - athey aren't going to be able to be in control in about 5 seconds! And we laugh our heads off because that's exactly what we'd think, and go through, and look like, in a similar situation..😂😂
@Youtube_Stole_My_Handle_Too
2:47 Bright guy you are. You caught that significant moment.
@laurataylor8717
@laurataylor8717 Год назад
I believe in American comedies we tend to go with a character who is the confident idiot. Brits have the more loveable oaf, the underdog who looks to his mates for validation. It gives British humor a humble quality that's very appealing.
@Rudron1
@Rudron1 Год назад
Just watching Red Dwarf or Black Books will convince anyone which humor is better.
@jaccilowe3842
@jaccilowe3842 Год назад
I really enjoyed watching you slowly get it. A lot of Americans just don't understand the difference.
@evelynwilson1566
@evelynwilson1566 11 месяцев назад
Oh my goodness. 'We look back at nineties stuff.' I feel so old.
@2001perseus.
@2001perseus. Год назад
The big difference for me, is that American humour is often sanitized to the point of near death formulaic. British humour left that behind decades ago to the point where nearly nothing is sacred. The boundaries are continually pushed. Push the boundaries in the US and the networks will shut you out. For example the late Bill Hicks and George Carlin. Hilarious to many Brits, shunned by network TV in the US.
@MaryRaine929
@MaryRaine929 Год назад
I love Ricky Gervais. He‘s my favorite a**hole! 😂 The Brits really nail it when it comes to dark n‘ dirty humor!
@Isleofskye
@Isleofskye Год назад
Dark,Dry,Deadpan,Ironic,Satirical,Sarcasm:)
@AlexGys9
@AlexGys9 Год назад
Yeah, Ricky Gervais is the best. Did you see his performance at the Golden Globes in 2020? An additional benefit was Ricky getting those celebrities all offended, frustrated and not knowing whether to lauch or to cry
@MaryRaine929
@MaryRaine929 Год назад
@@AlexGys9 It was so hilarous! I wish he would host again, but I think he was too inappropriate for the audience.
@AlexGys9
@AlexGys9 Год назад
@@MaryRaine929 Yeah, those celebrties are so easily offended. They have not figured out yet that it is a personal choice whether or not to take offence.
@geekexmachina
@geekexmachina Год назад
Its a bit funny you saying Monty Python Flying Circus has a happy vibe giving "Life of Brian " ends with the cast being crucified to music, and "The Holy Grail" the cast get arrested
@Foxhunter49
@Foxhunter49 11 месяцев назад
For me the biggest difference is that Brits can laugh at themselves, often setting themselves up for humour. One of the best 'set ups' were 'Yes Minister' and 'Yes Prime Minister' I cannot even begin to imagine Americans making a comedy about their politicians.
@carmenl163
@carmenl163 Год назад
I love the ridiculing, even dark humor that some US comedy shows have, like Roseanne, Archie Bunker and Modern Family. That first season of Modern Family was hands down the best comedy show of all time for me. Those characters were the funniest ones ever on television because they were completely over-the-top but always had a surprising element to them. And there were a lot of US comedy movies like The Naked Gun, Dumb and Dumber, MIB, The Pink Panther, Back to the Future (and many more) that I found very funny. And let's not forget the stand-up comedy that gave us Robin Williams, Eddy Murphy and Joan Rivers.
@MrBulky992
@MrBulky992 Год назад
And "Airplane", surely?
@MrBulky992
@MrBulky992 Год назад
The sitcom "All on the Family" in which the Archie Bunker character originated was an American rewrite of the British 1960s sitcom "Till Death us Do Part". Archie Bunker was the Alf Garnett character from the latter.
@carmenl163
@carmenl163 Год назад
@@MrBulky992 I didn't know that, so I've watched an episode of the UK version. But 'All in the family' was 2.0. Maybe it was Edith who made it so much better than the original? Because she brought a simple sweetness that toned down the aggressiveness from the UK series.
@seanmorris
@seanmorris 11 месяцев назад
Paraphrasing British comedian Al Murray's character The Pub Landlord. '...we don't have a British dream, because we're awake!'
@stevetheduck1425
@stevetheduck1425 Год назад
The guy example saying; 'you know how to take the reservation, you just don't know how to hold the reservation' would be answered by a Brit with 'I then give back a small fraction of the reservation. It's the American Way!'.
@lifechangeshypnosis8991
@lifechangeshypnosis8991 10 месяцев назад
A different perspective. Gives a better viewe.. Thank you from the uk
@stevehartley7504
@stevehartley7504 Год назад
It's not that we don't like it, we do! We just laugh at a whole range of stuff,
@felonmarmer
@felonmarmer Год назад
Humour is defined by the society that creates it. In the UK we've been crapped on from a great height for longer than you, so that reflects in the comedy. But hey, you are catching up!
@janetbristow6895
@janetbristow6895 Год назад
For me, as a Brit, Mash was your finest and funniest.
@bulwinkle
@bulwinkle Год назад
Perhaps the best ever TV comedy series to come from tht USA was Mash.
@PeleRana-pp6zc
@PeleRana-pp6zc Год назад
In American comedy the main character is the hero. In British comedy, the main character is usually a failure and ends up messing things up. Or at the least is a anti hero. The British laugh at themselves constantly and that is reflected in the comedy( life is a tragi- comedy) American like to laugh at the mistakes of others so the main character reflects the American spirit. He’s the smartest man in the room whereas the British comedian is shown as not very bright. The British don’t like to brag( it is almost a deadly sin here) The Americans generally love blowing their own trumpet You can even see that on celebrity chat shows
@robertmcconnell1009
@robertmcconnell1009 11 месяцев назад
having seen the American pilot version of the vicar of Dibley with Kirsty alley ..it says it all...
@Bertie22222
@Bertie22222 Год назад
In england i grew up in a constant wind-up, piss take, sharp tongued and brutal environment. Everyone was at it, wherever you went, if you were with older kids, you were the material and it could be savage. A German once said to me that when he was in a hotel in Spain there were lots of Brits and for 24 hours they were either laughing or singing.
@Lily-Bravo
@Lily-Bravo 11 месяцев назад
Well they wouldn't have been sunbathing because the Germans would have had all the sunbeds!
@Safi-Dee
@Safi-Dee Год назад
I mean, America is a young country with much more optimism. Kind of like your older sister or brother, Europe are over here watching its always sunny and curb your enthiusiasm line "aw, they're starting to grow up and lose their childlike wonder" 😂
@johnlaine2654
@johnlaine2654 11 месяцев назад
Hey Ryan, Have a look at an Older Aussie movie called The Castle… it’s about an Aussie family who have been told their home, which is adjacent to an airport,is being compulsorily acquired for expansion. The story is the battle to stay in the home(Their Castle),and live their everyday ordinary lives. Aussie humour at its best. BUT,you have to watch the Whole movie for it to make sense. Hope you enjoy it.
@ChrissaTodd
@ChrissaTodd 11 месяцев назад
I wish they brought up the IT crowd for this, because as someone who has watched too many american tv shows, in the IT crowd when chris o dowds character is bullying jen in the first episode not wanting her there, in america they would become a couple usually, take brooklyn 99 with how jake treated amy, but no he and jen never ended up together, they just stayed friends. and that was so nice. ike yes bullying someone and it turning into a relationship is not the right way.
@danellis-jones1591
@danellis-jones1591 Год назад
British comedy is often more complex, and assumes a higher level of knowledge of the audience. But the 80s soaps are a good example. Dallas and Dynasty were in big rich homes and families. It's aspirational and "I could be them". UK soaps are Eastenders and Coronation Street, which are dark and working class. Tge viewer things "thank god I'm not them!" And Australian soaps, Neighbours and Home and Away are just slightly more dramatic versions of reality in suburban Australia.
@carmenl163
@carmenl163 Год назад
To me, this comes across as a contradiction. First, you say British series assume a higher level of knowledge. But then you name all kinds of working-class TV shows. ??? How do they require a higher level of knowledge?
@danellis-jones1591
@danellis-jones1591 Год назад
@@carmenl163 The soaps aren't comedies. They're a hood example of cultural differences. It's pretty widely accepted British humour doesn't have spell things out. There is some great intelligent US comedy, but it's more of an exception. If you watch UK comedy panel shows, a lot (not all) of the comedy is quick witted and smart
@johnmarshall9604
@johnmarshall9604 Год назад
British sitcoms, I think, tend toward "well, this sucks, doesn't it? Bloody ridiculous though too, right? Come on, let's laugh at the bastards; it takes some of their power." American sitcoms have more of a tendency toward "hey, you're home now. Don't be sad, be happy! Go to bed happy! It's better for you! (Then get up in the morning, refreshed, get back to work, and keep making money for your capitalist overlords.)"
@tibouzankor1997
@tibouzankor1997 Год назад
To me, American humour tends to be “in your face”, lacking any subtlety. It’s not as funny when you can see the joke indicating that it’s turning and coming your way.
@natmanprime4295
@natmanprime4295 Год назад
idealism vs realism, thats right. larry davids stuff is like british because its east coastal america, which is influenced by seafaring british and west european culture, which is about realness.
@Austtube
@Austtube Год назад
And there is Australian comedy. Somewhere between Irish comedy, British comedy, and a dash of Americanism. And the think about never dreaming about one day being President. That is an important difference to everything Commonwealth, including Canada, Australia, NZ and so on. This is something to do with the saying "There is no such thing as Patriotism in a commonwealth country. Think of it. Canada, Australia. We are self-aware. But not quite patriotic.
@kristymac3236
@kristymac3236 Год назад
Very interesting, I think you were right saying American humour was more corny. I think on the whole the Brits have a darker sense of humour. I know I laugh at inappropriate moments . That said I love Friends and happily watch it over and over again which is not usual for me. My teenage granddaughter loves it too.
@uinsel
@uinsel Год назад
when I see US comedy I am often not that entertained because it is so foreseeable. I like comedy with layers, so to speak. Even if I get the joke only when seeing it for the third time.
@treadtyred9742
@treadtyred9742 11 месяцев назад
The difference is in part that bit of sarcasm around 2:30 ... and they can
@coopsnz1
@coopsnz1 Год назад
It ain't half hot mom ! Hilarious British army comedy of the 70s ... Windsor Davis was a legend .... Watch the episode showing the flag
@vicksenful
@vicksenful Год назад
You hit the nail on the head with "corny" (imo anyway). It's that 'everything has to be uplifting & have a happy ending' vibe with a lot of US shows that turns your stomach a bit. And I don't know whether the US is capable of producing the level of self-deprecation you get with a standup like Dylan Moran. Of course there's some great stuff from the US, it's just a different flavour ... but when a British show's redone in the States, the original always wins hands down (but then I'm Australian).
@solreaver83
@solreaver83 Год назад
This guys review is on a specific darker Brit humour. It is too narrow a view. I once heard it explained as Brit comedy assumes the viewer gets the joke and can be subtle, dry or sarcastic whereas American have to make it clear they are making a joke just to be sure you don't miss the joke.
@annettemoynihan7064
@annettemoynihan7064 Год назад
Watch only fools and horses and porridge..or rab c resbit and father Ted.. British comedy at its finest ❤
@gbsailing9436
@gbsailing9436 Год назад
Oak Ryan, let me put the difference between the two countries like this: At 02:30 Ricky Gervais suggests 'a' difference between the two countries humourous aspects. His last sentence: "and they carry that, they carry that with them." This is said with a mouthful of cynicism, sarcasm, and truthfulness altho while trying to be funny and bland by the dead pan delivery. It's both truthful and humourous because of the prose and the delivery, which you just didn't get. Us Aussie's who have anglo - Saxon heritage get it. and can spot it a mile off. We've been raised on Monty Python, The Goodies, Black Adder, etc. and the like. It is a cultural thing. It takes years of learning and exposure to the subtle nuances and idioms of the culture to appreciate. Don't expect to pick it up over a weekend watching a couple of videos on British humour. Try The Two Ronnies' 'Mastermind' to get a full dollop of this. It will be very hard to digest at first. You may need to research the history of various historical figures of British history. But it genuinely subtle and hilarious once you understand it and the level of complexity in its inception. Classic creativity, as opposed to just simple minded character mis-play representation from the Americans...
@julesmarwell8023
@julesmarwell8023 Год назад
Hi Ryan. how is you . ?? My mate just got back from Holi in the usa. HE LOVED IT met lots really nice people. and Being an Aussie. the yanks treated him. really nice. which made him think.. You Yanks really like us Aussies. You have a good one mate. and take care.. bye for now. Keep the vids coming, always enjoy them.
@wessexdruid7598
@wessexdruid7598 Год назад
For a start - it's spelled with a 'u'.
@Dan-kb2oz
@Dan-kb2oz 11 месяцев назад
It's not just comedy but a difference in the way British people and Americans generally are. As an English man, we see a stereotypical American as largely being optimistic, energetic, visibly happy and ready to party, whilst often being loud. This isn't to say that people from the UK are miserable or unhappy (putting aside current politics and the state of the country) we just tend to have a much less excitable and more relaxed and down to Earth mindset. Take this for example. If you ask an American how they are they might say "I'm doing great!", where as a Brit will likely say "not too bad". This isn't said to mean 'well my life isn't as crap as it could be', it's simply a more relaxed response, as most of the time people aren't "great". Great is when something amazing's just happened. The common British reply of "Not too bad, thanks. How are you?" just means, 'I'm alright thanks, how are you?'. I can understand why from an American perspective this and our comedy could appear to have an air of gloom or darkness, but really it's just rooted in a more down to Earth realism about shit that happens in life.
@Finkele1
@Finkele1 Год назад
I travel to work everyday by tram. I have been travelling south east asia countries and ofc recognise them in Finland. They are always well behaved but other like from middle easy and africa, It's amazing how loud and not caring a shit of culture of country what has saved them. If i would flee a war or just wanted better life i's try to exactly how their culture is.
@hellmalm
@hellmalm Год назад
Well it’s important to laugh. Loves a lot of both, the British seems closer to home though, our humor here in Sweden is similar.
@marknieuweboer8099
@marknieuweboer8099 Год назад
As a Dutchman I don't think the difference has much to do with misery, cheering up, quality or even self depreciation. The two points are already shortly mentioned. English humour indeed is more negative while American humour is more positive. In English comedies things always go wrong beyond repair, while in American comedies everything ends up fine. Also English humour relies more heavily on insults while American humour relies on witty oneliners and silly behaviour. It's not fair to compare shows like Cheers and Friends (both upliftin) with say Monty Python (the opposite). Cheers and Friends should be compared with eg 'Allo 'Allo and Are You Being Served (I dislike all four). The counterpart of Fawlty Towers (Monty Python is, despite its influence, unique) would be several movies with Richard Pryor/Gene Wilder and young Eddie Murphy (especially Raw and Trading Places). The counterpart of Keeping up Appearances would be All in the Family. I wouldn't dare to say that these examples of American humour are any worse. A very underrated American comedy is 1941. A cheesy example of terrible English humour is any Benny Hill show.
@kischtrine
@kischtrine Год назад
There was a small clip of Stephen Fry in the video you watched. Here is a link to the whole video of him talking about the difference between the two types of humor. I think it’s well explained: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-8k2AbqTBxao.htmlsi=dPI7H4gBGdsoY1Dw
Далее
UK Game Show Bloopers AMERICAN REACTION
16:26
Просмотров 42 тыс.
American reacts to British VS American Comedy
13:28
Просмотров 29 тыс.
БАГ ЕЩЕ РАБОТАЕТ?
00:26
Просмотров 270 тыс.
American reacts to Could SOCIALISM fix America?
22:32
Просмотров 122 тыс.
Humour! British VS American
20:34
Просмотров 446 тыс.
4 Extinct Languages we should bring back
13:27
Просмотров 8 тыс.
American Reacts to 10 British Accents Ranked
23:02
Просмотров 73 тыс.
American reacts to: america - What they don't show you
16:12
American reacts to Eurovision Explained for Americans
18:17
American reacts to European Girls vs American Girls
17:31