American Venom as RDR 1 John Marston (a totally original video idea that has never been done before) 

You know what, I’m not saying John doesn’t look good with a full beard but the OG look is definitely better.

I just can't help but appreciate the effort Micha's VA put in his character. After all these years of playing the game I'm still amazed by how this character can cause so much hatred over him among the fans. This indicates that the work was done perfectly

14:20 The way he runs up to you from behind, talking shit with no weapon drawn, just to immediately get shot, yell, and fall over dramatically reminds me so much of the enemies from Red Dead Revolver.

It's nice to see John with his original long arms weapons gun belt

Man, Arthur was right about John and his luck. If he wasn't there on that mountain, Charles and Sadie would have most likely still had gotten badly wounded, with no one there to save either of them. They would probably have met them same fate as Arthur, for Arthur, going after the same man.

Lore Accurate John Marston

Now its john marston. Not that john morgan bullshit

John's RDR2 look bothers me less than his RDR2 walk. He had the coolest looking walk in RDR1, especially while holding his sidearm.

6:03 Bro even got the John Marston aiming animation :0

Man seeing you create og john marston into rdr2 made me wish rockstar put more effort into fixing him, i love the animations you added from the first game

in a way its pretty symbolic cause its like the passing of a torch, once you finish this Several years later john will be back with this outfit only to be hunting his former gang members

11:31 the way that guy tried to get up

bro converted rdr2 into rdr1 while Rockstar only releases dlcs to gta online 🚬🗿

this video has been made 800 times and i will continue to watch it every time

If rdr1 had a remaster

Gotta wear Arthurs hat man

Truly an rdr moment

For those who don't know and are wondering why John looks so weird in RDR2 in the epilogue compared to RDR1, due to phenomenal amounts of crunch and the tight deadline, Rockstar didn't have time to make a seperate model for John that would work with all the features Arthur had during the main game, so they instead had to jury-rig a mostly-correct-looking John out of Arthur's character model. While they probably could've used John's regular model from the story, chances are that would've instead been derided as 'lazy' rather than making a whole new one, since it wouldn't have had other options like customisable hair without potentially breaking something that was best left unbroken lest it make more problems that needed fixing.

The guns sound so good with that mod 😂

They don’t even disarm him they leave his gun on him the whole time lol

damn the guns are loud asf

When I see this it reminds me how RDR2 has very detailed morning light and that RDR doesn't that much, but great vid still.

Does anyone have a mod to pitch his voice and make it just *slightly* deeper like in rdr2? The higher nails on a chalk board sound was great for the main campaign but John 3 years before RDR1 shouldn’t have been so different from the original game’s depiction of him and with all of the cosmetic improvements, he still sounds like the younger John from the Gang’s days pre TB Arthur

Very nice!

I think Rockstar tried to remake John to make him look better, and they did well in the plans, and we can see this when we look John on the screenshots they made before the game release, but the epilogue version is completely different from the pre-release version. Why? Probably because his model bugged at some point and they where in short time to release the game, so they messed up a bit and only fixed twice in a very discreetly way. I played on the Xbox, so I saw this happing since the beginning.

A RDR2 Ending RDR1 Style. I like it.

Low brightness 😍

19:06 he-he-hello son

I try to replicate the look as accurately as possible in the base game with the facial hair And it always feels slightly off, like some parts of his facial hair are highlighted more than the rest

The most reddit level

What are all of the mods you use? And does this affect Arthur? I have WhyEm’s catalogue and clothing but I was wanting to get mods that would change John but not Arthur. And I don’t want it to conflict with WhyEm’s mods

Haha you hit the guy more

all got to play as Jack marston on red dead 2

W video cowpoke

Also how do you stop the hairline from showing in the 1911 mod. I am using JMRE too, with the level 4 haid, but it still shows.

Welcome back Mr. Marston

The only missing part is rdr1 dutch

Really enjoyed this mod showcase even though there’s a lot of True John Marston ones out there, I also like the gunfire resound as well. Fell like the weapon is actually popping when it fires 🤝

You forgot the JM body and arms mod 😅

15:34 You gonna try to use a long range weapon at close range? 2 can play at that game.

what mod are u using for the subtitles?

The hair looks bad but nice

should have used the rdr1 accurate abigail mod 10/10 video tho

I noticed that you are using the promotional image and trailer graphics. Are the nights visible? 🤔 Last time I tried, the nights were way too pitch black, and I couldn't play because of it.

The only thing I don’t like with John in rdr1 is the rifle holder on his back because it makes the back of the weapon stick out more so that like the rdr2 rifle on the back more

I have a question for you, how did you get jmr and enhanced to work with jm 1911? Because when I use jmr and enhanced it shows beta jm head not 1911 head?

whats the font mod?

Friend, a question, I know that this subtitle mod no longer exists, but could you put it up for download because I really liked this subtitle??? thanks

can you do a tut on rdr1 john?

do you have the link to brutal motions? it's deleted

How'd you get the subtitles to look like RDR1 too?

how did u get that hair

whats the subtitles mod called?

This is amazing. Now If you want to actually prove you're doing something original, make wanted rampages with the original RDR outfits. I have never seen someone doing that and would be so sick if you did so.

Mod For John RD1 hair pls

for some reason johns hat in rdr2 looks so bad / flat compared to the rdr1 version like here

The funny thing is the people who say John doesn't look similar clearly just don't use the barber for the beard and only the top hair Because I let John's hair grow out to 7 and cut his beard and he looks really similar with his hat on imo But the graphics and John's outfit look amazing along with Uncle

I know this has nothing to do with the video, but I have to get this off my chest somewhere. I see a lot of people saying that John has always had Arthur's body. This, however, is untrue. In 1.00, John has his own body and jawline. His beard also grows slightly different. But his beard is a bit broken, and his body clips through the outfits sometimes. I think Rockstar, instead of fixing these issues properly, just shoved Arthur's features on him and called it a day. Again, I know this is irrelevant to the video. I just felt like venting 😅

What revolver what that?

This was pretty awesome to see OG John in his OG looks. Why didn't you shoot Micah in the face? And how is John not freezing without his winter cowboy outfit on? I guess the mods that you used tricks the game thinking that you're dressed appropriately for the winter weather? 🤷🏻‍♂️🤷🏻‍♂️🤷🏻‍♂️

Why does your lighting in your game look very bright and natural looking I've been trying to make mines bright for a while and what file did you edit was it the timecyc? Or is it the visualsettings.dat?

Honestly if you used arthurs holster and the rdr1 abigail mod this would be perfection and maybe the rdr1 beta shirt if you have the right textures