Тёмный

Ames Moot Court Competition 2021 

Harvard Law School
Подписаться 261 тыс.
Просмотров 144 тыс.
50% 1

This year’s hypothetical case, Charles Artiss v. Westlake Pharmaceuticals, Inc., asked the teams to address one of the foremost hurdles in a lawsuit: personal jurisdiction.
This year's presiding judges were Elena Kagan ’86, associate justice of the United States Supreme Court; Kimberly S. Budd ’91, chief justice of the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court; and Consuelo Maria Callahan, United States Circuit Judge for the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals.
The Carrie E. Buck Memorial Team (Petitioner):
John Acton, Jason Altabet*, Matt J. Bendisz, Ryan Dunbar, Maria Huryn, and Fenella McLuskie*
The Lila A. Fenwick Memorial Team (Respondent):
Chinyere Amanze*, Avita Anand, Reagan Chrisco, Sarah Maher, Morgan Sandhu*, and Mariah Watson
(*denotes oralist)
The Ames Moot Court Competition is one of the most prestigious competitions for appellate brief writing and advocacy in the country. The students participating in the Final Round started the competition in fall of their 2L year. Two teams progressed to the Final Round through their strong research abilities and excellent written and oral advocacy.
For more information, visit the Board of Student Advisers website orgs.law.harvard.edu/bsa/fina...
To view the history of the Ames Moot Court Competition, including decades of videos and info on past competitions, go to : hls.harvard.edu/ames-moot-court/

Опубликовано:

 

16 ноя 2021

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 136   
@benabrahamson8487
@benabrahamson8487 2 года назад
I understand all of the words individually, but not together.. still can't stop watching
@Khimbdrgrg1
@Khimbdrgrg1 2 года назад
Same here
@ronawhatever
@ronawhatever 2 года назад
U can Wikipedia Civ pro personal jurisdiction and tort vicarious liability and corporate law agency theory. These keywords would probably help u understand it better!
@Feliole
@Feliole 2 года назад
Jargons are often used in law and court decisions (judgment). They are sort of titles for some rule or court decision which apply to a set of situations. Decisions/Judgements of courts apply the same rules to the same situations. For example: “This rule applies in Case X which has these circumstances. Therefore the same judgment and the same rules should apply to Case Y which has similar circumstances.” Context is key that’s why law students/lawyers study massive amounts of text so that they can apply those rules to a similar situation. Hope this explanation helps as to why law jargon sounds so alien. - From a J.D. Studying for the Bar
@kennethcarvalho3684
@kennethcarvalho3684 2 года назад
Hahaha true
@isaiahbaggett5014
@isaiahbaggett5014 2 года назад
Every time I watch these, I think of this comment :P
@TeamTimeRiders
@TeamTimeRiders 2 года назад
I just mooted this past semester, and this is absolutely impressive. To be able to delve into caselaw so effortlessly in answering minute and specific questions from judges is unbelievable. These law students could give most practicing lawyers a run for their money. Insane. That’s the level of Harvard.
@onebuffalo5402
@onebuffalo5402 2 года назад
no they couldnt give practicing lawyers a run for their money. They'll be good in time but they also mock trail this about 200x before the competition. something real lawyers dont do (at best a real lawyer might run 1 mock trial if its a massive case)
@dragonflarefrog1424
@dragonflarefrog1424 2 года назад
@@onebuffalo5402 Ahhh I didn’t know that. Repeated study of one case would make anyone good.
@tylko_do_pracy1083
@tylko_do_pracy1083 2 года назад
@@onebuffalo5402 You're right that they practiced way more than a normal attorney would, you're also confusing mock trial and moot court. Two completely different kinds of audiences and argumentation styles. If you don't practice, you're going to have a bad time. Oyez has a huge cache of SCOTUS oral arguments, you can really distinguish between someone who practiced and someone who didn't.
@esol927
@esol927 2 года назад
@@onebuffalo5402 To be fair, if you're a real attorney arguing before the Supreme Court you're probably going to practice more than once, lol.
@liezltatoy2887
@liezltatoy2887 Год назад
8
@americanswan
@americanswan 2 года назад
The stress I would have standing before a court like that.
@arvinhernandez2503
@arvinhernandez2503 2 года назад
Love the fact that Justice Kagan never forgets to mention and honor her former law students, and one of them, Elizabeth Prelogar, is now the Solicitor General of the United States (mentioned at the last part). 💯
@yorkman129
@yorkman129 2 года назад
Fantastic to see that Ames is back! I don’t understand some of the technical legal arguments but the quality of the oralists is very impressive.
@mohansurya7518
@mohansurya7518 2 года назад
9
@Oldwoman6285
@Oldwoman6285 2 года назад
I thought I knew English till I started watching moot courts in english
@govindmenon2874
@govindmenon2874 2 года назад
Babe wake up new Ames Moot Competition just dropped
@user-ci8qs2oc1b
@user-ci8qs2oc1b 2 года назад
Brilliant students. Must be very intimidating arguing about /applying Ford considering Kagan wrote the opinion.
@futurekillerful
@futurekillerful 2 года назад
Finally...it's here. I've been waiting for so long....sitting in a corner...pondering "what is life without Ames".
@curiousgeorgia11.11
@curiousgeorgia11.11 2 года назад
lol are we going to be seeing ur face at one of these in the future 😏
@nanayawnkansahoduro7034
@nanayawnkansahoduro7034 2 года назад
Couldn't wait to see it been uploaded. Great insight from all candidates. Great stuff
@muhammadfarhanzahidabdilla3217
@muhammadfarhanzahidabdilla3217 2 года назад
Woww. I am speechless. This big annual event is coming again... Hope i'll be there soon.
@williamgregory1848
@williamgregory1848 2 года назад
My favorite time of year. When the next generation of lawyers argue in court. (I’m also glad to see one of my heroes, Justice Elena Kagan, back at the Ames Court)
@esmaboztas1747
@esmaboztas1747 2 года назад
I’ve been waiting for this!
@cadlarkaweso9214
@cadlarkaweso9214 2 года назад
Finally... Winter is here... Waited for this for a year
@kfoster1935
@kfoster1935 2 года назад
I’d simply faint.The sheer amount of pressure is suffocating.
@Adam_Pianist
@Adam_Pianist 2 года назад
I've watched multiple of these and continue not to know anything they're saying. 💀
@drippysonic9060
@drippysonic9060 2 года назад
Read the captions. It’ll all make sense better lol
@the_tax_consultant
@the_tax_consultant Год назад
Technical language can be a bit difficult to grasp at first, but it gets better with practice!
@Mthomilk
@Mthomilk 2 года назад
I'm an LLB student watching all the way from South Africa, I love this.
@anonymoususer7119
@anonymoususer7119 2 года назад
31:47 to 33:15 This young man is great at going back and forth with Judges.
@elliewise4704
@elliewise4704 2 года назад
So excited to watch! I’ve been waiting for this all year!
@alillachmojahid3498
@alillachmojahid3498 2 года назад
Your dream is to become a lawyer ?
@elliewise4704
@elliewise4704 2 года назад
@@alillachmojahid3498 As a step to becoming a judge, yes!
@alillachmojahid3498
@alillachmojahid3498 2 года назад
@@elliewise4704 ohh good way to your nice goal , you have a Instagram ? I want to ask you about this work ( judge) 🙂🙂
@godwinmsekwa9073
@godwinmsekwa9073 2 года назад
I am so much excited also, I like to be a part of the upcoming moot Court, when it will be held
@godwinmsekwa9073
@godwinmsekwa9073 2 года назад
@@elliewise4704 congratulations 👏👏
@brentturno861
@brentturno861 2 года назад
Been waiting for this! 😱
@ruchpat1
@ruchpat1 2 года назад
Thank you Harvard Law School for posting this video.
@rsjrx
@rsjrx 2 года назад
The party must be wild upstairs. Kagan knows how to let loose.
@anonymoususer7119
@anonymoususer7119 2 года назад
I've been waiting for this
@futurekillerful
@futurekillerful 2 года назад
I was finnaly able to sit down and give this a listen... The third speaker was incredible...I can't say I heard a single "um" really in her entire argument. I think, if i remember right, i can say the same thing about the 4th speaker as well tbh. Moreover, the way she articulated her thoughts+ her tone was something to behold.
@emiliemartin813
@emiliemartin813 7 месяцев назад
Oh my goodness this was so much fun to watch! Bravo to everyone's hard work!
@roxannepedlar7763
@roxannepedlar7763 4 месяца назад
The danger is found in the different side effects that are being felt by the petitioners who have brought the suit😢
@cassiachung4805
@cassiachung4805 2 года назад
21:39 that hair slick was so confident omg LOL
@rafd3593
@rafd3593 Год назад
Some impressive performances including that from a fellow Brit. I wouldn’t like to stand before those judges. I’d crumble.
@joshua_2850
@joshua_2850 2 года назад
I want to become a lawyer but man i cant imagine myself standing there and not shaking
@BlueSupermoon20
@BlueSupermoon20 Год назад
Don’t worry, this is not the day to day for most attorneys. And presenting a case in front of these judges is not what most lawyers will ever face in their careers! Law is dynamic. And you will learn oral argument skills to equip you to deal with situations like this.
@n0twist1
@n0twist1 2 года назад
just checking in to see if anyone fainted this year
@hazel5447
@hazel5447 2 года назад
🤣🤣🤣🤣 same
@anonymoususer7119
@anonymoususer7119 2 года назад
1:06:21 Excellent response to the question on precedents and stare decises (i may have spelt that incorrectly)
@DB-gl3jx
@DB-gl3jx Год назад
stare decisis
@Abdilahi977
@Abdilahi977 Год назад
Although I am not a law student but I like this videos. I started to watch the video but I didn’t understood what they are talking about.After you read the paper that they attached it, you can enjoy the whole video until the end.
@archersbane
@archersbane 2 года назад
I feel like they can never get the audio right until 30-45 minutes in the competition but it does get better. Also, deciding on who the best oralist was must've been tough but Morgan Sandhu was the right choice!
@an0n71
@an0n71 2 года назад
That speaker “stacy” at the beginning doesn’t seem to be too confident she nervous
@curiousgeorgia11.11
@curiousgeorgia11.11 2 года назад
She’s British amongst native Americans
@lakeshagadson357
@lakeshagadson357 2 года назад
it will be good if yall lawyers get together with other lawyers who does the same thing that you do.
@ngochuong7679
@ngochuong7679 2 года назад
thank you
@nob6023
@nob6023 2 года назад
no one fainted..
@counselcouncilfellowship5344
@counselcouncilfellowship5344 2 года назад
This was very spirited. Mr. Artabet was well prepared.
@Jupiter-shorts_
@Jupiter-shorts_ 2 года назад
Very professional
@fredypelaez113
@fredypelaez113 2 года назад
Español cuando van a subtitular eso
@donmiller2689
@donmiller2689 2 года назад
Brilliant!..
@PIX-HUGEIFY
@PIX-HUGEIFY 2 года назад
who won!? Both right?
@ianmann28
@ianmann28 6 месяцев назад
Finally, an oralist with a RP accent! Thanks Fenella
@mikebanks1233
@mikebanks1233 2 года назад
One state claims they have jurisdiction, then another state claims they have jurisdiction is this possible if so why??
@memyself4431
@memyself4431 2 года назад
Hi living that scenario for 3 years no answers
@drippysonic9060
@drippysonic9060 2 года назад
Well I do recall, from my attention payed in class, that there is a concept called “State’s Rights”; whereas, a state government could have jurisdiction to enforce constitutional laws unto their citizens rather than having permission from the federal government.
@whitenova754
@whitenova754 Год назад
Nice to see a justice from my state supreme court.
@daniellewyatt7966
@daniellewyatt7966 2 года назад
Can someone explain what they r fighting about, r they fighting about drugs or Ford?
@esol927
@esol927 2 года назад
It sounds like the basic facts of the case are that the Plaintiff took the generic version of a drug and was injured in a way that the warning label didn't cover. So they are suing the manufacturer of the *brand name* drug, who wrote the label that appears on the generic version. The question is whether the manufacturer of the brand name drug is sufficiently connected to the state, and to the harm that occurred, to allow the court to exercise jurisdiction over them. The first speaker relies very heavily on Ford, a case involving a similar, but not identical, set of circumstances, to argue that because the Supreme Court allowed jurisdiction to be exercised in Ford, the court should also allow jurisdiction to be exercised here. So they wind up arguing a lot about Ford, because the Judges are trying to poke holes in the argument that Ford is *actually* applicable to the facts of this case.
@lakeshagadson357
@lakeshagadson357 2 года назад
i been want to know what its like to be on cnn or cspan.
@joshuaknight311
@joshuaknight311 2 года назад
What's do the winner get
@moscowirl7253
@moscowirl7253 2 года назад
respect.
@timothykozlowski2945
@timothykozlowski2945 2 месяца назад
Easy to tell when these took place
@chrisdvine
@chrisdvine 2 года назад
Aaaand that's why I didn't get into Harvard!
@johnbowden4761
@johnbowden4761 2 года назад
stupid question....they referenced "the state of Ames" multiple times...does the Ames competition take place in a fictional state?
@SoLyrical2
@SoLyrical2 2 года назад
yes. Ames is a fictional jurisdiction.
@johnbowden4761
@johnbowden4761 9 месяцев назад
appreciate the clarification@@SoLyrical2
@roxannepedlar7763
@roxannepedlar7763 4 месяца назад
The gaining of profit is absolutely important to the Pharmaceutical Company😮.
@aldrinzothanmawia9589
@aldrinzothanmawia9589 2 года назад
Nice
@justinpannu8257
@justinpannu8257 2 года назад
I disagree with the judges - the gentlemen was by far the best oralist.
@SalesforceUSA
@SalesforceUSA 2 года назад
I love MIT.
@vaibhavigupta9400
@vaibhavigupta9400 Год назад
Why wouldn't they just sue who manufactured the drug?
@ezulafeef5688
@ezulafeef5688 2 года назад
The second guy.. am I looking at Mike Ross in real world...?
@laurencetarquinio6716
@laurencetarquinio6716 2 года назад
💯
@thimomwwn6428
@thimomwwn6428 2 года назад
LLB
@estimateking7981
@estimateking7981 2 года назад
wow
@victoriaax6800
@victoriaax6800 2 года назад
why did they literally hammer Ms. Amanze
@VineetaSinghVerma
@VineetaSinghVerma 8 месяцев назад
Ames Moot Court! Medicine is completely a different world! other than law ; because it needs empathy! One cannot become a good physician without empathy! Pharmaceutical companies need to be more informative before using a particular drug! I am a native English speaker who can speak French, German , Spanish, Mandarin, Swahili (Africa); Tamil, Telugu, Malyalam(Indian Subcontinent),Arabic( United Arab Emirates), Punjabi or Urdu ( Northern Indian States)! Basically I have a very deep root of British Ancestry ! My paternal family was involved in Bureaucracy and Judiciary ; and my maternal family was involved Science and Technology which also includes Agriculture (Small and Large Scale farming);
@genethharris3894
@genethharris3894 2 года назад
Well say and done some how there get time how they kill on get a way tell them God don't sleep
@robertorivera4482
@robertorivera4482 2 года назад
0:41 isn't she the one who fainted years ago?
@DB-gl3jx
@DB-gl3jx 2 года назад
No she isn’t.
@samararoberts7596
@samararoberts7596 2 года назад
Lol, no 🤣
@sylvia8742
@sylvia8742 2 года назад
👍
@phoenixcollege6608
@phoenixcollege6608 Год назад
la mujer y el de lentes mi gustan.
@user-ek9vg8eo1j
@user-ek9vg8eo1j Месяц назад
she does not emphasis important key pieces
@truongnguyenytb
@truongnguyenytb 2 года назад
Tôi cho rằng không thể thuyết phục được Tòa nếu bạn lụm thứ bạn đã từng vứt vào sọt rác.
@LucilleMilo
@LucilleMilo 2 года назад
the young lady introducing the case needs to find something else to do. litigation is not going to go well.
@joseluisortega732
@joseluisortega732 2 года назад
First
@ariamasoudifar9589
@ariamasoudifar9589 2 года назад
When will you bring conservative justices?
@trangvophuong6919
@trangvophuong6919 2 года назад
They... are conservative justices? On this moot court, Justice Kagan is the only judge that was appointed by a Democratic President. Judge Kimberly Sudd was appointed by a Republican governor, and Judge Consuelo Callahan was appointed by a Republican President. This panel has a 2-1 Conservative supermajority.
@jennifera3074
@jennifera3074 2 года назад
Oh aria
@rpdbu8250
@rpdbu8250 Год назад
7th Circuit Judge Easterbrook was there previously.
@xximpacts2cks
@xximpacts2cks 2 года назад
I’d just bring up my Fortnite wins and earnings and it would be an auto dub. I’d box these judges like fish, absolutely cranking 90’s. Case closed.
@moscowirl7253
@moscowirl7253 2 года назад
lel you go man
@carltapnio4810
@carltapnio4810 2 года назад
Smart 🐑
@VP-km1ru
@VP-km1ru Год назад
hard to take anyone that wears a face diaper seriously.
@strangerrrrrrr
@strangerrrrrrr 2 года назад
boo 🍅
@evansjohnarek2271
@evansjohnarek2271 2 года назад
That young man is too bright for these women even judges cannot defeat him.
@birdieblair5817
@birdieblair5817 2 года назад
That’s such a dumb correlation
@curiousgeorgia11.11
@curiousgeorgia11.11 2 года назад
@@birdieblair5817 the dumbest
@drippysonic9060
@drippysonic9060 2 года назад
@@birdieblair5817 Do you know the definition of correlation? That word doesn’t belong in this sentence.
@Frenite
@Frenite 2 года назад
Do they really all have to be wearing masks?
@9290SC
@9290SC 2 года назад
No lol. Virus goes straight through masks!!! With the exception of N95
@Miss.Scarlett
@Miss.Scarlett 2 года назад
why is everyone wearing masks? its very weird
@jennifera3074
@jennifera3074 2 года назад
Are you new here
@cleo.butterflysflyinthesky1637
You live under a rock?
@user-ek9vg8eo1j
@user-ek9vg8eo1j Месяц назад
shes very monotone and unenthused
@VP-km1ru
@VP-km1ru Год назад
these people must be high on something to speak like this...just string together a bunch of big words into sentences which make 0 sense. talk about blowing hot air out of one's mouth.
@anthonymoran1121
@anthonymoran1121 10 месяцев назад
Just say you don’t understand
@evansjohnarek2271
@evansjohnarek2271 2 года назад
That young man is great and understand law unlike these his colleagues women who are too mounthy and no substance .
@pheeuh
@pheeuh 2 года назад
Did you visit this video to be misogynistic?
@cassiachung4805
@cassiachung4805 2 года назад
The blatant misogyny in your comment
@HA-ug4qu
@HA-ug4qu Год назад
@@pheeuh wtf 🤣 what misogyny ? Just criticizing women is misogyny? Maybe he's not a very good judge hence he's not in the video but how tf is that misogyny 🤣🤣🤣
@pheeuh
@pheeuh Год назад
@@HA-ug4qu you know that wasn't constructive criticism.. there's a complete difference from criticizing and insulting someone
Далее
Ames Moot Court Competition 2012
1:56:06
Просмотров 65 тыс.
small vs big hoop #tiktok
00:12
Просмотров 4,8 млн
ТИПИЧНЫЙ РЕСТОРАН
12:09
Просмотров 327 тыс.
BASS MANDA LIXAR TUDO E MOSTRA A CARA DA  NAMORADA NINA
0:32
Ames Moot Court Competition 2009
1:27:14
Просмотров 25 тыс.
21st John H. Jackson Moot Court Competition - 17 June
2:52:49
Harlan Fiske Stone Moot Court Competition 2018
1:41:07
Просмотров 28 тыс.
Ames Moot Court Competition 2016
1:36:35
Просмотров 261 тыс.
A Conversation with the Justice Clarence Thomas
54:37
Просмотров 627 тыс.
12 Tips for Appellate Advocacy
44:26
Просмотров 91 тыс.
Condoleezza Rice: Why Democracy Matters
1:23:45
Просмотров 89 тыс.