Just a heads up as a few people have asked after this video....I would be thrilled if anyone else would like to animate any of my animatics. Please go ahead. Just give me a shout which one you want to do and send me a link when you're done so I can make another video similar to this to promote your work and do a little review :)
A quick question because I’ve never tried animating something like this. Would you recommend drawing the backgrounds first? I feel like this is a obvious question lol but I want try to push myself outside of my comfort zone
I agree. Hers had more detail. In his it was still like an animatic, just more movement. His just had shadows and lighting but the characters were just solid colors. Now im not saying he did a bad job (definitely better than what i could do) but just not what i would want if that was my animatic.
Because animation shouldn’t have detail, it makes it a hundred times harder to animate, especially when doing it solo. Hers are just drawings that aren’t even fully done, it is much easier for her to add detail.
The colors really shine in the animation, I really feel like this artist is going places if allowed to grow and improve their already-impressive talents! There are few shortcomings, but the good parts are just SO GOOD. That's not even acknowledging the fact that they took on this project and managed to *finish* it. I really want to see them continue improving their art. If the colors are this beautiful right now, then imagine what their skills would be in a year from now.
@@funnymonkeylover Dear Elizabeth, Thanks for wasting your own time into replying to a comment of a stranger from another country. Jeez, people these days are so sensitive, did i offend you? Oh, sorry i don't care. My opnion is mine and if you don't like it, who cares? You're just one more stupid person that will waste their time reading this. Glad I wasted your time. xoxo João Victor
@@viktor2434 You don't have to be so rude about it, you could've said "Yeah, but I don't really like the lighting that much." that way, nobody would be offended and you could voice your thoughts out without being so rude. Have a nice day!
There a few important details they forgot in the animated one but overall its really good cause animation is really hard and its harder to add details plus i love the effects added
I’m no professional, but I do have a few nitpicks. First off, just wow! The animation is amazing. There were a few chunks that weren’t exactly animated, but it still conveyed motion, so it still flowed well. And the colour is absolutely beautiful and stunning. Some bits were a bit too intense in my opinion. The dark shadow that contrasts the light hitting objects is kind of much to the eyes. Lighting is hard to understand with angles, and especially in animation. Logan did an amazing job, but there’s definitely room for improvement. Now the nitpicks. I don’t really have many, except that the sketchy style when drawing the characters didn’t really blend well with the background. It’s best to stick with the style on the entire screen. That’s really it in my opinion. This is an amazing animation! And I will definitely want to see more from both artists in the future.
I ABSOLUTELY LOVED BOTH SO MUCH!!! The animatic definitely was better in some area, mainly line art which I think was a bit shakey and I feel didn’t convey as much as the sketch (this is very common, line art isn’t always better tho sketches can be quite the mess). But in animation, I can’t express how great the effects were. Seeing the fire come to life made it more than something small and showed real power. Colors were better than the other in different places, that nice tone in the animatic was nice and I think just studying color theory a bit more can really balance it out as in some scenes I feel the bright colors were awesome (not only for effects). Is it possible for you to make a tutorial how you achieved such wondrous effects with the fire and other things? Either way, you’re incredible and I really hope to see you improve, hope my own insights might be a bit helpful. You’re talented, and you’re going to go far, you already are far.
I feel this should have been an arc in season 5 of svtfoe, somehow that evil unicorn that stabbed marco would be turning him to the dark side, and he would have dark magic
@@bachledong7874 One day I will make a part 2. I have the song and basic plot worked out but it will be a big project so I will stick to doing some smaller projects for now until I have the time to properly work on it :)
You guys should do an animation together. You’re attention to detail with his glorious touch of color, you guys will make a really good animatic. My request for the animatic if you guys decide to do one, is It’s Over Isn’t It? From Steven Universe. I love Steven Universe so much!! 🥰🤩😊 ❤️
His was really cool, definitely, and I love the glowy/bright colors effects, but I still prefer yours, to be honest. The details, art style, shading, colors, movement, and all just feel more natural. Love both! SO cool! Was really nice to see them side by side here! Gorgeous work, you two!
I've really like Logan's animations. This vid was great~ And it's always amazing seeing someone's skills improve and improve the more they work. It's heartwarming and motivational too. Not to mention entertaining
This gave me goosebumps! I L❤VE IT!!! I missed the days when I would watch Star Vs The Forces Of Evil until I got busy with school and addicted to RU-vid, I stopped watching tv ;-; This is so beautiful and it gives me sad memories of how I ditched tv for RU-vid and I missed a lot of shows like Adventure Time and Fairy Tail (I only got to watch till S4 ;-;) Though the times when I watched tv were really memorable and fun....
I Really love Both, I was waiting that coloured version for a Year, but I have to say, the base version, make it more emotional with such more details, Star face when she looks to Marco's House, 🤩 pass soo much drama, and the hope that's inside her to rescue Marco from his Madness, both of them are really Awesome work of animation and storyboard (that storyboard it's insane, and give some point of an epic history) Sorry for the English, I'm Brazilian 🙂
Honest to the truth I like both. You for having the incredible idea of making this animatic and his for having the courage to animate this masterpiece despite people have High expectations and not always kind in their criticism. Good Job!!!! Both of You!!!!
oh my god I have been waiting for this for so looonnggg.... oh. it is pretty much just tha animatic with color :( but I gotta say I could never do such a thing as move their mouths so good job!
I hope they keep making more videos, it really has inspired me to make some comics about this series with this video, it makes us not forget the Star versus the forces of evil, it's great, I love it.
I think the mouth movement and the walk is weird in first part but the design in the characters are nice and I like the mud of the walk of the soldiers in the end nice touch
Oooommmgggggg I love both so muuuccchhhh but they both still make me cry because I love the "story" behind it even though its just an animatic/animation XD
I love how she knows that we’ve seen it like honestly it’s a classic in the animatic community now like she just combine two things so well in the song was so amazing at the time and it’s still Liz like everything holds up now honestly she needs to do one of the duet between Cassandra and Adrian
His coloring,animeting and lighting is amazing like amazing but your drawing is better if you guys could like do a colab you could draw whil he does the coloring,lighting and animating it would make a reallly amaing animatic
I love the animation but I just think I love the animatic so much since it has so much detail and idk I like the style better but the animation is also very nice
