Animation vs. Physics 

W

25초 전

ong fr fr

nice

yoo

im pretty sure its also a reference to dr strangelove

​@@maxberardi2146I was gonna say, riding a rocket with a cowboy hat is pretty on the nose if you know what he's referencing. Lol

It's also an homage to Major Kong in Dr. Strangelove riding an atomic bomb, after it falls from the bomb bay of his plane, waving his cowboy hat the whole way down.

It also visually differentiates which TSC we've been following.

@@DPSFSU Space Cowboy Reference?

I'm not a physics expert/nerd. But I do know my fair share of knowledge about physics and I understood most of the concepts of physics in this video.

I hate the physics subject that we learn at school bc it’s so boring, but i actually find this even more interesting and a better way to learn.

bro i actually play psp on all class of physice on the back

Yo at the end i think what they mean (or not) is matter is infinite, you can’t destroy or create it as with the portal at the end / beginning

Math>Physics

But ultimately this is not possible to get into the quantum realm through a black hole or any other way 😊

Ok this actually gives me the goosebumps bro. 😭 But it made me wonder (dunno if this is real) if our future selves is the present self trying to change or alter directions our past self is doing. Man the universe is so mysterious

what is this alien speak i dont understand 😭😭

we knew bro.

@thetank2997 but I understand it

\o/

Math is the fundament of Physics, Physics is the law of the universe, while Chemistry is the nature of matter. When these materials combine in a certain order, they form and nurture living entities.

everything is always connected

This is a beautiful comment on yt 😢definantly gonna use a Lin for graduation quote

No, it's not Nature that's all. And the Creator! Because he is an Architect. Calculated, Measured, Weighed. This is how he laid the foundation for the harmonious order of the Universe. And nature is just the nature of the surrounding world, it was not nature that created such laws of physics, only by the power of the Creator! It's enough!

Wazzup bro

Who’s Oscar

10 mins ayo

2 min

​@@deaconation7013oscar is like thropy

It ain't no cinematics it's the laws of the univrrse

@@Soviet_government_ Yes - the laws of the universe, displayed in a cinematic way, masterfully (a cinematic masterpiece).

@@Soviet_government_ it was still cinematic

@@ungamer6241I think he meant to say Kinematics (branch of mechanics regarding motion)

@@ZeroTempz could be

It's not the Kardashev's Scale, it's Type IIB String theory. Basically, he's going to explore a universe with different physics. This is probably a common misunderstanding, though.

I feel the same !

I feel the same

Glad to see another aerospace engineer here too!

Literally the exact same thing with me. i started watching him so long ago and now seeing this as an aerospace engineer is so awesome

Respect to you and alan becker bro

I was wondering why his name sounded familiar to me when I ran into this video. I saw the old video again and got a wave of nostalgia. His improvement is amazing

YOO YOUR WORKING MY DREAM JOB HOWS IT LIKE

Bust

@MrRiley2007 Nice try

Exactly wish I seen this before I failed my physics exam

Are you physics students? Nice -w -

Nah

*Second Coming, the most committed devotee in Physics, decides to challenge you into this Physics duel. How much knowledge do you know? Will you survive the beats of unusual laws of Physics?*

Cara eu adoro seus vídeos alan backer

Cara vc ta certo

@@NguyenMinh792 bruh its not my subject i will study physics this year 😂

@elijahkeeley nope! With the ring magnet have a positive attraction on one side and a negative attraction on the other side it will first pull you in and then propell you away from it

@@lightwolf2497 but on either side, the poles are opposites, therefore either side has attraction? so they would have to turn off in order to avoid undoing the acceleration

@@angeld23 what i thought is if we can create a single magnetic poles for example, both sides are negative. when we met the ring with positive charge they would pull us in while in the other side, negative charge of ring meet with our space craft negative charge they wouldn't pulling us back

@@Zeus-ju4hw How does single poled magnet make sense

@@anusthanbhandari2766 i mean take a sample of a rocket, using two magnet on both side of the rocket

Would be cool seeing a animation vs history like a time warp so like the Titanic and Napoleon

Agreed. These are REALLY educational and addicting. They mix the intuitive visuals of 3Blue1Brown with the amazing story telling of Alen Becker.

You probably don't want history.

I wonder what history would be like

History sounds cool

As a fellow person to understand string theory, I also understand that, simply through one wormhole, which can also be said as an opened wormhole, which would be held open by a type of matter that humanity most likely will never understand, there is a copy of our universe which just might have live that does understand this strange matter, and does understand everything we do not.

Actually, Alan casually

@@westongriffin9338 Is it like Quantum Immortality?

Halfway through the video the physics became so theoretical to the point of fantasy, probably why physics is so fascinating to alot of people.

@@Amogus-nj6dh what?

Ei vc e do Brasil eu sou do 6 ano e não entendi muito o vídeo me explica

​​​​@@LucasOliveira-ij5wd Bem, é muito complicado para explicar, vou tentar simplificar as coisas, mesmo que sou ruim em física, para começar, o próprio título do vídeo é: física, é uma matéria que começa a estudar a partir de 5° ou 6° série. Ainda é cedo para entender, mas, se quiser ver vídeos de física, é um bom começo para ver, acredito que têm vídeos que são fáceis de entender, mas, a maioria dos cálculos são difíceis de entender. Vou editando pouco a pouco... Vai ser bem longo e tem muitas coisas que eu nem imaginava e nunca estudei essas teorias por serem bem complexos/complicado para compreender... 0:20 distância, o ponto onde o TSC ou The Second Coming (o personagem de cor laranja) caminha. 0:30 velocidade, a letra v é a velocidade, nesse caso a velocidade que ele caminhou. 0:40 eu não sei traduzir, se eu não me engano é deslocamento ou distância, indica o deslocamento percorrido por ele, provavelmente com a presença de linhas são o deslocamento percorrido no sentido à direita, o total e a esquerda, a ordem de cima para baixo. Vou tentar editar o resto mais tarde... Mas, só posso dizer que o vídeo em si está repleto de cálculos que é diferente da matemática. Alguns, que a partir do foguete ou a imã, acredito que tem ligação com astronomia, a maçã desintegrada se refere a biologia (essa matéria tem a mesma série da física, como se diz, substitui a ciência para biologia) ou ciência (a partir de 2° ou 3° série que começa a estudar), por fim, ele encontrando com ele mesmo volta para a física, o final do vídeo eu não entendi nada... Vou ver direito e tentarei explicar. Observação: o comentário que você viu está em inglês, traduzindo: agora faça outra matéria (química, biologia e outros) (Cara, a parte da magnética é TÃO DAORA, eu já tinha estudado na escola) Espero que entendeu o que editei, desculpa se ficou longo, e acho que tem um vídeo com um professor reagindo com esse vídeo. Acho que ele explica melhor do que eu.

@@SoulierKaiser Obrigado amigo vc e de qual série eu sou do 6 ano bora ser amigos?

@@LucasOliveira-ij5wd tenho 30 anos, eu já estudei certos cálculos de física. Mas, nem todos por ser complexo. Se quiser ser meu amigo, tudo bem. Depois vou tentar continuar a traduzir, ou vou tentar encontrar o vídeo de um professor que encontrei.

ikr? the music and vibes feel so nostalgic I should watch Zathura again

I understood most of the stuff up until the stick figure was in the black hole, what was happening in there?

as a not physicist, I didn't learn anything from this video.

Does breaking reality itself with time in singularity considering as psychics?

​@@danielhuelsman76 don't worry, we in physics don't really know either. That's the fun part

Yeh 100% its incredible. I can't get over how good this is ❤

i earn more than 10k in 1 week without studying lmao

@@cenkkinqzzzz3002job? just curious.

@@mrbigsta4221 its called lying on the internet

@@deathstare0 lmao

@@deathstare0 Nah. He's a politician only job you need little to no skill.

Same question, where does this video and the maths one fit in the wider timeline? Of AvM and AvA

It’s the Second Coming tho, the Chosen One is the black one

I think of the physics one to be the continuation of the math one, since in the end of the math one our Chosen One got literally teleported at random into realspace. What is more real of a realspace than a world of pure physics? In other words, he overshot his goal, of home, by quite a bit. XD

Nah, for math he walked into a calculator app and for physics he was snooping in the physics engine of kerbal space program

From what I’ve heard/read. Animation vs Math wasn’t Alan’s idea, it was one of his team members. So he had to trust them that they know what they were doing, and according to an actual Oxford Math professor, who did a reaction video to Animation Vs Math, the math equations in the video are all correct and accurate

Fax bro

italy

True

​@@lcareoHey I'm italian

Fr

chemistry nerd over here lol, it would be amazing if they did. (just a suggestion though.)

Animation vs Chemistry would go crazy ngl

as a chemistry student i was going to request this too!

No way orange can live against a black hole 💀💀💀

breaking bad?

FOR REALLL

This is a beautiful work of art

the thing is that it isn't an alan becker animation no more, at least not only him. Its a team that works behind all of the animations in this channel

@@bunashud9793 Yup

sooo it evolved into a rendered sphere? WOAH 🤯🤯🤯

I don't know what you're talking about, i couldn't understand a thing.

Is that possible ?

I have huge respect for people who has anything to do with Physics as a career. Physics is extremely fascinating!

I counted the frames where orange walked 1.5 meters, he walked 1.5 meters in 12 frames, which meant he could walk 60m/s which is 6 times faster than Usain Bolt.(correct me if I'm wrong)

I am not a physics student, nor have I ever been.. but I understood the concepts for at least half of the video.. then it got confusing

I dont understand why anyone would dislike this, it's amazing.

I agree, I was just amazed, with my mouth opened, this animation, together with those concepts of Physic, It was an unique experience, imma save that video to show it to some people later... Its wonderfull

Eh, it isn't exactly "Calculated". Don't let those numbers fool you, it's far from accurate. But this is art, and in art, the proximation is more important than accuracy.

Indeed, I felt the same as you did man this was incredible

Somos 2 😄

So true😊

Good luck guy

noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooi hate the Chemistry

@@sgstaw5 ch3ch2ch2ch2ch2ch2ch3 go brrr

@@sgstaw5 I hate it too, but Alan will sure make it compelling and change your mind

All I remember about chemistry is most of it is basically addition. There's definitely more to it, but I don't remember anything past high school chemistry lmao.

@@main.ignisha All I remember from chemistry is me putting the wrong solution in stuff and the beaker exploded

Finally found this w comment

​@@sleppistickman5742.....

Interstellar was based on real physics, its a reference to CTCs, tho it is definitely a creative interpretation since no one knows what it's actually like

我也这么认为

Physics students will absolutely watch this for forever, I don't understand it, but maybe one day I will

I would watch this

How about creating a DNA?

​@@ayzekpie9432that's shown in this video

Animation vs Biology

Animation vs. Geometry would be great!

He literally showed what took me over 3 weeks memorise in 3 seconds

Acho que sou uma dessas pessoas...

You're right! But not me.

Physics is fun and cool. I've been learning by myself about it and I feel so good about the fact that I understand a lot of the concepts in this video.

Yea

Omg hi Mr Lawrence

can i get an extension Mr Lawrence

Sir Lawrence let me pass your class

mr lawerence i am a new student i am you

Hello Mr Lawrence I don't know who u r

Same here!

Same here

I think bro going to make a Vid : Animation vs. Chemistry

Calm down, there's a lot of fiction at the end...

​​@@Shanyae9I'd say it's educational until he enters the black hole.

whats next is most likely either gonna be chemistry or biology as those are the next two subjects in science that are this fascinating when delved into, but who knows, alan could easily surpise us with something we wouldnt have expected.

Since what's the "science" subject as we know it is ramified into both Physics and Chemistry (at least where I live), we can just wait for "Animation vs Chemistry"

next one will probably be chemistry if we are working in order of purity

chesmitry and they cook meth

Not a scientist, but the way I interpereted it was that the "ice" begins as only near-frictionless, but later transitions into a perfectly frictionless surface. Orange seems to have at least some friction, given the way they slow down after throwing the ball lasso. And when pulling the ball in the first time, an arrow in the opposite direction (possible representing friction?) appears. Whether Newton's law still allows this I can't really say. Maybe it's the angular momentum being transitioned to a purely forwards momentum after building up velocity, since the angular momentum is just coming from the force of Orange's arm alone?

I see the same problem. But the comment before me could have already answered it.

You're correct. It's impossible. The magnetism explanation also doesn't work as he's adding energy to the system without doing any work, and there are tons of issues with the black hole part obviously. It's a fun little video, but it's not a perfect explanation of physics.

@@aust2354 That's a fair point. (Newton's laws apply with or without friction.) Upon closer inspection there's a small arrow that shows mu = 0.1, which means there's technically a small amount of friction. So technically he could "lasso" himself across the ice.

the “Force by throwing the weight” is cancelled according to Newton’s 3rd Law, but Rotating the weight makes centrifugal force and its reaction(=-centripetal force). when he threw the rotating weight at “Specific time”, the angular momentum has transformed(A lot has been omitted, but as a result) as horizontal momentum to the surface made him go forward. If Orange rotate the weight, he starts spinning on the frictionless surface. So the “Specific time” should satisfy; 1. When Spinning Orange is Facing to Forward, 2. When Rotating Weight is at 90deg to Forward.

*Einstein

I love how time travel was explained as a causal loop

Nice got a pin

The most interesting thing about this is that it can be understood by anyone anywhere in the world

If you haven't seen Alan's other work, he does a LOT of wordless storytelling, especially in some of his more recent work like Animation vs Minecraft Season 3 and Animator vs Animation 6. The things he manages to convey are seriously awesome.

Sim/yeah😮😮😮

It's 16 minutes and 18 seconds to be exact 😊 .

Came for the animation, stayed for the existential questions. 😹

You can get up to about the 12:40 mark from educational RU-vid videos. I'm CompSci but I have an addiction to staying up late watching PBS Space Time videos which made this make a lot more sense.

So, you drop the hat in the video.

As someone who only got as far as a Bachelor's in physics, 11:33 is the boundary of my understanding. Maybe I should be watching PBS Space Time lmao

As someone who didnt understand what was going on, it looked cool.

As a high scool student, I've lost it after the 4:40 mark.😢

I just wish that phisics could be that simple, but great for baiting new folks to go to phisic class

@@sansgranie6164 nothing is as simple obviously but it gets the basic concepts across well enough and manages to spark interest

Perfect😊

Honestly, he should be featured in a deathbattle by Screwattack!

I think this is a aspect that all stick-figures have - rapid learning, self-improvement, and photographic memory. I personally head-canon that the AvA universe is where human imagination and concepts come to life and "imprint" into reality, explaining why random stick-figures, video game characters, phone apps, even cave art can turn alive. Due to this, since stick-figures are culturally seen as "badass" going by the thousands of "stick figure fighting" videos, the concept of a stick-figure is a badass by their nature, and a badass can learn concepts really quickly (such as mastering martial arts almost instantly after observing for a minute). Also explains why the physics dimension seems to work off of our *MODERN* understanding of physics, not a "more complicated" true life version - it's not actually the dimension of physics, its the dimension of humanities *understanding* and *concepts* of physics. Most of the higher end phyics stuff TSC had learnt would probably not even work, because humans don't know if Singularities, Tipler Cylinders, Manifolds, Worldsheets etc even exist aside from "well our current models could work or need to work with these in place." Also why the Math Dimension uses human Maths, not "real" math - mathmatics as we understand is a language we invented.

he got actual 200 IQ

@@sidratulmursalinbhasha2960 no

first edit: why is everyone getting mad at my comment? im just saying first, and plus, yes nobody cares about me saying first so what's your point

And?

nope, this is a cool comment though

yes actually, just try a physics question that asks to divide by zero

HAH

Me too, I love the intense music when Second went through spagettification process

AM I NOT THE ONLY ONE WHO REALIZED THA

He should make one about chemistry!

@@thatprogramer he probably will make one

@@Andersand6 prob... Anyway how's your day so far?

I think it’s just an interstellar reference

not once did he directly manipulate physics in this video lol not too sure what you're talking about my g

Up until now the strongest version was creative block that would destroy the Minecraft universe With this addition, he has become a sort of higher dimensional existance that can manipulate time and space and physic concepts as if they were literally toys

​@@youtuber-tg1puVery cool reference to our existence, dude. Very well "spoken".

@@djmewtwo6981no it’s the awakened version

ITS AMAZING

i liked ur video it was pretty good

thanks @@toki3204

thanks for your comment@@wizardsknowledge1138

are youe elso?wwi

school? String theory :D yes

I haven’t learned Doppler effect and physics of black holes, but luckily someone explained it to me

Good job man🎉🎉

The video feels like physics class. It starts out easy and suddenly it gets complicatedt

yeah but if you haven't learned them you won't understand anything

Symbolism Happens

Mavity!

more than that, it is the paracausal apple.

He looks handsome and clever with the cowboy hat

It's like Interstellar xD My first thought when I saw the beginning of the loop xD (If you don't get it, watch the movie, I ain't gonna spoil it.)

same, I just forget anything i learn especially cause of no interest

Brothers? 😨

just the oranges in this chat

im infiltrating the oranges

You have to watch Interstelar. It doesn't go as far as this animation did, but it sure gets pretty close.

How many interpretations of singularities is there...

I wanna study physics too😍

singularities aren't confirmed to exist their just theories.@@alphieum3703

@@alphieum3703 too many, trust me, toooo many (i'm physics student too)

Interstellar interpretation is canon according to neil de grasse tyson

1st

Scares and excites me that I see Alan Becker, out orange boi and the speed of light squared in the same animation

YESS

​@@bigfuze320the 'orange boi' is named The Second Coming

Yes

Ahah, I put your message into the translator, and the last “Physical” was translated as “physical education”...

Physics

ben ortaokul 2ye giden bir çocuğum.Daha çok korkutucu geldi.umarım değilidr xd

Truly a cinematic masterpiece

Bet you'll get better at physics bud

His name is the second coming not orange

We reached from simple child play kinematics to wave fronts, orbital physics and magnetism in like 6 mins. It was a journey tho !!

Su nombre es the second coming no naranja 😡

That’s only really if you care about AvA lore

@@Booda428 easier to just call him orange tbh

Thank Terkoiz too. He's the one who lead this.

I think he will release Animation vs. Chemistry :)

So Epic

@@hungmcsr8562 oh I can't wait for that :)))

Well, if Alan cut off the "the end" and RU-vid allowed 15 minutes on shorts, then it would be a perfect loop!

Once you see your future, your past, it started a loop already. Unless at the end, you decide to "loop out", then the loop will end.

Infinity

it was also completely justified, because time and space become each other in the space below the event horizon, it's a logical consequence of the path he took instead of "this story needs a grand conclusion, lets make it a time travel story now" that some tv shows do...

@@MrRiley2007 nah

This is so true.

Yeah, a loop with various differences every time. Which obviously means this isn't canon 😅

@@Marukanitel I mean, we are inside tsc dream

I’d say it’s more a time *fold* than a loop.

Oscars are cringe.

Award* not Oscars.

​@@LuisAngel-sb8xd yeah true instead of saying "Oscars" they should say "Award" like the guy on top of me

@@LuisAngel-sb8xd Actually oscars are for movies. This is also counted as a short movie so it nominates for oscar awards

@@ImTheOne_WhoAsked yall are going way too in depth with this, the film is good, that’s all I’m tryna say, calm down

Tooo be honest, this video has to violate some rules for entertainment, like how Orange goes faster than the speed of light.

Bro he just went from normal physics to theorical physics, there was no progression what so ever

@@chesterlai9444 You really dont get what he means? He means that the concepts of the physics became more difficult to understand as the video continued. Nobody talked about wether its just theories or real physics

@@chesterlai9444 why someone always Gotta be negative

i might be wrong but... at 7:18 how could he continue go front in the same speed as the space ship?

​@@user-vw6bd7bb5n Because in space there is as good as no resistance or friction. Lets assume the rocket didnt accelerate. That means that, while orange was on the rocket, the rocket and Orange himself experience the same velocitiy. When he let go of the rocket, he went on having the same speed as the rocket because (like I already said) in space there is most no resistance or friction.Things would change if the rocket was accelerating. Then Orange would stay with a nearly constant velocity when he let go of the rocket while the rocket itself is going faster over time

Go solve your differential equations lil bro.

@@j.a1905 go dive inside my pfp lol

"lil bro🤓"

Even just as someone in High School with Physics class this was amazing... Yes, I am a nerdy kid, but still

@@Yourmom082 "lil bro🤓" - 🤓

and probably one of the most high quality videogames humanity had ever seen. id be all for it, though its better if alan sticks to animations as making a videogame of this quality could lead to a rockstar games clone lol.

Alright. You will get a reply soon when it's done. Thanks for giving me the challange.

The videogame that comes closest to it that I know is Outer Wilds, wonderful game. Physics is always a wonderful subject if you are interested and ready to learn.

I agree that will help the quote on quote Gamer kids to learn something

GTA 8 :

And then the few minutes of string theory at the end

And to theoretical physics

​@@trbz_8745Да! Значит я был прав что это теория струн, ура!

Fr

He should do statistics next.

I think Chemestry's next

​@@Alexander99602 chemistry*

@@pokenath242 no, he said “chemistry’s” which means chemistry is