Apparat - Ash/Black Veil (Live) 

You looked for Apparat. I salute all of you! x

Perfect example of the differentiation between downloading a song & listening to it live.

Ich kann nur weinen, wenn ich dieses fantastisches Stück höre. Für die Ewigkeit.....yeahhhhhhh

That drummer was putting in WORK. The whole song was practically a fill.

Pure magic. The fact that this video has less than 200k views, makes everything even more special, as if it were a gem reserved for a few. Thank you Apparat

Ein Gänsehaut Lied wie vor elf Jahren mittlerweile schon... wie die zeit vergeht. Live und im Aufbau so überzeugend `WoW` Tolles Ding

My friend died yesterday and I listen such masterpiece for him🙏😔

DAMM THEY ARE SOO TIGHT. LOVE THAT DRUMMERRRR THOUGH.. WOW, LOVE the vocals, the strings, the keyboards, literally I have played this everyday. Trancends time, my soul aches when I listen to this.. The most BEAUTIFUL MUSIC that I have ever listened to. EVER.

I think this is my favourite video on RU-vid. People who are awesome at what they do, massively into what they’re producing and working in such harmony to make a fantastic piece of music. Can’t wait to see Apparat on tour in a couple of months.

This is soo fucking beautiful. Literraly i cried when i saw this video.

today is September 19th Damn 9 year old video. love this song

Un morceau de toute beauté qui vous émeut au plus profond de vous !!💖✨

this was actually very pleasant for an on stage performance, I did not expect that studio quality ... my walls are melting

my fav song in this life ..

My favorite song ever. Hope to see you one day

Incredible to find that artists are still alive, thriving and inspiring. Maybe in future study of artists the awaking that the end was much farther than we felt and the future was ours for the taking sets in. Tomorrow is ours. Not theirs. What are YOU going to do???

Pure sorcery. They are magicians, epic just epic.

A dedicated set of people, creating top notch music. Making you feel each beat and strand of music that there is. Best ever heard!

Oh, I swear I saw her right out there Caught a glimpse of her grace, Slightly misplaced. She's around Without audible sound Covers the mood with a gloom, She's alone in the room ...And the walls are melting. Today time froze And I will need a cause To carry on on my own The walls are melting The walls are melting

sacha your voice gives me peace

cuantos recuerdos con esta canción, definitivamente la música es lo mejor que puede existir. es lamentable que en estos tiempos todo sea tan sintético y vacío.

Te admiro tanto sascha .Eres mi ídolo músical .Como me gustaría conocerte y hablar sobre música .Un saludo desde mallorca .

Der Drumer war mal mein Schlagzeuglehrer... EIN GOTT!

The most beautiful piece of music I have heard in many years

Chaque moment difficile de ma vie est accompagne de se video et le calme revient a linterieur de moi merci pour se 7 minutes magistral

Шедевр на века

Captivating melody, a little melancholy, but full of passion and emotion. AMAZING!!!

I think is the best direct ever made...Thanks a lot!!!!

My love inside all the notes of thise composition Sasha i hope that your life vill be long and full of the inspiration. With love from Moscow

impeccable timing, so tight!!!

Might be the best live performance I've ever seen. Cheers.

Escuchar esto es como volar... Tocar esta musica debe ser algo más aun ...

Stunning beyond words.

Art of Flight of my Mind ❤

Completamente fascinado con esta cancion .Estoy enamorado de sylvia eugenia pero vive aen alicante .

How is it possible I didn't know Apparat before ?!!! This music enters the very closed circle of musicians I could listen over and over. I put Apparat on my top ten with this single song. In my musical heart, Apparat is close to Pink Floyd, Mazzy Star, Radiohead (obviously), Sigur Ròs, Lisa Gerrard and a few more less known (Mathilde Renault, The Nits)...

This Song is changing my life... Thank You

See this performed live in Budapest with my girlfriend... Amazing!

MAGICIANS WITHOUT A DOUBT.

♾️❤️from🇵🇱

WOUAHOU !!!!!!!!!!! emotion !!! music and extasy... thanks APPARAT

космос!!!!!!!!!!!

Still in love with this ❤️

Einfach nur PERFEKT!!! Das sind richtige Künstler! WOW!

Don't know why but this song talks to me. And it is talking about a witch's death in the most beautiful way ever.

fantastic......

Juro que la vi allá fuera.. alcancé a ver de reojo su gracia, aunque un poco desenfocada. Y es que ella está por doquiera, sin pronunciar ninguna palabra audible. Cubre su tristeza en la oscuridad, en su refugio de soledad. Las paredes se están derritiendo... El día de hoy es congelante; creo que necesitaré una razón para seguir adelante, sin nadie alrededor. Las paredes se están derritiendo... las paredes se están derritiendo... las paredes se están derritiendo... las paredes se están derritiendo... las paredes se están derritiendo... Las paredes se están derritiendo.

I came here to listen to the album version and found this version. NOT SORRY. I'M IN TEARS. :(

Autentica musica progresiva, vamos los Pink Floyds de sigloXXI, con un gran dosis interpretativa y fuerza renovada

Voice of an angel

enjoyed alot !

Merveille...

love!

НА ВСЕГДА!!!!!!!!!!!!

ich liebe diesen song !!!!! danke......

Absolutely genius!

love it.

❤❤❤❤

wow!!

Exquisite music. Amazing!!!

Art. No more words needed!

magistral!

SOOOOO GEIL!!!

Grandiose ! Purement génial.

No words...Simply in love,amazing...

Beautiful discovery!

magicians

maravillosa fusion de sonidos, es perfecta!!

Amazing!!!

Very Gooood! Its like a Freefall flight!!

a masterpiece !

Llevo años escuchándola y siempre me gusta. Gracias.

Magique 😍❤️

only 4 comments...I must count for the other 15,577 views...wouldn't oubt it...love it

No words 💗💗

this is song magic and ı found new :) im sorry

Impresionante canción.

Amazing 😍😍

Immer und immer wieder...

Maravilloso!!

... brutal!!! cheers.

#1!!!

Necesito escucharla de vez en cuando, me inspira.

beautiful

I thought the album version was good... wow. Just wow.

Very cool...your music is called " GILA "in indonesian language,,I am enjoying it,,thanks.

Amazing

Merci BB 🙏 Je t'ai fait découvrir Apparat ... Mais maintenant ... Quand je l'écoute 🎶 💎 🤩 Je pense à TOI 😍 À NOUS 💞 😘

This song must be so fun to play! I love it so much!

The only thing wrong with this wonderful piece of music is that it lasts just over 7 minutes.... It could've lasted 17 minutes for me.

💚

awesome

Damn... This is good!

Superbe !

Brillant

WOOOOOOW

Capolavoro.... Spettacolo...sembra Yann tiersen elettronico

super

He conocido una mujer fascinante que se llama sylvia eugenia y es preciosa y muy inteligente prro vive en alucante .Es preciosa .Yo a multimar no vuelvo con salvador mama tiraneta .

Удаляйте Ютуб, лучшего не будет больше никогда после этой композиции