Poor Lady? I see absolutely nothing poor about this woman, although coming into this video fresh I would not dare insert myself into the era in which this happened. As we were not alive to experience the political turmoil of the era. Whether or not she deserved to be executed for trying to what appears to be overthrowing the sitting government at the time. She accepted the consequences fully and with great dignity. Considering the time. There were a lot more brutal methods of execution available. The system in which she died under indeed was corrupt, but I don't see anything poor about her she had a lot more strength than people might give her based on a movie's interpretation.
En Estados Unidos tenemos la inyección letal y la silla eléctrica hasta hace 3 días y en Inglaterra hay cadena perpetua.Enriqie Vlll le cortana la cabeza a sus mujeres .En España nunca se mató a una Reina y menos con un hacha como si fuera un árbol.
I don't know why, but I am very interested in the history of Spain, Portugal and the colonization of South America by these two countries(even though I'm despise colonialism and racism as such), maybe because of my Asperger Syndrome, I am attracted to the Iberian culture :-) How did Marian Pineda deserve her fate that she was sentenced to death in such a way? Why do the Spaniards admire her today?
@@PawelK198604 We must be twins, my friend, since I too have Asperger's syndrome. Mariana Pineda was an outspoken person who supported democratic reforms and social justice issues, along with that of her late husband, who was also a Freemason. Both read various writings of Simon Bolivar, American Federalist Papers by Thomas Payne, Jefferson, Franklin, etc on his treatises on liberty and equality and tried their best to introduce such practices in Spain. After her husband died, Mariana continued to carry on his work and shared her views with like-minded people, dissolving the feudal caste system, granting women's rights (including the right to vote, run for public office), Gypsy and Basque recognition, religious freedom among the Jewish and Moorish communities under democratic rule. The ruling monarchy viewed such ideals as radical nationalism and therefore a threat to the status quo. The old school conservatives feared the likes of Pineda's ideology would cause social dissent and unrest, resulting in the destruction of the monarchy in almost the same way as it did in France and put the Church and its governing representatives at risk during their revolution and Reign of Terror 1789-1799. They didn't want a repetitive bloody coup d'etat of that sort done in their country. Pineda was well aware of the consequences of her words and actions and was willing to give her life to such a cause if need be. She was a marked woman for speaking her mind in a time when women were deemed as mere chattel by being meek and obedient to their husbands, parents, etc Some might have called her callous and a traitor because of this, but Spain's views have changed in such a way people like Mariana would be proud of and yet like other newly independent countries, still have a long ways to go, however. I hope this helps answer your question...If you wish to chat further, you can also send me an email printangel@aol.com
@@PawelK198604Mariana Pineda formaba parte del movimiento liberal, que deseaba para España una monarquía parlamentaria como la inglesa, una democracia. Fernando VII, el rey de entonces, era un rey absoluto que abolió la Constitución. Mariana encargó el bordado de una bandera liberal, y, al ser descubierta, fue detenida y condenada a muerte por traición. Lo que la hace admirable es que le ofrecieron varias veces la vida y la libertad a cambio de delatar a los liberales que conocía, y se negó a ello siempre. Siempre se la admiró en España por eso.
She is young and beautiful. Must be terrifying walking up to the garrote, knowing that in just a minute you will take your last breaths on this world. She was very composed and handled it very well I thought.
What a lot of faffing about, and what a lot of psychological torture for the condemned. A skilled execution in Britain took less than 20 seconds, in skilled hands. 7 was the record.
matismf there's no justification for such an awful method of execution and Franco was a fascist who overthrew the legally elected government. So he's hardly the good guy.
She killed no one. She was found guilty of a liberalism conspiracy which, notably, included the rights of women. She refused to disavow her beliefs and got strangled for it. Dangerous for women to have equality or liberated notions back in 1831.
She didn't kill anyone, but was involved in helping a liberal prisoner escape. She was offered a chance to live by snitching on her cohorts, but refused to do it.
Ximena G "Por qué los comentarios son en ingles si el video esta en español?" Por la misma razón que los comentarios son en español cuando los videos son en inglés.
Porque a los anglos les encanta resaltar todo lo oscuro de la historia de España. Sin reparar en que no hay nada más oscuro que su historia. Ya sabemos que son expertos en exagerar sus victorias y esconder sus derrotas y sus miserias.
Garrote. Se sujetaba el cuello con un aro que se hacía girar al mismo tiempo que un tornillo rompía las cervicales. Se suponía que era rápido, pero había reos que tardaban hasta veinte minutos en morir, y otros se ahogaban en su propia sangre.
Basically snaps your neck and crushes the windpipe. A bit like hanging except you sometime strangle to death if your neck doesn't snap when you first drop.
The Garotte, an inhumane way of killing someone, it wasn't as quick, and clean as this film shows, it slowly compressed the neck, slowly crushing the throat and neck of the condemned , who met a hideous demise.
No es hipocresía, la condenó la ley del hombre, la ley de Dios la considera su hija y le ofrece su apoyo hasta el final. Ahí la Iglesia no podía evitar la muerte.
It is hypocrasy, since the church always sided with the absolutist rulers. They protected each other and innocent people seeking freedom paid the price
I dont either. She was executed for political treason and conspiracy. The monarchy's of Europe did not tolerate other liberal opinions, and that is why the 1848 revolutions were also put down. It is Spain very conservative and the inquisition was still active until 1834.
sedition and to take part in a liberal conspiracy. widow and mother of two youngsters, she had been delacted for having just embroided the words law, freedom and equality on a flag and accused of taking part into a liberal conspiracy... since she had refused to denounce any supposed accomplice she was put to death
Era un símbolo de luto y entonces el luto por una persona ejecutada por motivos políticos era un desafío a la autoridad. Demostraban su respeto a Mariana y su desprecio a los verdugos.
It was the priests who addicted the whole of China to opium ... It was the priests who dropped the two atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki ... The priests are the owners of the world drug business ... The priests promote Woodstock gang bang worldwide ... They are the "idols" of young people who follow them devotedly in the service of God ... In fact, the convents are full of young people eager for sacred music, modesty, virtues and prayers ... The priests run the arms industries, all revolutionary movements and terrorist organizations ... Yes, priests are the owners and agents of the lucrative industries of pornography, pedophilia, organ trafficking, the white slave trade ... Priests rule in Soros, Rothschild, Rockefeller, Ford, etc., they also rule the ONU, parliaments, judicial courts, armed forces around the world and determine wars and crises... Everything in the name of God... for the happines of demons! All right... I understand!
@@elbertderf803 For example, it is not because a father is bad that all fathers are bad, nor that, it will give us the right to condemn paternity. The "deliberate attempts at sarcasm" are not admissions of begrudge, but were a direct reaction to what you deliberately imply in your original placement.
Execusion de mariana pineda en la ciudad de granada ,,,,una maravilla de himajenes de uno de esos barrios la catedral ,,,la audiencia probincial ,,calle de elvira y los paisajes sublimes de los monumentos de la alhambra,,,subida en un caballo blanco ,,,camino de la muerte ,,,y todo por una cospirasion ,,,y una bandera republicana ,,,granada la recuerda , en una centrica plaza con su nombre con una bella estastua donde a quedado inmortalisada ,,,para siempre ,,,,antonio ,,,preguntaban un mensajero que sinifica los crespones negros o telas que dejaban caer en los balcones ,,,todo,,, son el luto por aquellos que mueren ,la tristesa de aquellos que no pueden hablar,,,por el miedo y el rencor andalucia y casi toda españa en esos años era muy de mantillas negras ,,,, la negrura de la muerte,,,,y en los cantes andaluces esta precentes en sus rrimas,,,,los hecos de la tierra,,,peteneras ,,,,soleares ,,,martinetes ,,,los cantes de la tierra y para quien preguntan sobre crespones negros,,,,descubran otra gran obra de ferderico garcia lorca,,,la casa de bernarda alva y veran todas las mujeres de la casa de luto por la muerte de padre de familia ,,,silencio y luto en el corazon ,,,el negro ,,,,la oscurida,,,el de la muerte,,,antonio ,,,,,
@@manchego6610 un burrito ...tan maravilloso que párese un caballo ....y confusión ..y le contesto a esa persona que me dice lo de mi ortografía .......primero los nervios de redactar , en pocos minutos en el pensamiento ...segundo en mi niñez , ni escuelas. Ustedes lo tienen todo ..y ensima , se burlan de una persona mayor ...ni escuela ni comida ....usted tan listo , vivira ,a cuerpo de rey ....yo no ...con ella le quiero decir la edad que tengo , sin estudio de nada ....si he escrito este , algo , impecable para mí ,a sido por haber victo , la serie , y recordar mi tierra ....dejen por favor las críticas y sehan ma benévolos....
@@antonioalvarezberbel5328 Oiga, que yo no me burlo de nada. Que me limito a decirle que va montada en un burro y no en un caballo, que con la edad que dice usted que tiene, debía distinguir entre un animal y otro.
@@franciscosanchez7474Vengan a Uruguay y observen los crimenes barbaros que hay y las penas son ridiculas. Después opinen si es necesario o no la pena de muerte. Saludos
Nesesito una explicación:Es una verdadera historia?Quien era Mariana Pineda?Y por qué le ejecutaron?Disculpe,no soy Español y por eso no conozco estos temas. Era una rebelde?No creo que era una asesina,porque se ve que la gente le simpatiza....
Las cosas se han de entender dentro de la época en la, que están, no defiendo la pena de muerte porque creo que sólo hay uno que da la vida y la puede quitar Pero humanamente hay gente que se la merece. Terroristas por ejemplo, por ideas políticas si no han causado muertes no.
ella no era terrorista, ayudo a huir a un rebelde, pero en realidad eran fieles al gobierno legitimo y la constitución. El rey regreso a espana con ayuda de los franceses y lo jodio todo
@@brianrodney5202 todos los que la conocieron coinciden en que Mariana Pineda era una mujer hermosa. Aunque le faltara un incisivo superior. Pero ella hubiera preferido morir a prostituirse con Fernando VII.
Recuerdo que ví esta serie cuando era niña, pero incompleta y por lo tanto no comprendí por que la iban a ejecutar. Después indagando supe que fue por una (a mi parecer), estupidez injustificada. Por otro lado creo que la serie está muy bien hecha, con una fotografía maravillosa y escenarios naturales y exteriores increíbles y hermosos.
