Are Milk and Fruit Juice Healthy Drinks for Kids?

Подписаться 448 тыс.

Просмотров 30 тыс.

50% 1

To start comparing quotes and simplify insurance-buying check out Policygenius: policygenius.c... Thanks to Policygenius for sponsoring this video!
Is there such a thing as a healthful beverage? All other mammals consume only two liquids over the course of their lives: breast milk and water. The evidence for telling humans that some beverages are necessary and that others should be avoided isn’t nearly as clear as many believe.
Other HCT episodes:
CBD and Mental Health: • Does CBD Improve Menta...
Economic Disparities and Breathing Disparities: • Socioeconomic Disparit...
Be sure to check out our podcast!
• Podcast
Other Healthcare Triage Links:
1. Support the channel on Patreon: vid.io/xqXr
2. Check out our Facebook page: goo.gl/LnOq5z
3. We still have merchandise available at www.hctmerch.com
4. Aaron's book "The Bad Food Bible: How and Why to Eat Sinfully" is available wherever books are sold, such as Amazon: amzn.to/2hGvhKw
Credits:
Aaron Carroll -- Writer
Meredith Danko - Social Media
Tiffany Doherty -- Writer and Script Editor
John Green -- Executive Producer
Stan Muller -- Director, Producer
Mark Olsen - Art Director, Producer
#healthcaretriage #Milk #Nutrition

Опубликовано:

13 сен 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 199

@healthcaretriage 3 года назад

To start comparing quotes and simplify insurance-buying, check out Policygenius: policygenius.com/healthcaretriage. Thanks to Policygenius for sponsoring this video!

@dkoda840 3 года назад

Hello is it possible you can puts links to any documents or studies you cite in the video? Please and thank you.

@scotthendricks5665 3 года назад

IT'S JUST FLAT SODA

@jjcarvin4755 3 года назад

since the rule becomes no leaving the house until the homework gets done when summer homework also gets given out when will these children get vitamin D the people who are against milk are for big pharma giving out supplements that usually are faker then donald trumps hair i am going with that one because i forgot the one i used to use before trump became president my vitamin D got down to 7 since i stopped drinking milk (to much of a pain to add chocolate and i am unable to drink it plain)

@wezul 3 года назад

"You can have it if you want it, but don't be under any illusion that you need it." - PERFECT. *chef's kiss*

@ahorrell 3 года назад

One of my favourite things about this channel (and one of the reasons that this is one of my favourite channels) is that he doesn't just uncritically cite 'studies' as facts. He recognises that there's effectively a hierarchy of research methodologies, and that some methodologies have shortcomings that SHOULD be noted. Good stuff, doc!

@Nicksonian 2 года назад

It’s funny how some RU-vid nutrition gurus will say, “this study kinda looks like crap, but it proves everything I say so it must be true.”

@stevencaruso825 3 года назад

"I can't imagine eating cereal without milk," surely a nod to John Green and his water-cereal ways

@jonnycarlo 3 года назад

@katiegreenwood3132 3 года назад

@laurakemp5979 3 года назад

@manthanpakhawala6365 3 года назад

Wanted to type the comment as soon as I heard it in the video

@megeles 3 года назад

Water in his cereal? No wonder he struggles with nihilism.

@war5561 3 года назад

My doctor dad never let us have juice growing up and I can still hear him in my head ‘grumble grumble it’s just sugar water!’ But he was right.. grumble grumble 😂

@chrisalan5610 3 года назад

I've heard that juice was fine because it had "healthy" sugars my whole life, I'm glad that it's getting called out now

@ClayMastah344 3 года назад

I’m sure if you get actual non gmo fruit and juice it that you’ll be good to go, it’s when the companies start adding fructose and dye and extra sugar that it goes to hell.

@HSKCHER 3 года назад

@@ClayMastah344 with all due respect, you replying this after watching this video shows that you are falling in all of the pitfalls healthcare triage is warning against. (plus what do gmo's have to do with anything? Cmon you're better than this)

@namehere4954 3 года назад

It is healthy sugar but becomes unhealthy because phytonutrients are stripped away. When you eat whole fruit, if there is excess sugar, it will bind to phytonutrients and pass through the body. There was a study done where folks were fed 22 servings vegetables and 22 servings fruit DAILY with no adverse effects including no weight gain. There's another study done that shows type 2 diabetics shouldn't limit fruit because it doesn't adversely affect them as well because phytonutrients bind to excess sugar and pass it through the body. The food product closest to the source is usually healthiest and the refinement of foods make them unhealthy.

@jjcarvin4755 3 года назад

better then those stupid vitamin supplements and honestly drinking more milk would have made it so i never almost slammed my head against the dresser my vitamin D level got down to 7 by the time i got it checked luckily nothing showed up as anything in the MRI i got at 23 but the dizziness happened around fifteen years old

@chrisalan5610 3 года назад

@@namehere4954 could you cite that study? If it's legit I'd like to read it, but as far as I know sugar is harmful in excess for a variety of reasons. Not just weight gain because of the calories, but also an increased chance of heart disease, diabetes, etc. There is no "healthy" sugar because no matter what the source is they have a high caloric value, could cause disease, and do little for you other than give you calories. Sure, fiber and other nutrients from fruits are good, but you can get those from other sources. You shouldn't think fruit is always healthy just because it's healthier than candy, you can get pretty fat off bananas

@zizkazenit7885 3 года назад

Your advice, “treat all calorie laden beverages as you would alcohol” has improved my diet a lot

@Ensorcle 3 года назад

Still one of the best places on the internet to receive helpfully presented and summarized healthcare news. And I met Dr. Carol at a conference! Just as down to earth and kind as he appears in the videos.

@DutchLabrat 3 года назад

Historically milk got labeled healthy back when animal protein and fat were rare in the diet of the urban poor. It made sense then to subsidies and promote more milk in the diet, it was a cheap way to prevent malnutrition. Maybe there are places in the world where this is still true but not in the Western world.

@namehere4954 3 года назад

No. Milk was a byproduct of the beer industry. Cows were brought into cities to eat spent grains from beer production. They milked the cows and gave the milk to infants who's mother's couldn't breastfeed. This lead to a 40% infant mortality rate which then lead to pasteurization. In the 1930s/40s the dairy lobby (the oldest & most effective lobby group) pushed congress to get their product into schools. It was then marketed to folks as if we were drinking it since the beginning of time when in fact we haven't. This summation is from Milk: Nature's Perfect Food by Melanie DuPuis. Also, ALL plants have protein so people aren't really ever protein deficient unless they're literally starving to death. Plant protein is superior to animal protein as it comes bundled with phytonutrients.

@DutchLabrat 3 года назад

@@namehere4954 : Is even anything in that blather true? :D

@namehere4954 3 года назад

@@DutchLabrat referenced a source for you. Go educate yourself bruh.

@lizmerrick6883 3 года назад

@@DutchLabrat It is. My dad used to work for General Mills. The dairy lobby is super powerful. Children were especially targeted, but there was a huge campaign for milk drinking among adults as a health food. But most adults have trouble processing more than a small amount of milk. I don't know if they still do this but the government used to buy up and store large amounts of powdered milk. There was some idea they'd be used in an emergency but all went bad. Also you'll notice plant based milks in the US are now called 'Almond Beverage' or 'Oat Beverage' because of the Dairy Industry.

@AngelaMerici12 3 года назад

@@lizmerrick6883 Yeah, because is not dairy. And is not milk. Those things are as processed as any other thing you buy in a box.

@mtadd 3 года назад

I was drinking 2 liters of juice a day thinking it'd be healthy...when I got my blood work done, my doctor thought I was at risk of pancreatic failure.

@xinic5 3 года назад

Nice

@tomisaacson2762 3 года назад

I used to drink a lot of milk. Until I realized it was giving me acne. Anytime I have dairy I can expect I'll breakout sometime soon.

@KillCoMentalMusings 3 года назад

I feel a lot of what is happening now is older giant industries don't want to change for the more informed consumers. The industry selling cows milk doesn't want people to stop drinking it, even though it also is used in making cheese and yogurts. This can be seen in everything from how our electricity and gas are being produced (into possibly solar & hydrogen options) and in the meat industry where new alternatives options will eventually replace the mass slaughtering of animals. The hope is science and education will begin to change what used to be seen as normal in the future, but people are really going to have to demand and support the smaller growing options first.

@junipertree2601 3 года назад

If my kids are having a unusually light breakfast, I add in a cup of milk to make sure they are getting protein and fat to stay satiated. They are extremely active and on the lean side so it suits our health goals. If you treat it like part of a meal, rather than a freebie I think giving milk is fine. I dont do juice because it's expensive and I have no self control with it haha

@Mike-. 3 года назад

Have you done an analysis of heavy metals in baby foods? If not, can you?? Thanks!

@gwvaio 3 года назад

Water, got it

@AmDizzle40 3 года назад

Straight mic drop at the end I love it!

@cheydinal5401 Год назад

It's always important to remember that bread, pasta, rice, even corn-based food ( *but not potatoes* ) all have tons of protein as well, and actually at basically the exact carbs/protein ratio that you're supposed to get them at Now, of course there's somewhat different proteins in meat/milk compared to plant-based food, but in terms of just total protein those foods that are typically considered to be basically pure carbon have a surprisingly large amount of that already

@scotthendricks5665 3 года назад

How do we make table sugar? We basically juice cane or beets and remove the water. It's just sugar.

@talideon 3 года назад

About the only reasonable argument that can be made is around vitamin D, and that's only because above a certain latitude, people are generally chronically deficient in it anyway.

@acasccseea4434 3 года назад

Cite your study that shows people are chronically deficient. I'm sure geography plays a massive role in it.

@ThaZapa 3 года назад

@@acasccseea4434 His comment literally says "above a certain latitude".

@talideon 3 года назад

@@acasccseea4434 Oh, come on! Are you for real?! Most of Europe deals with some form of vitamin D deficiency. You want a study? Fine. Two seconds in Google will give you this: pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22883239/ I'll let you put in a few seconds typing some keywords into a search engine if you want more. There's plenty. Above a the latitude of around Madrid in the northern hemisphere, it becomes acutely difficult to synthesise vitamin D for much of the year. It's part of the reason why historical populations that far north are so pale, and why those of darker complexions who live there have particularly acute issues with vitamin D synthesis. This is one of those things in science that isn't even remotely a debate.

@asier_getxo 3 года назад

@@talideon and yet these countries are among the countries with the highest milk consumption... If not enough sun, supplementation is how it should be dealt. You have to drink way too much milk for it to be enough.

@talideon 3 года назад

@@asier_getxo I think you overestimate how much vitamin D you can actually get from milk. Oh, it certainly helps, but it's not enough to cover what people should have. For that, you need exposure to sun for enough of the year and/or supplementation of some kind. Not to mention the fact that we spend so much of our time indoors these days, which makes the problem even worse: if milk had been enough to cope with the deficit in the past, it no longer is

@cbpd89 2 года назад

I think I'd be pretty hard pressed (pun intended!) to eat 6 oranges in one sitting, but one glass of orange juice is made from 3 or more oranges and I can easily drink 2 glasses of orange juice. So I'd be getting all the calories and sugar, none of the fiber, and I don't feel full so I eat more other stuff. Eat your calories instead of drinking them and you are less likely to over indulge.

@ThienTruong-iy5ix 2 года назад

I freaking love the sass doctor Aaron Carroll has in this video.

@BrianHutzellMusic 2 года назад

0:53 "...poured over documents..." I see what you did there!

@jaguar36 3 года назад

Fruit = Healthy, Juice = Not healthy. Does that mean whatever is left after the pressing is some super food?

@lizmerrick6883 3 года назад

Its mostly due to how the sugar hits you. There are vitamins in juice but they're counteracted by the huge spike in blood sugar. Plus you end up consuming more (it takes several apples to make the juice in one cup.) Fruit has not only the vitamins, but fiber and more phytochemicals. Plus the sugar is introduced into your blood stream at a slower rate which is less taxing on your system.

@bramvanduijn8086 2 года назад

Define super food. What does food do that super food does better? Food is stuff you can eat to get calories, the requirement for specific micronutrients is entirely secondary. Does that mean super food has more calories? On the other hand, if you insist it is about the trivial goal of micronutrients then you still need to prove that in that case more is better. I'd say that there are clear micronutrient examples where more is worse. Like fat-soluble vitamins, they quickly become poisonous.

@Red_Neck 3 года назад

One advantage of milk is that you don't need to eat and drink separately.

@mattwodziak1750 3 года назад

You forgot the fact that when you have kids, alcohol is recommended to maintain sanity. In moderation of course. Everything in moderation. Even moderation.

@paxundpeace9970 3 года назад

Be moderate in your recommendations. Even a moderate about of Heroin makes you addicted this is even true for many opiods taken longer then recommended.

@bramvanduijn8086 2 года назад

@@paxundpeace9970 What makes you think heroin is not an opioid?

@JocelynMlynarz 3 года назад

How about applesauce (the kind with no added sugar) ? I don't know about the US, but in France it's quite a popular alternative to fruits for kids...

@hawleyrigsby3123 2 года назад

Better than juice because the fibre is retained, but packaged sauce may be heavily heat treated to increase shelf life, so once the kids have teeth, better to provide apple slices

@cheydinal5401 Год назад

But fruit juice has potassium (unlike soda), which almost everyone gets way too little off, some even less than others. So it's not just empty calories, but I agree that vegetbles have a much better sugar/potassium ratio, and even whole fruits are better for you because dietary fiber is also anti-inflammatory, and the dietary limits in whole fruits calory consumption more by filling up the stomach and intestines more than juice does I'd say, much better to drink fruit juice than soda, but the high sugar still makes it something that should be a treat, like candy

@migrastilnaturalmigrainesu7897 3 года назад

I was just talking about all the sugars in fruit! Thanks for this.

@benzost920 3 года назад

What?! No mention of a nice hot cup of robuts black coffee for kids to kick off their day at kindergarten? And don't forget that a nice vodka martini can potentially save a kid's life if they drink a methanol-containing cleaning fluid through enzyme inhibition (if I'm remembering my old biology class material correctly, that is).

@davidwright7193 2 года назад

You're right about the treatment for methanol poisoning. Alcohol dehydrogenase shows a high preference for ethanol over methanol. The idea is to prevent methanol being "detoxified" by ADH producing the very toxic formaldehyde for long enough that it is cleared by the kidneys instead.

@jankosakotic7003 3 года назад

Yes

@GoneZombie 3 года назад

I use the Patches O'Houlihan Criterion for choosing beverages: It's STERILE, and I LIKE THE TASTE!

@harshbarj 3 года назад

Without watching. As with anything, it's about moderation. Even so called "unhealthy" foods are fine in moderation. So a Big Mac a month is not going to be a problem. A Big Mac a day, Ya, problem. Now, off to the video!

@harshbarj 3 года назад

Nailed it!

@paxundpeace9970 3 года назад

Glad to be back.

@mikelberke8239 3 года назад

Making a blanket statement that the majority of children are getting enough protein is super frustrating. It turns off the idea that we ought to see what the general levels are depending on individual circumstances and adjust the nutritional needs to fit the needs of the Individual.

@tomisaacson2762 3 года назад

He's talking about studies done at a population level to discuss GENERAL recommendations. If you want your kid to get individualized nutrition advice, you've come to the wrong place. Do you go to videos about epidemiology and get frustrated and say, "Making a blanket statement that the majority of people with diabetes ought to have their A1C checked every one to two years is super frustrating. It turns off the idea that we ought to make individualized decisions based on individual circumstances"? We know! That's why they're called GENERAL recommendations. That's not what "blanket statement" means. Here's an example of a blanket statement: all people who get frustrated that general recommendations are not individualized are morons. See. That's a blanket statement.

@bramvanduijn8086 2 года назад

The key word is "majority". That makes it not a blanket statement.

@billyb6001 Год назад

Except coffee

@paxundpeace9970 3 года назад

4:25 and we aren't even at the point of arguments that milk is unhealthy because of the sugar and fat content.

@loganprichard1439 3 года назад

Maybe because those are wrong based on how satiating milk

@SudaNIm103 2 года назад

If only there was something we could add to water to make it more palatable‽

@jeffwalther 3 года назад

This was mind blowing!

@Bigandrewm 3 года назад

But, but . . . but what about my extra-healthy Sunny D? It's not real juice therefore it's healthier!!!

@djhero0071 3 года назад

So I’ve got a question. Do other nations like in Europe or Asia have the relationship America has with milk and dairy in general? Because I feel like most of the milk propaganda can be traced back to dairy farmers lobbying Congress to help advertise milk at a time people were drinking less, when it’s nowhere near as healthy as they, the doctors, the advertisers, and so many other groups said it is. I wonder if any other countries have experienced something like this. Personally, I like milk but I know that I have to switch to an alternative at some point because cow milk is by far the worst milk for the environment but also knowing I’ve been lied to about it’s health benefits ever since I was a kid helps too.

@asier_getxo 3 года назад

Nah, I'd say its even worse in some european countries (netherlands, sweden, france...). Some french supermarkets have literally a third of their shelves just for dairy products.

@steveh46 3 года назад

@@asier_getxo When I lived in France, admittedly a long, long time ago, milk was not a big deal at all. Cheeses are a very big deal and rightfully so.

@asier_getxo 3 года назад

@@steveh46 they asked milked and dairy in general, and I purposely wrote dairy. Honestly, I have not a clear understanding of us relationship to milk and dairy beyond Americans I know and culture (movies, TV...), which is arguably a lot. But as far as I can see, the milk is as present in France as in the US. Typical in every breakfast and many times for dinner too. And overall French are and were obsessed with dairy, and not just cheese lol. They have yogurts as desert after most meals. And I was born, raised and live 100 km from France, studied for 15 years in a French school, and have been to the country countless times and for long periods. So I know what I talk about. In Spain if you want weird yoghurt for example, you go to French supermarkets here. Cause they're the ones who have most of them.

@namehere4954 3 года назад

90% of Asians, 20% white Europeans (68% of the world total) are lactose intolerant. Most cultures have traditionally used milk to make products, not drink it ravenously like Americans which yes, was born out of marketing. Here's a brief history: Milk was a byproduct of the beer industry. Cows were brought into cities to eat spent grains from beer production. They milked the cows and gave the milk to infants who's mother's couldn't breastfeed. This lead to a 40% infant mortality rate which then lead to pasteurization. In the 1930s/40s the dairy lobby (the oldest & most effective lobby group) pushed congress to get their product into schools. It was then marketed to folks as if we were drinking it since the beginning of time when in fact we haven't. For more explanation look to the book - Milk: Nature's Perfect Food by Melanie DuPuis - it is comprehensive history of milk.

@Adderkleet 3 года назад

Ireland had pro-milk ads on TV. "Them bones, them bones need - calcium!" very catchy song.

@VampireSquirrel 3 года назад

Didn't you tell us coffee was healthy before?

@gyozakeynsianism 3 года назад

He didn't say it was an important part of a balanced diet, that's for sure.

@Magnulus76 3 года назад

No, they are only marginally healthier than soda pop. There are better sources of calcium than milk. Two traditionally made corn tortillas have almost a quarter of your RDA of calcium, more or less the same as a cup of milk. A tablepsoon of blackstrap molasses has a third the RDA.

@paxundpeace9970 3 года назад

Classic Aaron Carrol video.

@dtaylor4200 3 года назад

Why would it be recommended to drink the milk of a different animal?

@Carlos-zs1zj 3 года назад

Exactly!

@aliaj8497 3 года назад

Is there an easy way to access the studies cited?

@hawleyrigsby3123 2 года назад

They will be listed as the references for the recommendations. You’ll just need to locate the recommendations on the organization’s website and the hope that the papers are open access

@Matt-wc2mf 3 года назад

"We'd never tolerate soda being advertised as healthy" Heh... Have you seen all these ads for sodas saying they're made with "real sugar"?... Refined sugar is healthy now!

@evensong3356 2 года назад

To be fair thats less for health (unless you are one of those people that think natural = better) and more for taste as natural real sugar based sugars do usually taste way better then traditional sodas.

@kemitchell 3 года назад

Don't mammals also consume fruit juice, by eating juicy fruits?

@rahsf2012 3 года назад

Such a good question! Yes, but the quantity of sugar is much less in a piece of fruit than it is in a glass of fruit juice. Also, a piece of fruit has fibre in it. Fibre reduces the speed at which we digest something. That means the sugar doesn't enter the bloodstream as quickly, which means the negative effects of it are reduced.

@scottnieradka6836 3 года назад

Is (unsweetened) kefir actually healthier than cows milk? I definitely know older generations who swear by it, and then dubious health food marketing from newer brands. (And why are they specifying cows milk in the studies, do they hate the goat milk?)

@asier_getxo 3 года назад

Well, they could also talk about rat milk or elephant milk. I guess they just tossed up a coin to decide what milk to talk about.

@rosep4630 3 года назад

No idea about kefir, but goat milk comes up a lot in American pediatrics board questions. If not fortified, it has inadequate folate and other vitamins.

@WIImotionmasher 3 года назад

mmmm but milk good.

@Robot_Overlord 3 года назад

I that flannel shirt you look like a Canadian Penn jillette.

@seanwebb605 3 года назад

Being Canadian is awesome!

@peterwalker8466 3 года назад

But, but..... tasty liquid make chimp brain happy!! :( Regardless, though, this is good info and well presented. It makes sense that extraneous stuff that tastes good because of a bunch of sugar should be consumed in moderation, or avoided if possible.

@napoleonibonaparte7198 3 года назад

TLDR: Be a moderate.

@ipadair7345 3 года назад

please be yes, because otherwise I will not be able to find an excuse to drink milk. I haven't watched the video yet, will update till fully watched Edit: Kind of sad since it means I won't have an excuse, but guess it's fine if I drink milk in moderation.

@Valiant1010 3 года назад

No excuse to drink milk, try eating it instead lol. Like the Dr said, treat it as a "treat" (pun intended). Indian Burfi comes to mind, it is delish!

@musthaveV8 3 года назад

Juicy milkers are

@lohphat 3 года назад

Plants don't lactate. It's almond and oat mash juice. It is not "milk". Stop calling it that.

@catherinecase1142 3 года назад

And peanut butter is not butter 🤷🏻‍♀️ Language evolves over time.

@oliverwilson11 3 года назад

It has been called almond milk for hundreds of years. The dairy lobby can impotently cry about it all they want, but they're just showing their ignorance of culinary history

@tomisaacson2762 3 года назад

Next you'll be telling us cocoa butter isn't butter and hand cream isn't cream and non-dairy coffee creamers are creamers. Who cares? Lol and who says milks must come from lactation? Did the God of English inscribe that rule into a stone tablet and have you spread the message to the world?

@lohphat 3 года назад

@@oliverwilson11 It's not the "dairy lobby" it's biology.

@oliverwilson11 3 года назад

@@lohphat Yes it is the dairy lobby that is pushing this illiterate campaign to redefine the word "milk". www.nytimes.com/2017/02/13/well/eat/got-almond-milk-dairy-farms-protest-milk-label-on-nondairy-drinks.html

@skpjoecoursegold366 3 года назад

cow's milk..............................................is for baby cows.

@IS-su2jf 3 года назад

And fruits are for growing plants, doesn’t prevent you from eating them. That’s just a bullshit argument, doesn’t say anything about nutritional value

@handlethisnut 3 года назад

Not false

@HSKCHER 3 года назад

@@IS-su2jf thanks. Was about to post the same

@PhpXp 3 года назад

Kind reminder to everyone here that plant-based milks are the more ethical and environmentally friendly option.

@Sporkredfox 3 года назад

*not almond

@PhpXp 3 года назад

@@Sporkredfox almond too. There's a myth that it's production requires a lot of water. It does, but still only half as much as dairy milk.

@seanwebb605 3 года назад

It suits your ethical positions.

@rosep4630 3 года назад

Between milk and synthetic milk, that is. Water is still far more environmentally friendly than any other option except maybe the juice you could extract from invasive species.

@lemmingsgopop 3 года назад

Alcohol for adults is not really equivalent to soda for children, I'd argue.

@BlueRoseFaery 3 года назад

Yeah its actually worse

@SaucerJess 3 года назад

💙💙💙

@surrealistidealist 3 года назад

0:34 How could he forget to include coffee?!? ☕ All of modern medicine is now completely discredited in my eyes! 😜🤣

@southerngrandma4353 3 года назад

Lol.... I love my coffee! ☕️☕️

@richardb.3808 3 года назад

Drinking the milk from another mammal is ridiculous when you think about it. Switch to plant-based milk. For your kids, see a nutritionist to make sure they eat what they need. Juice is just sugar, not any better than other sugars. Eat the fruit instead, or do like me and make smoothies using complete frozen fruits.

@bramvanduijn8086 2 года назад

Did you not watch the video? Switch to water for daily consumption and leave all other beverages on the "special treats" list.

@richardb.3808 2 года назад

I only drink water.

@Varizen87 3 года назад

I clicked on this video, and as of this comment, I haven't heard Aaron say ANYTHING, but I am guessing right off and recording this that at some point, he's gonna go on a rant about Big Milk and the Milk Industry.

@tany2191 3 года назад

what's the point of showing the text he's reading out? it's just distracting and not helpful at all.

@MontyQueues 3 года назад

if milk and fruit juice is not healthy for adults, why would it be for kids ? a bum TSH

@lyngirasol5773 3 года назад

Ooooo two study's ....very scientific

@greenredblue 3 года назад

Funtime activity: accurately remember any two facts from this episode. I failed...

@therabbithat 3 года назад

Plant milks actually are "more healthy and special" because they are so much better for the planet that we live on. Even almond milk, which has the biggest environmental impact, has a tiny tiny tiny tiny impact compared to cow's milk. You have to take emissions into account when you talk about health, so many floods and wildfires this year, clean drinking water getting more scarce and more expensive, these are health concerns. Also most soy milks are fortified, it's just the "organic" ones that aren't.

@bramvanduijn8086 2 года назад

Drinking water is even better.

@jerther_ 3 года назад

Oh no, I really (reallllly) like you guys but the arrival of a private sponsor is kind of a no-no to me :'(

@seanwebb605 3 года назад

You can't milk an almond. They have no teats.

@MohamedTarikRochdi 3 года назад

It's weird for me that when Americans and Europeans talk about juice, they talk about the processed (industrial) kind. For me the freshly made juice is the only juice, the other is just a sham.

@MerissaFaye 3 года назад

Sorry but the cow milk vs plant-based milks makes no sense. Unsubscribing.

@TacComControl 3 года назад

I'm gonna have to put a firm foot down on this one. While your conclusions are mostly valid, comparing Milk, Juices, and other drinks to ALCOHOL is Extremely irresponsible. What you are telling people with substance use disorders is that the drink they're addicted to is no more harmful than the stuff they put in their cereal. You should have known better, Aaron. And you really, REALLY should address this.

@grogblue 3 года назад

Wow, that's what you heard from: "Every beverage other than water and breast milk might be treated they way you treat alcohol for adults." What you've done is reversed the statement to identify that you could treat alcohol the way you treat milk instead of the other way around.

@oliverwilson11 3 года назад

It's an analogy about frequency of consumption, not a statement about relative harm

@HSKCHER 3 года назад

Wow imagine being that condescending while being wrong lmao

@TacComControl 3 года назад

@@HSKCHER Wow imagine being such an alcoholic that you defend that bullshit.

@tomisaacson2762 3 года назад

Obvious troll is obvious. Try harder next time please.