Тёмный

Are religions still relevant in the 21st century? Yuval Noah Harari 

Piotr Karter Films
Подписаться 2,6 тыс.
Просмотров 63 тыс.
50% 1

This is a great extract froma longer video of professor Yuval in coveration with Natalie Portaman. ( • Natalie Portman and Yu... .
As this video is an extract of a longer video and it is not mine, it has not been monetised.

Кино

Опубликовано:

 

8 окт 2018

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 307   
@driverdave1298
@driverdave1298 2 года назад
This guy is a high priest of his own religion, but can’t even see it
@alankern9563
@alankern9563 3 года назад
"For me, spirituality and religion are totally different things. They are almost the opposite of one another. Spirituality is about questions. Religion is about answers. Spirituality is when you have these big questions, like what is consciousness, what is the meaning of life, who am I, what is the Good. And you go on a quest to find out the answers to these questions, and you have the courage, the willingness, to go wherever these questions take you. Religion is about answers. It's when somebody comes and says, "This is the answer. You must believe that. If not, you will burn in hell, or we will burn you." It's the antithesis of spirituality. And I think that in the 21st century, we will need spirituality more than ever before."
@DhruvPatel-zg1zs
@DhruvPatel-zg1zs 3 года назад
All indian dharmic religion are based on yoga and experience. Even science like ayurveda. Our culture is not based on book. So in dharmic religion even if you not believe in god you are accepted. Even atheist hindu are there. They not believe in god but they are spiritual. Buddha is also great example.
@bhimanjali
@bhimanjali 2 года назад
@@DhruvPatel-zg1zs yeah. But dharma or religion create violance like Hinduism and Islam very bad for humanity . We should take good teaching , rational and moral while eradicating superstition and pseudoscience this is spritulism In Buddhism . I am a Buddhist and also a atheist . Dhamma teaches humanism..
@jesusislord8895
@jesusislord8895 Год назад
I started of in spiritually, it’s all a lie dressed up as truth, I was spiritually attacked by spirits for months, when you dabble into them things you open yourself up to a lot more than you expect and it took a man who new what to do to help me and he used a prayer that involved the name of Jesus Christ and YHWH and I was free from it, that happened became I was meditating and getting crystals and things of the yoga nature, turned out to be the worst thing I had done in 40 years of my life, 3 years on im Catholic, don’t be fooled by the idea of spirituality is a good thing, it’s not, you are not protected as you think, it’s dangerous, and so is this man
@chaitalichatterjee4742
@chaitalichatterjee4742 11 месяцев назад
​@@bhimanjalireality is a controlled hallucination and stop clarifying something as pseudoscience I hate that word I mean i don't believe in some 5 sensed monkeys using useless empirical concepts to describe outer things thats science at it's best
@singhskeptic5742
@singhskeptic5742 5 лет назад
very clearly explained..
@johnpuleo3176
@johnpuleo3176 Год назад
very clearly explained by a bald headed pussy
@8biskit607
@8biskit607 2 года назад
His rating to religion is even less than any worst movies 🤣🤣
@christinerainwater9255
@christinerainwater9255 2 года назад
These are lizard people.
@vikram6577
@vikram6577 2 года назад
@@christinerainwater9255that's the exact reason why he rated it 2😅🤣
@annapopovic
@annapopovic 2 года назад
He is going to start reengineer humans??? Playing God never ends well.
@Charlie-xp9lq
@Charlie-xp9lq 2 года назад
Sadly religions have become more about themselves than the God of all Creation. God himself hates religion !
@margitkorbe6481
@margitkorbe6481 2 года назад
Doesn't it seem that he has confused spirituality with philosophy? Spirituality cannot be dealt with on a purely mental level - this is where it stays philosophy. True spirituality springs from experience and has to do with a connection to source. For a technocratic brain it might be unfathomable.
@petroniaskho
@petroniaskho Год назад
The dark data worshippers have no capacity for true human experience - love and spirituality. Everything is a transaction, or a utility.
@Vakor2020
@Vakor2020 Год назад
Interesting how he contradicts himself explaining something beyond his understanding with a materialistic perspective.
@Mmmm12345
@Mmmm12345 4 года назад
Well for me I see spirituality in religion and I’m happy .. I pray 5 times in a day it’s a meditation for me , cleansing and I feel recharged again full with energy.. because it is all bout blessing and blessings! You need a ritual to express spirituality and this is can’t be without religion.. practicing religion is a way to preform dozens of spiritual emotions inside you 😃 ... but have it open and wide without religion it’s a kind of mess or loss, things need to be organized in a certain way .. we are not living in a bubble or an empty space we’re you feel but not suppose to express through practice !
@solecurious1448
@solecurious1448 4 года назад
M. Ahmad Oh yes you can express spirituality without religion. You can create your own ritual that supports doing good and being your higher self. You don’t need a religion to tell you how. I totally agree with Yuval. I tried different religions before I decided I am spiritual but not religious. Asking questions and being free to explore ‘who I am and why am I here’ are 2 important questions that pulled me closer to God, help me realise the power of God and the power that lies within me. Instead of guilt and feeling like an imposter within a religious construct that alienates me from simply being me.
@Mmmm12345
@Mmmm12345 4 года назад
Sole Curious creating new rituals for me is a waste of time , I already have a set of rituals in my religion because it’s deeply practical religion were you find a ritual for every thing along with specific prayers for each ritual .. it’s deep spiritual and practical at the same time .. if I have the material ready why I creat something new .. moreover we have religious laws that discipline us in many ways and make our life much easier.. add to this we have a holy book that explain life matters , after life , answer question of creations of human being and beyond.. and explain the laws .. it’s a complete religion which don’t leave with question ! Why I have to creat something new and start from zero .. maybe you mean for those who born without religious system ? Your idea maybe will be a good one for them , but even those if they did a good search on world religions they will find something suitable for them
@donaldmcronald8989
@donaldmcronald8989 4 года назад
​@@Mmmm12345 You would prefer to adopt someone else's rituals rather than to look and create for yourself?
@Mmmm12345
@Mmmm12345 4 года назад
Donald McRonald I prefer to follow What I believe that it’s God ritual .. than man made ..
@donaldmcronald8989
@donaldmcronald8989 4 года назад
@@Mmmm12345 But they all believe that. Why not make your own and then believe that one instead?
@katrivers1489
@katrivers1489 5 лет назад
These are excellent objective answers given in a simplified & logical format on religion that the whole world would benefit from hearing as killing in the name of religion still exists. Thank You for asking it.
@IsaacAsimov1992
@IsaacAsimov1992 3 года назад
Great comment !
@donporda2874
@donporda2874 3 года назад
There is killing for the sake of democracy in Libya, and it is in fact not that, and in Iraq, why do you focus on religion strictly and do not be strict about those who kill in the name of civilization and progress? And who decides on morals and equality between us and all human beings? Harari, who says in his writers that the equality of human beings has no basis.
@Laflamablanca76
@Laflamablanca76 2 года назад
lol objective….. asking a gay man to grade religion . You’re funny 🤦🏻‍♂️😂
@MilahanPhilosophersCorner
@MilahanPhilosophersCorner 2 года назад
As if atheists won't be violent lol.
@shoutingatclouds6841
@shoutingatclouds6841 2 года назад
@@Laflamablanca76 He is a low level pharmaceutical salesman no one takes religious advice from this carpet bagger.
@Shreyasiiiii
@Shreyasiiiii 2 года назад
Excellent👏... I got my answer😀.. Thank you
@grohr7697
@grohr7697 2 года назад
Don't settle for this answer. The answer is Jesus Christ.
@judithlauron2856
@judithlauron2856 Год назад
PERFECTLY SPOKEN AND ONE OF THE RARE TIMES ANY INTELLIGENT HUMAN DELIVERED THIS MAGNIFICENT TRUTH.
@devrds
@devrds 3 года назад
Religion is the gateway to spiritually, it is like studying in kindergarten before graduation. Not all in the world would be clever enough to directly jump on spirituality.
@joaoveiga3382
@joaoveiga3382 2 года назад
Religion is just a name for the intellectual work done by humans in the field of meaning and values ​​of men, the evidence that there was some divine intervention in religious books is poor unless you consider that everything including consciousness and the laws of the universe are divine there I could understand and possibly agree with you but I'm not really sure if anyone really knows this big question.
@hussainrashaan1772
@hussainrashaan1772 Год назад
@@joaoveiga3382 I think you are talking about the bible … sometimes sounding smart .. makes you sound dumb . The Quran is words if god not men . Learn before you speak .
@Canvas73120
@Canvas73120 Год назад
You dont need to be a fool before learning to get clever
@glenysregina9135
@glenysregina9135 2 года назад
History says human appeared on earth! Lol until science proves to me how humans appeared. Religion will stand out as the answers to my existence. At least with religion i have an idea of my origin as a human and am happy with my connection with the God i believe in.
@dhruva08
@dhruva08 4 месяца назад
ego needs answers, most spiritualists get comfortable with not having a definite answer. Universe is mysterious it may always remain so, if youve already got an answer your spirituality has hindered
@jamalibaloch5611
@jamalibaloch5611 4 года назад
How one can speak about religion and God without having deep knowledge about them? Science has proved spirits and the unseen world. Lets keep it simple, what is wrong in following religion? No religion ever harmed humans. These are humans who misused religions. Some selfish people create a misconception about an entire peaceful religion. Without religion, there will be a total chaos. Religion is a necessity and the ultimate truth of life. And everyone will be accountable for one's deeds on the day of judgement.
@Mmmm12345
@Mmmm12345 4 года назад
Jamali Baloch nice comment jamali ! I agree with you and by the way I belong to the same family you belong to ! I saw your last name and I said oh a cousin is writing comment her 😂 it’s a same view of mine 👍
@ninaj6307
@ninaj6307 4 года назад
No religion every harmed humans? I suppose you haven't heard about the Spanish Inquisition, Crusades, Salem Witch Hunts, September 11 etc.. etc... I could go on and on.
@reembagadi7875
@reembagadi7875 3 года назад
@Homo Sapien he gave his opinions just like harari gave opinions, don't be a snowflake.
@sukottoshinobe7360
@sukottoshinobe7360 2 года назад
Totally Christians have never killed anyone 🤣🤣
@killa34mam76
@killa34mam76 2 года назад
@@reembagadi7875 And he gave his opinion too chill.
@brightbusiri
@brightbusiri Год назад
I appreciate your time
@nicholasalderman773
@nicholasalderman773 2 года назад
He states the goal is to prevent human suffering, but that is his own self-determined goal, and it is terribly misunderstood by him, if in fact, the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob exists, because if you truly wanted to prevent human suffering there is only one solution, and it came on a cross at calvary. Without that solution, the suffering for humans is eternal. People should always be seeking truth, which is exclusive by its nature, and the most important question to ask is: Did Jesus exist, and is HE who HE claimed to be? If he existed and HE is who HE claimed to be then Christianity means everything, if HE didn't exist and/or HE isn't who HE claimed to be then you can dismiss Christianity. But don't be lazy in answering this question, no one can do it for you, it takes real work and studiousness, and a heart that honestly wants to know the truth. "You will seek me and find me, when you seek me with all your heart." -Jeremiah 29:13
@mohammadfeizi3571
@mohammadfeizi3571 4 года назад
and what if some body find answer of question in religion? my religion said go after your question and find best way . never obey your religion because of your father and mother faith but reality is one!
@solecurious1448
@solecurious1448 4 года назад
Mohammad Feizi I found that religion is the one that messed me up until I realised I do believe in God but don’t need a human construct telling me how to believe in God. Spirituality gives me the freedom to show up as I am - acknowledge my flaws (instead of feeling guilty for being a sinner), and always works towards a better version of myself. It took lots of courage to live as My True Self. Asking questions was what liberated me, even when there doesn’t seem to be any immediate answer. I knew God has my back. I don’t need to know everything for God to answer my prayer. Otherwise what is faith? Asking questions IS liberating. Your mind will blow up if you only allow one truth and one way. What if you approach the questions with curiosity and allow the ideas to flow... not lock down with your own perception? What if there is truth everywhere, it takes time to find your own truth? What if the truth embodies different perspectives? You just need to find it? As Long I know I am doing everything with the best intention and not harm others or myself (thinking I am not good enough, only someone else, like God, can save me. Hence, not taking action to improve myself.) I am at peace with my truth and who I am.
@RealLife-dp9dd
@RealLife-dp9dd 4 года назад
Could you give us one example of one question you found and one answer to that question in your religion?
@optionsmasternationalstock9578
@optionsmasternationalstock9578 3 года назад
Islam is the cancer for humanity. Islam kills gay people and Noah Harari is a gay.
@Leo-wp4tn
@Leo-wp4tn 3 года назад
That's call TO THE POINT ANSWER
@MegaVIDEOGAMEVIDS
@MegaVIDEOGAMEVIDS 2 года назад
It's always a question of utility for these people never if said religion or religious claim is actually true (I might add philosophical claims as well especially concerning metaphysics and epistemology. Don't you dare make an objective claim about those!) They never seem to bother questioning their governing presuppositions and take for granted the very possibility of knowledge in our world. Looking past the confident speech and indeed the words he says that are agreeable to the modern person's sensibilities, what's said here is nothing short of trite drivel and shallower than the pond we're said to have come from.
@petroniaskho
@petroniaskho Год назад
Thank you. You've articulated everything I was thinking but struggled to explain so clearly. This guy terrifies me because he's so worshipped (ironically) by the elites and the vanguard.
@natashatomlinson4548
@natashatomlinson4548 Год назад
It’s humorous to watch someone who likes to think of himself as being very rational committing the fallacy of overgeneralizing in front of all these people . “ All generalities are illogical except for the possibility of this one .”- Kurt Godel
@vincentlesmes247
@vincentlesmes247 5 лет назад
What about hope? Either the answers from the religions are the real thing or not. It gave to the humans something to believe in. Gave to their suffering lives in this world a meaning of happiness and without it many would have felt realistically hopelessness...in search for an eternal answer.
@InlightmediaUk
@InlightmediaUk 5 лет назад
I think you make a great point Vincent, I invite you to listen to his whole talk (link in the description) because he clearly differentiates Religion from Spirituality. I think our desire to connect to something much bigger then ourselves will always be there, it's only the images we use about it will change. Institutionalised Religion does more good then bad nowadays I think but I am also aware of the fact that there are plenty of great religious figures (mostly at the bottom of the religious hierarchy) who do a lot of good in the world.
@jasonmuniz8802
@jasonmuniz8802 5 лет назад
Hope is just an emotion. Nature/life/being/reality with all its violent beauty is the only god.
@petroniaskho
@petroniaskho Год назад
Not allowed with the Davos crowd. You will eat the bugs, pay taxes and live in your pod, and be happy.
@dhruva08
@dhruva08 4 месяца назад
if you are truly spiritual, you wont bother about hope, because you remain peaceful whatever negativity happens around you. Hope is wanting something more pleasant in the future which you dont have at the moment. This is the trick of the mind, the mind is never happy whatever it has at the present moment so it searches elsewhere in the future
@christelhayward4344
@christelhayward4344 2 года назад
He likes his own voice so much. Was there time for her to answer?
@MilahanPhilosophersCorner
@MilahanPhilosophersCorner 2 года назад
La ilaha illa Allah.
@pawelg8652
@pawelg8652 Год назад
so in 2:10-2:30 he says that religion is about someone saying that you must believe in this or that (which is... very, very strange oversimplification for someone who is considered to be smart), while in the beginning he says religion is not necessary in 21st century, so he... says we should... believe in what he says? 🤔 There's something strange about this guy
@MaratibAliShad
@MaratibAliShad 3 года назад
Though it is very clear and confident opinion, however, current form of religion exist in the world are lack of spirituality. Spirituality has become separate domain beyond religion that is sign of game changer events happened in recent centuries. All spirituality were deeply linked with their founders actually like Jesus, Muhammad, Moses, Ram except Gautham Siddarth. Now religion is a lifestyle of groups and culture, but later with evolution of human development, their founders basis of spirituality were separated by jurists or modernists gradually. Now, we have religions with its essence. In this stage, I agree with Yuval Harari what he said in this video. In contemporary times, many great religious people are emphasising and motivating on both religion+spirituality and they have been very successful in giving new identity of their followers nations such as Sheikh Nazim, Deepak Chopra and also Christian and Jews spiritual gurus. I think re-combining both religion and spiritual is most wisely approach for going forward. We cannot ignore religion to be more successful and wise.
@minasithilindustries
@minasithilindustries 2 года назад
He misrepresents religion sometimes I notice. He says “religion says you must do this or go to hell”
@karlmunford7000
@karlmunford7000 2 года назад
Indeed, build a strawman then knock it down so you don't have to deal with your sins but excuse them.
@tonyramos1204
@tonyramos1204 Год назад
You may not believe this but my hope is that the Spirit of God will bring conviction...he immediately goes to a saying things like that because even though he's not a demon he's a human created in God's image, he's certainly possessed by one according to what the BIBLE states...satan wants to attack Christianity because he is direct opposition to the true God of the universe. The scripture says that he is full of darkness whereas God is full of light!
@esotericwisdom49
@esotericwisdom49 3 года назад
In the 21 century we need probably spirituality more then ever before .this is very true
@kalpanagupta6166
@kalpanagupta6166 2 года назад
This is why Eastern religions are focused on spirituality, but Abrahmic religions are based on faith. Follow x, otherwise burn in hell fire
@sergiomarchelli
@sergiomarchelli 2 года назад
there is no spirituality separated from religion.
@hardcoreblt9409
@hardcoreblt9409 2 года назад
What's point of creating heaven or hell (don't know exists or not) along with creating this infinitely big universe.... & Why life exists only on earth..... ?
@warrenwagner451
@warrenwagner451 2 года назад
Perfect, a science-fiction hack and an actress giving us all enlightenment and knowledge to live a better life... NOT.
@petroniaskho
@petroniaskho Год назад
They're really pushing hard with this guy. Globalist leftists think he's some kind of saviour, but any decent human with common sense can see what he really is.
@prometheanevent
@prometheanevent 2 года назад
The desire to be seen as being among the intelligencia will cause smart people to fall for anything. Harari needs to “own nothing.”
@bipulmishra2194
@bipulmishra2194 3 года назад
Who is she with harari?
@gaylenhalbert4391
@gaylenhalbert4391 2 года назад
I believe it is Natalie Portman.
@bipulmishra2194
@bipulmishra2194 2 года назад
@@gaylenhalbert4391 Ok thanks
@BubbleBurster-nv1vl
@BubbleBurster-nv1vl Год назад
Yuval is totally nuts. He wants to create his own religion and play god.
@hardcoreblt9409
@hardcoreblt9409 2 года назад
Why there are so many god & religions.... Almost 4000 religions... & More than doing good things most of major religions are no longer serving purpose or can say done harm tremendously
@denisecrawford2425
@denisecrawford2425 Год назад
All he's saying, in the 21st century people can use all the teaching and benefits of religion, but don't practice religion or aligned themselves with any religion. Unbelievable how these people think they can hijacked a practice a doing away with it by stealing its teachings and core practice.
@jamesstmanhattan
@jamesstmanhattan 2 года назад
I concur.
@hussainrashaan1772
@hussainrashaan1772 Год назад
Yes only one the true one not words of men that is Islam and the Quran ! 😊
@camreese
@camreese Год назад
Weve seen too many civilizations try to excise God from their cultures and seen societies collapse to take his word for it
@faryalroy1443
@faryalroy1443 Год назад
I don't think there can be any better explanation than this 👏🏻 👏🏻.. This man has become the ultimate source of answers to the questions we had in our minds since long.. Awesome
@carmenvljn
@carmenvljn Год назад
what is wrong with you?
@delmanpronto9374
@delmanpronto9374 Год назад
@@carmenvljn useful idiot. like bezmenov predicted.
@DutchWestIndianCo
@DutchWestIndianCo Год назад
Most of this I've heard in Anthropology 101. Check out "Meditations" by Rene Descartes, it's a much more well thought out take on this.
@tropicalstrings
@tropicalstrings 2 года назад
If you are not believer you can never feel like a believer. Spirit is part of the divine. Thats why we are sinking to earth not to the brain. We lack music vibrations of the brain. You do not play music. I hear that.
@DutchWestIndianCo
@DutchWestIndianCo Год назад
Even the T.A in my Anthropology 101 class is smarter than this guy, and I question some assumptions they made in that class.
@AlexSharayMusic
@AlexSharayMusic 5 лет назад
In my opinion, Religion is like medicine....if you get the dosage wrong, it will either kill you (or others), or it will have no effect. Which religion is the best medicine..? Well, that is too heavy and controversial a question for here. Peace to all....
@InlightmediaUk
@InlightmediaUk 5 лет назад
Knowledge is the best medicine and there is no problem with getting the wrong dosage, the more the better...
@FreedomFROMReligionID
@FreedomFROMReligionID 4 года назад
Religion is not medicine. Like Yuval says, it is mostly harmful. I was a muslim before, until I found out that the stories in the Quran (and other religions) are mostly fairy tales, like the Noah's ark (no historical evidence whatsoever on the huge ark and flood), splitting of the moon, and many more.
@youssefrea9574
@youssefrea9574 4 года назад
@@FreedomFROMReligionID can you answer me please are you feeling good right now cause i tried it i have been atheist but i wasn't happy i couldn't sleep i was all the time saying no i am wrong :/ and i became muslim after it i am here for asking really are feeling happy and good without religion ?
@donaldmcronald8989
@donaldmcronald8989 4 года назад
@@youssefrea9574 I can't adopt a set of ideas just because they make me feel good. Can you?
@christophermills9289
@christophermills9289 Год назад
I have listed to his book "Sapiens" on audio and I have read the graphic novel. Highly recommend both.
@ImStupid01
@ImStupid01 4 года назад
2/5 is not a pass mark. Ops.
@valiantcustomcleaning5743
@valiantcustomcleaning5743 5 месяцев назад
I don't understand this opposition between spirituality and religion. Isn't religion an organized attempt to enhance spirituality among a group of people through ritual, repetition, and the cultivation of shared values? Some public intellectuals can be naive at times...
@pranavautade7865
@pranavautade7865 3 года назад
i think when talking about religion he is mostly concedering idealogies of western religions and not the eastern religions like hinduism,buddhisim,jainism,sikhism,i'd like a debate between him and a expert on eastern religions
@timb1441
@timb1441 2 года назад
You will find out what this world is going to be like someday. When Jesus comes down into the clouds and Christians are called up to meet him, Jesus is going to take the Holy Spirit out of the world as well. Goodness and humanity in people will be gone completely. This guy and every other atheist will learn the hard way. Survival of the fittest will be the way. The weak will be stepped on.
@obarilaleogosu6339
@obarilaleogosu6339 2 года назад
Nonsense
@lkfndr6045
@lkfndr6045 2 года назад
You are right Tim Barter
@mysongsmitch8528
@mysongsmitch8528 Год назад
Amen to that
@raymondtendau2749
@raymondtendau2749 3 года назад
No wonder i prefer spirituality so much. I got many questions. Religion only got Answers.
@restinaaprilianti4798
@restinaaprilianti4798 3 года назад
TRUE
@nazk5478
@nazk5478 3 года назад
Why ask a question if you don't want any answers?
@raymondtendau2749
@raymondtendau2749 3 года назад
@@nazk5478 Questions you cannot answer are usually far more acceptable than answers you cannot question.
@tytiw516
@tytiw516 3 года назад
@@raymondtendau2749 Are you a fan of Richard Feynman?? But, sorry that answer is really arrogant 🤣. I mean what is your purpose to go to school everyday and then finish the exam by answer the questions ???
@siddharthachatterjee9163
@siddharthachatterjee9163 3 года назад
Yuval Noah Harai is the most practical academic thinker of our time.
@johnfal1849
@johnfal1849 2 года назад
More like a demon incarnate.
@dhunsaker26
@dhunsaker26 2 года назад
Read the Bible. Theres your thinking…
@thetheoreticaltheologian2458
People always asks how religion has affected civilizations but they never ask how atheism has affected civilizations. Now of course a gay man such as Yuval will rate religion very low for obvious reasons. Now me as a Christian guy I would rate Christianity pretty high but I know that we haven’t always done things the way Christ commanded us. I also think atheism hasn’t been all that great but there are some things that atheists have done that has benefited civilizations. All I’m saying is that it would be hard to say that any one group is perfect who is without any flaws. I will also say that I think in this day in age Christians are one of the most accepting people in the world since most people from around the world flock to Christian majoritive countries for example America who h is by far the most diverse country in the world but is called the most racist country by atheists “which is pretty weird.” You can even openly blaspheme Christianity and our God and never get the thought that you might be in danger of what you said. You wouldn’t be able to see that in most other religions especially if it were said in their own country.
@petroniaskho
@petroniaskho Год назад
“Satan, on the contrary, is thin, ascetic and a fanatical devotee of logic. He reads Machiavelli, Ignatius of Loyola, Marx and Hegel; he is cold and unmerciful to mankind, out of a kind of mathematical mercifulness. He is damned always to do that which is most repugnant to him: to become a slaughterer, in order to abolish slaughtering, to sacrifice lambs so that no more lambs may be slaughtered, to whip people with knouts so that they may learn not to let themselves be whipped, to strip himself of every scruple in the name of a higher scrupulousness, and to challenge the hatred of mankind because of his love for it--an abstract and geometric love.” - Arthur Koestler (Darkness at Noon)
@AshishKunjachan95
@AshishKunjachan95 4 года назад
It would be nice if Google and Facebook employs Philosophy graduates 😛
@altruex
@altruex 3 года назад
Microsoft took a bit of an approach but they hired internal members, to allocate and focus on the aspects of AI ethics. But even then, its a step, but not enough. Society lacks the collective morality to move forward .
@colorfulflowers574
@colorfulflowers574 2 года назад
Philosopy without science is also stupid
@mncpakistan9995
@mncpakistan9995 Год назад
Now Cartoon like this will guide god to make special religion for him, his wishes are same as devil.
@user-ow9ri5xy5n
@user-ow9ri5xy5n 4 года назад
0:21
@sacrificejuni6139
@sacrificejuni6139 Год назад
If man created God, then who created man?
@DutchWestIndianCo
@DutchWestIndianCo Год назад
This guy is a pseudo intellectual, who works for Klaus Schwab. Read "Meditations" by Rene Descartes
@benwilkonski8635
@benwilkonski8635 5 лет назад
Solid .01
@binasharma7128
@binasharma7128 3 года назад
Mr. Harari, I love the way you separated spirituality from religion--some people think they're the same, and your explanations are marvellous. Thanks so much!
@raindeer3428
@raindeer3428 3 года назад
spirituality comes from religion , do your research before you throw stupidity
@TheSwward
@TheSwward Год назад
The human who just created spaceship that can run out of oxygen any moment is ready to challenge god that created bigger space ship that swim across the cosmos without running out of oxygen for many millions or billions of years.
@user-os3fp9gg2x
@user-os3fp9gg2x 3 года назад
If any religion can be proven like science we would believe in it!😇😇😇💦🔥
@Tsjabt-lk6ez
@Tsjabt-lk6ez 2 года назад
Well science simply hypotesis-data-conclucions while religion start from conclucion-data-conclucion So its kinda funny when people claim these two had positive relationship
@imatheistandslaveoflucifer279
@imatheistandslaveoflucifer279 2 года назад
Brother. Buddhism also. You any evidence of after life. Hinduism Buddhism jainisam this three religion are teaching re birth concepts but any scientific proof have re birth.🤣🤣🤣🤣
@user-os3fp9gg2x
@user-os3fp9gg2x 2 года назад
@@imatheistandslaveoflucifer279 some monk(phikku) can remember his past life with some evidence to show that it's true. 😇😇😇( っ'-')╮ =͟͟͞͞🏀
@imatheistandslaveoflucifer279
@imatheistandslaveoflucifer279 2 года назад
@@user-os3fp9gg2x no. I Want Scientific evidence. You belive karma. Any scientific definition have karma. (Don't tell karma like a newton's3rd law ). Hinduism jainisam and Buddhism are teaching dharma,karma,samsara(only Hinduism),Reincarnation. You belive Reincarnation? Please tell what's your past life and after your death what's future life? 😏😏 Brother Hinduism jainisam and Buddhism three religion are dharmic religion😃. As a athist this three religion are peaceful religion in the world😇😇😇. And same religion are only teach about ahimsa(non violence)🥰. Then I respect that three religion.🙏
@mickeyguide3112
@mickeyguide3112 2 года назад
@@imatheistandslaveoflucifer279 btw you have quite a contradicting username, atheists and lucifer in the same sentence lol. Atheists don't believe into spiritual 'nonsense' like lucifers, satans, God etc.
@solecurious1448
@solecurious1448 4 года назад
Yuval is brilliant - distilling a complex question into something so simple. But 21st century sounds dull and empty. How I dread the time when Engineers, science and technology take over human Essence and define it for the human race. Science and technology love certainty. As humans, we live for faith and hope in the face of life’s uncertainties... hoping that someday we will meet our Creator, to be better versions of ourselves or simply, to live a good life during our time on earth. With certainty, it displaces faith and hope. What about free will? It makes obsolete what it is like to be a full human. It sounds like everyone will move to the beat of one drum - the Engineers’.
@donaldmcronald8989
@donaldmcronald8989 4 года назад
I cannot find free-will unless I redefine it.
@harsh.jaluka
@harsh.jaluka 4 года назад
Sole Curious I do not understand why you think that explaining and understanding the world we live in will make it boring and dull. The whole appeal of science, and engineering as an extension, is to marvel at nature and attempt to understand how things came to be. There’s tremendous beauty in understanding how things work if you care enough to indulge in the subject.
@littlesam6280
@littlesam6280 Год назад
“Yuval is brilliant” Yuval is also the guy pushing trans humanism and hacking the brain and body, and of course he works with he WEF. Jesus Christ loves you please repent and forgive
@petroniaskho
@petroniaskho Год назад
His dark vision is the end result of a Godless, nihilistic world. He is the modern day Satan, presented as some kind of wise man. Do not trust this guy. He's the front man for all that is evil - Global control of humanity by a tiny elite in Davos.
@Chatrar5853
@Chatrar5853 2 года назад
howcome these people write good books
@gloriatemael2510
@gloriatemael2510 11 месяцев назад
No elishpeking
@karol_p
@karol_p 5 лет назад
If he says religion was unnecessary in the past then he has no idea about psychology or he has an idea, but prefers to say what the masses want to hear.
@InlightmediaUk
@InlightmediaUk 5 лет назад
Usually you first listen and then comment, not the other way round haha
@karol_p
@karol_p 5 лет назад
@@InlightmediaUk 1:00 I refer to his claim that religion was unnecessary for morality and is now unnecessary. So inaccurate. And I know he himself practices Vipassana and science, both built on religious foundation.
@InlightmediaUk
@InlightmediaUk 5 лет назад
@@karol_p I think what he means is that you don't need religious institutions to tell you what is right and what is wrong. There are religions practices and spiritual practices that get you thinking and develop empathy within you. Two unique ingredients necessary to build our morality from. Only undeveloped minds still believe in religious dogma. I understand in Poland Catholicism has been sold to you as part of your identity. It's just a marketing move to keep you addicted to it. You do not need religion to tell you what is right and what is wrong, what you need it conversations.
@karol_p
@karol_p 5 лет назад
@@InlightmediaUk People organize into organizations (what you call institutions) to be able to cooperate and make things possible which are impossible to achieve by one person. You say conversations are enough but people eventually wish to preserve the achievements of a given group and so they form larger organizations. I am thankful for the Catholic Church which preserved the findings of a large tradition of theologians and even classic Greek philosophers. Without this institution, those findings might have been lost. My point is, organizations are built to preserve certain outcomes of conversations so that the next generations do not have to build knowledge right from the start, but they may build on the established foundation. You must not be confused that human nature is particularly good. There are precursors to morality that are present in the animal kingdom - that is true, but the appearence of higher consciousness in man created the necessity for a new level of ethics, not present in animals. In order to even have a civilized conversation with their fellows, young humans must be educated into culture, taught not to steal, not to lie, taught how to concentrate etc. This is impossible for animals. So empathy is not possible without culture. Now, dogma are formed as specifications of the general symbolic truths about the world, that a given society regards as true. The whole dogmatic structure is just a map. And it is not arbitrary, but built on thousands of years of "conversations". I think that a reasonable and educated person understands that dogma are mostly referring to transcendent reality and not necessarily to the physical domain. And such person also does not follow them blindly but tries to understand and verify them. Although not necessarily by opposing them publicly at any given occasion. You see, the outcome of many generations of theological investigations is certainly worth understanding first before going into the world openly criticizing it.
@InlightmediaUk
@InlightmediaUk 5 лет назад
@@karol_p I completely agree and understand. To give you another example religions or people inspired by religious beliefs have created probably the most beautiful works of art ever created. I know as I lived in Rome for 25 years. Modern art does not come near to what those artist have achieved in the past. I think our relationship with the 'beyond' as I call it, it's extremely important. It's the religious monopoly on moral thinking that I am criticising. Religions can exist, and they probably should as they do a lot of good. But I also want to point out at all the horrors that religions across the world have created and are creating. I do not like religious institutions and religious hierarchy. Everything in the world of humans, when it goes past a certain size becomes a monster.... the latest example is factory farming....what the fuck are we doing!?!?!? Is that so difficult to see that we could easily survive without eating meat!??!!? And I am not even vegan. It's just common sense....where is your religion in this discourse? Historically speaking the connection between religion and good is very recent.... it came about with the Vatican's marketing move to call Giovanni Papa XXIII as the 'Good Pope'... before then no one really expected the church to be good. You just had to listen, and if you didn't they'd burn you as heretic. I mean, the conversation is very complex here and also very interesting to have. Thank you for your input, I very much appreciate it.
@ganesankrishnamurthy8658
@ganesankrishnamurthy8658 6 месяцев назад
Y N H ❤
@grohr7697
@grohr7697 2 года назад
I believe that Harari gave up his spiritual quest too soon. If people search long enough and sincerely enough, they usually encounter Jesus and know the truth. Before anyone claims l am narrow-minded and "judging" other religions, l challenge you to read the New Testament. Be sure to find a translation that doesn't sound like a Skakespearean play. If you go down the "Jesus path" and it looks like a sham or a cult, then you're not really and the Jesus path. Try again. When you find Jesus, you will know love, and you won't find any satisfaction in "judging others. "
@grohr7697
@grohr7697 2 года назад
... "not really on the Jesus path."
@itsmarsh6
@itsmarsh6 2 года назад
Spirit doesn't exist i think 🤣 we're just a brain with a body heart lungs eye legs hands and some skin that will broke down when we get older 😅
@1eV
@1eV 2 года назад
He is gay, but how is he staying in Israel? Is gay marriage allowed in Israel?
@petroniaskho
@petroniaskho Год назад
Yes. Israel is 75% secular. They're basically an atheist nation pretending to be a religion so they can have an ethno state.
@apache1729
@apache1729 2 года назад
They are relevant to give hope to poor,desperate,sick people in underdeveloped countries. I cant see the point of religion in countries like Netherlands or Germany,they have science and quality of life
@nithinraj4746
@nithinraj4746 3 года назад
My favourit thinker ❤️❤️❤️❤️His thoughts must be shared more and more💯💯💯
@ChibiTalha
@ChibiTalha 3 года назад
Religion is not religion unless one understands it and sees the big picture, otherwise, it's just a mask. I disagree with the notion that religions aren't relevant. I am a proud Muslim and I have always found meaning in my religion, if someone who is less educated tries to talk me out of it than that person is the one I perceive to be "ignorant"
@InlightmediaUk
@InlightmediaUk 3 года назад
There will always be a bigger picture in this life my friend, knowledge and understanding are far bigger than the time we have on this planet
@Laflamablanca76
@Laflamablanca76 2 года назад
What would you think a gay man would rate religion though ? I mean really 🤦🏻‍♂️
@Laflamablanca76
@Laflamablanca76 2 года назад
@Sid Thomas Hahaha clearly your definition of “ attacking” is suspect at best…… observation? Yes…. Attacking ? Not at all 😘
@Laflamablanca76
@Laflamablanca76 2 года назад
@Sid Thomas You can thank religion FOR education . Can’t make this stuff up, sheesh 🤦🏻‍♂️
@johnpuleo3176
@johnpuleo3176 Год назад
Noah was definitely afraid to fist fight in High School.
@ruslanhesenov6825
@ruslanhesenov6825 3 года назад
Well, this historian does not know about human psyche, i'd like to debate between him and JBP
@user-yt2kn8sr6y
@user-yt2kn8sr6y 3 года назад
no cap this dude be talkin' god's language 💯
@gloriajaorasdr5938
@gloriajaorasdr5938 Год назад
Deception Spirit of the Antichrist
@FreedomFROMReligionID
@FreedomFROMReligionID 4 года назад
The concept of "god" has many problems, it shows that it is a concept made by humans. Can "God" create a stone so strong that He cannot destroy? If the answer is "no", then God is *not* omnipotent. If the answer is "yes, by creating something to destroy the stone", then still the conclusion would be God is NOT omnipotent because He *cannot* do it by Himself. Also think about the concept of heaven and hell. Why can't God just create humans that he *knows* will go to heaven, and still test them with disasters, death, suffering, etc, only that they will go to heaven in the end? He can do that, can't He? Why not? Why burn in hell forever? Because "god" is just a concept made by human brains.
@sycorez
@sycorez 2 года назад
What you are asking (in the first paragraph) is if God can be a logical contradiction. You're asking can a being be omnipotent and not omnipotent at the same time. It's like asking can someone be a married bachelor. Or can there be a squared circle. There are responses to this as God does what is in God's nature. But also another which puts such a question to shame as Harry Frankfurt puts it "For why should God not be able to perform the task in question? To be sure, it is a task-the task of lifting a stone which He cannot lift-whose description is self-contradictory. But if God is supposed capable of performing one task whose description is self-contradictory-that of creating the problematic stone in the first place-why should He not be supposed capable of performing another-that of lifting the stone? After all, is there any greater trick in performing two logically impossible tasks than there is in performing one?" Basically, if you are asking for a logical contradiction, then the answer can also be a logical contradiction.
@sycorez
@sycorez 2 года назад
The second paragraph doesn't make sense either. You assume God doesn't know who will and won't go to heaven. But that leads to a different question and I'd like to respond to what you asked here first. If God creates beings that will go to heaven, then what is the point of the test? It makes the whole test thing redundant. Just put them in heaven. They're all going to past the test. Such beings will not be able to have free will. As they will go to heaven they won't be able to disobey God. The better and more difficult question would have been to ask why would God create beings he knows who would fail the test and send them to Hell.
@petroniaskho
@petroniaskho Год назад
You are using logic to form an argument. Good start. Interesting you don't see the irony. Where do those meta rules of mathematics come from? You can't create a concept without a set of eternal rules to structure it.
@mmc5261
@mmc5261 2 года назад
Asking this guy about religion is like asking a priest about quantum entanglement lol I don’t think this is trade
@EMan-qg6dv
@EMan-qg6dv Год назад
If you are reading this, Jesus wants to have a relationship with you. Not a religion.
@ayushverma6000
@ayushverma6000 Год назад
If you know everything and don't have any doubt,it's religion. If you don't know anything and desperate to know the truth of everything,it's spirituality.
@soroushdarvish9281
@soroushdarvish9281 Год назад
This guy is bundled up in a state built on religion. But now he has a crusade against religion because of his sexuality. It’s very obvious.
@jamesstmanhattan
@jamesstmanhattan 2 года назад
His books have totally rearranged my brain, and the way I see the world. The guy has changed my life making me a more informed person, more informed about myself, and more informed about the world I live in.
@richardreeves5764
@richardreeves5764 Год назад
He believes in spirituality because he doesn’t want want face the very thing that he knows is wrong. Therefore, by his denying God he feels justified in saying that common people have to be done away with.
@glenysregina9135
@glenysregina9135 2 года назад
Harari may have knowledge about history but it’s obvious that he has very little knowledge about religion. The best example he can give about religion is that if you don’t do something you will burn or be burned. Spiritually is about asking questions, After asking the questions about yourself and going on a quest to find the answers , don’t we believe the answers that are found? Spirituality and religion are different but they work together
@Canvas73120
@Canvas73120 Год назад
Lol. Both r at opposite ends. Suirituality is about questioning and religi9n is about blind faith. Obviously religious fools will never admit it.
@glenysregina9135
@glenysregina9135 Год назад
@@Canvas73120 no need to insult anyone or call them fools for believing what they believe. After all they are not losing anything by being fools
@gytis321s2
@gytis321s2 Год назад
There is no beliefs. There is only facts and evidence. There is zero evidence of religion or god. If god exist, why he's so useless. Millions of kids die every year to nature catastrophies, diseases. Why your god don't save them.
@glenysregina9135
@glenysregina9135 Год назад
@@gytis321s2 you sound pathetic
@joseloures7701
@joseloures7701 Год назад
Tenham muito cuidado com este homem, leiam a Bíblia ele tem muita coincidência em apocalipse. Não é atoa que os ricos e poderosos chamam ele de profeta.
@rishabhmishra8591
@rishabhmishra8591 2 года назад
Dharma is not religion. Religion is a word created by west. Dharma is the way of living not any religion. Be it Santana Dharma, Bodh Dharma.
@rishabhmishra8591
@rishabhmishra8591 2 года назад
@Sid Thomas science and spirituality is itself an integral part of the DHARMA
@Yasin23
@Yasin23 2 года назад
People should stick to what they know.. he is clueless in the case of Religion.
@amysutton6932
@amysutton6932 3 года назад
She literally calls out the Lord’s name in vain twice before they speak 🤭
@tharalpius778
@tharalpius778 2 года назад
He is really good
@Lauritz777
@Lauritz777 2 года назад
Prays he not gets power.
@petroniaskho
@petroniaskho Год назад
He has power. He's the 'spiritual' advisor to the reptile elites in Davos. Fakk this guy.
@stefniehatzimichael209
@stefniehatzimichael209 2 года назад
Jesus said I am the Truth, Way and LIFE......
@bkb4364
@bkb4364 Год назад
A total lie
@shreyansh4593
@shreyansh4593 Год назад
Surprise, surprise! He lied!
@praveenkumar-yo1xg
@praveenkumar-yo1xg Год назад
Do not believe him or anyone who can predict future for 50 years from now. God is God no matter how much human intelligence can invent. He can't make the wind blow neither he cannot recreate ocean or go beyond human questions. He can't answer how long human beings can survive on this earth. Can he create a soul or a human being or create a new universe which has stars or just like new nature no human intelligence can't. They can only expand their intelligence through phycial realities that's it. Can he end the accidents or suicides or any natural calamities which might occur on this earth planet. Can human intelligence give birth to new baby just in one day no he cant
@praveenkumar-yo1xg
@praveenkumar-yo1xg Год назад
Ofcourse he is the truth brother. Jesus was speaking about salvation of souls. They are not bothered about it in this video. Kindly do not get take up by his talk. Always belive God is greater than human inventions. He can make or break but as human beings we have been blessed with good potential if it's used for the good of the world or to shape the life of human being in proper way then it's good or else it is going to be destructive
@ANPDog_AlimentacaoNaturalCaes
Jesus said many things, and his suposed followers dont follow what he said, they Just repeat bible verses like a parrot
@DhruvPatel-zg1zs
@DhruvPatel-zg1zs 3 года назад
Rate yoga from 1 to 5. So yea, india is ahead in this. Yoga is rising when all other Abrahamic religious finding hard to survive because they are religion of book. Dharma stand again time and still not failing against modern science.
@abdullahfaraj9803
@abdullahfaraj9803 5 лет назад
Religion is very relevant very important
@InlightmediaUk
@InlightmediaUk 5 лет назад
and in the wrong hands... ehmmm heads... potentially very, very dangerous ;) educate yourself and you'll understand and make the most out of it.
@FreedomFROMReligionID
@FreedomFROMReligionID 4 года назад
I used to think that when I was a muslim. Now I am an atheist because I found various scientific errors and stupid things in the Quran and hadiths and the Islamic scholars just have to do various kinds of mental gymnastics to defend ridiculous verses. If you really learn your religion, you will know that people created the story of "God", there is no such existence.
@laurentiumihai4478
@laurentiumihai4478 4 года назад
@@FreedomFROMReligionID Islam is a great lie and deception ! If you look in the past, about what greats minds have to say about Islam, you will convince yourself that is nothing but a mess ! The orthodox christianity has survived for over 2000 years, and there you will find all your answers !
@ChibiTalha
@ChibiTalha 3 года назад
@@FreedomFROMReligionID If I may humbly ask? What are these errors that you talk about?
@cyruskhan3462
@cyruskhan3462 2 года назад
@@FreedomFROMReligionID There are absolutely no errors in the Quran.
@shoutingatclouds6841
@shoutingatclouds6841 2 года назад
Yuval Harari is a nonessential worker.
@petroniaskho
@petroniaskho Год назад
Useless eater with no real skill to contribute to his community. Imagine that pipsqueek when the antifa mob comes to the door.
@michaelcontreras148
@michaelcontreras148 2 года назад
Sounds like Satan
@gregspace2
@gregspace2 Год назад
Yes God is relevant, Jesus is my savior, always and forever, I pray for you
@mmc5261
@mmc5261 2 года назад
This guy has no idea what he is talking about, religion is the vessel spirituality is the substance, you can’t separate them. Why people trust these bling fools is beyond me, he thinks spiritually is about asking questions hahaha
@cyruskhan3462
@cyruskhan3462 2 года назад
Among 100 only 5 can practice spirituality, the rest of 95% need religion.
@praveenkumar-yo1xg
@praveenkumar-yo1xg Год назад
How can we believe that you are speaking truth. You can just guess or suppose. You are still a human being even though your book is sold in multiple languages. You are only human not the creator of this universe or human being. You are manipulating man.
@scottsmitherman5333
@scottsmitherman5333 Год назад
Religions are useless! Jesus Christ is Useful! Jesus is the Way, the Truth, the Life noone gets to God except through Jesus. He Created humans made in His Imagine to populate His Earth He Created. Gave us free will to choose our Creator or reject Him. Died and rose again for His creation to save us from our sins!
Далее
Типичный продавец на пляже 😂
01:00
Sam Harris & Yuval Harari - Meditation, Religion & God
18:02
Yuval Noah Harari and Jared Diamond in conversation
50:52
Bananas in heaven | Yuval Noah Harari | TEDxJaffa
15:18
Will the Future Be Human? - Yuval Noah Harari
29:44
Просмотров 657 тыс.