Audience Response to Attachment Parenting

Подписаться 108 тыс.

Просмотров 35 тыс.

50% 1

Bethenny's audience had an opportunity to voice their own opinions about breastfeeding toddlers. What followed was a heated debate between our attachment parenting moms and some vocal members of Bethenny's audience.
"bethenny," the brand-new talk show starring Bethenny Frankel - businesswoman, bestselling author, and self-described "Queen of Too Much Information" - will debut nationwide September 9th!
Subscribe to Bethenny's channel:
bthny.com/Zwg0wu
Bethenny.com: bthny.com/16t0Z1O
Twitter: bthny.com/19pXMi2
Facebook: bthny.com/14113lD
Pinterest: bthny.com/1411214
RU-vid: bthny.com/1780ppn

Развлечения

Опубликовано:

19 июн 2012

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 53

@amberosborne4688 7 лет назад

It's always the non parents who judge

@martikaalexis 12 лет назад

And she has no kids either. Get real. And why did she bring up sleeping with Mom and Dad? To be totally honest, I slept with my Mom for a LONG time, like 12 years plus and I'm a completely functioning adult with healthy relationships. Get over the judgement and just accept that most Moms know what is best for their children.

@dawnten 12 лет назад

Leave it to the wanna be teacher who has never had kids to jugde. She had no right to comment at all.

@rachealhardman9364 8 лет назад

She was literally just trying to make them sound wrong there at the end I really didn't like that.

@Smartass8504 12 лет назад

Wow, the teacher who stood up and gave her opinion really had no clue what she is talking about. Going to school for education doesn't give you the knowledge or experience (like she claimed) on this topic. Like it or not, the research does actually bake up the mom on stage's views. She is correct as well. The US definitely has his anti-breastfeeding/let's just bottle-feed our children thing going on that much of the rest of the world simply does not have. People really should read up.

@haize-ew3hr 10 лет назад

I am the proud Momma of an 8-year old boy. Attachment parenting is the only way I could imagine raising him. I am so so happy that more people are becoming aware of this completely natural way of parenting. Peace!

@ashleymichaels9193 8 лет назад

Best comment of that video goes to Bethany " So your taking into account the world point of view where they're out just, ya know.....there's no running water and like also the metropolis." I'd love to know what scene out of jungle book she had swimming around her head when she made that pause.

@quinngrey8916 6 лет назад

I feel like a kid who gets the attention they needed as a child and never had to beg for their parents attention and care, just had to ask for it, would be a lot better at communicating with others in later life and would be a lot more confident in their relationships. Yes kids should develop a sense of independence but why should a two or three year old not feel that their parents will care for them when they need it? Why should an infant not know that their parent will come when they cry? Why does a baby need to be independent?

@lilyt99 11 лет назад

I don't think I have even heard about this "Attachment Parenting" label, but I was breastfed until I was 4. I love my mom. We are very close. I don't think there is any problem with it. I also really like cow milk. I drink 4 cups of milk a day. I'm a milk person. So what? My body, my mom's body, our business. It's not perverted. The breast is made to give milk, and it doesn't usually stop producing milk at 6 months or 1 year, it does it for years and it's good for kids. So why restrict that?

@arahousett3082 5 лет назад

Breastfeeding has health benefits beyond 1 year, nutritional benefits subside but immunological benefits go into early toddlerhood.

@ChiaraBells 7 лет назад

tbh, getting sound statistical data on this parenting style is probably going to be near impossible. So in the end, it really just depends on your own opinions, as always...

@queenstixxzz 5 лет назад

I am sorry but breast feeding at 5,6,7 years old is disgusting. This isn't a debate over breast feeding or moderating your children and making sure they turn into good people. You are breast feeding a kid. Not a baby, not a toddler but a kid. A kid who is going to be ridiculed from start to finish if his peers ever actually see this. You are a grown woman, who should feel like a pervert for letting your kid suck on your breasts. The child already has a bond with his mom, this isn't needed. Breast feeding is without question better than bottle feeding....but this is way beyond "normal".

@Heavens-Humanaterian-Army 7 лет назад

im totaly for attachment pearenting i didnt do it at all for my first and she has big issues i half did it for my seconds and she is a lot more calm and in 10 weeks im haveing my 3rd and im going as hippie as i possably can no holds barrded...

@naseemweathers8358 3 года назад

Good for you the world needs more mothers like you mothers who are nurturing and loving

@raea3588 5 лет назад

The only time I've ever worried about older toddlers breast feeding is if I see a specific toddler get hurt or upset and the first thing mom does is pick them up and offer her breast. I believe when a child becomes verbal it's very important for them to start verbalizing their feelings and learning to self soothe. Breast feeding should be a bonding time and comfort when needed but not a solution for every problem. I know they spoke about this concern right off and I think those who practice Attachment Parenting with care seem to get the balance right.

@violetrosepoisonivy 10 лет назад

proud attachment momma right here! and i agree 7 is about the limit of breastfeeding. but i don't see why breastmilk is seen as something so taboo or weird or gross, the other day i was making oatmeal and ran out of milk so guess what i used?? yup best oatmeal yet =p its just milk! lol

@rsmith9551 7 лет назад

svetarose s 7 years old Is absolutely absurd. I am All for breastfeeding and loved my laleche girls but you need your head examined if your nursing your 7 year old in the third grade

@naseemweathers8358 3 года назад

Good for you I’m a man but I’m thrilled to hear moms like you who are nurturing and loving just think about all the moms who either have abortions or they give their kids up for adoption And breast-feeding it looked at as being gross because the media has deemed a woman’s breasts as sexual objects for men

@chrysldlg 4 года назад

It's so RIDICULOUSLY SAD HOW A WOMAN CAN HAVE AN OPINION OPINION ON BREASTFEEDING AND MOTHER HOOD WHEN SHE HERSELF IS NOT ONE .😂🤣

@naseemweathers8358 3 года назад

I was thinking the exact same thing you don’t have children so don’t speak on it I’m a Man and it thrills me to see nurturing loving mother like this I’m all for attachment parenting

@AtotheCtotheA 12 лет назад

no they just have the same producer

@nanaimojenny 12 лет назад

As a Mom I support it. As an ECE I have a hard time if I am the one caring for the child. I nursed till my son could say Milk Mama. (mostly because my partner said it was time to stop)

@KikaD3 12 лет назад

I totally agree that moms in the US bottle-feed their kids waaaay more than moms in other countries, esp since working moms have to go back to work after only a few weeks after giving birth. In other countries that are much more family-friendly, moms spend at least a year with their newborn and breastfeeding is indirectly stimulated that way. All in all, why don't people just mind their own business, esp in situations when other ppl's actions don't even affect them!?

@Naturalfairthinker 11 лет назад

I can't believe you drink milk from animals! That's totally gross!!!

@daniel13333 8 лет назад

Is it me or is one of Ellen's family members in the audience at 1:54 lol

@AM-re2bc 6 лет назад

DARKAVENGER 😂😂😂

@greenglassturtle 11 лет назад

no not really...

@bobichina 6 лет назад

In Asia it’s the norm

@DamianReport 12 лет назад

Thats ellen' studio right? I suppose their using it while she is on vacation.

@gilberthpavon6725 5 лет назад

Come on it's for the mom please

@Maclovesyouu 12 лет назад

4:25 to 4:34 the girl is like shaking her head in the back :O

@Naturalfairthinker 11 лет назад

Hey it's this guy! :D

@Naturalfairthinker 11 лет назад

Amen sista. Don't forget those coconuts! My babies were weaned on those! It was easy too, I drank it all through pregnancy and while i was nursing, so they loved it to death! :)

@a27garbo 12 лет назад

This was so much better from Bethenny, no interrupting the guests, having different views and discussing it, having a real dialog!

@ATChampagne 12 лет назад

Really? o.o I am more independent BECAUSE I was pushed away. My mom is a very busy woman so she never got that much time for me so I kind of started to learn how to be on my own. Plus my mom stopped breast feeding me after at a very young age.

@FLOWER5358 12 лет назад

I WANT ELLEN BACK

@Carissa99Xo 10 лет назад

These people are not thinking what's best for the kids, they only think of themselves and what they want.

@rschreuer 12 лет назад

Personally I'm not in favor. I think that it's nice the entire nurturing thing, but I think I grew up appreciating my parents and respecting them and finding comfort in them just as much without being breastfed until I was old enough to remember. I think, personally, that it's not really the children getting too attached but the moms. What will she do when he's in college and she can't comfort him so closely anymore. She might go nuts worrying.

@KittieZombieSlayer 11 лет назад

7 years old cutoff? wow someone needs psychological help

@AM-re2bc 6 лет назад

KittieZombieSlayer And yet you probably drink cow's milk: milk from a cow's teat and meant for a baby cow.

@ESNDN 6 лет назад

A M A M Jersey cows produce more milk than the calf can drink. They average between 5 to 6 gallons a day. The most the calf will consume is 2.5 gallons by the time they are of weaning age. If you don’t milk the cow, she will become ill and develop mastitis. So no, not all of the cows milk is meant for the calf. This is why they we have been using cows milk for centuries.

@malibuXoXobabe 12 лет назад

I don't have kids and I've never done any research so i don't really feel like i even have the right to an opinion on this subject, but I will say this, a family member breast feed her kid until he was 5 and it always grossed me out.

@LittleGuy1984 11 лет назад

my aunt did that and I saw that as a little kid and it has affected me till this day I'm almost 30. Cause of that I couldn't breastfeed my son when he was born I felt grossed out and weirded out by it so I pumped lol

@LittleGuy1984 11 лет назад

I don't!! I'm proud to say I don't :) I drink the milk from nuts (i.e. Almonds)

@greenglassturtle 11 лет назад

ewwww that is so gross i can't believe they are still breast feeding. the kid is going to remember that and its gross! they are old enough to drink cow milk for god damn sakes!

@juliac8225 7 лет назад

It's ok. They can reminisce about it one day over a cup of tea. Talk about the "bond" and stuff

@ESNDN 6 лет назад

Sam Smith you must not drink cows milk, or eat eggs, or eat ice cream, etc... don’t be stupid. Humans are the only creatures that will breast feed that long. There is nothing nutritional once the child is that old.