Тёмный
No video :(

Benchmade 940 vs 940-1: The Best Blade For You 

AsianKy1e
Подписаться 1,6 тыс.
Просмотров 42 тыс.
50% 1

Working off the premise that both of these serve different roles, they are great knives. But an "upgrade" in materials may not be an upgrade at all.
The S90V with all of it's edge holding abilities has one major trade off. The ability to sharpen/re-sharpen it. It is a very hard steel that comes with a price. This is true of the Carbon Fiber scales as well. CF is strong and light but is it as durable as Aluminum? I'm not too sure since I make a point to try and not drop my knives. The question I have here is about the longevity of the Carbon Fiber. Lastly, in terms of quality. I found that my 940 was overall built better with greater attention to detail than my 940-1. For a knife at this price point they should have kept a better eye on the production line and put out more consistent and better made product. Regardless of the "Blue Class" status, it could have had a closer watch.
Even with those criticisms I still have and love both knives. Before you decide which you are to purchase (which will probably be both) ask yourself the intended EDC role. You will not be dissatisfied with either purchase.
Benhcmade Knife Co.: If you ever watch this, a full titanium version without steel liners would be amazing. Keep those lines simple, clean, and free of screws. Plus some M390 would be great too.

Опубликовано:

 

15 авг 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 76   
@Tyok-ig8hw
@Tyok-ig8hw 8 лет назад
I have the 940-1 and carry it more than any other knife in my collection. I have dropped it a couple times on multiple surfaces (lots of gravity in my area apparently) and the CF has a small dent but no fibers sticking out that splinter into your skin. So no worries there. Also, I've carried mine so much (and flicked it habitually) that the Omega springs failed. That said, when I sent it into BM, they not only replaced the Omega spring, they also shaved off the screws stinking out into the blade cavity and resharpened it without me even requested. Great knife and great knife company!
@user-xy7sk6wq8t
@user-xy7sk6wq8t 2 месяца назад
Great video comparison, like the presentation of your experience and opinion. Really helped my off the fence of which to buy. Went with the original 940... thanks man!
@duncg8123
@duncg8123 9 лет назад
Hey nice vid! On the subject of damage to the carbon scales: firstly, you can never polish a fibre. There will always be exposed fibres unless there is a lacquer or paint applied. In this case, I'd be happier if I dropped my 940-1 than the ally version. Why? CF won't leave an obvious bright scratch! What ever happens to it you can remove it with fine wet'n dry paper to an almost new condition. Can't do that with an anodised/painted ally handle ;0) I wager the CF scales will look newer for longer. Also, you have the option of brining it back to new in 10-20 years time. (To qualify that: I used to be a composite tech in F1 and a WRC Rally team. I've worked with glass, carbon and aramid composites for many years) This is a great knife and just took delivery of one yesterday! Used your review to decide. Cheers!
@andrewsnape1705
@andrewsnape1705 6 лет назад
Still a great, informative video after nearly 3 years. Thanks mate
@asianky1e30
@asianky1e30 6 лет назад
Andrew Snape thanks man!!
@sputumtube
@sputumtube 8 лет назад
Don't know if anyone else has mentioned it but the 940-1 will be easier to keep clean with it's open construction. My standard green 940 accumulates pocket lint quite a lot.
@asianky1e30
@asianky1e30 8 лет назад
+paul greenwood You know, now that you mentioned it you are correct. Due to the pillar construction of the -1 its incredibly easier to either use canned air or just your lungs to blow lint out. Thanks for mentioning it!
@grizzlycountry1030
@grizzlycountry1030 3 года назад
I've had no problem with either construction version. Both blow out easily with lung power, canned air or air compressor.
@salsworld9498
@salsworld9498 3 года назад
Great video. After years of wear. Make a follow up video on the condition of the fiber.
@amacro11
@amacro11 8 лет назад
Just picked up the 940 they had the 940-1 that I checked out and just plain liked the 940 better, enjoyed the comparison Al
@asianky1e30
@asianky1e30 8 лет назад
+amacro11 Thanks man! Honestly, you can't go wrong with either one. The F&F was better on the 940 as you saw me point out the little flaws on the 940-1. For the blade length, weight, and blade type; this series of knives is EXTREMELY hard to beat. Enjoy your blade!
@efromhb
@efromhb 4 года назад
Got my first 940 last week. The 2001 20th anniversary titanium. Now I want the original.
@andrewdanger2830
@andrewdanger2830 8 лет назад
Great comparison and excellent steel explanation--has greatly enhanced my understanding.
@asianky1e30
@asianky1e30 8 лет назад
+andy danger Thanks for the view!
@SonOfAHerbert
@SonOfAHerbert 9 лет назад
Great video! I posted my previous comments before watching lol. I would deffinately agree with you on the s90v. From factory, the edge is visibly a little but toothy like you said. Mine is, however, hair shaving sharp, but I hope stroping it will make the edge nice and pretty and even sharper. I too fear the day that I just use it too much and find that its too dull for me to sharpen. I hope stroping after each use will keep it nice and sharp for a very long time, especially since its just a light duty knife for me. Also, I am quite curious about how the carbon fiber will hold up over the years, that also scares me with how long it will last because I got it with the intention of carrying it (paired with another knife) for a very long time, especially for the money thats put into it. I mean, my dad has been carrying his same little Kershaw 3115 (now made in China called the Coral Creek) with him for 30+ years and its been purely a good user knife, been through hell and back and held up. I just hope my 940-1 holds up at least as good as that (im sure i will treat it much better) and I can carry it for that long. I posted a comment on your instagram picture about the clip retention, although I see you have switched to a split arrow, when you had the original clip on, did the knofe ever slip almost out of your pocket? Happpened to me a couple times now and today it almost fell out. Scary.
@asianky1e30
@asianky1e30 9 лет назад
We'll see how it wears over time man. I'll be doing an update video after about a year of ownership to to show the wear and tear. It is not in my pocket every single day however. When stropping mine it does reduce the "toothy-ness" of the edge but it will never be like S30V or S35VN due to the structure of the steel. But like I said in my Instagram, I did have to bend my split arrow clip just a little bit to make it tight. The stock clip, however, did not need any adjustment. It just might be a small quality issue which wouldn't surprise me since this knife seems to have some already. Keep watching the channel bro and thanks for the view!
@appleztooranges
@appleztooranges Год назад
I bought the original 940. Hopefully I won’t regret it. Could have. Gotten the 940-1 for an extra $80
@suttonmatthew
@suttonmatthew 3 года назад
Those screws sticking out in the handle are a show stopper for me.
@danhal9966
@danhal9966 2 года назад
Just bought a 940-1,what a beauty!!!
@hillbillyknifenut83
@hillbillyknifenut83 8 лет назад
If you haven't already , you should def check out the 940-1501 , it's a KnifeWorks exclusive and has CPM-20CV steel , black and blue g10 and open construction with blue standoffs for $199.95 (used to be $179.95) ... I have that and the two here , can't live without them !!! lol
@AndreVautour
@AndreVautour 9 лет назад
Good video! I agree the carbon does look nice on this and I really like the blue standoffs and flow through design on the 940-1. But like you I am also concerned about the durability of the handle (since I plan to use whichever one I get a lot and not just collect it) And I also agree some of the grinds I've seen on the 940-1 have been pretty bad for a $300 (CAD) knife. I also agree that the screws showing is pretty terrible for such an expensive knife. One guy i talked to was able to find screws with the same heads that were slightly shorter so they did not show through, but you should not have to do that. Overall I think the 940 likely be more durable and I still think it looks good with the green and purple back spacer.
@USMarineSniper11
@USMarineSniper11 9 лет назад
Great video dude!! I am 16 years old and have been looking at both of these knives for a long time now. I couldn't agree with u more regarding the S90V compared to the S30V. Being 16 i am not a very good sharpener and i feel like the S90V would be very hard to sharpen all tho the 940-1 is bad ass!! But i feel like im not going to need to sharpen my knife that often so when i get enough money I am totally getting the 940-1! thanks for the video!!
@asianky1e30
@asianky1e30 9 лет назад
Thanks for the comment man! Blade steel has always been important to me since really getting into knives. Save up and make sure you get one you'll love the first time! Stay tuned for my CRK Small Sebenza video in the future bro. 
@SonOfAHerbert
@SonOfAHerbert 9 лет назад
I just got mine and I say go for it! I recommend Soonerstateknives.com for buying knives they have great prices, $225 for the 940-1 as opposed to $263 anywhere else!
@SonOfAHerbert
@SonOfAHerbert 9 лет назад
Its deffinately my favorite, but you gotta be careful, Benchmade doesnt have the best quality control so the knife you get will either be quite good or pretty bad. I got lucky :)
@USMarineSniper11
@USMarineSniper11 9 лет назад
Ben Gonzales Thanks dude for the advice!! Soonerstateknives.com seems like a good site and cheaper!!
@dalecarpenter8359
@dalecarpenter8359 6 лет назад
I paid $ 180.00 for a crooked river . I had to check to be sure it wasn't a clone . A$17.00 ganzo has better fit and finish . Now is it to much to ask for a knife that cost so much more be so much better !!?
@williammurphy6104
@williammurphy6104 5 лет назад
I respect that you want to care for your knifes, but if its a collectors knife leave it in the box or display case. If its an EDC then don’t be afraid to drop it! It isn’t worth it ruining your day. I have owned a ton of knifes but only 5 high quality ones (excludes my kitchen knives). When I was 11 I saved up all my money and bought a $50 single blade folding knife for Scouts. That was 1994. 10 years later when I bought my AR from Gander Mountain I saw the 530 and said this is the knife I would grow old with. I actually ended up giving it to my mom when the 531 S30V became available and she continues to drop it constantly and uses it daily as a paramedic. I drop mine non stop and I know that G10 is different from CF but the CF should handle drops no problem. The closest knife i have to a collectors knife is a Benchmade Emerson Spec War CQC7 which go up in value every year and even that knife I’m not afraid to pry with or drop it. My honest recommendation to everyone is for an EDC buy something you are not afraid to scratch up and drop. Like the video creator mentioned S90V may be more difficult for some to sharpen so if you are going to get something that is harder than S30V then I would recommend you ensure you always strop it after each use. You could probably go 3-6 months only stropping and some super soft touch up. Then just send it in to be sharpened at Benchmade. That CF Osborne is sexy!
@ogenmatic
@ogenmatic 7 лет назад
Just ordered a dash one today. Ever try Rob with his ApostleP RU-vid channel for resharpening? Does an excellent job.
@asianky1e30
@asianky1e30 7 лет назад
ogenmatic never have actually! Seems pretty popular! What was his turnaround time?
@ogenmatic
@ogenmatic 7 лет назад
AsianKy1e You'd have to contact Rob. Depends on his workload but sharpening & RU-vid are his full time vocations.
@chrisv2994
@chrisv2994 Год назад
asian kyle eats ramen, drinks mountain dew and punches holes in his drywall. has nice knives too!
@AGC828
@AGC828 Год назад
CF scales---if it has texture then it looks/feels good. But when the furface is smooth and maybe shiny it looks cheap and plasticy. So would it still have been wortht he added cost? Just to have an "exotic" scale material? Might not even be solid CF. And as mentioned their's no weight advantage...or not felt. Blade steels---also "as mentioned" S90V is much harder to sharpen and is brittle. And not needed for "everyday tasks". S30V or even VG10 will do just fine...is much easier to shparen...better for most who have little blade sharpening experince...how often does the "average entusiast" sharpen their knives? HONESTLY. It's not like most sharpen 100 blades a week ...nor have most appreenticed under a "blad sharpening master" for 10 years...shaprening over 5000 blades...it's a skill...not going to develop sharpening 1 blade once a month on a Spyderco Sharpmaker :)
@dseednorwayn47
@dseednorwayn47 9 лет назад
good review of two great blades. :)
@jolIyjoeker
@jolIyjoeker 2 года назад
I just received my 940-1 and am returning it immediately the knife is unnecessarily light due to the cf scales and way too blade heavy and I dislike the feel and everything about the carbon fiber scales minus the look. I already ordered the original 940, the s90v blade seems awesome though.
@asianky1e30
@asianky1e30 2 года назад
Agreed! It’s a fantastic knife but the balance is all out of sorts. Granted that’s a minor issue on a folding knife but still. Enjoy both!
@SneakyCaleb
@SneakyCaleb 9 лет назад
Thanks for making this video! I am going to get the 940-1 and add a custom blue pocket clip(: I will probably get the regular version later.
@asianky1e30
@asianky1e30 9 лет назад
No problem man! Post the photos on Instagram and tag me in it!
@Toki52
@Toki52 7 лет назад
Premium knives shouldn't have any blade play. The 940-1 is sweet, but bad QC is unacceptable.
@asianky1e30
@asianky1e30 7 лет назад
Toki52 agreed. Shouldn’t have it at all. But dang the knife is sooo good regardless!
@WordMadeFlesh777
@WordMadeFlesh777 6 лет назад
Toki52 the axes lock by design lends itself to slight blade play. Us knife nerds are fanatical about blade centering and blade play but as long as it isn’t excessive it’s not really a real problem that affects performance.
@Toki52
@Toki52 6 лет назад
The Axis lock is the most innovative of our time, it is extraordinarily robust as well. I've never had any blade play. That said, I've sold a half dozen or so due to non-use. Their uneven grind and blade centering was their biggest faults. Spyderco and Zero Tolerance destroys them in quality and value. My last remaining Benchmades are for nostalgia only. Benchmade's first and last niche is the high end butterfly knife.
@asianky1e30
@asianky1e30 6 лет назад
Toki52 pretty much the only Bench Made I’ll buy again will be a version of the 940. All others.... well ZT makes better quality for the price lol
@Hege_
@Hege_ 9 лет назад
Should i get the 940 or 300-1?
@RazorBladeAppleFilms
@RazorBladeAppleFilms 8 лет назад
+Henri Lyyjynen I don't have 940 but I REALLY want one, however I do have the 300-1 and it is really great. Deep carry pocket clip, SUPER smooth, perfect centering, I love the handle aesthetics.....Overall I'd say it's worth it and definitely better than the griptilians. However, the 940 is still in my sights if that tells you anything.
@asianky1e30
@asianky1e30 8 лет назад
+RazorBladeAppleFilms I still dig the 940 series over the 300 personally :) I wouldn't turn down either though!
@RazorBladeAppleFilms
@RazorBladeAppleFilms 8 лет назад
AsianKy1e Me too honestly, I got the 300-1 as a gift and can't bring myself to get a 940. The price. ugh...
@viper2788
@viper2788 6 лет назад
I've heard otherwise that benchmades have better heat treating compared to Spyderco...
@corycarlson3846
@corycarlson3846 9 лет назад
i have a 484-1 far superior knife. as for my carbon fiber handle, it is light as a feather but, hard as a FUCKING ROCK!. Its my edc. i'm an installer and use it on everything 6 days a week. i've dropped it in the street a few times. not a mark on the knife anywhere! CF is set with epoxy or like chemical, way harder than any "normal" material.
@asianky1e30
@asianky1e30 9 лет назад
Cory Carlson Ive come to the same conclusions as well about the CF! Its pretty much rocks! As long as Benchmade does not change their formula, i would have no issue buying another CF scaled knife from them. Feather light and premium quality construction. Ive held the 484-1, it is just superb! Perhaps one day I'll pick one up, but until then; I highly recommend any of Benchmade's cf products to hit the market!
@Cooldibs
@Cooldibs 8 лет назад
How did you get benchmade to send you the pocket clip?
@asianky1e30
@asianky1e30 8 лет назад
It is literally as simple as calling them, asking for the clip models you want, and waiting. Just like that. All you have to do is give them an address and they create you a profile so that way when you ask for more they just send you the ones already saved for you. Super simple. They see the clips as sacrificial and are willing to replace them hence why they use the same 2/3 hole design all the time.
@kd7gxfsmd
@kd7gxfsmd 8 лет назад
Have you gotten your hands on a 940-2 yet?
@asianky1e30
@asianky1e30 8 лет назад
Unfortunately not! I can't seem to snag one in any sales or trades :/
@6688846993johnny
@6688846993johnny 9 лет назад
If you are worried about sharpening the 940-1 or any other knife with harder to sharpen steel get you some diamond stones like dmt or a sharpening system with diamond stones like kme or lansky. The diamond stones sharpen way easier than Synthetic or natural stones.
@asianky1e30
@asianky1e30 9 лет назад
Yeah, I'll probably end up doing that anyways soonish
@peterisrael2012
@peterisrael2012 9 лет назад
John Sevaldsen most knife companies recommend not sharpening with diamond stones unless its a ceramic knife .
@6688846993johnny
@6688846993johnny 9 лет назад
Never heard of that but I'm not worried, tons of people sharpen all kinds of knives with different steels using diamond stones no problem PeterPiperGamer YT​
@peterisrael2012
@peterisrael2012 9 лет назад
John Sevaldsen it doesn't hurt the blade for the most part its just that diamond sharpeners are known to wear fast because the diamonds come loose while grinding , so most custom makers and companies say ceramic will last longer and achieve the same result without stripping your blade of excess metal as diamond does.
@518jeremias
@518jeremias 6 лет назад
Any way you can swap the blades between the two?
@asianky1e30
@asianky1e30 6 лет назад
Jay Jerevicious when I tried it I could. YMMV though! Not sure why you’d want to swap the out though!
@518jeremias
@518jeremias 6 лет назад
AsianKy1e okay I really want the s90v but with the green body.
@asianky1e30
@asianky1e30 6 лет назад
Jay Jerevicious fair enough, Death Of All Things makes g10 scales. Look him up on instagram!
@knivesinourlives7997
@knivesinourlives7997 3 года назад
I just got mine l
@chiammao1027
@chiammao1027 9 лет назад
............is come out with another titanium handle version of this but instead of having all your screws in your liners blah blah blah plus a blade in CPM S110V steel.
@jojojeep1
@jojojeep1 4 года назад
Just use it, every three or four years spent 90 bucks and buy new handle covers
@dalecarpenter8359
@dalecarpenter8359 6 лет назад
Its hair splitting ! Not hair popping !
@asianky1e30
@asianky1e30 6 лет назад
Dale Carpenter potato patato
@deankundrata2300
@deankundrata2300 6 лет назад
Field test that knife then
@evanacey1414
@evanacey1414 3 года назад
Carbon fiber is stronger than steel bud.
@griffinvolk1912
@griffinvolk1912 7 лет назад
Carbon fiber is very hard, so it's super unlikely that u could chip it
@asianky1e30
@asianky1e30 7 лет назад
Griffin Volk very unlikely but I would be lying if I didn't have some concerns. A buddy scratched his full carbon mountain bike after all. Needless to say he had some choice words haha
@johnhickey8233
@johnhickey8233 3 года назад
M
@lalogallardo2387
@lalogallardo2387 6 лет назад
940-2 in g10 is the best
@evictioncarpentry2628
@evictioncarpentry2628 6 лет назад
I have both. Like the original 940 more for EDC so I sold it and bought RBW CF scales for my 535 instead. Anyone that's worried about scratches on their edc knife should pull their balls out of their wife's purse.
Далее
From the Sharpening Bench:  940-1 Conclusions
14:41
Просмотров 74 тыс.
Classic Italian Pasta Dog
00:20
Просмотров 1,1 млн
The Perfect EDC...Benchmade 940-1 Carbon Fiber!!
20:12
Why I'm Switching My Pocket Knife
20:49
Просмотров 740 тыс.
Benchmade 940-1 Long Term Full Review
15:53
Просмотров 35 тыс.
review of the benchmade 940 after 10+ years
24:12
Просмотров 212 тыс.
Benchmade Bugout VS 940!!! (535-3 VS 940-1)
15:11
Просмотров 49 тыс.
Final Benchmade 940 Review- You May Hate It!
11:42
Просмотров 12 тыс.
Actually Buying the Best Big Survival Knife
27:12
Просмотров 74 тыс.
FAKE Benchmade 940 Vs. A Real Benchmade 940
18:46
Просмотров 4,2 тыс.