Best Mechanic's Tool Set Under $200? 2021 Gearwrench, Tekton, Pittsburgh, Craftsman 

What pisses me off is the huge amount of bits and Allen keys. Just make a kit with ratchets, sockets, wrenches, extensions and adapters. That's it, I don't care how many bits are in it, just sell people what they want,.... a serious mechanic set.

I really liked the in depth look at all the sets. Tekton is almost always the best, but always good to look at other brands. Can't wait for a part 2!

This is one of the better tool comparisons i ever seen. A lot of the other tool review guys never go into the disadvantages of the products like you do and it is super helpful that you did in yours. Glad i subscribed!

Tekton has always been solid. Good video.

Great video! Love how you ensure that you detail each set and the positives and negative’s. I definitely agree about gearwrench warranty! Took me 6 months for replacement of 10mm ratching wrench! Keep up the great work!

Well done! Thank you for including the shake test. It really is an important component when considering tool options.

Just found your channel and I am more than happy to be added to your subscriber list. I find your channel informative and formatted well without some of the fluff of other channels. Sometimes you just need the facts and solid opinions from an actual user of these products. Awesome job!

Thanks for taking the time and looking at all these. Specially like the shake test, can’t tell you how many times I have opened my old sets up to find the sockets everywhere.

Finally, another video, which specifically states was is in the kit. Nice relieved, also great to the know-how on what you get depending on the kit brand you go with. Thanks so much for sharing. A good solid refencere.

I have enjoyed both of your reviews of tool sets. I was in the market for some truck tools and I think the metric only sets from Tekton might be a great choice for me so thanks for the suggestion! If you want to continue doing these comparisons I would suggest adding some of the really cheap Amazon sets as well to see how they do against the more established brands.

I have the tekton sets my self have used them professionally for almost two full years and they have been great. I really enjoy using them

Love your videos and the shake test! Driving a flat bed truck through the mountains and a couple ditches going across a rocky road is what we do. Tools ain't cheap so appreciate you doing these comparisons for our education. I'd be happy to see a destruction test of wrenches/sockets/ ratchet wrenches from various manufactures not usually stress tested like dewalt, crescent, Stanley, duratech, etc... plus a Pittsburgh or craftsman tool in there for reference to be able to compare a more complete picture. Seems that's what youtube is lacking.

I’ve been planning on getting the Pittsburg set for months now as my own Christmas gift, but after watching this I think my mind has changed to the Gear Wrench set! Thank you for the new information

I'm glad you included the tekton sets, those looked like the best ones to me. Look forward to a part 3!

I like the vids, keep up the awesome work! I definitely wouldn’t mind see another part to the series. I’ve actually been contemplating lately on upgrading from my craftsman sockets to tecktons. The big thing for me is the “no skips” missing sizes screw with my OCD. Even if I’ll never use that size, it’s nice to know I have it. I guess I’m just weird like that lol.

I’ve been in the market for a starter set to work on my cars mostly maintenance and repairs, and your videos being in depth helps out so much! And I actually appreciate you shaking them around, if I dropped my current cheapo tool box or even opened it wrong I’d have to spend 30 mins putting everything back.. So far I’m looking at that craftsman from the giveaway and then maybe building on it with some tekton tools in the future. But now the GearWrench caught my eye haha either way Looking forward to part 2!!

I found this channel through the first round of tool sets reviews. I absolutely love this idea for a channel. This biggest problem I have with all of these sets are the skips and the tools that you get that are filler. I would love to see a video where you could go and piece together a decent tool set with no skips and no fill and have a decent set of tools. For example, My 1/4" tool set came from O'Riley's auto. I didn't like their 3/8" and 1/2" stuff though. I did like a Tekton 3/8" set so I got that. The only limitation would be what individual people are working on. A home tool box, doesn't look like mine, when I work mostly on cars. Love this, keep it up.

Great videos. These are really helping me decide which sets to go after. Would love to see a DeWalt breakdown. My dad was a craftsman man but my uncle swears by his DeWalt tool sets. Definitely do part 2.

These tool sets are what get people started in the realm of tinkering on cars, perfect for a first timer or as a mobile set. Good video mate, cheers!

Thanks for diving so deep into each set and sharing the wisdom!

Loving the diversity in sets and price rages. Can’t wait for part 2

Great video. Keep them coming. I enjoy seeing the comparisons with different tool manufacturers. Tekton is my favorite for at home. I started collecting craftsman for my toolset in the car.

Great video! I'd like to see a part 2 as well. I think I'd also like to see how some of HF's Quinn line compares to their Pittsburgh Pro and Icon lines, just because Quinn seems to have little representation and kinda seems like it's out there in no man's land in the HF world

As a native Michigander, I like how much love Tekton has been getting the last couple years. They've stepped up their game big time, and they should absolutely be in more people's arsenals. New to your channel, the videos are great 👍 audio is definitely getting better lol. There are some pretty inexpensive rode lapel mics that might help out, if you don't mind having a mic clipped to your shirt 🤷‍♂️. Congrats on 3k, keep up the awesome work 💪

Thanks for the content man! I’ve been trying to figure out what to get as my first set so these videos help! Looking forward to the next one.

Just started watching your vids, I'd love to see a part 2 and I like the in-depth longer videos, but I would also like to see some quicker 15-20 min videos comparing the manufacturers, congrats on 3,000 too!

That craftsman 216 kit has tempted me to get their rolling tool box honestly. Thanks for the reviews, and yeah dewalt would be a great inclusion for part 2.

Not sure why your channel hasn't garnered a larger following. You're thorough and informative! Good luck to you!

Love your reviews and personal perspective. I grabbed a gear wrench set that was $100 less. Model 83001. No filler. Lacks combination wrenches and spark plug sockets. I almost picked up their combination wrench set, but like you said I noticed how chunky they were.

Yes I’d like to see a part 2. I’ve always been a big fan of Tekton tools. I purchased my first Tekton wrench set 7 or so years ago and They’ve held up very well.

Would love to see a part 2! Maybe compare buying individual tools to “compete”with the box sets? Could provide an interesting counterpoint!

Thanks for sharing your opinion on all these tool sets. It’s really nice having some insight on what to consider buying. It’s very helpful again Thank you! I personally have the Tekton set love the ratchet very comfortable in the hand and also it’s nice that they include the breaker bar. I also was in a tech program when I bought it and tekton offer a 15% off for student on top of the 10% they give you back. So it was actually very affordable when I first started out. I would love to see a part two maybe seeing what you think about the husky set or Milwaukee set.

This was a great overview! I have an old US made 108 piece Craftsman set that has served me well but I'm looking to expand. I really like that 308 piece set and the Gearwrench. I'll need to check them out!

I started my career with the 301pc Pittsburg set, now I only wrench from home but I’ve bought a lot since. It was a great set to start with!!

I bought that same exact Tekton 3/8 set a couple years back and it’s been the best ratchet set I’ve owned.

I have the 301 Pittsburgh, I love it, my buddy bought one too, of course I have a ton of other tools, but the Pittsburgh set does most of my work I need

Yes definitely a part 2, I've been loving this series. The Hart set from Walmart, Masterforce from Menards would be good ones to add to the comparison. Then you have Capri that would be a good one to put up against the Tekton. Then theres the Quinn set at harbor freight.

I really enjoy and appreciate all your reviews especially on the Mechanic Tool Sets. Keep up the great work. Makes me want to buy myself a set but I already have some and I am just a DIYer.

i would love to see a part 2 to this video, congrats at 3k subs you really diserve it man.

Part two would be super helpful. The kobalt bigger mech sets or maybe budget combo wrench sets might be a good idea too

Yes definitely part 2! I'd love to see more Tekton reviews. Also would be interested in Wera/Wiha/Knipex/Klein Tools reviews

I gotta say, I’m loving that Gear Wrench tool set, I’ve been seeing lot of guys rave about the brand and I’m starting to see why. Would love a part 2, I really want to get my father a tool set for Christmas this year and just looking for the best bang for my buck!

i apreciate the reviews, most tool boxes do not are not specific on what sizes they have on their advertizing , and none show what sizes they skip, your reviews are very informative, ive been looking around for a good replacement box since i need wrenches and larger sockets for auto and motorcycle projects , the pittsburg 301 looks to be the best set for the job

Just starting to get really into working on cars and it’s nice to see the differences of quality in the different sets.

Part 2 would be cool. I'm looking at the stacking systems (I like the idea of versastack and that 216 piece set snapping together) and more opinions on them are always welcome. Also I've had the older version of that tekton 1/4 set probably 5 or 6 years and it's been great

Love the videos can't wait for a part 2 maybe some kobalt set (they do have lots of filler though) I've decided to make my own set using mainly tekton, been looking at the Craftsman for an on the go road trip kit.

My choice would be the Tekton also. I'm all about having complete sets of everything. A while back I bought a set of the westling machine socket trays and then had to go thru and buy all the missing sockets to fill all the pegs. But now I have every socket I'd ever need.

I’ve had fairly quick results getting gearwrench tools replaced until just recently when I tried. Simple extensions and ratchets delayed for months. Interested to see the results for the giveaway. Definitely handy to have a portable set

Great job and review. I will share my experience with the only Gear Wrench that I warranted was completely different than yours. I sent them a picture and had the wrench back in 4-7 days. I don’t remember the exact time, but I was impressed with the no hassle exchange. I will preface that it was pre-COVID for what it’s worth. Also, definitely need to include the Dewalt 192 as it is the most complete for a starter set and was down around $100-$120 during BF last year. I completely love the Tektons too and how they are doing things. Warranty matters, which is why I give Harbor Freight a lot more credit than most even though I don’t have a ton of their tools. I definitely have my fair share, and know I could swap something easily if needed.

Appreciate all the videos. Always been a help when im looking at what to buy!

Thank you for the honest reviews. Been working in my car for the last year as a project and buying tool by tool adds up. The tools set is a better decision.

great video been looking at these sets and the video helps me pick which one AWESOME!!!

Great job being able to see the sets before making a choice. Keep them coming. Tekton is a great brand.

One dude at work has nothing but tekton tools at the diesel shop I work at. Have held up very well. Impressed.

I've wondered how the Dewalt stacks up against these brands. Great giveaway, I've been eyeing that Craftsman set for awhile. Keep up the good work

Pulled the trigger and bought the 216 Craftsman set. The compact form sold it for me over all the other sets. The top trey was also a great way to add more to it without adding more tools.

I definitely want to start building my tools and tekton keeps scoring high. I hate that most of these sets skip sizes. Good video. It has helped me confirm my choice for Tekton.

Thanks for the Gear Wrench review! I love that set the most but the only bummer is the half inch drives. Part 2 for sure. Maybe some Husky and Kobalt thrown in the next vid?

Just found your channel recently and I really enjoyed your $100 tool video and this one. I Would love to see a part 2 to this. You could also do a video on assembling a tool set for $100, and $200 (not in the sets). Keep up the good work!

Great video. I got some Tekton last year love their sockets and ratchets. As a DIY I highly recommend them As well

Make all the videos, Bud. You have had me back and forth on the Tekton site after watching your videos. Been to Harbor Freight, Home Depot, and Lowes as well. Haven't bought anything yet. I have a few hundred dollars in Husky stuff in my truck tool box, but working out of bags sucks sometimes. I will probably end up with Tekton, i like those thinner cases. Maybe a video showing how the sets sit in a truck tool box? Great stuff!

A lot of good information and nice to see what sockets are skipped and covered with other brands.

Thank you for these recent videos. Great information. I'm going to start shake testing everything before I buy.

Great job so far on showing what all comes in these sets. I’ve had no problem with getting my Gearwrench tools warranty replacement. Tekton sockets and ratchets have been great and I haven’t had to use their warranty yet. I just recently bought some of their pliers to try out. I like them so far, good quality and price is right. Maybe you could do a comparison of pliers and adjustable wrenches from several different brands. Keep up the good work!

I like the craftsman set looks like it would clean a couple of drawers in my tool box .. craftsman has always fit my budget even when they manufacturing in the great USA.. I believe Craftsman may be the best staring kit for any one that’s getting into tearing things apart at young age ..

Thanks for the honest review on these sets can't wait for more videos!

I enjoy watching this channel... your choice of material to present is relevant to me... you show the tools and give your honest opinion... I made some tool purchases bcoz of your explanation... I chose tekton to enjoy their warranty is hassle free...👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼

You got me convinced in Tekton, I’ve seen your last video where you had all three tekton master and the deep impact sockets I like it. The price has gone up…$410.00 for three sets, hopefully they would have a Black Friday sale soon.

Wallyworld currently has a Hart 221-piece set on sale for $94 (normally $148) that I wouldn't mind you looking at. As far as I know, you're the only guy doing these head-to-head looks at these kits by price point who really evaluates both the good and the bad. And if you're giving away that Craftsman kit, I'd give it a good home. UPDATE: I actually snagged one of those Hart 221-piece kits just now for $47!!! It was an "open box" one, all there, but missing its cardboard cover. Just for a gag I hauled it over to the nearby camping and sporting goods desk and asked what they could do on the price, and they slashed that already-on-sale $94 price by 50%, just like that. It's not a bad little kit with 90 tooth ratchets, easy-to-read sockets, and the perhaps the least "filler" or "fluff" of any such "Mechanic's" box kit I've ever seen. Honestly, I needed another 200+ piece tool kit like I need gills on my buttocks, but sure I bought it. Wouldn't you?

Part 2 definitely please. Show newer Techs what $200 Snap-On gets you vs a set like Craftsman or Tekton

Nice video. It's crazy how much prices have gone up since this video was made. Craftsman and Pittsburgh are the only ones in the 200 range now. Still I think the Tekton Sets are reasonable. For sets that don't have skips you can't go wrong.

Hell yes a part 2!! You’re awesome!!

I would love to see a part 2. Some sets I would like to see there include the 128 piece capri tools, 171 piece channellock professional, 204 piece klutch, 180 piece duralast, and the 247 DeWalt.

Nice video, thanks for the comparison. Bought the Pittsburgh 301 piece and have liked it so far.

Yes to additional videos ion new tool sets. Thanks for putting these videos together.

After watching this video i am highly recommending buying both tekton master sets.! thanks ! Also yes definitely a part 2 would be nice !

Keep up the good work, these reviews will help me in my efforts in buying a tool set👍🏽👍🏽

Thanks for this video review. I'll be looking into the Tekton sets now.

Thank you again for the reviews, looking for an affordable set as a gift for my brother. Your reviews are just in time

Definitely part 2 I'm a DIY'R and your channel has been very informational for me I'd like to see maybe the bigger sets out of husky or Cobalt

Appreciate your videos. Good call out on the size of the ratcheting wrenches. If you do another video, I would be interested in your feedback on the Craftsman Gunmetal Chrome sets. There is a set that would fit under your $200 limit and one that fits under the $100 limit. Just for kicks, it would be funny to list what you could get from a truck brand for the $100/200.

Yes I’d like to see a part 2. I’ve always been a big fan of Craftsman tools. especially when they were USA made.

Yes Part 2 will be great! Great videos Also, missing comparison with Milwaukee set. Is there anything amazon or somewhere else

Great job describing the different sets. Part 2 would be nice but I’d love to see a comparison of the warranty processes. I recently went through the process with craftsman and I was a bit disappointed. It took 3 months to get a new ratchet. Tekton is sounding very appealing for their warranty now.

Definitely a part 2 video I am in the process of buying tools I have always had a kind of mixed bag for Years and I got robbed and am starting over thank you for helping me out with the the videos

Nice review! I was thinking about trying out the gear wrench set, but will probably stick with craftsman

Great video, I would love to see another on $200+/- sets! So far between this video and your last, I don’t know any others to consider so it would be great to see your thoughts and suggestions as to any more sets for us to look at!

Thanks for review. I'd be interested in a part 2. I like learning about the Tekton brand.

Love the content man ! Happy holidays

Great series! Thanks for it. I was looking at the Kobalt, but that case… Similarly, the SAE Milwaukee socket set just went down in price for Black Friday. …and as a suggestion, take a look at Hart. I am super interested to see the quality compared to Husky and Kobalt, given that they are and older brand with solid hand tools.

Great content! I've been looking into buying some set of tools, this helped!

Keep up the great work. I would like to see a part 2. Maybe check out some sets from these companies: Capri tools, dewalt, hart, maybe even channel lock.

I have a soft spot in my heart for Craftsman... Loving this series. Prefer the under 200 set reviews.

Never used gear wrench sockets and ratchets but have used the wrenches they’ve been good for me. Good video

If you haven’t already, the Pittsburgh 225 set is a neat compact contender. Definitely a good set that deserves more love

I just found your reviews. They are very helpful. Thank you.

Found your channel a couple of mouths ago loving the content. I won’t mind seeing some power tools IE Milwaukee versus HarborFreight versus snap on and or other master” tools set like the Milwaukee hand tools and husky. I’ve also seen stuff on sonic tools like a whole tech cart filled with tools.

Definitely a part 2. it'd be nice to see the Pittsburg 225 piece set.

Love the vids, they've helped me decide which sets to go with.

I appreciate your content, good stuff! If I had anything to say as you go through the sets, is maybe mention the product names a tiny bit more. I liked the 216 pc Craftsman. I went to get the set but couldn’t pull the trigger. Instead, I bought their 25 pc screwdriver set, and went elsewhere for the 32 pc wrench combination set. I wish I waited for more Black Friday deals to see how things shake out. Why I went with Craftsman is because I’m not as heavy a user as I used to be. I also saw a video of a Tekton wrench rounding out, whereas the Craftsman snapped the head of a bolt right off; but savings and how much I’d really use being my deciding factor.