I feel they are a little better than Aftermath, but too expensive. I wish they had a propper set like they did with LotR as they had more than enough lore to get ideas from. However, there are some cool reprints, like those Swords of X and Y and a few enchantments. Overall I would give it a 6/10 score. PD. I feel the same way about art cards, I pulled the Ulamog one on MH3, was excited then very annoyed.